Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2012-04-07 – KR.mp3
UUID: 52b0af29-0d14-47e2-a15d-83fd3699a263
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Awareness and Knowledge (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2012-04-07
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 35m
Words: 3,996
So as is said in the famous quote from the Sankirtasutra, the existence of this gives rise to that for the sake of generating this that has arisen. It is through ignorance that all suffering arises. This quote from the Sampota Sutra, which is fundamental, is actually mentioned as well in Je Tsongkhapa’s Great Stages of the Path in Lamrim and Cemu. And in the Great Stages of the Path, Je Tsongkhapa actually indicates that the quote is drawn from the Sutra of the Sport of the Lion. It could be that the Samputa Sutra is actually a subsection of this Sutra.
In any case, based on our experience, we can see that any composite phenomenon necessarily arises independence on its own substantial cause and independence on its own cooperative conditions. This is what is explicitly taught in the Samputa Sutra when it is said from this that arises. Buddha taught this explicitly, to point out that phenomena such as, for instance, green sprouts arise necessarily from their own substantial cause, which is the seed of the sprout, as well as the cooperative conditions which are necessary for this, seed to sprout, which are water manure and so forth. This quote from the Samputa Sutra from the existence of this that arises for the sake of generating this that has arisen is a difficult passage which is interpreted in detail by Asanga in his Abhidharma Samuchaya And Asanga draws specifically from this quote from the Samputa Sutra, the or fleshes it out through pointing out the existence of these three conditions on page two of your English translation of the Abhidharma Samuchaya. These are unchanging conditions, impermanent conditions, and effective conditions.
The fact that dependent arisings arise from unchanging conditions, indicates that dependent arisings necessarily arise from causes which are existence. They cannot arise from causes which are non existing phenomenon. The second category of conditions arising from impermanent conditions indicate that dependent arisings not only arise from causes which are existent, but in addition, these causes must be impermanent phenomenon. Dependent arisings cannot arise from permanent phenomena. Finally, the third condition arising from effective conditions points out that dependent arisings cannot arise from any cause whatsoever.
All results are not the consequence of whichever cause. A result is the consequence of its own specific cause and this cause must be concordant in type with the result which it generates. So for instance, if the cause is ignorance, the result can only be contaminated karma. So farmers have direct experience of this. If you sow rice seeds, you do not expect to have a crop of wheat.
The sprouts must be of a concordant type with their cause. Likewise, if you sow wheat, you will not obtain rice. If you sow the seeds of banana trees, you expect to reap bananas down the line, and the same thing for apples. In other words, the cause is of concordant type with the effect it produces. These teachings on the concordance and type of causality even though they were may not have been explicitly intended for this, counter directly the belief in the existence of a creator or a god, which was prevalent in India among the Brahmins before Buddha’s time, among the numerous systems of dharma present.
In addition, the fleshing out of these teachings on causality and the subdivision into three conditions, the immutable, the impermanent, the effective condition is a feature not only of the 12 links but of composite phenomena in general. So if we trace backwards the clear and cognitive continuum of the mind as has been explained in previous teachings, we can see it naturally extends into previous lives. Ageshila feels that through familiarizing ourselves over and again with these reasonings and the idea that the mind circles again and again in cyclic existence, we will derive great benefit. And therefore, the person is imputed on the composite of body and mind and the mind itself comes from beginningless time under the influence or dominated by karma and klesha. So it is not the case that the mind in this affair or we for that matter are independent.
We do not have any independence in the slightest. This is something which one can only fully understand through experience and through meditation on a karma. If we analyze the impermanence of the mind, however, we see that the situation for the mind is somewhat different from that of material objects such as this house. If you take this building, we can say that the period when this building was built is over. Its cooperative conditions were assembled.
The building was built and it never will be rebuilt in this way again, that is in the past. This is not the case for the mind. In the case of the mind, the mind is beginningless and what impels the mind from life to life is the presence within the substantial continuum of the mind of a limitless number of karmic imprints. These imprints are led to maturate to maturation through the presence of various afflictions. The mind as such a result can move either upwards or downwards.
The question which arises is in as much as the continuum of the mind is impelled further through the maturation of karmic imprints implanted in the mind previously by the power of afflictions, what happens when the root of the afflictions, which is craving, is eliminated, is abandoned? There are in this respect two systems of thought. Broadly speaking within the schools of tenets, which include the Vaibhashikas, Sautrandika, and one fraction of the Chitamatra, the so called true aspectarian Chitamatras. It is taught that once craving is abandoned, in other words, once the practitioner has become an arhat, at this point, since whatever karmic imprints may still be present in the mind, afflictions no longer can arise, at the end of that life, the continuum of that being is severed. The mental continuum is severed.
Then this is very much in keeping with the passage from Vasubandhu’s Abidharma Kosha, which says, without craving, there is no future rebirth. There is in this respect numerous discussions regarding a nirvana with remainder and a nirvana without remainder and it is posited in terms of the bodily aggregates by these schools. And therefore, my apologies, I didn’t identify the quote correctly. As this quote, without craving, there is no future rebirth, which is indeed by Vasu Bandur, but in his commentary on dependent arising indicates, the mode of thinking of these schools is quite valid and it indicates clearly that for those who are on the path of lower vehicle arhats and therefore whose goal is attaining liberation from their own suffering, once craving is eliminated, the mental continuum is interrupted. This however is not the case for Mahayana practitioners who from the beginning are aiming for a different goal and following a different path.
So we can get a very clear sense of the impermanence of our own continuum through reflecting back on our state when we were five years of age and the changes by the time we were 15 and the changes much later by the time we were 50. This clearly indicates that there is a constant process of imperceptible change, and this is the foundation on which one practices meditation on death and impermanence. As Jiren Boutin Jitsong Kopas says, having been born, there is no certainty regarding the time of our death. Therefore, foundation of practice has to be meditation on death and impermanence. Engaging in this meditation on death and impermanence progressively, we will see that our contentment will increase and our desires will decrease.
With the increase of our contentment and the decrease of our desires in turn both expectation and, fantasies will dwindle and with the dwindling of expectation and fantasies one’s own inner happiness will increase. In turn, there will be less suffering for oneself. As Shantideva in his Bodhisattvacharyavatara based on experience says, irrespective of the activities one engages in, if one’s mind travels apart from the object of concentration, then there will be no benefit in the slightest. Clearly, means that whatever dharma activities one engages in, whether it is study or the recitation of mantra, if one’s mind wanders, these activities will not yield their fruit. Therefore, one’s mind must be focused on one’s activities and then training in the reduction of desire and the increase in contentment.
One will be able to study in greater depth and to realize the key points of the teachings. And therefore thinking in this way, one should practice and in this way progressively one’s practice will become vaster and vaster. And therefore, independence on the substantial cause for a higher rebirth, which is an ethics of abandonment of the 10 non virtues conjoined as is taught with the practice of the six perfections, one must also generate the cooperative conditions for such a higher rebirth, which are prayers to that effect. Generally speaking, there are countless possible higher rebirths and without such prayers, we lack any control over the process. Therefore, one must take prayers to be reborn in such a way that one has a connection with the Mahayana.
Please be aware of the fact that prayers alone have no benefit whatsoever. Prayers need a foundation to yield their fruit as is taught explicitly in the second section of the Paramita teachings in which the nature of dedication and prayer is addressed. Dedication and prayer need to rest on a foundation which is an accumulation of merit. Without this, they are powerless. The teachings today are teachings on the path of the being of middling scope.
Therefore, we should generate the motivation that these teachings be of benefit to us and to others as tradition tradition wants. And Geshe laurek has developed rather extensively on the motivation. Motivation is important, but we will assume you have generated it. Then if you want to do the recitations. So this was an extensive presentation of the motivation.
Geshela paradoxically has less to say about the main topic than about the motivation, about which we have reflected carefully. However, when the motivation is well created, then whatever karmic imprints we have from the past can mature, but this is not easy. So, in the case of study in general, not only dharma study, it is important to examine carefully from all angles. And as this topic, here is a difficult topic, Geshela is not suggesting that we engage in analytical meditation on it. We might get dizzy in the process, but instead that we examine it again and again at the various angles, we will definitely benefit from doing this.
And if we from our side have a good motivation, the motivation to help others and we explain topics as these, then there will definitely be benefit. And as Jed Zongopas says in his song of experience, also known as the shorter or the concise If one does not put effort in reflecting on the thoughts of suffering, one will not be able to generate the wish to be free from cyclic existence and if one does not put effort in understanding the process of ingress into the truth of origination, one will not be able to attain liberation. The meaning of this quote is that if we do not put effort in understanding the faults of the first noble truth, the noble truth of suffering, which refers in general to these three categories of truth of suffering Geshe lai has explained, the suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and all pervasive suffering, but specifically all pervasive suffering which is that suffering inherent within our contaminated aggregates and which gives rise to the suffering of impermanence, then we will not be able to generate the wish to be free from this suffering. And in turn, if we do not attempt to understand the cause of the noble truth of suffering, which is none other than, karma and the afflictions, therefore thereby not understanding the noble truth of the origin of suffering, we will not be able to attain liberation from suffering.
So Geshela has no real experience in this matters but he for himself finds that there is benefit in compressing his commitments and spending some extra time trying to meditate on the source of the teachings, the origin of the teachings for some ten or fifteen minutes, what he explained so far on the four noble truths and so forth. And in addition, in keeping with the seven verses of mind trainings instruction, with a pure mind engaged in dharma, this practice should be engaged in in the morning when the mind is clear. To flesh out somewhat what was taught yesterday on the first of the 12 links, ignorance, there is a different presentation of ignorance among the various schools of tenets. Generally speaking, the Vaibhashika, the Sautrantika, and the Svatantrika Madiamikas consider that ignorance refers to that ignorance which grasps at a self. The presentation within the mind only school, the Chittamatra school, which relies on Asanga’s Abhidhamma Samuchaya, is somewhat different.
In keeping with the passage from Abhidhamma Samuchaya, which says, ignorance engages its object ignorantly or with confusion, the mind only school considers that the feature of ignorance is the mode with which it engages its object. And this is very much in keeping with our experience. For instance, when we meditate on deity yoga initially, if we try to meditate without looking at a picture of the deity, we actually probably do not or are unable to visualize anything. It’s only when we look at the picture of the deity that we can visualize something. In other words, the mind is unable to engage its object.
Generally speaking, the Abhidharma Samuchaya and the Chittamatra system teaches that ignorance is included within the six first collections of consciousness of the eight normally accepted in that school. However, in the presentation of ignorance within the Srinjuke Guildsen’s texts, ignorance is exclusively a mental consciousness and can never be a sense consciousness. As Geshela explained yesterday, the feature of ignorance is that it engages a wrong object and therefore is a wrong mind. And moving onwards at present to the second of the 12 limbs of dependent arising. The definition of compositional factors within the 12 limbs of dependent arising on page three of your handout.
Is that mental factor of intention which impels later another existence, which would have been impelled by it. And to was motivated by an ignorance which is subsumed within one series of dependent arisings with itself. So the best way to understand this is to take an example. Let us imagine that with the motivation of tremendous anger within one’s mind stream, which is rooted in that ignorance which innately apprehends phenomena and persons as self existent. We generate the powerful intention to kill another person who is our enemy.
Then the first limb of ignorance has been complete and the second limb of compositional factors which is that intended karma arising from the intention of killing another is complete as well. At this point, part of the third limb of consciousness is actually suffused, is impregnated by this intention and engages its object in this way. We have therefore, two and a half limbs which are complete at this point. Now if we analyze this in terms of the definition of compositional factors, we can see that compositional factors are intention. They are a mental factor and these compositional factors will give rise later on as a result of the karma which has been accumulated to another existence.
In this case, a miserable existence. The distinction can only be made between happy and unhappy existences and the unhappy existences are to be seen really as the karmic equivalent of punishment for a crime in the same way as in society at large. Nowadays, for instance, in Tibet, the Chinese, impose a death sentence on those who have killed other. Then the harm inflicted on another, killing another, rebounds upon oneself. So this is the meaning of that first part of the definition.
The second part is that it was motivated as Geshela explained by an ignorance which is part of the same sequence of 12 links as itself. Now, if for instance we have some very beautiful plans for the future, some very beautiful thoughts for the benefit of others. One who has studied carefully and who knows how to analyze motivation will, say to us, these projects of yours are beautiful indeed, but what was the underlying plan? If we examine carefully, we can find that frequently the underlying plan was either to benefit directly oneself or perhaps even to deceive another. So in this case, the examination of the motivation is critical.
Likewise, returning to the example Geshela gave of planning to murder another person. Once the intention to kill another person has arisen within the mind, clearly, must accumulate a large number of requisites to do this. We need the tools to perform the deed, we may have to say something to others verbally and so forth. There are two ways to look at the actual accumulation of karma at this point. One can, see it as part of the second limb, but alternatively one can also see this anger which has suffused the third limb which is the limb of consciousness as actually karma.
This is a very elegant way of viewing things. Now regarding the divisions of karma, karma in general can be divided into karma which is an intention and karma which is intended. Karma which is an intention is that state of mind, such as for instance, anger, which is planning on harming another. Generally speaking, karma, which is an intention, has three subdivisions, virtuous, non virtuous, and immutable karma, which is an intention. The second broad subdivision of karma is karma which was intended.
Karma which was intended is actually the contact or the penetration of karma which is an intention into the activities of the body or of speech. In other words, it is engaging in activities impelled by this karma, which is an intention. And therefore, the karma which is intended, the second subdivision of karma is subdivided into two broad categories, bodily or physical karma which is intended and verbal karma which is intended. If we take an example of bodily karma which is intended, things will become clearer. If we start out with the karma which is an intention, the first the subdivision of karma, the intention to kill another person.
Once this intention, this mental factor of intention becomes a mental factor of intention which engages directly our body and we start to perform the deed to kill the other person, this karma becomes a karma which is intended. Likewise, if we were and there are three such subdivisions of physical karma which is intended. They are killing, stealing, and sexual misconduct. Likewise, regarding verbal karma, which is the second subdivision of karma which is intended, It has four subdivisions, lying, harsh words, divisive speech, and gossip or idle talk. If we were to take another example of the manifestation of such karma, Once the intent to lie has arisen within the mind, which is the intended karma, and this intent to lie becomes concrete and engages the speech organs and leads us to utter a lie, this concretization of the intention to lie is the karma which is intended verbally.
There are alternate divisions of karma. If one divides karma in terms of its nature, one can distinguish between virtuous contaminated karma, non virtuous contaminated karma and, immutable karma. Non virtuous contaminated karma is generally defined as that karma which is accumulated under the power or under the sway of the afflictions. A third subdivision of karma is in terms of the activity of karma. Here one can subdivide karma between impelling karma, establishing karma and completing karma.
Impelling karma is a karma which impels a future life, establishing karma is the collection of cooperative conditions for that and completing karma is that karma which fleshes out or completes the details of that life. So we will stop here for today. Since the topic of karma is a vast one, Geshela has explained so far the first limb of ignorance, the second limb of impelling karma or compositional factors, and part of the third limb of consciousness. Are you a bit confused about beginningless ignorance? If you don’t answer, it’s probably So it’s difficult to talk about ignorance without actually talking about the nature of mind.
That’s really the topic of Loric. But do you understand the process of transition from ignorance to karma? Good. Very good. Wellness.
Michelle, we’ll take one question. One question. So one must make a distinction between two forms of ignorance. Ignorance in general and ignorance within the 12 links of dependent arising. Ignorance in general has a common locus with sense consciousnesses.
This is clear. Ignorance within the 12 links of dependent arising never has a common locus with the sense consciousnesses. It is necessarily a mental consciousness. But that’s not the ignorance within the 12 links. So, Asanga in the Abhidharma Samuchaya points out that ignorance in general can be a sense consciousness.
For instance, when we see from a part, a far, the pinnacle of a house which looks like a human being, then the eye consciousness itself is mistaken. However, ignorance within the 12 links of dependent arising can never be a sense consciousness and is necessarily a mental consciousness because that ignorance is the ignorance which apprehends at a self or apprehends at that which belongs to a self, thinking I or mine. An ignorance which thinks I or mine cannot be a sense consciousness. And, moreover, ignorance within the 12 links of dependent arising is necessarily a conceptual consciousness, and a, a fantasy. On the other hand, sense consciousnesses by definition are never conceptual consciousnesses.
And Jasmine. Let’s not Yes. Yes. What is your question? Yes.
So, virtuous contaminated karma is necessarily accumulated under the power of ignorance and non virtuous karma, which by definition is contaminated, is necessarily accumulated under the power of the afflictions. Excuse me. And therefore, it is said in text that contaminated virtuous karma is necessarily accumulated within one’s mind stream with the presence of the afflictions. To give you an example, for us who are ordinary beings engaging in an ethics which is an abandonment of the 10 non virtues is contaminated virtuous karma. It is virtuous but it is contaminated.
For us, who are ordinary beings, practicing the ethics which abandons the 10 non virtues is contaminated virtuous karma. For instance, for yourself, if you practice the ethics which abandons the 10 non virtues to obtain with the motivation of a being of the small scope to obtain a higher rebirth in future lives, then this is a virtuous deed but it is contaminated. It is contaminated by what? By the the conception which apprehends the inherent existence of the self. Why is it called contaminated?
Because it is motivated by ignorance which apprehends its object wrongly. Alright. Yeah. Yeah. Oh, yeah.
Which example? This one here. So it depends. If this ethics of an abandonment of the 10 non virtues is at the level of an intention, then it is intended karma, the first subdivision of karma. However, at the moment when that ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non virtues actually refrains from committing murder, killing in other words, then it has actually engaged the body through that restraint and it becomes karma which is intended.
So this is clearly explained both in the Lamrim and in Asanga’s Abhidharma Samuchaya. So please write down your extra questions and Geshela will take them Wednesday evening after the Lamrim teachings. Write them down. Otherwise, we will forget.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- completing karma drubje kyi lä (Tib)
- Also called finishing karma, the karmic imprints that ripen to determine the type of experiences we have when we are reborn, as opposed to throwing karma that determines the actual rebirth. LYWA
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
- What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
- suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
- Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA
- Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
- The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.