Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2015-04-05 – KR.mp3
UUID: f4609322-d7a3-4010-8d51-8e9bf8cd558d
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Death and Rebirth (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2015-04-05
Duration: 1h 41m
Words: 4,121
So I would like to present self grasping in a very simplified form without focusing on the details, relying on scriptures and explaining both self grasping and the view of the transitory composite. Then it will be helpful to think that this is indeed a rare occasion. You have a lotsawa who is experienced and very skilled in what he does. And therefore, you should try to benefit from these explanations. As Aria Chandakirti says or the glorious Chandakirti says in Madhyamaka Avatara, the root of afflictions without exception is the view of the disintegrating composite.
Once we realize that afflictions are present within our mind stream and we have ascertained that they are defective or faulty, we shall search for the origin, the cause or the root of these afflictions. It is definite that the source, the cause of all of the afflictions heralded by anger is none other than self grasping, in other words, the view of the transitory composite. What do we mean when we say that self grasping or the apprehension of an I, in other words, the sense I, I, is faulty or defective in as much as it is a consciousness. This means that its object of appearance, its aspect, or its object of engagement is defective or wrong. Then if you will listen carefully, my goal is to present this in few words in a concise fashion.
So when this eye appears within the context of self grasping, what is its mode of appearance? What appears is that the I, which is the imputed phenomenon, is in the basis of imputation that it is not only independent and autonomous, but truly established as well. Why does this appear to us? This appears to us because self grasping is within our mind stream. Here, when we refer to the imputed phenomenon, the I, and the basis of imputation, the aggregates, it is critical to be able to differentiate between imputed phenomenon and basis of imputation.
Let us take one example. Let us take Aaron. We all know Aaron. Now the imputed phenomenon Aaron is a mere name, a mere noun. What is the ground of imputation or the basis of imputation?
The basis of imputation are the aggregates of Aaron. As we all know Aaron, when we encounter or see the aggregates of Aaron, the name Aaron immediately springs to mind. So we now understand the distinction between the I, which is the imputed phenomenon, and the basis of the ground of imputation, which are the aggregates. How does this I appear under apprehension? It appears as if it is existing from its own side, independently and autonomously within the aggregates.
For us, it is very difficult to identify this I which is the object of refutation within our mind stream. And the way to do this is to observe the powerful sense of I which arises when forceful emotions are induced, such as great fear or great anxiety. In addition to this, it is critical to recollect the kindness of one’s spiritual teacher when reflecting on this topic. And independence on this, the identification of the object of negation, the I, will be easier. So this is the skillful means within the context of the view to identify the I, which is the object of negation, to identify a powerful sense of I induced by great emotion.
So how do we proceed in identifying this purported I existing within the basis of imputation, the aggregates? Then if such an I existed, we should be able to find it to identify it. This is something or these are lines of reasoning we should engage in for a long time. This understanding will not arise at once. I am not saying this is difficult based on personal experience, but just on the text.
How do we proceed searching for this I within the basis of imputation of the aggregates? We seek. We seek from the crown of the head to the soles of the feet for such an eye and back up trying to find it. Then we believe this I exists, therefore, we must be able to find it. It is either outside or inside the aggregates.
Therefore, we should search in a relaxed fashion from the top of the crown to the sole of the feet if it is within the aggregates. Some teachers, I don’t remember exactly which ones when they were giving an introduction to the view, would address the student quite directly and say, where is your I? I think this is how Mahalo Tzawa addressed Milarepa. For sure, this is how Milarepa told his disciple. Then assuming it is Mapa, he would say, so show me this eye.
You speak of your house, your car, your vessel, and so forth. Show me this eye. And when we are searching for the I within the aggregates, as you know, there are five aggregates. Form, in other words, matter or the body, sensation, discrimination, composition of factors, and consciousness. So we initially search within form for the eye.
Then when we search within form for the eye, how could we find it? After all, the I includes sensations of pleasure and of suffering. These sensations are not material. How could they be within the form aggregate? Then let us exclude the form aggregate and look at the remaining four aggregates starting with sensation.
Then could we find the I within the remaining four bases of imputation, the remaining four aggregates? No. The remaining four aggregates, sensation, composition of fact discrimination, composition of factors, and consciousness, are all consciousness. Then we have immaterial component. We eat, we sleep, we meditate, we do things.
How could this just be consciousness? Then I will not enter into further detail regarding the search for the eye in the aggregates, but when we search for the eye within the aggregates, we cannot find it. Right? Then we seek, seek, seek for the I within the aggregates, and we do not find it. It is unfindable.
This does not mean that its nonexistence is findable. So in English, we speak of sol for the eye. When we say that this I is unfindable within the aggregates, it is critically important to understand that this does not mean that its nonexistence is findable within the aggregates. In addition, one should reflect on the fact that not only is this I or this soul unfindable within the aggregates, it is unfindable out of them. So when we seek for the I within the aggregates, it is unfindable under ultimate analysis.
At the same time, its nonexistence is not findable under ultimate analysis. So what does this mean? The I does exist. After all, we speak of my car, my house, and so forth. So what is exactly its mode of existence?
Here, if we do not have experience, there is a very high risk that we will fall in the extreme of nihilism. So what is the mode of existence of this I? Within the fact that this eye does not exist in the slightest, within the basis of imputation, which are the aggregates, this I is a mere imputation on these bases of imputation. Apart from the fact that this I is a mere imputation on the basis of imputation, it is not established in the slightest. This non establishment in the slightest is emptiness.
So this is emptiness and his holiness, the Dalai Lama has said that the way to engage in these investigations is to seek for the I over and again. And upon realizing its unfindability, to understand that this does not entail the findability of its nonexistence. So this total unfindability of the eye within the aggregates, this is emptiness. The appearance of the I as existing from its own side within the aggregates, as being established, truly established within the aggregates, this is the object of negation. Emptiness and the object of negation are directly contradictory.
What or to which mind does the object of negation appear? It appears to the apprehension of a self. What counters this? The wisdom realizing emptiness. Let us take the example of the table in front of Geishira.
How does this table appear to us? This table appears to us as established from its own side. Yet, under ultimate investigation, what do we find? What is this table? The corner of the table is certainly not the table.
It can’t fulfill the function of a table of holding things up. If I put my cup there, it will fall down. So no part of the table is the table. Then what is the table? The table is a mere imputation on the collection of these parts.
So this is how one has to proceed in the analysis of the relationship between the object of imputation, the eye, and the basis of imputation, the aggregates. So therefore, how precisely does the object of imputation, the I, exist? It does not exist in the slightest from within the basis of imputation. It is a mere imputation upon this basis of imputation. It is established as a mere imputation, it arises as a mere imputation.
In this case, what precisely is the relationship between the object of imputation and the basis of imputation? The relator here is the imputation of an I. The related object is the basis of imputation. This is the relationship between the two, and this must be understood. So what is the object of refutation which appears to the ignorance grasping at a self?
It is a an I or a self which exists independently, autonomously of anything else. Such a thing obviously does not exist. Therefore, since it is a mistaken object, the mind which apprehends it is also a mistaken mind. And independence on this mistaken mind, desire, hatred, all the afflictions arise. So I will re explain this.
What is the object of appearance of grasping at a self? The object of appearance of grasping at a self is precisely this I which seems to exist without depending on anything else. This becomes the object of predilection of grasping at a self and independence on such an object of predilection in turn, all of the afflictions arise. I will not explain this further in detail because there is no benefit. That’s the way it is.
Then it is important to rely on a very profound line of reasoning known as the royal syllogism to understand this. The royal syllogism is as follows. The subject, the person, is not truly established because of being a dependent arising. If one formulates it more precisely, it reads as follows. The subject, the person, is not truly established upon its basis of imputation because it arises independence of its basis of imputation.
Then once one understands correctly the process of imputation of an imputed phenomenon such as the I on its basis of imputation and applies this to all phenomena, all phenomena become illusion like. They are not illusions, they become illusion like. When they become illusion like, you can see that attachment and predilection would dwindle. This is how it is. We’ve covered this in forty minutes.
So to spend too much longer on this would be meaningless, I wanted to cover the material in a concise fashion. We can only present here the words since we don’t understand the meaning. Then try to reflect on this if you have time. What do I say? You do have time.
So reflect on it. It is very beneficial. It’s not the case that you don’t have time. And from your own side, without checking text, to reflect on this by yourself. You have taken numerous notes, read your notes.
If you don’t understand something, ask your translator. For sure he can explain it. He has studied these texts. So this is how one should proceed when one wishes to understand a topic one studies. Initially, one must study it, but then one must ask questions not without having studied first, but after having studied, preferably from someone who has experience and not just from anybody.
Then one’s own understanding would improve. So after understanding the thoughts of cyclic existence, in other words, the thoughts of the afflictions, one will generate the mind striving for liberation. At this point, one endeavors to accumulate as much virtue as possible. Let alone this, understanding emptiness and reflecting on emptiness, the virtue accumulated in this way becomes a cause for liberation. Why is this the case?
This is the case because the mode of apprehension of ignorance, in other words, grasping at a self, is grasping at a self which is established from its own side. Emptiness is precisely the non establishment of the sense from its own side. In other words, the opposite to the establishment of the self from its own side. It is this ignorance which grasps at the existence of the self from its own side, which is the cause of cyclic existence. Activities or deeds which are accrued through reflecting on the self not being established from its own side are the direct opposite of this and act to gain liberation from psychic existence.
Let us therefore generate the motivation after reflecting on the faults of cyclic existence and of the afflictions which strives for liberation from these, and striving for liberation from these generates resolve to listen to teachings such as this one on the Lamrim and so forth. When I say to generate the motivation, I mean by this that you should meditate and you should meditate on what we covered. In other words, the explanations on emptiness and so forth. So this will lead us back to the topic of the 12 links. And as you remember yesterday, one student asked what precisely will happen in the case of people, for instance, who were given morphine at the time of death and who died without any feeding whatsoever, unaware of the death process.
Then as you remember, we said that links eight, nine, and 10 were the links of maturation of the karmic imprinted plans placed into two links. This is an important doubt. So such a person could not generate the limbs of craving and appropriation, which would cause a maturation of the karmic imprint placed during the third limb into the limb of existence. However, such a person would generate craving in the intermediate state, in the abalo state, craving for rebirth into its future location and or in its future rebirth, and this would cause a maturation of the tenth limb. This is the way some scholars explain this type of situation.
And this is explained in great detail when one studies topics such as Madhyamaka and so forth. And therefore, the eight and the ninth limbs, the limbs of craving and of appropriation, cause the maturation of the impelling comma deposited during the second limb, the limb of composition of factors, into a realizing comma. This realizing comma leads to the tenth limb, the limb of existence. At this point, one is impelled into the next rebirth and there are four possible types of births. One can be born from an egg, from the womb, from heat and moisture, or experience miraculous birth.
Assuming one is born from the womb, in other words, one has a mammalian birth, then the consciousness enters within the union of the spermatozoa, which comes from the father, and the egg from the mother. So, the period from the instant of conception when consciousness enters the fertilized egg, the union in other words the spermatozoa and ovum, all the way up to the appearance of the sense organs is known as the limb of name and form, the fourth limb. So the limb of name and form, the fourth limb therefore extends from the instant of conception up to the point where the sense organs are complete. During this period, the embryo looks like a globe a global a global, so global entity. Then the limb of contact extends from the period where the sixth sense organs are complete up to the point where sensation becomes possible.
The limb of sensation occurs when pleasant and unpleasant sensations are experienced. This whole process from the limb of name and form through to the completion of the limb of sensation lasts seven or eight years. As is said in Abhidharma, after conception, eighteen weeks lapse until the human body is perfected and the nineteenth week birth occurs. Then the limb of birth covers birth specifically. The limb of aging and death extends from the moment after birth until the time of death.
Then the limb of aging, the twelfth limb, extends from the second instant of birth until the time of death. Then the process of aging and death are fused in one limb, the twelfth limb, since it is considered that aging begins at birth and the process of decay, whitening of the hair, wrinkles and so forth begins really with the birth process. Then there is a doubt at this point which arises. One might think after all, at the level of the eleventh limb, since birth has occurred, normally all 12 links should be complete. The birth which is a maturation of the impelling karma has occurred.
This is not the case since for the 12 links to be complete, the totality of one cycle of the 12 links including the limbs of aging and death must be completed. Then we are transmigrators, beings of cyclic existence. In other words, the totality of our aggregates are subsumed within the 12 links. If we take our five aggregates in this life, which of the 12 links are they subsumed in? The last two, birth and aging and death.
Then in our continuum at present, most probably the limbs from limb four to 10, name and form, the six large eye, contact sensation, craving appropriation, and existence do not exist. So if you have questions, ask your questions now. I’ll take two or three questions and then we’ll stop. Then since I explained a lot regarding the grasping of a self ignorance, it would be good to ask questions on that topic. Mark?
So the realm of sujism is presented in Buddhist texts as follows. The subject, the person, is not established from its own side or is not truly established because it is independent arising. A more precise presentation is the subject, the imputed phenomenon, I, is not truly established or established from its own side within the base of imputation because it depends on the base of imputation. Four minutes, I thought This is minutes. Gishou said he already explained this for four minutes.
So generally speaking, we are unable to identify the I which is the object of negation at present because powerful emotions are not present in our mind stream. So it is when these powerful emotions are present that we should identify the I. Now how does the recollection of the spiritual teacher help? When we recollect the kindness of the spiritual teacher, a very powerful emotion arises within us. To whom has a spiritual teacher been kind?
To me. This powerful sense of I am the recipient of the kindness of the guru arises and the one analyzes this. Then when we speak of the love of the spiritual teacher, we should understand that it is not a love for us for this life. Like the love our parents have for us, I mean, it’s clear our parents love us or the love our children have for us. It’s only for this life and it is interested The love of the spiritual teacher is rooted in great compassion.
Then when we think in this way that it is a love for a large number of lives, this is very heavy, very weighty. Yeah. And? Yours is a profound question. It is good you think like that.
Then I gave a superficial explanation. In reality, it is very possible. Specifically, the mind only school, as you know, teaches eight collections of consciousness, and the seventh consciousness is known as the afflicted consciousness. Now the afflicted consciousness does not contain anger, but it does contain desire and craving. So certainly a Chitamatra explanation of the death process for people who die under morphine would be very interesting.
It would be the craving in the afflicted consciousness, the seventh consciousness, which causes the maturation of the karmic imprint. Your question is interesting. It is related to the issue of the seventh and the eighth consciousnesses in Chitamatra. The afflicted mind is the seventh and the mind basis of all is eight. Now these are not consciousnesses like our ordinary consciousness.
These are very subtle consciousnesses. So generally, you So death process is the same for most people. Breathing becomes more difficult and stops. At this point, the limbs loosen. After a couple of minutes, the limbs once again become rigid.
Rigor mortis sets in. At this point, one can say the consciousness is gone. Then, obviously, this only applies to a, quote unquote, relaxed death from disease. Bach in Tibetan means in between. Bardo is the in between state, the intermediate state.
It occurs between one’s death in one life and one’s rebirth in the next life. Abidharma states that one stay stays up to forty nine days in the Bardo. This is just the nature of the Bardo. And during this state, which one only experiences if one is being reborn from the desire or the form realm, beings from the formless realm do not experience this, then one will seek for one’s next rebirth, one’s next body. So we don’t see Bardo beings.
They have a subtle body made of subtle matter. In the Bardo, one is impelled by one’s previous karma. Whether or not Bardo beings have thinking processes like ours is difficult to say. Mhmm. Rajat?
This is the case because the intermediate state, the Bardo, is a state in which one has a physical body which leads one into the next life. And for beings who are reborn in the formless realms, in the formless realms, one has no physical body at all. Therefore, such a body is unnecessary. So one has to see for oneself whether the feeling which arises or the sensation which arises, whether one recollects or when one recollects the kindness of the spiritual teacher is of a different nature from the sensations which normally arise or not. And if it is of a different nature, it is not related to the ignorance which grasps at the self.
If it is of the self nature, the same nature, then it is related to craving. So this sensation is not of the same nature as the powerful sensation of pain which arises when one is, let us say, burnt or the powerful sensation of cold which arises when one freezes. So it is not the case that when we try to identify the I, we have to experience painful feelings of heat or of cold and so forth to identify it. It is is a matter of faith. No.
Birth from heat and moisture is not rebirth in the hell realms. It is due to warmth. I ask Krishna for permission to add something. It seems to me akin to nonsexual reproduction in algae, in plants, and could even extend to mitosis and meiosis in cells. Then if we analyze, returning to Natalie’s question, the sensation which arises when we recollects the kindness of the spiritual teacher, this sensation actually induces a particular form of bliss.
This is not easy to understand. So in the case of a child in the dying in the womb, it is not a decision of the child, if you wish. It is of the nature of karma that after the death, the child will actually enter the intermediate state. So as I mentioned before, I suspect that this is related to a subtle consciousness such as the afflicted mind mentioned in Chitamatra in which these are present. This is a question which arises from good studies since obviously such an infant especially early on would have no sensation.
So how could craving and grasp and appropriation arise? I mentioned yesterday that I would have liked you to read some important pages of L’Amrim Chenmo on the Noble Truth of Origination. I have no way of knowing whether you read them or not, but I noticed there has not been one single question on the topic. But there are explanations regarding self grasping within those pages. We will stop here.
Key terms in this teaching
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
- The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.