Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 06052017ILIA PART 1 – IS.mp3
UUID: 02fc61cd-bb77-461c-aada-07c0060e0e8c
Teacher: Ilia Durovic
Collection: Lam Rim (Ilia Durovic)
Date: 2017-05-06
Duration: 57 min
Words: 7,884
Various schools of philosophy when I was young, but time is limited. There’s not that much time in a human life. Then, we have to find what corresponds, as I was saying before the break, with reality. And that is up to yourselves to decide for yourself. It cannot be decided if you must use Welcome everybody.
So I would first I hope you enjoyed your cup of tea after this rather heavy handed initial presentation. And I would very much like to encourage you for your own practice to try to link the teachings you get at TBI, the Buddhist teachings with Thank you very much. It’s how fresh we go in, you know, this depends on many old faces and a couple new ones. Then I’m obviously repeating myself. We will continue in our exploration of the three principles of the path of together, you know.
And today and maybe next time as well today for sure, we will be talking about bodhichitta. But before, I wanted to think a little bit about who we are and where we come from. So, basically, it’s not a natural step for a westerner, especially in a country like Australia, which is very materialistic, to come into a Buddhist temple, especially a Tibetan Buddhist temple. As proof of the fact, you are today two, four, six, eight, nine, maybe a tenth is arriving. Out of the city with a population of one and a half million I believe.
Right? Then if we add Buddha House, let’s say in all of Adelaide you have when there are regular teachings at TBI Buddha House a maximum of 50 people, maybe 40 people attending teachings. So for the remaining one point four million nine hundred thousand nine hundred ninety five. Right? What we do here is completely irrelevant.
Then why are you here? What pushed you to or what brought you to TBI or to Buddha House or perhaps to a Thai temple? Why did you do something which is this abnormal? In a nutshell, you are all here, we are all here because we suffer. Now the modalities of suffering are very different.
Some people suffer physically, some people suffer mentally. The two interact with each other. Physical suffering creates, when the mind is untrained, mental suffering. Then mental suffering, there’s a feedback loop, amplifies the physical suffering. Mental suffering can also create physical suffering.
My father cooperated with a great Swedish scientist in America who was a pioneer of the effect of stress in fostering cancer. So stress induces cancer, you know. But whether it is physical or mental suffering, I think it’s a given that every single one of you, for reasons known best to you, have pushed the door of TBI or other Buddhist centers for the first time because you suffer. Not only because you suffer, but because the solutions which are offered by our society to suffering did not work. I am sure every single one of you tried if it was physical problems to go to the doctor and got specialist care.
If the issues were mental, you went to therapists, psychologists, maybe even heaven forbid psychiatrists. You know when you see a psychiatrist you go like this, right? But if you are here it is that whatever the suffering was their answers did not work. So what I would like to address first with you is our society’s view on happiness and suffering. What our society proposes to counter suffering when it arises and to see whether this works or not.
There is a limited sphere in which what our society has an offer does work. And then the Buddhist view calls for an expansion of the scope of suffering, which is dramatic. So that is what we will address after before entering the topic of bodhichitta. So I think there is really very little point in talking about these advanced topics if we cannot link them with your lives in one way or another. So as our societies are massively materialistic and have been so really since the industrial revolution, the eighteenth century, there’s a basic premise for all our societies, which is that there is a clear undeniable correlation between material prosperity and happiness.
This is a point of dogma. Societies and their qualities are measured in terms of GDP, gross domestic product. In other words, wealth. The wealth of a society which nowadays defines whether it’s a successful society or not. And then it’s a very naive question, but what I would like to ask is, is it true that there is a clear correlation between the prosperity of a society and the happiness of its inhabitants.
And then if PowerPoint cooperates, can do this otherwise. Yes. So I wanted to show you a very interesting chart, you know, which basically this that is actually difficult to get, but was compiled during a period covering 1995 to 2,000, over 70 countries, 80 countries almost. And it plots what is known as a Human Development Index, I’m really sorry, my laser pointer is quite dark, which reflects the total wealth of a society, not just the financial wealth, but for instance in a country like this one, which has a very developed welfare system. This is physical health welfare provides, mental health availability of therapists and so forth.
So in Abscessa you have the Human Development Index, and in order that you have the assessment of the inhabitants of the country of their own levels of happiness. Right? How happy are they? So if the materialist thesis was correct, you’d expect basically all of the countries with a high human development index to be extremely happy. In other words, to be up here on top.
Right? And you would expect all of the poor countries with a very low human development index to be at the bottom here. They are poor and they’re miserable. They’re rich and they’re happy. Now what is interesting is that to a degree there are some countries up here, they include Australia, but this was two zero five, which are both rich and happy.
But there are a huge number of countries down here, which are actually very rich, but miserable. And these include Ireland, Georgia, Hungary, Lithuania, Slovakia, Estonia, Belarusia, Albania, Armenia, Russia, The Ukraine are on the very bottom of the list. And then you have countries, two African countries, which are extraordinarily poor, Tanzania and Nigeria, which are way on the top. They are very poor, but people rate themselves as actually happier than any of the developed countries. So this is very interesting because what this shows is that there is not an automatic correlation between material prosperity in the broad sense of the term.
We’re not talking of the crass American understanding of wealth here, but the comfort of a society and happiness. And you are broadly here for that reason. Westerners turn to Buddhism when they realize that it is not because you are richer and you have a prettier wife or more handsome husband and a more beautiful house and you can go on vacations to more prestigious places, you know, that you are happier. It’s at that point that the model starts to collapse. And this chart very interestingly shows this lack of correlation.
So there’s a lot of research, and you may have heard of some of the research which has been going on in of all places, Bhutan, on the happiness index, you know, and an attempt to measure the success of the country by other criteria than just by wealth. So this is the world at large, but you might think that Australia is different. And then, unfortunately, have news for you, it is not. Then I did something which I’m not supposed to do and plotted two charts on top of each other. You’re supposed to look at data these days without any relation between each other.
When you plot data together, it’s very interesting. The bottom, have data from the Australian Treasury Department, so I only have a little 2,000, which plots what’s known as a GDP per capita. That is the wealth of a society divided by the number of inhabitants. So the average wealth of the ordinary Australian over one century, a bit less, sixty years. You can see it’s pretty much all over the place.
We go from 2.2 to 1.8, up to 3.2, leading up to the seventies. Obviously a big depression, and then it’s rising steadily. And what I plotted above is the self assessed happiness of Australians from 1945 to 2000. You see the straight line. It has steadily declined with no relation whatsoever with material prosperity, GDP per capita.
In other words, Australia’s economic situation has gone left, right, up and down, but people are steadily more unhappy. So once again, this demonstrates that for Australia, there is not an automatic correlation between prosperity and happiness. There’s something flawed, in other words, in the realm of Denmark, There’s something flawed with materialism. You know the famous line from Hamlet. Right?
And then let us narrow our focus and look at the male suicide rate over the twentieth century in Australia. So it’s very interesting. If you look at the fifteen to twenty four age group, which is basically the group normally which should be the most optimistic about life, you’re just beginning your life. Right? The rate of suicide between nineteen o seven and 1990 is multiplied by almost five.
We go from six per hundred thousand to twenty seven per hundred thousand. It drops slightly two thousand to twenty per hundred thousand. And you can see this very clearly. The bottom black line of the chart is the suicide rate of the the young, basically, which we can say skyrockets in one century. And the suicide rate with the elderly drops.
That, I think, is quite easy to explain. You know, much better medical care, much better facilities for the elder, less suffering. But why are young Australians suiciding with this frequency? And actually, a friend of mine who’s used to be a well known radio presenter, here told me he had interviewed a psychiatrist who told him that these figures grossly understated the percentage of suicides. He said, there’s an awful lot of suicides which are just disguised by the wishes of the family and with the cooperation of the police as accidents.
Know, someone drives his car into a tree and it’s a terrible accident, he lost control of his car. So once again, we see a society which is materially, extraordinarily successful. Certainly Australians live better now than they ever did. Certainly far better than the nineteenth century. And where people are more and more unhappy.
Now, how or what does our society propose when the times get hard? I suspect many of you have started to feel the crunch. Talked about it quite a few times at TBI when I first came to Australia in 2008, 2009. Back then, I think Australians were very complacent. What I generally heard was it won’t happen here.
This is what I’ve heard in all the countries which have crashed financially. We are different. Australia is different. The conditions are different. You know?
And my wife, keeps track of the social, how do you call them? Social records, social sites, Facebook and all that. Social media. Social media. My wife keeps track of the social media for me.
She’s my intelligence agent. You know? And we have active so she keeps track of what happens in the part of, the hills where I live Blackwood. This was something she brought to my attention just last week. An old couple, elderly in their seventies, facing bankruptcy, who have to work at any price.
And they will pick weeds, they’ll do small, medium labor, and they’re trying to get permission from their landlord to sublet their flat. This becomes very, very common in the hills. From what I see in Downtown Adelaide, it’s quite common too. So when this happens, what happens? I covered the names here so that it’s a very nice looking old lady, know, very typically Australian.
What happens in this type of situation? The promises of the model have collapsed. Right? Or the model promises, a, prosperity, and b, a correlation between your prosperity and your happiness. So I’ve shown you that there’s really no correlation or certainly no automatic correlation between prosperity and happiness.
And now, the society cannot deliver ever increasing levels of prosperity. And we see it. We see it in the fragile groups. The single mothers, the retired people, everyone who’s basically trying to keep the living standard they had before the GFC. You know, it is no longer possible.
And instead of accepting this, people take levels of risk like this old couple they do not understand and go bankrupt. They lose not just what they wanted to have, they lose what they needed to live in a modicum of dignity. Then what does our society propose when this happens? What is proposed is a psychiatrized unhappiness. And this is a very interesting material, I can’t get this for Australia.
These are topics you don’t get funding to study. Because it is a little bit too close to the bone for our consumer societies. This is US data which shows clearly how unhappiness has become a psychiatric problem. And you look at the total inpatient days per 100,000 inhabitants over a ten year span, the data is not available post GFC, I would imagine it has skyrocketed. Now what is striking here is you can see in children ages five to 13, total inpatient days double, more than double.
In adolescents, they certainly increase thirty, forty percent. It’s only in the elderly that they grow. So once again, we have the pattern we saw earlier of tremendous mental suffering among the young and teenagers. Largely due, in my opinion, because I don’t have children but I have nephews, so I study the young through my nephew and nieces, Largely due to the collapse of expectations. Then, if unhappiness is psychiatrist, just how effective is psychiatric, in other words, medicalized treatment of unhappiness?
In other words, treatment of depression, of anxiety, of obsessive troubles and whatnot, you know. Then some recent studies are very interesting in this respect. This is in your bibliography, I don’t know if it was handed out. If not, ask at the front desk. You know, the article is very interesting by Kirsch and Deacon.
It’s a meta analysis, in other words, analysis of analyses, analyses of studies of the effect of antidepressants, all the antidepressants, compared with placebo, in terms of the initial severity of the depressive situation. What is striking here is that there only appears a clinically significant different difference, that is in green, between drugs, any drug and placebo, in extremely severe cases of depression. In any but the most severe cases of depression, a placebo, in other words a sugar tablet, which has basically no medical efficacy in and of itself, is as effective as an antidepressant. Prozac or whatever they prescribe these days. And this is quite interesting because what is a placebo?
A placebo is a crutch which is used to bring the healing powers of the mind in the picture. In a nutshell, that’s what it is. The healing powers of the mind are not recognized. They’re a big problem for the pharmaceutical industry because when you want to study a drug, want to eliminate all the suggestion. So you test this so called double blind test.
Those of you who studied science know. One group is given a placebo, one group is given, let’s say, the antidepressant you want to study, Neither group knows who received what, and then they compare the results. And the difference between the two groups is the efficacy of the drug. So if this is the case, you can see already that antidepressants are not terribly effective. Basically, would be a lot less expensive to hand out Smarties to people and tell them they’re antidepressants.
Now what becomes even more interesting is when you contrast the effect of antidepressants, what is known as cognitive therapy, in other words learning to seek differently, and placebo in the treatment of depression. Now you see in terms of percentage responding to treatment, that cognitive therapies and the various drugs, which are in white and in blue, are broadly speaking equivalent. It’s quite astonishing. A cognitive therapy costs nothing. There’s no development cost.
You have the skill of learning someone to think differently in a more constructive way, and that is, broadly speaking, equivalent, especially over the Lojong, with the administration of any of the standard drugs. You can see, basically, the difference is probably statistically insignificant over sixteen weeks, fifty seven point five to fifty eight point three. What is even more interesting is the rate of relapse between cognitive therapies and placebos, placebos and ADMs. And here, what’s striking, if you look at cognitive therapies, which are in blue, the rate of relapse is extraordinarily low. This is quite haunting.
Quite haunting because it indicates that cognitive therapies are by far the best choice, they are the cheapest choice, they are broadly speaking for most cases as effective as antidepressant medications, and the relapse rate is lower. Why are they not used? They’re not used simply because the whole approach flies in the face of the dominant paradigm, which is a materialist paradigm where you treat a disease with a pill. And all of you are here, as I said at the beginning, because you suffer or you suffer. And I would like to think that these charts have demonstrated one thing, which is that learning to think differently is an extraordinarily effective way to counter your own suffering.
This is not my own affirmation as a practicing Buddhist, there’s data to support it. If you learn to think differently, you will be able to overcome whatever certain mental issues you are facing, and the rate of relapse is lower. And both for yourselves and for society, the cost is lower. Now, the scope of suffering as understood in Buddhism is broader than that which has brought many of you here. And this is where we have to move up from a vision of the world which is focused on this life alone to one which expands perhaps beyond the scope of this life.
I would only talk of two subdivisions of suffering today, because I think they are easier to understand. The eightfold and the sixfold subdivision of suffering. Then within the eightfold subdivision of suffering, birth we don’t remember. Rumor has it that if we do, we would be in big trouble. Some therapies which try to bring back birth memories it seems to be quite traumatic.
In this room I’d say a third of you experience right now the suffering of aging to a greater or lesser degree. Once you start going to the gym to try to look good, once you start dying your hair, once you start using makeup, you are experiencing directly the suffering of aging. So it’s an interesting thing I noticed at TBI that no one ever seems to grow gray. Just me. I seem to grow gray grayer each year, and when I don’t shave a couple days, it’s basically white here.
Everyone else is astonishingly vivid, you know. And this is a suffering of aging, isn’t it? Suffering of sickness, many students come here. Typically, it is cancer or Alzheimer’s, degenerative diseases which affect Westerners. They tend to come in the final phases, where basically it is late.
Nothing was really done. They just lived their life, didn’t think too much about things. And then at the end, in emergency, they come and sometimes they can be helped, like Geshe Yama Rinpoche helped someone who’s dying of cancer. Sometimes it is not possible. It is very, very late.
And then the suffering of death, Chris works in palliative care. I think if you want you can talk to him during the break. He sees firsthand what the suffering of death is. Westerners generally, not always, do not die well. If you’re a materialist and you really haven’t thought too much about what comes after, even you’re dogmatically convinced that there is nothing, then the death process is one of extinction.
So in addition to the physical pain we talked about, you have a feedback loop where the mind basically amplifies this pain through fear and anguish, you know. The deaths are very hard. A friend of mine who was a doctor in a French hospital told me that they had one cancer patient they had to strap down. She was dying of cancer, a younger woman, you know, and well, you know, the final phases, basically, you have, you know, intravenous drips everywhere. Right? Typically, you are permanently on morphine. You have medical solutions for that. And she kept crawling out of the bed, dragging the grips behind her, they’d find her crawling in the hallway on all fours, right? So they had to strap her down, you know. In my own father’s case when he died, you know, the final phases he had to be strapped down.
They strapped him down with leather straps, you know. In his case it was a suffering of suffocation, he died of lung cancer. Then it is death by a thousand cuts as the old Chinese said, you know. Then in this room, every single one of us is going to go this route. Anila perhaps first, but there’s no guarantee, you know.
There’s no guarantee. So it’s a gateway we have to cross. How we cross it? Physically, there’s very little I have to tell you. You read the whatever sites where all the good advice is given about diet and all that.
You know, just, you know, don’t over indulge, don’t drink, don’t smoke, please don’t use drugs. Right? But mentally, it’s up to you. Because really, one is alone on the night, as my mother said it. So I have seen lay people die very well.
I have seen Sanga die very badly. I saw a Tibetan monk die very badly. I know of a Tibetan monk who died very badly. Liver and kidney failure, you know, he was just screaming all along, you know. The robes, they make no difference.
Then the four last sufferings, I think everyone in this room is probably here because of that. Encountering the unpleasant, well, all of us, we encounter experiences we don’t want. You may wish to get a loan from the bank to buy the house you dream about, and the bank doesn’t give it. Right? Because your revenue stream is not sufficient.
That’s encountering the unpleasant. You may wish to have a partner, but no one wants to be with you because you’re too old. I don’t know. What do you think we’re talking about? You laugh.
It’s true. What do you think we’re talking about? This is reality. Right? If I ask you your ages, most of the women will not give me their ages.
Right? Because it affects their market value in terms of partner. Right? So the big effort, it’s a turning point. All the women I’ve ever known who said they would not use makeup, start using it around 41, 42, right?
So we encounter what is unpleasant, and we don’t encounter what is pleasant. We would love to encounter what is pleasant. We struggle. Right? Everyone wants more money, it doesn’t come.
Everyone wants a better job, it doesn’t come. We don’t get what we want. And then the suffering of the five aggregates, I will not talk about it, is specifically Buddhist. So it’s a bit premature at present. And the six fold suffer subdivision of suffering, again, all of us have experienced this.
The suffering of uncertainty is one of the biggest ones. We have no way of knowing what our future leads to. I was in Switzerland ten years ago, now I’m in Australia. You are in Adelaide today. Tomorrow, you might be forced to move elsewhere.
Today, some of us are happily settled, others are single. Tomorrow, it may be the opposite. There is no guarantee. I was ordained. Today, I’m a layperson.
Others are ordained. Tomorrow, they will be lay people. This is the suffering of psychic existence. And the fault of insatiability, which is that whatever we have is never ever good enough. Is it?
We have a decent situation, but we want more. We have a house, but we want a better house. We have a partner, but we want a better partner. This is the human predicament. Then, at present, have to expand our understanding of the scope of suffering from this life to the Buddhist sense that there are many lives in the past, and unless we do something about it, an infinite number of lives in the future.
Now, already based on what we talked about so far, on the suffering in this life in a wealthy country like Australia, just how many of you want to go through this over and again? Health problems, mental problems, relationship problems, money problems, going back to school over and over and over again. Right? Then imagine having to die over and over and over again. Not one time, but millions of times.
Not easy deaths like here on the morphine, but hard deaths. Not deaths in the hospital, but deaths from a wound, from being eaten alive, depending on the rebirth. Animals eat each other alive. We have a cat who we we feed left to himself. That cat leads eats other beings while they are living.
Right? The fault of being conceived over again is the fault of birth over again, which is horrific for the child and horrific for the mother. And the fault of falling from the high to the low so many of us have experienced since 2008, I’ve lost track of the number of students here who had high status in society, who now no longer have high status, have low status. Then depending on the student, it is handled better or worse. I’ve received a large number of emails in the last couple of years.
I remember one in particular, Lojong student of Henri Burchay, who crashed and burned in 02/10. He’s doing very well, then, you know, he lost his job. This is a standard sequence I used to see in France, which now you have here. He lost his job, then he couldn’t pay his bills, then his wife left him, they divorced, then he went bankrupt, then he had a depression. This is the sequence in which these things unfold.
Right? And he wrote me he had to reinvent himself. And then I was perhaps unskillful in my answer. I said, well, so many of our students have either crashed and burned. But the teachings are of benefit and people don’t like to be put face to face with the reality of their situation.
Hence the laughter a couple minutes ago when I said, too old to have a partner. Right? It’s laughter to defuse tension. As you know, you know, in terms of animal behavior, especially among primates, laughter defuses tension or anger. Right?
The person is angry. You know? So this is our situation. And then the final thought of psychic existence is that of being alone. Then in this room, I think a majority of our students are alone.
If you are single, you are definitely alone. And if you’re in a relationship with someone who doesn’t understand you, you’re perhaps even more alone than single. Then, if this is not just the human lot, but the lot of every conscious being, is this really something we should be desiring? Or is it worth escaping from? If this is happening not accidentally during one life because somehow through, as I explained at the beginning, a fluke of circumstances, GDP growth is not sufficient and we’re not able to buy the house, get the partner, buy the partner, because many men and women do just that.
Then if this is the way things are, we have to try to find a way out. So once one starts reflecting over and again on first, as I explained to you, the fact that the materialist model is actually is pie in the sky. It’s a model where all of us are being led by the tip of our nose to foster economic growth. We are being convinced that being efficient economic agents is not just in the interest of society, which it probably is, but is in our personal interest as well. And that sacrificing our lives to economic productivity and not asking the big questions, because the big questions are precisely what are going to stop you dead in your tracks.
That is a way to be a constructive member of society. The big questions for our society have no answer. That’s a dogma. Because if there were an answer, people would stop working whatever the hours are in Australia, eight to five, nine to six, I don’t know, You know, five days a week and doing overtime, and they would sit back and say, but why am I here? Where am I going?
What is this life for? And at that point, there is a big impact on a market economy. Market economies do not like philosophers. Market economies do not like spiritually inclined people because they are not productive. So the first step therefore is to create a strong sense or to generate a strong sense that we have been excuse me, I use a very vulgar term here, we have been conned.
You know what conned means. Right? We have had the wool pulled over our eyes. We have been taught that happiness can be obtained a certain way and only that way. And all along it has been obvious to those with eyes to see that this is false.
And the data, as you can see, is in. It’s not Buddhist data. You know? And then if that is the case, we have to seek for a realistic way to obtain happiness. And the data I showed you about cognitive therapies makes a very strong case that changing the way we think is a realistic approach to being happy.
Now, how do we change the way we think to maximize happiness? The more our thinking meshes with reality, with the way things actually are, as opposed to what we would like them to be, the happier we will be. The less tension there will be between our expectations and what the world out there can deliver. If you are convinced that you are Michael Jackson and the world has to treat you as Michael Jackson, you’re going to be miserable because it’s not going to happen. If you are convinced that you aren’t someone terribly important, that you don’t matter, and that no one really cares, you will matter, you’d manage quite well, because that is actually reality.
For this reason, and this is the core of the Buddhist understanding, if the road to happiness is to mesh our mental expectations with what the world is with reality, then we have to understand how the world is. And we understand how the world is through relying initially on empirical data, and then on reason or logic. There’s nothing else to Buddhism than this. Buddhism is rational in the beginning, the middle, and the end. Then Buddha Śākyamūni, who was without any doubt the greatest philosopher of all time, at least for myself, and who was also known as Buddha means the enlightened one.
Śākyamūni is the sage, Muni, of the Shakya clan. Now, Śākyamūni set off on this path to try to understand how the world actually is, what is the actual mode of existence of phenomena in ourselves, And to change his mental outlook so that it mirrored this, and in so doing, attained peace. This is the road which is offered to us. Do you understand? Does this make sense to you?
Then I won’t enter in detail in the way the world actually is. The core is taught in the four seals, which we talked about many times at TBI, that our composite phenomena are impermanent, or contaminated phenomena are the nature of suffering, that, all phenomena are empty and selfless, and that there is a nirvana which is peace and happiness. Of these four seals, the three first ones are accessible exclusively to logic and experience. That all composite phenomena are impermanent and disintegrate, you can experience if you just think about it. Contaminated phenomena are the nature of suffering.
Just take yourself as a contaminated phenomenon as an example. Look at your lives. Ask yourself authentically, is your life a happy one or not? Your answer will probably be no. And then that phenomena are empty and selfless.
Selflessness is an extension of impermanence. The only seal which is not directly accessible to experience or reason is the existence of a state beyond suffering known as nirvana. That is a difficult point. That calls for careful reflection that we won’t enter into here. It calls for analysis of causality.
So once one understands that our experiences are of the nature of suffering fundamentally because of the inadequacy between what we want and what is possible. And that what we want is inexhaustible. We are impossible to satisfy. No car is ever good enough. And what is available is not inexhaustible, then you can see the importance of mind transformation.
This is what Buddhadharma has on offer, nothing else. Now, the transition to bodhichitta occurs when one understands that we are all identical in this respect. It is not just me alone who wishes for things which will never happen and create tremendous bitterness and unhappiness because of this. It is every single one of us whose expectations are totally unrelated to the underlying reality. This gives rise to empathy initially and compassion.
We are all in the same boat. And now after this very general introduction, which was intentionally nontechnical, to try just to give us all a sense of where we come from and where we are going, I would like to enter into a presentation of bodhichitta, which is a more formal, more precise and traditional presentation. But I think I’d like to take questions at first right now on what was covered so far. All the articles are listed in your bibliographies. Positive psychology.
I’m just thinking about that it’s also a modality that’s used to change the way we think. Definitely. And I wonder what you think about the sort of outcomes, obviously it doesn’t lead to liberation, but the outcomes of such a modality. Positive psychology, I know little but I’ve heard about it. Any therapy which involves changing the way you think and which changes the way you think so that this corresponds more with reality will make you a happier person.
It’s a given. And the question is your scope. Most of our students, I don’t want to say all, but sometimes I feel it’s all, come here because of problems in this life, and because they’re looking for solutions in this life. I think it’s a reality of Western Buddhism. The scope, in other words, is very, very small.
There are problems which can be solved of this life, can be solved within this life. But there are problems which cannot, because we bring most of what we are from a past which precedes this life. You, Andy, bring, I would say, 99% of who you are from a distant past, which we do not know. Some of that past comes out in dreams. Your dreams can tell you an awful lot about where you come from.
Some dreams are comically connected, some dreams you have images of past lives. There are, and this I won’t cover today, I’ve done this many times at TBI, there are repetitious patterns over the lives in cases of children who recollect past lives or in cases of hypnotic regression. Then the patterns which are covered are mainly the most destructive patterns because people go to see psychiatrist largely because they’re in big trouble. Suicide is a classic, suicidal impulses life after life after life after life. They amplify over time.
Issues with anger as well, you know. So you can see that if you take positive psychology, any discipline which is going to circumscribe itself to this life, if it is true that the mind goes back basically into the infinite past, cannot be a true therapy. It can start to help, for sure. But until the root issues are addressed, you cannot eliminate the problems. And for most Western Buddhists, would say what is broadly speaking missing is a heartfelt belief in the existence of past and future lives.
It is accepted, but it is not integrated. And the best way to address that one, I think, is to study Stevenson’s work. Study Stevenson’s work, then the work of psychiatrists like Morris Neverton, who did fantastic work, you know, regressing people via hypnosis, people who are he’s a psychiatrist by training. And some other ones whose work is more tentative, but certainly Netherton and Stevenson did remarkable work. And then you can see in these cases how patterns of behavior go from life to life.
Like with Stevenson, it’s very striking. Stevenson found that the dominant memories children had of their previous life was a mode of mode of death. So children who remember past lives, in Stevenson’s research, comprised seventy percent of all the children who remembered sorry, children who remembered violent deaths comprised seventy percent of all the children who remembered past lives. And the main phobia of the child in this life was linked to the mode of death. So this clearly shows that the accounts modern psychology gives of phobias are probably in, at best, incomplete, possibly completely fallacious.
If you have a phobia of fire, of water, or you have agoraphobia, you’re terrified of crowds, it may have nothing to do with your early childhood whatsoever. Freud was very hampered in his work by the materialist model with which he worked, and it might very simply be due to the fact that you were crushed by a mob in your previous life. You know? There’s many phobias phobias of snakes, phobias of spiders with people. I’ve known many cases where the person has had no experience with the snake, the spiders, or fire.
Then one wonders where this comes from, you know. Then you could see why positive psychology would be helpful, but very limited. Very limited. Do you have other questions? I’ve heard a little bit about the experiments where they have children who are put in a room and they have, say, a marshmallow put in front of them and they’re asked if they delay eating the marshmallow.
Maybe you’ve spoken about that as well. These children I do. I have enormous so the children who the longer they’re able to delay eating the marshmallow, they have much better life. The more successful they are, yes. And I was thinking that perhaps the path of being medium scope is kind of that quality taken to the infinite or as far as it could go.
Exactly. I mean, the basis of the path of the building scope is the training in ethics. Ethics is a capacity to say no. Right? Ethics is very simply the capacity to say when faced with temptation, no, I will not do this.
You have ethics if you have strong boundaries. You don’t have ethics if you have weak boundaries. Ordination is ethics at the highest level. One has strong vestimentary boundaries, which symbolize, if you wish, one’s inner boundaries. Then the marshmallow experiment shows that even in this life, children who have what we used to call willpower or self control are inordinately more successful than those who don’t.
You know, it’s a predictor of success in life. The capacity to say, No, I will not. I would like to blow up, but no, I will not. You know, I would like to stuff my face, but no, I will not. But that’s yes, definitely.
Definitely. That’s all that ethics is. In Tibetan ethics is tsultrim, the mode of behaving. So it doesn’t correspond at all to the English term ethics which derives from ethos in Greek. Do you have other questions?
So the one thing I wanted to point out, and it is a very long prelude to the bodhichitta, but I think it is necessary, is basically, and I recapitulate before the tea break, that there is no necessary correlation between happiness and material welfare. And I think the data is in internationally, it’s in for Australia. Look at the rate of suicide, it’s self evident. And that, when people have to face hard times in a society like this, where they have been told, basically, that there’s nothing before this life and frankly we don’t have a clue what ask comes after, and asking the questions is a waste of time, we should focus on the here and now, then these people cannot handle it. As a result, unhappiness is treated as a psychiatric disorder.
This has dramatically increased in the last twenty years, and it is an approach which does not work except in the most severe cases. Unless you’re dealing with clinical depression, antidepressants are as good as placebo. The data is in and it’s in from a meta study, which means a study which correlates multiple studies. Not only this, but learning to think differently, in other words cognitive therapies, in terms of efficacy as beneficial as antidepressants, and in terms of rate of relapse are far superior. Then, what cognitive therapy should one adopt?
One in which the mind is taught to think in keeping with the way things are. How do we know how things are? Through experience and logic. Experience and reason. This is Buddhism.
You analyze reality, just in a second, I’ll take your question. You analyze reality, you analyze who you are, your own situation, analyze carefully, and then you try to change how you think, and you change how you think through meditating on what you have analyzed. Then here, because it’s a Buddhist center, you people do not have the time to study in-depth, the way it is done in the monasteries via debate and so forth. The presentation is more basic. One is presented at Lamrim.
One is taught, you know, the elements of the Lamrim, how to meditate on the Lamrim. But it is up to oneself to compare this with reality and see whether it is true or not. If it and we’re not speaking of the details like Mount Meru. Right? But the basics.
If the basics don’t correspond with reality, then we should walk away. Yes, Brahoni, please. I was just about I thought, is this a good analogy or not thinking? It might not be, but it might be. Nietzsche had that idea of who?
Nietzsche. He had an idea of A Nietzsche. Trying to live one’s life as if that were going to happen eternally again, again, again, and trying to instead of, you know, as a way of thinking of past and future lives as motivation for ethical behavior to take that mindset? Yes. You’re referring to the in which Nietzsche refers to the cyclical nature of the universe.
He draws it from Plato. Then whether the universe is cyclical or not, we don’t know. That’s sort of an open question. And I’m not terribly sure what Nietzsche meant in the Zarathustra I think it’s been the approach to think that one should try to live one’s life with the mindset that it could happen eternally on repeat and so if that were to be true that it was possible that each lifetime could happen again and again and again then we should aspire to live such with the Lam Rim as a guide that in the next life and the next life and the next life if we keep following the Lamrim we’d be taking that idea of I think there are elements which are quite close. It is not the case that each life is exactly identical to the previous one.
One life you might be a woman like yourself, and the next life you might be a man. Right. In the following life you might be something else. But the Lamrim is still a problem. But these blocked patterns, the eight sufferings, six sufferings, the three sufferings, this is a repetitive pattern.
This happens not in one life, but life after life after life, whatever are rebirths. In some rebirths, it’s more manifest, in others less. And you asked me, last Tuesday, which rebirth one should strive for. And I told you that the rebirth one should strive for is that with the optimal balance between suffering and happiness. Only happiness, we make no effort at any type of spiritual development.
Only suffering, we are unable to do so. So a human rebirth, certainly what’s known as a human rebirth of leisure and endowment, is optimal because there’s enough suffering to prod us to find answers, but there’s not so much suffering that we are basically crushed in the process. It’s a happy medium. My wife’s dog may or may not understand that she is suffering, but her mental capacities are so limited, there’s absolutely nothing she can do about it. And she will be be reborn as an animal over, well in her case maybe not, but over and over and over again.
And saying mantra at the ears of the duong is cute, but it doesn’t work. If it worked, all the animals could be saved that way. You accumulate merit when you do it, but to think that you can save animals by reciting mantras in their ears, which they do not understand as mantras, is naive. It’s very naive. We have to throw a very, very long and hard look at our own situation and that of animals in the lower realms.
This is why and I will stop here, we will cover bodhichitta formally after the break. This is why one must avoid at any cost a rebirth in the lower realms because frankly there is almost no way out. Once you’re reborn as a dog or a cat, the only hope you have is previous karmic imprints. They have to be brought to mature, and you have to meet the circumstances for this. In the meantime, you accumulate gigantic amounts of non-virtuous karma.
Gigantic. Then we’ll take a break now, and after the break, we’ll cover bodhichitta. If we could try to make it ten minutes, it would be good.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- four seals
- The four basic tenets that define Buddhism. They are: all compositional phenomena are impermanent, all contaminated phenomena are by nature suffering, all phenomena are empty of self-existence and nirvana is true peace. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- Mount Meru
- The mythical center of the universe in Buddhist cosmology. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
- Yama shinchi dagje (Tib)
- The Lord of Death, seen on the Wheel of Life. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.