Lam Rim – 2016-05-10 – KR

1 h 31 min · 4,054 words · 10 May 2016

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2016-05-10 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Explains the foundations of the Mahayana path: uncontrived definite emergence and bodhichitta, with great compassion as the water and manure that sustain the path. It discusses whether emptiness or uncontrived definite emergence comes first, and why calm abiding combined with insight into emptiness is needed to permanently abandon afflictions. Much of the session is student questions on these points.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 31m

UUID: 3d48d297-b1bb-4890-94d0-58755fd556d3

Date: 2016-05-10

Words: 4,050

So within the general presentation of the five paths, in other words the path of accumulation, of preparation, of seeing, of meditation and of no more learning, the foundation or the ground is the thought of definite emergence. Now specifically within the presentation of the paths of the Mahāyāna, the foundation is bodhichitta or the Mind of Awakening of the Mahāyāna. So the mind of definite emergence is necessary both at the beginning and in the middle of one’s practice. At the beginning, it is this generation of the thought of definite emergence which ushers entry into the path. After this, the stronger thought of definite emergence, the swifter one approaches to one’s goal which is liberation.

So definite emergence is therefore important in the beginning and it is important in the middle. Now whether it is important at the end as well is a matter of some debate. Since definite emergence, a sort of definite emergence is a mind striving for liberation. Now once one has become an Arhat, is there a place for such a mind or not? This is something one must analyze.

Clearly, as far as the path of a Mahāyāna being is concerned, great compassion is important in the beginning, the middle and the end. Great compassion is important in the middle since it is the uncommon cause of bodhichitta. In the beginning since it is the uncommon cause of bodhichitta. It is important in the middle since without it one sinks out of the Mahāyāna path and it is therefore akin to water and to manure with which one fertilizes crops but it is also important in the end as well since it is what enables the fully enlightened beings to perform their activities. Therefore, the path of the Mahāyāna is compared to a crop and great compassion to water and manure fertilizing the crop.

So as I explained last time, there is no definiteness regarding having generated the wisdom realizing emptiness within the mind stream of beings who have generated an uncontrived thought of definite emergence or who have generated bodhichitta. In other words, one can have generated an uncontrived thought of definite emergence or bodhichitta with or without having generated a wisdom of realizing emptiness. Now in your opinion, what is the more difficult to generate a wisdom realizing emptiness or to generate an uncontrived thought of definite emergence? What’s your thinking on the topic? What’s more difficult?

It’s more difficult. An uncontrived thought of definite emergence. Mhmm. And mother? Majority seems to find renunciation really hard.

Steve believes that it’s harder to generate a mind realizing emptiness. Why? So this is due to the presentation in Lam Rim of the insight realizing emptiness at the very end of Lam Rim but that is not the sequence of generation of an understanding of emptiness. It is due in my opinion to the fact that the topic of emptiness is a very difficult topic and therefore it is presented at the end. Emptiness can be generated earlier or later.

This is my private opinion as well that between the two, we’re not talking of other realizations but between uncontrived definite emergence and the realization of emptiness, uncontrived, sort of uncontrived definite emergence is harder to realize and the thought of realizing emptiness is somewhat easier to realize. So actually this is something which has to be based on one’s own understanding. Otherwise, to try to base these on the Geshe texts is difficult. We should see in terms of one’s own understanding whether it is easier to generate emptiness first and definite emergence after or the other way around. So the reason for which most assert that definite emergence is more difficult to generate than emptiness is simply the numbers.

There are more people who have an understanding of emptiness than there are, it seems great beings with an uncontrived sort of definite emergence. But in your opinion, what other reason is there for which it is harder to definite, to generate an uncontrived sort of definite emergence than emptiness? Let’s go. So most of you have said that it is more difficult to generate an uncontrived thought of definite emergence than to generate a realization of emptiness. Why?

Why? Exactly why. Another? Maggie? It’s very good.

You have all answered in terms of your own understanding. Now regarding the means of progressing on the path in Maitreya’s Abhisamayālamkāra, it is said that initially one generates definite emergence and on that basis one gives rise to an understanding of the four noble truths. This is in contradistinction to Je Tsongkhapa’s teachings in the three principles of the path in which he says at the very end of the poem, having in this way, realized the essence, retire in solitude and put effort. This indicates that one would initially gain a realization of emptiness and thereafter dwell in solitude. Dwelling in solitude refers to generating the wisdoms arisen from meditation.

And one dwells in solitude precisely because one may not have countered the vanities of this life or may not have countered the vanities of all lives. Since definite emergence is subdivided into mere definite emergence where one counters the vanities of this life and fully characterized definite emergence in which one counters the vanities of all lives. So in a nutshell, once one or two generate an uncontrived thought of definite emergence, it is not necessary to have a realization of emptiness. However, it is necessary to have at least a realization of the coarse surfaces of persons in the sense in which it is understood by the lower schools of tenets. And therefore it is forced to say that to attain an uncontrived thought of definite emergence, one must necessarily have the realization of emptiness.

As Je Tsongkhapa says in these three principles of the path, in as much as having generated definite emergence and bodhichitta, if one’s understanding is not upheld by the view, one will not be able to sever the root of existence, strive at realizing interdependence. This clearly indicates that there are beings who have either uncontrived definite emergence or bodhichitta and who have not realized the view. So Ralph’s answer was very good. It does depend indeed on the qualities of the trainee and their karmic imprints. However, the issue here is once one enters the path, in other words, once one enters the path of accumulation, since the path is entered at the level of the path of accumulation, must one have generated uncontrived definite emergence or must one have generated in addition a realization of emptiness?

And the answer is, one must have generated an uncontrived thought of definite emergence but one can have generated a realization of emptiness or not. Both are possible. So we have therefore explained several times the generation of an uncontrived thought of definite emergence. I think you have a good understanding of it. We shall therefore set it aside.

And as you remember, the definition of a path is a sapient mind which is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence. So when one enters the path, one enters it at the level of the smaller path of accumulation. Now when one progresses from the smaller to the middling level of the path of accumulation, at the level of the middling path of accumulation, one necessarily focuses on an understanding of emptiness in keeping with the Prāsaṇgika view. That focus on an understanding of emptiness in keeping with the prasanika view may or may not be present in beings who are entering the path. But once a being progresses from the smaller to the middling level of the path of accumulation, such a being has a very powerful striving for liberation and is unlike us who basically are sleeping and stuffing our faces.

Instead, such a being focuses exclusively on the means to attain liberation and at that point necessarily understands that the only way to attain liberation is the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika view. So once one understands that the main obstacle to attaining liberation, in other words to attain the state of an is that ignorance which grasps at a self, then one will seek energetically for the means to counter this ignorance grasping at a self and this is none other than the view of selflessness in keeping with Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika. Then one has great delight in this. And in our cases, we have been born at the end of the twentieth or the beginning of the twenty first one, end of the twentieth century. We live in the twenty first century, A century in which sensory excitement is at its maximum, sensory stimuli is higher than ever before.

Then in a century such as this one, it is much more difficult to generate an uncontrived thought of definite emergence than a couple thousand years ago when there were none of these means of sensory stimulation where lives are much simpler, much plainer and in which I am convinced it was much more straightforward to generate a realization of the Four Noble Truths. But this is a century we are born in. Then this is why Je Tsongkhapa in his praise of dependent origination praises our teacher Buddha Śākyamūni for teaching dependent origination and not any dependent origination but subtle dependent origination which opens the gateways to the teachings on the four noble truths and so forth. So our teacher Buddha Śākyamūni lived some two thousand five hundred, two thousand six hundred years ago and war, the world has changed greatly since that period. It is extraordinary that the praise we address to Buddha Śākyamūni can still be grounded on his teaching of dependent origination.

Then in my opinion, once a being has attained the middling level of the path of accumulation, that being focuses on understanding of emptiness and understanding that an insight focused on emptiness is indispensable to gain direct realization of emptiness and realizing that the foundation for this insight is calm abiding at the level of the middling path of accumulation, such a being puts great effort into obtaining calm abiding. In my opinion, at the level of the great path of accumulation, such a being will engage in the training in insight to gain an insight focused on emptiness. Now once one has attained an insight focused on emptiness at the level of the great path of accumulation, one will at that point enter the path of preparation, Prayogamārga or Jorlam in Tibetan. One is said to have entered the path of preparation because one is close to prepare or to apply to emptiness, the direct realization of emptiness which occurs at the level of the path of seeing. Now one has to give some details here on an insight or vipassana or Lhaktong focused on emptiness and what this means.

This is called in Tibetan Lhaktong or superior seeing because it is a seeing of emptiness which is superior to that which occurs in the context of calm abiding. Now, Lhaktong, strictly speaking, superior seeing or insight is also called seeing because just like abiding, it is focused on an object, in this case emptiness. The difference of calm abiding however, there is a factor of analysis which is involved in the process. During a calm abiding focused on emptiness, there is no factor of analysis focused on emptiness. But during an insight focused on emptiness, on the basis of a calm abiding focused on emptiness, there is also a factor of analysis which analyzes emptiness.

However, unlike analyses within our own minds, which induces agitation, This factor of analysis which is focused on emptiness with an insight in no way interferes with calm abiding. So one might wonder at this point why precisely is an insight focused on emptiness necessary to attain liberation? Why is calm abiding not sufficient? Now when calm abiding is present within the mind, indeed the afflictions are temporarily interrupted. They are not abandoned.

There’s a temporary surcease of the afflictions and this is akin to the example of a river. If we have a great river and we interrupt the flow of a river with a dam which is constituted of wood and stones and so forth, it is a temporary process. We eventually must put an end to the river at its source for the flow to cease. It is the same thing with the relation between calm abiding and insight. Now you will understand somewhat better the utility or the relevance of insight when you understand that a mere realization of emptiness is of little benefit.

A realization of emptiness alone based on calm abiding, let us say, in other words, a valid cognizer realizing emptiness cannot put an end to the afflictions. Actually, such a realization of emptiness occurs at the level of the middling path of accumulation. It is indispensable that it occur at that level. So what is necessary is repeated habituation with emptiness with ever more subtle minds and it is this which can counter the afflictions. So what is therefore necessary to attain liberation?

What is necessary is a direct realization of emptiness and this direct realization of emptiness arises independence on calm abiding, but not on calm abiding alone. It also needs an insight, in other words, a factor of analysis which is focused on emptiness. And when these two, calm abiding and insight are conjoined, focused on emptiness, one eventually attains liberation. So what is this process of direct realization of emptiness? How does one reach that point?

Initially, one generates the wisdom arisen from hearing through attending numerous teachings and developing an interest in emptiness. Then on this basis, one starts training in the wisdom arisen from thinking. And when the true wisdom arisen from thinking has been generated, one will have generated a valid cognizer realizing emptiness. At this point, one must generate a wisdom arisen from meditation which is focused on emptiness. This will be an insight which is focused on emptiness and this insight at the beginning is conceptual.

Then through repeated familiarity, eventually it becomes a direct perception of emptiness. So now for a couple of minutes, please reflect on the fact that to gain a direct realization of emptiness, it is not sufficient to rely on a calm abiding focused on emptiness. A mind of calm abiding will lead to a temporary surcease of the afflictions, a temporary interruption of the afflictions. It cannot lead to a permanent abandonment of the afflictions. For such a permanent abandonment of the afflictions, we must give rise to an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight focused upon emptiness.

Let us meditate on this. Number six, mental offering. Verse one, it is three. Thank you. Do you have questions?

So in the middle scope of the long ring versus in the 37 factors of enlightenment, they’re both realization that self grasping is the cause of suffering. However, I wonder why do the being has to realize the same thing again in the path of accumulation if that being has already realized that thing in the middle scope? You have to repeat your question. I didn’t understand everything. Slowly and clearly, please.

In the middle scope of the long rim, there’s Middle scope of the long rim, yes. There’s meditation on the origin of suffering and the origin of suffering is the self grasping mind. While in the path of accumulation, there’s this, in the path of accumulation in the 37 factors, there’s the same thing again. That’s a good question. When we train in the path shared with the being of the middling scope, we must enter the path and we enter the path at the level of the small path of accumulation.

Then indeed, we do meditate on the noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering. It is not two times that we do this, it is the same process. It’s very beneficial to think of the presentation of the Lamrim and that of Salam as one and not to separate them. Then when we enter for instance in the path of the being of the middling scope, to enter the fully characterized path of the being of the middling scope, we must also have entered the path. In terms of the constituents and the goals or the outlook of beings, there are three different paths but otherwise the core presentation is the same.

Another question. If you have a question, you must ask it. There’s no point in attending a class like this and not asking a question on the topic. Yes, hello. Could I just clarify please?

I don’t know if I got it down right. Did you say that the progression from the small to middling path of the path of accumulation necessarily the person under understands that the only way to achieve liberation is through the Prāsaṇgika view. And Geshe-la, if you did say that, where does that leave the other Mahayanis, the Chittimatrans and the Svetlanti? There is a benefit in reviews of the lower systems of tenets, it’s a down words in terms of the difference of acumen of the trainees. There are trainees of duller acumen who benefit from these views.

So when one studies tenets, it is not the case that one must first be a Vaibhāṣika and after being a Vaibhāṣika become a Sautrāntika then become a Cittamātra and eventually a Mādhyamika. That’s not the case. One can focus from the beginning on the tenets system one is interested in. However, the reality of experience shows that when students study Prāsaṇgika immediately, they fall into the extreme of nihilism. To avoid this, one studies the tenets step by step.

So when it comes to the presentation of paths, one must progress from the path of accumulation to the path of normal learning in sequence. That is not the case when it comes to tenets. One does not have to train as a Vaibhāṣika then train as a Sautrāntika and so forth upwards. However, there are advantages to this. The first is that one’s own understanding deepens in the process.

The second is that one is able to help people who for instance are particularly attracted to the Sautrāntika view because one understands it. Any other question? Past. Past. Past him.

Last week, Geshela said that it is realizations of emptiness that is what causes one to move upward along the path, that it is not an increase in the thought of definite emergence. And tonight, he as I understood it, it was said that the stronger the thought of definite emergence, the swifter the progress. This this makes sense in terms of the the qualifying word swifter, but I just want to confirm if there is a contradiction there. Excuse me, I must be getting deaf. Can you repeat loudly and clearly?

Sorry. I understand the beginning and then it becomes a mumble. Okay. So you heard what I said about last week? Yep.

Whereas this week, if I understood you, it was said that the stronger the thought of definite emergence, the swifter the progress. There seems to be a subtle contradiction there, but I just want to check. The uncontrived thought of definite emergence and the realization of emptiness are in no way contradictory. Instead, they cooperate with each other. The stronger the uncontrived thought of definite emergence, the greater the intensity of the meditation on emptiness.

The greater the intensity of the meditation on emptiness, the closer one becomes or one comes to liberation. In other words, two minds cooperate with each other. And mother. Yeah. Second.

It’s less of a question and more of a clarification because I couldn’t keep up with my notes. While explaining insight, it started off you started off saying, also called seeing because like I’m abiding, it focuses it focused on an object, but I couldn’t keep up from that point on. I was hoping to get a So the reason for which insight is called superior seeing literally in Tibetan is that it is superior to calm abiding in as much as it is focused on an object but in addition unlike calm abiding, there is a factor of analysis which analyzes this object and when insight has arisen, the bliss of pliancy arisen from analysis arises. This bliss of pliancy arisen from analysis is not present during calm abiding. For this reason, insight is said to be superior to calm abiding.

Another question? Last week, Geshe-la said that there are different definitions of nirvana. How should we avoid using the definition that Indian philosophers use? Like what are the different definitions of nirvana? So the Buddhist presentation of liberation or nirvana which we must rely upon is one which understands that the root of cyclic existence is ignorance grasping at a self and that the antidote to this is the wisdom realizing selflessness.

When one applies this antidote, one generates an abandonment of the afflictions. That abandonment is nirvana. Now the non Buddhist understanding of Mokśa is perhaps different. I’m not quite sure but they seem to consider that the attainment of calm abiding and specifically the bliss of the pliancy generated by calm abiding is moksha or liberation. Then this represents a temporary interruption or cease of the afflictions.

It is not a permanent abandonment of the afflictions. They can arise and will arise again. Okay and, Lawrence? I reviewed the small scope and medium scope. I realized that the attainment in the small scope should be turning away from the vanities of this life.

It means turning away from the eight worldly dharma. However, this turning away is based on meditation on death and impermanence. Therefore, it generates a feeling that those eight worldly dharmas are insignificant. It’s not really a turning away because it’s not turning away from the delusions caused by the eight worldly dharma. And the delusion is caused the eight worldly dharma causes delusion and this internal delusion should be turned away realized as the medium scope.

What is the question then? The question is, am I understanding correctly? Not quite. The object of abandonment of the path shared with the being of the small scope is the vanities of this life. It is not the eight worldly dharmas.

And the object of abandonment of the path shared with the being of the middling scope is the ignorance which grasps at the self. These two are quite different. Ant. Thank you. I believe Natalie, last week, asked for an example of a path mind.

And Geshe-la, if I recall or recorded it correctly, replied that it was a mind that no longer falls under the sway of the afflictions. But he has said that a a path mind can be a mind that has realized emptiness, and it can also be a mind that hasn’t realized emptiness. So it seems that a a path mind can still actually be under the sway of the afflictions. Yes. Yes, there is no definiteness regarding beings who have entered the path having a realization of emptiness or not.

Therefore, there are countless afflictions within the mind stream of beings who have entered the path in that respect. They are strictly identical to us. Where they are very different is in their understanding of the faults of the afflictions where they are billions of times superior to us. Drop here tonight at thirty, nearly. Thank you very much.

Then instead of wasting our time, if we put effort at study and try to gain an understanding, some type of experience, then this will be of tremendous benefit to us. Okay. I’m just wondering, you know, like, when you recognize your affliction, you know, and stop in, you know, just a second to think about it, and is it on the right path that you sort of, you know, eliminating the affliction? Generally speaking that is very good. It is very good when the afflictions have arise to immediately recognize the afflictions as afflictions, recognize their thoughts and stop them.

However, that alone is insufficient to say that one has entered the path. To enter the path, we need to have generated uncontrived definite emergence or renunciation. Okay.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Why must a practitioner realize the same thing again on the path of accumulation if they already realized it in the middling scope?

It is not done twice; it is the same process. When training in the path shared with the being of the middling scope, one must enter the path, and one enters it at the level of the small path of accumulation. There one meditates on the noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering. To enter the fully characterized path of the being of the middling scope, one must also have entered the path. It is very beneficial to view the Lamrim presentation and the presentation of the paths as one and not separate them. In terms of the constituents and the goals or outlook of beings there are three different paths, but otherwise the core presentation is the same.

Is it the right path to eliminate afflictions by recognizing them and stopping them when they arise?

Generally speaking, this is very good. When afflictions arise, it is very good to immediately recognize them as afflictions, recognize the thoughts involved, and stop them. However, this alone is not enough to say that one has entered the path. To enter the path, one needs to have generated uncontrived definite emergence, or renunciation.

Scroll to Top