Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2012-04-21 – KR.mp3
UUID: 2efc5c58-c2a6-4011-885c-85da9ff8156d
Teacher: Ilia Durovic
Collection: Tenets (Ilia Durovic)
Date: 2012-04-21
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 21m
Words: 9,615
Yeah. This is very hot. Up to you. Is it okay? No.
No. I’m fine. Very fine. It is very hot. So moving onwards with our topic, turning point in the history of Christianity occurs around 03/25 when Christianity becomes the state religion of the Western Roman Empire under the aegis of Emperor Constantine.
At this point, it becomes necessary to actually formalize Christianity to define what this at times contradictory system of tenets is and this is done by a series of conclaves, the foremost of which is the Nicene Conclave in 03/21 in which the first of the so called creeds is elaborated. This is to this day the statement every Christian attending liturgy in the Eastern Orthodox Church and mass in the Roman Catholic Church must recite during mass. A person who cannot recite this in faith is not a Christian. So from a Buddhist standpoint, we would call this a system of tenets. And this system of tenets includes key elements, some of which are related to the trinity.
This was the main topic of the debates during the two first Ecumenical Councils of Nicea and Constantinople in which Jesus is defined as the son of the second, there was a second person of the trinity, the first person of the trinity being the father. This son is not created. He is not, in other words, a creature. He is generated within all eternity and is of the same nature as the Father. The main problem within Trinitarian theology, which is a very specific problem to Christianity, is that whereas within Judaism and Islam, God is one and this radical oneness is simply asserted.
The New Testament explicitly speaks of three persons within God. The so called Father, Son and the Holy Ghost. These are spoken about in the Gospels themselves and therefore their actual relationship within the God head has to be addressed and this was the focus of the two first ecumenical councils. The main heresy, because this is really the name, heresy in Greek means actually a different opinion, haerezia. The main heresy the two first councils were countering was the so called Arian heresy which arose in Alexandria and which asserted that Jesus was a creature.
In other words, Jesus the Christ was a human being like us. Then this, we will see a little bit later, prevented any true mediation of God and of his creatures through the person of Jesus. And it is to counter this that the Nicene Creed asserts that Jesus is begotten, in other words, generated by the Father before all worlds, in other words, outside of time and specifically is not made, being of one substance with the Father. Yet he is fully man, he rose again, in other words he was resurrected and the Nicene Creed also honors the Holy Spirit who within the dynamic of the Trinity proceeds from the Father. A true Christian acknowledges only one baptism for the remission of sins.
In other words, there is no gateway to the remission of sins apart from baptism. For one who recites such a creed sincerely, there is no other gateway to salvation. Our teachings for one such would not be a gateway to salvation and assert the physical resurrection of the dead. Now the Greek is very explicit more so than the English. He who is born solely out of the father was he born.
The son, in other words, the second person of the trinity, arises out of the father in eternity. He is he is generated he is not created of one nature with the father. And we will see in these charts on Christian Trinitarianism what precisely is understood by this? This is an ancient symbol of the trinity, the three circulars intersecting. So what is the Christian vision of the relation between God and creation and the relation between the three persons within God.
The problem which Christianity addresses is a problem all monotheisms address. How do we account for mediation between eternity and time? Eternity is the realm of God. Time is the realm of creatures. Eternity is the realm of the creator.
Time is the realm of the creatures within the world. If there is no communication, God is irrelevant to man. This is a fundamental problem for Judaism and Islam. God is radically transcendent, radically other from creation. When all is said and done, why should human beings care about God at all?
He is totally alien. If there is communication, how can there be communication? Christianity postulates one person, Jesus, who has both natures. The nature of God and the nature of creation. In other words, Jesus according to the Council of Carthagon in April is both totally divine and at the same time totally human in one person.
Because he subsumes both the divine and the human nature, his existence is sufficient to allow a mediation between eternity and time. Therefore, for a Christian access to eternity is access to this one person who has within him both natures. Faith, this is the green arrow here, rising from creation in this one person is sufficient to give access to the Godhead. It is not only sufficient, it is necessary. There is no other access because there is no way to bridge this gap apart from this one person who voluntarily abased himself into creation.
Now from the standpoint of the Godhead, God himself, according to the New Testament includes three persons, the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost. The Gospels clearly indicate that the Son is generated by the Father out of time in eternity. The Holy Ghost is said to proceed. It’s another verb in Greek from the Father again in all eternity and there is a debate to the present day between the Roman Catholic and the Eastern Orthodox Church regarding the relation between the Son and the Holy Ghost. The Orthodox Church considers that this is the sole relation there is.
The Father giving rise to the Son and the Holy Ghost proceeding from the Father. The Roman Catholic Church asserts that the Holy Ghost proceeds also from the Son. This is the root of the schism of ten fifty four. Be it this as it may, it is the person of the son which is of one nature with all the other persons which manifests within time. It is an extraordinary model.
I think in terms of sophistication, the Christian reading of the incarnation is the most sophisticated account which can be given of a monotheism, a radical monotheism, which is meaningful for man. The basic problem with all radical monotheisms is that God becomes fundamentally irrelevant precisely because He is so alien, He is so removed from man. And it is this model which is alluded to in the Kenotic Hymn of the Philippians, Philippians two we talked about, in which Paul says, and the son abased himself literally into matter to be glorified in the resurrection after his death on the cross. Numerous debates arose within Christianity about key elements of the revelation specifically what aspect of God could be communed with. There is a fundamental difference in this respect between the Western traditions and the Eastern Orthodox traditions, which carries through into a difference between western and eastern spiritualities.
The western Christian traditions which is both Roman Catholicism and the Protestant traditions consider and this is in truth opposed to the spirit of radical monotheism, that it is possible to experience the essence of God, the nature of God, and that this is what happened on Mount Tabor when Christ was transfigured. On Mount Tabor, Christ manifested surrounded by light with Elias and Peter, Elias and Moses on either side. I think it was Peter, James and John saw him and the question which arose is what precisely did Peter, James and John see when they saw this light surrounding Christ? Did they see the nature of God? In which case the nature of God can be seen by a creature?
Or did they see something else? Thomas Aquinas, and we will talk about him in a couple minutes, asserts that they saw the essence of God. All the Eastern Orthodox Church Fathers assert that the essence of God which is none other than the Father is unknowable. It is apophatic. The Son is communicated freely to man but what the disciples saw on Mount Tabor are the energies of God.
These are manifestations of God which are accessible to man. This debate endures to the present day. And this leads us to Thomas Aquinas and his understanding of the Godhead which is one which is with us to the present day. As you probably know, Thomas Aquinas was the greatest church father of the middle ages and perhaps one of the two greatest Christian thinkers of all time with Augustine. Now for Aquinas, it is possible to see the essence of God.
It is actually possible for the blessed after death to experience directly the totality essence of God. You can see how this position to which Aquinas arrived largely because of his Aristotelian leanings is at odds with the very inner core of the Semitic monotheisms. This is something which is very, very alien to the Semitic monotheisms and which is in many respects profoundly Greek. And then Aquinas has to qualify this position and say that although God can be seen, in other words experienced, he cannot be understood by a creature, even one of the blessed. Aquinas formulated the famous proofs of the existence of God which are relevant to us since they are used nowadays even by the evangelicals and the Roman Catholics.
So we have to be aware of them. Of these proofs, one especially is central. We have five proofs. God as prime mover, as the first efficient cause, the so called argument from contingency, the argument from degree and the teleological argument. And I will perhaps cover them very briefly and focus on the last one since we are running a bit short of time.
The argument of the prime mover is none other than the assertion that an initial source of impetus is necessary for the universe. The universe must have received this initial source of impetus. This initial source of impetus is postulated to be God. This is an argument which would cut little or no ice nowadays. The second argument is the so called first efficient cause.
The efficient cause for Aristotle is the maker. We would say in Buddhist terms the cooperative condition. There has to be a first maker. The universe cannot have arisen from nothing. This is a much stronger argument already.
It is one which is used nowadays. You do hear it. The third argument from contingency is an extremely subtle argument. It makes a lot of sense within Aristotelian philosophy. Nowadays, I am not sure it would.
In a nutshell, Aquinas is saying that if there had not been an initial efficient cause, then it would have been impossible for things not to remain eternally in non existence. There has to have been an initial existent to impel things into existence and this initial existence we call God. The fourth argument is a platonic argument. It basically asserts that to be able to call beings in the here and now good, beautiful, deep, meaningful, we need that an ideal of beauty, depth and meaningfulness exist. This ideal of beauty, depth and meaningfulness is postulated as God.
This argument only is convincing if you accept the reality of ideas. The fifth argument however remains a very powerful argument in favor of the existence of God. It is used by all of the monotheisms, Judaism, Christianity and Islam, the so called teleological argument or the argument from design. Aquinas says, we see that things which lack intelligence such as natural bodies, in other words physical phenomena, act for an end and this is evident and they’re acting always in the same way. In other words, natural laws exist.
The existence of natural laws cannot be fortuitous. One would expect things to move at random and there to be no laws unless an intelligent being existed by whom all natural things are directed to their end and this being we call God. So we would say in contemporary terms that the non randomness of the universe is proof of the existence of an intent of a creator. The fact that the universe follows mathematical laws and let us say that the force of attraction between two solids is formulated as G m one m two over the square of the distance and that this is a universal law is sufficient proof of the existence of God because had there not been a creating intent, the universe could not be mathematical. This is a powerful argument and it is an argument which is reformulated by the great British theologian, William Paley, who formulated as a famous clockmaker argument.
Suppose I had found a watch upon the ground and it should be inquired how the watch happened to be in that place. I should hardly think to say the the watch might have always been there. And Paley then adds, there must have existed at some time and at some place or other an artificer or artificers, in other words, a maker who formed the watch for the purpose we find it actually to answer, who completed its construction and designed its use. In other words, the existence of a complex mechanism such as a watch entails necessary existence of a factor, a maker of the mechanism. The universe is the most complex mechanism there is.
It follows mathematical laws. Therefore, there is necessarily an author of the universe. The argument is very strong until we analyze it. When we analyze it, what we realize is that the argument does not prove the existence of a maker, the argument proves pre existing intent or pre existing information. So the argument, the so called teleological argument can be invoked indeed by the monotheists and it is, it can just as well be invoked by all the Indian traditions.
The Buddhist and the Hindu traditions which say that such information, such pre existing structure and information is none other than karma and causality. The argument is very problematical for strong materialists. The classical rejoinder to this argument is the infinite number of chimpanzees typing on an infinite number of typewriters over infinite time the works of Shakespeare. So if you have an infinite number of chimps given infinite time typing at random on a typewriter, somewhere down the line the total works of Shakespeare will have been typed. This is the only rejoinder there is really to the teleological argument from the standpoint of strong materialists.
It’s an extremely weak rejoinder because it presupposes what? An infinite number of chimps and an infinite number of time. Now any model of the universe we have does not presuppose an infinite number of particles, let alone an infinite number of cells, and does not suppose an infinite number of time. All the models we have at present, even the cyclical models suppose a finite amount of time from the Big Bang onwards. Then it is very difficult to account for structure in the materialist models.
And for this reason, a variant of the teleological argument is invoked to the present day. Michael Behe is one of the leading exponents of the so called argument of irreducible complexity. He’s an American biochemist, a brilliant man by all accounts, who points out the existence in biology of mechanisms, highly complex mechanisms which cannot be reduced to their parts without the mechanism collapsing and sees this as a very strong critique of the theory of evolution. Then the main critiques addressed to Behe have been that the examples of irreducible complexity which he has given have generally been reducible. But it is a somewhat weak rejoinder because the example Behe never invokes which I think is a very strong example is the example of messenger RNA, the precursor of DNA.
Then if you take messenger RNA, messenger RNA encrypts proteins through encrypting the amino acids which constitute the proteins. It is a code. It is a code which contains information coded in the sequence of adenine, guanine, cytosine and timine. How such a code can arise at random is very difficult to understand. Very difficult.
And I personally find the argument of infinite monkeys hamming away with infinite hammers at DNA molecules very unconvincing. So what I would say is that the teleological argument proves clearly one thing. If structure exists we must suppose there has been either pre existing structure or intent which is up to us to determine. Structure exists, this is a given. We have biological structure in the case of the cell.
The cell is basically built around information and we have physical structure, the physical laws. The existence of these laws, their regularity is sufficient to raise with us the issue of intent or pre existing structure. Then for regular systematic laws to arise out of randomness is a very improbable assertion. We now have to address the issue of the dilemmas of revealed monotheisms. In other words, the dilemmas of all the Abrahamic traditions, Judaism, Christianity and Islam.
There are a number of core issues which are problematical for monotheisms. The first is theodicy. It is the explanation of evil. How in a universe created by an almighty, omnipotent and all good God can evil exist? This is a problem which subsists to the present day.
How can we account for the tsunami which wiped out some 300,000 lives seven years ago if the world is a creation of an all good omnipotent and omniscient creator. It has to be accounted for. Then accounting for a first cause has historically been a problem for the monotheisms. What is the state of the first cause before causation, before creation? As we said, accounting for communication between the creature and the creator is a Lojong problem for all monotheisms.
Judaism and Islam do not address it. Christianity does through the person of Christ in which both natures, the nature of the creator and that of the creature, the human nature, are equally present. Then this raises specific problems for Christianity. How can one person Jesus be at the same time totally divine and totally human apart from sin as says the Council of Cathedral. And the final, I would say, well it’s perhaps not a nice thing to say, but the final nail in the coffin for certain monotheisms is accounting for discrepancies between revealed scriptures and reality.
This has I think been the bane of Christianity whose cosmological model simply collapsed in the face of modern scientific discovery. Specifically the geocentric model in which the earth was at the center of the universe. Having said this, I think the revealed monotheisms have been overall forces for tremendous good in human history. These are simple traditions, easily accessible. They all teach powerful ethical traditions, all enable the practitioner to develop a form or a degree of love and empathy.
Their weaknesses arise from the fact that many of them are culture bound and the de emphasis on the use of reasoning which has become the main feature of our civilization. This leads us to the second category of religious traditions we will cover today, the Indian religious traditions. This is a picture, a statue of Buddha Shakyamuni in his meditation under the Bodhi tree when Buddha took the vow to meditate until he found the answers to his question irrespective of the physical hardship. If we try to study the Indian traditions, we find that broadly speaking they can be divided into three groups. The so called pre Gangetic traditions, the traditions of ancient India from approximately 2,000 to 800 BC, the Gangetic traditions and the later traditions.
Traditions. We will consider only the two first groups. The pre Gangetic traditions include Vedic religion which we will talk about today. The religion which is taught in the four Vedas and the Gangetic traditions which include the Brahmanas, which are the commentaries on the Vedas, the famous Upanishads, the great mystical texts of ancient India and the so called darshanas or views. These correspond almost exactly to our schools of philosophy.
There are six orthodox darshanas. These are the views which accept the authority of the Vedas and there are three unorthodox darshanas which do not accept the revelation of the Vedas, they are Buddhism, the Jain tradition, and the Indian materialist tradition, the lokaryatas. For ourselves, in as much as we are interested in Buddhism, it is extremely important to understand the religious and cultural context within which Buddhism arises, which is radically different from that within which our religious traditions arose. And that is why we will cover briefly Indian religious traditions. Vedic religiosity is one of the most, perhaps the most ancient stream of religious thought in the history of humanity.
And in many respects, one of the most beautiful. It is a highly developed form of animism which eventually evolves into a pantheism and is formulated through a series of hymns which are collected in the four Vedas, the Rig Veda, the Yajur Veda, the Sama Veda and the Atarva Veda, which were composed, which were actually uttered some forty centuries ago in Sanskrit. The core teaching of the Vedas is universal law known as ritta. Ritta is actually the cycle of the planets, the regular cycle of the planets, with the sun, of the stars and the gods and the Vedas are seen as the guardians of harmony. Ritta over time evolves and in later Indian thought becomes dharma.
Dharma is cosmic law in ancient in later Indian thought as ritta is cosmic law two thousand years before Jesus Christ. The major Vedic gods are Varuna who is god of the sky, Mitra who is god of the morning sky, Surya, Indra, Soma, and Vishwakarman. Vedism is not a monotheism in the full sense of the term. It has been called a henotheism. In other words, when the Vedic hymns praise a god, they praise him alone, but the next Vedic hymn may praise another god.
But each god when he is addressed is unique. It’s a very convenient state of affairs, frankly. It can be seen as a precursor to monotheism. The function of the gods is to guard universal harmony and the function of man is to propitiate the gods through sacrifice. So we are in this respect in a mental universe which is not that different from that of the early Semitic monotheisms.
The function of sacrifice in the Vedas is similar to the function of sacrifice in the Old Testament. Sacrifice maintains universal harmony and man through his misbehavior, through displeasing the gods, causes universal disharmony. There is however a clear evolution in the Vedic conceptions of the Godhead. In the early Vedas, we have pure nature worship, the worship of thunder, of the sun Surya, the worship of Varuna and so forth. This evolves into an ethical stage in which the main god worshipped is Varuna who rewards the good and punishes the evil.
Varuna evolves into Indra who is the Vedic god of victory corresponding exactly to the Greek Zeus and the Roman Jupiter. This is the god of the Aryan tribes descending into the plains of India and overcoming the Dravidians. And Indra in turn leads to Prajapati, the foremost being, and into the abstract god of later Hinduism, Brahman, who is the ground of being. Brahman corresponds almost exactly to Paul Tilich’s vision of the ground of being in his systematic theology. And I have included one of the most beautiful hymns of creation from the Rigveda, the Nasadiyah hymn.
Those of you who know the Old Testament can see how similar it is to the account of creation in the Old Testament. With one major difference, the Rishi, the seer who composed the Nasadiyya says at the end of the Nasadiyya that he himself does not know whether this is actually what happened or not, nor do the gods. What should be said is that the Vedic hymns were composed overwhelmingly in a state of intoxication. The Rishis systematically used soma. We’re not quite sure what Soma is but it was a hallucinogenic plant from Northern India.
It became a god actually and it was used in a ritual context to inspire the poets. The Vedic Rishis are poets, seers, and philosophers, all wrapped in one. And as we said, the Vedas include four Vedas, the Rig Veda, the foremost Veda, the Yajur and Sama Veda which include ritual, revelation and the Atarva Veda, the latest Veda which includes specific rites and is very magical in its import. Each Veda is constituted of three components. The hymns or the mantras.
Mantras here mean hymns. It doesn’t have the meaning of mantras in later Hinduism. The which are rituals, the sacrificial rituals only for householders. In other words, you have to be married to perform the to the present day. A Brahmin who is not married cannot perform sacrifice in India.
And the Upanishads which are included by traditional Indian religiosity within the Vedas, they are the meditations and the philosophies generally developed within the forest milieu. What is unique about the Vedas is that when I said the Vedas were composed, it was somewhat inaccurate. The Vedas were sung. They were not written down for more than two thousand years. They were transmitted from the mouth to the ear orally for twenty centuries.
To my knowledge this is the longest oral transmission in human history. And to this day the Vedas are memorized by young Brahmins like this young boy who is blindfolded and reciting the Vedas from memory. The accuracy of the recitation of the Vedas is phenomenal. To give you an idea of the volume, we have approximately 10 books, mandalas, and 1,000 hymns in the Rig Veda alone. There are four such Vedas.
All four Vedas have to be memorized by a Brahmin and they were transmitted orally syllable by syllable for twenty centuries, approximately from fourteen hundred BC to the Gupta Dulisty May. Now when the British came to India, they disbelieved this notion that the Vedas had been transmitted orally for two thousand years. There’s nothing in the West which begins to compare to this. And they tested the recitation of the Vedas of Brahmins from the Extreme South of India, Kerala, and that of the North of India, Kashmir. They found that there was not one syllable of difference.
And the question which arises is how is it possible to transmit the equivalent of thousands of pages, I used to have them, it is a collection of this size approximately, over 20 centuries without ever writing it down and it is the famous Padapata techniques. The techniques of memorization of the Vedas which has led to the phenomenal intellect of the Brahmin class to the present day. When the Vedas are memorized, they are memorized as follows by the young child. The first word and the second word, the second and the first, The first, the second, the second, the third, the third, the second. This is the simplest Pada Pada memorization.
Then we have flag recitation, Vajapada. You start with the first and the second word at the beginning of the text and you go to the end of the text and you memorize the last word, word n and word n minus one. Then you go back to the beginning and you memorize word two and three. Then you memorize word n minus three and n minus two until eventually you meet. The two streams of memorization meet.
The third, form of recitation which is the most difficult is Ganapatha. In this form of recitation you memorize word one word two, two one, one two three, three two one, one two three, two three, three two, two three four, four three two, two three four and you move onwards. What you have is the usage of combinatorics for memorization. It is not surprising with this type of training that the Brahmin class in India has shown extraordinary aptitude for mathematics and that nowadays, companies worldwide employ computer programmers who are overwhelmingly Brahmins, in India. And I was very surprised when I lived in India to see the computer programmers programming on notepads.
They don’t program on computers. They just write out code. It’s quite astonishing. I think this is a direct result of, these techniques of mental training. Now what are the fundamental features of Vedic religiosity?
The first is henotheism as we said. The second is realism. For the Vedas, the god, the world is real and it is god. In the Vedas, is no clear belief in reincarnation or in samsara. But there is an assertion of an afterlife in a body of light.
The Vedas are profoundly optimistic. A key element in the Vedas as we said is sacrifice which perpetuates cosmic order. They are naturalistic. These are some of the most beautiful poetry dedicated to nature you can read. I cannot encourage you too highly to read Rigveda.
It is translated in English. It’s listed in the bibliography and the Vedas do not know of a priestly caste. Each family head is a priest. There is a very powerful Vedic ethics which is rooted in reciprocity and generosity. So this is the substratum of all of the great philosophical and religious systems of ancient India.
And now we will start addressing some of the branches and specifically what I have chosen to call the Gangetic Nexus, The group of religions and systems of thought which arise around the Ganges in this very fertile area in the center of India and which include mainly the Upanishads. This is a picture of a very famous Indian Yogi, Tatwale Baba at the age of 80 just before his assassination actually. He had ceased to age from 35 onwards. Then this was confirmed by classmates of his who were interviewed who were a hoary old gentleman and who who didn’t know what to say to be frank with you. Who didn’t know what to say.
Tatwale Baba was a Punjabi from the same area of India as the Sikhs who are the cab drivers now in Adelaide. He left home at a very early age, traveled to Rishikesh and then in the mountains, in the foothills of the Himalayas as a Vedantin. He was a Vedantin engaged in meditation and obviously attained siddhi paranormal powers, to be able to stop the aging process. He is one of the typical Indian yogis who can be traced, whose model can be traced all the way back to the Upanishads. So the Upanishads of which we will talk, which form the inner core of the orthodox Darshanas in ancient India are 108 in number.
But there is only a couple Upanishads which are central. These are mainly Chandogya Upanishad, Brihadaryanaka Upanishad, Kena Upanishad, Taitiriya Upanishad, Aitarea Upanishad, And of these the two central ones are certainly the two first, Chandogya and Brihadaryanika. These are some of the greatest texts which are ever composed in ancient India. I have listed them in the bibliography. There are three excellent translations in English.
The oldest one by Max Muller, which is a very hieratic translation. The one I listed by Patrick Olovel which is a very readable translation and a translation by Wendy Doniger of Flaherty. I would strongly recommend that you read them. I think they are almost indispensable to understand the milieu in which Buddhism arises. Buddhism arises in the milieu of the Upanishads.
In other words, in the milieu of the forest thinkers of the Ganges of whom Buddha himself, Buddha Shakyamuni was one. Now what are the core teachers of the Upanishads? The core teachings of the Upanishads are rooted in the Vedas. So you have to keep what we said about the Vedas in the background and see the Upanishads as a philosophical development on the Vedas. The Upanishads think teach monotheism, but unlike semitic monotheism, their monotheism is panentheistic.
In other words, God is not radically other and separate from the world. God is the world and the world is God. Panentheism literally means the world is in God. The Upanishads teach union with Brahman who is God. They are pessimistic.
They view life as broadly speaking, unsatisfactory. They teach the internalization of sacrifice. As you remember we had said in the Vedas that sacrifice maintained universal order, ritta. The Upanishads teach that exterior sacrifice is subsidiary to the interior experience of sacrifice. For the first time they teach reincarnation, which was not explicitly taught, probably not taught at all in the Vedas.
They are broadly speaking indifferent to the Vedas as a revealed tradition. And the main preoccupation of the Upanishads is the nature of the soul, of the self. This is the religious tradition in which the nature of the Atman, the self, is addressed in its fullness. Now if we look at some of the passages from the Upanishads to get a sense of their import, we can first see this tremendous questioning which occurred in India, broadly speaking between the eighth and the fourth century BC. Whence are we born?
Where do we live? And whither do we go? O ye who know Brahman, tell us at whose command we abide here whether in pain or in pleasure. And one of the most famous prayers of the Upanishads, lead me from the unreal to the real, lead me from darkness to light, lead me from death immortality. This prayer clearly clearly formulates the respective relations of conventional and ultimate reality.
Conventional reality according to the Upanishads is unreal, it is darkness and it is death. Ultimate reality which for the Upanishads is God, is real, it is light and it is immortality. And this ultimate reality which the Upanishads teach is Brahman, the ground of being, God in his ultimate form. As again the Brihedarianika Upanishad says, how many gods are there really? He said.
Now answer us a further question. The Vedic gods Agni, Vayu, Aditya, Kala, thus some do meditate on him, some on another. Which of these is the best for us? And he said, these are but the chief manifestations of the highest, the immortal, the incorporeal Brahman. Brahman indeed is all this and a man may meditate on, worship or discard also those which are its manifestations.
This vision of theism is the dominant vision in India to the present day. All of the religions are merely cultured expressions of an underlying faith in a transcendental God which cannot be understood by reason and who is understood within the framework of the culture. For this reason, a Vedantic practitioner is open to the practice of Christianity, of Islam, of Judaism, of Hinduism because he sees in every one of them the expression constrained by space and time of belief in the Brahman. So I personally feel that the Indian understanding of monotheism is the highest understanding of monotheism which has ever occurred. The third feature of Upanishadic monotheism is panentheism.
In other words, that everything is within God. And as is said in the that from which these beings, in other words creation, are born, that in which when born they live, and that into which they enter at death, that is Brahman. Creation is born from God, creation is God, and after our extinction, we return to God. This is Upanishadic thought at its highest. The goal of all living creatures is union with the Godhead.
And this union with the Godhead is symbolized by that famous line in Chandogya Upanishad, That art thou. That is Brahman. Thou is Atman. You the Atman, the individual soul are God. You are Brahman.
As says, when they are all banished, those desires lurking in one’s heart, then a mortal becomes immortal and attains Brahman in this world, then man becomes God. The totality of the practice of Indian yogis to the present day is what is known in the Eastern Orthodox church as deities, deification. The wish to become one and inseparable from the Godhead from Brahman. This wish is an impossible wish in the Semitic monotheisms. So you can see the chasm between these two visions of theism.
The semitic monotheisms in which God is radically other communicates with creation by his own free will through a revelation in which man can only have faith. This is the only access man has to the Godhead. It is through faith in that revelation and the import of that revelation is the law, the commandments, or faith in a person for Christianity. On the one hand, and within the Indian tradition, the concept that there is nothing but God. That phenomena are perceived as not God through ignorance.
The moment this ignorance is eliminated, the Godness, the Brahmanness of all phenomena is realized and at that point, all is one. This is something we will talk about much more next time when we talk about Vedanta. Pessimism underlies much of the Upanishads. It is not the radical pessimism of Buddhism because the Upanishads are so suffused with this idea that God is present in everything, but the non god vision is profoundly disappointing for the Upanishads. And therefore Chandogya Upanishads says that does not age, does not age as this body grows old.
That is not killed when this body is slayed. That is the real thought of Brahman. Ennita contained all desires. You can see here the same four foes, the same fundamental sufferings of which the Buddha Shakyamuni spoke, birth, aging, sickness and death. Whether it is Upanishads, Buddha Shakyamuni, Jains, the focus on escape from a cyclic existence which is seen as the fortress of birth, aging, sickness and death is the same.
There is only disagreement regarding the means. Then as we said in the Upanishad, sacrifice is internalized. This is a offering sacrifice in India. In contemporary Hinduism only the can offer sacrifice, member of the caste. Yet for the Upanishads, this sacrifice is trivial.
It is an external sacrifice. What people normally call a sacrifice is in reality celibacy. It is a life by the life of celibacy that one finds him and here the Upanishads give a Sanskrit etymology of which is a relative in Sanskrit, the lower. What people call offering is celibacy, Brahmacharya. And what people call embracing the wilderness, in other words going in the forest to meditate, is once again Brahmacharya.
Brahmacharya or celibacy is the beginning of practice in the Upanishads as it is the beginning of practice in Buddhism because it is through celibacy that we counter the main desire normal beings have. Then the control of the senses, the control of food leads progressively to the elimination of coarse desires. At this point, it is possible to start to eliminate the more subtle afflictions of the mind. And the final teaching of the Upanishads are the teachings on reincarnation. So beautifully symbolized by the Noria of which Kensurin Potej spoke.
A man who is attached goes with his action. These are the teachings on karma. Action is a transition of karma. To that very place to which his mind and character cling, reaching the end of his action of whatever he has done in this world. From that world he returns back to this world, back to action.
From karma, back to karma, from life to life. All the Upanishads accept the revelation of the Vedas, this is a copy of the Rigveda. They consider it is subsidiary to the realization of true wisdom as I said in Chandogya Upanishad, I know the Rigveda, the Yajur, the Sama, but I do not know the self. This knowledge of the self of the Atman within each being which is the mirror of the ultimate Brahman is what leads to Moksha, to liberation in the Upanishads. And therefore the main preoccupation in the Upanishads is less with Brahman and more with the nature of the self or the Atman.
This is a statue of the great Indian yogi and thinker Patanjali, the author of the Patanjali Sutras, Yoga Sutras. So as I said in Chandogya Upanishad, the self, the Atman, this inner being, what we would call the soul, is free from evils, free from old age and death, free from sorrow, hunger and thirst. The self whose desires and intention are real, that is the self that you should try to discover. When someone discovers that self and perceives it, he obtains all the worlds and all his desires are fulfilled. And this self is experienced in dreamless sleep.
It is in dreamless sleep when man is basically not conscious that he is in contact with the core of his being according to the Upanishads. It is this self which is the main object of negation in Buddhism. So if we do not understand clearly what the teachings on the self in ancient India were, we will not understand what the Buddha was addressing. What was being negated? When we say that the selflessness of persons, the core selflessness of persons is the absence of a absence of a person which is which is permanent, one, and autonomous.
It is precisely a self which is permanent, one, and autonomous which the Upanishads teach. So all the milieu, the gangetic milieu is identical. While the goal is the same, the goal is moksha or liberation, the paths are radically opposite. The Upanishad and the Vedanta later teach the path of the realization of the self with the absolute Brahman. Buddhism in all of its schools teaches the path of no self.
And finally, the cosmologies of the Upanishads, the accounts of creation. There are four such accounts. The most ancient is that matter exists eternally independently of God. God fashions matter but he does not create it. This is a Sankhya account.
This goes back maybe 15 centuries, excuse me, 35 centuries to the fifteenth century BC. The second account which is very similar to the Judeo Christian account is that God creates a universe out of nothing and is then independent of God. This is Ramanuj’s vision. Ramanuj is one of the main Vedantic authors who criticizes Shankara and of whom we will talk next time. The third is that God creates the universe by transforming himself into it.
This is probably the main view of the Upanishads. It’s also Shankara’s view. Finally, God alone is real. There is no universe. These are the four visions of the world according to the Upanishads.
So you can see we have two religious universes which oppose each other. That of the semitic monotheisms born in the desert, fascinated by the absolute, struggling with means to formulate a communication between the absolute and the created, seeing man’s function as that of living within a revelation in which he can only have faith because it cannot be understood by reason and the lush gangetic milieu of the jungle in which God is one with the world. The debates which arise then are debates around the nature of the Atman. Does such an Atman exist as Upanishads teach it? Does the Buddha’s Brahman exist as Upanishads teach it?
Or in opposition, as Buddha Shakyamuni taught, is there no such thing as either Atman or Brahman? And if we attempt to contrast in detail these two traditions, we can see. Comparing revealed monotheisms, in other words the Abrahamic traditions and the Gangetic traditions. In the revealed monotheisms we have a radically transcendental God. In the Gangetic traditions he is immanent or pantheistic or in the case of Buddhadharma there is no God.
In the revealed monotheisms, God is personal. In the Gangetic traditions he is either impersonal or non existent. In the revealed monotheisms the world is real. It is worth doing something in the world. In the Gangetic traditions the world is unreal.
In the revealed monotheisms the world is good. In the Gangetic traditions the world is evil. In the revealed monotheisms history is linear. There is a creation and there is an end of history. Man progresses from this beginning to this end of history.
In the Gangetic traditionals, we have cyclical ahistoricity. The universe goes through phases of creation, phases of disintegration, phases of creation, phases of disintegration eternally. The revealed monotheisms are anthropocentric. Man is the center of creation. The Gangetic traditions are not anthropocentric.
Man is one of many other living beings all of which have Atman. Plants have Atman as well. In the revealed monotheism there is no past life, it is only one future life which is eternal, in happiness or in suffering. In the Gangetic traditions there are infinite past and future lives. Finally, the goal of the revealed monotheisms is salvation.
The goal of the Gangetic traditions is moksha or liberation. So you can see that there are profound differences between the revealed monotheisms and the Gangetic traditions. And that for us who come from this cultural milieu, to pass into a religion which belongs to this tradition demands first that we become fully aware of the monotheistic baggage we carry with us. Be able to leave it behind and be able to appropriate the cultural background of the Gangetic traditions before choosing one of the Gangetic traditions. It could be for instance the Vedanta.
It could be Buddhism. But it is very dangerous to change religions without being fully aware of this cultural background and without being able to turn one’s back against it. Now you might say that much here is irrelevant for a secular westerner. I would agree only in part because a real world, a good world, and linear history are the foundation of capitalism and of the market economy. If you are going to function as a member of a capitalist society efficiently, you have to subscribe to this Weltanschauk.
You cannot subscribe to this Weltanschauk. Can you be a sincere Buddhist and function in this world? It is very difficult. Can you be someone who functions in this world and practice fully in the Gangetic traditions? It is very difficult.
Take an issue for instance, take the issue of marriage. Marriage for the revealed monotheisms is a good thing. God created man and woman, He created them to marry. Marriage in the Gangetic tradition is a concession to the weakness of man. It is not a good thing.
Take money. Money in the revealed monotheism is a good thing. God gives money to those who have satisfied him. This is the vision of Calvinism. It is a vision which has built America.
This is completely alien to the Gangetic tradition. In the Gangetic tradition, the ideal of every practitioner is eventually to flee the world and to live in a state of meditation. So for us, it is critical to understand the baggage we carry with us and then the pure choices are very difficult. But if there are incompatibilities, we have to address them. Then I have said what I was hoping to say.
I hope it hasn’t been too dizzying and if you have any questions, I will do my best to answer them. Yes. Marriage in the Buddhist context is seen as a pragmatic institution. It is a practical arrangement for life in society when one cannot be a monk. The ideal of every sincere Buddhist practitioner is to be a monk.
For that matter, the ideal of every sincere Hindu is to be a sannyas. In the presentation of the four ages of man in Hinduism, the last age, when one is old, abandons one’s family and one goes and lives in the wilderness to gain realization before one dies. Now I can see with the body language that this is a big issue, but I think it is very important to be clear about this. The idea that the world is a good place to be is alien to Indian thought in general and to Buddhism in particular. It creates very big problems when westerners try to convert to Buddhism because for instance, they do not accept the noble truth of suffering.
A noble truth of suffering is an assertion which is rooted in the Gangetic traditions. The Upanishads would have probably endorsed it. But it’s totally alien to the monotheism. It’s not only alien, it is antithetical. If you believe God created the world, the world is not a place of suffering.
Does that go towards answering your question, Jasmine? Yes. I think one of the very big problems if you’re asking about relationships in the West has been the fantasy of relationships. So the Christian ideal of marriage is one which is very popular throughout the world because it lends weight to a fantasy of relationships. It is a God sanctioned relationship.
Hence, there is a sacrament of marriage which is rooted in the New Testament in Christ attending the marriage at can. I think it’s John three. However, in the Gangetic tradition, there is in the pure Gangetic tradition, there is no sacrament of marriage. So when young westerners become Buddhist, they get married, they often want a Buddhist marriage. Monks do not bless marriages.
Monks have nothing to do with the birth of children, blessing marriages. They can only intervene at the time of death. And this creates a lot of tension, a lot of tension. It creates tension because we are functioning here but the tradition we are trying to be part of is here. So we have to function in society then we have to earn money, we have to pay taxes, we may choose to be married, but it is very important for us to keep these ideals, if we want to be sincere Buddhists, these ideals of the forest within us.
Then these are not Christian ideas. The path of Christianity and the path of Buddhism are opposite. You see, for instance, when young westerners convert to Buddhism and, for instance, typically become ordained, instead of studying, they immediately engage in social work. It’s quite astonishing. Monks and nuns engaging in social work on a very large scale.
In other words, being ordained as Buddhist monks and nuns and behaving as Christian monks and nuns. This is not the Buddhist path. The Buddhist path is self transformation and through that self transformation, eventually one is able to help others. Atisha says that until one has attained shamatha, one cannot help others. In other words, without single pointed concentration which gives the paranormal powers, just telepathy, to read another’s mind, to understand their predispositions, until one has that level, one cannot benefit others.
So this premature social activism is actually part of being in this milieu. That’s why we hold these classes at TBI for all of us to try to understand the world we are entering and to try to bridge the gap with this world which is very different from ours. Are there other questions? Well, there are many things we do understand, aren’t there? If all of them were God, things would be very awkward.
And the more the less we feel is God. Well, if you say God is what we do not understand in the sense that God is something which is beyond our understanding, you are basically very much in the realm of the semitic monotheisms or of the Vedanta. A Buddhist would not agree with that statement. For a Buddhist, everything which is essential to liberation or full enlightenment is accessible through reasoning. For instance, to attain liberation from cyclic existence, we must meditate on the selflessness of persons.
That is accessible through reasoning, only through reasoning. Then to attain full enlightenment we must meditate on the selflessness of phenomena. That is also accessible only through reasoning. What is inaccessible to reasoning must be investigated to see whether it actually exists or not. Does that answer your question or it does.
Are there other questions? Yes. No. In a nutshell, the answer is no. Brahman is seen as permanent one and independent.
Then the ground of being in the Upanishadic tradition is seen as permanently unchanging. All change is Maya, is illusion. From the Buddhist standpoint, we would assert exactly the opposite. We would say that all phenomena which can be perceived by the senses without exception are impermanent. This is not their illusory nature, this is actually their true nature.
For that matter, the omniscient mind of the Buddha is also impermanent. It is only phenomena which are mental which can be permanent. Such phenomena do not necessarily change instant by instant. Ideas, for instance, conceptions as we call them. Then from a Buddhist standpoint, an Upanishadic yogi or a Vedantic yogi who is meditating on Atman and Brahman, first from our standpoint would realize neither Atman nor Brahman because they do not exist.
But if he meditated single pointedly on the conception, he would probably generate Samadhi. He would generate single pointed concentration. Then he would generate the cause to be reborn in one of the form or one of the formless realms. If and it depends which realm he is born in depends on what the focus of his concentration is and the intensity of his concentration. If he focused on non existence, total non existence, which is what the Vedanti seems to focus upon, in other words, that the Atman is neither different nor one with the Brahman.
Then he would be reborn in the highest realm of psychic existence, Chiang Mai, the peak of psychic existence and he would stay there for as long as a karma which impelled him there kept him there but he would fall from this realm. It is not possible to conciliate the vision of the Upanishads with any of the Buddhist presentations of selflessness. Because the Upanishads teach explicitly the existence of an Atman. In some cases it’s seen as physical. It’s actually something which the Atman is actually at the heart.
It is the size of a thumb. In other cases, in other Upanishads, it pervades the body. But in every single case, it is permanent one and independent. Then the reason for which meditation on such an object cannot lead to liberation is because if you meditate on an object which is permanent one and independent, you are meditating on an object which acts as a very powerful basis for attachment and hatred. Then as long as you are meditating on an object which is a very powerful basis for attachment and hatred, you cannot eliminate attachment and hatred.
This is, I would say, the biggest Buddhist critique of the monotheisms. For all the good there is in the monotheisms as a foundation for ethics and certain types of practice of compassion, when you formulate or you postulate the existence of a creator separate from creation as in the semitic monotheisms or a creator who is one with creation but in either case who is permanent one and independent, such a creator acts as the most powerful possible base for the generation of anger and desire. And a Buddhist would understand Islamic fundamentalism in these terms. Such a creator who is permanent one and independent, who gives his law from on high, who is unique, gives can give rise to tremendous feelings of sectarianism for or against those who participate in that system of belief. We’ll talk about it next time but the basic problem with that vision of Brahman is that it is basically at odds with reasoning.
Because if you say that Brahman is the world, you have in a sense said nothing. You have given another name to the world. Then the immediate question which arises is why do we misconstrue Brahman, who is the world, to be individual phenomena? Why do we see phenomena instead of Brahman? The standard answer in Vedanta is through ignorance.
Then the Buddhist rejoinder is this ignorance is a phenomenon as well, isn’t it? You have to say yes. Then this ignorance is Brahman. Then you are saying that ignorance is within Brahman and is affecting the perception of Brahman by other parts of Brahman, the beings who are also part of Brahman. Then at a certain point, the system starts to look extremely contrived.
But that’s what the Vedantins say. The Vedantins say that reasoning cannot lead us to the absolute, that this is beyond reasoning and therefore they lead to these paralogisms. That’s why I wanted to talk about it because it’s very very common among western Buddhists. Very common. Hope you will be able to come.
Are there other questions? Then if you have the possibility, try to read some of the books listed. I also distributed, I think, a copy of the five proofs of the existence of God drawn from Aquinas’ theological sum, Summa Theologica, read through them. It is very beneficial and as for those of you who are Buddhist, as western Buddhists, you have to understand how these proofs might be considered invalid. You have to basically understand what is attempted and why it is invalid to be able to move on.
Thank you very much. Thank you very much. Thank you very much.
Key terms in this teaching
- atman dag (Tib)
- Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- inner being nangpa (Tib)
- Another term for a Buddhist, so called because the person has entered "inside" the teachings of the Buddha by taking heartfelt refuge in the Three Jewels... LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- oral transmission lung (Tib, Wyl)
- The verbal transmission of a teaching, meditation practice or mantra from guru to disciple, the guru having received the transmission in an unbroken lineage from the original source. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- siddhi ngö drub (Tib)
- A realization or attainment, either common or supreme. Common siddhis refer to psychic powers acquired as a by-product of the spiritual path; supreme siddhi refers to great liberation or enlightenment. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.