1 h 38 min · 4,323 words · 19 October 2011
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains the wisdom arisen from hearing, meaning study of the Dharma, as the foundation of practice and the first outline of the Lam Rim’s third section on how to listen to Dharma. It covers the benefits of study, the three wisdoms of hearing, thinking and meditating, and why the Bodhipathapradipa contains the whole path for the three scopes. A question and answer session follows at the end.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 38m
UUID: 61e3348b-d562-4dfc-88de-9ce064c0880e
Date: 2011-10-19
Words: 4,319
So let us generate a good motivation to listen to these teachings. These teachings which encompass the totality of the practices of the beings of the three scopes. These practices will be developed later however they are already referred to at this preliminary stage of the teachings and this motivation of traveling ourselves on the path of the being of three scopes is a motivation we should generate. So as Candrakīrti says in the Madhyamakāvatāra, it is critical in trying to understand emptiness to rely first and foremost on a qualified teacher who is able to teach emptiness and then to focus one’s mind single pointedly on the emptiness ascertained as best one can. And it is in practicing in this way that the understanding or the wisdom of emptiness arisen from hearing will arise.
Then when this wisdom understanding emptiness from hearing has arisen in keeping with Candrakīrti’s quote in the Madhyamakāvatāra, an extreme joy and happiness will arise even in the mind of an ordinary being. This joy and happiness is comparable to that of someone who is crying with tears of joy. Therefore, says that it is suitable to explain emptiness to such a being who reacts by crying and by having the hair of his body or her body stand on end when emptiness is explained to him since that wisdom which understands emptiness which is partly present within his mind is none other than the so called Buddha nature. And Candrakīrti who was the foremost disciple of Ārya Nāgārjuna explained in this way that emptiness which is bereft of any obscurations. Today we will cover mainly the wisdom which has arisen from hearing which is a wisdom which arises actually through study.
This is what hearing refers to here and through repeated habituation to a topic. This is the type of wisdom of which Candrakīrti was talking about. So in as much as hearing is central to the presentation of the second outline, specifically the third outline, this is why Geshe-la explained it in detail. And the second outline is extremely important, important both from the standpoint of the four greatnesses, which are four greatnesses which have to be understood both by the teacher and by the students and also from the standpoint of these three specific characteristics of these teachings of the Lam Rim, which are teachings which originate generally speaking in Jetsün Tsongkhapa’s, great treatise the Stages of the Path, but specifically in Atisha’s Bodhipathapadipa.
Now in the third outline, the first subdivision of the third outline referring to the way to listen to the dharma is developed in great detail by Pabongka Rinpoche because it is so central to our practice. As Acharya Vasubandhu says, do not engage in dharma impelled by the afflictions. So if one engages in dharma practice impelled by the afflictions such as competitiveness and so forth, the the dharma practice ceases to be dharma and becomes itself harmful. And it is for this reason that Pabongka Rinpoche’s root teacher Dakpo Gomchen, and Dakpo Gomchen said this mode of listening and explaining the teachings is the crux of the preliminary practices. It is the crux of the preliminary practices because it is on it that practices totality depends in the self same way as a traditional example given in Tibetan astrology is that if one does not determine accurately the first day of the lunar month which is done only by observation, then all one’s reckoning of the calendar days up to the fifteenth day is wrong.
Likewise here, if the basics are not present, everything which comes after is wrong. And it is because this third outline is so central since if one does not practice it well it is very difficult to understand the key points or the pith later on that it is developed in detail in three subdivisions on page six seventy four of your outline of Pabongka Rinpoche’s text subdivisions or outlines three eleven, three twelve, and three thirteen. The first of these outlines is contemplating the benefits, the Tibetan sense of hearing the dharma which is meant as studying the dharma and this refers specifically to the Buddhist dharma among all dharmas. Since if one understands well the benefits of hearing the dharma, in other words the benefits of studying the dharma, there is no hardship whatsoever in the effort which is necessary to do so. It is important at the beginning to understand these benefits.
So what specifically is meant by the wisdom arisen from hearing? When Geshe la, for instance, explains, let us say, meditations related to impermanence. This is not the topic here. And the translator translates. Then when you hear the sound impermanence, this actually does not refer to the wisdom arisen from hearing.
What is said to be the wisdom arisen from hearing regarding impermanence is what occurs when the ascertainment understanding the meaning of the word impermanence which is perceived by the ear occurs and when repeated reflection on the meaning of this word occurs. It is not necessary for the wisdom arisen from hearing to arise through hearing teachers, teachings from one’s teacher. It can also arise through studying texts. For instance, texts which refer to impermanence. Therefore, this wisdom which arises from hearing is in no way a sensory consciousness.
So hearing here, which refers to study, is capital both in worldly affairs and in the dharma. Everything in worldly affairs, arises as a result of hearing. For instance, we utilize planes. Planes arise as a result of, study and reflection. Likewise, in dharma, it is similar.
There is nothing which can be said not to arise from study. So to give an example which is afraid may make you laugh, but it is based on direct experience. If one does not know English, if one has not studied the English language, then when one comes from afar, as is his case, and one has to go to the facilities, to the toilets at the airport, one is unable to read on the door whether it is for men or for women. And, Geshe la was in a very difficult situation looking at the two doors, and thank heavens, a kindly passerby pointed to him that he had to go through that one. So, again, Geshe la says he was quite ashamed and quite worried that some of the passersby might think because of the way he was dressed that perhaps these were Tibetan women.
There were many doubts like this. So not only in worldly affairs is it indispensable to engage in study, but in dharma, if one wishes to actualize dharma, is inappropriate not to engage in study. And for that matter, even if one wants to improve one’s mind, it is inappropriate not to engage in study. And for that matter, it is indispensable to study Buddhist science as it is known nowadays, which is the science of the mind and a presentation of the different categories of minds. Minds are subdivided into minds which are valid cognizers and minds which are not valid cognizers.
Valid cognizers are subdivided into two, direct and inferential valid cognizers. All minds which are not valid cognizers are subdivided into five. Convictions, doubt, mind to which phenomena appear but are not ascertained, wrong views. So subsequent cognizers, conviction, doubt, wrong views, and minds to which phenomena appear but are not ascertained. All of us are familiar with anger.
Anger actually within the seven fold division of mind falls in the category of wrong views. So why is mind a wrong consciousness? Why is anger a wrong consciousness? Anger is a wrong consciousness because it understands phenomena to appear in the mistaken way in which it itself perceives them. For instance, a mind of anger perceives its object, which is its enemy or its foe as being its foe or its enemy in all its aspects without exception, without further examination.
This is almost never the case. And since it is well known that there are cases where our enemies can help us, it clearly demonstrates that minds of anger are minds which are mistaken with respect to the nature of their objects. They are therefore wrong consciousnesses. And since anger is a mind which perceives an object which actually is a nonexistent within objects of knowledge, it is a wrong consciousness. Now the counter to anger is well known as patience or forbearance.
As is said in the Uddhana Varga, which is the Tibetan Dharmapala, the collection of teachings. From hearing, one understands dharmas. From hearing, one reverts from sin. From hearing, one abandons that which is not an object. From hearing, one attains
Nirvāṇa. Therefore, the totality of what is to be practiced and what is to be abandoned is understood through hearing. So for instance, the totality of the Buddhist teachings are divided within the three baskets, the three Pitakas of Vinaya, Abhidharma, and Sūtra. The Vinaya Pitaka specifically focuses on the training in morality or the training in ethics. And if we were to take one example, through the study of this basket, this Pittaka, one can understand what the 10 non virtuous deeds are, how to abandon them, and therefore how to turn away from them.
Likewise, the foremost topic of the Sūtra Pitaka, the basket of Sūtra, is concentration. And through training and concentration, one can progressively eliminate distraction, sinking, and agitation. Likewise, the foremost topic of the Abhidharma Pitaka, the basket of Abhidharma is wisdom. And therefore, through this training of wisdom, which entails an understanding of emptiness, one can, for instance, progressively eliminate one’s apprehension of the existence of a self of persons. Likewise, the wisdom which arises from hearing is a counter for benightedness.
Benightedness, that ignorance which is akin to a fog, is the absence of knowledge regarding, for instance, a topic such as the alphabet, the kakaganga. Then when one’s teacher teaches one the alphabet, this acts as the direct counter to that benightedness. Likewise, once a teacher has explained to the student a treatise on grammar known as the 30 subdivisions, then the students’ misunderstanding or benightedness regarding this disappears. So, Krishna, I’m not quite sure what examples to give you. His example all come from Tibetan culture.
But if he were to ask you what the if you were to ask him what the name of this object is, he would not be able to answer you in English. So if Geshe la were to ask or if Chris was to ask Geshe la what this is, Geshe la would be unable to answer and would just have to nod his head or swing or sway his head. Do you understand? Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. So if if one asks Geshe la what this is, he has no word to answer. He just has to say, I don’t know. And the example which is given in these texts is having gained this knowledge of the Tibetan alphabet when one returns to one’s homeland and one’s relatives ask one what the letters of the alphabet are, one then has this understanding arisen from study. So these verses from the Udhana Varga, Geshe la will explain briefly.
So it is akin, hearing is akin to someone who returns to his home, his house, and in which there is no light. Even though he knows that he has everything he needs in his house, he cannot find what he needs because there is no light, because of the obscurity. Likewise, without hearing or without study, we are unable to know what to practice and what to abandon. On the other hand, if one lights a butter lamp or perhaps a modern equivalent in one’s house, then one can see exactly what one has. Likewise, through hearing we know exactly what is to be practiced and what is to be abandoned.
So what is the topic of hearing or study here? The topic of hearing or study is or are the two lineages extending from Ārya Nāgārjuna and his sons downwards to Atisha, the lineage of the profound view, and the lineage extending from Ārya Asaṇga downwards to Atisha, the lineage of the vast practice. These two lineages were blended or fused by Atisha himself and on their basis, he composed his lamp for the path, the Bodhipattapadipa. The Lam Rim Cemo itself derives from it and these are the treatises which are fundamentally referred to here when one talks of the topic of the wisdom from hearing. A second similarly for the simile for the wisdom arisen from hearing is given in the Jātaka.
It the accounts of the lives previous lives of the Buddhas. The wisdom arisen from hearing is said to be far superior to material possessions since material possessions lead us to be worried about theft. Wherever we go, if we travel, we are always worried that thieves will break in. And even when we are at our own home, we are afraid of thieves. However, this wisdom arisen from hearing is interior and cannot be stolen from us.
And Ashvaghosha, the compiler of the Jatakas who was certainly speaking from experience says, hearing is a lamp to dispel obscurity. It is a supreme treasure which cannot be stolen by thieves. And therefore, the advice which Pabonga Rinpoche gives to his students and through them to us is not to be busy with meaningless affairs. In Tibet, it is said that it is the business of someone churning butter tea, which is completely meaningless, but instead to busy ourselves with meaningful affairs. To give the example of selflessness through the study of selflessness, it is possible to progressively dispel the ignorance which apprehends the person as inherently existent.
And this wisdom arisen from hearing enables us to understand clearly what are the virtues to be practiced and what are the faults to be abandoned. Therefore, engaging in any activity, we have the possibility to examine whether it is suitable or not to engage in this activity. And it is said that the Bodhisattva king who had Atisha invited to Tibet, when he was imprisoned by the king of the Ngari, who the wisdom arisen from hearing was able to pacify his mind in jail. For that matter, most of the so called friends of this life are extraordinarily unreliable. Friendship is mainly a matter of being attracted to money and to wealth and to the lifestyle they provide.
Then when money, wealth, and the lifestyle are no longer available, the friends surprisingly enough disappear. This is not the case with hearing and study. So it is said of one of the tutors of the Dalai Lama’s, we do not know which one, when he was travelling to an area called Jadrelle that he met one of his relatives. It would seem to have been his maternal uncle. And wishing not to become too close to this relative again because he was ordained and this relative could be a source of downfalls for him, He kept his instance his distances.
However, when he became the tutor of the Dalai Lama, he nonetheless imparted advice to this relative. Now regarding the vanity of human relationships, Geshe la would like to recount a famous Tibetan tale. It is that of a beggar, a pauper, who was completely destitute, and because he was completely destitute, would not be recognized by any family members. Then his fate changed and he earned a lot of money. People kept coming to him saying, I am your uncle.
I am your long lost aunt, and so forth. So finally, he decided he had to organize a meal for all these dear relatives.
He organized a huge feast and gathered them all there. And then at the end of the meal, he put all his gold on the table, and he prostrated with the gold. And he said to the gold, source of all my lost relatives, I thank you. Connect the example to the meaning. The friends of this life, the friendships of this life are not very meaningful and not very stable.
However, the qualities which arise from study are. And these two examples which were given demonstrate two aspects of study. The first demonstrates the qualities of study which lead to the elevation of someone to the level of a tutor of the Dalai Lama whereas the second demonstrate the vanity of worldly friendships and relationships where someone ends up prostrating to a pile of gold and saying, source of all my relatives, I thank you. And this is why if you need friends, make friends with these three wisdoms of hearing, thinking, and meditating. These will be reliable friends.
And therefore through training these three wisdoms, first the wisdom arisen from hearing, then the wisdom arisen from thinking which ascertains the meaning, then the wisdom arisen from meditating, we will experience the totality of the teachings of all the Buddhas. And there is a verse in the treatise called wisdom which says from hearing or from study arises faith, from faith arises an understanding of causality, from an understanding of causality arises the practice of virtue and abstaining from non virtue. We may have experience of this. We may very well know that the more intensely we study, the more powerful our mind becomes and the more our mind changes. This is why Pabongka Rinpoche’s advice to those who are of sharp capacities is do not waste your time dedicated to study.
And if you are unable to do so, the strict minimum, and this refers to Buddhists, is to have stable refuge. And it is very important to understand the triple gem and refuge to have studied The way people who have not studied posit the triple gem and refuge is often quite odd. So Geshe la may ask us to posit from our own side the triple gem since after all we are Buddhists. Another major benefit of hearing or study is as is said in the famous Tibetan proverb, the light faults of the fools weigh them down whereas the heavy faults of the scholars are light. The light faults of the fools or the uneducated weigh them down because being uneducated they do not understand what faults are and having committed them do not purify them at all.
If for instance one breaches the Bodhisattva vows, one should purify them through the Confession Sūtra’s recitation. If one breaches the tantric vows, one should purify them through reciting the Vajrasattva mantra. Those who are learned, who are well educated, do this immediately and therefore their heaviest faults become light. This is a major difference between those who have studied or who are educated and those who have not studied or who are uneducated. To give an example for this, take a lump of iron.
If you take a lump, a solid lump of iron, and you drop it in the water, it sinks at once. However, if you take the same lump of iron and turn it into a very long and wide sheet of iron and place it on water, it will float. This is an example. And advises those who are older and for whom the study of the five great treatises would be difficult to study Lam Rim treatises by the Pänchen Lama such as the swift path or his so called red commentary. So we should not think I am old.
My mind is dull. There is no hope for me. We should actually take hope. Each beast of burden, whether it is a horse, a cow, a donkey, or a sheep, has a burden which is appropriate suited to its size. To summarize things, even though this is explained in greater detail further, the totality of the path stretching from relying on the spiritual teacher at the basis all the way up to the union of Samatha and Vipassana are explained in the Bodhipattapadipa.
And it is not necessary to go very far away from the Bodhipathapadipa. Instead, the example which is traditionally given is it is akin to entering a house, putting down one’s cushion, and sitting down. So for the totality of the paths of the beings of three scopes, the small, middling, and great scope are explained in Atisha’s Bodhipathapadipa. They’re explained in a definite sequence. There is a place for each topic.
It is akin to the example of a monk’s room and the room of a lord. What is in a monk’s room would not be appropriate in the room of a lord, and what is in a lord’s room would not be appropriate for a monk’s cell. So Geshe la has completed the presentation of the beginning of the third outline, the way to listen to dharma, and we’ll stop here. And at present regarding Jill’s question last week regarding whether someone who was not a Buddhist could accumulate the heavy karma of abandoning dharma through criticizing portions of the teachings. Geshe la reflected on the question and the answer is most probably he could, he or she could, because if such a person were to say that this aspect of the teachings is of benefit and that aspect of the teachings is not of benefit, or if they were to say that through the practice of virtue one does not eventually experience happiness and through engaging in non virtue one does not eventually experience unhappiness since they would be deprecating causality.
In other words, not deprecating a dogma, but deprecating the actual reality, the actual mode of existence of things with an evil intention, then they would accumulate the non virtuous karma of abandoning dharma. To take the example of Candrakīrti’s critique of Svatāntrika Madhyamaka presentation of emptiness epitomized by Bhāvaviveka, Candrakīrti repeatedly asserts that Bhāvaviveka’s presentation of the selflessness of persons and the selflessness of phenomena cannot lead to liberation. However, he is not guilty of the abandonment of dharma for two reasons. First, because his motivation was excellent, and secondly, because he points out again and again that Bhāvaviveka’s understanding is of benefit for those who wish to engage in the Prāsaṇgika view, taking the Prāsaṇgika view as our reference. And at present, we have 10.
Vishal and I would like to dedicate to your questions. Yes. To answer your question about the nature of milk, the nature of milk is to be water or liquid. He’s joking, however. So regarding the nature of milk, the nature of milk is probably to be humid, to be moist, to be wet.
There’s a big difference between the oral transmission of what is known as lung. In other words, the pure verbal transmission of the text and the oral transmission of commentaries on the one side and the wisdom which arises through studying by oneself a text. In the case of this text, Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand, we have received the oral transmission from himself, those of us who had it from Sarah, who is the holder of the oral transmission. Then there is a particular blessing which goes with that from lineage of teacher to lineage of teacher. Other questions?
Yes, Pamela. Let alone that fear of being born in the lower realms is not an affliction. It is actually a virtue. It is the motor which actually will lead to renunciation. Fear is I asked Geshe-la directly, is fear always an affliction?
He said, by no means. So most definitely, fear is not always an affliction. Then, there was a misunderstanding regarding my pronunciation. Mhmm. Are there other questions?
Yes. There are many types of conviction among which there are convictions which are not based on reasons. If, for instance, we believe that sound is impermanent without having a good reason for believing that sound is impermanent, then this is a conviction that sound is impermanent, is not based on a reason. For instance, in this room, probably all of us accept that the tablecloth on Geshe-la’s table is impermanent. However, if we accept that it is permanent without providing a sound reason for its impermanence, then our acceptance is merely a conviction which is not based on reasoning or on reasons.
Yes? So there is a doubt about this. There are such students in the great monasteries, Geshe la says, who never attend pecha pecha of the classes which are given every day or every two days by the teachers. They never attend the classes. They only study in their rooms and they debate with their classmates.
Some of them do well. However, there is a general feeling that they don’t do as well as those who are confronted with the teacher’s viewpoint where there is this powerful meeting of two minds. If one stays alone in one’s room or in one’s house in one’s studies, probably the results will not be very stable. There’s a clear experience of this at the great monasteries where classes are constituted of hundreds, sometimes more than 200 students. The monasteries themselves contain thousands of monks.
These monks all attend teachings and then all meet in their thousands to debate. This confrontation of viewpoint creates very powerful certainties within the mind, more powerful than staying alone in one’s room and studying. Yes. There’s a big difference between debate on the one hand and attending teachings on the other. More, debate enables us to give rise to the wisdom which has arisen from thinking.
Attending teachings is an extremely different experience since we attend teachings from teachers who themselves have gained experience and who can give us some type of experience themselves. If however you want to travel the path of debate, it is a very hard path to travel. If you want to study for instance the perfection text, it has to be studied for seven years. Are there other questions?
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
- The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
- graduated path of the three capable beings kye bu sum gyi lam gyi rim pa (Tib)
- The three levels of practice of the lower, middle and higher capable being, based on the motivations of trying to attain a better future rebirth, liberation or enlightenment. Also known as the three scopes. LYWA
- oral transmission lung (Tib, Wyl)
- The verbal transmission of a teaching, meditation practice or mantra from guru to disciple, the guru having received the transmission in an unbroken lineage from the original source. LYWA
- preliminary practices ngondro (Tib)
- The practices that prepare the mind for successful tantric meditation by removing hindrances and accumulating merit. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- tantric vows sang ngag kyi dom pa (Tib)
- Vows taken by tantric practitioners. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.