Lam Rim — 2014-04-19

49 min · 6,403 words · 19 April 2014 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim — 2014-04-19
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 49-minute discussion session, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen responds to student questions about the distinctive features of Buddhist philosophy compared to other Indian schools. He explores what makes Buddhism unique: the recognition of subtle impermanence and all-pervasive suffering within conditioned existence, and above all, the teaching of selflessness as the gateway to liberation. Through careful comparison with Hindu, Jain, and other traditions, he clarifies why impermanence—rather than permanence—is central to Buddhist causality: cause and effect are always of different natures, never the same. He uses vivid examples like a rosary of beads and an iron chain to explain how continuous causality can exist alongside moment-to-moment change. He also addresses the paths of small, middling, and great scope, emphasizing that the transition from self-grasping to self-cherishing is not automatic but depends on individual disposition, and stresses the critical importance of maintaining an unbroken link with a qualified teacher as the foundation of all genuine practice.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2014-04-19 – KR.mp3

UUID: bcfd7175-c757-46dd-835f-ac7565e11f8d

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Awakening Heart

Date: 2014-04-19

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~6,401

This transcript was generated using AI speech recognition and correction

File: 2014-04-19 – KR.mp3
Collection: Lam Rim
UUID: bcfd7175-c757-46dd-835f-ac7565e11f8d

—

This transcript was generated using AI speech recognition and has been reviewed for Buddhist terminology accuracy. Some inaccuracies may remain. Please refer to the original audio recording as the authoritative source.

# 01-140419_1328.mp3 > **Collection:** Audio Recordings — Unclassified-No-Transcript > **Duration:** 49.7 minutes > **Words:** 6,405 > **Model:** Deepgram Nova-3 > **Corrections:** 22 Buddhist terminology fixes > **Transcribed:** 2026-03-02 22:01 — Then what are your questions? Focused very much on what we covered this morning, and if we have time, we can cover some of the material from yesterday again. So…

Read full transcript

# 01-140419_1328.mp3

> **Collection:** Audio Recordings — Unclassified-No-Transcript
> **Duration:** 49.7 minutes
> **Words:** 6,405
> **Model:** Deepgram Nova-3
> **Corrections:** 22 Buddhist terminology fixes
> **Transcribed:** 2026-03-02 22:01

—

Then what are your questions? Focused very much on what we covered this morning, and if we have time, we can cover some of the material from yesterday again. So it’s a path of the being of the small scope, uncommon features, and the beginning of the path of the being of the great scope. When Geshela said this morning that probably specific to Buddhist Śākyamūni’s teachings, speaking in relation to the path of the middle scope, the contaminated aggregates we have arise from karma. He then went on to say, this origination does not start with karma, it arises from ignorance.

Perceiving what does not truly exist as truly existing and that leads to karma. The origin of contaminated karma, this is the specificity of Buddhism. Is the, therefore the uniqueness of Buddha Śākyamūni’s teachings in this respect, the whole of that or the proposition that contaminated aggregates arise from Karma? So is it the logical flow starting in this instance from ignorance? I understand your question.

So we have to give a bit of background for this one. All of the so called Gangetic schools of thought of ancient India, perhaps with the exception of the materialists, the Cārvākas or the Lokayatas, and one or two minority schools, all teach the existence of cyclic existence, in other words of a cycle of lives everyone agrees. saṃsāra is basically acknowledged by all and all without exception consider saṃsāra a locus of suffering all do all wish for liberation or Mokśa from saṃsāra So this is, if you wish, the the leitmotif of ancient Indian thought, just as the leitmotif of Semitic let’s say Judeo Christian thought in the broadest sense is the idea of creation, man’s status as a creature, in man’s attempt to satisfy the wish of his or the wishes, the intent if you wish, of his creator and man’s failure to do this. In all the Semitic traditions, Judaism, Islam, and Christianity, I view Christianity as a Semitic tradition in its inception, attempt to try to find, the response man can have to his failure to fulfill the wish of his Creator. All of the Indian traditions attempt to find the way to liberation from psychic existence.

Now where they disagree is a) what precisely the sufferings of psychic existence are and b) what the means to gain cyclic liberation from cyclic existence are all the traditions this is Buddhism, Hinduism, Jain teach that cyclic existence is a locus of what we know as a suffering of suffering Only the Buddhists acknowledge the existence of the suffering of impermanence, the suffering of change as we know it, because most of the Indian traditions do not recognize impermanence it’s a Buddhist specificity, and not one acknowledges the existence of all pervasive suffering. So already in terms of the diagnostic of the suffering of psychic existence, there is a twin Buddhist specificity. The suffering of impermanence is specifically Buddhist and it is precisely for this reason you have a large number of treatises by great Buddhist scholars like Ratnākaraśānti which will typically be called Ksanabhangasiddhi proving impermanence, they are proving impermanence to the Nyayas, to the Vaisheshikas, to the Vedantins and whatnot, and in addition the core assessment Buddha Śākyamūni makes of the nature of psychic existence is that psychic existence is pervaded by all pervasive suffering. All pervasive suffering is a suffering of the contaminated aggregates. Okay?

When we speak of contaminated aggregates, what we mean by contaminated aggregates are aggregates, in other words form, sensation, discrimination, compositional factor and consciousness, our constituents, taken under the power of karma and klesha. So every single one of us in this room is a concatenation of contaminated aggregates. Buddha is unique in Indian thought in teaching that this is of the nature of suffering. Then, Buddha Śākyamūni’s teachings are unique in world religions in teaching selflessness as the gateway to Mokśa. Everyone agrees in India that Mokśa and liberation is the goal.

Everyone disagrees regarding how to get there. So all the non Buddhist traditions assert that the goal is a recognition of the identity of one’s own inner self, known as an Ātman, a soul, with either a universal principle which might be Purusha for Sāṃkhya or Brahman in Vedanta. The Buddhists are alone in inserting and asserting, and it’s a very forceful assertion in India, that there is no ātman on the inside and there is no Brahman or Purusha on the outside which leads a Buddhist to be accused of atheism by the other Indian traditions which is true we are atheists there’s no particular you know, doubt about it. So to answer your question therefore, it is the whole stream or the whole causal string from contaminated aggregates to selflessness, which is a Buddhist specificity, and then really, if you want to put it in one word, it’s selflessness. Does that answer your question?

Do you have other questions about this morning? I’d like to emphasize it’s really it would be very much to your benefit to study ancient Indian philosophy. There are simple introductions. The best is Radhakrishnan, but that’s a two volume treatise. It might be a bit inaccessible.

But take the Upanishads, read them to understand what precisely was the dominant viewpoint in the milieu in which Buddha taught when we speak of a refutation of an inherently existing self what are we talking about The Hindu vision of the self is almost identical to the Buddhist the Christian vision of the soul, the one difference is that the Hindu Ātman pre exists this life and post exists this life, the Christian soul is created at conception according to the Christians at least. But otherwise, the idea of something which is permanent one and independent somewhere within ourselves is a core idea of the Upanishads, and they describe this stuff, it’s quite amusing, as being of the size of a thumb or perhaps a bit smaller. It’s true. I think it’s in Chāndogya Upanishad, and I’m not quite sure where that comes from. Do you have other questions?

Sam, please. The Upanishads, u p a n I s h a d. These are the some of the holiest texts of ancient India, they were composed between the seventh century BC and somewhere some as late as the eighth or ninth century A D, but these were the texts composed by the forest yogis in the milieu we called them the Sanyas, in the milieu in which Buddha evolved and they presented dominant view which eventually was incorporated in Vedanta by Shankara. Yes, Sam. That liberation from Mokśa was an incarnation as Brahma.

But Buddhism teaches that that’s just another stage of suffering. Is that correct? So as we move up towards the higher states, that’s one of the key differences is that we recognize that that state as a god or that incarnation as a god is actually still being bound to saṃsāra, whereas the difference, or that being the key difference, is that correct? It’s awkward, because basically the Upanishads were composed over more than a thousand years and they disagree in more than they agree in. You have one Upanishad for pretty much every position.

It’s a real sign of the independence of thought of ancient India. Then what they understand as Mokśa varies. For some it is simply becoming Brahma, which the Buddhists interpret as being reborn as the God Brahma, which is a rebirth in psychic existence. But then you have a whole rereading of the Upanishads, you have several rereadings, certainly, in history the the latest and the dominant one is Shankar’s rereading in what the sixth seventh century of our era, which is now I would say the way most Indians read the Upanishads they’re not even aware of the fact that they wear Shankara’s lenses when they read the Upanishads. And for Shankara, the Upanishads teach that the individual soul must become aware of its identity with the universal soul, with Brahman.

When this happens, that soul is liberated and the person becomes what is known in Sanskrit as liberated, while still alive. So it’s really helpful to understand the differences in the Indian views to understand the Buddhist specificity, and the Buddhist specificity is really selflessness, and to a subsidiary degree impermanence, it’s astonishing how provoking impermanence is to the Indian mindset, Astonishing. You’re talking about answer your question, sir? And try to read the Upanishads. It’s extremely interesting.

Don’t just rely on our presentation of Hindu thought, because the presentation of Hindu thought which you get many from Candrakīrti’s Madhyamakāvatāra, you have to keep in mind it’s basically in late eighth, early ninth century presentation, and the Tibetan understanding is pretty much frozen in time. Right? Now, Indian thought evolved before that and has continued to evolve after that. So it’s very interesting to study. Chris, excuse me.

When you talk about impermanence, you’re talking about subtle impermanence, I’m assuming? Not gross? Well, it’s difficult to deny cause impermanence, although Vedanta goes very far in that direction. Once you assert that conventional phenomena are Maya, illusion, then so is impermanence. No, it’s difficult to deny cause impermanence.

Subtle impermanence is a very big problem for Hinduism. You have to keep in mind, is this something which is too far far reached for or you find it interesting? The core difference really between the Hindu schools and Buddhism in terms of the understanding of causality is a relation between cause and effect. So the Hindu schools, starting with Sāṃkhya, assert that cause and effect are of the same nature. It’s called Satkaryavadin, the path, if you wish, the Vada of the unity of entity.

What do you say when you are saying that a cause and an effect are of the same nature? You are saying that nothing changes. That change is an illusion. The nature of the cause is present in the effect. The effect is just the cause under another aspect.

Now the Buddhist viewpoint is radically opposite. The Buddhists assert that cause and effect of different natures, and this is very very provoking from a the standpoint of the other Indian darshanas viewpoints, because if cause and effect are of a different nature, and every phenomenon, let’s say this table changes instant by instant, and you have each instant, the instant of this table is the cause of the succeeding instant, and each of those instance is of a different nature from the preceding one. You don’t just have change, have true change, true impermanence. Then, once you assert this it becomes impossible to maintain much of the Hindu tenets so the main arena of debate between the great Hindu scholars and the great Buddhist scholars up to the eighth century was impermanence it wasn’t selflessness and beyond impermanence was causality a cause and effect of one nature as Sankhya and all the Hindu schools assert Satkaryavada or a cause and effect of different natures as the Buddhists assert Asatkaryavada. If you meditate on this you will find it’s very powerful for mind for the mind.

What sort of a world are we asserting in which every instant of a phenomenon is of a different nature from the preceding instant? Please, Sam. In any other language could be misconstrued as continuity or permanence because it can be a subtlety. How can that be confused or can’t that be confused with the concept of an if you talk from a subtlety perspective. So if you take away all the language and realize that there’s a continuity of a mind stream which can be another interpretation of the Ātman, isn’t there a commonality between the two?

Not a difference? Okay. This is one rosary, right? By asserting that this is one rosary, are you asserting that none of these beads are different from each other? Okay.

You can assert that this is one rosary, and simultaneously assert that every one of these beads is different from each other. Right? Okay. Now this is a Buddhist position on the nature of the mind. Each of these beads is one instant of mind.

Each of these beads is different, not just different, it’s different in nature, it’s a different thing, truly different from the succeeding one, but together they constitute one rosary, and the the key debates in Indian philosophy hinged on how do you ensure continuity, so the Hindu said, if you view cause and effect as a different nature, you cannot maintain the core continuity of the causal chain, it’s a little bit what you’re saying. The Buddhist answers, far from there, it is only through viewing cause and effect as different that we can justify the existence of causality otherwise why would an effect arise in the first place? And the debate between Hinduism and Buddhism then hinged on the possibility of an existence of a causal continuum, to be this rosary, in which each causal instant, each bead is of a different nature than the preceding one, and yet is inextricably linked to it. An even better example than the rosary, which I personally prefer, but I don’t have one around, sorry, is a big iron chain. So I try to carry one when I it’s probably just topic next time I could do that.

But you’ll forgive me, you know, my pockets are too small. If you have a big iron chain, you can clearly see that each link of the chain is of a different nature. It’s a different thing, fully different from the preceding link, yet there is such a thing as a chain as a whole, alright, the chain as a whole is a substantial continuum, each link is each instant of the chain. Well the linkage would be the causal relationship, that intimate connection which makes one link dependent on the previous one and and makes it an anticipator of the succeeding one. Then this is how you have to understand the 12 links or the 12 limbs.

Better translated as 12 limbs, really. These are 12 different things. Right? They are completely different, they’re different in nature. They’re in a causal relationship but different in nature because things which are causally related from a Buddhist standpoint are necessarily of a different nature.

Okay? That’s an excellent question, Richard. Mokśa was attainable because non moksha was an illusion. You have to wax poetical, you have two fundamentally different sensitivities in Indian philosophy, the dominant sensitivity and the Buddhist one. The dominant sensitivity is the view of permanence it’s permanent ease everything is permanent in one it is just an illusion that we do not perceive it when we awaken from our dream from the Maya we see things as they are.

They had always been like that. There is nothing to realize. This is, I think, the dominant view in Jain, in Hinduism, the various schools of Vedanta and so forth. And then you have the Buddhist viewpoint, which is completely different. For which change is real, it is not an illusion, and this reality of change means that we evolve in an extremely unstable and rather frightening universe.

It’s very different viewpoints. Do you do you see the difference? Then in the centers, I think because of the premature introduction to tantra, a lot of people end up with a crypto Hindu form of Buddhism, where the mind of clear light everyone pays lip service to impermanence and selflessness, but the mind of clear light is basically reassuringly seen as a soul. There in the background, permanent one, unchanging. This is not at all the correct understanding of the mind of clear light.

Mind of clear light is impermanent. Every single instant is different from every other single other instant. It is just as selfless as any other phenomenon. You have other questions about this morning? Yes, please.

My questions concern the aggregates. Firstly, I’ve completely forgotten what they are so long ago since I originally had teachings on them. I mean you did go through them but I’ll get you to go through them again. But then is it the case that the aggregates can only be contaminated so you need to be, no, so you can purify your aggregates. So you can still be a living being but without being in saṃsāra if you purify your aggregates?

Then I will answer into the details, because there is disagreement between the various Buddhist schools on this one. First, what are the aggregates? The term aggregate is one you might very profitably meditate upon. Skanda in Sanskrit, Pungpo in Tibetan, it means a heap of things, a heap of let’s say of incense of dust. The aggregates are collections of things and the presentation of the five aggregates form, in other words matter, the body, sensation, discrimination, compositional factors in consciousness is for the purpose of leading to a breakdown of the person, a subdivision of the person in the parts of which no Ātman can be found.

This is the goal of the presentation. So once you eliminate the body, then you eliminate sensations a sensation of which is pleasant unpleasant or neutral then you eliminate discrimination the mind which analyzes these sensations then you eliminate compositional factors which is mainly karma and intention and then you eliminate consciousness which is the main minds, from a Buddhist standpoint there is nothing left, so this is why the aggregates are presented. Then the Buddhist schools disagree, Broadly speaking, the Hīnayāna schools consider that attaining full enlightenment, or for that matter attaining liberation, means that one abandons one’s aggregates. So one becomes, one attains nirvana, and at that point one becomes an Arhat. And at the time of one’s death, one enters into a Parinirvana, a permanent nirvana, in which there is no remainder.

It’s called a remainderless nirvana. This means that consciousness is extinct, everything is extinct, there is a true cessation, because the motor for the five aggregates, which is Karma and Kleśa, has disappeared. Then the Mahāyāna schools don’t agree. They consider that there are such a thing as uncontaminated aggregates, the example of which would be, for instance, a Buddha’s Supreme Emanation Body, which is manifested for the sake of sentient beings. So you have here a very core distinction between the Hīnayāna and the Mahāyāna.

Then you find traces of the debate between two traditions in Śāntideva’s Bodhisattvacharyavatara, where Śāntideva debates with the Hīnayāna practitioners and says, if this is truly your view, why do you pray? I mean, who do you pray to if you consider that the continuum of the Buddha has ceased? Because if that is truly the view in Theravāda, then upon the Buddha’s entering Parinirvana, dying literally, nothing was left. Then in Hīnayāna, as in Mahāyāna, there are prayers. Who does one pray to?

So the Mahāyāna view of Parinirvana is that the Arhats enter into what is known as the stupor of concentration they are drunk with concentration and they remain in this state, a very profound Samādhi in other words, until the Buddhas draw them out of this Samādhi. Traditionally this is believed to happen in a pure land, the Arhats are considered ensconced in it’s quite beautiful gigantic lotuses whose petals are closed, they don’t see anything of the outside, and eventually, the Buddhas of the great bodhisattvas manifest and jolt them out of this stupor of concentration, and they enter then the Mahāyāna path with a couple advantages and major disadvantages. So the advantages typically would be that they will have calm abiding, will have generated renunciation, they will have eliminated all of the afflictive obstructions. The big disadvantage is because they have attained a state of peace, they have no empathy for the suffering of others, and therefore no particular incentive to practice the Mahāyāna. This is the biggest disadvantage of first attaining liberation and then being awakened, if you wish, out of liberation to become a Bodhisattva.

So does that answer your question? Concerning Khensur Rinpoche, given that, don’t know the terminology but when his body was burned there were the relics, sacred relics there and so forth. Is that an indication that he had purified his aggregates? It’s very difficult to say. It’s very difficult to say.

I mean clearly the relics are the sign of particularly advanced tantric practices. As disciples of Rinpoche, obviously, we train our minds to see Rinpoche as a manifestation of a fully enlightened being. This is what is meant by Guru Yoga. From Rinpoche’s own side, who Rinpoche was, we have no way of knowing. We have no access to each other’s mental continuums.

Do you have other questions? Yes. Oh, Natalie, maybe. Just following on from that previous question of Deborah’s about that led you to talk tell us about the Bodhisattvas and Buddhas shaking these Aahat’s out of their lotus petals. Have we got any stories about what sorts of things they do to actually get them to start empathizing and wanting to become Mahayanas practitioners?

I really don’t know, perhaps a strong cup of coffee passed through the lotus petals? I don’t know. The term used is the one exactly you used, Yoa, to shake, to shake. Yes Richard. Again leading on from what Deborah was talking about, if the middling scope is about eliminating self grasping and the great scope is about eliminating self cherishing.

And the road to the great scope is necessarily by the small scope and the middling scope. And your amusing at least picture yesterday of arriving in Paris but having to go via Perth sounds a bit as if one is flying Emirates via Doha as well. And in order to get there, you’ve got to stop in Perth and then in Doha. That seems to presuppose that in order to get yourself cherishing, you’ve got to go via self grasping. You have two paths.

Once a semblance of renunciation has been generated, one can decide that it is too difficult to help others and focus on oneself. This in all of the Theravāda schools is seen as the realistic decision. Most people don’t want to be helped. If they don’t want to be helped from one’s own side one can’t really do a lot it makes no sense to waste a lot of time on people who don’t want to make the effort on their own side the Theravāda traditions in Thailand and Burma recognize the theoretical existence of bodhisattvas but they also say it is far too difficult to pass it is unrealistic it’s much more sensible to attain liberation for oneself and therefore they really do focus on the elimination of self grasping, the apprehension of a truly existing self, to attain oneself liberation. Then Geshela put it very nicely today, I think, The practitioners and this is a matter of the comic predispositions of the person.

There are some people who have a natural predisposition for the Mahāyāna, from what limited experience I have, and some who simply don’t. And however much preaching would engages in those who don’t, don’t, and those who do, do. Those who do naturally have a sense of empathy for others and find it very uncomfortable to think that they themselves are going to attain either liberation or even more advanced states, you know, while others continue to suffer. Then dominant in that mind’s person is countering self cherishing. And as Geshela did explain, self cherishing and self grasping are intimately linked.

The one is the cause of the other. Does that answer your question? It appears to suggest that you don’t need to have completed the path of the middling scope before embarking on the path of the great scope, and it is not necessary to arrive at completion of the path of the middling scope before we have transitioned to the path of the middling You wouldn’t have to become an Arhat before you enter the bodhisattvayana. The distinction to be kept in mind here is the one I mentioned yesterday between the path which is specific to the being of the small and the middling scope and the path which is shared with the being of the small and the middling scope. Is very different.

The path which is specific, let’s say, to the being of the middling scope means that one’s goal is nirvana, and one practices, in this case, meditation on the Four Noble Truths and the 12 Links until one attains nirvana. Then at that point, as I mentioned earlier, one can enter the Mahāyāna, the path of the being of the great scope, but this is a very uneconomical way to go about it, simply because one’s motivation, which is a dominant factor for entering the Mahāyāna, will be weak. Alternatively, one practices a path shared with the being of the middling scope. One engages in meditations on the Four Noble Truths and the 12 links, and then, without completing the path of the being of the middling scope, one realizes all other beings are in the same situation. Then, the moment one generates uncontrived bodhichitta, spontaneous bodhichitta, one will have entered the Mahāyāna, on the path of accumulation.

Then with this spontaneous bodhichitta, one starts meditating on the selflessness of phenomena. One generates calm abiding, progresses on the path of preparation, and when for the first time one gains direct experience of emptiness, one would have entered the path of seeing. One still has not eliminated the afflictive obstructions, which an would have eliminated at the end of the path of the being of the middling scope. Are you still with me? The bodhisattvas eliminate the afflictive obstructions much later at the level of the eighth ground.

They progress upwards from the path of seeing through seven grounds, meditating on the emptiness of phenomena with ever deeper efficiency and at the level of the eighth ground they eliminate the afflicting obstructions and then at the level of the tenth ground they eliminate the obstructions to omniscience and become fully enlightened. So this is really I’m sorry to present this in such a short way, this is a topic of grounds and paths of Salam. Hopefully we will study this at TBI this year at some point. So just following on from that, we were discussing earlier at lunch the transition between self cherishing and other cherishing. My question was, is there a point in the instructions in the path of the being in the middle middling scope where by following the instructions you get to the point of deciding I’m gonna cherish others not myself.

So what you’re saying really is it’s more a part of someone’s disposition rather than any specific instructions within the path of the being of the middling sky. Precisely. There is no necessary transition from the path of the being of the middling scope to the path of the being of the great scope. I’d like to point something out which, you know, I think has to be said because it’s something I’ve heard frequently in centers. It is an extraordinary thing to be a being of the middling scope.

You know, there’s a lot of casual lip service paid to being a Mahāyāna practitioner. I don’t know a lot of Mahāyāna practitioners. Among the Geshe’s I know one or two. I know one westerner who is a Mahāyāna practitioner, not in this country. Otherwise, don’t know any.

And I know very few practitioners of the middling scope. A true practitioner of the middling scope is someone of extraordinary capacity. My late teacher Geshe Rapten heard when he was in Switzerland that the great Burmese monk Mahasi Sayadaw, one of the very, very great Sattipatthana practitioners, was coming to Switzerland, and it was said that he was an Ahad, he had become an Ahad. Geshe Raptan, who was recognized as Bodhisattva by His Holiness, on the path of seeing or above, did everything he could to invite Mahasi Sayadaw to give refuge at Tharpaland, because he said it is extraordinarily rare to receive refuge from an Ahab. So keep in mind, you know, most of us are not on the path of the being of the small scope, as was mentioned yesterday.

It’s a big thing to be in the path of the being of the small scope. And the middling scope is something else altogether. To be on the path of the being of the great scope is extraordinary. And you have to keep in mind, to give you an idea how difficult this is, that Avalokiteśvara himself abandoned the great vehicle. That’s the reason for which Avalokiteśvara’s head is shattered in eleven pieces.

Because Mara manifested and asked Avalokiteśvara for his right hand. And Avalokiteśvara was practicing the Bodhisattva path, cut his right hand and gave it to Mahara with his left hand. And then Mara said you lack any manners altogether since you’re handing me something with your impure hand and refused to accept the gift Then Avalokiteśvara despaired helping beings and was tempted to practice the path of the being of the middling scope. And his head shattered. Then whether this is a legend or not, I let you decide.

But it is when people sincerely start practicing the path that this sort of issue does arise. For us, I think it doesn’t arise, you know. All this to say, Jill, that there is no automatic transition. You can practice as a being of the small scope indefinitely without ever feeling that saṃsāra is worth giving up. And I think this is a case of the overwhelming majority of sincere Asian Buddhists, then you can practice for a very long time as a being of the middling scope and eventually attain liberation.

And the Mahāyāna asserts that you are brought out of liberation by the Buddhas eventually with great difficulty. The Theravāda does not accept that you were ever brought out of liberation. Right? And then there is the heretic viewpoint of the Ichantrikas, who assert three final vehicles. Then, it’s not a viewpoint which is accepted, not one which I accept myself, but it is something which is really born from experience.

They assert that there are some beings who by nature are of the hearer vehicle, some beings who by nature are of the solitary realizer vehicle, some beings who by nature are of the bodhisattva vehicle, and that they can only attain the liberation or the enlightenment corresponding to their vehicle, and they will never change vehicles. Their assertion at that point is already awkward, but they go one step further and assert that there are beings who don’t belong to any vehicle and who will never attain either liberation or full enlightenment. Then, it’s a view which actually is very much in keeping with one’s experience of people. There are people who simply don’t care. And however much the material is presented to them, it never impacts their mind.

Say this is a city of one and a half million, 99.999% will never bother to come to a place like this, and probably 95% are not involved in any spiritual practice of any type. Then, it’s quite easy to say that all sentient beings will reach for enlightenment, but when one actually gives meaning to the words, things get more difficult. Right? The saving grace, as Gesheva said, is that all sentient beings have Buddha nature, the Buddha gotra. So the potentiality is there, but the means to lead that potentiality to fruition, that’s something else.

Then we have time for another question if you have another question yes Judy please if you mean every single sentient being yes yes from the standpoint of the Mahāyāna yes because they have the tathagata therefore at some point since the potentiality is there and the efforts of the Buddhas occur through infinite time, it should happen. So for every single sentient being, there would be a moment when that sentient being would attain full enlightenment. Then, whether there is a moment when the totality of sentient beings without exception will have attained enlightenment, that is a topic for another debate. But you see, all of us in this room are probably trying quite sincerely to attain either liberation or maybe full enlightenment. Which one of us has attained it?

Some of you have received long repeated instructions on calm abiding. Have you attained it? It’s not easy to attain things. Even if you have the instructions and you put the effort, it doesn’t always happen. Far too much.

Too much. Accepting that this is the point that we need to start at. That we can probably lose our way by trying to understand too much at once. It’s very much my feeling, very much my thing this is what Geshe Thubten Ngawang was an excellent teacher in Germany, if it was a big problem of Westerners, we are accustomed to getting things quickly, are accustomed to instantaneous satisfaction and therefore he deemphasized any type of tantric practice and encouraged Westerners to think in terms of practicing for three countless eons And that is what is helpful. I just think this life is coming to an end, like many of us are old in this room.

I am old, I have done what I could in this life, I don’t have any real attainments, but I attend teachings every week, I take notes, I study as much as I can, I meditate as much as I can, then I try to become a being of the small scope, if I can? Then in the next life I’ll try to become a being of the middling scope, if I can. Then a couple lives from now, if I’m lucky, a being of the great scope. But there’s one precondition for all of this: it is that the link with the teacher never be broken. So if you attend teachings, but you do not maintain that pure connection with the teacher, then unavoidably, in a future life, maybe the next one, you will not have a teacher.

Then, at that point, you probably will be lost. It’s possible to reconstruct things oneself like the Pratyekabuddha would, it’s very difficult. So the precondition for serious practice in the Lamrim is a very powerful connection to at least one teacher. And that connection is made through practice? Yes, initially it’s made well it’s maintained through practice through practicing what the teacher teaches.

So if you remember the outline of the Lamrim, first you have relying on the spiritual teacher, the foundation of the path. And then, the totality of practice is how to take the essence of a human rebirth after relying. But that initial reliance is very difficult for Westerners. I’d say easily one third of the Western Buddhists I know have broken with their teacher. Then the karmic result of that easily, easily, especially among lay people it’s common, right?

Then the result of that is because it’s a heavy karma that they will be without a teacher at some point in the future and that is where things can spiral without control. Depends on the person. I mean, you have taken a teacher, it’s a one way road. Right? It’s not a road you can go in and then change your mind and go back.

If you have done that, you have accumulated the karma of abandoning the teacher. And then that karma must be purified. But it’s not something that we have said that we have what accidentally, like if you still got that feeling of devotional, you’re still doing the practices that you’ve been taught, then there’s no way, you know I think the break has to be, like, a conscious break to occur. Well, for what you’re describing is a situation where you haven’t broken with your teacher. What does it mean to break with one’s teacher?

It means intentionally to stop seeing the teacher within oneself, to lose progressively respect for the teacher, and to stop practicing what he taught. Then, if any one of these is present, you have definitely started breaking with your teacher. And the the best advice one can give is initially, don’t take a teacher lightly. I know very few westerners who have taken a teacher carefully, and as a result there are problems because once you have chosen a teacher you must relate to him and there are three ways to relate to him we’ll cover this and maybe stop for today according to the Vinaya according to the Mahāyāna and according to tantra according to the Vinaya you see him as a representative of the Buddha so if you take monastic ordination you would relate to your teacher who gives you ordination as to an ambassador of the Buddha. Then according to the Mahāyāna you see him as of the nature of the Buddha.

In appearance, an ordinary person, but of the nature of the Buddha. According to tantra, you see him as of the nature and in appearance a Buddha, appearing ordinary only due to one’s own karmic obstructions. Then it is clear that the tantric practice is far too demanding for most of us, and even the Mahāyāna level of practice causes problems. One has to be very careful. It is really a one way street.

Then in those very rare cases where the person has made a very big mistake and has entrusted themselves to someone who obviously is unworthy, what His Holiness suggests is taking gradually distance without ever explicitly criticizing or demeaning the teacher. That is what can be done. In my own case, have 11 teachers. I have always chosen a teacher who was introduced to me or recommended by another teacher. All are at least 60 years of age.

All are highly respected within their own tradition, there’s not one rumor to the contrary, and as a result I have found it straightforward to rely on my teachers. But I would recommend to all of you to have one teacher. One teacher is difficult. More than that is too difficult. One teacher.

And if you’re not sure of your own stability, better to wait. Better to wait. Then I’m afraid we have to stop here for today. Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

atman dag (Tib)
Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
Bodhisattvayana
The Bodhisattva's Vehicle, another name for Paramitayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
parinirvana
The final nirvana the Buddha attained when he passed away in Kushinagar, India. LYWA
Samkhya drang chen pa (Tib)
Early non-Buddhist philosophical school; the so-called "enumerators," because they advocate a definite enumeration of the causes that produce existents. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
Shravakayana nyen thö kyi thegpa (Tib)
The Hearer Vehicle. One of the branches of the Hinayana. The path of hearers (shravakas), practitioners who strive for liberation from cyclic existence on the basis of listening to teachings from a spiritual guide or teacher. LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

When Buddhism speaks of impermanence, does it mean subtle impermanence rather than coarse impermanence, and why does this matter in debates with Hindu schools?

Coarse impermanence is hard to deny, although Vedanta goes far in that direction by calling conventional phenomena Maya, illusion, and so impermanence too. Subtle impermanence is a big problem for Hinduism. The core difference lies in how cause and effect relate. Samkhya and the Hindu schools assert Satkaryavada: cause and effect are of the same nature, so nothing truly changes and the effect is just the cause under another aspect. Buddhists assert the opposite, that cause and effect are of different natures. If a table changes instant by instant, and each instant is the cause of the next but of a different nature, there is true change and true impermanence.

Scroll to Top