Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2011-08-07 – KR.mp3
UUID: a660c365-40ba-4399-a1bb-60d99be54896
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2011-08-07
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 33m
Words: 3,613
The boundary between dharma and non dharma is the motivation. There are three categories of motivation: the motivation of the being of small, of middling, and of great scope. The motivation of the being of great scope is a motivation of the being of great scope from the standpoint of the middling scope. The motivation of the being of middling scope is a motivation of the being of middling scope from the standpoint of the being of small scope. It is through generating first the motivation of the being of middling scope that one then rises to the motivation of the being of middling scope and eventually to the motivation of the being of great scope.
So even though this treatise is one which presents a teaching from the standpoint of the being of great scope, nonetheless, this has to be founded on the practice of the being of small scope, and on the basis of that, one in turn gives rise to the practice of the being of middling scope leading to that of the being of great scope. In addition, one can practice the great vehicle teachings from the standpoint of the smaller, the middling or the great vehicle. One who practices the great vehicle teachings from the standpoint of the smaller vehicle is one who practices the Mahayana with the hope of being freed from the suffering of future lives. One who practices the great vehicle from the standpoint of the being of middling scope is one who practices them with the wish to be freed from all suffering in all lives. And one who practices them from the standpoint of the being of great scope is one who practices them with the thought that the suffering of all beings is unbearable and with the wish to free them therefrom.
Was said to be the result of sinful karma. Hence even at the cost of one’s life, it is a practice of the children of the conquerors, never to commit non virtuous deeds. This is a presentation of the practice of the being of small scope And Geshela will in turn teach the practice of renunciation from the standpoint of all three scopes, the being of small, middling, and great scope. So what here is meant by the being of small scope, the nature, the characteristics, and the features of a being of small scope are synonymous. A being of small scope is one who, between this life and future lives, privileges future lives.
Now, generally speaking, this life and future lives, in as much as they are lives, are equal. However, they are unequal in terms of their numbers. Therefore, it is legitimate to privilege future lives at the expense of this life. And broadly speaking, the three categories of beings are those of the highest scope who strive for the state of full enlightenment endowed with the three or the four bodies of a Buddha. The being of middling scope is one who strives for a state of liberation from cyclic existence and the being of small scope, the lowest category of being, the minimum in terms of practice, is a being who at least focuses principally on future lives.
Now, in every single case, such a being is predicated on a human existence, which simply refers to the aggregates of a human being. This is how one should try to practice. So the path of liberation of the being of small scope refers specifically to meditation on death and impermanence. Generally speaking, clearly to be able to live in this life, we need some focus on the vanities of this life, such as food, clothes and so forth. But one should not generate attachment with respect to this.
In this context, Geshela would like to mention something which may be of benefit to the students. When we dissolve the mandala of the medicine Buddha in the ocean and the tormas of offering to the deities were destroyed, Tenzinla mentioned to Geshela that this was a sign of the transience of all things and requested Geshela and the monks to make specific prayers for one person who was present who had throat cancer and who as a result of throat cancer had become unable to speak. The voice had been extinguished. So for this person, they, recited the refuge pair, the 21 Taras, the heart sutra and so forth. And Geshela said that he was told that during the recitations, tears could be seen coming forth from the eyes of this person.
It is probable that this was the end of the human life of this person. So it is good for us to reflect on this and understand how ephemeral our lives are. And it is therefore said that the end of this life is certain and this life is fleeting. The fact that the end of this life is certain refers to the fact that our death is definite. It is pre programmed at the time of birth.
From the time of birth, our aggregates disintegrate. And as to the fact that the time of our death is uncertain, it is our life is fleeting, This is evident by the fact that we are completely unable to say with certainty, tonight I will be alive, tomorrow I will be alive, let alone in one month or in one year I will be alive. And it is a definite certainty that within a hundred years not one of the us will be in this room. And therefore, what is to be done about this? The foremost key here is a practice of dharma.
And as is said in the fourth verse of the practice of the Bodhisattvas, attvas, page 11 of your English translation. One will be separated from kith and kin, befriended for long. One will abandon the remnants of the traces of wealth accrued with effort. Consciousness, the guest will cast away the bodies in. Mentally relinquishing this life is a practice of the children of the conqueror, conquerors.
Here, one will abandon all one’s families and lovers, Geshela says. One will lose all the money which one has accumulated, and consciousness will abandon the body and move onwards alone. Therefore, abandoning this life is a practice of the children of the conquerors. And the only thing which is of benefit in this context is a practice of dharma, which we can take with us. And therefore, since this life does not last for long and is fleeting, one should put effort at implanting virtuous karmic imprints in the mind precisely because they are what would endure.
Otherwise, if one focuses on anything else, it will pass with this life. And when meditating on death and impermanence, since it becomes clear that there is no guarantee, there is no certainty that we will not be reborn in the lower realms, we need protection against this. The foremost protection against this is taking refuge in a protector, and such a protector is the triple gem. Specifically, the triple gem is able to protect us from rebirth in the lower realm, because the crux of the triple gem is the path of an Arya being. And an Arya being is one which has realized what is to be realized and abandoned what is to be abandoned.
So how should we proceed? We should give rise to complete faith, 100% faith in Buddha Shakyamuni, our teacher, as the protector who can protect us from lower rebirths. This does not mean that Buddha Shakyamuni is able to lift us bodily as it were and protect us directly from the lower rebirth. Instead, this faith in Buddha Shakyamuni is a faith in the unmistaken teachings of the Buddha and specifically the unmistaken presentation of the Four Noble Truths. The two Noble Truths from the standpoint of suffering and the two from the standpoint of realization.
It is through these that the Buddha can help us. As is said, I do not benefit beings through cleansing them, nor can I salvage beings myself? It is through teaching suchness that I help beings. And therefore, with complete faith in the teachings of the Buddha, we will then put in practice his teachings on the four noble truths, and specifically in this context, the teachings on death and impermanence. These teachings have not only been uttered by the Buddha, they have been analyzed by the great beings of ancient India, such as Aryanagarjuna and Aryadeva, Shankideva as well, and they were then put in practice by great beings in Tibet, such as Jitsun Milarepa.
And here, what is meant by meditation? Meditation is a process of repeated reflection or appropriation. One engages in this through scripture, reasoning and examples, coalescing the three and focusing on what one wishes to realize as one’s object of meditation. For instance, in this case, one would take death and impermanence, and one familiarizes the mind again and again with this, until one gains realization of it. And what is the path of a being of the small scope?
The path of a being of small scope is a path of the ethics which abandons the 10 non virtuous deeds. And then the verse which teaches the path of the being of small scope on page 24 of your English translation is, the extremely difficult to bear sufferings of bad rebirths by the Muni was said to be the result of sinful karma. Hence, even at the cost of one’s life, it is the practice of the children of the conqueror never to commit non virtuous deeds. So here the bad rebirths, which I refer to, are rebirths as an animal, for instance, rebirth as a horse, as a leopard, or Tibetan animals such as yaks, zoos, drees, or for that matter foxes or wolves. And when Geshela was young, he had a direct experience of just how much hardship can be involved in this life as he and his family had to go to collect wood on the mountains and they would leave early in the morning at 03:00 or so, often with little or no breakfast, walk up the mountain sides, cut the wood all day and come back in the evening bearing their load of wood.
The loads were so heavy that it caused open sores to appear on the back and very acute pain in the knees of the bearers who could not stop for any refreshment of all food. And as they came down the mountain in the evening, they would hear the howls of the wolves and the foxes. So in this respect, the Chinese occupation of Tibet was beneficial, since the Chinese improved the material conditions which people had to deal with. And how do we know what the results of these non virtuous deeds are? We actually know them through the teachings of the Buddha Shakyamuni, who had direct insight in the nature of causality.
Such very subtle causality is an extremely hidden phenomenon which we do not have access to. And through reflecting on the teachings of the Buddha, eventually we generate this strong motivation not to commit even the slightest non virtuous deed. It is said that it is the practice of the children of the conquerors never to commit non virtuous deeds. And passing onwards to the path of the being of middling scope on page 25 of your English translation. The 37 practices reads, the bliss of the three worlds is akin to dew on the tip of a blade of grass subject to destruction in a mere instant, striving for the supreme state of unchanging liberation is the practice of the children of the conquerors.
As Quince William Patrice himself said when teaching the three principles of the path, when desire for the vanities of cyclic existence does not arise even for one instant in the mind, one has attained renunciation. That renunciation which is referred to here is an uncontrived renunciation which arises spontaneously. And therefore, we have to strive to attain liberation and for this, as Je Tsongkhapa says in his concise, who does not understand the truth of suffering towards liberation will put no effort. Here the truth of suffering refers to the first of the four noble truths. So someone who does not understand the reality of suffering will make no effort at liberation.
And as Maitreya says in the Uttara Tantra, through understanding the result and the cause, one then understands the path leading to the abandonment. The result refers to the first noble truth, noble truth of suffering. This cause refers to the second noble truth, the noble truth of origination. If one were to take the example, for instance, of the flu, a disease which affects us, then the flu itself would be the result, the first noble truth, the sufferings of which we understand, fever and so forth. Its cause would be the noble truth of the origin of suffering, which in this case would be getting chilled, drinking cold water, wearing cold clothes and so forth.
The noble truth of cessation, the third noble truth would refer to the goal which is to eliminate the flu, to heal oneself from the flu. And the fourth noble truth, the noble truth of the path would be the various means for doing this such as taking medicine, keeping warm and drinking warm water. And if we analyze the first two noble truths, the noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering, our physical and mental aggregates would be an instance of the noble truth of suffering. It is of their very nature to be suffering in the same way as if we have a thorn stuck within our flesh, suffering is the only thing which we can experience. And it is their nature to be of suffering because they are the result as the first noble truth of the second noble truth which acts as their cause.
The second noble truth, the noble truth of origin, refers both to karma and to afflictions. Afflictions can be seen as that which motivates the accumulation of comma and would comprise for instance desire. Generally speaking, when one is striving for future lives, most probably, although Geshela says one would have to investigate this carefully, the motivation would almost necessarily be an afflicted motivation. Such an afflicted motivation could in turn only give rise to an afflicted result which is of the nature of suffering, therefore, to suffering bodies in future lives. And then what is the root of these afflictions?
The root of these afflictions is beginningless ignorance. Beginningless ignorance is that mind which beginninglessly apprehends innately or spontaneously the self as inherently existing, and this is at the root of the three poisons symbolized by the swine, the cock, and the snake within the center of the wheel of life. The swine, as you know, symbolizes ignorance, the cock symbolizes desire, and the snake symbolizes hatred. Now, this innate ignorance, this innate benightedness within our minds is extraordinarily stable because it is beginningless and it apprehends the self as existing inherently, as not being a mere nominal or conceptual imputation. As this innate ignorance increases in strength, in turn, benightedness increases in the strength and in turn, both desire and hatred increase in potency.
The object which is apprehended by this innate ignorance is none other than the inherently existing self. So, once one is able in dependence on the works of Arya Nagarjuna, Aryadeva and their disciples, to understand emptiness, which is none other but the absence or the non existence of such an inherently existing, such a self characterized self, and one is able to generate this within one’s continuum, then the benightedness will progressively decrease and with it the power of both desire and hatred will decrease. When one gains direct realization of this, one is moving on the path of an arya being towards liberation. And this cessation of the afflictions is none other than liberation, which occurs as a result of the wisdom which directly realizes the selflessness of persons. This in turn must be generated within one’s continuum, independence on the three wisdoms.
Such a wisdom is itself the result of the wisdom arisen from meditation. The wisdom arisen from meditation arises in dependence on the wisdom arisen from thinking, which in turn arises in dependence on the wisdom arisen from hearing. One trains in this way and eventually upon this realization of the selflessness of persons, most probably Geshela says, one can say that the noble truth of the path, the false noble truth has been realized. However, to realize the noble truth of the path, it is indispensable to lay the foundations of conviction in karma and causality and strong refuge in the triple gem. And the verse referring to the path of the being of building scope on page 25 of your English translations, the bliss of the three worlds is akin to dew on the tip of a blade of grass, subject to destruction in a mere instant, striving for the supreme state of unchanging liberation is the practice of the children of the conquerors.
So, we can see that the happiness of this life, the happiness of cyclic existence is transient and ephemeral. If we take the example of, for instance, cooling ourselves off, after five minutes of cooling ourselves off, we become chilled. Likewise, when we try to warm ourselves up, after five minutes of warming ourselves up, we become too hot. Therefore, the happiness of coolness and the happiness of warming ourselves up is transient by nature, like dew on the tip of a blade of grass. It is subject to destruction in a mere instant.
Every single phenomenon in cyclic existence disintegrates instant by instant and therefore it is said that the practice of the children of the conquerors is to strive for the unchanging state of happiness, which is liberation, that cessation of the afflictions. And passing onwards to the verse which teaches the training of the being of great scope on page 26 of your English translation. If mothers who have been loving towards us since beginningless time suffer, what happiness can one have? Therefore, bodhicitta to liberate measureless sentient beings is the practice of the children of the conquerors. Here, every sentient being can be said to have been our relative, our father or mother, since beginningless time, and to have had for us all the love a mother has for her child.
We are all similar as is clearly indicated in the second verse, in as much as all of us experience the all pervasive suffering of cyclic existence, then if mother sentient beings suffer, what happiness can one have? Independence on that reason, this is the meaning of the word therefore in the third verse, generating bodhicitta to liberate measureless sentient beings is the practice of the children of the conquerors. So we have some ten or fifteen minutes. If you have questions, I shall be glad to answer them. So it is actually the first, second, third stanza, which I will read from the translation of the Institute of Higher Tibetan Studies.
At the time when the difficult to obtain great vessel of leisure and fortune has been obtained, the practice of Bodhisattvas is to continually listen, think and meditate day and night in order to ferry themselves and others from the ocean Of Samsara. In as much as our aggregates are of the very nature of the truth of suffering and it is said in the these aggregates of cyclic existence are suffering. Are there other questions? The wisdom of cessation perhaps. You have a doubt.
I will try to formulate it. So I reformulated your question. How can one obtain an uncontaminated result from a contaminated cause, specifically the noble truth of cessation? I thought so. Then Geshela says, basically, it is undeniable that these aggregates are contaminated.
There is no doubt about that. But that does not mean that they cannot be put to work to gain an uncontaminated result. Actually, they can be used for all uncontaminated results. So it is said in scriptures that many eons ago, there was actually basically no violence in warfare and most of the human rebirths were precious human rebirths. However, nowadays those beings who have precious human rebirths have obtained them as a result of virtuous deeds committed or performed in past lives.
Therefore, it is maturation of a past cause. We should not think only of this life but also of past lives. And also, this may be of help, Geshela says, actually the holy beings pray to practice during the ages where violence and strife is at its highest because their practice is even more forceful during these periods. And where they obtain far greater merit. Yes, Richard.
So I have to reformulate your question. Geshela says there is a strong relation between the eye of this life or the self of this life and the eye of future life. That relation is the foundation for causality. So this course for some analysis, but basically, it is that merely imputed self whose continuum actually passes into future lives. Does that go towards answering your question?
One can formulate two selves, the self which is imputed on the basis of the aggregates of this life and the self which can be imputed on the basis of the aggregates of all lives. We can look at the self in those terms. Will stop here for today. And if you feel like continuing this question next time.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- four kayas catuhkaya (Skt); ku zhi (Tib)
- The classification of a buddha’s body into four: jnanakaya (wisdom body), svabhavikakaya (nature body), sambhogakaya (enjoyment body) and nirmanakaya (emanation body). LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- graduated path of the three capable beings kye bu sum gyi lam gyi rim pa (Tib)
- The three levels of practice of the lower, middle and higher capable being, based on the motivations of trying to attain a better future rebirth, liberation or enlightenment. Also known as the three scopes. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
- three poisons dug sum (Tib)
- Attachment, anger and ignorance. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.