1 h 35 min · 4,803 words · 6 June 2018
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk covers the three faults of the vessel (upside down, leaky, soiled) and the need to join hearing, thinking and meditating on the Lam Rim. It then explains the coarse ignorance that apprehends the person as permanent, one and independent, and how realising the person’s impermanence counters it. The recording ends with a question and answer session on these points, with the answer deferred to the next week.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 36m
UUID: 9dbaf3a9-0926-49fc-9e1b-adb729a10657
Date: 2018-06-06
Words: 4,799
As Vasubandhu says in his, the bestower of dharma and the receiver of dharma, most both must be impelled by a worthy motivation. And the meaning of this passage or these verses is that both the person who teaches the dharma and the person who listens to the teaching must have a good motivation. So here, when, it is said to generate the motivation, this generation of the motivation doesn’t just refer to the audience, the students generating the requisite motivation to listen to the teachings. It also refers to the teacher generating the requisite motivation to teaching the students, specifically to generate the motivation to initially enable them to hear, in other words, listen correctly to the teachings, then to generate a valid cognizer, which ascertains the meaning of what was taught, and finally, to meditate on that for which a valid cognizer was generated. It was to generate the motivation to, give rise to teaching, to hearing, thinking, and meditating.
And if one is able to generate such a stable motivation, then there are no obstructions or hindrances to the teachings because these are not imparted motivated by the afflictions. This is how Geshe la sees it for himself. Then, from your own side, as listeners of the teachings, it is often said that you should abandon the three faults of the vessel. These are three faults in which a vessel or a vase is used as a simile. Do you understand?
Then this is a very meaningful section of the Lam Rim. We should listen after having abandoned the three faults of the vessel. If we are unable to abandon the three faults of the vessel, there is no benefit to the teachings. The first fault of the vessel is the vessel being placed upside down. Then it is self evident that if you place a vessel or a vase upside down, it is impossible to pour anything inside.
Whatever you pour on top of it will never make it inside the vessel. Likewise, if when you are attending teachings, your mind is wandering elsewhere, there will have been no benefit whatsoever. Therefore, you should link your minds and your bodies. Your mind should be in the temple with your bodies. And this is very meaningful.
After all, it’s only one hour, a bit more than an hour. Then one should say to oneself, I’m not gonna waste my time by coming here. I will put effort. I think one and a half an hour, you know, just easy. No long.
So the second fault of the vessel is, that of being a pierced or leaky vessel. Then, even though the vessel is not upside down, if it’s right side up, but there is a hole in the bottom, it leaks, then whatever you pour inside does not stay there. Likewise, when one attends teachings, even though one listens to the teachings, one must, in addition, put effort at grasping them with one’s memory as remembering them. Otherwise, if one does not remember them and one forgets them, what is the point? And the third fault of the vessel is the fault of a soiled or filthy vessel.
So even though the vessel is upright, and in addition, it is not pierced and does not leak, If one puts food inside and this food is filthy or unsuitable or inappropriate, then again, there is no benefit. So what this means is that if one attends teachings and one listens carefully to the teaching, therefore, akin to the upright vessel, and one remembers the meaning of the teachings. In other words, the vessel is not pierced. But one attends teachings with a wrong and evil motivation. Instead of being motivated by the wish to attain liberation or full enlightenment, then attending those teachings acts as an obstacle to one’s attaining liberation or full enlightenment.
Because of being blended with an evil or wrong motivation. So one therefore needs a motivation, which thinks, may I attain liberation and full enlightenment? Such a motivation is compatible with the long wind. Mhmm. Do you understand?
Already? Okay. And in addition to abandoning these three faults of the vessel, one, should practice or listen to the Lam Rim, in such a way that hearing, thinking, and meditating are inseparable. This is the advice which has been repeatedly given by his holiness, the Dalai Lama, and by. It is a very crucial piece of advice from the Lam Rim.
Then in our own cases, it is exactly the opposite. Hearing, thinking, and meditating are not inseparable. They are completely separated. We hear one category of teaching and immediately are seeking for something new and exciting, which will we which we will find interesting. And in our own cases, it is self evident that we are in a desperate hurry.
When we listen to the path shared with the being of the small scope, We pass rapidly through the object of meditation and are in a hurry to reach the path shared with the being of the middling scope without thinking or meditating. Then we do the same thing for the path of the middling scope and in a hurry to reach a path of the being of the great scope. Then we listen to the teachings of the path of the being of the great scope. And when we want to think about them, we have forgotten, everything which we heard. So our situation is that of someone who, when he attends teachings, doesn’t think.
And when he thinks about the teaching, has forgotten what he heard. Then in our own cases, it is difficult to practice and study in this way because we are in the midst of society. Many of us have families with children. Then we have little time. As a result, realistically, our hearing, thinking and meditating will not be inseparable.
They will be separate and distinct. However, we should try to practice them inseparably as much as we can. And for instance, when we study the path shared with the being of the small scope to do so continuously before passing on to the other paths. And this is how Geshe la hopes to proceed during the ten day Lam Rim retreat, which TBI will be holding, at the beginning of the month of October. The goal will be to first listen to the teachings and to give rise to an ascertainment by means of thinking of a valid cognizer if possible, and then as much as possible to give rise to an experience arisen from meditation.
This is not easy.
So for instance, if we take the topic of death and impermanence Mhmm. We would listen to teachings on death and impermanence, and then using reasoning reflect on the topic of impermanence, trying to generate, an ascertainment by a valid cognizer of impermanence. And at this point, we would meditate as much as we can on what we had understood by means of that valid cognizer. So if we take the topic of death and impermanence, we have all received teachings on death and impermanence many times. It’s a given.
Then, it is also a given that we are able to reflect on them. And one day, if we do so, we will generate a valid cognizer realizing the topic. Then at this point, we must generate a mind arisen from meditation focused on death and impermanence. And this would have occurred when even in the dream state, we recollect death and impermanence. Then it is clear that in the dream state, we have a very powerful grasping at our own self.
And it is only when thinking of death and impermanence arises spontaneously and repeatedly continuously in the dream state that one can say that one has a realization arisen from meditation of death and impermanence. Then Geshe la can say that it is a given because it is his own experience that in the green green state, we have very strong self cherishing, a very strong grasping at our own permanence. He sees that within himself. So, at present in daily life, we can indeed think about love, empathy, bodhicitta and so forth, but these experiences and reflections do not transfer or translate into the dream state. It is only when they do so continuously that we will know we have an experience arisen from meditation.
And for this, we need great habituation. As Maitreya says in the fifth chapter of the Abhisamayālamkāra, when phenomena appears appear akin to a dream even in the dream state. Then, this refers to the appearance of the experience of emptiness in the dream state. It indicates, therefore, that this is an experience arisen from meditation. So what Geshe la would like to suggest to you is that you have at least the following resolve.
I may not have the time to practice correctly, but I am aware of the fact that I should train in the three principles of the path and I should train in the path shared with the being of the small, the middling and the great scope in sequence and incrementally. This is the bare minimum we must have. This is what we need. So let us generate such a motivation during a couple of minutes, and then the, recitation of the prayers will occur. Please go for the prayerbook, page one.
We recite one b, two, three, four, and also page five, number six Mandala offering, first one and the three. Then in our cases, excuse me, we forget. So when we study the path shared with the being of the small scope and we passed with the path shared with the being of the middling scope, we forget what we studied during the path shared with the being of the small scope. And then when we move onwards to the path of the being of the great scope, we forget what precisely definite emergence is. And even after having studied it, if one or two weeks later someone asks us what is definite emergence, whereas two weeks ago we could express clearly what it was, two weeks later we are unable to do so.
Mhmm. And this is a clear sign that hearing, thinking, meditating are completely dis dissociated for us. Then why exactly should we give rise to a mind arisen from meditation focused on impermanence? Actually, it is very difficult to do so. One must engage in listening, in thinking, and in meditating.
Then whether in life at large in society or in dharma practice, there has to be a reward, for whatever we do, a gain. So what’s the reward? What’s the gain for generating such a mind? The reward is happiness. So the the thing we should ask ourselves is, what’s my reward in generating a mind arisen from meditation focused on impermanence?
My reward is happiness.
Merely through, minds arisen from hearing or thinking, it is not possible to generate such a happiness. One needs a mind arisen from meditation. And why does a mind arisen from meditation focused on impermanence give rise to profound happiness? Simply because it counters the main source of mental suffering we have at present, which is discontentment, lack of contentment. Once one has generated a mind focused or risen from meditation, focused on impermanence, then one is no longer subject to strong desires.
One is content with one’s lot, and one just remains at ease and happily viewing phenomena as illusions. What do we need? We need mental happiness. What troubles mental happiness? The afflictions.
Then we have to analyze what exactly is the antidote to the afflictions. So when we have a headache because of the flu, we go to the doctor, get a shot, and the next day it is cured. Then, mental suffering is, not treated in that way. The only thing which is of benefit to, heal mental suffering is engaging in hearing, thinking, and meditating on the Lam Rim. Prayer is of no benefit at all.
Okay. So what is it therefore which troubles the mind? It is the afflictions present within this mind, and these afflictions arise in dependence on causes and conditions. As was explained, what is the main cause of this these afflictions? It is ignorance.
Okay. Should I explain that there are two categories of ignorance, coarse and subtle ignorance? Coarse ignorance is that apprehension which apprehends the person as permanent one and independent. Subtle ignorance is the apprehension of the person as autonomous. Then please listen carefully.
This is a new topic. And in general, one should listen carefully, but for new topic particularly. So this has already been explained over the last couple of weeks. We will cover it quickly again. What is the coarse self or the coarse ignorance, which is a coarse apprehension of the self of persons?
It’s the apprehension of persons as being permanent one and independent. What is the antidote to this coarse ignorance? It is, either the apprehension of the impermanence of persons or if you prefer, the apprehension of persons being empty of being permanent. Now, this apprehension of persons as being empty of being permanent counters this ignorance apprehending the person as permanent one and independent. So please keep in mind the following analysis.
A person is a name. This name is imputed on a basis of designation, which is the aggregates. It is in dependence on the apprehension of the impermanence of the aggregates that one infers that the person, which is the imputed phenomenon, is impermanent as well. Have you understood the way in which one establishes the impermanence of the person or of the I? Yes.
What is it? Therefore, the mode of understanding or realizing the impermanence of the person is that, one understands that one can understand the impermanence of the person in dependence on understanding the impermanence of the aggregates which are its basis of imputation. Mhmm. Alright. So please do reflect on the following.
If someone asks you, why are persons impermanent, you will typically answer because they disintegrate instant by instant. But then if your, examiner asks you why exactly do they disintegrate instant by instant, you are led to analyzing the aggregates, which are the base of imputation of the person to see whether they themselves disintegrate instant by instant or not. So, therefore, the wisdom which realizes the impermanence of persons is the antidote to, that apprehension of persons as permanent and independent. Now what exactly is the mode of apprehension of persons as permanent one and independent? Actually, the apprehension of persons as permanent one and independent, only occurs within the mind stream of beings contaminated by wrong, tenets.
So this mode of apprehension is not an easy one to understand. If you don’t think about it over and again, it’ll be difficult. Now moving onwards, it was mentioned that, when we reflect on, our I or the person, it appears as separate from the aggregates, but owning the aggregates in the self same way as someone living inside a house is separate from that house, but owns that house. This is how things appear to Geshe la’s mind. This is how things appear to all our minds.
So the example of the owner of a house and of the house he lives in is helpful to us, then Buddhist texts to give two other examples. See which of these is most beneficial for your minds. One example is that of the relationship between a king and his court. The other example is that of the relationship between a herder and the livestock he herds. This is how the relationship between the person and the aggregates appears.
Even though in reality, the person is related to the aggregates, nonetheless, it appears in this way. So it is independence on this that a non Buddhist, the founders of Tenets, the non Buddhist philosophers of ancient India who asserted the existence of a person which was permanent, one and independent. Upon observing this innate sense of a person which exists separately from the aggregates, said that, this is what has to transmigrate since they accepted the existence of past and future lives and asserted that the coarse aggregates such as the body and so forth were incinerated on the funeral pyre. Then this entity which transmigrated, they said since it was not dependent on the aggregates had to be permanent. So it is in dependence on this reason that the non Buddhist philosophers of India became the propounders of permanence, the propounders of a partless self, and the propounders of the independence of the person.
So the aggregates obviously depend on causes and conditions. The body specifically depends on the union of the spermatozoa of the father and the ovum of the mother. On the other hand, the person does not. Therefore, they teach that it is permanent and independent. And the third reason is that since the person does not depend on parts such as the form aggregate, the aggregate of sensation and discrimination, which cease at death, then the person is said to be unique or solitary.
So the flow of the form aggregate, the body ceases at death. The flow of the aggregate of sensation, of discrimination, and so forth all cease at death, but the flow of the continuum of the person does not cease at death. For this reason, these non Buddhist philosophers say that it is unique or isolated. So, based on these three reasons, they assert a person which is permanent one and independent. This position is specific to the propounders of wrong tenets.
Please. So how has this presentation been so far for you? Do you understand what is meant by the apprehension of the person as permanent one and independent? Is that present within your own continuums or not? Probably not.
But this is the assertion of the non Buddhist philosophers of ancient India, and they assert that the person is permanent, one, and independent, independent on this innate sense of the person as being separated from the aggregates. Did you get it? Don’t understand? If you have questions, now is the time to ask your questions on this topic. Yes, Shalar, I’m not sure, but didn’t some of the non Buddhist philosophers of ancient India also assert a creator god?
In which case, how did they align how did they square that with saying that person was independent and one if it was created by god? So Geshe la finds it difficult to answer your question because there’s so many schools of ancient Indian non-Buddhist philosophers. Some accept the existence of a god. Some do not accept the existence of a god. But in either case, he believes they assert that the person is permanent.
So here, please do understand that we are not when we speak of the person in this context, we’re not talking of the person which eats, walks, and so forth. Indeed. The non Buddhist philosophers of ancient India were talking of a subtle part of the mind called the ātman, which is that which transmigrates from life to life. Okay. Just would like clarification.
It may just be a terminological thing. I guess you thought that the person is said to be be be sorry. I’ll start again. Since the person does not depend on parts, the person is said to be unique or solitary. So that’s the equivalent of saying the person is one within the person permanent one and independent.
Is that correct? So when not quite. When the non Buddhist philosophers of ancient India refer to the person being unique or isolated, what they mean is that this person does not depend on its parts. The parts are the parts of the part holder, which is a person. The part holder does not depend on the parts.
So when we refer to the person being unique or isolated, this actually means that the person is independent, independent of the parts. So can I just follow-up that then, please? So within the phrase permanent one and independent, I don’t understand within that non Buddhist philosophical position what the one bit means. So when we speak of oneness here in permanent one and independent, it is a compactness as as opposed to the person being loose. It means that the the person is one.
So so here, this does not refer to the number one, Geshe la says. It refers to a sense of compactness. As opposed to being loosened up. Okay. So, if you can understand what is meant by the apprehension of the person as permanent, unitary, and independent, you will be able to understand what is meant by the emptiness of the person being permanent, unitary, and independent.
Do I have? I was just going to ask, is there a difference between the terms reincarnation and rebirth? It’s the same thing. There are two different terms in English, but there’s only one term. Yeah.
Truthfully, In English, reincarnation etymologically means to take a body again. Rebirth means to be born again. In Tibetan, the term is just new life, new existence. These are English terms. In Sanskrit or Tibetan, there’s only one word.
The meaning of all these terms, past and future lives, reincarnation, rebirth is the same. So, Geshe la would like to take your questions about the persons being permanent unitary and independent. Yep. Thank you. I was wondering why it necessarily follows that when one realizes the impermanence of the person, why they necessarily realize the emptiness of the person being permanent one and independent, like you said last week.
And I came up with what I think is the might be the reason why, and that would be that if one understands the mode of existence of the self in the aggregate, so the the nature of their relationship as being of one nature but different isolates. So that would be the first part of three part thing. The next would be to realize that person is impermanent and then using the reason that the person is impermanent, it necessarily follows that the person is empty of being permanent one and independent. So I thought that there were the there’s like a three step process. First, you have to understand the nature of the relationship of the aggregates in the self as being one nature but different isolates.
And then there needs to be a realization of impermanence. And then it necessarily follows that one realizes the emptiness of person being permanent one and independent because of the realization of impermanence. I was wondering if that is the case. I’ll ask you to repeat. I’ll pass it as you speak, but you have to compress a bit.
Okay. So the reason that the realization of the person as being empty of being permanent, one, and independent follows the realization of the person being impermanent. Is because when one has realized the impermanence of the person and one understands that the aggregates in the person are of one nature but different isolates. One necessarily realizes the emptiness of the person being permanent, one, an independent. Mhmm.
Mhmm. Okay. That So it’s not exactly a question. Right? I was just wondering if you if that is the case.
The way that the reason why when one realizes the impermanence of the person, one necessarily realizes the emptiness of the person being permanent, one independent. In brief, because the person’s being impermanent and the person being one permanent one and the person’s being impermanent and the person not being permanent one and independent are one and the same. Once one has realized that the person is impermanent, one has realized that the person is empty of being permanent. Having realized that, one realizes the person is empty of being permanent one and independent. Yeah.
Yeah. Sure. Just about the permanent one in independent picking up on Jill Jill’s question. I always thought the one referred to the the self being unitary as in partless. Is that incorrect?
Here, unitary means compact. No. Not directly. So we have to check carefully, to what the name is affixed when we speak of the person being empty or being permanent, unitary, and independent, referring to unitary.
At the beginning, Geshe la was saying that if we practice the death and impermanence, we can bring it into the dream state. How do we know that we bring in this sort of practice into a dream state? How do we know? In brief, once one has generated a mind arisen from meditation focused on death and impermanence, one can practice, meditate on death and impermanence even in the dream state. So the dream state is not like the dream state of an ordinary being.
So at present, when we dream, we are profoundly convinced that what we dream is real. Then once one has generated such a mind arisen from meditation focused on death and impermanence, one recognizes the dream as a dream. It becomes unreal. At the beginning of the teaching, Geshe la was referring that we’re having problems. We separate the listening, the thinking, and the practice.
Now when we talk about listening, would be reading dharma and reflecting about it also being considered listening? Or is it only listening when the teacher teaches? What about if I read the transcript of the teaching? That would be also like listening. What if what do you see just there?
So my question is No. I understood. But the last words, transport? No. No.
That transcription. Basically, if I read, this will be also like listening. Would that be the same with the reading and listening? Most definitely, reading a book is technically hearing or listening in a Buddhist sense. Then even when you close the cover of the book and you think casually about the topic that is still hearing.
So hearing is all or refers to all the activities in which we depend on another, on the speech of another, oral or written. The wisdom arisen from thinking begins when we use our own uncommon lines of reasoning and appropriate what is studied. Okay. So, Geshe la, I would like to ask you to think carefully about or on whether there is a difference between the apprehension of the person as permanent, unitary, and independent and the mere apprehension of the person as permanent. Is there a difference or not?
So there is a very great difference between these two. You should analyze whether the three or four logical possibilities, three or four overlaps. Check for yourselves in your own continuum. Does the apprehension of the person as permanent, one, and independent exist in your continuum or not? Then does the apprehension of the person as permanent exist in your continuum or not?
Then once you have understood this, the differences will become evident. So is there a difference or not? Yes or no? Question. Why?
What is the difference? Quickly, please. Please. In short. In my mind, the person being permanent one and independent is a strengthening or, yeah, I I would say a strengthening of the position that the permanent the person is permanent.
So it’s sort of an elaboration in and makes it even more substantially established and even more separate than just a mere apprehension of permanence. So the the person that’s permanent one and independent is a lot that person is a lot stronger and a lot more separate from other things and a lot more indestructible. Okay. Both you have. Okay.
So what Geshe la is asking you is very simple. Are they different or not? If they are different, what’s the reason? Why? They seem to be different because, for example, even understanding my dependence on the aggregate, so therefore not feeling sorry.
Start again. I think the difference because I can I could feel permanent even though not permanent one and independent? I could feel that I’m dependent on my aggregates, therefore, not independent, and yet still feel apprehend myself as permanent. So please think about this carefully. Geshe la will give the answer next week.
In brief, the apprehension of the person as permanent, one, and independent exists only within the continuum of propounders of wrong tenets. On the other hand, the apprehension of the person as permanent exists in numerous forms, both in the minds of those who are not the propounders of wrong tenets and in the minds of those who are the propounders of wrong tenets. So Geshe la would like to know how many overlaps or how many logical possibilities there are between these two minds. Okay. Thank you.
[End of recording]
Key terms in this teaching
- atman dag (Tib)
- Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- mandala khyil khor (Tib)
- A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
- mandala offering
- The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
In the phrase 'permanent, one and independent' as a non-Buddhist view of the person, what does 'one' mean?
Here 'oneness' does not refer to the number one. It refers to a sense of compactness, as opposed to the person being loose or loosened up. The person is held to be one in the sense of being unitary and compact. The teaching adds that if you can understand what it means to apprehend the person as permanent, unitary and independent, you will be able to understand what is meant by the emptiness of the person being permanent, unitary and independent.