Lam Rim — 2012-04-15

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim — 2012-04-15
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2012-04-15 – KR.mp3

UUID: 5e2b9bf7-bfb1-4c60-8bb6-410d068e2aaf

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)

Date: 2012-04-15

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 1h 32m

Words: 3,881

As Ariatana Kirti says, the triple gem is for the attainment of liberation. In other words, Ariatana Kirti defines refuge in the triple gem as having liberation as its goal. What is this dharma in which we take refuge? It is the teachings of the Buddha and they exist to the present day in Tibetan in the Kangur or the Trepitaka which has over 100 volumes as well as in the commentaries on Buddha’s Trippitaka, the collection of the great shastras of ancient India which has over 200 volumes. However, the very essence of both the Kangyur and the Tengyur is comprised within the Lamrims, the graduated stages of the path and these are translated in English.

For this reason, we ought to study them and through studying them we will actually generate a powerful aspiration towards liberation and true refuge. And therefore, we must understand the Buddha as the author, the teacher of this dharma. The dharma as what is taught, what actually leads to liberation, and the Sangha as those who enable us to practice this. If this understanding is rooted in the Lamrim, then it becomes true refuge. True refuge is not something which is up in the sky above us somewhere and we look upwards to take refuge.

True refuge is within us. So this is the understanding we must generate. Therefore, to take refuge through faith alone is inadequate and unstable. A refuge which is taken through faith alone will not withstand the vicissitudes of life. And when hardship arises, we will think I have taken refuge for all these years, I have practiced merit for all these years and yet I am in great difficulty and at this point extreme wrong views may arise.

Refuge must therefore be rooted in reasoning and in study. It is independence on study that we can take authentic refuge. This is why the Buddha said in his sutra, I do not cleanse the thoughts of beings with water in my hand nor do I impart a blessing onto beings Instead, through teaching truth, does the Buddha liberate beings? And it is for this reason that it is entirely up to us whether we come to the temple to study or not and whether we practice or not. It makes a difference only for ourselves.

What we must resolve to do is to practice this Lamrim which encompasses the teachings of all of the sutras in a correct and precise incremental way 100% purely and clearly. Otherwise, there is no point in bothering. As Shantideva says in the Bodhisattva Acharya Avatara, all of the sufferings in this world do not arise causelessly. They arise from the foremost full self cherishing. The meaning of this stanza of Shantideva which is rooted in Shatideva’s own meditation and experience is that while we from our side believe that all happiness and suffering in this life depend on exterior events, This is actually an incorrect understanding.

Exterior own happiness and unhappiness depend on interior experience and specifically to eliminate suffering, we must eliminate self cherishing in its root the conception which ignorantly apprehends of the true existence of a self. So this is something we really must understand through experience. We get an inkling of it if we observe the behavior of other beings ranging from the smallest of insects upwards. All of them understand clearly the elimination of physical suffering and strive to eliminate it and all of them strive likewise to realize physical happiness. They strive to do this through an attempt at controlling the exterior world.

So we can see this in our social customs. In Tibet when one greeted someone, one would ask them, is your body happy? Which is a very strange question because what we are saying is that the sole happiness which counts is the physical happiness of the person. In English you say how do you do? It seems to be the same type of approach.

There is no understanding of mental suffering and mental happiness. Take good care of your So we can also see this when we meet and when we separate from relatives, old friends, brothers and sisters. We will tell them take good care of your health and what we are referring to is their bodies. Nobody ever says take good care of your mind, be careful of your mind. Atisha, on the other hand, when he met his disciples, the great Kadampa Geshe would ask them either in the non honorific or the honorific form if they were very high practitioners, has your mind been well?

This is rooted in experience and practice. Our teacher pointed out, however, that this is a dangerous question since most worldly beings will not take it well and may actually take offense or be troubled by such a question. It should therefore not be addressed to them. However, for a true dharma practitioner, someone who practices, then such a question can only lead to an enhancement of mental training. And Robert Che would also say to his students when they were going through difficult periods of their lives, practice well or if they were beginners who did not really practice, have a good disposition.

In our case, these are not things we should say since we are not practitioners, we do not practice and therefore we are not qualified to say this to another person. Then to give an example taken from worldly experience, our situation is similar to that of children in school. A child when he enters school must progress through all of the classes before going to university and getting a university degree. Now, all the ultimate goal may be getting a university degree. If one is a sixth grader, one’s goal right now is passing into seventh grade.

There is no talk of a university degree in this context. Likewise for us, while our ultimate goal may be the attainment of full enlightenment through generating bodhicitta, we are not able to do this at present. Our goal must be to practice step by step at the level at which we are. So as Geshele has pointed out, all living beings wish to eliminate bodily or physical suffering and to attain physical happiness. However, very few living beings understand the difference between physical suffering and happiness on the one hand and mental suffering and happiness on the other hand and how to actionize these.

For ourselves, if we consider ourselves Buddhist, then the path we should practice to attain mental happiness and eliminate mental suffering is the Buddhist teachings. And therefore what are the mental happinesses which we must create? These are first, that mental happiness which arises through striving for higher status in future lives. In other words, for higher rebirth in future lives. Then independence on that, that mental happiness which strives for liberation at the end of the cycle of lives and independence on that, that mental happiness which strives for full enlightenment.

What are however the obstacles which prevent us from actualizing these mental happinesses? The obstacle which prevents us from actualizing the first mental happiness, the mental happiness striving for higher status in future lives is none other than the apprehension of permanence. The apprehension of our five aggregates as permanent entities. The obstacle which prevents us from actualizing the happiness of liberation is none other than the apprehension of the self. And the obstacle which prevents us from actualizing the third happiness, the happiness of full and utter enlightenment is none other than self cherishing.

It is said that all three of these states of mind are present within our mental continuum. In other words, the apprehension of permanence, the apprehension of a self and self cherishing, all three contaminate our mental continuum. Now, to give rise to full and utter enlightenment, we need to realize these three principles of the path and foremost among these, Bodhicitta. We must therefore understand clearly what is present within our continuum and how to counter it. The apprehension of permanence acts as an obstacle to the attainment of higher status in future lives.

The apprehension of a self acts as an obstacle to the attainment of liberation and self cherishing in so far as it is an obstacle to cherishing others becomes a powerful obstacle to the attainment of full enlightenment. So our practice must be such a sequential or incremental practice starting by eliminating the easiest obstacle within our mind which is foundational and then moving upwards to the next obstacle and upwards to the following obstacle. This we can only do through study. At present, our study seems to act mainly as a source of confusion in our minds. This is not the way things should be.

And therefore, this is the meaning of the teachings that one should practice the practices of the beings of the three scopes in sequence. First, the being of the small scope, then the being of middling scope and then the being of a great scope. Geshe del Bopa said that when engaging in analysis, we are unable to gain any type of realization, we should endeavor to accumulate merit and purify the obstructions. So when engaging in analysis alone without these accumulations of merit and the purification of the obstacles, we will not attain our goals even over one century. Then what is the practice, the foremost practice of the being of small scope?

The foremost practice of the being of small scope is trying to obtain a higher rebirth in future lives. What is the main obstacle to this practice? It is the apprehension of permanence. In this matter, we are all the same. Every one of us in this room believes full heartedly that he or she will live to be 100, 90, 80.

Then Geshe-la said to me, what’s he supposed to say to you about this? Then Alila is 75? 74, five years. And we can see for ourselves that convinced every one of us that we will live to be 90 or 100. We put tremendous effort in accumulating all we need to live to be 90 or 100.

Food, drink, clothing, money, a house, a car and we have no time whatsoever for study and even lesser time for meditation. So we can see for ourselves that based on this conception that we will leave, we will live seventy, eighty, ninety, one hundred years, desire and in satisfaction become ever more powerful. We engage in ever more physical and verbal actions to accumulate money, to enhance our security, to accumulate food, to get a good house, a good car, good status in society. Yet, our behavior is profoundly irrational because all of us will acknowledge that we do not have the slightest control over how long we will live. Let alone that there is no guarantee that we will live to the age of 70, 80, 90 or 100.

There is no guarantee that we will live until next year. There is for that that matter no guarantee that we will live until tomorrow. Yet, based on this apprehension of our own permanence, which becomes ever more powerful as we habituate our mind to it, we engage in this type of behavior. The counter to this is to reflect on the fact that we are totally powerless to control our lifespan and having understood this and having started to meditate on death and impermanence, then progressively desire, attachment will decrease, contentment will increase and we will create the space and the time necessary for practice. Otherwise, if from our side we do not create the space and the time necessary for practice, then what can Geshela from his side suggest?

And those of you who have children, little children, should reflect on the fact that while indeed Australia has a good health system, there is no guarantee regarding the lifespan of your children either. And therefore our goal must be to recollect our mind which has scattered outwards in the world of phenomena inwards through reflecting again and again on death and impermanence, which leads to a reduction in desire and to an increase in contentment. As we do this, progressively, our mind will start to be focused on future rebirths. When this happens, as the focus on attaining higher rebirths in future lives increases, this motivation, this wish to attain higher rebirths in future lives becomes the cause for such an attainment. As Chandakirti said, there is no cause for higher status in future lives apart from ethics.

On this foundation, one must engage in ethics. The ethics which is referred to here is the ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non virtues. This is not a difficult topic. It is something we should reflect upon over and again and our attitude and practice should be that of a businessman. In the same way as you don’t enter business to lose money but you enter business to make a profit and when you gain some money, you hold it carefully while trying to gain more money, likewise should we practice with our merit?

And on this basis, having generated a mind which wishes for a happier rebirth, we start working towards the next stage of practice, the practice of the being of the middling scope. The goal of the being of the middling scope is liberation. Liberation from what? Liberation from our shared predicament, which is the all pervasive compositional suffering. What is this all pervasive compositional suffering?

It is all pervasive because all beings with contaminated aggregates share it. It is compositional because it arises from within our aggregates. It arises from the envy, from the jealousy, from the anger which are the mental factors present within our aggregates. And therefore here what is this all pervading compositional suffering? It is none other than our five aggregates which include jealousy, spite, competitiveness, desire, anger and so forth.

Why are they? The all pervasive composition of suffering because under the power of these afflictions present within our aggregates, karma and affliction are generated which give rise to suffering in future lives. What is the means therefore to eliminate this suffering? Just to interrupt the afflictions such as competitiveness, jealousy and spite is not sufficient because they will not have been thereby abandoned. Their actual cause must be eliminated.

Their cause is none other than the beginningless ignorance which Geshela explained during last week’s long Easter weekend seminar on the 12 links. It is a wrong state of mind which is wrong in as much as it apprehends a wrong non existent object. Independence on this wrong state of mind, all of the other afflictions arise giving rise to karma and to suffering in future lives. And therefore as Jay Sugupa says in his Song of Realization also known as the concise Lamrim, one does not reflect on the thoughts of psychic existence, excuse me, one who does not reflect on the thoughts of suffering will not understand the noble truth of suffering. Here, it is important to meditate on the thoroughly afflicted 12 links of dependent origination in the forward sequence from ignorance all the way up to the twelfth link, which is aging and death.

And as Jeff Van Goelper says in the following verse of the concise Lamrim, one who does not meditate on the mode and the stages of ingress into psychic existence will not understand the second noble truth, the noble truth of the origin of suffering. Likewise here, one must meditate on the thoroughly afflicted 12 links of dependent arising. And what is the main obstacle to the attainment of the permanent happiness of liberation? It is none other than ignorance. What ignorance?

The innate ignorance which apprehends the self as inherently existent since beginningless time. What precisely is the mode of apprehension of this ignorance? This ignorance is a mistaken mind precisely because it apprehends a mistaken object. The mistaken object it apprehends is the existence of an autonomous person independent of the outer imputation of that person on the basis of the aggregates, which are its basis of imputation. This is a non existent phenomenon.

The person is a mere nominal and conceptual imputation on the basis of the five aggregates which are its basis of imputation and has no existence apart from such an imputation. The mind which apprehends it as having such an existence is the innate ignorance. It is dependent on this innate ignorance as a preliminary link that all of the remaining 11 links of the thoroughly afflicted 12 links of dependent arising occur. Therefore, it is this which we have to focus upon and try to understand first through study and then through reflection. Merely talking about it is insufficient.

Ayurveda said famously in his Chattushattaka, The 400 Stances, through merely doubting the true existence of psychic existence, it is torn to shreds. Now whether such a mere doubt can actually rend psychic existence or not is open to question, but such a mere doubt is extraordinarily powerful. Such a mere doubt, however, will not arise without prolonged reflection and analysis. And in this context, Geshela would like to develop a point which was not fully developed during the seminar on the 12 links. That is a number of lives during which one cycle of 12 links must be completed.

One cycle of 12 links, one series of 12 links can be completed at the minimum in two lives and at the maximum in three lives. It can never be completed in less than two lives and it can never be completed in more than three lives. None of these three lives have necessarily to be subsequent. Now if we try to pause it the completion of the cycle of 12 thoroughly afflicted links over two lives, how would they be completed? Over the first life, the three first links which are the impelling cause as well as the establishing causes.

In other words, the three first links are ignorance, compositional factors and consciousness. And the establishing causes are craving, appropriation and existence would be completed and the following six effect links ranging from name and form through the four first impelling links through the two last established links which are birth and aging and death would be completed over the following life of that cycle of 12 links. Alternatively, if one cycle of 12 thoroughly afflicted links are spread over three lives During the first life, for instance, this life, assuming we accumulate the karma to be reborn as a human being, the three first impending links are accumulated. These are the links of ignorance, compositional factor and the causal component of consciousness, two and a half links technically. Then during a future life, which may occur at any point in the future, the three actualizing links are accumulated.

These are the links of craving, appropriation and existence and during the immediately subsequent life the remaining six links are accumulated. These are the links ranging from name and form, the six spheres, contact and sealing and then jumping, the following three links. The following two links are in this group. They are the links of birth and aging and death. So although Geshela was supposed to explain mind training like the rays of the sun, we have talked very little about it today.

But we have talked of essential topics related to our practice within the four greatnesses of the Lamrim. The first greatness which is seeing all teachings as non contradictory has been explained and the second greatness has been our main focus today which is seeing all teachings as oral instructions for practice. Seeing all teachings as oral instructions for practice, we take them to heart and then we progress ourselves upwards on the paths of the beings of the three scopes. Then we have come to the end of this teaching, Geshela will take one question. Is there anyone who has a Yes please.

Uh-huh. Let’s see number one. The one. The ephemeral one. If you were to summarize your question really short.

So the view of non Buddhist schools of tenets is that there is a an unrelated person which is separate from the five aggregates. Alright? And these two coexist and their view especially in the Indian tradition is that this unrelated person which is separate from the five aggregates is permanent, one and independent. This is refuted. Then the question is, if we don’t have such an independent person which is permanent one and autonomous, then can we speak of a person in the context of the five aggregates?

The only thing we can speak about from a Buddhist standpoint is a noun, a name, the mere name which is given to this flow of the five aggregates which itself is continuously impermanent. This is what is meant when we say that a person is a mere nominal, in other words verbal or conceptual imputation on the basis of designation, other words the basis of naming which is the five aggregates. How should one think about this? When we say I see you, I see a person in in other words. As ordinary beings what do we mean?

We mean I see your body. Now this body which we call in Buddhist terms the form aggregate, this is not the person. This is a very, very insufficient position because the person not only has a physical body, it has also four other aggregates. The feeling, the discrimination, the volition and the consciousness aggregates, which are all mental. Now this body, we will set aside at death.

Then if we say of the person that they are their body, we say that the person ceases at death. This is a position which is unacceptable to us. The four mental aggregates move on. Then what do we posit as the person when we say I see you? For instance, if Geshela says, we say I see you walk, are we saying that I see your body walking?

Is that a sufficient statement? To say I see you walk, we have to say I see something linked to the five aggregates. So in other words, we impute, we name a person on the basis of the body and the mind together, the collection of the body and the mind. And we can see this through experience. For instance, when we look at Anila Japatinsin and we say, Anila Japatinsin has a tall body, It is very obvious that Anila’s tallness is actually designated, is named on the basis of the appearance of her body, her form aggregate.

Then Geshela says, if we look at your translator and we say Ilya is a very erudite, a scholarly person, then it is obvious this cannot be named or attributed on the basis of Ilya’s body. It has to be attributed on the basis of his mental qualities. You have to all of us have to gain experience. Otherwise, just to speak of the selflessness of persons as such, then things become very odd. We have to try to live this.

Yeah. I try a little bit tight. A little bit tight. Yeah. It didn’t matter.

Alright. Yeah. Yeah.

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top