Lam Rim – 2011-09-28 – KR

1 h 32 min · 4,099 words · 28 September 2011

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2011-09-28 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. This session continues the explanation of the four greatnesses of the Lam Rim, covering the greatness of easily discovering the intent of the conquerors and how the first two greatnesses relate to the three kinds of wisdom. It describes the Lam Rim as a vessel for reaching the ultimate intent of the Buddha, taught through Tsongkhapa’s three principles of the path, including how conventional and ultimate truths are understood together.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 33m

UUID: 90a6e43e-19e4-447a-8d31-374726f2a2a3

Date: 2011-09-28

Words: 4,095

As Tsongkhapa says, with a good intention, one attains both the grounds and the paths. Without a good intention, neither grounds nor paths can be attained. Therefore, privilege over all the intent. This verse stanza describes exactly the behavior we should have. We should privilege the motivation for listening to the teachings.

In the case of dharma, this has to be an uncommon motivation. Now all this uncommon motivation should be the motivation of the great vehicle. Nonetheless, it is similar to constructing a skyscraper. We construct a skyscraper even though we want to construct a very tall building, we must start by erecting the first floor and the foundation solidly. If they are not solidly erected, the whole building will collapse.

Therefore, the uncommon cause of the practice of the great vehicle is a practice of the being of middling scope. The uncommon cause of the practice of the being of middling scope is a practice of the being of small scope. This has to be our foundation. And in turn, each of the practices of the three scopes is subdivided into the greater middling and smaller practice of that given scope. Now if we take the example of the cycle of meditations connected with the practice of the being of small scope, these include meditating on the suffering of the lower realms, on karma and causality, meditating on death and impermanence and on refuge.

It is this we should try to meditate upon for the following two minutes to create a strong motivation. Yeah. And as you remember, there are four principle outlines which we are covering. These are the four greatnesses of the dharma. Within the greatness of the dharma given to increase one’s respect for the instructions.

This is in the outline of the text on page six seventy three of your English translation. So this initial fourfold subdivision is that in the greatness of allowing one to realize that all the teachings are without contradiction. The greatness of allowing all the scriptures to present themselves as instructions. The greatness of allowing one to easily discover the true thought of the conquerors and the greatness of allowing one to save oneself from the worst misdeed. Alternatively, this second outline can be subdivided also into seven.

And here, why do we study the second outline? The greatness of the dharma given to increase one’s respect for the instruction because independence of one’s respect or more precisely one’s veneration for the instruction. And here the instruction refers to the Lamrim in general, but more specifically to its root, which is the lamp for the path, the Bodhipathapradīpa composed by Atisha. Independent therefore on veneration for this work by Atisha, in turn, faith will arise within our mind stream. This faith will give rise to the wish to practice this instruction from which enthusiasm in turn arises.

And from the enthusiasm, pliancy, shinjangs, will arise, both bodily and mental pliancy. Now pliancy is defined by Je Tsongkhapa in his great treatise on the path as that feature of body and mind which enables us to study indefinitely what we want without any fatigue or exhaustion. And those of us who are assembled here today to attend this teaching should reflect on what it meant to attend the teachings in Tibet when the monks assembled in the great monasteries and where they faced levels of hardship, we could only begin to imagine. This was only possible because on the basis of veneration for the instructions, in turn, the wish or the aspiration to practice them arose. This gave rise in turn to enthusiasm and thereby to pliancy.

This is what alone enabled them to subsist without any food, any barley meal for two, sometimes three days. And therefore, this second outline on Page six seventy four of six seventy three, excuse me, of your English text, the greatness of the dharma given to increase one’s respect for the instruction, which corresponds to page 60 of your English text in the text. This is subdivided into four greatnesses which are outlines 21, 22, twenty three and twenty four. And then three features which are outlines 25, twenty six and twenty seven. The four greatnesses are the greatness of allowing you to realize all the teachings are without contradiction and the greatness of allowing all the scriptures to present themselves to you as instructions.

These were covered broadly speaking by Geshela last time. Then the remaining two greatnesses are the greatness of allowing one to easily discover the intent of the victorious one and the greatness of allowing one to save oneself from the worst misdeed. And therefore, we must be careful when we listen to these teachings since our actual ultimate goal is the understanding of the Four Noble Truths. And the first subdivision, the second outline, subdivision two one, the greatness of allowing one to realize that all the teachings are without contradiction, refers specifically to that feature of Atisha’s lamp for the path where Atisha fused all the teachings to answer the five questions of king What is meant here by teachings within the greatness of allowing one to realize that all the teachings are without contradiction? What is meant here are all of the non contradictory utterances of the Buddha which refer to the four noble truths.

And to develop this first greatness, the greatness of seeing all the teachings as non contradictory, the four categories of teachings of the Buddha, which are the sutras of the lower vehicle, the sutras of the greater vehicle, the Vinaya and tantra or Mantra, are all to be seen as non contradictory. Even though there are superficial differences or discordances between them, they are all not inappropriate as means of training for one person trying to progress from the stage of a being who has not entered the path all the way to the state of full enlightenment. To repeat the example which Geshela gave formerly of someone who is afflicted with a very high fever and who consults a doctor, or the patient has very high fever, the doctor will forbid him from consuming either meat and alcohol which will increase the heat element in the body. However, as soon as a fever has abated because in turn the wind element lung increases in the body, the same doctor will instruct the same patient to now take both meat and alcohol. In both cases, while the advice is contradictory, the goal is the same.

Now to show how this example applies to the practice of the beings of the three scope and of tantra, initially, one trains as a being of the small scope in the teachings on death and impermanence, on the suffering of the lower realms, and on refuge. Once this is stable, that same person who had trained in those trainings then trains in the teachings on the Four Noble Truths, the trainings and so forth. When that is stable, that same person in turn trains in the practices of the great vehicle and the six perfections. When that is stable, that same person engages in the tantric vehicle. And this is therefore the summarized presentation of the greatness of the dharma in that it shows all the teachings to be non contradictory.

Reflect on this and Geshela will ask us questions later on. And therefore, what is meant here by this greatness of the teachings in as much as they show the teachings to be non contradictory, leads into the greatness of seeing all the scriptures as direct instructions. What is meant here is that when we ourselves read a text on Lamrim or the graduated stages of the path, The words themselves become, if you will forgive us the expression, one’s teachers. One can say that the words give rise to the wisdom arisen from hearing within one’s mind stream. It is very important here that this greatness of the teachings in being non contradictory is not something we study in the abstract and apply to other persons who are studying these topics.

It has to be something which impacts and connects with our own mind. So that when we study the teachings, we also see the teachings as non contradictory. What is the broad meaning of the second greatness of the dharma? The greatness of allowing all the teachings to arise or to dawn as oral instructions. It means that whatever the dharma text we are studying, whether it is sūtra or tantra, the very single letter na which is one of the letters of the Tibetan alphabet is in and of itself seen already as an instruction to be put in practice.

And to enter in greater detail in the second greatness of the dharma, which is a greatness of allowing all the scriptures to arise as oral instructions. What is meant by this is that all of the teachings from the very beginning of the path, which is relying on the spiritual teacher or the virtuous friend, all the way up to the culmination of the path, which is the union of śamatha or calm abiding and insight or vipassana. All of these teachings are meant as teachings which are to be meditated upon using a union of analytical and concentration meditation. Now in some cases, such as relying on the spiritual teacher, there is mainly analytical meditation and little concentration meditation. Whether one is engaging in meditating on relying on the teachers who thought or through action.

In other cases, there is a combination of the two. How does one practice this? It means that whatever topic one is studying apart from the lamrim is fused or poured into the Lamrim. If, for instance, one is studying topics related to the great vehicle, such as the presentation of the generation of bodhichitta in Maitreya’s Abhisamayālamkāra, then these teachings are injected into the Lamrim practices of the being of great scope. On the other hand, if one is studying in the context of the fifth topic of Paramita, the teachings of the 12 links of interdependent origination or on the four noble truths, these are injected within the lamrim teachings of the practice of the being of middling scope.

Likewise, if one is teach studying teachings on refuge which are injected within the context of the practice of the being of small scope. Now to give an example of taking all the teachings as oral instructions, let us imagine preparing a meal. There is, to prepare a meal, a series of requisites. We need rice. We may need wheat.

We need condiments, spices. We need meat and so forth. We cannot prepare a meal with rice alone. And therefore, in the same way as to prepare a meal, need rice, wheat, oil, spices, meat, and so forth. Likewise, when we engage in practice, we take teachings from one context.

This may be the rice, and we inject them in their appropriate place within the lamrim. Then we take teachings from another context, and we inject them again in their appropriate place within the Lam Rim proceeding in this way. So this is a summarized presentation of the two greatnesses which Geshela had covered last time. The greatness of seeing all the teachings as non contradictory and the greatness of all the teachings dawning as instructions for practice. And the third greatness which we will cover today is on page 673 of the outline.

Page 67 of the body of your text. The greatness of allowing you to easily discover, you should correct your translation. It’s not the true thinking, it’s the intent of the victorious one. So this greatness is what we will cover at present, but Geshela would like to mention that the two previous greatnesses he explained, the non contradictoryness of the teachings and all teachings dawning as all instructions are actually wisdoms arisen from hearing. So in Geshela’s opinion, the two first greatnesses are set within the category of the wisdom arisen from hearing.

There are three categories of wisdom. The wisdom arisen from hearing, from thinking and from meditating. These two first greatnesses fall within the category of the wisdom arisen from hearing. The greatness we are covering at present, which is the greatness of allowing all the scriptures. The greatness of allowing one to easily discover the intent of the victorious one.

This is probably within the category of the wisdom arisen from thinking. And the two lineages which have been transmitted from the Buddha downwards are respectively the lineages of method which passed from the Buddha downwards via Maitreya to Asaṇga, Sailingpa, all the way to Atisha himself. Whereas the wisdom lineage or the lineage of the profound passed from the Buddha to Nāgārjuna, Ariadeva, then Candrakīrti, eventually Vidyakokila, the elder, and from him to, Atisha as well. So these two lineages were separate up to Atisha’s time. It is within Atisha that these two lineages become fused and inseparable.

And even if we are able to practice correctly the Lamrim tradition which is forwarded from Atisha downwards, integrating within it the teachings on the five fundamental treatises which Geshela explained last time. Nonetheless, it remains very difficult for us to attain the state of a fully enlightened being endowed with the four bodies. And therefore, Paul, it is possible to understand the ultimate intent of the Buddha relying on these great treatises, the five great treatises and so forth. Nonetheless, it is far from easy. Relying on the LUM rim on the other hand makes it much easier.

And in this respect, one could give the example of traveling to Melbourne. If we have to travel to Melbourne, we could indeed walk all the way to Melbourne, but it would take an awful long time. We could just hop on the plane and it would take less than one hour. So the plane in this respect is a metaphor for the Lamrim, which enables us to easily understand the intent of the victorious one. And regarding this third greatness, which is explained on page 67 of your English text, It is said that Je Tsongkhapa, when he mentioned it in his Lamrim Chenmo, in the great treatise on the path, did not develop or expound on it.

Pabongka Rinpoche says that his precious protector, by which he probably means his root teacher, Dagpo Rinpoche, told him that this was none other than the three principles of the path. So, indeed, it is possible to practice the Buddhist teachings through relying on the five great treatises which Geshela explained last time. It is much more straightforward to practice them by relying on the summarized instructions of the Lamrim. And in the stance, the three principles of the path of Je Tsongkhapa in which he says, for so long as the appearances which are incontrovertible interdependence and that emptiness which is bereft of assertions appear as different for so long the intent of the victorious one, in other words of the Buddha, has not been realized.

In this stanza, what Je Tsongkhapa is saying is that as long as we see conventional and ultimate truths as different, we have not understood the intent of the Muni, of the Buddha. However, as soon as we have seen them as identical, we have understood his intent and by extension or by implication, Je Tsongkhapa says that the actual intent of the Buddha is the teaching of the authentic view, the teaching of emptiness. And this is why the teachings on renunciation and on bodhichitta are ancillary teachings to the teachings on the view. This is formulated quite clearly in the opening stanza of Tsongkhapa’s three principles of the path in which he says, as much as I can, I shall explain that essence, the meaning of the essence of the teachings of all of the victorious ones, the path which is praised by all of the sons of the holy conquerors, and that gateway to liberation for the fortunate ones? The first verse here, the meaning of the essence, which is taught by all the victorious ones refers to renunciation or definite emergence.

The second verse, the path which is praised by all the scions of the holy conquerors refers to bodhichitta. And the third verse, that gateway to liberation for the fortunate ones refers to emptiness, the view of emptiness. And therefore, in the stanza which Geshela had quoted previously from the three principles of the path, the first verse, that incontrovertible interdependence which is appearance refers to conventional existence, or the understanding of emptiness bereft of assertions refers to ultimate existence. When it is said that for so long as these two appear as different, for that long the intent of the conqueror is not realized. What is meant is that both conventional existence and ultimate existence must be understood as one.

So all this stanza is difficult. Nonetheless, if we think about it, we will increase our understanding. So this stanza of these three principles of the path probably ushers the prasanika madhyamika view, it probably cannot be understood in terms of the Chitamatra view or the lower views. So, if we were to take the example of Geshela’s table for instance and analyze its mode of perception, all it is true that the table and phenomena in general appear as inherently established from their own side. Nonetheless, it cannot be said that they are realized actually as inherently established.

And the presentation of the two truths amounts to nothing else than asserting that more phenomena do indeed appear as if they were inherently or truly established, they are not in the slightest inherently or truly established. So for all the schools of tenets below the Prāsaṇgika school, the non inherent existence of Geshela’s table necessarily entails its non existence, I. It cannot exist if it is non inherently existent. For the Prāsaṇgika school, that is not the case. Its non-inherent existence merely implies that it is a conventionally existing phenomena, which can perform the functions of supporting Geshela’s books, his bell, and his tea cup.

So there’s a very pretty example, Geshela, I would like to give to the ladies in the audience, which is when we look at our face in a mirror to see how beautiful we are, then the reflection of the face in the mirror is not the face. And it’s not being the face refers to the ultimate existence of phenomena. However, on the basis of the reflection in the mirror, we can touch our makeup up. And then this obviously is a conventional existence of phenomena. And therefore, this example is given by those leaders of Mādhyamika thought in history, Nāgārjuna, Āryadeva and their successors who point out that whole, the nonexistence of the face in the mirror, when one looks at one’s reflection in a mirror, points out the features of ultimate existence.

Nonetheless, the fact that the reflection of one’s face in the mirror is able to function to enable us to check for faults or warts on one’s face points out to conventional existence. And therefore what is meant in the context of outline 2.3, the greatest of allowing one to readily or to easily discover the intent of the conquerors, is that through understanding that the actual intent of all of the five treatises, which are the treatises on Paramita, on Mādhyamika, on Abidharma, on Vinaya and on Pramāna, is none other than teaching the practices of the beings of the three scopes, the small, middling and great scope, as well as teaching the three principles of the path, one can understand thereby the true intent of all the teachings of the conquerors. And therefore as Geshela had previously explained within the four greatnesses of the dharma, the two first greatnesses, The greatness of understanding all the teachings as non contradictory, the greatness of all teachings dawning as oral instructions for practice are to be categorized within the wisdom arisen from hearing. Or the third greatness, the greatness of easily understanding the intent of all the conquerors is to be understood as categorized within the wisdom arisen from thinking.

The uncommon feature of the wisdom arisen from thinking as opposed to the wisdom arisen from hearing is that the wisdom arisen from thinking entails ascertainment by a valid cognizer, which is not the case for the wisdom arisen from hearing. So in the same way, to give an example, if we want to find lost jewels in the floor or on the floor of the ocean, we initially need a boat to get there. Otherwise, we risk to lose our lives. And therefore, to analyze more carefully this example, this metaphor for the greatness of allowing one to easily discover the intent of the conquerors, The vessel which allows one to travel on the ocean is none other than the Lamrim or the graduated stages of the path. One is impelled to engage on this vessel through faith in the spiritual teacher who is skillful in means in guiding the vessel.

The ocean itself is the ocean of Buddhist scriptures. Whereas the jewel at the bottom of the ocean is none other than the ultimate intent of the conquerors, which is these three principles of the path. So this is an old fashioned example which is no longer very convincing since nobody believes in jewels at the bottom of the ocean. So Geshela would like to challenge you. What example, modern example do you propose?

Give us a small concise example, yes. Can you have another one? Yes. Give an example. Nothing else.

You must really value your pictures. And this weekend, during the long October weekend, Geshela will be teaching the eight verses of mind training of the great Kadampa Geshe, Geshe Langri Tangpa, on the instruction of Khensur Rinpoche. His Holiness the Dalai Lama has taught this text many times and has said it is as beneficial for him as Śāntideva’s Bodhisattvacharyavatara. Since the text is translated in English and has only eight verses, Geshela would like to ask us to memorize it in English and he himself will teach on this basis. Then when we recite it, we will derive great benefit.

So we will stop here for today and next time we’ll cover the last and final greatness of the Lamrim. And Gesheel I would like to ask you how you identify or how you define the first greatness, the greatness of all the teachings being non contradictory. How do you define or characterize the first greatness? The greatness of all the teachings being non contradictory. Yes.

So to start with old phenomena not impermanent, do understand that? For instance, space is not impermanent. It is permanent. Okay. Geshela is going to have to debate you that we don’t get dizzy.

This time is going. The next question, yes. So, yes, that’s the example indeed. What would be the meaning of the example? Geshela will take one question on today’s topic, which is the third greatness of the Lamrim, easily understanding the intent of the conquerors.

So if we take this threefold division of wisdom arisen from thinking, hearing, thinking and meditating, it seems difficult to say that in the context of the wisdom arisen from hearing, there is no thinking at all. The boundary between the wisdom arisen from hearing and the wisdom arisen from thinking is the generation of a valid cognizer which realizes what one has heard. At that point, the wisdom arisen from thinking arises. Now, for the wisdom arisen from hearing, what it is, is to again and again hearing teachings, the meaning of the teachings becomes ever more familiar to the mind and at a certain point a valid or a prime cognizer arises. At this point, one shifts orders of magnitude and the wisdom arisen from thinking has arisen.

No. Conventional truths and ultimate truths are opposite and completely contradictory. However, both can be posited on the basis of the same object. One can, for instance, posit the conventional truth of Gescheler’s table and the ultimate truth of Gescheler’s table on the basis of one and the same object, yet they are opposite. So the meaning of that stanza is that for the conventional truth, which is the appearance of interdependence and the ultimate truth, which is an emptiness, is bereft of assertions are contradictory.

Nonetheless, they can be posited on the basis of one and the same object. So it’s a very good sign the rain has stopped.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
tantra gyü (Tib)
Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Is it right to say there is no thinking at all in the wisdom arisen from hearing?

The boundary between the wisdom arisen from hearing and the wisdom arisen from thinking is the generation of a valid cognizer that realizes what one has heard. At that point the wisdom arisen from thinking arises. The wisdom arisen from hearing comes about by hearing teachings again and again, so that their meaning becomes ever more familiar to the mind. At a certain point a valid or prime cognizer arises. At this point one shifts orders of magnitude, and the wisdom arisen from thinking has arisen.

Scroll to Top