Lam Rim – 1B – Talks 1991 – KR

46 min · 2,639 words · 1991

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 1B - Talks 1991 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains the Four Noble Truths as a framework of three factors each: the entity, the activity, and the agent. It covers true sufferings as impermanent and contaminated, the true sources of ignorance and karma that must be abandoned, true cessation as liberation, and the true path of wisdom realizing selflessness that one must cultivate personally. A closing question and answer distinguishes the self to be refuted, which exists independently of the aggregates, from the nominally existent self that relies on them.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 47 min

UUID: 9eb70592-c7fb-492a-a2bd-6b8320a5923d

Words: 2,635

So, he was pointing of the two at our body and saying it is in the nature of suffering. That is an embodiment which is assumed under the force of afflictive emotions and karma. And he said, This is a superior’s true suffering. Suffering. And so a superior, an ārya, is one who has direct realization of emptiness.

And having attained this high quality, they saw that this type of embodiment embodiment as in the nature of suffering. And, you know, generally when we talk, if what we say is factual, we say, oh, that’s true. Or, we talk about something and it turns out to be non factual, we say it’s false. So, he was saying that what is seen as suffering by an ārya or a superior who has had direct realization of emptiness, what they see as suffering is true. This is the way it is.

Factual. Therefore, it was described as being a superior’s true suffering. That is to say, a suffering it is a it is true. It is factual that this embodiment is seen as suffering by superiors those who have a direct realization of emptiness. So here he was talking about the the nature or the entity.

So the embodiment is in the nature of suffering. It’s an entity of suffering. But just as in the cup, we want to not only know the entity of the cup, we want to be able to recognize the cup as a cup. Likewise, we want to be able to recognize suffering as suffering. And so this is the second of these two factors, of these three factors.

That is the activity. They’re recognizing the suffering, the true sufferings as true sufferings. So, understanding the nature as being suffering, then we try to recognize then that nature is to be recognized or to be known. Suffering is to be known as suffering. Just as in the case of but then to go on, one should come to know suffering as suffering.

Just as in the case of a cup full of tea, tea is something to be drunk. That is we can understand that tea is something to be drunk. But then there involves an agent, someone who actually does the drinking. Likewise, the appropriated contaminated aggregates have a nature of suffering. That suffering that suffering is is to be recognized as suffering, one should come to know that suffering as suffering.

So the agent. So the one should know for oneself suffering as suffering. So, the aggregates are in the nature of suffering. This suffering is to be known. Oneself should recognize or come to know that one’s aggregates are in the nature of suffering as the agent who knows.

And how are we we to know that the aggregates are in the nature of suffering? Firstly, that the aggregates have a characteristic of impermanence. That is to say that they momentarily arise and disintegrate. They are not stable. They’re quickly lost.

So they are of our body and mind. Our body is not stable. It’s simply momentarily. It’s quickly lost. It disintegrates.

But not only is the body impermanent, but it’s also in the nature of suffering. That is because the body was assumed under the force of karma and afflictive emotions. That because if it’s the causes which brought it about are unhealthy, then the product is unhealthy. But not only is the body impermanent, but the the I which is imputed to the body impermanent, you know, the I which appropriates the aggregates, the appropriator of the aggregates. You know, that that some hold that the this I is permanent, that it’s independently existent, that we have a conception that the I is permanent, that this I, the I which goes, which eats, which sleeps, which works.

But in fact this I is again impermanent. It is momentarily arising and disintegrating. So the the I which is imputed to the aggregates is not such a permanent self that that there is a that it is the aggregates are selfless or are empty of such a type of self. So the I which is empty and selfless is to be understood that if by seeing all of these various faults and that there is no a permanently existent I if there was a permanent existent I then there would be no achievement of liberation. It is by coming to understand the non existence of this permanent existent I, our selflessness, that we are able to achieve liberation, that we can achieve liberation from cyclic existence.

So if the if the self which is imputed to the body, the was permanent. That this I, that I that goes, that eats, that does things, if this I was not selfless then there could be no liberation. One cannot abandon cyclic existence. But because this I is selfless that it is impermanent and without self, and one can achieve liberation. So it is grasping at the self which keeps us circling within cyclic existence, is the basic cause of cyclic existence.

That it is due to this grasping ignorance which grasps at a permanent independent self which causes us to take rebirth again and again, continually experiencing suffering. It is through that this process is set in motion under the power of ignorance. Under the power of ignorance we engage in various actions create karma which as a result we experience various types of suffering. So and we again and again take rebirth. It is by meditating on selflessness that we are able to remove from its very root ignorance and thereby achieve liberation.

This ignorance grasping at self is a true source of suffering or that is a true sources. It is under the force of the ignorance grasping itself that we keep we continually circle within cyclic existence. Due to the force of ignorance, we engage in various types of actions which bring about result in suffering. It is these two factors, ignorance and that and the actions which arise out of ignorance, which are the sources of our suffering. And this is referred to as two sources.

And in Tibetan, this is the Tibetan word for true sources. What is translated as true sources is or and there’s two syllables. Means all. Means arising. So what this means is that all suffering arises from these two factors.

That is the ignorance and the karma, are engaged in under the influence of ignorance. So this is the second noble truth. The superior’s true sources. That is to say, they are superior’s true sources because this is the way they were seen by superiors. And that they saw these two factors as being the two sources of suffering.

Therefore, referred to as superiors, two sources. So that’s the entity of two sources, karma and afflictive emotions. And then as we mentioned with in respect to the first noble truth that there are the three activities or three factors that of its entity or nature, the activity and the agent. And the entity of true sources is karma and afflictive emotions. The activity is that true sources are to be abandoned.

In the case of true sufferings, we said true sufferings are to be recognized or understood. In the case of true sources, we are to abandon true sources. That is to say karma and afflictive emotions. Is that the true sources ignorance and the karma arising out of ignorance are to be abandoned. That’s the activity.

And then, who is to abandon? The agent? Oneself. So one is to abandon these two sources. So why are we to abandon true sources?

Because we don’t want to suffer. And these are true sources are the causes of suffering. If we do not eliminate true sources then we’re never going to eliminate suffering from its root. Without eliminating true sources then we’re always going to have to experience the result and sufferings from these causes. So in order to eliminate suffering, it’s necessary to eliminate its cause.

Its cause are these two sources ignorance and the actions engaged in under its influence. So an analogy would be if we lived in a valley The rains were continually flowing down the mountainside and flooding ourselves. And we weren’t happy about this situation. Long as you know, so in order to alleviate that suffering, we have to trace the sources. We have to trace the cause of our problem back to its source and tracing it back to where the water is flowing down from the mountains.

And we have to dam it unless we block the flow of that water. We’re going to be continually being flooded out. And it’s never going to end because the cause is continually present. Without damming the water, we’re going to continue to experience our problem. If we dam the water, if we block the water, then our problem is eliminated.

So, it is through the taking of a body that we experience all our troubles. So, we have to achieve a state where we no longer assume such assume again a body. That is, that we have to in order to do that, and we have to remove its cause for the taking of embodiment. And that is ignorance and karma, which are true sources. These two sources are the basis for experiencing all of our sufferings.

They are our causes. So therefore, we are to eliminate two sources. So in this in in it previously presented analogy where, you know, one one resides in a valley and one is continually being flooded out. And one simply is a circumstance where one experiences a great deal of suffering and one wants to remove that condition. You know, what does one basically want?

One wants the happiness of not experiencing that suffering. And out of that one is moved to trace the source, the problem, to which is bringing about the problem, the flooding and to bring it to an end. So one goes about implementing the method to block the source of the problem, thinking that one wants to achieve a happiness which is a freedom from this suffering. To the third of the Four Noble Truths, and that is to say true cessations. That this is the nature of a superior’s true cessation. So from where does our suffering originate?

It comes from we understand that it comes from ignorance and karma. And so these are to be abandoned. That in order to stop our suffering we eliminate these causes. And therefore understanding this we strive to bring it into these causes, that we bring a cessation to our suffering. Just as in the case of wanting to we block the water in order to prevent the suffering of continually being flooded out.

We want to eliminate our suffering. We want to abandon our suffering. So this abandon abandonment of our suffering is a cessation. So we are to abandon the suffering which is to be abandoned. So a superior’s true cessation is the abandonment of the suffering which is to be abandoned, the ridding of that suffering which is to be gotten rid of.

So this complete cessation of this suffering is a superior’s true cessation. So, this cessation is the abandonment of suffering. It is a liberation. So, again, with respect to cessation, there are these having identified the entity of what we mean by cessation that there is the activity involved, and the activity is that cessation are to be actualized. And what it means actualized is that these true cessation are to be attained that this represents the elimination of our suffering, the attainment or the of true cessation.

Then, with respect to the agent, who is to actualize these cessation? Oneself. It is one itself must eliminate one’s own suffering. Therefore, one self must actualize these cessation of one’s own suffering. No one no one other than oneself can do this.

So this is the agent in terms of who is to perform the actualization, oneself. The the foe destroyers or the arhats have attained true cessation, but their attainment of true cessation doesn’t benefit ourselves. One has to attain true cessation for oneself. So one determines that I really have to attain a true cessation if I’m ever going to experience a happiness divorced of any suffering? And what is the means?

How I go about achieving that? This brings us to the fourth of the Four Noble Truths, the Superior’s True Paths. Here, what is meant by a true path? Path is like a road that we travel. And here we’re traveling down the road of liberation.

By means of traveling down the road, we go from where we are to our destination. And here our destination is liberation to bring about an actualization of true cessation. And that road, that path, is path of the wisdom directly realizing selflessness. The wisdom directly realizing selflessness is a true path. So that’s the entity.

And then the entity being the wisdom directly realizing selflessness, and then activity with respect to is that true paths are to be cultivated that we are trying we must travel down this road to this destination. And the way we do that is through cultivation of true paths, or meditation of true paths. And that is to say, to ourselves that true paths are to be cultivated in terms of developing the wisdom, understanding, selflessness that we are developed this quality. And in terms of the agent, who is to do the cultivating? One self necessarily must cultivate for one self.

It’s of no use if someone else travels down the road. It doesn’t get you to your destination. One self must cultivate the path for oneself. If one goes oneself, then one will arrive at the destination. Okay.

So we’ll spend a few minutes on questions. Can a self realize no self? So there are two selves. There is self which is to be refuted, and there is the nominally existent self. So the self which is to be refuted.

Is to be its non existence is to be understood, and that which understands this is the nominally existent self. The wisdom of that nominally existent self understands the nonexistence of the self which is to be refuted. So, what is the self which is to be refuted? That is a the the self which does not rely upon the five aggregates. They have five aggregates aggregates of forms, feelings, perceptions, mental constructions, and consciousnesses.

So that self which does not rely upon the five aggregates, does not rely upon the continuum, the continuity of these five aggregates, which exists independent of these five aggregates. That is the self which is to be refuted or negated. So the object, the self which is being negated, that is to say the self which does not rely upon the aggregates, that self does not exist. But the the I which, that the self which relies upon the aggregates, which is imputed to the aggregates, that self which says I go, I eat, that self exists. So, in the case of Jampa, the I which is imputed to his body and aggregates, that which is designated the I which is designated to that that body and aggregates that I exists.

That that that I that wears monk’s clothing, monk’s robes, it it translates, it writes, it eats food. So, but the I which is not reliant upon the five aggregates does not exist. There is no phenomena which which exists independently which does not rely upon something else. Everything is reliant or dependent. So the self which relies upon the five aggregates exists.

The self which does not rely upon the five aggregates does not exist.

Key terms in this teaching

contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top