1 h 29 min · 3,596 words · 26 February 2014
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teacher explains how to approach the Lam Rim through overview meditation, urging repeated reflection on past and future lives, karma and causality as the basis for striving toward the three scopes. He links this to meditation on death and impermanence and stresses meditating rather than relying only on study. The session closes with questions on motivation, oaths and overview meditation.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 29m
UUID: 7aa99da3-2f6c-459c-94ae-2a0c52472b5e
Date: 2014-02-26
Words: 3,592
We do the prostrations initially. Start. Sucking in. Thank you. Good.
Laughing. Otherwise, if you sit over there with long drawn out faces, I have a hard time teaching. Forgot we should generate the motivation keeping with TDI’s traditions. It is critically important to generate as good a motivation as possible. As soon as we wake up in the morning, ideally, If one has time, one should spend one hour or more doing so, otherwise at least a couple of minutes.
The best motivation is the motivation to benefit others for however long one is able to do so, years, months or days. But if one is unable to generate such a motivation, at the very least one should generate this strong motivation never to harm others. I myself should really only teach what I practice, and this is something I have some experience in. I generate this motivation every morning, and it has been of great benefit. Do you generate such a motivation every morning?
So please, those of you who aren’t doing this, generate the motivation every morning in this way for one month and then see whether what I say is true or not. Does it help or not? As Śāntideva says in a famous verse, Whatever suffering arises arises initially from the mind. Now generally speaking, suffering is subdivided into two broad categories, physical and mental suffering. When one refers to physical suffering, one is referring to the suffering vehicle or mediated by the sense consciousnesses.
Whereas when one refers to mental suffering, it is to that mediated by the mental consciousness. And these times are continues therefore identify clearly the cause of suffering. Now in the world, when we strive for happiness through trade or through agriculture, probably the happiness we strive for is physical happiness. Clearly, all of the activities we engage in, agriculture, trade and so forth, which are physical activities designed to enhance our happiness and through enhancing our physical happiness eventually to enhance mental happiness. Yet we see that despite these efforts, suffering still does occur.
And it is for this reason that we must have reservations regarding this. And therefore, I believe that the activities such as agriculture, trade and so forth, we engage in may perhaps establish a modality of physical happiness and a physical state bereft of suffering. It seems difficult for them, however, to create mental happiness or a mental state bereft of suffering. Yesterday, I started teaching Lorig, Awareness and Knowledge. And as you remember, I made a distinction between sensory and mental consciousnesses.
Just as sensory and mental consciousnesses are distinct, likewise, is the sensation of happiness which arises in dependence on sensory consciousnesses and that which arises in dependence on mental consciousnesses are also distinct. In my opinion, however, it seems difficult to eliminate the sensation of suffering which arises in dependence on the mental consciousness and to enhance the sensations of happiness which arise in dependence on mental consciousnesses through anything else but a type of practice of dharma. Since the sensations of suffering which arise in dependence on mental consciousness are such afflictions as anger, competitiveness, envy, jealousy, and so forth, these can only these can only be countered through the appropriate dharma practice. It is very important to distinguish the happiness which arises in dependence on sensory consciousnesses from that which arises in dependence on mental consciousnesses. We can clearly see that there is a big difference between the experience of gobbling down 100 Momos or wolfing down water and any type of mental experience?
Yes or no? Yes or no? That’s really the way it is, isn’t it? So, this is a situation of the sensations of suffering arisen independence on mental consciousnesses. And then, as you know, one refers to the mind which strives for future lives.
Actually, one refers to the mind which strives for future lives and beyond. Now, from your own side, please investigate whether should such a mind arise or a state of mind arise powerfully, the sensations of suffering arisen independence on the mental consciousness would cease or not. Then I prefer not to tell you everything because if I tell you everything, you will sit back and snooze away. So check from your own side. Then there really is no point in these magisterial presentations of the teachings, all of the teachings after all in the text liberation, the palm of your hand, you could just as well read it by yourselves.
What I would like you to do is to check from your own side individually, investigate. Is it true or not that if the mind which strives for future lives and beyond arises powerfully, then the sensation of suffering which occur independence on the mental consciousness will disappear. Check for yourselves, then it will be a powerful experience. This is the teaching of His Holiness the Dalai Lama and of our holy teacher, Khensur Rinpoche. I had the privileged opportunity during one year at Sera to study closely under the aegis of Khensur Rinpoche and over and again Rinpoche said to me, investigate by yourself and meditate, investigate by yourself and meditate.
And I saw that this was very important because I would inquire over and again or request teachings from Rinpoche and Rinpoche would answer, meditate and study by yourself. This is how experience is acquired. Meditate and study by yourself. Then Buddhist treatises assert that once the mind which strives for one’s will in future lives arises powerfully, then common or ordinary renunciation has arisen. At this point, one’s mind is happy, comfortable and at ease.
The totality of the path ranges from the foundation reliance on the spiritual teacher up to Yuganaddha or the state of union. Last year, when I was here, I explained reliance on the spiritual teacher. Then, I explained last year the foundation of the path reliance on the spiritual or the virtuous friend. However, without explaining this in a formal setting in terms of Lamy, which would be difficult, I’d like to cover the topic again. If we wish to progress on the spiritual path, we must rely on the instructions of our glorious forerunner, Buddha Śākyamūni, and the great practitioners of the past such as Ārya Nāgārjuna, Ārya Deva, Asaṇga or Vasubandhu.
They all taught that initially one should generate the correct motivation, then accumulate to the two collections before attaining the goal, the result of such a practice. However, in our case, the doubt may arise, after all, we have not met Buddha Śākyamūni, we have not met Ārya Nāgārjuna, Ārya Deva, Asaṇga, Vasubandhu, then how is it possible for us to practice? Clearly, the one person who has imparted all these teachings to us is our spiritual teacher. Then, how should we view the spiritual teacher in accordance with the Lam Rim, with the graduated stages of the path? We should view him as a Buddha in actuality, a real Buddha, and if we view him in this way, we will benefit greatly from the practice.
And the two subdivisions are initially relying on the spiritual teacher, the foundation of the past, and the second subdivision, how to train the mind thereby. How to train the mind thereby comprises the totality of practices ranging from reliance on the spiritual teacher to the attainment of the state of union. Now, should one engage in the practice of these stages leading from reliance on the spiritual teacher up to the state of full enlightenment? Initially, one engages in the practice of hearing and generates a wisdom arisen from hearing. Then, independence upon that through repeated reflection, one generates a wisdom arisen from thinking.
And finally, through repeated meditation, one generates the wisdom arisen from meditation. An alternate presentation of the process is that one alternates between overview meditations and concentration meditations, focusing on the topic one wishes to cover until one is able to generate initially a contrived experience of this topic and eventually an uncontrived experience of this topic. Then I suspect that the overwhelming majority of you have received not once, but many times over teachings on Lamrim, both from His Holiness, Dalai Lama, and from our holy teacher, Khensur Rinpoche, as well as from numerous other teachers. It therefore would be very pleasant to engage in an overview meditation on Lamrim and present Lamrim in this way. If you had time to do this, then maybe you have not time, I don’t know.
But I’m joking about this topic. Then how should one proceed? One should initially generate the motivation striving for welfare in future lives in accordance with the Lamrim, the practice of the being of the small scope. However, the Lamrim makes no mention of an understanding, a conviction in the existence of past and future lives. This is fundamental, since without this it seems very difficult to erect any practice.
Then, on the basis of such a conviction in the existence of past and future lives, a conviction in the existence and operativeness of karma and causality can arise. Once these two are present, it is possible to generate in a relatively straightforward way the wish to strive for one’s benefit in future lives. Is this sufficient? No, it is not, because we are beings who should strive for liberation, and therefore, one should try to generate the wish for liberation from the sufferings of cyclic existence, at which point one will have become a being of the middling scope. Is this sufficient?
No, it is not. Why don’t you move further and wish to generate a wish striving for full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings? And therefore, it is indispensable to generate this desire to attain full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. Now, to do this, what is necessary, one must have generated love and compassion as a preliminary, and to generate them what is necessary. As a preliminary, one must have generated also renunciation or definite emergence and the correct view of emptiness.
Then in my personal opinion, when one refers to overview meditation, one refers to such a training leading to the actualization of the common or shared path and then involving oneself or practicing independence on this, the inseparable union of sūtra and tantra, which refers to the practice on this basis of both the generation and the completion stages. Then one should try to understand the overview meditation of Lamrim in this way. Initially, one trains to generate wisdom arisen from hearing, and then one tries to give rise initially to a contrived experience of the topics of Lamrim. Probably, a contrived experience of these topics cannot arise without the wisdom arisen from thinking at least. And therefore, one must reflect on these topics over and again, taking for instance the topic of the existence of past and future lives and whenever one has a free moment as much as possible thinking, do past and future lives exist or not, and analyzing carefully.
In such a way, the contrived experience of the existence of past and future lives will occur. And this repeated process of reflection is really nothing else than meditation. Then, in this context, I will explain things a bit differently because you have received Lamyrim teachings many times, which is basically a rather good thing. When I mention a topic, you say, ah, yes, he’s talking about the practice of the being of the small scope. And another topic, say, ah, yes, it’s the practice of the being of middling scope.
And another topic, ah, yes, it’s the practice of the being of great scope. So you have received many teachings, but it is necessary to meditate. The holy teacher, Khensur Rinpoche, said to me many times, you must meditate. And here, one must find one’s own reasons which generate conviction in this. As Rinpoche said, one must generate the sense that this is the way things are and no differently.
Literally in Tibet, this is the only road. And then, once one has meditated and reflected carefully on past and future lives and on karma and causality, quite naturally a striving for future lives and beyond will arise within one’s mind stream. When this wish to better oneself literally in future lives and beyond arises at any time, even in the dream state, then one can say that one is a being of the small scope. Now you should check for yourself whether this is the case or not, but in my personal opinion, the practice of meditation on death and impermanence is closely related to this. Then you should check for yourselves, check by yourselves.
Then, at the very least, one should engage in these reflections for one hour, preferably longer. All of us are beginners, and therefore, to try to meditate on such profound topics over a couple of minutes will lead to no realization. Then if one meditates over and again on past and future lives and karma and causality, a fully characterized meditation on death and impermanence can indeed occur in dependence on this. Here, practicing in this way, one oneself can experience great benefit. Then we shall stop here for today.
I would like to ask you to model your practice on that of the holy teacher of Khensur Rinpoche, and on the great determination and power he put in his practice of meditation. Then we ourselves should take an oath, a stable oath to practice in this way. Even if we lack the capacity to do so, such an oath itself is of great benefit for the future. Rinpoche taught over and again at TBI, I myself benefited greatly from his teachings and I hope you have done so too. We were all very fortunate to receive such teachings at TBI, and I would like to ask you to generate a strong sense of fortitude and determination, literally of mental strength, saying to yourselves, I shall practice in this way.
Upon Tenzing’s return to TBI, I think the details of Khensur Rinpoche’s passing will become clearer. If you can meditate, meditate forcefully as much as you can, then there is 100% certainty that your mind will benefit from this. Alright. Any few questions? How is it that an oath can have power even if one does not have the strength to sustain it?
In my opinion, the mere taking of such an oath is highly beneficial. Then it is very difficult for us to keep all the oaths and promises we have taken, but we try to keep as many of them as we can. Another? Another? Geshela spoke about if you meditate over again on past and future lives and karma and causality, a fully characterized meditation on death and impermanence can occur.
What is a fully characterized meditation on death and impermanence? I didn’t understand the first bit of your question. Could you speak louder? Geshela said that if we meditate over and again on past and future lives and karma and causality that a fully characterized meditation on death and impermanence can occur in dependence on this and my question relating to that is what is a fully characterized meditation on death and impermanence? What are those characteristics?
Take the case of someone who is facing a capital execution in one hour’s time. If you were to offer to that person a huge amount of wealth in the form of money, gold and precious objects, probably no attachment whatsoever or very little if any would arise in the mind of that person. Then, a fully characterized meditation on death and impermanence is one in which an ordinary being such as oneself, in an ordinary life experiences no attachments whatsoever to the wealth, the gold, the pleasures of this life, because of an awareness of impending death. Another? Come come.
This is a question about questions actually. If I have difficulty with the teaching and I have a question From what I understand you’re saying I should self investigate that issue and meditate on it before asking. Is that correct? Initially, one should study the great texts, great scriptures. Then it is appropriate to ask questions from one’s teacher when one engages in meditation, and certain experiences arise, and one wishes to see whether these are experiences are appropriate or not.
And, yeah mother? Come, come, come, lots time. How do we check our motivation since our minds are deceitful? The best way to do it is really to generate, upon waking, a strong and stable mind, which determines to practice in accordance with the great vehicle and to engage in mind training in accordance with the great vehicle. Such a mind thinks, at the best I shall benefit others, but at the very least I shall definitely not harm them.
Yeah. Yeah. When Gishula is talking about an overview meditation of the When Geshela is talking about an overview meditation of the entire entire path, path, is he talking about something like reviewing the stages of the path For instance, if you were to link the passages of the foundation of all good qualities, which are corresponding to the path of the being of the small scope, with the path of the being of the small scope, and those which correspond to the path of the being of the middling scope with the path of the being of the middling scope, and those corresponding to the path of the being of the great scope with the path of the being of the great scope, this would qualify as an overview meditation. Then, in my opinion, an overview meditation of the Lam Rim would occur, for instance, when one is actually focusing in one’s training on the practice of the being of small scope. For instance, one is focusing on the practice of the being of the small scope, trying to generate initially contrived and eventually spontaneous or uncontrived experiences of the path of the being of the small scope.
However, one brings literally in an ancillary fashion to mind, so as not to forget them, the practices of the being of the middling and of the great scope. These are not our main practices, one just brings them to mind so as not to forget them. This would be an overview meditation. I’m very interested in the Lam Rim because it takes us through the three scopes. I do this on an annual basis and find it very useful but in my worst moments I wonder what I am doing playing around the great scope when I’m trying to get my feet off the ground on the small scope.
So should one concentrate on where one is at or do you take work through the overview as well? Generally speaking, what you say is true. It is extremely important to meditate on the path of the being of the small scope. And if one puts one’s efforts in that over and again, while maintaining some type of mental contact with the practice of the being of the middling and of the great scope, then when you generate a fully characterized path of the being of the small scope, it would be much easier for you to then train in the practice of the being of the middling and of the great scope. Chris?
Several. Geshela has spoken about specific things he remembers Khensur Rinpoche teaching. I recall really strongly Kensar Rinpoche teaching if one practices any practice with a Mahāyāna motivation, a strong motivation for the enlightenment of all beings that practice becomes Mahāyāna motivation. So even if it’s a small scope practice it becomes Mahāyāna practice because of the Mahāyāna motivation and I was wondering what Geshela thought about that teaching because for me it was very very inspirational to hear that. Yes, definitely.
Any practice which is engaged in with the Mahāyāna motivation becomes a Mahāyāna practice. Oh, yeah. Probably finish it. Probably finish it. Yeah.
Yeah. Okay. Thank you. Goodbye. Thank you.
If I can just say a couple of words. This is the first teaching for of the Lamrim on Wednesday nights with Geshela. And for those of you who weren’t at the morning tea, what I said to Geshela was thank you so much for coming all the way from India from Sera Je Monastery at a time when Tibetan Buddhist Institute has experienced a great challenge with the passing of our beloved holy founder and mentor, Kyabje Khensur Rinpoche. And we’re very honored and privileged that you have come here, given up your life to serve us in the lineage of Rinpoche and all the way back through Lama Tsongkhapa, all the way back to the Buddha, Śākyamūni. And this is very rare and precious and so we well, it’s hard to put into words our gratitude for you to be here with us and we hope that you enjoy your time in Australia again and we look forward to many more teachings.
Thank you, Keshe la. And also thank you so much to Lotsawa, to Ilya for being able to bring us Geshela’s teachings. Geshela’s English is improving all the time, but we need the loudspeaker of Ilya. Thank you, Gisela. Lhosa, Pooja on Sunday morning with Gisela 09:00 and then you’re welcome to bring some lunch to share if you can stay and just to continue the welcome of Gisela and the celebration of Tibetan New Year in an Australian way.
Thank you. Enjoy some chai.
Key terms in this teaching
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lorig
- Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
- The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
- tantra gyü (Tib)
- Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
- two accumulations sambharadvaya (Skt); tsog nyi (Tib)
- Also called the two collections or two types of merit, they are: the merit of virtue, which develops the method side of the path by practicing generosity and so forth, and the merit of (transcendental) wisdom... LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
What is a fully characterized meditation on death and impermanence?
Consider someone who will be executed in one hour. If that person were offered a huge amount of wealth in money, gold and precious objects, little or no attachment would arise in their mind. A fully characterized meditation on death and impermanence works the same way. An ordinary being like oneself, living an ordinary life, experiences no attachment whatsoever to wealth, gold or the pleasures of this life, because of an awareness of impending death.
How can we check our motivation, given that our minds are deceitful?
The best way is to generate a strong and stable mind upon waking. This mind determines to practice in accordance with the great vehicle, the Mahayana, and to engage in mind training in accordance with the great vehicle. Such a mind thinks that at best it will benefit others, but at the very least it will definitely not harm them. Setting this firm intention at the start of the day is the way to establish and check one's motivation.
Is an overview meditation of the entire Lam Rim path the same as reviewing the stages of the path?
One example is linking the passages of the "foundation of all good qualities" with the matching scope of the path: those for the small scope with the path of the being of small scope, those for the middling scope with the middling scope, and those for the great scope with the great scope. Another example is when one's main training focuses on the practice of the being of small scope, trying to generate first contrived and eventually spontaneous, uncontrived experiences of that path. Alongside this, one brings the practices of the middling and great scope to mind in an ancillary way, so as not to forget them. These are not the main practices. This is an overview meditation.