Emptiness — 2015-04-05

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Emptiness (TBI)
Emptiness (TBI)
Emptiness — 2015-04-05
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2015-04-05 – KR.mp3

UUID: 1ab03d25-5d61-48b9-adf1-0206a17638d7

Teacher: —

Collection: Emptiness

Date: 2015-04-05

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 49 min

Words: 6,923

Then this is our last opportunity to raise questions regarding the teachings. As Geshela emphasized the nature of ignorance this morning, let us try to focus some questions on ignorance. And then if you have any other questions on the 12 links as well. Then let me ask you a question. Why is Buddhism so counterintuitive?

So counterintuitive Everyone has a clear sense that there is an inherently existing I. We have a large number of world religions which are built on that idea of the soul. Buddhism flies in the face of the common experience of every body. I mean, every every single human being, every animal, every insect is convinced that not only does the I exist, it exists inside themselves as this permanent one independent thing. So how is it logical to say that this obvious self-evident assertion is wrong?

Why? No. I’m asking you why you’re Buddhist. I mean, Buddhism is at odds with our natural instinct. Our natural instinct is that the I exists.

Everyone deep down is somehow convinced that desire is a good thing. And I never forget a conversation I had with an old Muslim man on a train in India. It was a night night train I had to take to to Madras, you know. And when he learned I was American, he started waving a knife around. I had to sleep on the train, so it was very awkward.

You know? Luckily, he was a Hindu friend with him, so I calmed him down, and he blew up again. It was, like, couple hours of calming him down and then having him blow up. You know? He would periodically erupt saying, I hate Bush.

Then I told him, I never voted for the man in the first place, but I was guilty by association. And, eventually, we had a marvelous conversation, And he there was one thing he just couldn’t get. He told anger is a good thing. Anger makes me strong. I never forget what he said.

He said, I and only I can beat my wife. My son cannot beat my wife. So then we had a long conversation at the end of which what came out was that he suffered from depression. And this is a result of anger. Right?

Anger makes you very high at first and you become depressed. You know? But going back to our question, why are you Buddhists? If Buddhism is counterintuitive, how come you can be Buddhists? Right?

It’s a natural thing to believe there’s a soul and a god. Right? The Christians do, the Jews do, the Muslims do, the Hindus do, you know? That it’s That doesn’t mean it’s correct, but why? It doesn’t work.

Because under ultimate analysis, it doesn’t measure. Right. Why not? Well, do too, don’t we? Otherwise, you’ve been you wouldn’t be try striving for liberation, would you?

But you’re you explained to me within Buddhism why the other religion religious traditions are wrong. What I’m asking you is not that. I’m asking you, how come anyone is a Buddhist if Buddhism is so counterintuitive? Yes. And I mean, if that’s the way things are.

But what’s the answer for physics? It’s obvious. Right? Reason. Mathematics.

No. It’s not math. It’s mathematics. I mean, it’s counterintuitive. Nobody likes it.

I don’t know. A single physicist was happy about the situation. But the no. I don’t know anyone. Yeah.

Nobody’s happy. Nobody’s happy. You can’t explain what’s happening. And the better physicist just tell you, I do the math. Yeah.

You know? So with Buddhism, how do we have these very strange assertions? We sense there’s an I, but, you know. There’s something more much more fundamental at work. Much more fundamental.

Let me just add another thing, and then I’d I’d ask you your input. All the world religions, certainly all the Semitic religions assert the outside world is real, solid, real, massive. All the Buddhist religions, traditions assert it is unreal to a greater or lesser degree. All the world religions assert there’s a god, we don’t. All the world religions assert there’s a soul, we don’t.

So there’s something in the Buddhist methodology. That’s the crux here. That’s why I don’t think Buddhism is really a religion myself. What is it? Yes.

Yes. Yes. So to me, there had to be something more, deeper understanding of what happiness in that was about. How come this led you to refuting the existence of a self which seems intuitively obvious? I don’t know whether it was even a refuting of that.

It was more a realization that what I was being taught was not true. It didn’t come out true. Things weren’t happily ever after. Things weren’t permanent, I guess, is another item that comes up. So that’s you’re very much on track of what I’m talking about.

It’s what philosophers call a hermeneutics of suspicion. You don’t believe what seems obviously true. A hermeneutics of suspicion is rooted suspicion of received ideas. So you suspected the received values of society that if you studied, you got a job, you got money, you married, you had children, you would be happy. Then that can extend further to a suspicion of what society says to us about reality.

Now the poor physicists have been dragged, I think, really kicking and screaming in this direction for one century. Kicking and screaming. It’s just they were led there by the mathematics. We are led there by logic, and that’s what I was driving at. In Buddhism, and that’s why I personally am not convinced Buddhism is best described as a religion.

What comes first is logic and analysis, analysis, not faith. So Buddhism is unique in this respect. No other great teacher has said to his students, check what I say through logic. And that is how we end up with these profoundly counterintuitive positions. Intuitively, it’s obvious.

There’s a self. There’s probably some sort of creator. The world out there is real. I know. Something responds.

And yet, when you analyze, it doesn’t seem to be the case. And if you say that the foremost tool for spiritual development is logic and we are unique in saying that, then you have to accept the conclusions. Excuse me, Pamela. You wanted to say something. No.

Just Almost almost everything everything. In science is counterintuitive. Yes. That’s a very good point. Not just in physics.

Looks like the sun travels around the earth. It doesn’t. It looks like the earth’s flat. It’s not. Exactly.

There there are so many things in in reality that are counterintuitive. They look one way and they’re not that way. And and you you asked the question, you know, why are you a Buddhist? And in, you know, in my own case, I’m a Buddhist because I wanna be free. I wanna be free, and then I wanna help others to be free.

And that was only possible by analyzing the nature of the afflictions, like what makes what makes me respond the way I respond and that sort of stuff. And where does you know, what sort of trouble does that get me into? And so, I mean, if all of your evolution has trained you, you know, every single animal, every single cell in your body is is evolved to grasp it itself, then you’re it’s a pretty big job. So let’s turn it back. My next question for you is where does self grasping come from?

How come it’s there? Yeah. The Buddhist answer is just there. But how come it’s there? Right?

Is it unsettled? It’s innate. Yes. But what does that mean and why? Sex is right.

Okay. How far back does it go? To the first the first form of life. See, these are the questions we have to ask. Right?

I mean, it’s not enough to basically master a system and a function inside it. You have to ask the question of truth at a certain point. Is this true or not? And if you don’t ask the question of truth, you will not commit and you will not practice. But the question of truth becomes okay.

All of modern science is telling us one thing, which is basically survival of the individual and of species necessary and therefore as a result, actually desire and anger. It’s good to hear. Yeah. But then independence on that, and this is in popular culture now, basically, desire and anger when all is said and done are good things. They’re necessary.

I mean, if you take the more active proponents of capitalism like Ayn Rand, desire and anger are good things. It’s the fight for survival in an economic system. So how can you counter that? That’s what Natalie says. I had a There’s a lot of things which work in life which are forced.

Right? No. But, I mean, through through analysis Tons of stuff. No. But through not just accepting.

Through analysis and seeing. And for me, I had worked out a lot of things, and I felt I was going counter to society in a lot of ways from a very young age. And then when I started reading Buddhist texts, was going, oh my gosh. Someone else thinks like this. So what you and Grant are saying, and I think that is really how people do become Buddhist, it certainly was the case for me, is that you are suspicious.

I have never believed what I was told. I’ve always had to check. You were suspicious. You didn’t buy into what you were being told. You started checking, and then you got in the habit and you checked everything else.

Right? Yeah. But the question obviously is once once again the same thing. Whether it works for you is only relevant for you. No.

That was the first one of the first stepping points I was saying, like, being suspicious and then finding that you had something opposite to put in its place that worked for you. But then the next step was finding that actually this wasn’t just you, lots of people. That there was a philosophy I’m just sort of thinking about I’ve never really thought about why it is that we have that, but it’s possibly the response of our of our sensory experiences, our senses, just taking that at face value. I have a body, therefore that is me. I you know, what I see, therefore, that is what is in existence.

Just that real superficial kind of experience just based on I think largely probably more our body even in our minds and not looking any further than that because of also the the kind of necessity to keep that functioning all the time. The Buddhists assert it is present in the smallest of insects. So I’m not sure an ant for instance, where I know an ant cannot recognize itself. There’s studies about this. It appears quite late among mammals.

You know? So if an ant can’t recognize itself based on your analysis, it wouldn’t have self grasping. But would it not be able to it can recognize the other? It can see that that there’s an other there, and as soon as you posit another, then you can posit a self. We don’t know.

I mean, I have to ask and act. Right? We don’t know. We don’t know. I mean Self recognition appears late, very late.

I mean, I think it’s with dolphins, elephants, some birds, it seems some crows perhaps, You know? What’s the mirror test? The mirror test, yes. But, I mean, the mirror test is a divinely human. Very.

Isn’t it? It’s a very human test on animals that are like us. But it that really doesn’t say anything that an animal is self aware. That we don’t know. That we don’t know.

That’s extrapolation. But but the thing about where self grasping starts is that the difference between a self preserving system and a system that is not self preserving is monumental. We have absolutely no idea how a system comes to be self preserving. None, zero, zip. It is it is the truck sized hole in modern science.

We just don’t know. Well, what we have is a situation where basically modern science, I use this as a very sort of generic term, Buddhism really are similar in being unable to answer the question of first causes. There’s no answer in modern science. We study or scientists study the way things are, the extrapolate groups. Buddhists do the same thing.

And Buddha Shakyamuni went one step further. He said, basically, the question of first causes is irrelevant. Now I think for modern westerners maybe that may not be true. You may not be able to uphold your conviction if you’re not able to go a little bit further than that. So the reason I ask you why you are Buddhist, if it was so counterintuitive, is to bring out the issue of suspicion and logic.

These are central elements of Buddhist practice. Buddhist practice is not faith based. Faith is necessary, obviously, so if we didn’t believe in something at the beginning, we wouldn’t stop investigating and suspecting. So we suspect we believe things aren’t quite the way they seem. So if Buddhism is based on suspicion and logic, this makes it quite unique.

I mean, I don’t know of another philosophical, certainly a religion which is based on this, I do not know. And then if we’re going to be good sincere Buddhists, we have to apply the suspicion and this logic to the teachings. Right? And see for ourselves, is it true or not? I’ve often been surprised at TBI how uncomfortable people are when I ask them, is this true or not?

That’s the basic question. Right? True means I am convinced this is the way things are just as I’m convinced that when an object is dropped on earth, it accelerates at this 9.81 meters per second square and that’s a fact. And if you disagree, I’ll demonstrate it to you. Then if you’re not able to say that, you cannot practice.

Right? So that course a lot of work. Right? It’s not enough to study what say. At a certain point, we have to sit back and say, okay.

What is true? Like this morning, Gesheera was very very forceful in this respect. I don’t know if you noticed that he started relying very heavily on a Chitamatra presentation which to answer questions. You are perfectly entitled to have your system of tenets. It is nowhere written in carved in stone that you have to be Prasangika.

In one of the tenets classes, one of the older students I asked one of the older students what her tenet position was. She said she was Prasangika. I said, why? She said, because what Khinpoche taught. And I said, that’s a very bad answer.

Each tenet system is adapted to a certain mindset. Before even choosing a tenet system, you have to ask yourself, is are the core teachings of Buddhism true for you or not? The core teachings really from a philosophical standpoint of the four seals. You have to be clear about that. The four seals, I assume you all know them.

Right? All composite phenomena are impermanent. All contaminated phenomena of the nature of suffering. Nirvana is peace and happiness. All phenomena are empty and selfless.

These are the four seals. Then if one cannot subscribe to one of the four seals, we cannot be a Buddhist. But is it necessary to subscribe to all the four seals? Yes. Now you’re you’re asking whether they’re independent or not.

That’s another question. And and there is, you know, I can see there’s a logical progressions of the the foundations of it. But in terms of Nirvana, I can only take that as on faith. Let’s take the four seals one by one because your point is a really important one. All contaminated phenomena are suffering.

I actually don’t know a single Western Buddhist who is not ordained who believes this. People who believe this become ordained. I don’t know a single Western Buddhist who really believes that their existence is suffering because if you did, you would become ordained. You You’d become a monk or a nun. You know?

That’s the natural progression at that point. So if we are not ordained, it means we have doubts regarding this. And this calls for very careful analysis. When we say all contaminated phenomena are suffering, the key here is to understand that suffering does not mean pain. Right?

Does not mean pain. So suffering is something much much vaster than that. For the Buddhist happiness is suffering. You have to be direct with this. When we speak of happiness, speak of the suffering of change.

Is this possible? You really have to think. You have to have life experience. Then the next seal is easy for us to accept. All contaminated phenomena are impermanent.

There is massive corroboration from modern physics, chemistry for that matter, biology and whatnot. Putting it in practice is another story because every human relation is a composite phenomenon, which means every human relation is impermanent and bound to fail. Then it’s something we never put in practice. Practice. Right?

To To disintegrate. Yes. To fail. I mean, that’s what disintegration is failure. Right?

So your boyfriends, your girlfriends, your children, your father, your mother, your spiritual teacher for that matter, Your relation to your spiritual teacher is a composite phenomenon. All this is bound to fail, to disintegrate, to die. If you do not die first, the other party dies and if neither dies, the relationship changes. It’s very powerful for Then the third one is crux. If nirvana exists and is peace and bliss, then it must be our goal.

But as historians, the dynamic has over and again pointed, the key is to become convinced that Nirvana, in other words, the truth of cessation exists. This is very difficult. So if Nirvana does not exist, then the only alternative is despair, really. Because we have established things change constantly and the other nature of suffering, so it’s hopeless. So how do you establish nirvana exists?

And that’s why Gesheera gave some major pointers yesterday. The fact that the afflictions within our mind stream are transitory, something which is transitory must have causes. Right? Otherwise, it would be there all the time or not at all. So if it has causes and you can eliminate the causes, you eliminate the arising of the afflictions.

And if you can do one, then theoretically, you should be able If you can do it for one, you can do it for all. It may take forever, but you theoretically can do it. And then the question is, do you apply individual antidotes or universal antidotes? So I think almost all of us apply individual antidotes to the delusions. Desire arises, let’s see, let’s say when you were young, you see a handsome man, a pretty girl, desire arises.

Then the antidote we are taught to apply is to visualize the foul nature of the body. A friend of mine has a very simple technique, he says you just peel off the skin and below two millimeters of skin, it’s a horror. Works very well. Ribetz taught to visualize the consciousness going into the esophagus and seeing the body from the inside. Now this is an individual antidote.

In other words, it works only against desire. If you’re angry and you apply this, it’ll make you more angry actually. Yes. Because you have a sense of revulsion towards the other person. It doesn’t work.

So if we have to apply individual antidotes to it, right? Yes, yes, yes, yes. So obviously, if we have to meditate on individual antidotes for each of the afflictions, it’s hopeless, isn’t it? Because you need one antidote for desire, a different one for anger, then a different one for jealousies, a different one for it goes on and on. We’ve got eighty four thousand afflictions.

So you read it. Eighty eighty four thousand. It’s taken a long time. Right? And pride and arrogance and verboseness, etcetera, etcetera.

So the next question is, is there a universal antidote? A universal antidote would have to be something which opposes all the afflictions. This is extremely interesting for us. In practical terms, saves a lot of time. And that’s only possible if all the afflictions have one root cause, and that is the crux here.

Do they or don’t they? And we should analyze and not just take it on board. You You could very well say they don’t. Then your practice would be complicated. But if you say they do, are the Buddhists right or are the Hindus right?

Because the Hindus have the same analysis as us up to selflessness. Except that the Hindus say the root of the afflictions is that we don’t see our soul and God, Brahman, as one. The Buddhists say exactly the opposite. We don’t see what we call our soul as nonexistent. Then obviously, these two answers are totally incompatible.

It’s one or the other, and I think we really have to understand the Hindu position because it’s so close to us. And when I say Hindu, it’s a Jain position to a degree, the Sikh position. You know? And then, obviously, the big strength of the Hindu position. And if you read the Hindu treatises which debate with the Buddhist, they’re translated in English, I would recommend that you read them.

Kumarila, it’s very interesting. His main argument is the one I addressed to you at the beginning of this discussion. How come you people believe in something which is so counterintuitive? It’s obvious that Atman exists, everyone believes in the Atman. So his argument is an argument from experience.

Our argument is an argument from logic. You cannot be a Buddhist and start invoking your own private experience all the time. It flies in the face of what we do. It’s like a physicist who keeps saying, yes, but the earth doesn’t seem to move up to the apple. Actually, it does.

Or yes, the sun exists now. Actually, you can’t say. The light came came from the sun eight and a half half minutes ago. All you can see is eight and a half minutes ago it existed. So if you are physicist, you cannot appeal to your private sensory experience.

If you are Buddhist, you cannot either. You cannot say, I feel, I experience, I think. It makes no sense. You are at odds with the methodology of the spiritual tradition you are in. And therefore, big question for us is, is it true that all the illusions or the delusions arise from self grasping or not?

That’s a big question. If it is, then Jill’s question arises. Right? Is it possible to abandon the delusions and self grasping? That’s the most difficult point.

According to his Holiness the Dalai Lama, this is a crux. It’s taking me years of thinking on this one because it’s not just a matter of applying an antidote and reducing something. Abandoning means it never ever arises again however much the inducements. It’s a very very major statement. It’s not easy to come to the conviction that the ant the afflictions can be abandoned.

Now I hope you have some questions. Please. Of direct experience of emptiness, say you’re a monk in this life and you have the direct experience of emptiness at, say, 50. You die at 55. You die at 52.

What happens to the conscious I mean, do you never accumulate any impelling karma ever after that? I mean, in the what about the what happens in the next I mean, are you so immunized against self grasping that that carries over into the next life? That’s for sure. I think if you if you are a first grounder, basically, you are let’s assume your body start from the first to make the presentation simple. Then by definition, basically, you’ll get a higher rebirth.

Not only will you get a higher rebirth, but in your next life as a child, you will feel that the outer world is unreal. Yes. As a child. Just you will be looking at things with detachment, a sense of unreality. I we are taught that the afflictions will not arise.

You know? Certainly, you know, with that type of meditative experience, you would become a Buddhist early on. You’d probably be born in a Buddhist family. You’d probably become ordained. And the first time you try to meditate on emptiness, you would get direct experience again.

So it’s the case with people who have calm abiding from past lives. I mean, have known cases. I knew one case where a Tibetan doctor examined this chap, and the doctor said you have calm abiding, you know, just because of the the pulses, you know. Then people who have this in their karmic background find concentration extremely easy. It happens very quickly.

I saw cases in the monasteries. I’ve known cases, You know? It just takes one, two contacts, and it’s back there again. So that effort is not wasted. Not wasted.

But you see, what is critical here is once you’ve determined there is such a thing as nirvana, and it takes a lot of work to do this, once you have convinced yourself that the ignorance grasping at the self is really the root of everything, the root of all the afflictions, The key is what is this mistaken self which is apprehended at? And this can only be determined through very painstaking logic. It’s on par with the work of a physicist who’s trying to crack a problem, whatever, in astrophysics or quantum mechanics. Mechanics. It’s that level of work.

It’s got nothing to do with how you feel about things. Because it’s true or it’s not true. There’s really no middle ground. If you don’t identify correctly the object of negation, you will be not be able to eliminate self grasping, and all the work you have put in that would pretty much be wasted. Alright?

And it is not possible for the Vaibhashikas, the Sautrantikas, Chitamatras, the Madhyamikas to all be right. It’s not possible. It’s not possible for those who assert Shentong and Rang Tong to both be right. It’s not possible. So some people are right, some people are wrong.

And that is something we have to decide. My big critic of a misunderstanding of the Rime tradition, the non sectarian tradition, which seems to arise among people who don’t want to have to decide. The Rime, the non sectarian. It’s a misunderstanding of this where there’s a sort of nebulousness, you know. Well, nebulousness is fine in the method aspect of the past, but not in the wisdom aspect of the path.

You cannot apply the antidotes in this way. Please. So the difference between the direct realization of emptiness and the analytical process that you just described, they’re two different approaches to the same outcome. Is that right? Or are they No.

You need them both? Or No. Need the analytical approach comes first, and there’s no way to avoid it. So if you we have to try to understand what conceptuality is. When I look at this cup, I see the green color of this cup directly with my eye consciousness.

There’s no mediation. Right? And if I close my eyes and I re remember the cup I have seen, something appears to my mind. We call this something a meaning generality. Very nice term, really.

It’s a generality. If you check what appears to take look at something, let’s say the cup, you will see that what appears is an image which is stripped of all of the individual characteristics of the cup. It’s just this general feature of a cylinder, a handle, and greenness. It’s a meaning generality. The minds which use meaning generalities are conceptions.

These minds are said to be mistaken because they identify the meaning generality which they see with the object, which is obviously false. The meaning generality is that this object stripped of all its characteristics. Now, all of human civilization is a product of conceptuality and nothing else. And the difference between us and animals is a development of conceptuality. Animals have sense perception.

We have a little bit of conceptuality. We have sense perception and massive amounts of conceptuality. So physics, mathematics, biology, chemistry, philosophy, politics is the work of conceptuality. This is the most powerful tool at our disposal even though it’s mistaken. Now to gain access to emptiness, we must use conceptuality.

We use conceptuality by bringing to mind the mental image, meaning generality of emptiness, which has been correctly identified, not once but over and again. It is said that if one does this over and again, eventually, more and more, emptiness will appear directly without a meaning generality to the mind. And, eventually, it appears as is said nakedly. Tibetan words just nakedly. When it appears nakedly, you have the direct realization of emptiness.

This is only possible because emptiness is in accordance with reality and reason. Now it is impossible to gain a realization of emptiness in another way than this. So if you reject conceptuality, you are rejecting the crutch which enables you to move forward. I guess I was asking, yeah, so you use conceptuality in the process of meditation on the nature of mind is one approach. But also it seems like there’s another approach, and that is that intellectual sort of discipline or logic logic going into what is the nature of the self the grasping self.

Yes. I see them as as as slightly different approaches to the same thing. Is that correct? It’s exactly the same thing. Right.

What we were doing this morning during the teachings was meditation. This is analytical meditation. You do not have to sit cross legged in a particular posture to do analytical meditation. Scientists do analytical meditation all day, but on science and worldly affairs. You can sit in a chair, it’s much more comfortable.

Then fixative meditation is meditation which is focused on one object. When you meditate on emptiness, there are two steps. First, you must identify the object of refutation, emptiness. Excuse me. The object of refutation, inherent existence, and then generate a sense of the emptiness of that.

And then you must focus on it. Now the explanation Geshela gave this morning of how to meditate on emptiness is really the explanation I have received from all my teachers over the last thirty years. This is how all my teachers have taught one should proceed. Geshevaptan had direct perception of emptiness and calm abiding. This is what he taught.

A big problem for us is that we are unable to differentiate between the I which exists and the I which is an object of refutation. And if you apply the Madhyamika reasonings now with a mind which is at rest, you will refute the eye which exists, and you will fall in the extreme of nihilism. Because we are talking, I am talking, you are listening. There’s an actor on my side and an actor on your side. So the key is that these two I’s are blended like water and oil.

It’s an emulsion. Alright? You have to separate them. And the way you separate them is powerful emotion. It can be any emotion.

Anger is very helpful. It’s a little bit less messy than desire. Desire tends to sort of suffuse the mind with a happy feeling. You can’t really work too much. Strong anger is a moment when you can do this.

When there is strong anger, the eye which is a mere imputation and the eye which is the object of of refutation are separated. The I which is an object of refutation becomes very powerful. When there’s very strong anger, you get a feeling here, you know, like, I I I am the victim and he or she is the monster and the opponent. And if you are training and meditating on emptiness, you will have to allow this to rise and you will even amplify it. Because your goal is while this is happening with a part of your mind to look inside and to focus on this very powerful sense of independently existent I which is rearing like a dragon.

And when it is strong enough, but it has to be strong enough for you to do this. Otherwise, you’ll refute the conventional the the conventional I. When it is very powerful, then you analyze with delicacy because your goal is not to to make it disappear. If it exists as it seems to appear, as a substantially existent autonomous entity, where is it? As Geshela explained, you analyze within the five aggregates.

Alternatively, you apply the one in multiple analyses. Is it one with the aggregates, separate both or neither? There are numerous lines of reasoning. But these must be applied only when after very powerful emotion, this huge sense, this pillar of I arises. And the moment it drops, actually, it’s your object of refutation.

You must push it up again. Right? Unfortunately, the person you’re angry. No. No.

Well, no. You don’t express your anger. Right? It’s inside you. But the Gesheus who train in this, I I have heard of cases, they will actually leave the monasteries and they will go to places like Dharamsala where they’re on the receiving end of a lot of contempt because they’re seen as, you know, the Gesheus who left the monastery monastery and and they’re not treated very well.

And then they’re often humiliated frequently. They’re not given good places at the teachings. And then the eye, this eye arises a lot, you know. Whereas if one is everyone is very kind to you, it doesn’t arise. Right?

So this is the object of reification. The key in meditation and emptiness on the surfaces of persons is identifying correctly the object of reification. And certainly in Jitsong Kappa’s tradition, we feel that this was Je Tsongkhapa’s main contribution. That in Tibet, under Je Tsongkhapa, the Madhya Mika reasonings were used to refute conventional reality. And as a result, the belief and the practice of karma and causality collapsed.

Alright. If you read Nagarjuna, it is clear. Nagarjuna equates karma and causality and emptiness. Interdependence and emptiness are two phases of the same reality. Then I have talked a lot during what was supposed to be your question session.

Do you have any questions after all of this? We have five minutes. Yes. Please, please, please. I just wanted to know about the limb of birth.

Some of the sources I’ve read talk about it being the point of conception. No. And we’re talking about it differently. No, because normally the limb of birth really is the instant the infant leaves the womb. You have at conception the limb of name and form.

Then you have the limb after that, let’s say, two months later, the limb of the six sources, then contact and then sensation which all occur within the room in my own understanding of this. Then the limb of birth occurs really at the very instant a child is born out of the mother’s womb. And from that point onwards, it’s a limb of aging and death. Does that answer your question? One of the older students was asking that question yesterday, and there are a large number of varying presentations of the 12 limbs.

This is very much the one in keeping with the Jasunga, Pazam, and Chebel. It’s a very rational presentation. It makes a lot of sense. You know? So it’s the one I personally use.

Please. If it because if it gets to us if it if it projects in your mind something close to nihilism by using that kind of a metaphor, It tends towards that. Well, this has always been the problem. And in my personal opinion, the term like taboo in Tibetan is what cuts nihilism. It is not an illusion.

It is like an illusion. Then, obviously, when you see your phenomena as like an illusion, then neither desire nor anger will arise, and you will see the dance of calm. But was it as a result of using such such terminology? Was there a shift that you were saying that Tsongkhapa sort of brought it back? No.

Yes. I think it’s certainly not related to that. It’s related to the application of the radical Madhyamika criticism to conventional phenomena, like the tetralama, the chart of scorty, you know, or the analysis of phenomena to being one multiple both on either. There’s a series of lines of reasoning. And if they are applied to anything but the inherently existing eyes, they’re applied to conventional phenomenon, you end up without a conventional base to stand upon.

So this is a product and this is why the Royal syllogism is presented, it was certainly presented by Kenser Gimbucher as the best way forwards to meditate on emptiness because it links emptiness and interdependence. All phenomena, the person, but all phenomena are empty of inherent existence because they are interdependent. If something is interdependent, it is empty of inherent existence. If something is not empty of inherent existence, it is not interdependent. One of the teachings that when Ripache taught on the 05/05/2010, what arises in dependence on another is empty in nature.

That which is not dependently arising does not exist. And when you were saying about logic, that Buddhism is essentially the first starting point is logic. When I read that and when I reflect it on personal experience that I was taught the existence of God and that I depended on God, that God didn’t depend on me. I didn’t have a personal experience of that, but also I didn’t have an experience of that when I asked nuns, of which there were many because I was raised in an orphanage, etcetera, etcetera. So but more than nuns, when I talked to a couple of theologians, not scriptural scholars, but when I asked around, there seemed to be this no, no, no.

And also included with that was a very strong experience of this is it’s not disrespect to Christianity. It’s just saying that doubt’s a theological sin. Christianity and Buddhism are fundamentally different. Exactly. So if if you doubt, that’s like a massive problem.

In Buddhism, doubt is fundamental, and there’s a distinction between afflictive doubt and non afflictive doubt. So it’s like so the way I arrived at my sense of beginning, it’s like it’s Ilya, it’s like some of us have to start with reflecting on personal experience in order to then discover the logic. Others of us can pick up the logic very quickly without an understanding that Buddhism starts from logic. Of us and maybe not everybody but some of us have to begin from life experience and go, what was what was I told and what did I experience that this existence called god was? Oh, I depended on god.

You’re like the boogeyman. Listen. All of you have the same initial doubt, the same initial suspicion of what you were told which eventually spread. And this suspicion, this doubt, from a Buddhist standpoint is what we build upon. It’s very constructive.

Then I will take only one very short question. We’re overtime already. I feel that I’ve read or I try and read a lot of books, and I come to the teachings, and we talk about trying to attain enlightenment, but what I feel I need is I’m not and this sounds silly, perhaps, but really clear on what exactly enlightenment is. I would like more information on that. I sometimes feel that, you know, I’ve got on this train to a destination, but I’m not clear on the destination.

And I don’t know if I’m alone in that. Well, expressing that it well. Or That will happen as you continue to follow the teachings. I mean, the nature of enlightenment is the main topic of Maitreya’s Abhisamayalamkara, and you studied at surgery for seven years. There’s work to do.

So all the schools have their own position. We can understand what enlightenment is for reasoning, then that is obviously a very different thing from the actual experience of enlightenment. Then I must stop here for today. I would like to encourage you to continue this critical stance at home and to try to ask yourselves about the subtext of Geshela’s teachings, what Geshela implies but does not say. When a teacher like Geshela, for instance, introduces as a tenet system to answer to a question, something very powerful is being said.

That you do not have a blind commitment to a tenet system. You must study the tenet systems and then find for yourself which corresponds to your understanding of reality. So before the practice of tantra, either Chitamatra or Madhyamika is sufficient. Then each school asserts that the other is insufficient to lead to liberation. So you get to decide.

Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
atman dag (Tib)
Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
four seals
The four basic tenets that define Buddhism. They are: all compositional phenomena are impermanent, all contaminated phenomena are by nature suffering, all phenomena are empty of self-existence and nirvana is true peace. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
real I
The I that appears to exist inherently from its own side without depending on causes and conditions, parts or the mind's imputation. It is the object to be refuted. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
tenet system drubtha(Tib)
A general term for a religious and/or philosophical system, whether Buddhist or non-Buddhist. It is often used as shorthand to refer to the four major Buddhist tenet systems that emerged from India. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top