2 h 13 min · 14,972 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The speaker links quantum mechanics and the role of the observer to Buddhist phenomenology, arguing that consciousness may be non-material. He then presents Buddhist ethics as consequentialist across many lives, with intention as the karmic motor, and gives ways to examine one’s actual motivation. The recording ends with a question and answer session on mind and brain, euthanasia and commitment.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 2h 13m
UUID: 91ede267-33d2-41bc-b007-20c5f3713cdd
Words: 14,968
Thank you very much, Chris. It’s a pleasure to see you all again. I am the resident translator at TBI with a background in Buddhist philosophy and many, many years ago a background in mathematics and physics from the Swiss Federal Polytechnic in Zurich where I started studying at the premature age. They actually delayed my entry for one year at the premature age of 17. Then in many senses it is physics and German philosophy, brought me to Buddhism.
So it is a bit of an uncommon path. I have never talked about this at TBI because it’s far removed, think from the interests of most of the people here, but these are topics which have been worrying me for many years. And I thought I would just present them to you in a fairly casual fashion. It’s a work in becoming if you wish. Then you might wonder why I should bring up the topic of, physics when we have a symposium on Buddhist ethics.
Fundamentally, is because much of present scientific discourse is co opted by the biological sciences, which in terms of their worldview, in terms of their Weltanschauung, profoundly or remain profoundly mechanistic and profoundly Newtonian. It is within physics and specifically within quantum physics that the possible domains of dialogue between science and Buddhism are at their most acute. Largely because in quantum physics, it is impossible to exclude the observer from an analysis of the phenomenon observed. And this therefore is perhaps the first step we will take in our understanding of the universe within which Buddhist ethics unfolds. So as Fritz London, who was one of the greatest chemists of the twentieth century, the founder of what is known as quantum molecular dynamics.
In other words, the application of quantum mechanics to chemistry said, one can doubt the possibility of establishing philosophical truths by the methods of physics, but it is surely not outside the competence of physicists to demonstrate that certain statements which pretend to have a philosophical validity do not. And in this context, I would like to try to analyze the possible models of the universe we will be referring to as substratum for ethical analysis. Generally speaking, I think one can divide models of the universe into what I have called non participatory and participatory models of the universe. And here I refer to participatory in the sense of consciousness participating within the physical universe. Now we can say that the totality of western modernity is rooted in a non participatory view of the universe.
For Newtonian physics, the observer is basically totally removed from the phenomenon being observed and this is the way things should be. And even in both theories of relativity, the special and the general theory of relativity, the observer whatever his status is removed from the phenomena being studied. Now this non participatory stance is rooted in western history. It is rooted specifically in the monotheistic background which has marked much of western philosophy. There is another alternative and it is only recently that it has come to hold sway.
It is the participatory outlook which is propounded by quantum mechanics in which there is an entanglement, a mixing between the observer and the phenomenon observed, which is only resolved in the act of observation. And this is the case for some, but not all schools of quantum mechanics. So there’s some debate about the Copenhagen School, which I’ll be talking very briefly about today. There is however no debate that the interpretation which I will focus upon today, von Neumann’s interpretation of quantum mechanics, and Wigner’s whose little house outside I hope you were able to admire are participatory. I’m in this context delighted that Ralph this morning spoke of John von Neumann, perhaps the greatest mathematician of the twentieth century, one of my personal heroes who is not only the founder of game theory, but certainly from the standpoint of physics, the first and perhaps the last to formally axiomatize quantum mechanics in a work which was translated far too late in English mathematical foundations of quantum mechanics.
So what we can see is that in a religious context, the monotheistic religions give rise to a non participatory view of the universe and so do so does secular materialism. I personally see a very tight connection between monotheism and secular materialism. I believe that monotheism in its historical evolution, once God is evacuated from what amounts to the clockwork universe, easily leads to secular materialism. There is however in the history of philosophy an alternative set of traditions which is epitomized by the great Indian philosophies. Buddhism, Hinduism, and Jain, and it is Buddhism which is of particular interest for us here.
Now, the model of the universe to which one subscribes is fundamentally intertwined with the ethics which one chooses to practice. It is clear and Pamela alluded this morning to the various ethical categories that non participatory universe models, which as we said are rooted in monotheistic religions or secular materialisms, naturally lead in the case of monotheistic religions to normative ethics, an ethics of obligations if you wish. And in the case of secular materialism to what I have chosen to call finite consequentialism, which is all of the consequentialist ethics from utilitarianism through the various contemporary forms. Participatory ethics certainly in the Gangetic traditions, the Indian traditions without exception are consequentialist, but it is a fundamentally different type of consequential which I would like to call infinite consequentialism. It is consequentialism in other words an ethics rooted in the consequences of deed deeds extended over infinite time instead of being circumscribed within one human life.
So this was the easy bit. Now I’m afraid we have to do a little bit of physics and I’d like to try to focus on core ideas to show those aspects of quantum mechanics which in my opinion lead in the direction of the gangetic traditions. If we look at the description of reality which is given by modern physics, we can say that there are three sacred numbers in physics which summarize the universe in other words omega as we know it. The first is the constant universal constant of gravitation from classical Newtonian mechanics, which is one of the core unexplained constants of the universe. It rules the rate at which two bodies are attracted irrespective of the distance.
The second is perhaps the most important number in physics. Certainly one of the most profound Planck’s constant H which is extraordinarily small. It is one of the features of these two numbers. This is the number which is preceded by 11 zeros. This is a number which is preceded by 34 zeros.
And the third is the number which is central to the theory of relativity which is the speed of light in a vacuum 300,000 kilometers a second. You can say that physics rests on these three numbers. Now in the case of quantum physics, what is very interesting is that quantum physics has moved radically away from the dominant paradigm of all science since the sixteenth century. Even Heisenberg who was certainly the most positivistic of the early quantum physicists sees quantum physics as moving away from simple materialism or realism. What exactly was the root of quantum physics?
Quantum physics arises in a classical context, and I won’t enter into too many details. It arises from a study by one of the leading physicists of his age, Max Planck, of the way in a in which a closed black box with one orifice in a state of thermal equilibrium radiates energy. Now the problem is that this pattern of radiation of energy was expected to follow certain rules according to classical physics, specifically Maxwell’s laws, and it didn’t. It broke so radically with it that Planck who described the phenomena, who described the energy being transmitted in what amounts to packets of energy, which are now called the quanta of energy, did not fully understand the import of his decision. And even though he is known as the father of quantum physics, personally I tend to consider Einstein, with his famous famed paper on the photoelectric effect as the actual father of quantum physics.
In the case of quantum physics, we are dealing with one of three physical models. Historically, physics starts basically with what is known as classical Newtonian physics. Newton’s physics in other words. What we would call nowadays classical mechanics for which the speeds are low and the sizes are great to put it very very simply. So if you are at speeds which are way below the speed of light, you have non relativistic phenomena.
As the speed increases particular phenomena come into play variation specifically of what’s known as the inert mass. And the moment the speed reaches 80% of the speed of light, the masses at a given velocity of velocity of 80 of the speed of light is twice the actual mass at zero velocity. At this point, we definitely can no longer ignore the relativistic effect. We have moved out of classical mechanics. There is however a nebulous boundary between the two.
Likewise with quantum physics, the boundary is actually defined by size. It is commonly said that quantum physics is subatomic. This is not true actually. We have molecules like ammonia which exhibit quantum, very strong quantum behavior. But definitely the moment you go above the size of a fairly simple molecule, you have moved back into classical Newtonian physics.
The basic problem is that more classical Newtonian physics can be seen as a simplified case of relativistic physics with low speeds and it can also be seen as a simplified case of quantum physics with high magnitudes or I have basically used here the moment of inertia as another criterion. There is a non negotiable boundary between relativistic physics and quantum physics, which is one of the main focuses of research nowadays in physics. And we may talk about a bit about it tomorrow. It is not the main import of this conference. In a nutshell, it is very difficult to conciliate Einstein’s theories of relativity with quantum physics.
It actually is impossible. There are certain theorems known as Bell’s theorems whose violation clearly demonstrate that when a system is Einsteinian in the full sense of the term, it cannot fulfill all of the criteria of quantum mechanics and reciprocally. The resolution of this dilemma is the most, actively researched area in physics nowadays. But what will interest us for this presentation is quantum physics precisely because of the importance the observer plays in the process. Now, what are the core concepts of quantum physics?
Perhaps the most fundamental equation in quantum physics is known as Schrodinger’s equation of which there are numerous forms. It is a way of describing the distribution of probabilities of what where a particle is and what a particle may do before the act of observation. There are many ways of writing it. This is one which is known as a time time dependent way. What are the properties of this wave function and why is it of interest to us?
And here I will use the classical term wave function which is very much depasse. Nowadays we would speak of the state vector, but it’s just a term you may have encountered in books. It may be a little bit more familiar to you. Fundamentally, the wave function is the quantum formulation of the law of conservation of energy. It contains all the measurable information about the particle being considered.
It is continuous And what doesn’t concern us here is that for a free particle, it’s a sine function. Now, what initiated the core preoccupations in the nature of the wave function and what happened under observation is an experiment which has been described by Richard Feynman, is America’s foremost physicist as the most profound experiment ever performed in physics. The so called double slit experiment. The double slit experiment is a very simple experiment initially in which one sets up a source of light as an emitter and one sets up a panel, this is very simplified representation, which if the light were behaving as a wave would cause diffraction and if the light source were behaving as a source of particles would cause a scattering of the particles. Now these are two radically different forms of behavior in classical mechanics.
In classical mechanics, you are either dealing with waves, let’s say electromagnetic waves or with streams of particles. There’s no such thing as the camel, the proverbial horse with a hump. It’s the one or the other. What becomes very interesting in quantum mechanics is that with a given source in this case of light, we actually on the measuring side at the level of observation observe waves or particles in function of what we choose to observe. Now this is so radically alien to the traditional models of physics that it has taken almost a century since the dawn of quantum mechanics before physicists are partly comfortable with what is happening.
It seems that the choices of the observer according to the Copenhagen interpretation or the conscious act of observation according to Von Neumann and Wigner is central to how a physical phenomenon unfolds. Now this unfolding of a physical phenomenon is known as the reduction of the state vector. This wave function which describes the behavior of the particle gives just a probability distribution for what the particle may or may not do. It is impossible to assert what the behavior of the particle will be without the intervention of an external observer. The question which became critical very early on in quantum mechanics was why was this the case?
Is it the mending of the external observer which inevitably causes this? This is the Copenhagen interpretation. It’s a very, very positivistic interpretation. Or is it the act of consciousness? The conscious awareness of a phenomenon which causes this reduction of the state vector, the collapse of the wave function, which is for Neumann’s and especially Wigner’s interpretation.
Now quantum physicists had piously thought they could contain the madness. They thought this was happening at the subatomic level and it could be kept, at the subatomic level and physicists would talk about the shameful behavior of particles in private, but in public we could keep the illusion of classical Newtonian behavior. Unfortunately, as Schrodinger who was not laughing when he developed his paradox found, There is a very clear contamination of quantum effects in what is known as the quantum classical boundary. The boundary between quantum and classical physics is basically nothing else but a pious illusion. It depends on the context and the system you’re dealing with, and you basically choose as an experimenter or as a theoretician to set the boundary as a certain level.
To demonstrate this Schrodinger formulated his famous paradox, the paradox of Schrodinger’s cat. And there’s an ongoing debate in physics whether a poor cat was ever subjected to this or not. What the paradox amounts to is creating a linkage between a quantum event and a non quantum event, macroscopic event, and showing that it is possible for the quantum effect to almost instantaneously contaminate non a priori non quantum microscopic events. Schrodinger said when you put a cat in an an enclosed box in which there was a source of radiation which emitted radiation very rarely. And a Geiger counter which measured, radiation.
This Geiger counter, this is Germanic, I’m sorry, was connected to a hammer which would crack a vial of cyanide. As I said, it’s very Germanic as as a model, you know. Now from the standpoint of quantum physics, the Geiger counter and the source of radiation behave as a quantum phenomena and the mechanism observing a quantum phenomena. The laws of quantum physics apply. The cat however as long as the box is open is definitely a non quantum phenomenon.
It weighs a couple of kilos. It is neither a quantum phenomenon nor a phenomena subject to the laws of relativity. However, once we close the box and we set up this mechanism, we have a wave function which describes the cracking or non cracking of the vial of cyanide in function of the emission or non emission of gamma radiation by the source of radiation. This wave function follows the laws of quantum physics unambiguously. The life of the cat or the death of the cat depend on whether or not this vial is cracked.
However, once the box is closed, we can say that the cat himself or herself is also subject to a wave function or a state vector which cannot be resolved without the opening of the box. Therefore, we end up with a situation where with the box closed, it is impossible for an exterior observer to assert that the cat is either alive or dead. From a Schrodinger’s standpoint, the cat was both alive and dead. Now the experiment has been often misunderstood in recent years, but Schrodinger’s goal was very clearly to show that it is impossible to draw a quantum classical boundary. Once you have quantum phenomena, it is inevitable for them to contaminate the non quantum environment.
And this leads us to the real reason I would like to talk about this topic today which is the issue of observation in quantum mechanics. These are some of the founding fathers of quantum mechanics. I should have put Einstein in the larger bubble because really in many senses of term, he is the founder of quantum mechanics with Niels Bohr, the Danish physicist who elaborated the first viable model of the hydrogen atom. He is student Heisenberg. And I am subject to the vagaries of PowerPoint.
Von Neumann should not be here, but here, but I think Von Neumann was exported up here. Von Neumann, Wigner and London all share the same viewpoint regarding the reduction of the state vector, which is at odds with that of Niels Bohr. And that is what we will be talking about at present. So there are broadly speaking two types of quantum mechanical systems. Those which emphasize the collapse of the wave function of the state vector and those which do not.
Those which do include the Copenhagen interpretation and the von Neumann interpretation. Von Neumann’s interpretation was fleshed out by Fritz London and Eugen Wigner who basically who basically talked about what von Neumann was afraid to talk, which was impact consciousness has on the reduction of the state vector. Von Neumann in the sixth chapter of his foundations, mathematical foundations of quantum mechanics alludes to the role of consciousness, but does not actually explicit it. It is London and much later Wigner who do so. There is a second school of interpretation of quantum mechanics, which I will not be talking about, which deemphasizes the wave function collapse.
It does not evacuate it as some have said, but it deemphasizes it. It’s David Bohm’s hidden variable synthesis. You may know of David Bohm as one of the, I think we can say, disciples of his homilus, dilemma, certainly a close friend. Friend, and Everett’s many worlds hypothesis. Both of which try to resolve the paradoxes which seem inherent in quantum mechanics.
The critical issue is precisely what causes the wave function collapse. Is it actually as the Copenhagen school says measurement by the observer with the idea that every measurement inevitably disturbs the system being observed and there is a sort of irreducible level of disturbance? And this is I would say probably the view which is publicly taught to this day in most universities. Or is it actually the consciousness of the observer as is von Neumann’s viewpoint. Now von Neumann’s viewpoint is actually known as the orthodox interpretation of quantum mechanics, basically because it is the most elegant mathematically.
The Copenhagen interpretation arises in 1927 during a conference at Solvay in Belgium. And it basically was something akin to negotiation regarding the status of the Aborigines in Australia. All of the leading physicists gathered, and the question was how do we handle this particularly embarrassing problem without making too much of a hash of it. And there was an agreement not to talk about certain things. And to attribute that about which one had to talk to observation.
So it was basically forced to pretty much by Heisenberg, against Einstein, against a very famous French physicist Louis de Broglie, who is the father of actually David Bohm’s interpretation. David Bohm’s interpretation is nothing new. It’s something which is 80 years old. And it has remained the dominant viewpoint. It is a viewpoint which enables one to use quantum mechanics without asking too many questions.
Because quantum mechanics works. It’s actually perhaps the physical theory which is the best verified. It is certainly better verified than both theories of relativity. It works yet it is profoundly counterintuitive. And to make it work without asking too many questions about what was lying beneath it, a gentleman’s agreement was reached.
Copenhagen is a gentleman’s agreement. But the gentleman’s agreement has been tearing at the seams especially since the nineteen sixties with the work of an Irish physicist, John Bell. So the leading physicists involved in the Copenhagen interpretation were obviously the giant of physics, Niels Bohr. Von Neumann of whom Ralph talked this morning, the Hungarian mathematician, a polymath if ever there was one, founder of not only game theory but modern computer theory who formalized quantum mechanics. They said of him Einstein said of him he was the fastest brain of the twentieth century.
And Fritz London largely forgotten, but whose book it’s translated in English, I can heartily recommend you. It’s short, it’s not too mathematical. Theory of Measurement in Quantum Mechanics. Fritz London basically goes where von Neumann does not dare to go. And finally Eugene Wigner, about whose paradox we will talk shortly.
So what is the Copenhagen interpretation of the wave function and the role of the observer? This interpretation pioneered by Niels Bohr and much more importantly by Heisenberg. It actually should be known as Heisenberg’s interpretation really. Amounts to saying that it is the process of measurement which introduces indeterminacy in the state of either the particle or the system being studied. This is something which is pretty comfortable.
If you come from a background in classical physics where if any one of you has ever worked with physics, you know, you spend your time with deltas for lambdas for, experimental approximations. This is something you can live with. You can live with the idea that there is some sort of irreducible minimum or should I say an irreducible, yes, an irreducible minimum to experimental interference which prevents you from understanding certain things about systems observed at the microscopic level. And for Heisenberg therefore, the trend, excuse me, the transition between what is possible, what is described by the wave function, and what is actual is directly related to the act of measurement. Whether the measure is sentient or not is not important for the Copenhagen interpretation.
Therefore, the Copenhagen interpretation is the interpretation which most materialists and certainly most non physicists in the biological and chemical sciences are comfortable with. It is however, from the standpoint of physics, a messy interpretation by all accounts. And this is why von Neumann in perhaps the most important work of physics in the twentieth century, mathematical foundations of quantum mechanics tries to formalize what the role of the observer is. Von Neumann defines three different components in every quantum experiment. You have the system observed which can be a particle or more frequently a system of particles containing thousands or tens of thousands of particles.
You have a measuring instrument and you have an observer. And von analyzes where the cut, which has come to be known in his honor, the von Neumann cut, has to be placed and what impact this has on the quantum behavior of the system observed. Von Neumann demonstrates in the sixth chapter of his treatise that there is no difference whether the cut is placed between the system observed on the one side and the complex of the measuring instrument and the actual observer on the other side, which is basically, we would say the Copenhagen approach, Heisenberg’s approach, or whether the cut is actually placed after the measuring instrument whether the system observed in the measuring instrument are seen as one whole and the actual observer is seen as isolated. So to give you and I apologize for the graphs which are my own creation and a clear sign of why I should never have become, never have studied drawing. If we take a very simple example which is the measurement of, the heat of, let us say, a particle of iron, an atom of iron, within a crucible, at the point of fusion.
We will assume that we have a temperature here for whatever the temperature fusion of iron is. The light rays which are reflected from the column of mercury penetrate the eye of the observer, impact the retina. In turn, they are transformed into neurochemical impulses which are assessed by the brain of the observer, by the visual cortex, and eventually are assessed by the observer himself. If we are observing one particle of iron in a smelting pot, we are observing a system which must be described in keeping with the laws of quantum mechanics. What von Neumann demonstrated is that his cut can be placed at any level here with no difference whatsoever as far as quantum mechanics is concerned.
The question von Neumann did not ask and I think it is frankly because he didn’t dare to ask it in the nineteen thirties, is what is there which differentiates the observer from another physical system? It is implicit in his sixth chapter. It is it is like the sword of the Marquis which is hanging throughout the sixth chapter of his treatise. Because it is fairly obvious that a physical system alone cannot cause reduction of the state vector. Especially if we see ourselves as prolonging for Neumann’s cut ever further inwards.
And this is what led one of the leading contemporary physicists, Henry Stapp. To point out that when von Neumann moved the cut step by step until at last the entire physical body of the observer and all that was described as physical was included within what is known as system one, he ended up by producing an ontology which is akin to Descartes’ psychophysical dualism because this implies the existence of a non material observer. Von Neumann’s entire formalization implies the existence of a consciousness which cannot be the byproduct of the brain. Now, von Neumann himself and those of you who are somewhat inclined mathematically, I can only encourage you to read his sixth chapter. Von Neumann himself did not put things in these terms, but Fritz London, who was had perhaps less of a reputation and less to lose, did.
And London says, the apparent point of departure of the theory, the idea of an observable world totally independent of the observer was a vacuous idea. This puts rest to classical Newtonian physics. It puts rest to materialism. It also puts rest to the dominant paradigm in much of the biological sciences. The formalism of quantum mechanics already implies a well defined theory of relation between the object and the observer, a relation quite different from that implicit in naive materialism.
As London points out, coupling with a measuring device is not measurement. And he says, we note the essential role played by the consciousness of the observer in this transition from the mixture to the pure case. Without his effective intervention, we would never obtain a new psi function. In other words, without the intervention of consciousness, we cannot have a reduction of the state vector. So certainly in von Neumann’s formalization of quantum mechanics and explicitly in London’s development of von Neumann, there is an assertion that consciousness is non material and cannot be a byproduct of the brain.
It is actually necessary for von Neumann’s formalization and for London’s interpretation that consciousness being non material, otherwise there can be no reduction of the state vector. Now the question London asks then is what is the nature of this consciousness and he defines it through a perception. The observer has with himself relations of a very special character, which we can call the faculty of introspection. He can keep track moment by moment of his own state. This is for London the key factor which defines an observer.
A mechanical system which is non introspective from this standpoint is incapable of causing the collapse of the state vector. Then there is a major question in my mind, and it has been for many years, regarding how far we can extend the status of quantum mechanical observers to sentient beings in general. Can animals cause the collapse of the state vector or not? I personally don’t agree with London, in as much as I don’t think that introspection is, a necessary criterion for consciousness. I do think, however, that certain types of consciousnesses, and I don’t think we will have time to talk about it today, but I personally believe that it is a consciousnesses which are known as Pramanas.
In other words, valid cognizers which are able and which are able alone to cause the collapse of the state. Some twenty, almost thirty years after von Neumann, and it’s many of the Hungarian physicists who did the pioneering work in this field for reasons unknown to me. Another Hungarian physicist, Wigner, came up with a thought experiment, which is to this day highly debated. And which seems to demonstrate that it is the consciousness of the observer which causes the collapse function or the state vector designated as psi. Wigner imagines and that’s a raison d’etre of the little cake in the living room.
Wigner imagines a friend of his in a house, in a laboratory, whose doors and windows are closed performing a quantum mechanical experiment on a system and himself on the outside with no means of communication with his friend indoors. At the moment of observation of the quantum mechanical system within the house, there is a collapse of the state vector. In other words, you’re no longer dealing with a package of probabilities regarding the position and momentum of a particle, but with a finite number of options. This collapse has not occurred for Wigner’s friend who is outside of the laboratory. Now Wigner’s friend who is outside of the laboratory can also describe the particle by a wave function.
Then we end up with a situation where one particle is described by two wave functions, which are different, one of which is collapsed and the other is not. Wigner concludes that it is the consciousness of the observer within the laboratory, the consciousness of observer A, which causes the collapse of the wave function inside laboratory A and that the system which is being considered can no longer be described by a wave function. If this is the case, once again, we seem to be moving towards a situation where a nonmaterial consciousness is indispensable to cause the collapse of the state vector in quantum mechanics. This is hotly debated to the present day. But I must point out that the physicists who have made the most important theoretical contributions in the last fifty years, men of the caliber of Wolfgang Pauli for instance, tend to have adopted for Neumann’s interpretation.
I would like in this point to talk very briefly of a topic known as quantum mind theory. Largely from a critical standpoint because I feel that it is premature. A leading British physicist Sir Roger Penrose, who with Stephen Hawking is probably Britain’s greatest living physicist, published a book some twenty years ago called The Emperor’s New Clothes. In which he proposes that the human brain functions as a quantum mechanical computer. And the mechanism whereby it would function as a quantum mechanical computer is highly complex.
It involves actually gravitational attraction between parts of the human brain. But the problem in which or to which Penrose abuts and all of those basically who have proposed quantum mechanical mind, hypothesis is that overwhelmingly the physical conditions within the human brain in terms of temperature, in terms of moisture, perhaps even in terms of the size of the particles considered, there’s a big debate about this, would lead to very rapid decoherence of the mechanism. In other words, the brain would cease if it had any quantum mechanical behavior to behave as a quantum mechanical system and to behave as a classical system. Now one of the leading proponents of the quantum mind theory is Henry Stapp and while I think Stapp has made some major contributions in quantum mechanics, I think perhaps regarding quantum mind theories and specifically the mechanisms he proposes, he has gone too far too quickly. The mechanism Stapp proposes is basically that the behavior of the calcium ion, and this is from his latest work, in 02/2007, he has he has had several proposals in the last thirty or forty years.
But basically that the behavior of the calcium ion at the extremity of a dendrite is necessarily quantum mechanical because the calcium ion is passing through an ion channel whose size is only slightly larger than the size of the calcium ion itself. And there is such an acute restriction of lateral velocity of the ion that in terms of longitudinal velocity, the uncertainty principle would come into play and we would expect quantum mechanical behavior. This is highly debated. There have been a series of articles published by Max Tegmark, which basically criticized Stapp’s position. And I personally feel that it is premature at present to propose a mechanism for a quantum mechanical brain when so little is understood both of quantum mechanics and of the way the brain functions.
I do think, however, that there are very strong theoretical arguments in favor of the existence of a non material mind. These arguments are almost unattackable. One can propose alternate interpretations of quantum mechanics, the Copenhagen interpretation, Everett’s many worlds interpretation. But it has not been possible since the publication of von Neumann’s work and the presentation of Wigner’s paradox some thirty years ago to disprove this position. This is therefore a strong statement from core physics.
Quantum mechanics is not subsidiary physics. We’re talking of the core of modern physics. Of the possibility of the existence of a non material mind, Actually of the necessity of the existence of such a mind for those schools of interpretation of subatomic behavior. So this is Stapp’s presentation of the, calcium ion theory which I would not dwell upon. Stapp sees the collapses of the waveforms at the level of the neurons as leading to an entanglement between psychophysical events.
Again, this is hypothetical. But there has been a very sharp rejoinder as I pointed out by Max Tegmark pointing out that any of the quantum mechanical brain models proposed would decohere very rapidly under realistic conditions for the human brain. And therefore in the present state of affairs, what we can say is that the mechanisms which are proposed for the mind body interface at the level of the human brain are unconvincing. But the existence of a non material mind is a position which can definitely be uphold within the context of contemporary science. It is actually, as we said, a necessity for certain schools of quantum mechanics.
We have spoken so far of the what amounts to the subject object relationship in the context of subatomic and perhaps molecular physics. I’ve also pointed out that Schrodinger’s paradox clearly demonstrates that if quantum mechanical effects are true, there is or there can be a contamination towards macroscopic effects. It’s my personal conviction that psi phenomena specifically, psychokinesis is one of these cases. And interestingly enough, psi has been very well studied. It has been studied by the former dean of the faculty of engineering at Princeton University, Robert Jahn, who eventually founded the Princeton Engineering Anomalies Research Lab.
And largely because of his interest in psi was professionally destroyed. Those of you who want to see what happens to a scientist who thinks out of the box, try reading his latest article, the Pear Project. After his laboratory was shut down, he actually went in print to describe the difficulties he faced over the decades. It is intimidating reading. It is intimidating reading and it explains why so much of this material to the present day remains basically taboo.
Our modern societies have their taboos just as the ancient societies. P E E A R, as the fruit. And its fate was the same as a fruit. What is very interesting in Jahn’s work is that Jahn studied psi, in other words, the control, put it very simply of mind over matter using a variety of different apparatuses. Mechanical, such as for instance this, ball contraption, a pendulum, electronic and actually hydraulic.
I was not able to find a picture of the hydraulic one, but it did exist. All of these apparatuses are designed to generate random events. And Jahn’s volunteers were asked to try to affect the random events in one direction or the other. Now what is striking is that the effects become manifest over a very large number of runs, which is something we would expect if there was contamination of quantum mechanical effects at the macroscopic level. And the effects are independent of the apparatus used which I think is particularly interesting.
You have the same type of effects whether you’re using a pendulum, wooden balls falling down into slots or an electronic random number generator. These are effects on the order of 10 minus 12 odds. In other words, this is it is extraordinarily improbable that this should happen accidentally. And as Jahn points out, these are statistically reproducible over large databases. In this particular case, over 375,000 experimental trials, it was possibly to move out of standard deviation to a very large degree to the high or to the low after you can see 120,000 trials.
Even after 20,000 trials, you can clearly see a large deviation with respect to what was expected. This clearly seems to demonstrate some type of action of mind over matter. This type of action of mind over matter is totally unacceptable within the context of both Newtonian physics. It’s actually a premise of Newtonian physics that this is impossible because it creates major problems with scientific observation should it be possible. And this is also completely unacceptable within the context of the special and the general theory of relativity.
However, it is possible and even necessary in some interpretations of quantum mechanics. And therefore, I personally feel that von Neumann’s interpretation and Wigner’s interpretation of quantum mechanics provide a possible theoretical template explaining Jahn’s results. So the key feature features Jahn obtained were first psi effect irrespective of the type of random generator, which I think is critical. If it was perhaps some unknown effect of electronic random, number generators, you would not expect to have the same type of effect with hydraulic generators or for that matter with pendulums, yet you do. Secondly, the greater the sampling, the greater the psi effect, which we would expect if we have some type of contamination of quantum effect at the macroscopic level.
And finally, and this is more of a theoretical conclusion, Von Neumann’s theory allows and actually demands strong mind matter interaction at the quantum level. JAN’s results seem to demonstrate weak mind matter interaction at the non a priori quantum level, at the macroscopic level. Then if I wanted to be a bit snide, I would say that Jahn’s greatness as an experimenter goes hand in hand with the usual theoretical weaknesses we expect from experimenters. But that’s a little bit too sarcastic. Jahn has proposed several models to explain what is happening.
Then Jahn’s quantum account of the phenomena concerned is best left aside because he basically just starts treating the mind as a field, you know, which is unwanted. The mind is unmeasurable. A field must be measurable. And then uses quantum mechanical equations to apply them to the mind as a field. This is formally possible, but there is no meaning to it.
He does propose, however, another model which is surprisingly close to Chitamatra phenomenology. What Jahn proposes is that there is a subliminal seed in some type of subconscious mind which manifests simultaneously as both experiment and event. You can see the extraordinary similarity with the Chitamatra model of a karmic imprint in the mind basis of all, manifesting simultaneously as the experience and the event. Jahn does not draw the Chitamatra conclusion that there is no such thing as exterior reality. It is my personal feeling that for Neumann’s theories and Jahn’s result which indicate possible contamination at the macroscopic level by subject object interaction give us a possible foundation for Buddhist consequentialist ethics.
And we can now move move out of this rather difficult topic which I hope didn’t leave you all too dizzy. There’s something with which we are more familiar, which is the relation between observation and intention in Buddhist philosophy and quantum mechanics. When I first met Geshe Rabten, these topics were very present in my mind in the nineteen eighties. And I suppose I could not have met a better teacher than Geshe Raptan. What I learned about phenomenology, I learned from Geshe Raptan.
What I learned regarding the importance of intention, which we will be talking tomorrow, I learned from Khensur Rinpoche. Then as a young man, I had the knack for asking embarrassing questions. So I asked Geshe Raptan once. Let us assume that it’s possible to postulate a phenomenon which is non observed, which is not possible in Buddhist philosophy. Every phenomenon is necessarily assumed.
But I phrase this as a hypothetical question. What would be its phenomenological status? And if you forgive me for the vulgar expression, Geshe Rabten blew my mind and said uncertain. I had just come out of Zurich Polytechnicum and this was just like I had a Tibetan von Neumann. I I I never expected a response of such power, you know, to what was a very, very theoretical and difficult question.
Now we have to address in this transition from quantum mechanics to the Buddhist worldview and to Buddhist consequentialism. The question of the relationship between observation and, intention in Buddhist thought. Observation and intention or observation and motivation are two fundamental activities of consciousness. But from a Buddhist standpoint, they have different roles. Observation and specifically observation by a valid cognizer is what establishes the existence of phenomena.
In my personal opinion it is what causes the collapse of the state vector of quantum mechanical phenomena and I personally as you will have guessed feel that we can extend the concept of state vector, at the macroscopic level. Motivation itself from a Buddhist standpoint is taught to be causally effective and to be the foundation of Buddhist ethics. And we will talk in a couple minutes of what the possible relationship between observation and intention is. You can see the interest of such an analysis because if we have intimated that observation from the standpoint of quantum mechanics can have physical effects and based on Jahn’s research can have microscopic effects. If we can link intention and observation, we will have intimated that intention can have microscopic effects too.
We will have given some type of theoretical foundation to the operation of karma. So this is not negligible. If we analyze the compatibility of the four schools of Buddhist thought with quantum mechanics, we can find within the Vaibhāṣika, Sautrāntika, Chitamatra and Madhyamika schools that the Hīnayāna schools, Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika are non QM compatible. These are realistic schools. You cannot bridge the gap between Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika on the one hand in quantum mechanics, especially in von Neumann’s reading.
I have put in yellow the schools which are compatible. Chitamatra is definitely quantum mechanic compatible. And within Mādhyamika, Prāsaṇgika is definitely compatible with quantum mechanics in von Neumann’s reading. I have strong personal doubts regarding the compatibility of Svatāntrika Madiameka with quantum mechanics, but we don’t have time to enter in an analysis of Svatāntrika Madiameka tenets to see why this is the case. So let us try to understand the phenomenologies of the two schools of Buddhist thought which are QM compatible.
If we take the Cittamātra phenomenology and note the extraordinary similarity between my diagram and Robert John’s so called M five diagram. You have a mind basis of all called the Alaya Vijñāna unfolding in time. This is critical here, which bears karmic imprints in purple. The operational karmic imprint in blue simultaneously gives rise to consciousness and that which is perceived. In other words, it simultaneously gives rise to the eye consciousness, in this case, taking an example, perceiving the blues color of the sky and the blue color of the sky.
Therefore, from standpoint, the eye consciousness perceiving the blue color of the sky and the blue color of the sky are both of the nature of mind. And precisely because they are both of the nature of mind, and it is impossible to talk of the blue color of the sky without talking of the eye consciousness perceiving the blue color of the sky and reciprocally, they are actually from the standpoint of Chitamatra phenomenology simultaneous. For this very reason I think we can speak here of clear quantum entanglement. And I use the term entanglement in a broader sense than the sense it is commonly used in physics. It is commonly used to refer just to particles.
I personally use it as well for the relationship between the observer and the observed phenomenon in QM which is legitimate in my opinion. So we can see here clearly a phenomenology which is QM compatible. In the case of Prāsaṇgika, things are more complicated and more subtle. There are three types of interdependence taught in the Prāsaṇgika school. Causal interdependence which is also taught in all of the other schools but it is of a slightly different order in Prāsaṇgika.
Componential interdependence, the dependence of the whole and the parts and reciprocally, which is also present in the other schools. And imputation interdependence, which is present and taught in its full scale only in the Prāsaṇgika school. If we take cause and interdependence, if you assume a causal relationship between two phenomena, the first instance is the blues color of the sky and the second instance of that color, then you have a clear dependence of the effect on the cause which is taught by all four Buddhist schools of tenets without exception. However, the uncommon Prāsaṇgika stance is that in addition to a dependence of the effect or the result of the cause, there is also a dependence of the cause upon the effect precisely because we cannot designate an effect without having a cause. This is uncommon and unique to Prāsaṇgika.
Componential interdependence is quite straightforward. A component, in this case the blue color of the sky, depends on its constitutive parts. The blue colors of the sky in the various directions and the blue colors of the sky in the various directions can only be postulated independence on the whole of which they are parts. However, what marks phenomenology is imputation interdependence. Where the phenomenon being considered, in this case the first instance of the blue color of the sky, gains existence through the designation of name and concept upon it by a mind which can exist at any moment in the future after the existence of this initial phenomenon.
We have two streams of imputation. We have a dependence of the imputed, in other words here, the blue color of the sky on the imputing mind. And we also have a dependence on the of the imputing mind on the imputed phenomenon. Therefore, the crux of the standpoint is that it is impossible to isolate phenomenon. It is impossible to isolate them causally.
It is impossible to isolate them con componentially. And what is critical, I think, from the standpoint of an understanding of QM entanglement, it is impossible to isolate subject and object. Now this seems to me very, very close to Schrodinger’s formulation of his wave equation. But it needs to be analyzed. And therefore, as we mentioned previously, while the issue is clear regarding observation, which, can be said to cause the collapse of the state vector, there is some question regarding intention.
Now if we adopt the Buddhist framework and we say that it is possible that observation of, in our case, a subatomic phenomenon by a valid cognizer, a Pramāna, causes the collapse of the state vector, the reduction of the state vector. What is the precise status and function of intention? Because from a Buddhist standpoint, it is not observation which is a karmic motor, it is intention. And it is here that the position, of the Abhidharma schools of the Mahāyāna. In other words, mainly Asaṇga’s Abhidharma Samuccaya is of tremendous interest.
Because in his Abhidharma Samuccaya, Asaṇga points out that every main mind is necessarily accompanied by five so called omnipresent mental factors. These include feeding discrimination, intention, mental engagement, and contact. But the one which concerns us here is intention. Because what Asaṇga is saying is that every main mind which includes acts of observations, minds which observe phenomena, and therefore which include Pramanas, which observe phenomena, necessarily has a factor of intention which accompanies it and which cannot be dissociated from it. It is of the same nature with it.
It arises at the same time. It has the same aspect and so forth. Therefore, for every main mind in the region observation, which causes a collapse of a state vector, there is necessarily an accompanying mental factor of intention which is operative in the karmic sense, and which can give rise to virtuous, neutral, or non virtuous karma. Non virtuous karma is obviously non operation, but it it is formulated nonetheless. So you can see how the is the linchpin in this analysis which enables us to bridge observation and intention by pointing out that intention is a mental factor which necessarily accompanies observation.
And the reason for which this is important is obviously because, in von Neumann’s presentation of QM, what is referred to is observation and not intention. At von Neumann and the QM theorists, stated that it was intention which caused the collapse of the state vector, this would be far less important. So what we can see is that there is to recapitulate an important strand of contemporary physics which has been verified to a far greater degree than actually any other strand of physics. In the case of quantum mechanics, we have verifications, relativity theoreticians would love to have. The general theory of relativity is very, excuse me, sexy but the verifications are few and far between.
There are a couple but there aren’t many. QM is verified every time you open a computer. The transistor is a product of quantum mechanics. So we have a dominant field of physics in which one of the leading theories considers that it is necessary to postulate a non material consciousness to cause the collapse of the state vector. This non material consciousness which causes the collapse of the state vector can be understood in Buddhist terms to be a Pramāna, to be a valid cognizer and is necessarily accompanied by an intention.
This therefore means that it is possible for intention to have macroscopic physical results. And this opens the door to an understanding of Buddhist ethics as a consequentialist ethics. Not merely as a system of conduct, which is arbitrarily chosen, but actually as an ethical system which is rooted in reality. And this was the goal of my presentation so far. So if we try to understand Indian consequentialism.
And as I mentioned at the beginning of this conference, the core distinction between Indian consequentialism and contemporary consequentialisms, utilitarianism and so forth, lies in the fact that Indian consequentialism is extended over the infinity of lives. Then we can see that the key factors of Indian consequentialism is that it extends a consequentialist ethics to the totality of lives of both the subject being considered and all other continuities of consciousness, in other words, subjects being affected. And that it extends this over an unbounded number of lives in an unbounded number of beings. Therefore, since it is impossible for a finite mind to assess the consequences of behavior over infinite time and an infinite potential number of recipients, a necessary corollary of Indian consequentialism is reliance on a partial or totally omniscient being who actually can reveal, teach in other words, the consequentialist ethics. And this is a universal position in Indian thought.
In Indian thought, karma and causality are taught by the being who has attained moksha or full enlightenment or in Hinduism by Ishvara. This is the case in Buddhism. Karma and causality are taught by the Buddha because they are not accessible to ordinary beings precisely because karmic consequences occur over the multiplicity of lives. This is the case in Hinduism in which Ishvara is the play master of karma and causality and teaches it within the Puranas. This is also the case within Jain.
So Indian consequentialist ethics are very different from what we know nowadays as consequentialist ethics. And ergo, the non existence of such a being makes it impossible to construct an Indian form of consequences. In other words, there is no Buddhist ethics without a being who teaches ethical behavior based on his attainment of, in the case of the Mahāyāna, full enlightenment. An understanding of karmic causality is therefore necessarily revealed. Now what are the varieties of Indian consequentialism?
As mentioned, we basically have two broad types of consequentialism. Those which assert the existence of a self, which we can call consequentialists with a core. These are Hindu and Jain consequentialists. And those which do not assert the existence of a self, the anatma vada, Buddhist consequentialism. However, their central position is the same.
There’s no difference regarding the teachings of karma and causality, at least regarding foundations between these three schools. They unfold over the infinity of lives. They cannot be assessed by an ordinary being, certainly regarding its details relying on reason alone. And the teachings of ethical behavior which are consequentialist and which have physical results must be revealed. Now in the Buddhist context, it is motivation, in other words, intention, which is the central motor within ethics.
And we can see this quite clearly if we make a Buddhist analysis of two men who are responsible for tremendous bloodshed in their age. Abraham Lincoln, who was largely responsible for what is known as the first modern war, the war of secession, the civil war in America, which caused an in excess of seven hundred thousand fifty seven hundred fifty thousand military deaths, which is huge for the period. And Adolf Hitler, who was largely responsible for World War two in an attempt to expand Germany’s Lebensraum, and who caused in excess of 16,000,000 deaths. From the standpoint of a normative ethics, perhaps even from the standpoint of a virtue oriented ethics, these are criminals. There’s there’s no other word for it.
From the standpoint of Buddhist ethics, much more careful analysis must be engaged in. We sense for ourselves that the motivation of Lincoln and the motivation of Hitler are fundamentally different. Yet in terms of the result, if you posit yourself, let’s say if you take a strong utilitarian position and you set yourself, let’s assume five years after the end of the civil war and in the middle of the second world war, from a utilitarian standpoint, both of these men made catastrophic choices. America was devastated and Europe was in the throes of war. From a Buddhist standpoint, the question of intention is central and we have to try to elucidate it.
If we analyze motivation, we find that actually from a Buddhist standpoint, it is positive motivation which is designated as positive because in the light of Buddha’s omniscience, it leads over the range of lives to happiness. Just as negative motivation is designated as negative because in the light of the omniscience of Buddha, it leads over the range of lives to negative experiences of the nature of suffering. This is not an arbitrary statement. It is a statement which is based on an assessment on the range of lives of the consequences of these deeds. In this case, it is critical for us when we engage, in various activities to elucidate our motivation.
And if we analyze carefully, we can see that we have both an acknowledged and an actual motivation. The acknowledged motivation can be both public and private. And at times it’s the same as the actual motivation, but in reality, of the times is not. We have some mental health specialists in the audience. I think they are all aware of the fact that actual motivation is frequently, perhaps most of the time, opaque to the subject.
Those of you who have practiced Sattipattana meditation are often quite surprised by what arises in the mind when one starts examining it ever so carefully. We certainly like to think that our acknowledged motivation is altruistic. But from a Buddhist standpoint, overwhelmingly, I would say exclusively for ordinary beings, the actual motivation is egotistical. And since the actual motivation is the karmic motor, it is this actual motivation which has to be brought out. Let us take an example.
Let’s take the example of attending teachings at TBI. Intention is subdivided through acknowledged and actual motivation. Then the public acknowledged motivation is to study Buddhist philosophy and attain full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. What we mouth every day meaninglessly, week in week out. The private motivation might be to learn to meditate to calm my mind.
I think it’s almost overwhelming for westerners who attend the center. And it is possible that the actual motivation is the same as one of these two acknowledged motivations. I would like to think all of us, in this room are bodhisattva. In my case, I’m quite sure I’m not. And for yourselves, I have hope, but it’s hard to say.
What is the actual motivation? What might it be? One thing I encountered many times over the last thirty years is to meet a nice man or woman who will become my boyfriend or girlfriend. This was very common. We had students until they paired up, then suddenly both disappeared.
We thought we had gained one student, we had lost two. Then this is not the case in Australia, but in America to meet Western Buddhists who are good professional contacts. Americans go to temples and churches for professional reasons. A very common motivation in Australia is simply I don’t want to be alone. People are lonely, they have no social life.
The center is a way to fill the hours. Another motivation we frequently see is it’s good for my children. All of these motivations are non Buddhist worldly motivations. As non Buddhist worldly motivations from a Buddhist standpoint, they only lead to worldly results. They do not lead to any beneficial results in future lives.
And therefore, it is critical for us to bring the actual motivation in the open. It’s lurking in the back of our minds. The door of the cupboard has to be opened. You have to let the light in. How do we do this?
And perhaps first, why do we do it? We do it simply because this actual motivation is what defines a karmic result. It’s not trivial. It is perhaps the greatest thing I learned from Khensur Rinpoche. The critical importance of motivation at the beginning of every single deed we engage in and the generation of motivation.
We learn what our actual motivation is by mentally eliminating the mundane rewards. For instance, we think to eliminate fame and prestige, I will do, let’s say I will stop sponsoring. I will sponsor secretly in such a way that people despise me. Then we eliminate the factor of social life, same way. We eliminate potential financial rewards by thinking I will do it for free.
And we eliminate health by thinking I will do it in such a way that it harms my health. Let’s say if you do prostrations, you bring prostrations to become fit, you’re not engaged in Dharma activity, whatever you might think. You’re engaged in gymnastics. Then I can suggest some very good health clubs. So the goal here is before engaging in a virtuous deed to think, okay, let’s say I want to make a big donation to the center but I’ll do it in such a way nobody at the center ever knows where it comes from.
Not only that, I’ll it in such a way that everyone thinks I’ve actually taken money from the center. Then I’ll do it in such a way that it’s completely free and in addition, it will come from let’s say my what do you call it in Australia? Your pension fund, your superannuation. If when you adopt those four decisions, your motivation has not changed, it was pure in the first place. If your motivation has collapsed, then the skeleton has come out of the cupboard.
You know where you stand. You were doing this for fail. You were doing this for your social life. Deep down, you were looking for money or you were trying to improve your health. Therefore, if your motivation collapses, you have to create a sound motivation.
And this sound motivation can only be generated. Now actual motivations are either contrived or spontaneous. A contrived motivation, as the image nicely puts it, puts it cause for effort. It’s the work of a smithy with iron. And a contrived motivation can only be generated incrementally and through generating all the motivations which lead up to it.
You cannot skip steps. This is why the is critical because teaches us all the steps leading up to the generation of one given motivation. It might be the motivation of being of small scope, of middling, of great scope. So let us take an example generating the motivation of take for taking refuge. The same way as we would take refuge in a cave during a storm.
We are very clear in our minds why we go into the cave. We have to be very clear in our minds why we take refuge. This motivation for taking refuge starts with a spontaneous negative motivation. The spontaneous motivation of an ordinary being. It is, from a Buddhist standpoint, necessarily egotistical.
If it is not egotistical, have not examined ourselves enough or we are one of the fortunate few who were born as Bodhisattvas on the path of accumulation. And the motivation for taking refuge entails generating the motivation of using a human life optimally. On this basis, meditating on death. On this basis, reflecting on future lives. And on this basis wishing for refuge from the suffering of suffering, in other words, course suffering.
This wish for refuge for the suffering of suffering is contrived motivation of the being of small scope. You can only generate this motivation if you have traveled this path. If you recite the words, this motivation will not arise. Instead, there’s a very high risk that one of the spurious mundane motivations, which arose before will be present. The karmic result will be radically different.
The karmic result of taking refuge over forty years, thinking it feels so nice being here with all my friends, is just that. It’s being with all one’s friends. The karmic result of taking refuge with this motivation of wishing for freedom from cause suffering over the cycle of lives is actually the cause for practice as a being of the small scope. And therefore, an actual contrived motivation can only be generated incrementally. It takes a long time.
I can find in my own practice it takes me between ten and fifteen minutes to generate an appropriate motivation. And it’s a contrived motivation. What is a spontaneous motivation? A spontaneous motivation is a motivation which arises neither artificially nor incrementally. It can only arise through Lojong habituation.
Now in our case, all our spontaneous motivations are negative. And we have put great effort in generating these negative spontaneous motivations over hundreds of thousands of past lives. They have become spontaneous. Anger, desire, self cherishing are spontaneous with us within us. They arise automatically.
The virtuous motivations are always contrived and they are always difficult to generate because we have no habituation with generating them. And therefore, our goal must be, as Je Tsongkhapa says beautifully, when through meditation, not even one instant of longing for the marvels of cyclic existence arises and day and night, the mind striving for liberation arises, then renunciation will have been well generated. Here teaches specifically how to generate a spontaneous motivation. It is a spontaneous motivation of renunciation is only generated through meditation, and its criterion is the spontaneous arrival day and night even in the state of sleep, of a wish for liberation. At this point, every single deed the person does becomes automatically a cause for liberation.
You are dealing with a true practitioner of the path of the being of middling scope. For a true bodhisattva, the thought of bodhichitta is never separated from consciousness. Then the deeds of such a being cannot be non virtuous whatever exterior appearances might be. Virtue and non virtue here is not understood in terms of the traditional Judeo Christian framework, which is normative. Pamela spoke this morning of the 10 commandments, thou shalt not kill.
Bodhisattvas, for instance, may have an obligation to kill in certain circumstances. With this very powerful motivation, there is extraordinary flexibility in the means. With our motivation, there is no flexibility in the means. Therefore in our case, precisely because our motivation we can assume is bad, we must be very careful to stick if you wish to the letter of the law. But the great beings, if you read the lives of the in ancient India, it’s quite striking, had tremendous flexibility in the means adopted to help others.
Because they worked within the framework, in their case, of bodhichitta. Uncontrived bodhichitta, not our bodhichitta. We cannot even generate contrived bodhichitta. And therefore, the difference between contrived and spontaneous motivations. Contrived motivations must be generated incrementally anew each time.
A A spontaneous motivation does not need to be generated. It is always there. And for a contrived motivation, if the motivation is not generated, the deed will not lead to the wishful consequences. The deed is unimportant. It is not the prostrations, the offerings, the robes, the studies which matter.
It is this which matters. This is what is karmically effective. And in the case of the spontaneous motivation, it is unnecessary to generate motivation. Every single deed automatically leads to the consequences of such a motivation. If we have generated within our minds the path of it being a small scope, every deed performed automatically leads to those results.
If we have generated the path of a being of middling scope, every deed leads to the attainment of nirvana. If we have generated the path of a being of great scope, every deed leads to the attainment of full enlightenment. For this reason, the generation of motivation is crucial. And this is why Atisha said, in the self same way as if the root is poisonous, so are the branches and leaves. And if the root is medicinal, so are the branches and leaves.
Likewise, all deeds whatsoever performed motivated by desire, hatred and bewilderment are exclusively non virtuous. In this quote of Atisha, the root refers to the motivation. The branches and leaves refer to the deeds of body and of speech, even of mind. Studies are deed of the mind which can be engaged in with a non virtuous motivation. And as we said, motivation is opaque.
It is totally opaque to others. We have no access to the motivation of another being. Their behavior is not a legitimate access to their motivation. The inference such and such and such is a good person because he engages in good deeds is a fallacious inference. It can only be a probabilistic statement.
Likewise, the assertion such and such is an evil person because he engages in evil deeds is once again a fallacious assertion. But let alone the motivation of others, our own motivation is most of the time opaque to us. And therefore, it is critical for us in our practice to bring our motivation into the open. And then if our motivation is incorrect or inappropriate, to correct it and to generate incrementally a correct motivation. This was all I had to cover today.
Thank you very much. And my apologies, we have finished, exactly, almost exactly at 04:15. I think I will take your questions with my other colleagues during the question session. Pamela, I see you will not be able to attend. I honestly I can’t comment on it because, I mean, there’s no question in quantum mechanics that there is entanglement between the subject and the object.
How tight it is, I think, is really the question. Then, I mean, Wigner certainly at the end evolved towards the evident position. He asserted basically that everything is conscious. He backed off the very last years of his life from that position. The field is evenly divided.
I think the most thoughtful physicists nobody or very few people until the nineteen sixties worked with the foundations of quantum mechanics. It’s quite surprising. Everyone used it because it worked so well, but there was this agreement not to touch the foundations. Foundations. Then Bell basically demonstrated that quantum mechanics and theories of relativity are incompatible.
That was what’s known as local realism in Einstein’s sense which is basically that there is a word out there which follows the rules of special relativity that the speed of transmission of data is at its maximum the speed of light is or can be broken by certain experiments constructed in quantum mechanics. And when Bell’s inequalities were formulated, it was found that they were violated, physicists have to look at the foundations again. But nobody’s terribly comfortable think Everett’s many worlds into predictions. For those of you who don’t know it, it basically amounts to saying that there is in reality no collapse of the state vector. What you have is a series of what we would call in science fiction terminology parallel universes in which every single possible event covered by the state occurs.
You have a multiplication of the possible events. The problem with Everett’s interpretation basically is that if you have a multiplication of the possible events, you have simultaneously multiplication of the possible observers. Then things become very quickly extremely messy. You have a scattering of an individual consciousness over an infinite range of possible events. For that reason, I think I I don’t know of a single leading physicist who works with Everett’s interpretation.
People have tried working with the pilot wave interpretation of David Born which basically asserts that there are a series of hidden variables, hidden parameter series which when they are considered enable one to give a much more a much less paradoxical account of reality. Then again Bell’s or the violation of Bell’s inequalities preclude a whole range of these hidden parameter theories. I think the jury is still out regarding David Bohm’s. But again, I really don’t know of a leading physicist who uses Bohmian mechanics. In both cases, if you take Everett’s multiple world theory, if take Bohm’s mechanics, it’s hard to see at present of an experiment you could construct to test them.
On the other hand, I think we have a fair bit of data coming from the psi research which seems to show some type of effect of the mind on matter. And that is something which is much more congenial with the von Neumann one and. Does that go towards answering your question? Well, nowadays, most of the mind and life research is focused on neurobiology. So there was a great age of cooperation of his holiness with physicists, especially von Weizsäcker and with David Bohm, which ended basically with the death of von Weissach.
And his holiness hasn’t done a lot of work now with physicists in the last ten, even fifteen years. Much of his work is with neurobiologists, I think because it’s a very dynamic field, number one. Secondly, through cognitive psychology, neurobiology has a tremendous impact on the popular worldview of people at large. People have become brainwashed, no pun intended, in with the notion that their mind is their brain. And it is perhaps to try to counter this that his holiness has engaged in this dialogue because clearly, if the mind is the brain, then we shut down TBI.
There’s no point in going through all this. If you believe that there is a point in being a Buddhist with immaterial mind, it’s up to you to explain what that point is. It might be a case of recuperating Buddhist techniques of meditation to calm your mind or to develop qualities, but that is a case of, if I wanted to be sharp, I would say intellectual colonialism. You either accept the ground premises of a system of thought or you are not within that system of thought. And it is up to each of us to have the intellectual honesty to ask ourselves whether sincerely we’re not talking of the details of Mount Meru but the core assertions.
For instance, reincarnation is a core assertion. Reincarnation is non negotiable. If don’t believe in reincarnation, don’t believe in karma. If you don’t believe in karma, there is really no foundation for Buddhist ethics. You have to amputate two thirds of Buddhist ethics.
Then if you don’t believe karma, there’s nothing to be liberated from. There’s no is no Buddha either for that matter because you don’t believe in the continuum of lives. Everything has just collapsed. So I think there are a lot of westerners who have a legitimate interest in Buddhist meditation techniques which you see as effective. It is legitimate but they are not Buddhists.
And it is to their benefit and to our benefit that they be very clear of their position. So I think one of the main changes I have seen in his holiness holiness’s position in the last fifteen years is that his holiness is now clarifying for Western audiences the boundaries between Buddhism and non Buddhism and encouraging Westerners not to convert to Buddhism because the general experience has been that these conversions are inauthentic. It’s a verbal conversion. It’s a conversion with mental reservations, and the person then does not live the totality of the This is how we end up with people like Stephen Batchelor who was one of my my classmates. Right?
Then I remember we had a big conversation here and I when he he broke with both his teachers. You know? It’s a dubious privilege. And after breaking he first broke with Geshe Rabten, went to Korea to meditate on Zen. And when he arrived at the Zen monastery, the Chan monastery in Korea, the abbot of the monastery who knew Geshe Mountain, visited Switzerland.
That’s how the contact is. Asked him if he was coming with or without the permission of Geshe Rabten. And Steve said he was coming without the permission. And the Abbott said in that case, you will be a kitchen hand for six months. And he had to clean the pots for six months.
Then he didn’t benefit according to his own words from his studies with Geshela. And according to the latest statements I read from Steve, he didn’t benefit from his studies in the Chan monastery. He was in a constant state of mental reservation. Then this is basically a waste of life. It would be much better if we were honest with ourselves.
In the case of Steve, instance, Steve is agnostic. Perfectly legitimate position. But you can’t be both an agnostic and a sincerely practicing Buddhist at the same time. These are radically opposed positions. So it would be best for someone like Steve and for many westerners who in that case to cut.
And westerners find it very difficult to take this type of decision. But it is both for their benefit and for the benefit of the transmission if there is a transmission of Buddhism to the West. I’m far from sure that there is a transmission person. I can say that the Dalai Lama when he is asked what the future of Buddhism in the West is, he’s very, cautious because there is a lot of interest, but interest is not the Buddhist make. You can sit in satipatthana for years.
If you don’t believe in past and future lives, you lack the foundation for ethics, you will never be a Buddhist. So I’m sorry. That’s a big development. Excuse me. But does it go towards answering your question?
My point is that suspension of this belief cannot be indefinite. It is natural and necessary at the beginning to suspend this belief. Five years, cyber analytics assessing. But you cannot spend your life in a state of suspension of disbelief. At a certain point, for your own benefit, you have to be very clear in your mind.
Either if you do accept the core assertions or you don’t. Then if you do, certain behavior can be trained and it becomes easier. If you don’t, at a certain amount a point, it amounts to hypocrisy. And we have been explicitly as Westerners accused of hypocrisy by many great Tibetan teachers Because we go to the through the motions. I often am very surprised when Khensur Rinpoche teachers and the great teachers teach you to see everyone prostrate.
Why is everyone prostrate? Do they all feel that Khensur Rinpoche is worthy to prostrate, Or is it just a shame? Does the prostration come from the heart? Or is it just what you do in a Buddhist center because that’s what everybody does? So if it’s what you do in a Buddhist center because that’s what everybody does, I think perhaps we have no time for people.
It’s not a social center. It’s not an Asian ethnic center. If it is sincere, then I think that’s marvelous. And this sincerity, this clarity in who one is, what one is doing and why one is doing is extremely important. The day becomes a very big problem because people for instance, you can you can attend teachings especially non tantric teachings indefinitely without becoming You can attend nine ms teachings for fifty years if if you want it without without becoming a a priest.
I think if after five, ten years you haven’t figured where you stand, perhaps you’d be better off doing something else. But the moment you’ve taken refuge or any of the vows you have committed, then I understand Westerners lose commitment. They lose commitment in relationships. They lose commitment in business. They lose commitment in religion, but you have committed.
You can’t commit and then shilly shally about. And therefore it’s better before committing to really assess carefully. That’s the goal of one of these talks to give the there are strong intellectual arguments in favor of the disposition. Then you have to assess. And no is also a very good answer.
No. I don’t believe that. I have analyzed. This is wrong. Or yes.
I have analyzed. This is true. But as I’ve mentioned many times, we have to ask the question of truth. None of us would behave in this way if money was concerned. And this has been the big problem especially in the with the transmission of Buddhism, which is that the moment things became real, and there was a cost.
This has been considered which is experiencing Australia over twenty five years. The moment, all these years when I need to help come to the center. Or the student had to make some type of sacrifice. Those students who had been attending for years on end prostrating, doing the guru puja offering, so doing the mantra reciting the main mantra of the guru, then the outlook of the teachers changes radically because there’s no benefit for the student tumor and and there’s there’s harm harm to to the the tumor. Teachers.
What does that do? You think it is too square? Think it’s perfectly legitimate to use Buddhist meditation techniques in health care centers. There’s a major caveat. They were never designed for that.
So if you’re going to use satipatana for mental health, it’s exactly the same thing as if you could use vacuum cleaner to power the normal. It’s your own responsibility because there can be unexpected side effects. For instance, you mentioned that the main goal of Buddhist meditation is to eliminate suffering. Well, if you meditate on the cheetah and you meditate well, you would expect to experience tremendous sadness. This is not a meditation for people who suffer from depression.
It’s not intended for that. Then now in Australia, for some reason, śamatha is being promoted. Calm abiding is being promoted as a means to calm your mind. This is false. I mean, it it probably arises from the translation comma binding, which is perhaps better translated as single pointed focus because that’s the meaning.
Comma binding does not come. As a matter of fact, someone who has some questions too. No. No. I’m fine.
It’s better for me. So I have another question, basically. Mhmm. And I I never really understood this dilemma that people have in trying to understand whether the mind is the brain or not because if I’m not incorrect, correct me here, the physical world explains just about two to 3% of what we believe exists. I don’t really like the word dark because it implies certain things particularly if you watch Star Wars too often.
But dark matter and dark energy supposedly explain the other 98, 97%. So there’s no reason why everything has to be material or at least what we can observe as being material. So I really never really got over that that particular issue myself. So I don’t really see a contradiction when people talk about, oh, well, the mind can only be what you observe as being the brain because we as humans have not had the capability or instrumentation yet to actually observe everything that supposedly as theoretists tell us are out there anyway. Fully agree with you.
I think people who come from a background in mathematics or physics tend to be really open to a raw material model. Typically, for instance, mathematicians and Platonists because you have the impression, you know that from bevy of great French physicists like Jean Charon, Costa de Beauregard, American, German physicists who have come out in support of this position. It’s in the life sciences. Specifically biology, that I think very very coarse forms of materialism have taken over. Largely because they are working within the classical Newtonian framework within which the observer is totally removed from the observed phenomenon.
Then the problem is that these biological paradigms have become almost dominant in our society. When you go to check your email and Yahoo has a latest on why, I don’t know. People whose right ear is larger than their left ear have it covered in large insula and as a result of this have more compassion. So you have a bevy of mechanistic explanations which are provided. Mechanisms don’t explain.
Mechanisms provide a mechanism. So this has been the problem of the biological sciences and I think it’s gone unchallenged for too long. Long. So it’s one of the reasons I I gave this very strongly scientific stand to this talk because I wanted to point out that this dominant school of physics with some of the leading physicists and mathematicians of the twentieth century, and Henry Stapp is still with us, unambiguously endorse the idea of a raw material consciousness as necessary in quantum physics. This is not tried.
And this opens the door to all of the religious traditions, obviously. But as I pointed out, it opens the door especially to the participatory religious traditions. There are more problems with the monotheisms. I mean, Christianity, Islam, and Judaism will not benefit greatly from this outcome. But Hinduism, Jain, and Buddhism all benefit greatly because there is this idea of mind as separate from that one and of mind as eternal, beginningless, So and endless, this is straight up the alley of quantum mechanics.
And as a result, Yes. Great American. Oppenheimer. Oppenheimer was fascinated by Vedanta. You could see why.
Exceptional situations which have to be addressed on a case by case basis. And in this matter, legislation from a Buddhist So if we cannot ascertain for sure whether consciousness is present or not, and we cannot say for sure that the person will not basically be reanimated at some point in the future, the premise must be in favor of life. In favor of active euthanasia. Whether you actually inject someone with a poison or you allow them to die of hunger whether you can feed them, it’s different. A deed of killing.
Now as we said, this deed of killing may be virtuous or non virtuous in terms of motivation. It’s almost impossible for an ordinary being to generate a virtuous motivation for a deed of killing. So from a Buddhist standpoint, such a deed is almost necessary non virtuous. Then we will talk about this tomorrow. The person is helpless.
They are helpless and they need help. Therefore, the deed is greatly amplified. This sort of deed is dangerous deed just as abortion. Killing a fetus is karmically much heavier than killing an adult in many respects because precisely the fetus is powerless. If the abortion is willed by the mother, which has an additional particular bond with it, this is a Buddhist conquest.
This is what Buddhist ethics later parts of life by so many cases like this. I was quite surprised. Often, and it’s surprising, they develop a cancer of a woman. Then I knew one such case, which had matured in this life of the world. And, unfortunately, this gave rise to great mental suffering.
But we have to engage as Buddhists into a karmic analysis as well. We try to help. Sometimes these issues are very are we comfortable with the idea that this type of behavior is generalized to society? Because such behavior is not value neutral. If it becomes a pattern of behavior Well, I think from a Buddhist standpoint here, we have no access to the motivation of others.
And at the beginning of our practice, I’m gonna put it really bluntly, we have no responsibility for others. We are first and foremost responsible for the transformation of our own mind. That transformation of our own mind enables us eventually to. Others. Atisha puts it very bluntly.
Atisha says in the body part of the body part, you can only help others when you have śamatha. Because when you have śamatha, you have access to certain powers such as telepathy, pre cognition, which enable one to see what the real needs of another are. Then we come from a Judeo Christian heritage which privileges immediate help. But we all know how destructive it can be, how do gooders can create more problems than if they had left the situation alone. So the first step is to train our own mind.
Then once our own mind is subdued, Potency without wisdom is useless. Wisdom without potency is ineffective. So in the case, for instance, Chris was a well king, we have full potency and can turn the respirator off in a jiffy, but we lack wisdom, for My opinion, it’s a very dangerous decision. Imagine the possible consequences. Imagine this becomes the emblematic case which changes the legislation nationwide in favor of openness to passive and active isolation, then it may be a very negative decision.
Imagine that three years down the line, the man miraculously awakens medical technology changes, and we have kids. We have no knowledge. Therefore, it is very dangerous to act. The caveat would be if resources were so spares that someone who was young and dying of pneumonia, let’s take that case, vitally needed the respirator, and the respirator was being kept for this person who was in the coma, I’d like to extend an extra thanks to Ralph because Ralph suggested last year the topic of the symposium. Then it’s turned out to be a very fruitful one, I think.
Key terms in this teaching
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- Mount Meru
- The mythical center of the universe in Buddhist cosmology. LYWA
- omnipresent mental factors sarvatraga-chaitta (Skt); sem jung kun dro (Tib)
- One of the six groups of mental factors, these accompany every main mind. There are five: feeling, discrimination, intention, mental engagement and contact. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
- The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
- Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.