Lam Rim – 20092017Lamrim(Salam5

1 h 34 min · 4,632 words

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 20092017Lamrim(Salam5
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. This session continues the Lam Rim teaching on the path of meditation. It explains the subtle mind that carries over between lives, how coarse minds depend on the brain, and why the Lam Rim does not treat rebirth in detail. It also covers calm abiding and why arya beings no longer accumulate impelling karma. Questions from students on the subtle mind, dreams and death are answered.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 34m

UUID: eda613be-3512-4e87-bdf4-b30c2b37d2d4

Words: 4,628

Mhmm. Human beings are really remarkable. And when we say human beings are remarkable, we really refer to their thinking or perhaps if you prefer their brains. So when we say that human beings are extraordinary or human rebirth is fundamental, this begs the question just why? What makes it fundamental?

Then it is precisely this capacity to think which makes it fundamental. Otherwise, it is like that Tibetan jewel, the z we should have spoke about last time, which is completely useless. Then if you take the z for instance, then it is completely useless from its own side. We can’t eat it. We can’t do anything practical with it.

So when we say that a human rebirth is exceptionally important, we have to explain why. So and here, when the Lam Rim and its outline, as Geshe-la explained last time, says that one must first identify rebirth of leisure and endowment and then engage in practice. And the key practice for the being the path of beings of the small scope is meditation on death and impermanence. These two are to be practiced inseparably. Now here, when we speak of practicing inseparably, this means to practice some side by side.

There is nothing terribly mysterious about the term inseparable or indissociable. Now when we speak of the human mental capacity, it is extraordinary. We can investigate what happened thousands of years in the past, and we can project ourselves in the future many lives in the future. This is the reason for which actually in secret mantra, it is said that the human base is the only real base on which practice is possible. So there’s a lot of food for thought in this.

Then this mental capacity enables us to investigate whatever we wish, and this investigation leads us to investigating the subtle mind. The subtle mind is that which transmigrates from previous lives to future lives. Now this subtle mind can only be accessed through initially study. At present, we have no control over it. And in the Chitamatra tradition, the subtle mind is called the mind basis of all or the aliyavijnana.

Then in our own cases, whereas the subtle mind does exist within our mental continuum. It is a mind which we are at present completely unable to use. So here, Geshe-la explained many times the reason for which the topic of past and future lives of reincarnation is not treated in detail in the Lam Rim, and this is simply because the intended trainees of the Lam Rim were beings who had a profound conviction in the existence of past and future lives, and therefore, it was unnecessary. Just as for instance, in secret mantra, there is very little treatment of the common aspect of the path, the shared aspect of the path. In other words, the three principles of the path, which are definite emergence, bodhicitta and the correct view, or if you prefer, the path shared with the beings of the three scopes, the path shared with the being of the small, the middling and the great scope.

Now in your own cases, you all seem to enjoy greatly secret mantra, but the foundation of secret mantra is the three principles of the path. And Geshe-la cannot say that every one of you has these foundations. But if these foundations are absent, they must be generated initially. Mhmm. Do you understand?

As says in the foundation of good qualities after making the common path its foundation. And this indicates the importance before engaging in the practice of secret mantra of a solid grounding in the common path. And the great beings of old said, implant good karmic imprints. Then this is something all of us should do. But frankly, to practice tantra correctly, you need initially the foundation of the three principles of the path.

So therefore, frankly, to practice tantra correctly and authentically, it is indispensable to have had an experience of these three principles of the path, which are the foundation. Likewise, as was explained, the intended trainees of the Lam Rim were fundamentally Tibetans. In other words, they were people who had a deep conviction in the existence of past and future lives. For this reason, past and future lives reincarnation was not explained in detail. However, if one wishes to explain it in detail, the best way to do so is through explaining the subtle mind.

So then how precisely do we understand or can we understand this subtle mind? It is precisely through our faculties of analysis and investigation. This subtle mind does not depend on the neurological substructure of the brain. In the self same way, for instance, the sensory consciousnesses depend on the brain and on the nervous system. Now the sensory consciousnesses give us no access whatsoever to such a subtle mind and to the reincarnation of this mind.

If this were the case, then we could understand them in terms of heredity, our parents, in other words, of genetics. Now for instance, if you take the example of the aging process, when people grow older and hit the ages of 70, 80, 90, then as they grow older, they become more and more like children. Why is this the case? Simply because with age, the neurological structures which support the coarse consciousnesses decay, and we have no access to the subtle consciousness. So one becomes like an infant.

Now this is well known, obviously, with the exception of great beings such as the root teacher of who who passed passed on around the age of 93 or 94 and whose mind had extraordinary clarity like ours until the end or Kensur Kangyo Rinpoche himself whose mind retained complete clarity till the end. In our own cases, however, as we grow old, our coarse mental faculties decline. And at the same time, we remain completely unable to use the subtle minds which are present. So we end up like infants, like children. Now let us establish a parallel with the birth process.

When a child is born from the womb of

Mother. At that point, the child has almost no sensation. The subtle mind is present, but the coarse minds, depend on the brain and ultimately on the spermatozoa and the egg of the parents, therefore, finally on genetics, have not yet developed. Then as a child grows older, eventually, over the months and years, these coarse sensory consciousnesses are able to develop. This is exactly parallel to the process of dissolution of the coarse minds into the subtle minds.

So we have a process where coarse minds dawn out of the subtle minds and another one at death where the coarse minds dissolve in the subtle minds. Then it behooves us to identify this subtle mind. Once it is identified, we can use it. Mhmm. Do you understand?

It’s precisely because we are unable at present to use the subtle mines and rely on coarse mines that we have major doubts regarding the existence of past and future lives since these are not the remit of coarse mines. We have no access to past and future lives via coarse minds. But once we become able to use subtle minds, the situation changes completely. So please reflect on this carefully. So, therefore, when the infant is conceived and born, the main mind which is present is the mind basis of all.

And whether at in accordance with Chitamatra, and whether at this point the afflicted mind, in other words, grasping at itself is present or not is something which has to be investigated. As Ārya Vasubandhu says in the Triṃśikā, in the 30 verses, it, in other words, the afflicted mind, arises out of the ālāyavijñāna and depends on it. Now this implies an incremental process of development from the ālāyavijñāna to the appearance of the afflicted mind. This is a difficult topic. It’s a difficult topic, but if you are able to reflect a bit about it, it is quite profound.

So as Geshe was saying, it’s a difficult topic, but if you’re able to do so, think about it a bit. In our own cases at present, what we have access to are coarse consciousnesses. These coarse consciousnesses are so coarse, they disappear in the sleep state Mhmm. Which lets you imagine. Then, obviously, these coarse consciousnesses arise from the union of the father’s spermatozoa and the mother’s ovocyte, the ovum.

In other words, they arise ultimately from heredity and genetics. Then in Tibet, certainly, children, at least in Geisha’s time now, he doesn’t know, but children, both male and female, lived with their parents. They did not there was very little adoption. They didn’t live on the outside. And, obviously, one sees that children who are born from good families, you know, it’s a good social milieu, typically grow up themselves as being good people.

Now, ultimately, when we speak of a good family or good social milieu, what are we speaking about if not studies? Education. Then, obviously, in a case like this, these children’s brains at the end of the day arise from a fertilized egg, which shares genetic material from both parents. Therefore, there’s a genetic component. And these children are raised in the way in which their parents think, which is a cultural component.

Then apart from this, I am sure you think, what place is there for past and future lives? Do you understand? So this is why his holy name is Dalai Lama frequently quotes this verse from the Tathagatagarbha Sutras, the sutras of the Buddha nature, in which it is said, the nature of the mind is clear light. And this clear light refers to a fundamental mind which is completely pure and in which the afflictions are adventitious or secondary. Likewise, as Dharma Kirti says in Pramāna Varticum, the afflictions are adventitious.

The nature of the mind is clear light. Here, what this means, the term clear refers to the purity of the mind. And the fact that the afflictions are adventitious means that they are not permanently there. They are subsidiary to this mind. And as again, so Kangyo Rinpoche said many times when teaching the Lam Rim, and this must be something you have heard, we must deposit karmic imprints, but it is not easy to do so.

And indeed, it is not easy to deposit karmic imprints in the subtle mind. One must put effort for this to happen. Now once one is able to do so, one begins to be able to use a subtle mind. In Chitamatra, this subtle mind is known as the ālāyavijñāna or the mind basis of all. Then in Prāsaṇgika and Svatāntrika Madhyamaka, the term ālāyavijñāna is not used.

So one would just speak of subtle mind. Now this subtle mind is not only present in human beings, but also in animals. The thinking capacities which make a human being, these are specific to human beings and to the human brain. It is self evident they are not present in animals. So it is on the basis of the existence of the subtle mind in animals that we say in Buddhist texts that all sentient beings can attain enlightenment.

That’s the way it is. How is good? Do you like to meditation? Good? Now here, when we speak of subtle minds, this begins with calm abiding.

Then you love calm abiding. You love to meditate, don’t you? Then it is calm abiding which actually is the beginning of meditation. So this depends on calm abiding. So calm abiding in Tibetan is composed of two syllables, shi and ne.

Shi means peace or pacification. What exactly is pacified? What is pacified is the outwards distraction of the mind, the mind moving outwards to sense objects. Then all of us can see based on direct experience that it is mainly the visual and the auditory consciousnesses which are concerned. It is visual objects and sounds which distract the mind outwards.

Now this distraction must be pacified, and the mind must be withdrawn inwards. This is what calm and calm abiding means. So we can see that the vast majority of desire and hatred, friendships, and enmities arise in dependence on the visual consciousness and the auditory consciousness. The visual consciousness is the controlling condition, and the auditory consciousness is the immediately preceding condition which give rise either to desire or to anger. Now through controlling these, eventually, we are able to withdraw the mind inwards and give rise to calm abiding.

Calm abiding itself, however, is not sufficient to be able to gain control over the subtle mind. So this is a meaning of the first syllable of calm abiding. Shi pacification means to pacify the outward distraction of the sensory consciousnesses and mental consciousness and withdraw them inwards. Now the second syllable, and she in this context means to stop or to block. In other words, to stop or to block distraction.

Ne means to abide or to dwell. To abide or to dwell in a relaxed fashion focused on the object of meditation. This is calm abiding.

So the main source of exterior distraction of the mind are the visual and auditory consciousnesses. Therefore, when we are able to pacify them and withdraw the mind inwards, probably it can stay inwards. And what is necessary to pacify this exterior agitation of the mind? Contentment. Once we are able to generate contentment, the mind can be withdrawn inwards and can remain focused on its object.

Then this is something one has to experience for oneself. Geshe la says you have received many teachings. There’s no point in talking endlessly. You should meditate and check for yourselves. So if we do not train the mind in a selflessness which counters self grasping, but instead focus on training on calm abiding, then after attaining calm abiding, we will attain ever more subtle and more powerful states of meditation.

And if we do not have renunciation, then independence on these very subtle and powerful states of meditation, we will be reborn in what is known as the peak of existence. This is the pinnacle of psychic existence. Now this is the quest of the non Buddhist philosophers of India. So these are the four dhyanas, the path of the four dhyanas of ordinary beings. So this is the reason for which it is taught that at the beginning, when one wants to gain a calm abiding, one must live in solitude as a hermit simply to reduce the amount of visual and auditory stimulations.

Obviously, if you live downtown and you constantly can see what’s in the windows of shops and hear music, just how exactly do you intend to attain calm abiding? Some even when they meditate, Keshe believes wear earphones. Then what hope do you have? Sorry. My apologies.

Some when they meditate wear earplugs. But none of this happens quickly. One has to practice incrementally, and the most important is contentment. So, therefore, we have to try to find means to cause the subtle mind to become manifest. But initially, this must be upheld by the motivation of definite emergence and in addition by the motivation of bodhicitta.

Then if you can live in isolation and in a country like this, it is perfect. There’s not a lot of sound. There are no interferences. Obviously, if you live in a village, then it’s another story. So at present, let us meditate during a couple of minutes on the fact that the most important thing to give rise to calm abiding is to put an end to the activities of the visual and of the auditory consciousness, which are the main sources of distraction we have, and that the immediately preceding condition for this is practice of contentment.

In other words, we need definite emergence. So when after reflecting on the faults of cyclic existence, one enters, for instance, in meditation, then this probably qualifies as the accumulation of uncontaminated virtuous deeds motivated by what amounts to definite emergence. When, on the other hand, motivated by the ignorance grasping at a self, one engages, for instance, in the practice of generosity or protecting ethics with, as a motivation, the wish to gain a higher rebirth in later lives, this amounts to contaminated virtuous deeds. This is the difference between uncontaminated and contaminated virtuous deeds. So this is the reason for which calm abiding is important because one must engage in a samadhi, which is an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness.

And for this, one needs calm abiding as a preliminary. Now specifically, from the middling level of the Mahāyāna path of accumulation, one needs a calm abiding focused on emptiness. But since this will confuse you, let us make a more general statement. At the level of the Mahāyāna path of calm abiding, one need Mahāyāna path of accumulation, one needs a calm abiding focused on emptiness. Now as far as the presentation of salaam of grounds and paths is concerned, we have reached the point of the presentation of the path of meditation.

As you remember last time, Geshe la presented the path of seeing, which is the first time during which one gains a direct realization of emptiness or one sees emptiness nakedly. Now this is not uninterrupted. There is a point where that path of seeing will be interrupted, will stop, and one will engage in whatever activities one chooses to engage in. When after doing so, one returns to meditation, then at that point, initially, in Geshe la’s opinion, when one meditates on emptiness, one will not gain a direct realization of emptiness, but one will have to meditate in on it conceptually independence on a meaning generality, but very rapidly, one will gain again a direct realization of emptiness, one will perceive emptiness at that point. And at that point, one has entered the, Mahāyāna path

Of meditation in keeping with Maitreya’s statement in the Mahayānasūtrālamkara in which he says the path of meditation is the subsequent manifest realization of truth. Subsequent here means subsequent or after a severance, a cutting. So here, the Mahayānasūtrālamkara says that the Mahāyāna path of meditation is a Mahāyāna path of subsequent That on the path of meditation, truth, in other words, emptiness becomes manifest subsequently or again. And what this means is that one reenters in meditation on emptiness, and one puts once again great effort or will have to continue to do so because one’s goal is to eliminate the innate grasping at a self. So as you remember, what initiated this presentation of Salam was Geshe la’s quoting a passage of Vasubandhu, which says, after attaining the path of an ārya being, there is no longer any impelling karma which can be accumulated, but non virtuous karma can be accumulated.

So why do you think this is the case? So after obtaining an ārya path will no longer accumulates impelling karma. Why? Do you understand the difference between an ordinary being and an ārya being Which one? So what is what?

An ārya being has a non conceptual direct realization of emptiness. An ordinary being does not have a non conceptual realization of emptiness. So at the beginning, we agreed that the distinction between an ordinary being and an ārya being is having or not having the direct realization of emptiness. So this being so, why at the level of an aria is there no accumulation of impelling karma? An ārya being has a direct, non-conceptual realization of emptiness.

Therefore, they no longer apprehend the subtle mind or the as an I. Therefore, they have severed the ignorance that grasps at a self. So, actually, the term ālāyavijñāna is not used in the Lam Rim. It’s specific to Chitamatra. So if we replace it by subtle mind, what exactly are you saying?

That the ignorance grasping at itself has been severed because the wisdom realizing realizing emptiness no longer apprehends a self within the subtle mind? Why? When one has become an ārya, does one no longer accumulate impelling karma? I’m just going to quote, I think it’s from a sūtra. Once one has seen the truth, there is no more impelling.

And once one is bereft of craving, there is no more rebirth. Okay. That’s a scriptural quote, but Geshe was giving a commentary on that. Yeah. Yep.

Because the root cause which leads to impelling karma is the ignorance which grasps at a self, and a aria being has a non conceptual realization of emptiness of the I which severs that root of ignorance. Therefore, Another? In aria being, they get rid of the affliction of the mind afflicted mind. So they don’t have any more of that. So they they get rid of the, how you say, impelling karma?

Definite emergence must be attained before becoming an aria. There is a relation with definite emergence, but why do you ask? There is a relation of different things. So the first of the 12 links would be of ignorance is cut and therefore cannot give rise to the second. Similar to what’s been said, grasping at an inherent self is the basis for accumulating causes for uncontrolled rebirth in cyclic existence.

And so direct realization of emptiness removes the cause for accumulating the karma of being reborn in cyclic existence and such a being then accumulates the causes for liberation instead. So you answered well. Your answers were well thought out. To refine what you said, we can say that an Ārya being has gained a direct realization of emptiness. This direct realization of emptiness’s mode of apprehension is directly opposite to the mode of apprehension of beginningless ignorance.

It is better to say beginningless ignorance. Therefore, as a result of this, an aria being cannot accumulate impelling karma since the root cause of impelling karma is precisely beginningless ignorance. Now it is not the case, as someone said, that Ārya beings do not have any afflictions, have abandoned afflictions. That is not the case. Okay.

Then if you have questions, please ask your questions at present. We don’t say that calm abiding is an aspiration or a wish. It is a Samādhi. Therefore, it is a concentration. There is no definiteness that the calm abiding focused on emptiness has a realization of emptiness.

Mhmm. There are cases where it does and cases where it doesn’t. For calm abiding to observe or to be focused on emptiness means that calm abiding remains in a relaxed fashion, single pointedly concentrated on emptiness. Okay. Geshe la, earlier on you spoke about the coarse mind and the subtle mind, and you said that the coarse mind is not functioning when we’re asleep.

And if we can’t access our subtle mind after we’ve grown up, what mind is dreaming? So here, when Geshe refers to sleep, he refers to the deep sleep in which there are no dreams. Then when there are dreams, actually, we have started to wake up, and we will wake up soon as a matter of fact. Earlier this evening, you said that the coarse mind was hereditary and from DNA. Then what part does does past and future lives play in the coarse mind?

There’s no real relationship between our coarse minds and our past and future lives. There is a relationship between our subtle mind and our past and future lives. The subtle mind is related to our past and future lives. Coarse minds such as our visual consciousness and so forth ultimately arise independence on the biological base of the union of the spermatozoa and the ovum of our parents. At what age is the the the, you know, the baby, they have they start develop coarse mind, and at what age is we know that we access to our subtle mind in the old age.

So when we grow old, unless we have engaged in study, it is impossible to use the subtle mind. The subtle mind becomes naturally manifest only in the death state, and that’s a natural process. So for as to the age at which child children develop coarse consciousnesses, Geshe la isn’t quite sure. I was telling to him, you are parents. You know.

Geshe la doesn’t have kids. I don’t have kids. Geshe la, just following on from Jad’s question, I would feel I I would think that the coarse consciousnesses would have some relation to the subtle mind and therefore past and future lives just in terms of it’s our coarse consciousnesses which often lead us into creating negative karma or certainly developing negative karma. And the even the body and mental consciousness that we have this lifetime is the result of past lives, of past karma. So isn’t there a subtle relationship between the coarse consciousness and rebirth?

Yes. There is grounds for saying that if you look at it from the standpoint of the coarse minds being infusers and the subtle mind being a base of infusion. So Gesheera thinks it’s a very good line of thinking. He would investigate it himself how coarse minds infuse subtle mind with virtues and non virtues which carry on to future lives. Anyway, Anyway see, I don’t have to translate everything in anyway, as Chatral Rinpoche has said, it is extremely important for us to die with a virtuous mind because if we die with a virtuous mind, it is guaranteed we would have a higher rebirth.

But it is not possible to die with a with a virtuous mind without having trained in this over one’s life. Do you understand? So in brief, to die in a virtuous state of mind, it is indispensable to train in virtuous minds now. Otherwise, it is impossible. Then if we can die with a virtuous state of mind, we die in peace, at ease.

Okay. Susie? I’m really confused. I’m sorry. If the subtle mind No.

Good. Thank you. Thing I like subtle math. Exactly. If it’s something that at present we can’t use, but then when we train and we are able to access the subtle mind, and then we can see the past and the present times, But then you say the subtle mind is only accessed at the time of death.

Well, how do we know that? Because none of us So Geshe-la likes very much your sincere and honest questions. He finds them useful. Then as far as the subtle mind is concerned, at present, we cannot use it. But we cannot use it if we don’t study it.

It’s a general statement. If we study, it’s a different situation. Then at the time of death, the subtle mind manifests. It’s known as a clear mind of death, but it manifests naturally. Then unless we have trained in using it, it is impossible to use it.

Clint, do you understand? I hope I get you there. Okay. Thank you. So it is not easy, in other words.

The very essence of secret mantra is a manifestation of the subtle mind and its usage for meditating on emptiness. Then in the Pāramitāyāna, the vehicle of perfections, our teacher Buddha Śākyamūni had to train for three countless eons to be able to manifest the subtle mind. So this is not easy. Okay. Thank you.

Stubbing here tonight. Have you question? Okay. Sorry. So this is a post stop question.

Right? Okay. Is that a question or a statement? So from our standpoint, the minds of a being in the death state are very subtle. But a being has actually both subtle and coarse minds from his own perspective.

His or her perspective. Okay.

Key terms in this teaching

clear light ö sel (Tib)
The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

What role do past and future lives play in the coarse mind?

There is no real relationship between the coarse mind and our past and future lives. The relationship with past and future lives belongs to the subtle mind. Coarse minds, such as visual consciousness and so forth, ultimately arise in dependence on a biological base, namely the union of the spermatozoa and the ovum of our parents. So the coarse mind is tied to this physical basis, while it is the subtle mind that connects to past and future lives.

Scroll to Top