Lam Rim – 2012-10-10 – KR

1 h 41 min · 3,556 words · 10 October 2012

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2012-10-10 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teaching explains what meditation is: a mind withdrawn inwards and single-pointedly focused on an object with intensity, not merely sitting in posture. It covers three kinds of meditation (overview, analytical and fixative), with examples from the Lamrim on impermanence, love and compassion, and then discusses the spiritual teacher’s kindness. A short question session on meditation closes the recording.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 41m

UUID: 02fea67d-7add-4777-b019-396b01b8ae6a

Date: 2012-10-10

Words: 3,552

Exactly. If we choose a day, very nice. Meditation is extremely important and is valued both by the Buddhist and the non Buddhist traditions. In this matter, it is important to understand what precisely is meditation, how one engages in meditation, and what its goals are. Just to stay cross legged with one’s eyes closed does not amount to meditation.

So we all like to meditate and then it is important for us to understand precisely what meditation is and why we engage in it. Just to stay cross legged with one’s hands in the meditation posture and one’s eyes closed is not meditation. It’s merely a physical posture. It is something which is done to impress others. Meditation is to become accustomed over and again with one’s object of meditation with that with which one wishes to become familiar through meditation.

This is what meditation is. Check for yourselves if this is what you engage in. Geshela from his own standpoint has read the Lamrim over and again, and this is his own understanding. So can you give me of that? Thank you.

When is meditating becoming accustomed to what one wishes to become accustomed to alone? The answer is no. Otherwise, we would all be engaged in meditation most of the time. So what is meditation? If we take the case of a desirous mind focused on its object of desire, We can see that this mind is single focusly focused on its object of desire, the exclusion of everything else.

And all bodily and verbal activities are directed towards this. Does this qualify or can this be called meditation? This cannot really be called meditation. We are all similar. When we desire something, our mind is focused single pointedly on what we desire to the exclusion of everything else and we eventually gain an experience of that desired object.

However, we cannot call this meditation. Why can’t we call it meditation largely because being focused on an object which is your support for desire, the mind is distracted outwards by agitation. Whereas true meditation involves withdrawing the mind inwards and evacuating the senses. All of us, you understand? Does this with inward withdrawal of the mind suffice to qualify as meditation?

The answer is still no. Since when we fall asleep, our mind is totally withdrawn inwards. For that matter, Asaṇga points out that in unconsciousness, deep sleep, and states bereft of consciousness, there is no mental consciousness. So in this state of sleep in which the mind is totally withdrawn inwards, obviously, we are referring not to ordinary sleep but to deep sleep. In addition for such a state to qualify as a state of meditation, the object of observation must be apprehended and it must be apprehended in two different modes.

It must be apprehended strongly, the same way as when we hold strongly a cup and it must be apprehended with the factor of intensity with clarity. Now when these two are present, then one can indeed speak of meditation. Clearly, these two modes of apprehension dispel sleep. Therefore, meditation is a state in which the mind is not only withdrawn inwards but is single pointedly focused on an object of observation. This is meditation.

So this is how one should try to think about meditation. Otherwise, if we just stay in the meditative posture, there is no clear idea of where our mind may be going. Generally speaking, therefore, although there are numerous types of meditation, they are generally characterized by this inner withdrawal of the mind. The mind’s being single focused on its object of meditation with a factor of intensity. Then within the numerous subdivisions of meditation, we can distinguish between overview meditations, analytical meditations and concentration or fixative meditations.

Then regarding the first overview meditation, one meditates here on whatever one has a basic understanding of using whatever level of meditation one has attained. If one has attained calm abiding, this is the highest type of meditation accessible to us. However, even if one has not attained it, if from within the nine levels of mental abiding leading to calm abiding, one has attained placement or continuous placement, then that is what one uses. So what would be overview meditation in the context of Lamrim, of the graduated stages of the path? In the context of Lamrim, it would mean that one meditates on the totality of the path from its very beginning to its completion which is the attainment of the state of full enlightenment.

In other words, one would meditate first on past and future lives, then on karma and causality, then on death and impermanence, as well as on a precious human rebirth. Independence on this, one tries to generate a form of renunciation. Based on this renunciation in turns, one tries to generate bodhichitta and one progresses upwards until the state of union. Have pointed out the importance of the overview meditation on the graduated stages of the path. And if one has the capacity to do so, one actually should meditate on the totality of the path, generating fully characterized experiences of each of the steps.

For instance, a fully characterized experience of a definite emergence leading to a fully characterized experience of bodhichitta and so forth. If this is not possible, at the very least, one should bring to mind each of the topics in sequence of the graduated stages of the path. In so doing, one implants very powerful karmic imprints in the mind which will mature in future lives. And therefore, we should train incrementally in each of the stages of the path all the way through training our minds in bodhichitta, reflecting on the fact that since all sentient beings have the Buddha nature, then it is a state, the state of enlightenment which they can attain and we should try to lead them to that state. Then for ourselves clearly, it will be very difficult at present to generate these experiences.

Geshela doubts that anyone in this room has fully qualified definite emergence. It is very difficult to generate. But if we train our minds the same way as we train our minds for instance to ride a horse, then eventually we will become accustomed to do this. You might think the Lamrim, the graduated stages of the path is very extensive and this is almost hopeless. But the way to go about it is to proceed step by step slowly and to become accustomed to training in this way.

Geshela from his side has limited experience in the field, but this is how he feels about it. Well, generally speaking, the overview meditation on Lamrim is a meditation which does not rely on the recitation of texts but instead is basically a meditation which arises from thinking. Nonetheless, Geshela suspects that if we were to recite the Lam Rim prayer of the Lama Chöpa in its totality for thinking carefully of the meaning of each of the verses, we would be accomplishing something quite close to an overview meditation of the Lamrim since the totality of the Lamrim is included within this prayer. This is for overview meditation. Now regarding analytical meditation.

What is analytical meditation? Let us take the example of meditating on death and impermanence. The way we would engage in analytical meditation is if we are to say ordained and have studied, we would engage in analytical meditation on death and impermanence through using reasoning and trying to generate a valid cognizer of this. Otherwise, if we have not studied in that depth, nonetheless, we would take our body as an object of observation in the same same way as we might take the top of Geshela’s cup and observe it, analyzing all the reasons for which this body is impermanent and eventually will die until we gain some type of realization. And then if we are, for instance, meditating on the impermanence of our aggregates and of our body specifically, then we would analyze over and again using all the possible lines of reasoning to see the degree to which our aggregates are impermanent, transit, and change instant by instant.

The metaphor used for this given for this is to analyze in the self same way as you peel the bark of a certain tree which seems to have no core. The more bark you peel off, the more bark comes. In the self same way, one analyzes the aggregates taking them apart and seeing that nothing there is lasting or durable until one gets an experience. And then one moves from experience to experience until one gains a direct valid cognition which realizes the impermanence of the aggregates. Then this is an example of analytical meditation on impermanence.

There are numerous other topics such as emptiness in which you can engage in analytical meditation. Then regarding fixative or concentration meditation, as Geshela sees it, the difference is as follows. Whereas when we engage in analytical meditation on impermanence, for instance, there is clearly a subject, the mind which is meditating on an object which is a perceived impermanence of the aggregates. When we meditate on topics such as for instance, renunciation, love, forbearance, compassion, and so forth, there is actually only a subject. Then when we speak in this context of meditating on love or for that matter compassion, what do we mean?

We actually mean that we are trying to affect our mind by love or by compassion. To turn our mind through love and compassion into something else than it is at present. This is what is meant in the context of fixation meditation by meditation on love or compassion. So here, when we speak of meditating on compassion and we should be more precise and speak actually of the goal of meditating on compassion, we are saying that our mind must be affected by compassion. What this means is that as our mind must contact compassion, must come into contact with compassion and turn into something other or different than what it is at present.

This is what is meant by meditation on compassion or on love. Then what are Bodhisattvas? Bodhisattvas are beings whose mind has come under the power of compassion who have generated fully qualified compassion. In our cases, when we say we are meditating on compassion, we actually not meditating on fully qualified compassion, but merely meditating on ordinary compassion. So if we take the case of our own mind and a practice during one day on compassion, we can truly say that we are meditating on compassion when our mind contacts and is transformed by compassion.

So Gesheera suspects this is what is meant by concentration of fixative meditation on love and compassion. Then a fixative meditation in Tibetan is called Jogom. The verb means to affix or to place. To affix what? The mind on what?

On its object of observation. So we can’t really say that analytical and fixative meditation are contradictory. We can see, however, that analytical meditation predominates when we meditate on topics such as impermanence, and fixative meditation predominates as far as love, compassion, and so forth are concerned. There are numerous techniques of meditation and we should try to rely on authentic treatises which teach meditation not on whatsoever technique coming from no one really knows where. Instead, we should focus on an authentic practice of meditation and then we can be happy with our mental training.

Then we want to meditate, but if we can’t meditate, then we just stay in the posture physically, don’t we? As he said in Shantideva’s bodhisattvacharyavatara, having tied down the elephant, the wild elephant of the mind with the rope of recollection, all fears are destroyed. The wild elephant of our mind must be tied down with the rope of recollection focused on its objective observation and drawn inwards. And when this happens, all fancies and conceptions are destroyed, specifically those fancies such as desire and so forth. Their destruction means that we are immune to fear.

Meditation is very difficult for all of us since all of us are highly accustomed to allowing our minds to wander outwards under the power of distraction and desire. We have to train in withdrawing our minds inwards. And a good way to start doing this, which is the gateway leading eventually to meditation is to initially start by not allowing our mind to wander outwards without a good reason and to withdraw it inwards instead. It is said that when we rise in the morning, we must generate a motivation which will impel us throughout the day. However, generating such a motivation well is very difficult unless we have some type of experience of meditation.

Let alone generating a motivation such as renunciation, bodhichitta and so forth. So we have to generate some experience of meditation. And this has been a brief presentation of the categories of meditation which Geshela hopes you understand a bit better at present to generate the motivation to receive the teachings. First reflect on what meditation is and then try to generate a mind which is held by one of these motivations such as renunciation, bodhichitta, great compassion and so forth. When one wants to meditate, let us say for instance, on impermanence, on emptiness, on renunciation, on bodhichitta, on great compassion, it is obvious that initially one must know what one is talking about and what one wishes to meditate about.

And this one can only do through studying the great treatises in our specific case through studying the Lamrim. So one studies carefully the Lamrim but it is not just a matter of knowing the words. We do not meditate on the words alone. These words must impact our mind. We must think over and again an impermanence until we gain some sense of understanding of it and then meditate on this.

And then through careful study and meditation, we can get somewhere. Those who meditate generally seem to find during their meditation that there is reduced sensory perception. Meditation is performed with the mental consciousness. Therefore, even though the eyes do see, the ears do hear, this does not register to a large scale on consciousness. This is one of the signs that one is starting to meditate.

On the other hand, if we are hearing all sorts of things and focusing on all sorts of things with our eyes, then one can say one has started to meditate. We have at present reached the section in the graduated stages of the path dedicated to relying on the virtuous friend, the Kalyana Mitra. And the virtuous friend or the spiritual teacher in the context of the Lamrim, broadly speaking has the same meaning as the virtuous friend in the context of the perfection vehicle, the Pāramitāyāna. Now what do we refer to here? We’re referring to a being who has the capacity to teach us the totality of the path leading to full enlightenment.

Beings regarding such beings as or his holy Mr. Dalai Lama, there is no doubt. The friend, the spiritual teacher, which we want is a being who can teach in unmistaken and incontrovertible way the totality of the path from our present state of affairs all the way to full enlightenment, all the means leading us to the attainment of full enlightenment. It may happen that such a being has partial faults or seems to have partial faults. And in this matter, the advice which Tsongkhapa gives in his great stages of the path, which is based on experience is very profound indeed.

Tsongkhapa says, we can see for ourselves that when we have an enemy, even if that enemy or foe has overwhelming qualities, because he is our enemy, we focus mainly on his faults, however small they might be. On the other hand, for ourselves, even though we ourselves have mainly faults, we only see our qualities and disregard completely our faults. Is that true? There’s no doubt. That there will be perception of faults in our spiritual teacher is almost certain.

It is almost certain by the twin combination of the possible existence of thoughts from the standpoint of the teacher and the certain existence of karmic obstructions from our side which will cause the appearance of faults. And there is in this matter, a story which is recounted regarding the great Ganden monastery guru, Lobsang Dede when he gave the oral transmission of the Kangyur of the collection of the Buddhist Sutras. There was a monk in the audience who because of his karmic obstructions when Lobsang Dede was giving the transmission of the Kangyur saw the Kangyur in front of Lobsang Dede as a heap of raw meat. And so Lobsang Dede when he was giving the Kangyur was gulping down the meat. Then when the Kangyur volumes were taken away, this monk actually saw the attendants carrying platters of raw meat away.

This is due to karmic obstructions. So we must therefore meditate on joy at the thought that we can see His own teacher, the Dalai Lama, clearly. Then it is said that someone who had a lot of desire and who had actually been behaving as a thief came in front of Atisha once. And Atisha advised him to purify his karmic obstructions through engaging in practices such as prostration and so forth.

And as a result of this eventually, this brigand was able to see the Jowo statue in Ramoche Temple in Lhasa. Even though Buddha Śākyamūni, the fourth supreme emanation did manifest in this world of ours twenty five centuries ago, we ourselves were not able to meet him as it said, as it is said, we are the dregs of the dregs, the last of the last unable to meet the Buddha and reflecting on this, we can see that the kindness of our spiritual teacher from which we have received the teachings is actually greater to us than the kindness of the Buddha. Said, the kindness of the Buddha towards us is akin to that of someone who gives food in a time of plenty whereas the kindness of the Guru to us is akin to that who gives slabs of meat during a famine. If we reflect on this, we can see clearly that everything we know at present on for instance, bodhichitta, we owe to the kindness of our spiritual teacher. And then reflecting on this, we can see that the kindness of the spiritual teacher towards us is greater than that of Buddha Śākyamūni.

Then over time to practice progressively, we will be able to see supreme emanation bodies and so forth. Then to see supreme emanation bodies what we have visions of is very difficult until one gains probably at least the first ground. So we’ll stop here and if you have questions, please feel free to ask them. We will gain direct experience of being such as Avalokiteśvara when we have progressed higher upon the paths. Then we can meet Avalokiteśvara, Ārya Maitreya, Ārya Mañjuśrī.

At present, it is very difficult to point them out. As a side effect of analytical meditation, it is obvious that one’s inappropriate physical and verbal behavior will change. We’ll put aside the sense, direct sense valid cognizers for the time being. If we take the mental direct valid cognizers and the mental direct valid cognizer which realizes impermanence, yes, it is durable and extremely stable for that matter. Once one has attained such a mental direct valid cognizer, one becomes a member of the Ārya Sangha.

Oh, Sangha. That Sangha. I’m joking. Yeah. Questions on meditation. Yes.

When you are meditating and the mind is very troubled, it is distracted or agitated through a form of desire. Then one stops meditating and one applies first the antidote to that desire which may be a form of renunciation. Fixative meditation. So when one is meditating on love and compassion irrespective of whether one does it in keeping with the interchange of self and others which is taught in Bodhisattvacharyavatara or the seven fold cause and effect procedure. In either case, one is trying to give rise to a feeling of affectionate love for all beings which is akin to the feeling which a mother has for her single child.

Then the sign of such an attainment is when a love, let’s say if you are a mother and you have a child, the love a mother has for her child. If you are married, the love a wife has for her husband or husband for his wife. When that sort of love arises towards every single person which you meet, then this is a criterion of attainment. No one can say one has meditated on love and compassion. In the case of fixative meditation, fixative meditation is a meditation which is focused on its object and the experience arises from that.

Analytical meditation is a meditation which analyzes its object and the experience arises from that. But you cannot say that they are contradictory. They are opposite. Then you have to start meditating. Do you understand?

It’ll be meditation. Good. Good. Good. Thinking in this way, it will be very easy.

All right.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
oral transmission lung (Tib, Wyl)
The verbal transmission of a teaching, meditation practice or mantra from guru to disciple, the guru having received the transmission in an unbroken lineage from the original source. LYWA
Paramitayana Pharchin thegpa (Tib)
The Perfection Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top