Awareness and Knowledge — 2014-04-15

1 h 53 min · 4,523 words · 15 April 2014 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Awareness and Knowledge (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awareness and Knowledge (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awareness and Knowledge — 2014-04-15
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 113-minute teaching on epistemology (Lorig), Geshe Thubten Dorji examines how awareness and consciousness function moment-to-moment, using direct observation as the starting point. He analyzes the relationship between sensory and mental consciousnesses through everyday experience—noticing how sensory input shuts down as we fall asleep, how dreams arise from a subtle level of mind, and how we recollect yesterday’s thoughts yet cannot recall the exact moment of sleep. He then turns to logical inference and the concept of “effect reasons”—using the classical smoke-and-fire example to establish how we can deduce an unseen cause from its effect. Moving into the philosophical heart, he demonstrates how this reasoning applies to consciousness itself: because mind must have a cause similar to its own nature, and because our present mind connects unbroken to childhood memories, we can logically infer a continuum of consciousness extending backward beyond birth. He addresses questions about the brain-mind relationship, how subtle consciousness operates in deep sleep versus dreams, and whether inferential knowledge can become direct experience. Suited for practitioners with some familiarity with Buddhist logical reasoning who are exploring foundational philosophical arguments about rebirth and the nature of consciousness.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2014-04-15 – KR.mp3

UUID: bcadbdaf-3688-44a7-b17e-d556dda9e491

Teacher: HH Dalai Lama

Collection: Awareness and Knowledge

Date: 2014-04-15

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~4,521

As usual, let us generate the motivation to receive teachings. Within the twofold subdivision into sensory and mental consciousnesses of awareness and knowledge, it is very helpful for us to reflect over one day on the sequence of sensory consciousnesses and mental consciousnesses and their mode of engagement. While there is a close connection between sensory consciousnesses of the five doors, in other words the five sensory consciousnesses, and mental consciousness. Nonetheless, probably, while sensory consciousnesses are operative, generally speaking, mental consciousnesses are not. Then for beginners such as ourselves, mental consciousnesses have an intimate relationship with sensory consciousnesses of the five doors, and we can examine for ourselves when our sensory consciousnesses do not engage their respective object, the mental consciousness will very swiftly drift away into sleep.

In our case, we probably have direct experience of the fact that if we examine the sequence of sensory and mental consciousnesses over, let us say, a twenty four hour period of time, we will find that the mental consciousness is less interrupted than the sensory consciousnesses. If we reflect on it, we can probably understand that within the process of falling asleep, the sensory consciousnesses dwindle and eventually cease to operate, whereas the mental consciousness becomes ever more subtle. Then this is something you don’t have to study texts for, It is something you have direct experience of. And since we’re talking of Lorig, I thought I would bring it up. Then since it is impossible for us to fall asleep without the five sensory consciousnesses ceasing to operate, they initially cease, and the mental consciousness becomes subtler and subtler until eventually we enter into the sleep state.

And if you examine for yourself, every single one of us in this room knows that he or she falls asleep at night, but not a single one of us is able to identify the precise moment when he or she falls asleep. If the mental consciousness was operative within the process of the sleep process of falling asleep, then that will be an object of the mental consciousness and would be we would be able to identify it precisely, but we are not. And since we are studying awareness and knowledge or Lorig, it is worthwhile to check within our own mental continuum how sensory and mental consciousnesses operate. So we are unable to assess precisely the moment at which we fall asleep with a mental consciousness. Then clearly, in the context of tantra, there is a somewhat different understanding of this.

Does anyone of you know when exactly he falls asleep? Mhmm. You don’t understand. Then when we fall asleep, clearly there is no sensory consciousness, but if we enter the state of deep sleep, in addition, there is no mental consciousness that is severed or blocked. Then when within the sleep process, we rise out of deep sleep, at this time according to Buddhist scriptures, dreams occur and we enter the dream state.

Then we all know that the pleasant or unpleasant experiences we have during the day can affect our dreams and can manifest within our dreams. In this context, we can posit a dream consciousness, which is a subtle consciousness, and on this basis, we can impute a dream being. This dream being is different from the person of the daily life, since as we mentioned, upon entering the sleep process, the mental consciousness has ceased. Then when we rise out of the dream state, in other words, when we awaken, the dream consciousness ceases, and at this point, both the five sensory consciousnesses and the mental consciousness become operative again. In other words, their substantial continuum is restored.

Then when we wake up, all of us know that we can on occasion recollect the dreams we have. Clearly, the subtle dream consciousnesses continuum has been severed and the continuum of the mental consciousness has been reinitiated. While it would be difficult to speak of the subtle dream consciousness having the same continuum as the mental consciousness upon waking. One could say that a potency of the subtle dream consciousness remains present within the mental consciousness and this is what enables us to recollect our dreams. This is something which is of the highest significance for an understanding of the recollection of past lives.

Then, well, this is a difficult topic, it is difficult for us to understand clearly distinction between subtle and coarse consciousnesses, and the transition from the one to the other. I believe that reflecting on this will be of benefit to you to understand how a subtle continuum of mind can continue from previous lives, and how the karmic predispositions are carried. Now returning to the topic of inferential valid cognizers, as you remember the definition of an inferential valid cognizer is an incontrovertible predominator which arises, which newly is generated directly in dependence upon its own correct reason, which is its basis. Then an inferential valid cognizer, as intimated by its definition, arises directly in dependence upon its base, a correct reason. In other words, it arises in dependence upon a correct reason.

Then there is a threefold subdivision of correct reasons into effect reasons, nature reasons, and reasons of non observation. Then within the threefold division, effect correct reasons are particularly important for us since it is in dependence upon an effect correct reason that we are able to understand the existence of previous lives. Then what is understood as an effect correct reason is a reason which in dependence upon the uncommon relationship between an effect and its specific cause, infers from the existence of the effect, the former existence of the cause. Then let us take the classical example from scriptures of the syllogism, the subject on a smoky pass, the predicate, it follows that there is fire, the reason because there is smoke. Based upon the realization by a valid cognizer, in other words, the incontrovertible realization with 100% certainty that wherever there is smoke, there is fire, this reason becomes valid.

Here, the relationship between fire and smoke must be analyzed carefully. This reason is not an effect correct reason because fire is the result of smoke, nor is it an effect correct reason because smoke is a result of fire. For instance, one could say by extension that smoke is a result of the driftwood which gives rise to fire, but the reason would cease to be valid. What makes the reason valid is that fire is the uncommon contributing cause to the arrival of smoke. In other words, it is its direct substantial cause.

And therefore, the ascertainment that from the presence of smoke one can deduce the presence of fire is contingent on the twin ascertainment that smoke is the substantial result of fire, and that fire is the direct substantial cause of smoke. And therefore, in dependence on the fact that smoke is the direct substantial result of fire, and that fire is a direct substantial cause of smoke, but not only this in dependence as well on the fact that they are similar types, one can then ascertain the presence of fire from the former presence of smoke. Every entity, in other words, every impermanent phenomenon is an effect and as an effect necessarily both has its own direct substantial cause and a contributory condition. A cooperative condition, excuse me. And therefore, from the presence of an uncommon substantial effect, we can indubitably infer the presence or the former existence of an uncommon substantial cause, since this is a case for all phenomena including fire whose uncommon substantial, including smoke whose uncommon substantial cause is fire.

And therefore in the self same way that every direct substantial effect necessarily has a direct substantial cause, we can understand how a mental consciousness, which is a direct substantial effect, would have a direct substantial cause. Let us say we asserted the subject mental consciousness necessarily has a direct substantial cause because it is consciousness. If we were to say the subject mental consciousness necessarily has a direct substantial cause or if you prefer a cause which is similar in type to it, because it is ascertained as consciousness. We would be able to understand this through understanding that whatever entity, in other words, whatever impermanent phenomena necessarily is an effect, and as such necessarily has both a direct substantial cause and a cooperative condition, in the self same way as smoke has both a direct substantial cause and a cooperative condition. And therefore, it is reflecting in this way on consciousness and on the mode of abiding of awarenesses that we can gain not an experience, but an understanding of the existence of previous lives.

Then how would one proceed to understand the existence of former lives, former existences based on a correct effect reason? Initially, one should clearly understand that one’s base of imputation is both form and consciousness. Purely based on form as a basis of imputation, it would be very difficult to infer the existence of previous lives since our form, in other words, our body, is the substantial result of the union of the spermatozoa of the father and the ovum of the mother. To posit form, therefore, as a basis of imputation for one’s previous lives seems extremely difficult. If one posits mind as a basis of imputation for the person of one’s previous lives, then one can either posit sensory or mental consciousnesses.

Since sensory consciousnesses are interrupted, it seems preferable to posit mental consciousness as a base. Then this is these are very elegant lines of reasoning. Clearly, how does one explain the existence of past lives, which seems a little bit outlandish as an idea at first. Through understanding that one’s basis of imputation is one’s form and one’s mind, and that previous lives are the continuum of the basis of imputation. Now within the basis of imputation, form cannot really act as a continuum for previous lives, what remains is consciousness.

Consciousness is subdivided into two, sensory and mental consciousnesses, again it seems difficult for sensory consciousnesses to be the continuum on which previous lives is predicated, Therefore what is left is mental consciousness. Then as I mentioned, the mental consciousness has the capacity to project itself in time, in the past, in the future, to the left, to the right and so forth. Then this is something one can understand through analysis, if we take our present mental consciousness, clearly this present mental consciousness can recollect what happened yesterday. This indicates that the present mental consciousness is of one substantial continuum with yesterday’s mental consciousness, but we can also recollect what happened one month ago, which means the present mental consciousness is of one substantial continuum with a mental consciousness of one month ago and so forth. On the other hand, it is quite difficult to establish the existence of previous lives based on the sensory consciousnesses.

For instance, if we take the visual consciousness, it engages one object and then it engages another object, and its future engagement is not affected by its previous engagement. So it is difficult to posit this as a basis for the establishment of previous lives. And therefore, we can posit the existence of the substantial continuum of our mental consciousness one week ago, we can also posit its existence one month ago, we can posit its existence one year ago, and going back in time, probably as far back as our fifth or sixth year of age. You know. This is how you should think about things.

It’s not that difficult, is it? Cushion. The topic of a past and future lives is a critically important one. It is critically important obviously as the foundation for Dharma practice, but it is also fundamentally important because this is the actual mode of reality, the actual way things exist. Then obviously we can establish the presence of the substantial continuum of our mental consciousness back to the fourth or fifth year of age depending on our memories, and further back from that into the womb of our mother based on reasoning.

Apart from reasoning, there is no obvious way for us to do this, it is not something we can see for instance. Then if we progress backwards to the instant of fecundation of our mother’s ovum by the spermatozoa of our father, it is at this instant that the first instant of entry of consciousness in our physical aggregates occurs. If we take the first instant of consciousness at the moment of conception, this instance of consciousness must have a cause, which is a substantial cause or a cause of similar type to it. Why is this the case? This is the case because it is consciousness.

And therefore, the syllogism, consciousness at the instant of conception necessarily has a substantial cause or a cause of similar to type to itself, because it is consciousness is if one analyzes carefully, a correct effect reason, because the reason which is given, because it is consciousness is actually a result, it is the result of its direct substantial cause, the previous instant of consciousness. Now having established that the initial instant of consciousness at the moment of conception has a substantial cause or has a cause of similar type to itself. The question is, what is this substantial cause or this cause of a similar type to itself? Should we posit it as substantial cause, or as cause of similar type to itself, the consciousnesses of both parents, this would immediately entail that consciousness at the instant of conception is of the same substantial continuum as the consciousnesses of both parents and would entail that one could recollect clearly the memories of one’s parents before that time, which is obviously not the case. Then if we reflect carefully, it is obvious that there is no relationship whatsoever between the consciousnesses of our parents and our consciousness, since if there were such a relationship, we should be able to recollect clearly what our parents were thinking, which is not the case.

Then should the first instant of consciousness at the moment of conception have a substantial cause. This substantial cause is either changeable or unchangeable. If it is unchangeable, this means it is permanent, and in turn its so called result would be permanently present, which is obviously not the case. If this substantial cause on the other hand were non existent, then its result necessarily would be nonexistent as well, neither are therefore possible. Then having excluded the alternate explanations, the first instance of consciousness at the moment of conception necessarily has as its substantial cause, a direct substantial cause which is either a direct substantial cause or can be seen as a cause of similar type to its effect.

What can be posited as direct substantial cause or cause similar in its type to such a result, the last instant of the previous consciousness. One might try to posit it as a direct substantial cause for consciousness at the instant of conception, the spermatozoa and the ovum of the parents. But this also would be inappropriate since the spermatozoa and the ovum of the parents cannot give rise to consciousness. Then in dependence on reflecting on the existence of the direct substantial cause of consciousness at the instant of conception, one can understand that its direct substantial cause is the previous instant of consciousness in a former life, which is of a similar type to it. So this is how the existence of previous lives is established in dependence on an effect correct or a correct effect reason, which as you remember, infers the existence of the cause from the existence of the effect or to be more precise, infers the existence of the uncommon specific cause from the existence of the uncommon specific effect.

How is that? How’s it going? Then as you remember, an inferential valid cognizer is a cognizer which arises in dependence on its base, a valid reason. And I mentioned that valid reasons were subdivided within three: effect correct reasons, nature correct reasons, and correct reasons of non observation. Effect correct reasons are the reasons on the basis of which in Buddhist scriptures, one establishes the existence of former lives.

One does so through pointing out the relationship which exists between an effect and its uncommon specific cause. Therefore, the entailment from smoke or from the existence of smoke, one can deduce the existence of fire is indispensable for such a syllogism to be a correct effect syllogism. Now moving onwards to minds which are not valid cognizers, these are subdivided into five. The first of the subdivisions is subsequent cognizers. An instance of a subsequent cognizer would be the second instance of a mind which understands that on the smoky pass there necessarily is fire because there is smoke.

The first instance of the mind which understands that on a smoky pass there necessarily is fire because there is smoke, is an inferential valid cognizer, because it’s the first instance. Then the definition of a subsequent cognizer is an awareness which realizes through previously having realized. Therefore, the feature of subsequent cognizers is that they do not realize through their own power, unlike valid cognizers. We will stop here for today. If you have questions, Jade?

Can a direct valid cognizer be through hearing or feeling or is it only through seeing? Definitely, you have direct valid auditory cognizers, direct valid olfactory, gustatory and tactile cognizers. All five. I’m just wondering about the connection between the mental consciousness and the brain. Thinking back to earliest memories, I know I’ve got an early memory from 13, but I’ve heard of earlier memories in that with other people.

And I’m also thinking about people who have dementia and their brains function starts to deteriorate significantly. So what is the connection between mental consciousness and the brain? Our mental consciousness is quite weak in our present state. As I mentioned previously, if we were to cease any sensory input, most probably, most of us would drift off to sleep. However, as the mental consciousness is trained, this connection with the sensory consciousnesses becomes less powerful.

Then in my private opinion, as I mentioned, for most of us in our present state, the mental consciousness relies heavily on the sensory consciousnesses, and the sensory consciousnesses have a very strong, we would say neurological substratum, they are based in the brain. Thank you Geshe-la. I ask this question tentatively because I’m not entirely sure that it makes sense. Say if I take an object of negation such as the inherent existence of phenomena, does that object of negation come about through the sense consciousnesses or the mental consciousness or a combination? What do you mean by come about?

Does it have a direct sort of causal relationship that the sense, it needs a sense consciousness in order for the object of negation to come about in the mind or is it just a purely mental consciousness event? Perhaps the question does not make sense. Self grasping is not posited on the basis of the sensory consciousnesses, but on the basis of the mental consciousness. However, there is a relationship with the sensory consciousnesses, because for instance, when we see an object, which is a basis on which self grasping, or the grasping at the inherent existence of the object arises, that object is seen by the visual consciousness, but the self grasping arises within the mental consciousness. Yes.

In the syllogism, the subject, the first instance of consciousness or the instance of instant of conception, it follows that it has a substantial cause, because it is awareness. The reason awareness is a subtle state of mind, and subtle state of mind which can be posited is either the last instant of consciousness of the Bardo being, or one of the minds at the time of death. Little is said in the context of a presentation of Lorig regarding coarse and subtle minds. It does arise however, as we saw today in the context of analyzing the relationship between sensory and mental consciousnesses over a twenty four hour cycle, since it is necessary for the sensory consciousnesses to cease for one to be able to fall asleep, and from the standpoint of the treatises we are working with at present, during the period of deep sleep there is no mental consciousness either. A subtle form of mental consciousness arises however within the context of the dream state, and this is what is referred to here.

And therefore, during the state of deep sleep from the standpoint of the treatises we are studying, there is no mental consciousness. When one rises from the state of deep sleep into the dream state, a subtle level of mental consciousness is present. As one eventually rises from the dream state, in other words, as one awakes, then this subtle mental consciousness ceases, and coarse mental consciousness appears. Yep. Ready?

It is precisely because of the increase in the strength of the mental consciousness during these practices that we will not fall asleep. This is something I am really not able to explain at present. At the instant of conception, there is neither extremely subtle nor subtle minds, the mind at the instant of conception is a coarse mind. In relation to Molly’s question, I was wondering whether the prediction of a bad event in a dream is because the mental continuum, the mental consciousness is able to project itself into the past or the present or the future. So it can project into the future and then there’s that aspect of time which is actually curved rather than linear.

I have another question which might not make sense. Regarding say the first moment of subsequent consciousness at the moment at best I’m inferring that it exists through inferential valid cognition can the subsequent, the first moment of subsequent consciousness be experienced by direct valid cognition? Yes. Valid cognizer which realizes the first instance of a subsequent cognizer exists. Another question?

Yeah. Yeah. Come. The substantial cause can be a direct substantial cause, which maybe like fire There is a slight difference between direct substantial causes on the one hand and causes which are of a similar type on the other. For phenomena to be related as direct substantial cause to another phenomenon, all that is necessary is that the first phenomenon be in the substantial continuum of the second one and prior to it.

However, for phenomena to be of similar type, it is necessary that the potency of the cause do not wane over time, but be continually present as the effect arises. For phenomena to be of similar type, it is necessary that the potency of the cause, which is of a similar type to a given effect, not wane over time, but that this potency continually be present. I just wanted to check my understanding. Is it the case that the I just that the dream consciousness is a more subtle version of the mental consciousness which is more coarse and to follow that on that the clear light mind is an even more subtle consciousness. So yes, the dream consciousness is a subtle form of mental consciousness, and the fundamental mind of clear light is the most subtle type of consciousness.

Okay. So it’s definitely only six consciousnesses, not seven or eight. Okay. Thank you. Just further to the question about causes of similar type and direct substantial causes, how are those ascertained?

Is that something that’s ascertained by a logic or by empirical observation or both or Both exist. One can establish that phenomena are substantial causes through experience or through reasoning. Thank you. What kind of being experiences this valid cogniser which realises the existence of subsequent cognisers? Would it be a person with calm abiding or what what kind of quality would they need?

All of us have within our mind stream direct valid cognizers, which experience subsequent cognizers. A subsequent cognizer is merely the second instant of such a mind, and that mind can be experienced by the first instance of another mind, which would then turn out to be a valid cognizer experiencing that subsequent cognizer. Yes. No, never. There’s no mental consciousness.

Well, here we’re not talking from the tantric standpoint, right? We’re not talking from the tantric standpoint, right? So in tantra, yes. Here, no. From the standpoint of tantra, the fundamental mind would be present during that state, but we are unable to use it.

Then if mental consciousness arose in your mind during that point, you would awaken, wouldn’t you? Just thinking back on something that Natalie raised about the brain and the functions think in the West we have a problem separating them at times and I don’t know if this would be correct or not but when you look at people that suffer from dementia that’s more a failing of the brain to be able to work not necessarily the mind or the consciousness would that be correct? When there is a decline in the potency of the sensory consciousnesses for us ordinary beings, the mental consciousness finds it very difficult to operate. Alright. So I would like to repeat regarding the existence of former lives that while we are not able to experience this directly with our sensory consciousnesses, nonetheless through analysis and through valid correct reasons, it is possible to gain an understanding and this is of extreme benefit.

Then the reasonings which enable us to understand how the mental consciousness proceeds from life to life are extremely beautiful if one gains experience in them. Then the basis of imputation for ourselves is both our form, in other words our body and consciousness, we set the body aside and within consciousness, we set the sensory consciousnesses aside and focus on the mental consciousness. This is how one should proceed. Then over the long Easter weekend starting this Friday, thanks to the kindness of His Holiness Dalai Lama and our precious teacher, Khensur Rinpoche, we have the occasion to receive teachings on the Seven Points of Mind Training. If you have the opportunity, please feel free to attend.

In addition, I would like to point out that you have an excellent translator who is highly experienced and this is a great asset for the center. I have heard that many other centers do not have such facilities, and things are much more difficult for them. Then instead of wasting your time for Easter, try to attend the teaching. Clearly, if you have something important to do and are unable to come, it’s a different matter altogether. There was an email this afternoon just to remind people that they won’t be teaching following the Easter break, so that the Tuesday and Wednesday.

But the Deity practice and the Puja on Thursday at seven will would be take place. And and Tenzin, I think, is outside there. So if you wanna if you haven’t caught up with him.

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
clear light ö sel (Tib)
The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
lorig
Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
puja chö pa (Tib)
Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
tantra gyü (Tib)
Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Does the object of negation, self-grasping, arise through the sense consciousnesses, the mental consciousness, or a combination of both?

Self-grasping is not posited on the basis of the sensory consciousnesses but on the basis of the mental consciousness. There is still a relationship with the sensory consciousnesses. For example, when we see an object, that object is the basis on which self-grasping, the grasping at the inherent existence of the object, arises. The object is seen by the visual consciousness, but the self-grasping itself arises within the mental consciousness.

Scroll to Top