Four Noble Truths — 13072016 3

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Four Noble Truths — 13072016 3
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 13072016 3.mp3

UUID: 78f2671f-e259-4f7b-b342-70388ad625a9

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 1h 33m

Words: 4,521

Yeah. So I would like to talk a bit about how we think about things, our mode of thinking. Now this is something we have addressed many times. Generally speaking, all of us seek for happiness and within the two forms of happiness, physical and mental happiness, overwhelmingly, we seek for physical happiness. Then it is obvious that all of us seek for happiness, we put efforts at attaining happiness and we also strive to avoid suffering.

And the money, the wealth we aim for is precisely for that purpose. Now, within physical and mental happiness, we focus almost exclusively on physical happiness and physical happiness is basically worldly or mundane happiness as opposed to happiness arisen from dharma. Now clearly the suffering we are trying to avoid is physical suffering and all of us have direct experience of the means to eliminate this. For instance, these days it is cold. Then I’m quite sure there is not a single one of you who doesn’t have a heater at home with which to eliminate the cold.

Then we should not inflict any undue hardship on our body. And this is a case because hardship, which is physical, has mental consequences. In our own cases, we follow our minds and our mind follow our body and mainly the sense consciousnesses. Therefore, it is critical here to make sure that our body experiences no hardship and that we are in good health. And on this basis, we can accomplish what we want.

In addition to this, it is extremely important to have a relaxed mind, a mind which is at ease. And this is something I have explained here many times. Beginners like ourselves must pay particular attention to our body and our health because if we have a headache or stomach ache, then it immediately impacts our capacity to study and we must study. In my own case, every evening, I go for a one hour constitutionally circumambulation typically in Tibetum and it is actually quite different here from India because here I walk around and sometimes I don’t ever see anybody. In India, when I go for a one hour walk, always meet friends, we end up having a cup of tea and so forth.

Then obviously living alone for a long time is difficult and one must be careful if one is lonely to keep a relaxed mind, the mind at ease. Then regarding one’s body, one should do everything possible for one’s health and if heaven forbid one nonetheless does fall ill, then one should take the appropriate medicine for however long is necessary. And therefore, one of the things I would like to point out is how important it is to stay warm. It seems self evident, but if you don’t stay warm enough, then eventually you will become rapidly hungry and you will experience all sorts of health problems. In addition, one needs to sleep sufficiently.

This seems self evident, but let’s say in the great monasteries because of the cycle of pujas such as the Mangja, the collective pujas, the dhalja, the pujas of the monastery itself, one has to rise very early in the morning and one seldom has more than five hours or so of sleep every night. Then that’s obviously not enough one needs, I would suspect seven or eight hours of sleep a night. And if one does not have those seven or eight hours of sleep a night, then there are physical consequences the next day and obviously if one’s body is affected, so is one’s mind. Then it is therefore important to find means to remain in health and to take good care of one’s body. This is up to each one of us to do, then obviously there is a day where we will have to leave, but until then we should try to take good care of our bodies.

Then I want to elaborate regarding physical happiness, All of you understand the importance of staying in good health. Regarding mental happiness, mental happiness arises through dharma practice and the opposite of mental happiness is the three sufferings. The suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and all pervasive suffering, which are mental sufferings. Now, the goal of this study of Lamrim is precisely to eliminate mental suffering. I suspect there is no means to eliminate mental suffering apart from such study.

It is therefore the goal of these studies. Now the mere study of Lamrim is necessary to eliminate these three sufferings, but it is not sufficient. Through study alone, one cannot eliminate these three mental sufferings. The suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and more pervasive suffering. Instead, one has to give rise first to a mind arisen from hearing, then to a mind arisen from thinking and eventually to a mind arisen from meditation for this.

Now, you probably understand what these three sufferings are already. The suffering of suffering and the suffering of change can probably be eliminated at the level of the path of the being or at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope. Whereas all pervasive suffering, in other words, cyclic existence, can only be eliminated either at the level of the path shared with the being of the middling scope or at the level of the path of the being of the great scope. So, to cover some material we have covered already, let us address the path shared with the being of the middling scope. The topic of the path shared with the being of the middling scope is the four noble truths.

The noble truth of suffering, the origin of suffering cessation, and the path to cessation. And the motivation required for the path shared with the being of the middling scope is the mind striving for liberation. Now, once one has generated an uncontrived mind striving for liberation, one has entered the path shared with the being of the middling scope. But the doubt which can arise here is within the sequence of the Four Noble Truths, why precisely is the noble truth of cessation put in the third place and the noble truth of the past put in the first place? Why shouldn’t The doubt which arises is why shouldn’t one put the noble truth of cessation in the first place.

So this mind which is striving for liberation is none other than a mind which is striving for the noble truth of cessation. And one might wonder at this point, having attained it, why the noble truth of cessation should not be put in the first place. The reason for this is that at present we do not have access to the noble truth of cessation. When we speak of the four noble truths, the noble truth of suffering, of the origin of suffering, of cessation, of the path, it is a purely verbal enunciation. We don’t have access to the fully characterized noble truth of cessation.

And therefore, the mind striving for liberation which we generate is not a mind which has access to a fully characterized noble truth of cessation. And the reason for this is understood when one extends the mind striving for liberation to others. When the mind striving for liberation is extended to others, it is what is known as great compassion. This mindset which thinks, why would it be inappropriate for others not to be free of suffering, why should others not attain liberation? Now, great compassion is said not to observe the noble truth of cessation, not to have Nirvana as its object.

If that is the case, then when one turns great compassion onto oneself, in other words, one asks oneself, why is it inappropriate for myself not to be bereft of suffering, then that mind likewise does not have a fully characterized liberation or Nirvana as its object. So, once one has attained the realization of the path shared with the being of the middling scope, in other words, once one has generated an uncontrived mind striving for liberation, then at that point one is said to have entered the path. If one has entered the path, that means one has entered one of the paths of these three beings, one has either entered the path of a hearer or of a solitary realizer or of a bodhisattva. You may be a little bit confused by this, don’t worry. I am alluding to material which we cover during the Tuesday classes on grounds and paths on Salam.

And in a context like this one, a little bit of confusion and of doubt is a good thing. Then I appreciate that you have to work for a living, you have to keep an eye on family members, you have to take care of your children and therefore you have little time for study. It is obvious that with little time for study it is difficult to enter these materials but there is no reason to feel depressed at this prospect. You can create situations where it will be possible. Then our situations are a little bit different because I have free time which enables me to focus on these topics.

But I think it is rather positive if you get annoyed by the mundane tasks you have such as taking care of children and watching your parents and cleaning the house and say with irritation because of this I don’t have time to study. Then our two Anilas, Tenzin Hama and Tenzin Dohlkha being ordained have completely free time for study and therefore they should focus on study and study the Lamrim especially and deepen their understanding. And if they have questions, they can ask Yor Lodzawa, they can send him emails or telephone, please don’t telephone. And he will do his best to answer their questions. And as these doubts arise, then one’s own understanding deepens evermore.

I have my own study, so if you ring up, it interferes. And therefore, you can ask your translator if you have any questions, email him with your questions. This is how you will increase your understanding and Jean Pierre Chappell has to work, so it is a bit difficult for him, but the two of you have free time and it is through putting such effort and generating doubts and questions that one’s own understanding will deepen. And if I spoke English like your translator, obviously I would be delighted in your questions and would invite you to ask questions all the time, but I don’t. Then I don’t know exactly how you study in Australia but the way we proceed in the great monasteries is by means of a relentless quest for knowledge.

We study, then if we have doubts we ask questions, then we ask more questions and this is how one really develops one’s understanding. And this is why one relies on one’s elders in the monastery and here by elder I refer to elder in knowledge, otherwise the term has no meaning. One studies in-depth throughout the morning, then one goes to debate. During debate one debates intensively. This corresponds to our question and answers here and this is how one gains an understanding.

And the way one should study is in this case one should have a copy of a Lamrim text in front of oneself, there are numerous Lamrim texts but let us say Lamrim Chenmo and then from time to time if one wants to study other topics, one can focus on the view on Bodhicitta and so forth, but the main focus should be on the means of proceeding of the Lamrim. So, when one has generated an uncontrived mind striving for liberation, one has attained the realization of the path of the being of the middling scope. However, certain uncontrived mind striving for liberation does not have as object of observation a fully characterized liberation or a fully characterized truth of cessation. If it were to have as object of observation a fully characterized truth of cessation, one would have entered the path of accumulation. Now, this is not possible at this point because having merely generated one such mind, one still has the option to enter in the path of any of the three beings, hearer, solitary realizers or bodhisattvas.

Now at present, we will pass on to our main topic, the path of the being of the great scope. And within the training of the mind by means of equalization and the interchange of self and others, we have five subdivisions. The first is equalizing self and others. The second is reflecting through numerous lines of reasoning on the thoughts of self cherishing. Then the third is reflecting through numerous lines of reasoning on the qualities of cherishing others or altruism.

The fourth is the actual thought of the interchange of self and others and the fifth is a means of meditating on giving and taking Tonglen, independence on that. Since our main topic of study at present is the Mahayana, this is what we should focus upon and the direct result of this five fold process of mental training and the equalization of self and interchange of self and others is the generation of great compassion. The indirect result is a generation of bodhicitta. So the reflection on the first outline equalization of self and others involves also a reflection on the equalization of happiness and suffering. And then after this, one engages in reflection on the second outline reflecting through numerous lines of reasoning on the thoughts of self cherishing.

Now it is actually difficult for us to gain realization in the second outline because at present we have no realization of the path shared with the being of the small or of the middling scope. If we had realizations of those paths then it would be easier for us to gain a realization of the thoughts of self cherishing. But nonetheless, we can gain an understanding of these thoughts. At present, because we have no realization of the thoughts of self cherishing, it is very difficult to generate a realization of the qualities of cherishing others or altruism. It is not sufficient to just reflect in general on the force of self cherishing, we must actually distinguish between the numerous forms of self cherishing present within our mind streams.

We have self cherishing which is focused on this life. We have self cherishing, which is focused on future lives. We also have self cherishing, which is focused on liberation and on one’s own weal exclusively. These are all forms of self cherishing. Then obviously one of the key practices of bodhisattvas is giving up one’s own body and happiness and focusing on the happiness of others.

This is naturally very rare to see, but one does see occasionally beings who are able to do this. And when oneself experiences great hardship and difficulties, then instead of thinking that this is due to others, it is the fault of others, one should instead look within oneself and say this is due to my own self cherishing, indeed self cherishing is a great enemy and this line of reasoning helps one greatly in supporting hardship. Now what precisely is the realization one obtains through reflecting through numerous doors, in other words through numerous lines of reasoning on the thoughts of self cherishing or egoism. One reaches a point where one turns away from one’s own advantage. Just as the realization of the path of the being of the small scope is turning away from the vanities of this life and the realization of the path of the being of the middling scope is turning away from the vanities of all lives, then at this level of the practice of the great scope, one turns away from one’s own advantage.

Actually instead of advantage, translate cherishing, one turns away from cherishing one’s own self. And then at this point, one trains through numerous lines of reasoning in reflecting on the qualities of cherishing others or altruism. Independence on this one is able to generate the actual thought of the interchange of self and others and then through this one trains in the practice of giving and taking. By taking, one takes upon oneself the suffering of others and one wishes them to be free from all suffering, training in great compassion and by giving, one gives them all happiness and thereby one trains in love. Now these trainings occur in sequence, one necessarily must start with the equalization of self and others and when one wishes to engage in Tonglen, giving and taking, since one actually gives one’s own happiness to others and one takes their own suffering on oneself, one must initially, if one gives one’s own happiness to others, have completely relinquished self cherishing and if one takes the suffering of others upon oneself, then one must have trained in altruism or cherishing others.

One must therefore reflect on these five subdivisions of the interchange of self and others in sequence. And therefore, let us now meditate a couple of minutes on generating great compassion through reflecting on these five outlines. Mhmm. Please open the prayer book, page one. We recite one b, two, three, four, and also page five.

Number six, mandala offering, verse one and three. Now, when one trains in Tonglen, if one wishes to do so, one can also only take on oneself these suffering of beings through inhaling. Then from one standpoint, this practice of Tonglen, or giving and taking, is an effortless, an easy one, because it is a mental process. It involves neither speech nor body. Then, as I said, from one standpoint is it easy since it does not involve physical or verbal effort.

Then on the other hand, one does have to study these topics, study is not easy, which of the two ways more that is for you to say? Then, dharma is mental transformation. It is the means to obviate or eliminate mental suffering. As it is a mental transformation, it is in a sense easier than anything which calls for physical or verbal effort. Dharma does not call for physical or verbal effort in that sense.

There’s a change in our outlook. So when one engages in Tonglen and one takes upon oneself the suffering of others and one gives others one happiness and virtue, obviously this is not something which is being done in actuality. The suffering of others remains theirs. But we engage in this practice of Tonglen to transform our own minds. Then these three realizations of the three paths, the path shared as the being of the small, the middling and the great scope, amount to nothing else than transformations of our outlook, mental transformations.

This has little or nothing to do with our physical body and our contingent situation. Now it is precisely because we are unable to give up short term contingent happiness that we are unable to gain these realizations and that we are unable to gain mental peace. That does not mean when I say to give up short term contingent happiness that we should cease to engage in physical or verbal activities. These are after all necessary to avoid physical suffering. Then I have nothing left to add, at present I will take questions, One question per person please and short concise questions.

The wish to achieve enlightenment for the benefit of all beings is a motivation. Can someone have that motivation and still choose to ignore someone and not help them? And if that is the case, why would they do that? So you are referring to Bodhicitta, in other words, the mind which wishes to attain enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings without exception. Now, once such a mind is generated, it would have to be generated incontrovertibly.

Whether that necessarily entails helping every individual sentient beings at a given point is open to question, it is not certain. Then Japha Chopal, I suspect that you are referring to physical suffering. And obviously eliminating physical suffering is important, but what matters the most is eliminating mental suffering. Then obviously it is important to eliminate physical sufferings through giving food, drink and so forth, but at best that offers transitory happiness. What offers stable, durable happiness is eliminating mental suffering.

That is what we have to focus upon. And Nada? Yeshila, if I heard correctly, you said that in the practice of Tonglen, the suffering of others remains theirs. That is certainly the case for beginners like us, but is this always the case, including for highly highly realized beings? Keeping in mind that the Buddha cannot liberate by his hand.

Yes, it is said that suffering and happiness depend on the subtle winds and holy beings obviously are able to experience the suffering of others upon themselves through taking these winds, at least so it is said. Suffering is a sensation, a sensation is a mind. Minds ride on the subtle winds. Now, when powerful concentration, a Samadhi, is generated, then obviously it would be possible to gain control of these winds and reduce the suffering of others. So, however, once one has gained realization of Tonglen, of giving and taking, there is no definiteness about one’s actually taking the sufferings of others upon oneself.

For instance, if we take the example of a mother with a child, let’s say of one or two years of age, At that age, the mother feels extraordinary love for that child and if she had to give her life for that child, she would give her life without any doubt. But there is no definiteness that she will have to do so. So when a baby is or a little child is one or two years of age, obviously at that age they are adorable and this continues until around age three and after that it changes. But around age one or two, the mother can only think really of the baby I suspect and she would be ready to do anything for that baby including giving her life. However, it is rare for her to actually give her life for her baby.

Not that she’s not ready to do so, but the circumstances of her having to give her life do not arise. Then obviously we are very biased here, we talk about moms all the time, but I think fathers probably have these feelings too. However, frankly in my own experience, it is the mothers who take mostly care of children, fathers are only occasionally there, that is why the relation is so close with the mother. In practice of giving one’s happiness, so just to expand on the definition of giving one’s happiness, is the emphasis there on reducing self cherishing or compassion or generosity? Just In the practice of Tongle, or giving and taking, when we say to give one’s happiness to other and to take their suffering apart on oneself, actually the only difference between these two practices is nominal.

The meaning is the same. Likewise, as far as compassion and love is concerned, there is a nominal difference, But the meaning of love and compassion is the same. In the Pabanca Lamm Rim, the section on tongling starts with the advice to practice first on yourself. I have a question about that because here in the West, so many of us seem to have a really poor opinion, self opinion, self esteem of ourselves and we find that very difficult to actually give compassion to oneself. Could Geshela say something about that please?

So before engaging in studies such as the study of Tonglen in these advanced practices, the mind must be put in its natural place if you wish. It must become impartial, unbiased or if you prefer, untroubled. One must address the psychological problems first. So as is said, in Shantideva’s bodhisattva Acharyavatara engage in this practice of exchange of self and others in the greatest secrecy. And this was the policy of the Kadampas of Yor, for which these teachings on the equalization and the interchange of self and others were secret or confidential teachings as opposed to public teachings.

Once we have attained liberation, it doesn’t mean that we’ve entered the path of accumulation. Can Geshela explain what path of accumulation is? So, you may be confusing the mind striving for liberation and liberation. When you have attained liberation, obviously you have already entered the path of accumulation and gone through all five paths. But, when you generate for the first time an uncontrived mind striving for liberation, then you have not yet entered the path of accumulation.

Another. You pass, you can pass. I’m just referring to the secrecy of the teachings of the practice of Tonglen previously in the time of the Kadampas. Was that because it was not seemed to be appropriate for people who do have psychological problems? No, I don’t think it is related to the issue of protecting people with psychological problems, instead it is due to the fact that sharp trainees normally would realize the view first.

And then an understanding of the view would give rise to the understanding that self and other are mutually dependent. There is no other which can be postulated without depending on a self nor can a self be postulated without depending on another. Then such an understanding of the interdependence of self and other is of great benefit to generating the interchange of self and others. Once one understands the numerous faults of self cherishing, then one progresses rapidly to understanding that others are like one’s self. And this gives rise to an understanding of the interdependence of self and others.

Chris, I have a question? Is it a digression to be in doing Tong Ling to then digress into thinking about the I that needs to be negated when in doing the giving and taking self cherishing arises and then to deviate into then examining that the nature of that self? Or should one stick to just the Tong Ling and then reflect on that afterwards? Fundamentally, once one understands clearly the mutual dependency of self and others, then the practice of Tonglen becomes much easier. So on that basis Geshela, is it appropriate when we are looking at others, especially those we have challenges with, to perceive them as oneself in order to relate to and dissolve what is constructing the other?

Excuse me, especially those, I didn’t catch the word. That we may find difficult to relate to or have empathy with. This is very good, what you are actually talking about is the interchange of self and others. When you think of another person with whom you’re having difficulties and think, well, this person wishes for happiness like me, this person fears suffering like me, in that respect we are similar, it’s a form of practice of interchange of self and others. Okay, stop here tonight, thank you everyone.

Key terms in this teaching

four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA
taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top