Lam Rim — 2017-05-06

Lam Rim (Ilia Durovic)
Lam Rim (Ilia Durovic)
Lam Rim — 2017-05-06
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 06052017ILIA PART2 2.mp3

UUID: 3d67ae8e-7158-414a-a149-24185733afd7

Teacher: Ilia Durovic

Collection: Lam Rim (Ilia Durovic)

Date: 2017-05-06

Duration: 1h 49m

Words: 14,381

Puts rush. You go so far in this life, and you pick up in the next life. You just progress up the ladder of existence. But for this to happen, there are two keys to generate this bodhicitta as an instinct. It must be generated step by step, in other words, incrementally, starting by reflecting as I was saying about one’s own suffering until one has a profound conviction of one’s own suffering and a wish to be free from it.

And then at that moment, this is a turning point. If one does not generate compassion at that moment, then one will have generated uncontrived definite emergence. One will have entered either the path of a hearer or the path of a pratyekabuddha, solitary realizer. So that is a critical point where having generated the profound wish to be free oneself, one must think others are like me. And at that point, that wish for liberation for oneself extends to all beings who are just like me.

And one is on the edge of entry into the path of the being of the great vehicle. One would probably have generated at a point great compassion. Great compassion is not sufficient to enter the great vehicle, but one is just on the edge. Now to generate therefore bodhicitta, one must progress incrementally, and one must generate all the preliminary motivations. You cannot jump steps.

You can try, but it will not work. So you must initially travel the path shared with the being of the small scope, which was explained last year during these conferences and the three principles of the path. And you must give rise to a what is known as a limited definite emergence, a rejection of the vanities of this world. In other words, a rejection of this life. And then realizing that all lives are like this life, all lives are the nature of suffering and unsatisfactory.

One rejects all lives. This is fully characterized definite emergence. At that point, what has entered the path shared with the being of the middle scope. And here, one must extend this to all beings, and once one extends this to all beings, generates great compassion, and generates a wish to attain full enlightenment for their sake, one will have entered the Mahāyāna. It is not possible to jump directly to a meditation in the Mahāyāna.

Now when you meditate on the Lam Rim and Shakum, an overview meditation, obviously, you meditate casually on all the topics. You do an overview meditation. This is merely to familiarize oneself with the field. It does not lead to mental transformation. Mental transformation occurs if one meditates the way taught.

Taught taught taught in a different way from we do here the way we do here, simply because no one here would accept. Will go to see in his hermitage, and would teach one topic. For instance, the precious human rebirth. Identifying the precious human rebirth, its great meaningfulness, its rarities, then presenting the examples and the reasons. And then would go and meditate on this topic for as long as it took to gain realization.

This might be three months, four months, six months, whatever it took. Until he gained realization, he did not come for other teachings. Once he gained realizations, he would go to Geshe Rinpoche’s. Would test his realizations and would teach the next topic, in this case death and impermanence. Then once again would go and meditate on the ninefold death meditation, the three main topics, the nine reasons, the three results, and meditating more so on this in terms of simile examples, and would only return when he had realizations.

In other words, was actually walking up the steps of the graduated path to enlightenment. This is how one proceeds. This leads to progress. Then this is not without cost. When you meditate on these topics, will change as a person.

There will be a price to pay in your daily life. You will not be the person you were when you started out. You will not be a family person. You will not be interested in material success. You know people will leave you for this reason.

Your partners, your wives, your children will walk away. I’ve had students who came to me and said, I can no longer study with you because my wife said if I continue, she will divorce me. I had one student, very good student, who sent that to me. Straight Tibetan, actually. Can you imagine what Lama Yeshe would be?

You know? So before you engage on this path, understand that nothing in life is free, and the important things are not cheap. You will have to pay a price. Your outlook will change, and as a result, life will change. So as I said, an actual contrived meditation itself can only be generated incrementally.

But our goal is a spontaneous meditation, in other words, an instinct. Our goal is to generate bodhicitta as an instinct. Just as previously, we generated definite emergence as an instinct, and just as before that we generated turning away from the vanities of this life as an instinct. A being of the small scope is a being who feels only disgust when he or she thinks of this life. It is not something who thinks, someone who thinks about this, the person feels disgust.

And a famous example is given of they say he was an, so definitely he had turning away from this life. He must have been close to attaining based on the story, who was coming close to a river. You know? And in ancient India, women were bare breasted. You know, these are Christians who basically changed this.

So obviously, they were very attractive. And this monk was approaching the women, the river, and he saw a very beautiful woman, you know. And desire started to arise in his mind, and she smiled at him. And upon seeing her teeth, immediately the awareness of bone and death arose in his mind, and he felt disgust and revulsion. This is a result of meditation.

Then with further meditation, there is no attraction at all, just disgust. So these are our goals. Now, what are the differences between contrived and spontaneous motivations? In other words, constructed and innate or instinctive motivations. A contrived motivation, as you can see, must be generated incrementally every time.

You have to go through the process each time. When you meditate, let’s say you meditate, you have to do a sadhana, you should generate Bodhicitta, contrived Bodhicitta before the sadhana. Otherwise, it’s not appropriate to practice a sadhana. Then you must do this by going quickly through the totality of the long run, point by point. This is how you construct a motivation of bodhicitta.

If the motivation is not generated, if the contrived motivation is not generated, there will not be the corresponding comic result. Now for spontaneous motivations, they never need to be generated. They are there. Just like the instinct for individual survival is natural. It’s spontaneous.

We do not even think about this. And this is why Jetsongkapa says referring to definite emergence, but this applies to all motivations we’re trying to generate. Hence, when through meditation, through effort, in other words, nary one instant of longing for the marvels of psychic existence arises in the day and night, in other words, in the dream state as well, the mind striving for liberation arises, then renunciation or definite emergence would have been well generated. So you can see that this is not something which is easy. It’s not easy at all.

So I was as I was saying to you, in more senses than one, the generation of uncontrived motivations amounts to creating instincts in the biological sense of the term. These substitute themselves to the instincts of the survival of the individual or the species. So the best litmus test to know where you are in terms of your mind training are your dreams. If, your dreams show that you remain uncontrolled, then mind training has not taken. The dream state is a subtle mind.

So this is the type of mind which would transmigrate. If in the dream state, minds of compassion, or self restraint of ethics arise, then this wouldn’t carry it over into the next life. Until these arise in the dream state, it is unclear whether it will be carried over or not. So has always said, your dreams are very clear indicator of where you stand. If all you get is nightmares, then there’s work to do.

Right? Then I was going to cover some elements of logic, but I think I’m gonna skip that because we’re a little bit short of time and go directly to the nature of bodhicitta. Then I was gonna quote from great commentary on the nature of bodhicitta, but I will also give you the root definition from which is really one you should try to memorize. So the main debate which occurs regarding bodhicitta is whether bodhicitta is a main mind or a mental factor. Broadly speaking, all of the great Geluk monasteries consider because they rely on Haribhādra, who’s a late eighth century scholar, that Bodhicitta is a main mind.

It is worth pointing out that two of the greatest luminaries of early Buddhist thought, Asaṇga and Vasubandhu, both considered that bodhicitta was a mental factor. And personally, I am sympathetic to their view for various reasons. It has far reaching consequences in terms of how you analyze bodhicitta. Then Kamalaśīla himself defines bodhicitta as a main mind, which is motivated by the desire for the welfare of others and assists desiring perfect enlightenment. In other words, there are two components.

There is a motivation, which is helping others, and there is a goal, which is full and utter enlightenment, not for one’s own sake, but for the sake of others. The definition you should try to remember is Maitreya’s definition in Abhisamayālamkāra. Generating the mind is for the sake of others to strive to wish for full and utter enlightenment. This is the root definition which underlies all of the definitions of bodhicitta. And this is the end of the theoretical section.

I have shortened it today because Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen covers this a lot. There are a lot of discussions on the substantial cause of Bodhicitta, the cooperative condition of Bodhicitta. If Bodhicitta is a main mind, it will have one substantial cause and cooperative condition. If it’s a mental factor, it will have different ones. Likewise, there are numerous discussions on the relationship between great compassion and bodhicitta.

Great compassion is undeniably the cause of bodhicitta. Is it the substantial cause of the cooperative factor? So if you consider bodhicitta to be a main mind, great compassion has to be a cooperative factor. Then there are I just toss these debates to you. These are difficult topics.

There are many debates about whether bodhicitta exists in the mind of a fully enlightened being or not. The position of the monastic textbooks is that it does, but there are many awkward consequences if it doesn’t. Typically, enlightened beings would not be Mahāyāna beings. Then there are reputed scholars who consider that Bodhicitta cannot exist in the mind of a fully enlightened being because Bodhicitta is an aspiration for the attainment of a state that fully enlightened being has already attained, which means that Bodhicitta would be a mistaken mind. So in this case, one just sort of cleaves to the position of the monastic textbooks of one’s college.

So monastery’s monastic textbook author considered that Bodhicitta was a main mind and was present in the mind stream of fully enlightened being. The Bodhicitta is a main mind as a position of all the monastic colleges, that it is present in the mind of full enlightened being, that’s another topic. There’s a lot of debates about this. But you can think about it a bit by yourselves. Bodhicitta, obviously, in ordinary beings is a conceptual mind, but the fully enlightened mind stream does not have conceptuality.

So at the point of full enlightenment, Bodhicitta becomes non conceptual. What this means, it is up to you to think carefully about. These are all topics which we have covered during the Tuesday class in which Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen covers during the teachings here. So the section in the three principles of the path which concerns us is the following one. However, should that definite emergence not be held by the perfect mind of Bodhicitta, in as much as it will not become the cause of the perfect bliss of enlightenment, the intelligent generate the supreme mind of enlightenment.

Carried away by the four, the flow of the four raging rivers, tightly bound up by the fetters of karma, which are hard to loosen, ensnared in the iron net of self grasping, totally obscured by the great darkness of ignorance, wandering in boundless existence, life after life, tormented uninterruptedly by the three sufferings upon reflecting upon the predicament of mothers who are in such a situation, generate the supreme mind of bodhicitta. Then I will initially give the breakdown of this section in Jetsongkapa’s three principles of the path. And because Jetsongkapa dedicates in the three principles of the path, a little space to the mode of generation of bodhicitta, I will present it in terms of the Lama Chopa, the fourth Pänchen Lama’s prayer of the Lam Rim, which hinges on generating bodhicitta by means of the interchange of self and others. So in these three verses, these three stanzas, and if you have the root text, it would be good to take it out. These three stanzas can be subdivided into three.

And this is the presentation which is shared by his and the main commentators on this text. There is a reason to generate bodhicitta, how to generate bodhicitta, and the criterion of having generated. How do you know that you generated it? The first stanza presents the reason to generate bodhicitta. The reason to generate bodhicitta is that bodhicitta is the uncommon cause of the attainment of full and utter enlightenment.

If bodhicitta is present, whatever deed is engaged and motivated by bodhicitta becomes a cause for full and utter enlightenment. If bodhicitta is not present, no deed becomes a cause of full and utter enlightenment. In other words, if you practice generosity giving, let us say, $50 to a homeless person on Hindley Street. If you just do it like that, that deed of generosity is not a definite karmic deed. It may or may not give rise to results.

If you do it with the strong wish to attain a better rebirth in future lives, that deed becomes a deed of the person of the small scope and will lead to a higher rebirth. Probably as well, I’ll take questions at the end. Probably as a wealthy human being, and at that point, that deed will be comically exhausted and will no longer bear fruit. If you do that deed with a profound wish to become ordained and attain liberation from psychic existence, that deed becomes a deed of the being of the middling scope. And that deed reaches exhaustion when you attain liberation.

Finally, if you do that deed with the profound motivation of attaining full enlightenment only for the sake of others, not thinking of yourself, that deed becomes a deed of the Mahāyāna. And it will only cease to bear fruit when you attain full and utter enlightenment. It might be millions of years from now. For this reason, the the motivation of bodhicitta is compared to, what is the term in English, the elixir of immortality. Some some of you may have studied alchemy or heard of alchemy.

Then there was this endless quest for two things, the elixir of immortality and the philosopher’s stone. It’s actually the philosopher’s stone which transforms everything into gold. So in India, the philosopher’s stone was liquid. Go figure. And bodhicitta was compared to this elixir which transformed everything into gold because whatever deed would engage in could only lead to full and utter enlightenment.

So this is why one should generate bodhicitta. And then, as is said by Pabongka Rinpoche, even with a thought of powerful thought of definite emergence, no deed you create becomes a cause for full and utter enlightenment because this is not your goal. It’s exactly like putting money in the

Bank account. If you are saving for a trip to Paris, I don’t know. Just imagine that you had made an installment on the trick ticket and you’re basically making down payments. Whatever down payment you make to, let’s say, Expedia goes towards a trip to Paris and will not go towards a trip to New York. You might change your mind, but Expedia will not.

Then if you are planning to go to New York, whatever down payments you make to Expedia, I suppose I don’t know if they accept down payments, but let’s assume, will go towards a trip to New York. Do you understand how this functions? Then makes very clear the reason for trying to generate. If through even being endowed with a helpful thought, may the headaches of sentient beings be dispelled, one becomes endowed with measureless merit. What mean is there to speak of one who wishes to dispel measureless non virtue of each and every sentient being and establish each one as well in measureless qualities?

The amount of karma we accumulate is not only proportional to the deed, it is proportional to the base. Now some bases like the spiritual teacher are powerful bases. But when the base is a numberless amount of sentient beings, the fact that the base is numberless turns a deed into something which is immeasurable. If you wish to give $1 to one person, you would accrue a certain amount of merit. If deep down, you wish to give 1¢ to every single living being assuming they could all use it, the amount of merit you accumulate cannot be measured because your thought is one of benefiting infinity.

So with bodhicitta, if you wish, infinity is brought in the equation of the generation of motivations, which is not the case when you generate the motivation shared as a being of the smaller the building scope, where the goal at the end of the day is oneself. When you bring infinity in the equation, then the multiplier is infinite. When in addition, the goal is for enlightenment, the goal is also infinite. And this mathematics is the mathematics of infinity. It’s a beautiful discipline.

You know? But here you can see the extraordinary power of such a motivation. Then to generate such a motivation, one must expand one’s mind. At present, our mind is very, very small. Largely because our mind is very small, we suffer.

The moment we start thinking of others, our mental pressure is reduced. Our mental suffering is reduced. The more we think about others, the greater the reduction in mental pressure and stress. And here, I will mention briefly because I know some of you were involved in charity work and faced burnout. There is a very interesting article published by and some neurobiologist who was just booked or I just noticed it last night at 10:30, so I can put the bibliography or print it out.

They were trying to understand why some health workers and doctors experienced burnout and others did not. And what they found is that there is a very important distinction between empathy and compassion. Empathy fosters burnout, compassion does not. And this is supported neurobiologically. What they found is that empathy, which basically means to feel with another, in Greek, to feel with another, exhausts the person emotionally and fosters what is known as negative affects.

Compassion, which involves a more intellectual approach and which hinges on trying to find solutions to the problems others are facing does not foster negative affects. This is very interesting because this ties in very tightly, we’ll talk about it shortly, with the techniques of meditation on compassion in Tibetan Buddhism. And they actually found that there’s different areas of the brain which are activated as well. So it’s quite fascinating. Now returning to the three principles of the path, how to generate molachilas.

This is the uncommon method of generation within these three principles of the past. I I read already this passage carried away by the flow of the four raging rivers, tightly bound up by the fetters of karma, which are hard to loosen. This refers to sentient beings. Ensnared in the iron net of self grasping, which refers to ignorance, seeking as grasping at a self. Totally obscured by the great darkness of ignorance.

Wandering in boundless existence life after life, in other words, suffering repeatedly, tormented uninterruptedly by the three sufferings, the suffering of suffering, the suffering of change, and all pervasive suffering. Upon reflecting upon the predicament of mothers, in other words, mother sentient beings who are in such a situation, generate the supreme mind of Bodhicitta. This is a much more synthetic and organic meditation of Bodhicitta than the equalization and the change of self and others or the sevenfold causal technique. One basically almost visualizes all sentient beings as oneself, carried away by the four beavers we’ll be talking about briefly, in a couple of minutes. And then one generates an extremely powerful compassion for them, and strives to find a solution to their predicament.

Now, what are these four rivers? And here I will draw heavily on Khensur Rinpoche’s teachings on this topic in 2008 and 2009, in which I gave you a magnificent commentary on the three principles of the path. You have four rivers, which are distinguished between rivers at the time of the course and rivers at the time of effect. The rivers at the time of the cause are the four rivers of desire, of the view, of existence, and of ignorance. And this division comes from Abhidharma.

So the river river of desire is self evident, and here I quote directly. It refers to the afflictions of the desire realm. We see exception of ignorance, so it includes anger. These are basically all the afflictions which we as beings of the desire realm, as well as all beings of the six realms experience except ignorance. And those of you who attend the Tuesday class on Cittamātra will find the next distinction very interesting.

The river of existence refers to the affliction specific to the form and the formless realm, the higher realms. These are much more subtle levels of affliction than the afflictions of the desire realm. We cannot even begin to understand what the afflictions of your being of the formless realm might be. And the river of the view refers mainly to the view of the perishable composite. In other words, the view which identifies a permanent and enduring eye with these five aggregates.

In other words, my form aggregate, sensation, discrimination, composition factor, and consciousness, are impermanent and disintegrating instant by instant. This is one of the main motors of our enslavement to cyclic existence. If you look at your relation with others, and I think the computer doesn’t agree with me. If you look or we look at our relation with others, we can see that we view others as permanent, as attractive, and as clean. You might say that much of modern hygiene has as a main goal to make us attractive and clean.

If you take a human body and or a person, and you keep the person, let’s just say, in the bush of Adelaide for, let’s say, a month without access to a shower, brushing their teeth, in my case, shaving, we would look like animals, and we would smell like animals. Then all of us wash, brush our teeth, perfume ourselves, the various perfumes, various parts of the body, you know, that we dress attractively. The goal is to make ourselves attractive. Those those who are not ordained to turn oneself into an attractive sexual partner. Because an attractive sexual partner gets sexual partnership, then gets money, then gets support, comfort, and all sorts of things.

All of this is rooted in the view of the disintegrating composite, which has used these aggregates which are actually dirty. The human body is extraordinarily dirty, impermanent, was changing instant by instant as something permanent and attractive. And then the fourth river is the river of ignorance. This is the ignorance from the standpoint, which apprehends all phenomena, including the person as existing from its own side, as being inherently existent, as being truly existent, as being inherently existent. Then just as there are four rivers at the level of the cause, in other words, four causes of psychic existence, the river of desire, of the view, of existence, and of ignorance, there are four results, and these are the four first of the eight sufferings, birth, aging, sickness, and death.

And the Buddhist view of birth is particularly interesting because from the Buddhist standpoint, aging begins at the instant following birth. It’s a very powerful way to look at a human life. Aging does not really begin around the age of 45 or 50 when one starts to feel a bit doggy and one’s hair starts turning gray and, you know, all that, aging begins as soon as one is born. The death process has begun as soon as one is born. Very powerful way of looking at things.

So do you see anything? So I’m terribly sorry. I thought we had fixed these problems, but, obviously, we didn’t. Are they fixed? Good.

Now regarding the generation of bodhicitta, as you all probably know, there are two main techniques for generating bodhicitta. The sevenfold causal generation and the interchange of self and other, and they have different lineages. The first lineage we owe to Maitreya, but actually you find it mainly in the works of Asaṇga, in Asaṇga Yogacarya Bhumi. And the second lineage, we owe to Nāgārjuna, Śāntideva, and Serlingpa, Śāntideva’s — not Śāntideva — Atisha’s master in Sumatra. The first lineage is an exoteric of public lineage.

The second lineage is an esoteric or secret lineage, which was kept secret in Tibet until the time of Geshe Chekhawa. It was considered a particularly powerful instruction and was reserved to private teaching contexts. Then I represent here the interchange of self and others. Both lineages were present in Atisha. And these days, those who have the capacity meditate on bodhicitta using fusion of these two instructions, which is the eleven-point technique of meditation on bodhicitta.

I’ll talk about it briefly at the end. The reason I would like to present mainly the interchange of self and others is because experience has shown us that in a Western audience, there are major problems in presenting the sevenfold cause and instruction. So Geshe-la asked me some six months ago how to present bodhichitta, and I suggested interchange of self and others because there are major problems with recognizing all sentient beings as mother sentient beings. And I’ve seen Westerners find this intellectually very stimulating, but they are unable to integrate it and subscribe to the view, then there’s no benefit. So this is not a university.

We are not here to entertain people intellectually. Then I will skip some things. So how does one proceed to generate bodhicitta by means of the equalization and change of self and others? And here, I rely on the instructions from the Lama Chopa. Since it is a lama cuppa which presents this in the greatest detail, drawing both on the instructions of and on the totality of the teachings.

You can meditate on the totality of the Lam Rim from the standpoint of the Lama Chopa prayer, and this is something which encouraged greatly. If you can memorize the Lam Rim prayer at the end of the Lama Chopa, it imputes the totality of the Lam Rim. That’s very, very powerful, very powerful teaching. So initially, one generates a powerful sense of equanimity towards all sentient beings by seeing them all as equal to oneself in that every single one of them as myself, you know, suffers, and every single one of them has been my mother. Through having reflected on the manner in which all these wretched migrators who suffer, my mother’s, out of kindness, over and again protected me, blessed me to give rise to spontaneous compassion.

This is compassion as an instinct as opposed to contrived compassion. As a mother’s love for her cherished child. This is the stanza which is, if you wish, the prelude to the Pänchen Lama’s presentation of how to practice the equalization in the interchange of self and others. Now when one trains in the equalization and interchange of self and others, there are five steps. The first is equalizing self and others, and this was covered by Geshe-la last year at the beginning of this year.

The second is reflecting on the thoughts of egoism or self cherishing, then reflecting on the qualities of altruism, the actual thought of the interchange of self and others, and then the practice of Tonglen or giving and taking. It must be practiced in this sequence. If you do not practice them in this sequence, you will not gain the required result. Then how does one meditate on equalizing self and others? We are equal with others because just as them, we do not wish for the slightest suffering, and we are never satisfied with what we have.

There is no difference between us in this respect. Not wishing for the slightest suffering and never satisfied with happiness, there is no difference between myself and others. Bless me to give rise to happiness and joy in others. Then if there is no difference between myself and others, why do I privilege myself at the expense of others? Others are exactly like me.

They want to be as happy as they can possibly be, and they do not want even the smallest iota of suffering. There is no difference between myself and them. Then this is a very powerful verse to keep in mind when you’re dealing with someone who is difficult. Let’s say when someone gets very angry at you, you know. Then you see this person is like me.

This person is angry because they see me as an obstacle to their happiness. They do not want to suffer just like me. I am like them. I also get angry when I think people are an obstacle to my happiness. I also do not want to experience even one iota of suffering.

Then why should I be angry with them if I behave like them and they are like me? We are brothers or sisters. We are both in the same boat. There is no difference between us. I am not superior to them because I behave just in this way.

It’s a very powerful tool to eliminate self righteousness. And this outlook which is very prevalent especially in the West, according to which all our problems come from others and from the outside. We are somehow verina immaculata, immaculate virgins, and everyone around us is at best neutral and in the worst of cases monsters conspiring to destroy our happiness. You know? And this is very common.

You know? Now the more ingrained or entrenched this viewpoint is, the more unhappy we will be. Because it does not correspond in the slightest to reality. Actually, you remember what we said at the beginning of this talk, which is that our happiness is contingent on our outlook meshing with reality as much as possible. You can see here just the degree to which this stands

It refers to human reality. Now that neither none of us in this room is either angry or upset, what we think about it is obvious. We might not have thought about it by ourselves, but it is obvious that others behave just like we behave. There is no difference. When someone is abusive and yelling at us, it is not as if we ourselves never were abusive and never yell at anyone else.

They do it because they want to be happy just as we do it because we want to be happy. Who are we to stand in judgment on them? We’re just like them. No difference. We’re the same.

And the person who is kind and friendly with us, that person is kind and friendly for exactly the same reasons as a person who is angry and abusive. That person is kind and friendly because they want to be happy and because they don’t want to be unhappy. So if the motivation is exactly the same, why would we discriminate between the one and the other? They’re identical. It’s just in terms of the expression of the motivation.

One yells and the other speaks kindly to us. But both want to be as happy as they can be and cannot tolerate one iota of suffering. Then you can see how this would lead to a tremendous sense of equality, of equanimity. And this is why Śāntideva says, whatever worldly joy there is arises from wishing for others happiness. Whatever worldly suffering there is arises from wishing for your own happiness.

Now, before we enter into the details of how to generate or how to equalize and interchange self and others, we have to ask ourselves a question which I think is particularly beneficial for us as Westerners. Is this rational or not? Does this make sense or not? I think more than any other society, western society has exhorted the self. Main reason people come to Buddhist centers is largely because the ego, the self, is so great that they experience tremendous suffering.

They are attracted to the teachings of selflessness. I was checking some images for this class. I wanted to put some nice images for you in a PowerPoint presentation. It was quite interesting, you know. I googled self sacrifice.

Then I googled it. I checked the images. All the images were negative. It was striking. Every single image, you have posters with caption captions with very negative sort of cynical hostile captions.

What was one self sacrifice is the excuse of those who sacrifice others. It went just down down down the list. I was watching this and I thought, my goodness. Why such hostility to the highest expression of humanity? Why such anger?

Largely, probably, because of extreme egoism. And there were quotes of Ayn Rand. You may have heard some of you may have heard of Ayn Rand. Nobody did. A Russian thinker who emigrated to America and who became the apostle of egoism.

She wrote Atlas Shrugged. Yes. You know, made a very nice movie with Gregory Peck many, many years ago. So is it rational to interchange self and others, or is just is just wishful thinking? Then what is the self?

In our own cases, our body, which is the main base in which we impute selfhood, comes from what? From the spermatozoa of the father into oversight of the mother. Spermatozoa fertilizes fertilizes the oversight. We end up with an egg as I got. And on this egg, we impute, this is my body.

Now if we analyze, actually, this body is not really mine. It’s if you wish to break it down, 50% are fathers and 50% are mothers. We are self are certainly not the origin of our body. Yet, we are quite comfortable with appropriating it and imputing I on this basis. Then, if we can impute I on this basis, why is it inappropriate to impute I on other basis?

And this leads Shankhildeva to say, therefore, just as you conceived I with respect to the drops of semen and blood of others, in other words, your parents, so too you can be conditioned to cherishing others as you do yourself. This body is not yours. It’s my body is not mine. Physically, I look like my grandfather. Then, obviously, that has nothing to do with me as a person.

Yet, I cherish this body, and if someone slaps me, I get very angry. Why cannot can I not train myself to be annoyed when someone slaps another person? Why can I not impute my eye on another body? Logically, what is there to prevent me from doing so since after all this body is not really mine? Then and this is the difficult point of this line of reasoning, and that’s why it was probably kept secret in Tibet.

The training in the equalization and the interchange of self and others abuts unavoidably on an understanding of interdependence, and therefore is at its most effective when one has meditated on emptiness. It is the technique for generating bodhicitta for those of sharp acumen. Or as I said, by becoming accustomed to the equality of self and others, the mind of enlightenment, Buddhicitta becomes firm. Self and other are interdependent, like this side and the other side of a river, they are force. In other words, conventionally existent.

The other bank is not in itself, in other words, inherently other, in relation to someone else, it is this bank. Similarly, self does not exist in its own right, in relation to someone else, it is other. Then if I take for instance myself and Chris, from my own standpoint, Chris is an other with a capital o, existing out there inherently independently of my perception of him. But from Chris’ standpoint, I am an other out there existing independently, autonomously, without any participation from the from Chris’ side. In other words, we are both others and we are both selves.

My imputing otherhood on Chris is contingent on my imputing selfhood on myself. Chris is imputing otherhood on myself is contingent on Chris imputing selfhood on himself. The less Chris imputes selfhood on himself, the less the sense of otherhood he has with respect to me. The less I impute selfhood on myself, the less the sense of otherhood I have with respect to Chris. The less the sense of selfhood and otherhood, the less the afflictions.

Do you understand? The more your sense of I increases or with the Tibetans, we increase, the more the sense of him or her increases or them increases. This is the root of all afflictions and of all wars. You can see now, for instance, if you you look at politics in Europe, but in America too, starting even in this country, an exhortation of The Us versus them. What is called grasping at one’s own side.

The more you exhort us, the more there’s a them on the other side which is exhorted as well. Now when this is pushed to its logical conclusion, us becomes gigantic. Any infringement on us cannot be tolerated and is due to them, And they must be disbanded, dispelled, destroyed. You know, this is the rhetoric. Rhetoric which leads to wars is this one.

Now the rhetoric which leads to wars of the individual is the same. If you we look at how afflictions arise within our own minds. First, the eye increases. You notice when you fight with someone, you have an inner discourse. How dare he say this to me?

Me. Me. And then that other person as well, you know, becomes more and more isolated out there. And at this point when the anger arises, the anger is completely uncontrollable. Right?

So these lines of reasoning are very powerful, but they are very powerful if you engage in them before anger arises. Once anger has risen, it’s another story. So let us reflect then in keeping with, as you remember, the sequence of generation of equalizing self and others on the thoughts of self cherish of self cherishing of egoism, the second outline. This was a nice painting of Escher, this one. Someone who was looking at his own face in a crystal ball and sees reflection of his own face looking at his own face in a crystal ball within which is a reflection of his own face.

This is the paradoxes of the self. So the Pänchen Lama says, through seeing this grievous disease of cherishing one’s own self, in other words, egoism, as the cause for the arising of unwanted suffering, bless me to overcome the great fiend of self cherishing, holding a vindictive hatred for it. So at present, we hold a vindictive hatred for others. Now it’s often surprising when you meet Westerners how deep rooted the anger towards key people in their lives can be. I’ve not yet seen this with Asians as much.

But typically parents are the recipient of an astonishing amount of anger from Western students. Then this anger which targets others arises directly from our own self cherishing. The greater our own self cherishing, the greater our own egoism, the greater the sense that we have been ill treated by others. Whatever others do for us is never good enough. It should have been better.

It could have been better. It isn’t. And then we generate anger and hatred for the other person, which become positively toxic. Here, the advice relayed by the Pension Lama is through understanding that the egoism in our own mind leads to this polarization of self and others, which is at the root of the delusions, which have destroyed us. We are all here because of the delusions.

To generate anger for this, in other words, to turn the anger inwards. That’s why I encourage you to leave all the pop psychology you have ever read, and I’m sure you’ve read many volumes aside, because the advice of the great Buddhist masters is often completely at odds with pop psychology and self help. Shame is a good thing. Anger can be catalyzed and turned inwards. Anger with our thoughts is a good thing.

And satisfaction with ourselves is a good thing, forgiveness of others is a good thing, then obviously, as you can see, I’m completely at odds already with pop psychology. Right? And with self help. So as said, banish the one to be blamed for everything. Banish egoism.

Banish self cherishing within our heart. Or as I said, we have within us an evil being who shamelessly blames all problems on our kind teachers and friends, our friends, and those dear to us, our parents and relatives. And in daily life, and for that matter in the Buddhist centers, this is a very, very common experience. People are always a victim of others. I have very seldom heard someone blame themselves for what happened to them.

Yet, that is the very beginning of spiritual growth. Others are not to blame. Even if another assaults us, it is our own mental reaction which causes mental suffering to us. And from a Buddhist perspective, certainly from the long view, the assault of an other is determined. It arises from our own assaulting someone at some distant point in the past.

And if you study the cases of the reincarnation type, which Stevenson gives, it’s very striking, very striking. There was one case I listed, the case of Vijayakane, a young Sri Lankan who had murdered his fiancee because she actually refused to marry him and who was executed in, I think, 1928 for this. And after, I think, one one hair rebirth and one animal rebirth as a bird, he had elements of both he recollected. He was reborn as a human being, and he had stamped his fiancee with his right hand in the chest, and therefore, had obviously stabbed her at the liver of the heart, right, on the left side. He was reborn with an atrophied pectoral muscle on the left side.

It’s very striking. Then this is clearly a case where the harm one inflicts on another rebounds on oneself. And as a Buddhist actually, instead of blaming his parents perhaps for his heredity or lack of medical care in Sri Lanka for being, if you wish, stuck with this physical predicament, was able to blame his own past deeds, his own karma. You know? Then there’s some marvelous lines such as those of Nam Koppel, which points out that due to the strength of our acquaintance with a self centered attitude for beginningless time, if we hear the squealing of rats in a house, we are frightened of them nibbling our nose.

In other words, we are the center of our universe. Everything which happens revolves around us. It is often quite shocking for us to sit back and to think how overwhelmingly we unimportant we are to the well-being, not just of the world, but of people around us. If I take my own case, for instance, I’m going on 55. Then let us say tomorrow I had a heart attack.

TBI would continue just fine. Tendon would translate. You’d find another translator. Then my wife would be very sad, but would settle down, continue her life. You would probably all forget me within six months.

You talk about it a couple of weeks. How strange. You know, Ethan looked so healthy, you know, then he went quick, keeled over, and that was it. Right? Big man like that, you know, made a dent in the floor.

You know? And then after a couple of months, I will be completely forgotten. In other words, as a person, I am completely unimportant. You know? And all of us as people, we are extraordinarily or unimportant in the overall scheme of things.

We see the world that’s revolving around us. We believe that if we were not there, the sun would not rise and would not set. The sun has risen and set for millions of years without any one of us being around, maybe in different forms. It will continue after. Now this outlook which brings us down to size is extraordinarily beneficial for the mind.

We are not important. We don’t matter. What happens to us is not terribly important. If you are depressed or depressive, this is what will cure your depression. Depression arises from excessive self attachment, excessive egoism.

Then the more the self decreases, the more egoism decreases, the less depression there is. It’s quite striking if you take the Tibetans who really suffered a lot, that I actually I actually don’t know of a single case of depression. I knew one Ladakhie boy who was sort of depressed, and that’s because this old friend of mine was trying to get his nephew ordained, and his nephew did not want to get ordained, so he did what you always do in that case. He found the first girl he could find, and she became his girlfriend. And then this very pious Ladakhigeshi figured the dream of every Geshi is to have at least one of his relatives or friends ordained.

So he latched onto another boy who was still single. You know, and the depression was huge. And this boy became quite depressed because actually he didn’t want to go in a monastery, you know. Then, you know, that’s not really depression. That’s a rather realistic response.

So it’s interesting you see if you take rich countries like these that the rate of depression is so high when the conditions are so good, and that in poor countries the rate of depression is so low when the conditions are so bad. Do you understand why this is the case? It is because in rich countries, we have an inflated sense of our own self worth, of our own value. Then the smallest problem and people become indignant.

They become angry. And if they cannot find a solution, the anger is turned inwards. And then depression arises. Right? Then if we can reduce even without using the Buddhist techniques of meditation, our own sense of self worth and value, and really realize that in the overall scheme of things, we are really quite unimportant.

We don’t matter. Then one is very happy. You know? Otherwise, the more self important we think we are, the more fragile we are, you know, the easier it is to prick that bubble, you know. And therefore, the goal is to affectionately viewing others as as dear and beloved as much as you can, to develop an attitude which cherishes others to the degree with which we cherished ourselves previously.

The goal, in other words, is to take our egoism and to turn it into an attachment to others. That emotional intensity focused on ourselves becomes focused on others. And this is possible because as we explained, there’s actually no difference between myself and another. I impute I on my body, legitimately or illegitimately, however you want to put it, but I could just as well impute it on another’s body because this body is not mine. Then if we reflect on the qualities of altruism, in turn, our wish to equalize and interchange self and others will increase.

And I took the example of bread because I personally eat a lot of bread. I love eating bread. They say that people of Serbian origin eat gigantic amounts of bread, and I don’t know if that’s true, but it seems to be. Bread, like any crock like any, you know, product made from cereals, arises from the kindness of others. Someone has to sow the seeds, and someone has to cut the wheat, Someone has to grind the flour.

Someone has to make the dough. Someone else has to basically bake the dough. Then your baker has to sell you the bread. If any of these one peep these people is absent, we ourselves are unable, or in my case, I’m unable to eat bread. If it weren’t for the kindness of others, I could not eat bread.

Then if we take something more basic, Right now, I am speaking to you and you are listening. Who made this possible? No. I’m speaking to you, and you are listening. Basics.

Who made this possible? Go further back. If I the light casual answers. If I can speak and you can understand speech, who do we owe that to? Teachers.

Which teacher? Teachers of the age. School. Before you went to school, you could not speak. Your mother.

In this room, every single one of us learned to speak looking at our mother’s face. Before our teachers, long before anyone, our mother held us, and we looked at her mouth, and she pronounced words, and we imitated the movement of her lips. We learned to speak and to understand through looking at her mother’s face. If I speak today and you understand, it is thanks to the kindness of every single one of our mothers. If you did not have a mother, you would not be able to speak.

Children who are raised in the woods, if they survive, are like animals. Right? Often there’s brain atrophy. So when we speak of dharma, the subtext, the vehicle is speech. This we owe to our mothers.

Right? A mother never asked for payment for this. Never asked for a reward. Right? Then what else do we do did we do to come here which we owe to our mothers?

I see you don’t think a lot about your mothers. Before, it’s something more important than dressing. You can perhaps get away with walking naked in Australia depending where you are. You walked. Walked.

Mother taught you. Who else? Your mother taught you to walk and dressing obviously. Yes. But walking and speaking is huge.

Then who taught you to eat? Your mother taught you. Then, you see, when you when you start trying to generate bodhicitta, whatever technique you adopt, you need at least one person in your life to whom you owe everything. So if we have this powerfully self centered attitude You know, I used to joke with my wife about it that everyone here is, you know, a little bit like, you know, born from the Virgin Mary. There’s no father.

There’s no mother. He’s they never talk of their parents. You know? They don’t owe anything to anybody. Right?

It’s very strange as an attitude. It’s an exhortation of extreme egoism. You know? Then if we look back at our parents, we look at our mother, we look at our father, the kindness of the mother in particular is extraordinary. Pretty much everything we have, we have thanks to her.

And that is that kindness is a foundation on which, certainly in the several cause of relation, we will endeavor to generate bodhicitta. So it’s the other reason I suggested to Gesheera not to present that technique at TBI for the time being because many of our students have a very seem to have a very conflicted relation with their parents for whatever reason. You know? As I suggested, probably due to excessive self cherishing, you know. So then if you take your mother as an example, it’s quite something, you know.

Then you take the next step up, right, after your mother and your father, your teachers in school. Right? So I was lucky I had very good teachers in school. And there were examples for me all my life. I look back at my life with with my teacher of mathematics, let’s say, let’s have said, my French teacher was marvelous, like whatever he have said, you know.

Then look at all the people you learned something from. It’s quite astonishing. Right? And this is the kindness of others. Now what is interesting is that there is a direct correlation between altruism and physical health.

Here, the evidence is very strong and difficult to explain. You know, it’s funny. Whenever I talk about parents here, half the half the faces get uptight, though. It’s really interesting. Until you make peace with your parents and you develop love for your parents, it is impossible to develop any type of compassion.

Impossible. Altruism and physical health is a very interesting study. This they were trying to find what the impact on relation with the parents was on the health of people. And then it took a group of 120 or some young men. I mentioned this last year during the symposium in the early fifties.

And there they were basically interrogated or questioned about their relation with their parents, and their health was studied over the next thirty five years. It’s one of those very long term studies. And what they found was that ninety one percent of the participants who did not perceive themselves to have had close relationships with their mothers had diagnosed midlife diseases. Coronary artery coronary artery disease, high blood pressure ulcer, or alcoholism. In other words, having a bad relation with one’s mother is an extremely powerful predictor of mid age health problems.

Ninety percent is very powerful. Only forty five percent of those who reported a warm relationship with their mother had these problems. Eighty two percent of those who indicated low warmth and closeness with their fathers had such diagnosis compared with only fifty percent who reported high warmth and One hundred percent of those who had low warmth and closeness to both parents had such diseases diagnosed in midlife. So I plotted this. It’s very interesting.

This is what we end up with. Cold relation with one’s parents or the participants had midlife diseases. Cold relation with the mother, which is the most important parent, the closest to us in early childhood, ninety percent had. Then if they had a warm relationship with the father, as you can see here, only fifty percent had midlife problems. In a warm relation with the mother, forty five percent had midlife health problems.

We’re not talking of mental problems. We’re talking of physical problems. Physical problems are obviously rooted in the state of mind. But this is quite interesting. This makes us a very strong case for trying to be close to one’s parents.

And another team from Cornell investigated the health of married women with children. The idea was that women from poor social backgrounds would have more health problems than women from better social backgrounds, and what they found was exactly the opposite, or if you prefer, was completely unrelated. They found that the number of children, education, class, and work status did not affect longevity or health. What affected longevity or health was volunteering. Those who volunteered, fifty two percent of those who did not belong to a volunteer organization experienced a major illness compared to thirty six percent who did volunteer.

It’s astonishing. In other words, volunteering is clearly a manifestation of altruism. Altruistic behavior towards unknowns in women, one cannot say for men, but studies are very difficult to make. You have to do them over thirty, forty years, dramatically reduces the incidence of health problems and enhances longevity. Egoism, not volunteering, reduces lifespan and increases health problems.

So even from the standpoint of this life, you can make a very strong case for reducing self cherishing and increasing altruism. And you can see this when you plot it, it’s quite striking. Those who belong to a volunteer organization, less than forty percent experienced major disease. Those who did not, more than fifty. The next step, as we’re talking here of the, importance of cherishing others.

So I think I’ve made a fair case that there are physical benefits in this life. This is the mental benefits, altruism and mental health. Here, the evidence is more indirect, largely because the studies are still being done. It is not something which western study scientists study naturally. What evidence there is is not so much on the benefit of altruism from mental health, but on the damage, lack of altruism causes to mental health.

If there is a lack of altruism and empathy, then a series of mental health problems can occur depending on what type of empathy is miss missing. Affective empathy is typically the capacity to emphasize emotionally with another person. You find it in animals even. An animal would be distressed when an other other animal suffers. Cognitive empathy is a more sophisticated form of empathy, where if you wish, puts oneself in another person’s shoes.

Now, if effective empathy is absent, you have the most extreme forms of psychological disorders, psychopathy and narcissism. The incapacity to relate to another person as a person, you know, which is characteristic, in cases of severe crime, you know, serial criminals and so forth. If cognitive empathy is absent, then frequently one encounters bipolar disorder, that’s manic depressive states, and borderline traits. These are people who are, borderline psychiatric patients. And a study of prisoners, in jails makes this very clear.

So as I mentioned, we have four categories of mental disorder which, if you wish, are signed by the absence of empathy, bipolar disorder, narcissism, psychopathology, and borderline personality disorder. And I will skip a bit, the rate of psychopathy in prisons is around twenty three percent. The average population, it is one percent. So it is quite interesting that basically people who are unable to relate to others as persons, who lack cherishing others, who have strong self cherishing, are dramatically overrepresented in prisons. There is therefore a strong social interest in fostering this type of mind training.

This is very much to the advantage of society as a whole. I must apologize for the projector. We’ve been having troubles with it since last time. Now there are some indications that altruism is associated with higher levels of mental health. But right now, as I mentioned to you earlier, it is still in the process of being studied.

What is clear is that the absence of altruism is associated with severe mental illness. Moving onwards in the Pänchen Lama’s commentary on how to practice the equalization and change of self and others through seeing the mind setting cherished mothers in happiness as the door to the arising of infinite qualities, bless me to hold these migrators, these sentient beings, dearer than my own life, even should they become my foes. Once we understand that altruism is, even in this life, the gateway to physical and mental happiness, and definitely that as we increase in altruism, this self sense of self as opposed to other decreases and the afflictions decrease, and we will as a result be happier in future lives as well, then we will do everything we can to train our altruism. And therefore, Śāntideva says, whenever I turn my gaze upon a sentient being, thinking I shall fully awaken through depending on this being. Look upon him with open hearted love.

Because if he is a friend, he will help us. And if he is an enemy, thanks to him, we can practice patience. Without an enemy, there is no patience. And patience is according to all the Buddhist teachers, the most difficult virtue to practice. It is called the great ascetic practice.

And therefore, Geshe Chakkawa hands, whether they are our enemies or dear ones, all are the objects of afflictions as was mentioned at the beginning of the Pänchen Lama’s verses. Seeing everyone as a spiritual teacher will bring happiness even when you are alone. This was a great practice of the Kadampa Geshe. All are our teachers. Those who are kind to us are our teachers.

Those who are harsh to us are our teachers. As a result, we generate anger towards none. From those who are kind to us, we get help. Those who are harsh to us, enable us to practice the great qualities. Enable us to practice ethics, enable us to practice forbearance, enable us to practice enthusiasm.

And therefore, let us meditate on the kind, the great kindness of all beings. And it is at this point, once one has reflected on equalizing self in others, the core the thoughts of self cherishing and the qualities of self of cherishing others, that one should engage in the actual thought of interchanging self and others, giving and taking. And here I thought I would use as an illustration a magnificent fresco of Buddha Shakyam when he offering his own body to a tigress. Remember the famous account in the Jātaka. So the Pänchen Lama in the Lama Chopa states, in brief, through the mind which realizes the difference between the defects of the puerile, the childish, who enact exclusively their own will and the quality

Is it the lord of the subdueers, in other words, the Buddha, who enacts exclusively the will of others? Bless me to be able to equalize and exchange self in others. This first stanza focuses mainly on the equalization of self and others, and we request blessings to do this because it is particularly difficult to do. The second stanza continues, the thoughts of self cherishing since cherishing one’s own self is the door of all degeneration, in other words, all afflictions. For cherishing mothers is the foundation of all qualities.

These are the faults of self cherishing and the qualities of cherishing others. Bless me to make of the practice of the exchange of self and others, the heart of my practice. This verse requests blessings to actually exchange self and others. At this point, one engages in the practice of Torah, and I often have thought that this famous statue of the Buddha in ascetic meditation, which is his famous a favorite representation of the Buddha, had to be Buddha practicing. Here, this verse, the verse given at present in the Lama Chopa is adopted as a mantra, as a dharani by many Gelug teachers.

It is perhaps the central verse of all of the Lama Chopa. Hence, noble compassionate Guru, bless me that all of the sins, obscurations, and sufferings of migrators who are mothers, ripen at present without exception on me. Well, through having given my happiness and virtue to others, may all migrators have happiness. Bless me to make leisure and opportunity greatly meaningful. It’s a very powerful verse.

It is said to be the verse many great teachers recited going to their death when the Chinese started executing. The key elements in this verse is in the first stanza that the sins, obstructions, sufferings of my mother sentient beings ripen at present, in other words, now, right now, as I meditate, exception. Those are the two key words. In other words, when we engage in this practice, when we recite the stanza before engaging in the visualizations which link breathing with giving and taking, we make a heartfelt heartfelt respect that all the sufferings ripen immediately upon us with no delay, and it is all sufferings without a single exception. We will find when we make this request that there is a lot of mental resistance.

The greater the mental resistance, the greater the self cherishing. Then we should push through. Push through to reflecting on the fact that this mental resistance is precisely what has kept us as ordinary sentient beings. Or Buddha Śākyamūni and so many great teachers have become enlightened. The difference between us and them is there.

And then after this, we engage in the practice of giving through requesting that all our present happiness, all the virtue we have accumulated pass and mature on others. So this is exactly the opposite of how we practice usually. How we practice usually is that all the virtue we accumulate mature now as quickly as possible on ourselves, preferably in this life. And then we engage in a lot of advanced tantric practice reciting to eliminate all obstructions from ourselves. This is inverted practice.

The practice at the level of Mahāyāna, and Tantra is a part of Mahāyāna, it’s a pinnacle of Mahāyāna, is exactly the opposite. One should request that whatever virtue one has accumulated be given to others, not mature on oneself. One should request us sincerely and powerfully, give it completely up. And then that not only one’s own afflictions, but those of others. The suffering they experience, not just in developed countries like Australia, but poor countries.

The suffering of animals. The suffering of beings in the hell realms. All of that that we experience and that they not experience it. The more powerfully we can do this, the more powerful our practice. Then for us now this is difficult.

It’s very helpful to memorize this verse in English and recite it as you recite a mantra. I think it is perhaps more beneficial than any mantra I can think of, because it has real meaning. And here we engage in the twin practices of giving and taking. Then I will quote from Geshe Langri Thangpa, whose marvelous text, the Eight Verses of Mind Training. May I take upon myself loss and prefer victory to others?

This is the core of our mind training. This is the core of Tonglen. This is the core of giving and taking. When we practice Tonglen, visualize the suffering of others, in other words, loss maturing on us. We give victory, in other words, happiness to others.

In daily life, this is a road forwards for us. We accept humiliation. We accept loss. We accept suffering. We give victory, happiness, rewards to others.

The more we do this, the happier we will be. The more we do this, the happier they will be. And this is why, and I I very much like to quote these final verses of Śāntideva at the end of these presentations. Śāntideva says, and this is often called the pledges of Dalai Lama’s, during the intermediate eon of famine, may I become food and drink for sentient beings who are poor and famished? May I remain in their presence as various necessities?

May I protect those without protection and be a guide leading those upon the path? May I become a vessel, a bridge, and a ship. These are the good great body of darkness who can manifest as physical objects for those who wish to cross over the ocean. May I be an island for those searching for land, and a lamp for those needing a light. May become a bed for those who need rest, and a servant for all who want assistance.

And this is the road forwards for us. The great bodhisattvas are servants of all beings. Then this is what I wanted to cover with you today. For us, it is a very big stretch from where we are at present. At the same time, we can see that those beings who have trained their minds in this way, whether it is historians of the Dalai Lama or of the Greek Lamas, are far happier than we are, are far superior to us, then they did not get there naturally.

They get got there through effort, through meditation, through training. They themselves experience the same difficulties we experience. Some of them may be even more. The difference between us and them is that they travel the path and we still do not travel the path or have just started. Then it is entirely up to us whether we do this or not.

It cannot be done for us. It would be very nice if it was possible, but it isn’t. And the path can only be traveled one step at a time starting from where we are now. Broadly speaking, all of us are ordinary beings. I think all of us are worldly beings.

In other words, all of us are beings for whom this life comes first, second, and third. Then we have to see where we stand. If that is where we are at present, then to reach such an advanced stage, we must progress step by step through the path of the being shared with the small scope, the path of the being shared with the middling scope, and the path of the being shared with the great scope. We cannot jump. If we don’t start now, we will not start.

None of us is getting any younger. I see faces. Some of my ex students like Shaya was very young when she was my Tibetan student. Now, Shaya, if you’ll forgive me for saying so, you look more middle aged. Then ten years from now, again, you will be older.

It’s true for every one of you. I look at my own life. My own life is now in its last third. First two thirds are gone. If last third may be longer or shorter, I don’t know.

You know? But time is short. Some of you are lot older than I am. At time, my late father was not a Buddhist, but he he gave very good advice. He said, there’s only one thing in this world which cannot be bought, that is time.

Money is not important. Time, time we cannot buy. If you waste your time, then when you are older, there is regret. Why didn’t I do this when I was younger? Why didn’t I study?

Why didn’t I meditate? Why didn’t I do the retreats? And as we are going into a much darker period than the one which we all started out in, certainly much darker than when I first came to Australia, it is not going to get easier. It is going to get much more difficult. Here in Australia, you have not yet been bled.

It is starting to happen. Then before it gets too difficult, we have to put effort. Because once it gets really hard, then like in England, like in Greece, like in Ireland, like in Spain, your welfare system will be put in question. Those of you who live on benefits, there will be less Means assessment how do you think about it? Means assessment, right, will change.

Then those of you who live off trade, there will be less. Those of you who find jobs, you’ll have a harder time. Those of you who are disability benefits will be told you’re not disabled enough. At that point, you will have the mind training you have accumulated now. At that point, will not be able to attend teachings at TBI.

You will not be able to meditate. You’ll be overwhelmed by this life. If you have mind training, you will be able to protect your mind. You will not collapse into depression like so many of our students in the last two years. A bevy of students who have been hospitalized in psychiatric institutions.

I’ve heard rumors of quite a few of them, you know. Then this happens due to lack of dharma. Insanity, because that’s what it is, is lack of dharma. The person is unable to control their mind, and the mind enters into a closed loop. There’s a technical term which is used for this called rumination.

The mind starts ruminating like a cow ruminates, like nonstop. And then it depends on the strength of the mind, but eventually the mind breaks. And when the mind is broken, then everything else goes. So before this happens, as I explained to you at the beginning, we have to learn to think differently. These cognitive therapies, they are extraordinarily effective and they work.

You do not have to become Buddhist. I think for many Westerners, it is probably a mistake to become a Buddhist. Probably a mistake. It does not seem to work. Westerners do not have the Buddhist heritage and now are profoundly materialistic.

But learn to train your minds in terms of these teachings for your own sake. Because if you do not take care of yourselves, how can you talk about taking care of others? What sort of a lifeguard is it who can’t swim? First, you must be a strong swimmer. You must be muscular, you must be enduring, and you must know how to swim.

Then you can try to save others. Śāntideva puts it beautifully. He said, what is this talk of bodhicitta when even in the dream you didn’t consider doing this for yourself? First, we start traveling sincerely the path of the being of the small scope. Then we understand its limitations for ourselves because true spiritual training begins by what his holiness calls enlightened egoism as opposed to coarse egoism.

Enlightened egoism is true understanding of what is to our advantage. Then when we understand the limitations of the path of the being of the small scope for ourselves, then we move up for ourselves to the path of the being of the middling scope. And then at that point, there is a click which occurs when we realize that we are not alone. That click will not happen at the level of the path of the being of the small scope. It happens at the end of the path shared with the being of the middling scope, And then I wanna end with the.

This is the path for us. Then thank you very much. It was a long presentation. My apologies. But I was able to cover everything.

And if you want to ask questions, we have a couple of minutes. This is from my own perspective at the moment. With all the study that, I’m doing, all the reading, at what stage do I balance the study with the meditation? Normally, when you study a topic, you study it until you gain a stable solid understanding. At that point, you should meditate.

That might happen on a daily basis. That might happen on a daily basis or not. It depends on the topic. For instance, if you were to study an easy topic like Gassid impermanence, there’s nothing difficult to understand about the topic. You would study the Lam Rim.

Typically, what I would suggest is you start with Lam Rim Chenmo, which is our root. Then once you have understood Lam Rim Chenmo’s presentation, flesh it out with Pabongka Rinpoche’s Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand, which is liberation in the palm of your hand, and whatever other material is translated on the topic. Once you have an overall view, it might take you a day or two, meditate. Then you meditate by alternating analytical meditation and concentration meditation. Analytical meditation would be you would take these three routes.

Death is certain, the time of death is uncertain, at the time of death nothing is afloat with Tao. You start with the first route, then that’s an easy route to realize. Death is certain. What are the reasons for which death is certain? And you can draw the three traditional reasons, but I would strongly suggest since we all have access to the Internet, document yourself.

Look at the actuary statistics. The incidence of death, apply them to yourself. My death is certain. What what is my life expectancy? How many years are left for me as a person?

And focus on this. And that’s how one proceeds. Then when you’re studying difficult topics, let’s say if you’re studying Chitamatra, then you first have to gain certainty of the topic. That may take a lot longer than two days. Reading is analytical meditation.

Reading is not wasted time. It is not the case that somehow there is study here and there’s meditation there. This is not the case. The the path which Jetsongkapa taught is a path of union of study and meditation. You find it in the initial verses of.

I’ll try to give you an English translation. Nowadays, yogis with who manifest great enthusiasm have not studied, and those who have studied do not know the fine points of practice. In other words, in the prologue of Lam Rim Cemo, Jetsongkapa states that he wrote Lam Rim Cemul because in his day, which is around fourteen o nine, Lam Rim Chenmo was written around 1409, in Tibet, the majority of yogis had not studied. And for instance, when they meditated on emptiness, we’re not quite sure what they were meditating upon, meditated on some sort of absence. And the scholars did not meditate.

They just studied. So the path which is taught by Jitsong Kopai, and this really is a reformation of Tibetan Buddhism, which has been adopted by the other schools, is one where study and meditation go hand in hand. Are there other questions? Sorry I interrupted before. I didn’t realize you didn’t take clarifications on things, but I did work it out.

Right livelihood in connection to generating bodhicitta, are there any I mean, you did mention charity, but if you wanted to have a full time job and obviously make enough money to live on, are there books, or can you think of any specific occupations that stand out that a person who’s finished uni might wanna aspire to work in? The first step is not to harm others. Yeah. So there are professions we should try to avoid. Yep.

But what should one aim for? Then if once one is not harming others, for instance, let us say, this does not include professions, such as working as a butcher alone, but let us say you were working as a financial

Adviser and encouraging people to take on more debt than they could. You’ll be harming others. Yeah. That is to be avoided. Then to try to find a profession where one helps others, The medical profession would be a classic, anything in relation with medicine.

Then any form of counseling probably involves helping others. Then you have to analyze for yourself. It is difficult to cover all the professions. Then, ideally, before going to work, whatever your job is, you would try to create a very strong motivation to help others. If that is not possible, let’s say you’re a policeman, it gets complicated.

You may have to use force to restrain people. That’s part of your job. Then you should have a strong motivation as possible not to harm others. And if harm is called for, if you have to restrain someone who is violent, to use a minimum amount of harm. The key here you have is to distinguish between the overarching and the subsidiary motivation.

The overarching motivation in the Hīnayāna is to do no harm, in the Mahāyāna is to help. Then within that overarching motivation, you have subsidiary motivations. For instance, this is a reality now we deal with in our world. If you saw someone who was on the point of detonating a bomb in a mall to kill a large number of people. And within the overarching motivation of helping others, it might be necessary to use physical violence to prevent this bomb from being detonated.

It’s not mental violence, but it might be necessary to strike the person even if you had a gun to shoot the person. You would try to shoot in a non lethal lethal fashion, but there is no guarantee you would succeed. Once you have bodhisattva vows, this is not how shall I put this one? This is not optional. It’s compulsory.

You have an obligation to intervene. Yeah. Now you need, therefore, in terms of motivation, an overarching motivation of compassion, a subsidiary motivation where basically you might, let us say, want to take the bomb and run away and hide it or put it in a dustbin. I don’t know what you would try to do under the circumstances. And then you would need wisdom.

Compassion alone is not sufficient. You need wisdom to know how to best handle the situation. For instance, we see now a fair number of very distressed people, both on the streets and at TBI. Then when you meet someone who’s extremely distressed and who starts yelling and even has a weapon, how do you handle it? You must have the motivation to help that person and others.

Then the wisdom side involves a realistic assessment of the situation. Does talking help? Is more forceful means recommended? Is calling the police possible or not possible? I remember when I was a young student in America in Berkeley, I was coming home late one night, and I lived in a difficult part of town where the small area where I lived was nice, but all around it was basically the slums, the Oakland slums, are the harshest harshest in America.

So I always tried to come back before sunset. I used the subway. I had to be home by five, because around 05:36, the shooting started. So they had in those days, they they called them Mac tens. They’re very small machine guns.

You’d hear. There’s a drug dealer shooting it out on the streets. You know? And the police was absent. We had a policeman living in the in the building.

He didn’t want to get involved. You know? And then one time I I was stuck in Berkeley. I came home late around 09:00. The sun had set.

You know? And I was walking from the subway to my flat, and there was a poor woman, a prostitute, you know, against the wall. And her pimp was pummeling her, hitting her in the stomach over and again, you know. Probably, hadn’t given him enough money. You know?

Then the police does not come. There’s no point in calling. You know? They don’t want to get involved. It’s very dangerous.

And I thought, what do I do? I don’t know if he’s armed or not. Probably, yes. Right? But what I can do is shout at him approximately 20 meters, 20 meters distance with a handgun.

You don’t hit anything. Right? Then I shouted at him, you know, in a very angry way, but he stopped hitting her. You know, he didn’t want witnesses. You know?

That’s what I could do. So here, you must have the motivation to help, and then you must have a very realistic assessment of the situation involving your understanding of the social dynamic and your understanding of your capacities. You know? And here, you don’t have these difficult situations, I think. Maybe in some areas, but not as bad.

You know? So you have to be very skillful. Very, very skillful. And you have to be realistic. You need life experience.

If you are naive, unrealistic, you make things worse instead of making them better. And your goal is to help. Right? Just two things on that. First of all, thank you for this talk.

It’s think it’s been the strongest talk I’ve ever attended in my entire life for how real it is. So thank thank you for that. And then the second thing, on the technical stuff. I’m wondering if your screensaver timer isn’t timing out when you it may be That any input you can provide to Tenzin would be profoundly appreciated. Well, I think that’s what happens if you I’m at the mercy of of the material.

You know? Because when you touch the keypad, you see it comes back to normal. Right? So I think it may have a minute time out. Is that what’s bringing it back to life when you press the button or or part of the screen?

Or This little box here, I believe, which is being wicked. You know? Okay. Well, anyway, if I can talk to him Being wicked. For the talk.

Thank you very much. Do you have other questions? Then I think we shall stop here for today. Thank you very much. Yes.

So please join with me in thanking Ilya in the usual Australian way. Thank you. Geshe-la will be talking, teaching in the morning with Tenzin at half past ten. And next next week for Mother’s Day, there will be a Green Tārā Puja at half past ten.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top