1 h 32 min · 3,677 words · 26 April 2016
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues the Lam Rim teaching on meditation as repeatedly focusing the mind on a virtuous object, with recollection and vigilance as its two factors, and on afflictions as the root of mental suffering, traced to ignorance grasping at a self. It uses analogies of a potato and a seed to discuss substantial causes and cooperative conditions, and touches on past and future lives and generating bodhicitta through the sevenfold cause-and-effect method and equalizing self and others. The session closes with questions on arhats, bodhicitta and the person as a continuum.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 32m
UUID: 317fecfc-c812-43a9-866b-9266e712ff19
Date: 2016-04-26
Words: 3,673
Mhmm. I need So as usual, during a couple minutes before the beginning of the teaching, we will engage in meditation. Then our goal is to pacify our minds, and this pacification probably qualifies as meditation. And the definition of meditation given by in is a very helpful one, to focus the mind over and again repeatedly on a virtuous object. So it is important here to understand the purpose of meditation.
We ourselves as persons follow our aggregates, our body specifically, and our body follows our mind. Unfortunately, our mind follows the afflictions. In brief, we are under the sway of our minds, and our minds are under the sway of the afflictions. The afflictions can be briefly defined as unsuitable states of mind. And we can see, for instance, in the case of anger, which is an affliction, that when anger arises within our minds, it prevents our minds from remaining in a state of peace and happiness.
In brief, it troubles our mind. Therefore, more completely, afflictions can be defined as mental factors whose function is to generate unsuitable states of mind. And therefore, the result of meditation is that when we no longer allow our minds to be under the sway of the afflictions, in other words, to be controlled by the afflictions, but instead forcefully control our minds, forcefully subdue and tame our minds so they no longer fall under the sway of the afflictions and focus these minds on a virtuous object, then that is meditation. So you might tell me, but it is impossible to subdue the afflictions. Why get started?
Actually, let us start by trying to prevent our minds from falling under the sway of the afflictions in the here and now, and then extend this process over time. Then this has to be our goal. So we have defined meditation as a mind which is repeatedly focused on a virtuous object. Two factors are necessary for this focus. The first is recollection, and the second is vigilance.
Of these, recollection or memory is foremost. Now what precisely fosters memory? What fosters memory is an ethics which is an abandonment of the 10 non virtues. We all know what the 10 non virtues are. And it’s such an ethics which fosters our memory and our recollection.
And certain ethics gives rise to contentment contentment with little happiness, which naturally fosters powerful recollection. Now what precisely does this ethics, which is an abandonment of the 10 virtues arise from? It arises from a wish to protect our reward. What is our reward here? Our reward in future lives or beyond.
Then while dwelling in a virtuous state of mind, we should focus on whatever topic of the Lam Rim we wish to focus upon, either the totality of the Lam Rim in the correct sequence or the Lam Rim in general. If, however, we are unable at present to dwell in a virtual state of mind and our mind is distracted, then we must initially bring our back our mind back to a neutral state. And this is best done through focusing in an unmistaken fashion on the process of inhalation and exhalation, counting the breaths unmistakably either seven, fourteen, or 21 rounds. Once one’s mind has returned to this neutral state, it is then possible to edge it into a virtuous state of mind and focus on the Lam Rim. And at present, if we are able to withdraw our minds inwards, then this is actually quite an achievement because our minds are scattered outwards overwhelmingly under the power of the afflictions.
And therefore, to bring our minds back inwards, to withdraw them inwards, we must target the afflictions. We must, in other words, recognize the afflictions as afflictions. We must recognize the afflictions as our inner enemy. It is a rare scene indeed to meet someone who recognizes anger, pride, desire, arrogance, and so forth as an enemy. At present, let us adopt the appropriate posture for meditation.
The key elements are sitting cross legged, having one’s right palm on the left palm with the thumbs touching, a straight back, a slightly inclined head with one’s nose, one’s eyes focused on the point beyond the tip of one’s nose, and try to meditate. This should qualify as meditation.
So in my own case, during this period, I meditated on the path shared with the being of the middling scope since the root of our suffering is the afflictions, and I endeavored to find what the root of the afflictions are. To put an end to the afflictions, you have to put an end to their mother. And the mother of the afflictions is the ignorance grasping at a self. Then, it is the cause of the afflictions, but causes are subdivided into substantial causes and conditions. And I investigate whether it was a substantial cause or a condition.
Then in your own cases, you probably thought about things differently. There is no point in entering into it now. I assume that, most of us understand that suffering is twofold, physical and mental suffering or suffering on a physical and on a mental base. Physical suffering is self evident. It’s a suffering due to heat, to cold, and so forth.
Then, this can be addressed through controlling the exterior physical elements and need not preoccupy us here. The dominant form of suffering, however, is mental suffering, and it is mental suffering we must investigate and the causes of which the afflictions we must understand. It’s important to understand that external conditions alone cannot affect mental peace and happiness. It is internal conditions, specifically the afflictions, which affect mental peace and happiness and destroy it. Most of us are at present are at ease, relaxed, largely because our minds are at present focused on a virtuous object in a virtuous direction, and they have not fallen under the sway of afflictions such as anger and so forth.
Mhmm. So if the afflictions are what destroys our mental peace and happiness, then we have to find the means to eliminate them temporarily and if possible, permanently. Then it is important here to understand that the afflictions are not permanent. They are composite phenomena. They are causes.
In other words, they can be destroyed. In the same same way as, for instance, if we have, let’s say, a huge tree which has been allowed to grow uncontrollably until it overshadows our house or the building we are in, then such a tree presents considerable danger due to branches falling, the shade, and so forth. We might address the issue by trying to sever the branches, but instead it is preferable to focus on the root of the tree because if we destroy the root, then we destroy the totality of the tree. Just as if we want to destroy such a tree, we attack the foundation, the roots through pouring boiling water on it or burning it or whatever we choose to do. And as a result, the this tree dries out and eventually can be cut.
It is important to understand that the afflictions are not one with the mind. The afflictions are not permanent. They are impermanent. Sometimes they are present within the mind mind stream. Sometimes they are not.
As a result of this, we can see that afflictions such as anger are definitely not permanent because occasionally anger is present and occasionally it is absent. So here, it is therefore important to identify the cause of the afflictions, and we can see that afflictions arise both from self cherishing and more fundamentally from the ignorance grasping at a self. If the ignorance grasping at a self is a cause of the afflictions, then as causes are either, as I explained, substantial causes or cooperative conditions, which of the two would it be? Clearly, if the ignorance grasping at a self was a substantial cause, things would get quite odd indeed. But on the other hand, if the ignorance grasping at a self is a cooperative condition, is it possible through merely eliminating a cooperative condition that the result not arise or not?
This is something which has to be investigated. So let us take the example of a potato. Then the substantial cause of a potato is another potato. But what exactly are its cooperative conditions? Its cooperative conditions are factors such as water, heat, and manure.
Then, if we continue with our analysis of this example, if we eliminate one of the cooperative conditions, let’s say water, are we able to give rise to more potatoes from one potato? Obviously, no. We left with a single potato. Therefore, extending this example to the previous case of ignorance, it would seem that through eliminating the cooperative condition, we eliminate the arising of the result. Then if we keep this potato in the ground without watering it at all, over the years, does the seed for future potatoes remain or not?
Do you understand? So if you put one potato in the ground and you do not water it, then does the potency, the seed of that potato remain over time or not? Do seeds remain in the ground if you don’t water them? The potency of the seed remains. Right?
How long can seeds
In the ground without giving rise to a sprout. How about the monarch? Doing more. It remains indeed. So if you put a seed in a box and you do not provide water heat or manure, how long does the potency remain?
And they should ask me, I think there are some seeds from the pyramids which are caused to sprout. So we’re talking of thousands of years. So here, when we say that ignorance is a cooperative condition of anger and that the elimination of ignorance leads to the elimination of anger, we are in the context such as one referring to the Arhat, who are beings who have eliminated all of the seeds which give rise to the afflictions within their mindstream. So when we say that they have eliminated the seeds giving rise to the afflictions, we mean that they have severed the afflictions. The afflictions never ever again arise within their mind streams.
Then whether for such a beings, ignorance would have been the substantial cause or the cooperative condition of anger is something to investigate. It would be very strange if it was the substantial cause because it would subsist, it would disappear when anger arises. So when we say that the seeds of the afflictions do not exist in the continuum of an arhat, this is a little bit awkward. But what in reality is happening is that the afflictions never arise. So Buddhist philosophy is one which involves extremely fine, careful, and detailed analysis, such as precisely this one.
Now generally speaking, what we can say unambiguously is that once ignorance grasping at a self has been eliminated, the afflictions never ever arise again. However, whether the seeds of the afflictions have also been utterly destroyed or not, that is something which calls for analysis. Mhmm. So for this, one should study over and again, Reflect on the meaning of texts. So in dependence on the explanations which have been given over the last couple of teachings on substantial causes and cooperative conditions, we can understand better the existence of past and future lives.
Since our consciousnesses, our continuum of consciousnesses are basically both beginningless and endless, it is not possible to posit either a beginning or an ending. And the previous instance of the continuum of consciousness are the substantial cause of the subsequent instance. Then I am not saying that the continuum of consciousness is the person, but the person is imputed independence on the continuum of consciousness. Therefore, the person as well is both beginningless and endless. Then in dependence on these explanations, we will understand much better the power of the generation of bodhicitta by means of the sevenfold causal instruction.
These are the benefits of study. To try to gain such an understanding, in dependence on prayer alone will be extremely difficult. Instead, we have to study. There are, as you know, two means to generate bodhicitta. The first is the sevenfold causal instruction, and the second is the instruction of the equalization and the interchange of self and others.
Once through the lines of reasoning, which Kesheva has explained, one understands clearly the existence of one’s own previous lives, it is then possible to apply the instruction of the sevenfold cause-and-effect instruction for generating bodhicitta with great efficacy. Then when through meditating on the sevenfold causal generation of bodhicitta or the equalization and interchange of self and others generation of bodhicitta, one is able to generate a sense of closeness, not just to one or to two persons, but to all persons, then we will start to reap the results of these meditations. Once one has understood that the root of all one’s mental suffering is to be searched for deep within oneself, within one’s own self, and it is the afflictions within one’s own mind, and this is rare. And when in addition, one understands that every single other being, certainly this can be said for human beings, for animals, it’s more awkward. But with human beings, because of their intellect, this can be said, experiences the same difficulties, then one is on the good path a good path for giving rise to bodhicitta.
So here, even if we were able to eliminate all of the afflictions from our own mind stream and therefore, If, however, living beings in the rest of the world had not eliminated the afflictions from their own mindstream, then eventually, we ourselves would experience hardship. We might even be killed by them. In this year. So is it possible to eliminate all the afflictions from one’s own mindstream and that of all others? It is not impossible.
It will take a long time. Precisely because the mind is immaterial, it will take a very long time. If the mind were material, it would take it would be a matter of days for us to tear down these obstructions. But because the mind is immaterial to target the afflictions which are within the mind, which are themselves with the nature of mind, takes a lot of time. What matters is to understand that the possibility exists.
So in this world of art, all of the so called studies, advanced studies, are basically focused on bettering the condition of our body, our own physical condition. They are focused on improving welfare and material conditions. However, material conditions and welfare are insufficient to provide us with lasting happiness. We need, in addition, mental happiness. And mental happiness is something which must be studied.
We must study the causes of mental happiness. And through study, we will understand that this fosters mental happiness, whereas that harms mental happiness and try to generate our own mental happiness. Then if we are able to do this, imagine a world in which there would be no afflictions and law would be unnecessary. The police would be unnecessary. There would be no crime.
What such a world would be like? Imagine, therefore, such a world a world in which people had abandoned the afflictions. A world, in other words, in which police, law, constraints, wars would never happen. In such a world, we would not even need solid doors and locks anymore because no thieves would come in. Then the upheaval of the elements due to fire, wind, earth, that happens naturally.
That is something else. It is the afflictions which are our foremost enemy. Some of you might think naively that rifles or bombs are the foremost enemy of man. That is not true. A rifle or a bomb is completely ineffectual without an evil intent behind it, without an affliction behind it.
Which triggers a rifle or detonating the bomb. Otherwise, it’s just inanimate matter. And therefore, when one starts thinking in this way, how is it possible to foster peace and happiness in the world? How is it foster possible to reduce the difficulties in the world? How can I become a protector of the world, a teacher of the world that one is on the path towards generating bodhicitta?
Mhmm. So let us now meditate during a couple of minutes on bodhicitta. I’m not saying that by thinking in this way, you can generate bodhicitta. You really have to meditate hard to generate bodhicitta. Mhmm.
Okay. [inaudible] So I was going to explain the sevenfold cause-and-effect and equalization and interchange for generating bodhicitta from the standpoint of an understanding of past and future lives and of substantial causes, but we have run out of time. Therefore, if you have any good questions to ask, please ask them. It’s probably a bit of a rookie question, but I was thinking if everything is impermanent, how can it be that any affliction can’t arise at any time? What do you mean by If the arhats have have done away with the afflictions like these, and you say they can no longer recur, and yet everything is impermanent.
They would lead one to think that anybody could have a fall from grace. And and Oh. How does the affliction even come to be? It is because the afflictions are impermanent that they can disappear. Then the reason for which they never reappear again within the mind stream of an is because the arhat has abandoned or eliminated the foundation of the afflictions, which is self grasping.
So an akhat an akhat has eliminated self grasping, and that means that they see only the Buddha nature. They do not see individual human beings. There is no separation between an individual and a Buddha. And so because of this, what appears to be an affliction to a normal person actually becomes the path to an arhat. And so through this moving forward and passing through this suffering, which is this nature, the the actually progresses and doesn’t see death necessarily as an obstacle.
So here, an Arhat is not a Buddha. And we have Arhats who are Shravakas or hearer Arhats and Arhats who are solitary realizers or of different vehicles. Mhmm. What I was trying to say was that the Arhat sees only the Buddha. So there is no individual human beings.
There is only Buddha happening. As in there is no seed. There is no seed existing in other individuals. There is only If you are saying that the focus of the Within the you have two types of. You have hearer and solitary realizer.
For the second category of solitary realized, you are saying that their sole focus is their own enlightenment or Buddhahood, that is true. Okay. Next question. Yes, Shavannah. I asked one other time about the cooperative conditions for bodhicitta, specifically great compassion.
And going back to the description of the mental continuum being the substantial cause of the mental continuum and the sperm and ovum being the cooperative conditions of the person, I struggle to understand why, the cooperative condition is great compassion for bodhicitta. I would have thought that that was a substantial cause because it’s a mental continuum. It’s a good way to look at things. However, if great compassion was the substantial cause of bodhicitta, then it would necessarily be the case that when bodhicitta arises, great compassion would cease. And great compassion does not cease when bodhicitta arises.
It is still present. Yeshula does practicing Vajrayoginī when she’s
Stepping on desires and afflictions and ignorance. Help with, conquering these addictions and afflictions. So doing the meditations in the morning and a 108 repetitions, seeing that’s what she’s about. So the practice you were referring to of Vata Yogini is an Anuttara Yoga Tantra practice. Therefore, it is indispensable in the backdrop of that practice to have first a good motivation, in this case a motivation of Bodhicitta, and then to engage in that practice.
However, in dependence on that practice alone, it is difficult to eliminate the afflictions. Next question. Yeah. Keshe la, I struggle to understand how the, the person is beginningless and endless, and I guess my question is, when the ignorance grasping at a self is removed, is the person still imputed on the mental continuum? So both your doubts are very interesting and sharp questions.
Then regarding the first one, why the person is beginningless and endless. It is quite easy to posit the person as beginningless and endless once one understands that the mental continuum is beginningless and endless. And why would the mental continuum itself be beginningless and end endless? Simply because there’s no antidote to the mental continuum. Okay.
One question. Just one. Okay. Chris? I just wanna check that I’ve got this correct.
Is the substantial cause of self grasping a previous instance of self grasping? So in the case of the ignorance grasping at a self, probably its substantial cause will always be a previous movement of consciousness, that ignorance. In the case of other consciousnesses, sometimes a substantial cause is a consciousness. Sometimes a substantial cause is an imprint. Really?
Okay. Yeah. Please. It’s very good that you’re thinking about substantial causes and cooperative conditions. Please reflect on these two topics.
Mhmm. On the teachings on the weekend, Geshe-la spoke about the substantial continuum of a tree, and I was wondering sorry. This question’s a bit, please. Is the substantial continuum of a person or the mental continuum of a person comparable to the substantial continuum of a tree in that its previous moments, not entirely unrelated to the present moment. I don’t know how to say it.
Not unrelated, but they are. I’ll formulate a question for next week. Okay. Thank you. Sorry.
We are too late. Okay. I’d like to see you. Oh, thank you. Thank you.
That’s right. Thank you for everything. Good good question.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- Highest Yoga Tantra Anuttara Yoga Tantra (Skt); la na mä pä gyü (Tib)
- The fourth and supreme division of tantric practice, sometimes called Maha-anuttara Yoga Tantra. It consists of the generation and completion stages. Through this practice, one can attain full enlightenment within one lifetime. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- Yoga Tantra näljor gyi gyü (Tib)
- The third of four classes of Buddhist tantra, literally meaning "union" due to the increased emphasis on internal activities compared with the previous two tantras. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Is the substantial cause of the ignorance that grasps at a self always a previous moment of that same ignorance?
In the case of the ignorance grasping at a self, its substantial cause will probably always be a previous movement of consciousness, that same ignorance. Other consciousnesses differ. For them, the substantial cause is sometimes a consciousness, and sometimes it is an imprint.