Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2015-03-25 – KR.mp3
UUID: 4d94ff94-ca43-4004-8cb7-5c89d5b3447a
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2015-03-25
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 35m
Words: 4,185
So it is a very, very helpful way of thinking to try to understand how to make a human life meaningful. If one starts by making one full day of twenty four hours meaningful, then after that one is able to make seven of these days, in other words, one week meaningful, then one month, then one year, eventually, a full human life will have been made meaningful. Therefore, it is a very pleasant state of affairs to make just one day meaningful. You might think, after all, in one day, I have to work. I have to feed myself.
I have to take care of the kids. I have to take care of my elderly parents. Is this what is being referred to by leading a meaningful life? Or for that matter, is it meditating which is being referred to? Then my own approach, which I will explain to you, and I think this is a very meaningful way to proceed, is to rise early on a given day and from at that moment to create a powerful motivation.
As you said in Thogme Sangpo’s 37 practices of a bodhisattva, and I don’t recall the exact quote, that first moment of mind is most precious. And indeed, it is that first instant of mind upon awakening which is particularly pure. Then obviously, if one goes to bed really late, like eleven or 12:00 at night, it simply isn’t possible to get up at five in the morning. Once you try to go to bed earlier to get up around five. Mhmm.
So what is this powerful motivation we should generate? First and foremost, we should reflect in-depth on death and impermanence. It is said that death and impermanence is of benefit at the beginning, the middle, and the end. It’s of benefit at the beginning because it’s a gateway to practice. It’s a benefit in the middle because otherwise we succumb to laziness and it is a goad to practice.
It’s a benefit at the end because it leads to the completion of practice. So when we speak of death and impermanence, I am not speaking of death in the worldly sense. Everyone in the world knows what death is. That’s not what we’re talking about. Death and impermanence, although they are different, are conjoined.
This is meaningful. Now here when we refer to death, we are not referring to death from an accident or disease or being shot. It is simply the fact that this process of inhalation and exhalation is a hallmark of life. When it stops, we are dead. Then impermanence here refers probably to coarse impermanence, which Je Tsongkhapa alludes to in The Foundation of All Good Qualities when he says recollect impermanence and death.
Then a human being is considered to be able to live one hundred years. If we take my own case, at one point those one hundred years will be over and on that day I will die. Then it is clear that the continuum of coarse impermanence is connected to death and this is why coarse impermanence and death are considered conjoined. Then the first point to keep in mind is that if we take tomorrow, there is not a single one of us who can give a sound reason for which he or she would still be alive tomorrow. There is no good reason for this.
No justification for this. And for that matter, if we look at all of the people who are assembled in the temple today, it is probably certain that nobody will be left after fifty or sixty years. Definitely, a hundred years is a 100% certainty, every one of us will be dead. Then whenever one has the opportunity, it is extremely beneficial to think in this way. Once one has realized that this is a state of affairs, what is one going to do about it?
In a nutshell, one must abandon sin and practice virtue. This is the only thing we can do. So how should one proceed? Ideally, before going to sleep at night, just before falling asleep, one should look back on one’s day and enumerate virtuous and non virtuous deeds one has done. And if one has only engaged in virtuous deeds, one should rejoice.
And if one has engaged in sin, then one should repent and try to purify this. It is however difficult to do this just before falling asleep. One might be tired, one might not recollect, and since the mind upon rising is so clear, one can do it just after getting up in the morning. One looks back on what was done the previous day and one asks oneself, have I engaged mainly in sin or mainly in virtue? If one has engaged mainly in sin, then one generates repentance and regret.
If one has engaged mainly in virtue, one generates a mind which rejoices in this. And at this point, if one has engaged in sin, one applies the antidotes. And if one has committed a sin towards any creature, for instance, the smallest of insects, one generates love and compassion for this creature. Then if we train in this way, all four opponent forces will be present. It is extremely important, therefore, to examine oneself in this way.
Examine oneself and not examine others. Since it is oneself which must be examined and if we do this during twenty four hours and then extend this process of examination for days, weeks, months, and years, then we will have led a meaningful human life. I don’t really see what else there is as meaningful human life. And this is something which is not difficult. It does not call for an extremely acute and sharp acumen.
Anyone can engage in this examination. So do we have such an examination of oneself during one day? Do you understand? So if one has not generated a specific motivation, one should do so. And since we are covering the path of the being of the middling scope, after generating the motivation of being of the small scope, which should move up to that of the being of the middling scope.
I was not able to explain this in detail in the past, but we now have a translator that this is possible. And ideally, one should generate all the steps of the motivation from the path of the being of the small scope upwards. And for those of you who are new to the teachings, you should try to memorize the steps of the mind training of the path of the being of the small scope. Then where does the path of the being of the middling scope begin in the outline? It begins in how to train the mind to make a life of leisure and endowment meaningful.
Importance of a human base. In other words, a human rebirth. And in this matter, one might think, well indeed, the lamas have explained that a human base, a human rebirth is rare and precious, but after all, there are hundreds of thousands of human beings in China. How is this possible? This is not the right way to look at things.
Instead, one should look at one’s own self and realize how this rebirth is precious for oneself. Then it is said in the that this way of looking at things of someone who said to a teacher who was teaching on the precious human rebirth, after all, how can the human rebirth be so rare since there are hundreds of thousands of human beings in China is a wrong way of looking at things. Indeed, there are hundreds and hundreds of thousands of beings in China. I’m not quite sure how many people there are in Australia, but a lot. Certainly, in India, are a lot.
Millions in Delhi, in Mumbai, in Calcutta, but this is not what is being referred to here. What is referred to here is one one’s own opportunity in getting such a rebirth. These words of the Lamrim are extremely important for oneself. And then after having identified these three points in the presentation of a human rebirth of leisure and endowment, identifying leisure and endowment by reflecting on its meaningfulness and reflecting on its rarity, we realize that with the base we have obtained at present, we have indeed a base of leisure and endowment. And we must link this understanding with the reflections on death and impermanence which were mentioned earlier.
Understanding that this base is transitory, then we ask ourselves how do I make it meaningful? We don’t make it meaningful through the affairs of daily life, we engage in them of any way. It is something special we must engage in. What is that something special? It is the training in virtue and the abandonment of non virtue, specifically training in the practice of the ten ten virtuous deeds and forsaking the 10 non virtuous deeds.
Once we engage in training in virtue and abandoning non virtue, specifically training the 10 virtuous deeds and abandoning the 10 non virtuous deeds, the totality of the path of the being of the small scope is subsumed within this. Since independence on training the 10 virtuous deeds and abandoning the 10 un virtuous deeds, which are the object of abandonment, one will attain the object of attainment, which is a higher rebirth in a future life. And one will not have to fear being or falling in the lower realms. This we know because it was actually taught by Buddha Shakyamuni. Therefore, this leads in turn to refuge.
As Je Tsongkhapa said in these three principles of the path, in as much as a rebirth of leisure and endowment is rare and time is counted, abandon the vanities of this life. These two verses of the three principles of the path clearly link meditation on the precious human rebirth of leisure and endowment on the one hand and death and impermanence on the other hand. This is the essence of the practice of the being of the small scope and independence on this, we engage in the abandonment of non virtue and the training in virtue. And should we train in this way, we will indeed transform first one day and then a full human life into a meaningful human life. As a result of this, as is said in the Lamrim, at the very least, within the three categories of being at the time of death, we will be a being who will not experience fear.
And some of you might say, whenever Geshela teaches, he talks about death and impermanence. This is not trivial. It is an extremely important topic. It is important for beginners such as ourselves, but it is also important when one has attained the grounds and the paths to continue progressing. It’s not a small topic.
This was a practice of the great Kadampa Geshe of yore who said, if in the morning one doesn’t reflect on death and impermanence, the morning is wasted and is no longer meaningful. If in the afternoon one does not reflect on death and impermanence, the afternoon goes the way of the world. In a nutshell, the path of the being of the small scope comprises seven groups or cycles of meditation. Does this imply that one has fully characterized realizations of the being of the small scope? No, it doesn’t.
So what is a complete fully characterized realization of the path of the being of the small scope? It is that of one who has relinquished or turned away from the vanities of this life. What are the vanities of this life? The vanities of this life are desire for the affairs of this life. In other words, desire for food, for beautiful clothing, for material possessions, and so forth.
What is meant by relinquishing the vanities of this life? This does not refer to abandoning clothing and food. We have a body, contaminated aggregates. These contaminated aggregates need to survive to be covered and they need nutrition. Instead, what is meant by relinquishing or abandoning the vanities of this life is to realize that exterior objects, in other words, sights, sounds, smells, tastes, and tactile sensations, physical objects cannot give us the happiness we seek for and not to place 100% of our trust in them.
So relinquishing the vanities of this life does not therefore mean abandoning food and clothing. As Shantideva says very explicitly in Bodhisattva Charyavatara, give this physical base its due and then put it to good usage. In other words, we must provide our physical base with the food and clothing it requires before using it for other purposes. And if we train in this day, we will in this way, we will have abandoned the vanities of this life. And in accordance with the Lamrim, if we are a supreme being, then at the time of death, we will die with delight.
If we are a being of middling capacity, we will die with indifference. And if we are a being of low capacity, at the very least, we will not experience fear. Then when the Lamrim refers to the supreme practitioner dying with delight, this probably refers to the aspiration which does not fear lower rebirth, which arises on the first ground specifically upon the attainment of the path of practitioner of middling capacity at the time of death, we have equanimity or indifference, then for sure, we have completed the path of the being of the small scope and have relinquished the vanities of this life. Then in the case of the holy elder, Kenzo Kangyo Rinpoche, those of us who were present at his death can vouch that at the time of his death, there was no fear in the slightest and his mind was completely peaceful and at equanimity. As for his inner realizations, we cannot say anything, but what we can say for sure is that at the very least, he was a being of middling capacity at the time of death and therefore, at the very least, had completed the path of the being of the small scope.
Then regarding the equanimity or indifference of the practitioner of middling capacity at the time of death, such a practitioner may entertain the doubt whether or not he will be reborn in the lower realms, but this in no way affects his or her peace of mind. Then the second meaning of this indifference or equanimity at the time of death is that such a practitioner is freed of preoccupations with food, clothing, and so forth which obsess us. Then the practitioner of lowest capacity at the time of death has fearlessness. This fearlessness is a fearlessness towards death. This is something which we can train in.
I think you can do it. So ideally, one will have completed the criteria for realizations of the path of the being of the small scope. If one is unable to do so, one should be familiar with these seven topics of the seven cycles of meditation of the being of the small scope before progressing upwards to the path of the being of the middling scope. Once one has fully characterized realizations of the path of the being of the small scope, one has no conviction whatsoever in the capacity of external material or physical objects to generate happiness, durable happiness within ourselves. Instead, one looks inwards and one realizes that happiness comes from within the mind.
And that durable happiness which comes from within the mind arises through the eradication of the afflictions and this is what is called liberation. At this point, one is ready to enter into the path of the being of the middling scope. The objects of abandonment or the objects of relinquishment for the practitioner of the path of the small scope are external to himself or herself. These are external physical objects. Whereas the objects of abandonment of the practitioner of the middling scope are internal to himself or herself.
These are parts of himself or herself. In other words, it is the form aggregate, the aggregate of sensation, compositional factors, discrimination, and consciousness. There is therefore a difference in subtlety between the objects of abandonment of the practitioner of small and middling scope. As is said, the gateway to the path of the being of the middling scope is seeing the faults of the truth of suffering or the faults of cyclic existence. This is something which is not easy for ourselves because one must identify the truth of suffering or identify cyclic existence which is not easy.
Instead of this, we can validly identify the thoughts of the afflictions within our mind stream such as anger, envy, competitiveness, jealousy and so forth. Now when these faults arise, clearly we are unhappy and uncomfortable, aren’t we? So identifying their faults and wishing to be free from them amounts to wishing to be free from the truth of suffering within our mind stream. Then if you wish to identify cyclic existence, the aggregates which are subsumed within our continuum, all of our aggregates in other words, that is psychic existence. And if you wish to give an instance of your own psychic existence, anger, the subject anger, the subject envy, the subject jealousy are all instances of psychic existence within your mind stream.
Then obviously, we can identify the faults of afflictions such as anger and so forth within our mind stream and wish to be free from them. Why this is a case is something for us to investigate. However, be that as it may, when one wishes to generate the motivation to teaching such as this one, one should initially reflect on the seven cycles of meditation of the being of the small scope and then generate the wish to be free from the afflictions within one’s own mind stream and attain liberation. And the Lamrim, the graduated stages of the path is an explanation of just this. Therefore, with this as a motivation, we should study it.
And let us therefore meditate on this for a while. Meditating on this for a couple of minutes or even an hour is of great benefit. The path of the being of the middling scope is subdivided into two, a presentation of the Four Noble Truths and a presentation of the 12 limbs of dependent origination. The presentation of the Four Noble Truths begins with an identification of the noble truth of suffering. This teaching of the Four Noble Truths is particularly important since this is the first teaching Buddha Shakyamuni ever gave.
What is practice but training in what should be trained in and relinquishing what should be relinquished? To relinquish something, one must first be able to identify its faults. So when it comes to relinquishing or abandoning the truth of suffering, one must be able to identify the truth of suffering and its faults. The truth of suffering is best identified within our own continuum as precisely the anger, desire, afflictions and so forth within our own continuum. These arise from a base, a foundation which must also be identified.
Then to identify psychic existence, one must clearly understand what psychic existence is. Psychic existence is not one’s abode, one’s house, nor is the noble truth of suffering in the lower realms. There is no relationship. When anger arises, when envy arises, these are suffering, aren’t they? These are hardship.
So their thoughts must be identified. This is our cyclic existence. Then once we have identified their thoughts, we try to understand their origin, their ground. This is the 12 links of dependent arising. This is not difficult to understand.
So I shall stop here for today, And I will take your questions at present if you have pure questions. In other words, questions on the path of the being of the middling scope. And if you have no questions on that path, I will also take questions on the path of the being of the small scope. Then everyone can ask one question. And then after everyone has finished, if there is time, people can ask a second question.
So in brief, the four forces must be applied as follows. First, every thought which we have accumulated is accumulated with respect to either body or mind. And we must see these as a poison. Then seeing this as a poison, we must give rise to the force of rejection, which is this profound sensation, I shall never do this again. At this point, we must realize that whatever thought we have engaged in, we have engaged in probably with respect to sentient beings.
Therefore, we should train in love or in compassion. And finally, we should generate the force of the bond or the pledge, if you wish, the resolve never to do this again. So our minds are very low and it is something we have to understand. It is not sufficient for us to just study topics. We must also put them in practice.
No, impermanence is not a quality nor is it a characteristic. Impermanence is the nature of impermanent phenomena. Then in the case of our own aggregates, for instance, our aggregates are impermanent. But it is the realization of the impermanence of these aggregates. It’s the realization of its perishable nature, which is a quality.
Yeah. So there is a difference between the being of the great middling and small scope on the one hand and the supreme dharma practitioner, middling dharma practitioner and ordinary dharma practitioner at the time of death. There is no correlation between these two at all. So the supreme dharma practitioner at the time of death dies with delight. The middling dharma practitioner and, excuse me, the supreme dharma practitioner who dies with delight thereby indicates that this refers to a being who is on the path of seeing, on the first ground of the path of seeing.
The dharma practitioner of middling capacity at the time of death dies without fear, but this fearlessness does not refer to the ordinary courage we encounter. It is a fearlessness which arises from study. Finally, the dharma practitioner of ordinary capacity at the very least does not have terror at the time of death. This is liberation in the palm of your hand, right? No, I don’t need that.
It’s just a text. So in this course, I follow a liberation in the palm of your hand of KEVJPY. However, there are differences with other Lamrim. Specifically, are differences between liberation in the palm of your hand, its outline and the outline of Lamrim Cemo, which is slightly different. But these differences are not really important.
There are minor differences. For instance, in Lamrim Cemo, the outline reads, certainly, manner of training and the criteria of having trained. Whereas in Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand, the outline reads, generating the mind striving for liberation and the means therefore. There are slight differences between the outlines. So the identification of the object of refutation here, the I, occurs during the path of the being of the middling scope.
Yes, your doubt is correct. For so long as while we are in cyclic existence, we engage for instance in virtuous deeds motivated by an ignorance which apprehends at a self for so long the virtuous deeds which we have accumulated are causes for higher rebirth in cyclic existence and are contaminated. In brief, whatever virtuous deeds we accumulate under the power of ignorance, albeit virtuous remain contaminated. Another? So within the subdivision of the last two truths, the truth of cessation and of the path, these are said to be thoroughly purified for the following reason.
The term thoroughly specifically Namjang in Tibetan refers to the noble truth of the path which is the means by which the object of attainment which is a noble truth of cessation is attained. Now there are numerous truths of cessation. However, they are completely purified and for this reason, these two truths are called the completely purified truths. The topic of the path of the being of the building scope is the four noble truths which when it is expanded leads into the 12 limbs of dependent arising. For this reason, I would like to ask those of you who have the time and who are attending the Lamrim teachings to come for the Easter teachings on the 12 limbs of dependent arising, which will be held Friday, Saturday and Sunday of next week, the long Easter weekend.
In this way, your time will not be wasted. During those three days, I will explain the 12 limbs of dependent arising. This is a profound teaching and it is very helpful for you to receive it. And we have a good translator who has a sharp mental acumen and who has good understanding who will help. Then obviously, if you do not have time, nothing can be said.
Key terms in this teaching
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.