1 h 44 min · 4,612 words · 24 October 2012
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains why reliance on a qualified spiritual teacher is the root of the Lamrim path, stressing that faith must be joined with wisdom and that a teacher’s teaching should be examined before one relies on him. It discusses the qualities of a good disciple and the example of Atisha and Serlingpa, then answers questions on faith, comparisons with other religions, and the Buddhist tenet schools.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 45m
UUID: fdf6fad4-f954-452b-8ae9-0597d87ee5c6
Date: 2012-10-24
Words: 4,608
Oh. Generally speaking, in this world of ours, we need a teacher for whatever we are involved in. And in addition to being well educated, well trained in whatever he teaches, such a teacher must also be skillful in the means he uses to impart these teachings. Moreover, within these, Buddhist teachers are preeminently important and their mind even more important are the teachers of the great vehicle who teach one the paths to attain the state of full enlightenment. Said in the outline, the table of contents of the Lamrim, the graduated stages of the path, relying on the spiritual teacher, the root of the path.
This indicates how important reliance on the spiritual teacher is since it’s a full outline within the graduated stages of the path. And this is important whether one is training for attaining a higher rebirth in future lives or whether one is training for attaining definite excellence. In other words, either liberation or the state of full enlightenment. As Buddha Śākyamūni famously said in his sūtra, his Holiness the Dalai Lama quotes repeatedly, monks and scholars in the self same way as a goldsmith tests gold through cutting, rubbing and burning, accept not my words out of veneration. This indicates that it is up to ourselves whether or not we engage in the Buddhist teachings.
We have complete freedom in the matter. The Buddha expanded these teachings clearly and we ourselves must analyze carefully before engaging in them and specifically before relying on a teacher, on a spiritual teacher. Then after this, we must engage or rely correctly. In this verse, the passage do not rely out of veneration indicates that one cannot engage in the Buddhist teachings relying on faith or veneration alone. Otherwise, there will be problems later on.
Generally speaking, there are numerous great scholars and practitioners in the Tibetan Buddhist tradition. However, there are some specific problems which are related to the practice of protectors. Specifically the practice of a protector which is forbidden by His Holiness Dalai Lama called Dolgyal or previously called Shugden. Before we engage in reliance on a teacher who may be knowledgeable about the Lamrim, it is important for us to examine carefully whether or not this teacher relies correctly on His Holiness And see, if he relies on him on what grounds we can say that and if he doesn’t on what grounds. Buddha Śākyamūni has given us explicit instructions for this in this quote.
As is said in the essence of Nectar, Lamrim, a spiritual teacher whose instructions can lead us to supreme enlightenment. Here, the spiritual teacher which we need is a spiritual teacher who can teach the totality of the path ranging from the beginning or the gateway of the path, which is reliance on the spiritual teacher all the way up to the state of union or Yidam. Such a spiritual teacher transmits the instructions of the Dharma, which enable us to attain full enlightenment. You might have the doubt and if you do so, this would be a very good doubt to have. What about Guru Suvarnadvipi, Lama Serlingpa, whose foremost disciple was Atisha?
Guru Suvanna Vipi is explicitly described in the Lamrim treatises as Atisha’s root guru. And it is well known that Atisha received his core instructions on training in bodhichitta from Guru Suvarnadvipi. However, it is also well known that his understanding of the view was not that of Guru Suvarnadvipi. Generally speaking, we can say that the instructions regarding comportment, in other words, the method component of the path which Guru Suvarnadvipi imparted to Atisha are indissociable from those of Buddha Śākyamūni specifically the interchange of self and others. We must have reservations regarding his presentation of the view, however.
However, Je Tsongkhapa said himself in the essence of eloquence that for engaging in the practice of tantra and specifically of Anutara Yoga tantra, either the view of the Chitamatra, the mind only school or the view of the Mādhyamika school is acceptable. It is independence on the statement of Je Tsongkhapa and Legs bshad Nyingpo that we can say that Guru Suvarnadvipi who was a Chitamatran is acceptable as a foundational guru of the Lamrim tradition. Otherwise, if it was said in one of the works of the Lamrim tradition that their foundational teachers had to be Madhyamikas, then Guru Suvarnadvipi would not be acceptable as one of their foundational teachers. And here, to train initially in the path, one must rely on a spiritual teacher who can teach the instructions and one must rely on him initially through thought and then through behavior. Furthermore, the outline of reliance through thought starts with rely on the spiritual teacher through that root, which is faith.
This may be somewhat difficult for you to understand, but at present, Geshela would like to explain this central outline, rely on the root faith. So what or who precisely do we have faith in when it is said train in the root of faith? We have faith in that spiritual teacher who teaches us the unmistaken path. What aspect of him do we have faith in him? We don’t have faith in his head or his body.
It’s a dangerous point when you, for instance, fold your hands in veneration towards the teacher. It’s not in his body you have faith. Right? So here, what must we examine before having faith in the spiritual teacher? We must examine his speech, in other words, his teachings.
And generally speaking, we can be satisfied with a teacher who does not teach the totality of the path if our goal is to learn the graduated stages of the path. Then what we need is a teacher who teaches the graduated stages of the path and we must examine how he teaches the graduated stages of the path. Then if we take the case of Guru Suvarnadvipi, Guru Suvarnadvipi was peerless from the standpoint of his presentation of the conduct component or the method component of the path, but his view of emptiness was inferior. So here, we must examine the speech of the teacher when he teaches the Lamrim. And we need a rough understanding of what is taught even if we don’t understand the details.
Then on the basis of this rough understanding, we analyze what is taught and we ask others, we inquire about us regarding this teacher. This does not go as far as the presentation in Dhamakirti’s Paramanavartika in which it is said it is necessary to inquire regarding the actual qualities of the Guru. So please do not think that, it is Geshela’s intention to present himself as a potential teacher of the Lamrim. This is not his intention in presenting the manner of relying on the spiritual teacher at all. But if we take for instance, a spiritual teacher of the caliber of Khensur Rinpoche, when we first meet Rinpoche and we analyze Rinpoche’s teachings, we can see that Rinpoche is able to teach on various topics such as the Lamrim, the three principles of the path, tantra and so forth based directly on the great texts.
Then through such an analysis we can rely on him. If Geshela were presenting the topic with the hope that you rely on him, he would be very embarrassed. The faith which arises upon analyzing the speech or the teachings of the teacher on the Lamrim is a faith which is rooted in understanding the qualities of the teacher from within these three categories of faith. And this is precisely the faith we should generate in keeping with the Lamrim. And therefore here, the faith which we are generating is not an ignorant faith.
It is a faith which sees and appreciates the qualities of the spiritual teacher and which thinks he has attained, he or she has attained these realizations, why not myself? Independence on this faith, as Geshela explained in a different context, in the context of training for calm abiding, the wish to attain such a state arises and independence on that wish, enthusiasm in turn arises. That enthusiasm pushes us to study. Therefore, we give rise to enthusiasm, the wish to attain the state, and then striving for attaining that state. Kind of.
How does that sound? Think carefully about it. If you think sharply about it, understanding will increase. In Tibet, both the teachers and the disciples have tremendous faith. However, this is not a faith which is rooted in reasons.
It is not a faith which sees the qualities of the topic it has faith in. It is a faith which is sociological. It is rooted in the fact that for thousands of years, generations after generations of Tibetans were Buddhist. Such a faith is not stable, is not solid. In addition to the root faith, we do need a wisdom which understands how to train.
Without this wisdom which understands how to train, faith is ineffectual. It is a bit akin to the situation of someone who sees a fruit or an apple on a tree and wishes to eat that apple. They have the wish, the aspiration to eat that apple, But unless they have the means to actually get the apple, that wish is fruitless. On the other hand, if wisdom is present but faith is absent, it is easy to see that we are not able to accomplish our goals. Because faith is what gives rise to that wish which wishes to obtain, what it has faith in, that faith here is really of the nature of veneration and that wish in turn gives rise to striving and effort.
So without faith, there is no effort. This is obvious. Some people might think that it is sufficient to read a book on the topic and to practice based on a book alone. This is extremely difficult. To give you an example which will make it clearer, imagine you want to travel as a tourist to India.
You purchase the most recommended guidebook or travel book about India and read it from cover to cover. What’s in the East Of India, what’s in the West Of India, what’s in the South, the mountains, the flowers, the cities, the sites and so forth. But having finished reading the book, you would still be left with a doubt. Is this really true or not? How much can I rely on this book?
Then if you actually meet someone who’s been there and you ask him, is it indeed like this? And he says, yes, that’s the way it is. And if you go here, you’ll see that. And if you go there, you’ll see this. Then you will know for sure and will rely on the book.
It’s the same thing with the spiritual teacher. So if a fully characterized spiritual teacher who has experience of the totality of the path and is able to impart it, encounters a disciple who has true faith, puts effort in the practice and imparts to him the teachings, then there is no limit to what the disciple can attain. Whether it is a state of an Arhat, liberation, whether he can train in compassion, love or even the state of full enlightenment. This is akin to the relationship between Marpa and Milarepa. Is a quote by a Kadampa Geshe which says, upon meeting such a teacher, supreme bliss is possible.
And this quote has a parallel in the works of Nāgārjuna. Both these quotes refer to the type of relationship between Marpa and Milarepa. You understand? Do you understand? In a couple of minutes.
Faith here refers to 1% conviction. Conviction in a spiritual teacher who is able to teach the path and to teach it from experience. When a disciple meets such a teacher and he has this faith, this total conviction in the teacher and the teacher from his side is ready to impart the teachings based on his experience continuously without being for instance absent from time to time, then the student from his side can progress as far as it is possible for him to progress. So this is what faith is. We at present have not yet reached in our presentation of the graduated stages of the path, the actual body of the graduated stages of the path.
These are still the preliminaries. And here, once the student from his own side has heartfelt conviction, profound conviction in the teachings of his teacher, he must study them and then practice them. This is a motivation we should generate. You might quite legitimately think that you have been attending teachings for a long time, some of you for fifteen or twenty years. And here again, are talking of how to rely on the spiritual teacher.
To clear this doubt, it is very helpful to reflect on that episode in the life of Atisha when Atisha was 29 years of age. And he had received pretty much all of the oral instructions which could be received in Northern India at that period. Wishing to attain the state of a fully enlightened being, Atisha realized it would be unsuitable not to rely on bodhichitta, not to train in bodhichitta. And it would seem that at the period, the instructions for the interchange of self and other to generate bodhichitta were absent, were not prevalent in India. Atisha then set forth for his long trip to Sumatra to receive these teachings from guru Sovanadvipi and took him as his root teacher.
This is a very critical point which shows why we also, do not have the luxury to practice without a spiritual teacher. So in addition to the qualities of the teacher of which we have spoken extensively, we have to address the issue of the qualities of the disciples. In this respect, Āryadeva, Nāgārjuna’s heart son, his foremost disciple said in his, his, the 400 verses. One who is impartial, sharp of mind and endowed with striving is the perfect disciple. Impartiality here refers to the absence of prejudice, the presence of an equanimous mind.
We well know the problems partiality can cause. A sharp acumen refers to a disciple who is intelligent and a disciple who has striving refers to a disciple who puts effort. In addition, the lamrim adds two more qualities which are necessary. The first is faith or veneration in the teacher from the side of the disciple. And the second is obedience that the disciple listen to the instructions of the teacher.
There is an anecdote which may illustrate this. In Tibet, many of the great practitioners practiced long, often lifelong retreats in caves or hermitage on the top of mountain peaks. And one time the guru of was doing such a retreat. And a Tibetan aristocrat wished for to do a divination for him, a Mamo divination. And for such a divination, one has to make an offering to the teacher.
So this aristocrat sent his poor servant with a suitable offering, which was a gigantic yak skin filled with butter, which the servant had to hoist up to the mountain peak. And as the servant was hoisting this huge skin filled with fresh butter, cold butter, he thought to himself, this guru is like an animal. He just lives on the top of mountain peaks in the middle of nowhere. Then the guru was very skillful. So when the poor peasant came with his skin filled with butter and dropped it on the floor, The teacher said to him, you have undergone great hardship to bring this and spoke to him very kindly and gently, then gave him a nice meal and offered him the remains of tsok, which in Tibet were often very munificent and tasteful.
And as a result of this, the servant had a lot of faith in the teacher. It was perhaps faith born from Tzok in this case. I think some of you such as Natalie have been to Tibet. You know firsthand that the talk in Tibet is very tasty. Very delicious, isn’t it?
Yeah. Really? Oh. It’s very tasty. It is said, for instance, in some Vinaya treatises that when one wants to impart teachings, first, one must attract the disciples who are making gifts to him, then speak to him soothingly, and finally impart the teachings.
Here, stop. There’s nothing left for today. We will stop here. Please think carefully on the meaning of the statement. Practice the root faith and what faith means.
There are numerous religious systems in the world, the Christian, Jewish, Muslim, Hindu systems. All of them without exception emphasize the importance of faith. So reflect carefully on what faith is, whether you have it or not, and how to practice by conjoining faith and wisdom. Then, Geshela, will be glad to take your questions on the topic of faith. Very potent.
When I was in Tibet, I was amazed how much energy and effort the Tibetans put into their faith and their religion, even though they’d been oppressed for so long. And to me, it struck me as more than just faith. Like, they had some really deep rooted understanding of, Buddhism. Could you just comment on that? Here Geshela is speaking honestly and bluntly with you.
He doesn’t see any point in turning around the pot or trying to disassemble. The faith of most Tibetans is not grounded in reason. It is a faith which is rooted in the fact that their fathers and their mothers and their ancestors were Buddhist generation after generation after generation. It’s part of the lifestyle. If you were to ask an ordinary Tibetan who precisely Buddha Śākyamūni was, where he lived, few would be able to go beyond India.
What he taught, they would find difficult to explain. Whom he studied with, they would not know. Now you probably think of or have thought of faith in Tibet because you saw the extraordinary faith of the Tibetans offering prostrations, doing circumambulations, reciting mantras, turning their prayer wheels. But the truth of the matter is indeed they do accumulate merit. But do they truly understand the key points of these practices or not?
I was I was brought up in a different religion that, emphasized the importance of having childlike faith. Mhmm. But I was always interested in in studying and studying and studying and learning as much as I could. While study is important, it was always said that, it’s more important to have faith like a child. And, my father says that the reason I eventually went away from that faith is because I I accumulated too much knowledge, which seems very strange to me.
And I I was interested in what your thoughts were on that. Is one correct in assuming you’re talking of Christianity? All the great religions, Christianity, Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism are similar broadly speaking in teaching the importance of altruism, of love and of compassion. They share this. Now there are uncommon and very profound techniques for the development of love and compassion within Buddhism, which are specific to Buddhism and are perhaps not present in the other religious traditions.
However, broadly speaking from the standpoint of conduct of behavior, all the great world religions are similar. Regarding the view, however, in other words, the wisdom or the understanding of reality, however, there are differences. The Buddhist viewpoint is a profound and difficult one which teaches different levels of selflessness. Broadly speaking, there are four schools of tenets in Buddhism, the Vaibhāṣika, the Sautrāntika, the Cittamātra and the Mādhyamika. They are all identical in their presentation of conduct or behavior.
They differ exclusively in their presentation of the view. And if you take for instance the two highest schools, the Cittamātra or mind only school and the Mādhyamika or middle way school, they are basically opposite in terms of their view. So from your standpoint, Geshela would suggest that you reflect and analyze carefully to see where you want to go. It is entirely up to ourselves whether we wish to study or not, but it is an essential part of the Buddhist training to study. And in this matter, Geshela would suggest to you that a good way to look at it is to take what is of benefit to you personally.
This is perfectly appropriate. If something is of benefit to your mind, then you can practice it in keeping with the instructions which the Buddha gave in a sūtra in which he said, Monks and scholars accept not my words out of faith alone, but like a goldsmith, check them through cutting, rubbing, and burning. Is there a particular type of faith that the teacher develops in the student as time goes on and the student progress? So there’s no certainty in the matter, but it does happen that the teacher of one life becomes a student of the next life and reciprocally, for instance, His Holiness the Dalai Lama’s two tutors, Ling Rinpoche and his second tutor in his previous life became his disciples in this life. Just a small question.
This maybe maybe enlightenment and wisdom starts with the faith, and most probably the faith is inside the person. So in that in that connection, is it right to say that the faith makes an impact on the inner beauty of the person? For example, the heart, the soul, and the mind, and the person grows a bit more devoted and convicted to his faith from inside. And in that case, what is behind the person and what is in front of the person are small matters as compared to what is inside the person. Want to have a comment on that, please.
Generally speaking, the Buddhist path is a path of of non-Ātman, non-self. And therefore in this context, and this is a Buddhist specificity from the standpoint of the Buddhist presentation of wisdom. From that standpoint, when faith increases, there would be no increase in the beauty of the soul or the Ātman precisely because such a soul or such an Ātman is not considered as an object of knowledge, is not recognized as existing from a Buddhist standpoint. Now this is obviously not a standpoint which is shared by the other religions. My faith in some aspects of the path have been a little bit contrived, but others have gained strength as I observe and experience things to be so, to be in alignment with the Buddhist paradigm.
And I I wonder if faith is a continual progression as you continue to develop realization and insight, your faith would continue to deepen and strengthen or if the progression actually relies on the faith in the first instance. So are they interdependent? Or I guess I’m answering my own question. I guess to develop faith, you need experience to things in a certain way through a nap, or is it only through analysis? It’s a perfectly acceptable way of presenting it.
It is here we are talking of that faith which sees the quality specifically of the spiritual teacher in this context of other aspects of the grounds and of the paths leading to full enlightenment as that faith increases and that faith here refers to belief, to conviction, to veneration, then in turn one’s striving and one’s enthusiasm increase. And as one’s striving and one’s enthusiasm increase in turn the realizations come. Yeah. I guess you referred to Je Tsongkhapa as having said that initially, as the basis for the Lamrim, it didn’t matter whether you had the view of Cittamātra or Mādhyamika. I was wondering whether as a matter of faith, it was necessary at some point to resolve your view of it and your view on either of those?
And if so, at what point on the path that was necessary? Much depends here on the acumen, the intellectual faculties of the student and their constitution. A student of extremely sharp acumen will from the very beginning rely on the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika view and progress from the very beginning with that view. However, that view leads easily to nihilism. Then for this reason, a student of less sharp faculties will initially rely on the Vaibhāṣika view and its presentation of the person.
Then we’ll move beyond this view to rely on the Sautrāntika view and its presentation. Then we’ll move beyond this to rely on the Chitamatra view and its presentation. And finally, we’ll gain an understanding of the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika view. Everything depends on the faculties of the student. As far as the Dalai Lama said, there is in the Buddhist presentation of views, numerous views and I myself get frequently confused with all these views.
We have for instance within the Chitamatra view, the true aspectarian and the false aspectarian view. Then within the Mādhyamika view, we have the Svatāntrika Mādhyamika and the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika. And Svatāntrika is subdivided into Svatāntrika and Yogacāra Svatāntrika. So it’s when I said, I just have relied from the beginning on the Prāsaṇgika view, it’s made my life easier. And he said, this presentation of all of the views makes me dizzy.
I suspect it will make you dizzy too. Therefore, I will just present the Prāsaṇgika view. I just wanted to elaborate on what was brought up over here with I understand what Gesheela is saying about, the concept of myself, but I can’t, I just feel that if you don’t have faith in yourself and believe in your own inner potential, how, yeah, how can you ever have faith in anything else? So you are quite right, but you have to make a distinction between the two types of selves or the two types of I’s. There is a nominal I, a conventional I which is in no way refuted.
And this is what performs activities what we have trust or faith in. And there is an I which is an object of refutation And that is what is refuted. So Geshela would like to ask us at the end of this teaching on Lamrim in which we have accumulated definitely roots of virtue to dedicate these roots of virtue in keeping with the request of a Japanese lady who came to see him and who told him that she was highly distressed by the recent self immolation by fire in October of five or six Tibetans in Tibet. There have been some 59 or 60 Tibetans already who have sacrificed their lives for their country and we can only admire the tremendous faith and strength of these Tibetans and dedicate our roots of merit to them. I’d just like to let you know that we now have a number of transcriptions that have just come out.
Patience has been out for a couple of weeks. Thank you. But we also have calm abiding that Rinpoche and Geshela completed in, September on the weekend. There’s the eight verses of transforming the mind, the wheel of sharp weapons, and the 12 links of dependent arising. So these are all new.
They haven’t been out most of them have only been out in the last few days. Many thanks to Lily for doing all spiral binding and to the people who transcribed and very much to Jill who produced Patience and the Calm Abiding. Thank you. And if anybody is interested in assisting with transcribing, come and see Jill over here and enjoy some of, Carol’s delicious chai. What’s that?
Tuesday? It’s Lily’s delicious chai. Sorry. Carol, sorry. What was that?
What about oh, no. Not not this Tuesday.
Key terms in this teaching
- atman dag (Tib)
- Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- tantra gyü (Tib)
- Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
- yidam ishtadevata (Skt)
- Literally, "mind-bound." One's own personal, main - or, as Lama Yeshe used to say, favorite - deity for tantric practice. The deity with which a practitioner has the strongest connection. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Is it right to say that faith increases the inner beauty of a person, from the Buddhist point of view?
Generally, the Buddhist path is a path of non-Ātman, or non-self. This is a specifically Buddhist position, based on the Buddhist presentation of wisdom. From that standpoint, when faith increases, there is no increase in the beauty of the soul or the Ātman. The reason is that such a soul or Ātman is not considered an object of knowledge and is not recognized as existing in the Buddhist view. This position is not shared by other religions.