45 min · 5,306 words · 4 December 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk teaches patience as the antidote to anger, through analytical meditation on the worldly and Dharma disadvantages of anger and the advantages of patience. It explains that anger destroys one’s own happiness and virtuous imprints, and that the enemy’s harm arises from dependent origination. Quotes from Shantideva are used to support these points.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-12-04
Duration: 45 min
UUID: 130f2285-4502-4f22-a778-f1471cbe76c2
Words: 5,306
Rate can throw us into the lower realms. The enemy actually can’t destroy our happiness, it’s our anger that destroys our own happiness. And in cultivating patience, one so I don’t think I’ll talk anymore about the law of cause and effect as the basis for practising patience because if one’s understood the law of cause and effect, that should start to come fairly easily, that the enemy is there because I created the cause. Not me personally, therefore I’m a bad person, but somehow in the past the mind controlled by delusion and karma did something negative harm someone, so now the harm is coming back, and it depends for that harm to come back to me. There have to be some physical conditions and causes for that to arise, so that arises through another person and so on, and various other factors happening, my actions and so on.
So the more we understand that, we can practice patience. Also understanding that if I get angry now, I just prepare the causes for the same thing to happen in the future, again later on in this life and in future lives. So one of the main ways of cultivating patience is to do analytical meditation about all the disadvantages of anger and the advantages of practicing patience. So, the disadvantages of anger are the main disadvantages and one probably you can think of many more, but the main ones are, is that even from an ordinary point of view, when we are angry, it’s painful in the moment, it’s painful in our mind and it disturbs the body as well. Just that, It destroys our peace of mind right now, and it causes us to say and do many things that in the heat of the moment, we say completely ridiculous things, do terrible things, which we can regret the rest of this life.
In one moment of anger, we can kill a person or seriously injure a person, and so on, and we can suffer guilt over that for the rest of this life, and many other harms can come. Get a bad reputation, we start to get a reputation, Oh, this guy always gets angry, flies off the handle, slightest thing, avoid this guy, keep away from him. So we get a bad reputation and many things like that. And of course, by getting angry, it gets easier to get angry again and again in this life, so we and that anger disturbs our mind in the moment, so there’s no peace. Even from a worldly point of view, From our own point of view, from just a worldly point of view, anger is very damaging.
You get out of bed in a bad state of mind, you know, you spill coffee all over you, so you get even more upset, then you slam the door and something falls off the shelf and breaks, and you get more angry, and then you can’t start the car because you’re so angry and agitated that you’re doing the wrong thing, and then you crash into a car, then you get even more angry, you get to work and you’re fuming and you scream at someone, they scream back at you and you punch them and you get fired. Then you come home hungry, scream at your partner, your kids, the dog, you know, and then they throw you out and then you’re on the street. So, all these things, I mean they’re kind of extreme example, you know my examples now, But these type of things can happen from a moment of anger, you know? It sets off a whole lot of stuff. And also, when when we are angry, because our mind is completely agitated and very speedy and very frightened and upset and confused, because anger itself is an aspect of ignorance and it exaggerates the unpleasant quality of something far beyond what is there, we are not seeing even the ordinary reality as it is.
So there’s no way in a state of anger we can make really intelligent decisions. So, we get angry because we feel threatened, and if that threat is something serious, a threat to our life, and there’s a lot of anger and fear there, in that situation, actually to protect ourselves properly, we need a really calm, clear mind to decide what is the right thing to do to avoid some real danger. But in this mind of anger, we can’t do that. So to get angry when our life is threatened, in danger in any way, is the worst thing. Because when our life is threatened, need to have a calm, clear mind to work out how to protect ourselves properly.
So from all these points of view, just worldly points of view, ordinary points of view, anger is terrible for us, then of course it’s terrible for the people that we direct our anger to. It harms them, and we can hurt them, and we can hurt the people we like and love through our anger. And that can have consequences also throughout this life. So these are some of the worldly disadvantages of being angry. But then, from a dharma point of view, on top of that, the disadvantages of getting angry are that, of course, the main one is creating this negative imprint in the mind, this negative potential that will ripen as suffering in the future.
And because the suffering result, or the karmic result of any action is expandable, the result is far, far greater than the initial cause. So what we need to do is analyze, have this broader perspective, and analyze what is happening if we understand and accept the law of cause and effect. That right now, someone comes along and does something that we don’t like, that our self-cherishing thought is threatening my happiness. We are attached to our momentary happiness and someone seems to be threatening that. So to protect my happiness, what do I do?
I get angry. I get angry to get the energy to push that threat away somehow, either just in my mind, with my speech, or with my body. So there’s some threat to some little bit of happiness there, so one gets angry to protect the happiness. What does the anger do? It actually destroys their happiness.
The enemy hasn’t destroyed happiness. My anger, which is supposed to be protecting the happiness, actually destroys my happiness because happiness and suffering can’t exist in the mind at the same time. Anger is a very unhappy, agitated, painful mind, and the little happiness I’m protecting can’t exist simultaneously with anger. So my anger, not the enemy, my anger destroys the happiness, which is not happiness anyway, it’s just changeable suffering. Right?
So this is the whole scenario is totally ridiculous that we’re trapped in. Yeah? We protect a little bit of changeable suffering by some real suffering, some suffering of suffering, blank. So instead of a bit of changeable suffering, we’ve got, thank you very much, a whole pile of the suffering of suffering, which we create with our mind, which we then blame on the enemy. The suffering appears to be out there but it’s in our mind and it’s only happening like the average argument, how long does it last?
Shall we say ten minutes for the sake of argument? For the sake of argument, we’ll say, we have this nasty situation going on for ten minutes which is unbearable. Ten minutes of being yelled at, unbearable, right, because anger makes it permanent. So to stop this ten minutes of unbearable torture, you are such a bad person, I don’t like you, etcetera, etcetera, we get angry. This creates negative imprint in the mind which, with the twelve links, we don’t purify it, it’s a throwing karma.
Twelve links, zing, ripen, craving, grasping existence, birth, and then we experience the result. Maybe in a lower realm, as some non human being with a lot of suffering for a very long time. So to stop ten minutes of unpleasantness, have to experience a lifetime of suffering in the future. It’s kind of insane if karma is true, as the Buddha taught. It’s just completely absurd.
I mean, it’s insane to do that, which we all do, we all do, but it’s completely crazy. And as Lama Zopa Rinpoche says, There are three results, or four results of that one moment of anger get thrown into a lower realm. Then when one gets born a human being again, one experiences the result similar to the cause, a short life, lots of disease, a weak body, yeah. From that one moment of anger because someone said, I don’t like you, then the suffering environmental result, and the worst result of all, the habit to get angry again for the slightest reason, which brings all the suffering results again, which increases the habit, brings all the suffering results again. From this one moment of anger, all of the twelve links cycle, and again, and again, again, again, keep us trapped in saṃsāra.
So that’s one of the main things to meditate on, if we understand karma, if we have some faith in it. This is the way to protect our mind. More than that, maybe from a Dharma point of view, especially from the virtuous self-cherishing level of mind, wanting to achieve our own liberation, this is terrible, we create this negative karma. From a Mahāyāna point of view, there’s something even worse than that, because every time we get angry, not only do we create these negative imprints that produce suffering in the future, but our anger destroys all the virtuous imprints in our mind, burns them up. These virtuous imprints which we have acquired with such incredible effort over a long period of time, just in a moment, destroyed by the fires of anger.
So that means we never get anywhere on the path. We accumulate all this merit, and then it gets burned up. So it’s like snakes and ladders. You go up the ladder, then you get angry, go down the ladder, even further down No, no, down the snake, right? You go up the ladder, then down the snake.
Zap and zap. Pointless, frustrating, and all the time when we could have been going up and up and up, we go down and down again, and sentient beings are suffering. While we wander around in saṃsāra causing suffering to ourselves, the kind mother sentient beings are suffering. So our anger is delaying our enlightenment, adding extra obstacles, puts us further back, and we have to start again. So from a Mahāyāna point of view, this is probably one of the worst aspects of anger, as well as the fact that we are actually causing harm to mother sentient beings with our anger.
Alright, so if we contemplate these things again and again, we see there are no advantages, there’s only disadvantages in getting angry from a worldly point of view, from a dharma point of view, from the point of view of ourselves, from the point of view of others, there endless numbers of disadvantages if we look, if we investigate, if we take this broader perspective and see what is actually happening. When we get angry, it doesn’t solve the problem. Maybe temporarily it may stop the moment of anger, which is all the self-cherishing thought is concerned about, easy, happy now, you know, now. So we stop the person now, but we haven’t stopped the problem. We’ve just created the cause for the problem to arise again.
That person now hates us or hates us more, has thoughts of revenge, and that spreads to their friends and the friends of the friends, and the friends hate my friends, and the friends of the friends the friends of my enemy hate my friends friends and my friends friends friends. So it spreads and then you have a major war. So then, having had the major war, there’s even more reason to hate. So the next generation carries it over on, on and on and on. It hasn’t solved anything, it’s just increased the problem.
But this self-cherishing thought just wants a solution for now. So if we think about these things, put them more and more strongly in our mind, then we are mindful of this in our daily life, And then when anger arises, we have that mindfulness to act as an antidote. It’s like once we’ve had the experience of putting our hand in the fire, we don’t have to go around every day all the time saying, Don’t put your hand in the fire, don’t put your hand in the fire, don’t, don’t put your hand in the fire, you know? It’s not like that. Once one’s had the experience, somehow it’s just embedded in the mind, but there is some mindfulness when there’s some fire around, Don’t get close, stand back.
So it’s a little bit like that. At first, through contemplating these things, then our mindfulness has to be a bit more conscious, but the more we do that, it becomes spontaneous, more and more spontaneous and natural that we protect our mind naturally from these disturbing thoughts. First it’s effortful, but through the power of familiarity it becomes easier and becomes spontaneous Especially when we realize these things, because a realization means that it becomes a part of our mind, that understanding, that awareness becomes a part of our mind. Right now anger is a part of our mind. It just naturally, spontaneously arises in certain situations.
We can train our mind so that just naturally, in certain situations, patience will arise instead. It all depends on how we think through the power of familiarity. Okay. Thank you. Just before going on, maybe I should have said what patience is.
Patience is a loving, compassionate mind which overcomes the thought of anger. So, it has that quality. Like I tried to explain before when I talked about it, it’s not just grinning one’s teeth and gritting one’s teeth and burying it and suppressing one’s anger, but sort of not hiding it, it’s a mind that is the opposite. It’s a loving, compassionate mind which overcomes the thought of anger. It’s a tranquil mind towards difficulties.
It involves staying in a state of balance, regardless of what is happening, maintaining a relaxed, alert mind. It has the qualities of tolerance, acceptance, endurance. The great bodhisattva Atisha said that the highest patience is humility. So when we have a humble mind and that there’s there’s, you know, less of this thought of me, the strong sense of I, this ego, especially the ego sense of I. So when the ego is much less, then it’s much easier to be patient because also things don’t upset us.
We’re not attached to views of ourselves and so on. So I think this is very yeah. The highest patience is humility. And one Zen master said, It is patience which bears what you cannot bear patiently. Patience is to bear what is unbearable.
If there’s some little problem and it doesn’t upset you, we can think we’re practicing patience, but that’s not patience because it’s easy. So, when there’s something unbearable, when we can bear the unbearable, that’s being patient. Whatever we label unbearable, when we can bear it, that’s when we are being patient. A teacher. So, some other disadvantages of anger, there are endless ones but I’ll try to keep it unendless, is that just from an ordinary point of view, although this is a karmic understanding of karma, but just from an ordinary point of view, as well as all the suffering that we experience, suffering results we experience as a result of negative karma created by anger.
One of the specific karmic results of anger is to be born with an ugly body. When you practice patience, have a very attractive the karmic result is to have an attractive appearance, a pleasant appearance. To be born in a place where people think, by social conditioning and whatever, that you are pleasant looking, the karmic result of anger is to have what is conventionally believed to be an ugly appearance. Also, apart from anger causing killing, which leads to being killed and having lots of disease, also one of the not the throwing karmas, the ordinary completing karmic results of anger it acts to create various diseases. And if one has some disease already, then anger can make that disease worse.
So these are some of the more kind of temporary, temporal results of anger. Also, on the one hand, by getting angry again and again in this life, it may develop a lot of regret and guilt and shame and embarrassment and so on, which makes our life very unhappy. But on the other hand, the opposite result could occur that by getting angry again and again in this life, our mind could become very, very hard. Our mind becomes very bitter and hard, so that acts to destroy whatever good qualities we have even in this life, the qualities of kindness and sensitivity and humility and whatever can be destroyed in this life. And of course, then one of the great harms of following anger in this life is that it’s very difficult for an angry person to have a peaceful death.
Very difficult. The way we live is generally the way we die, so if we live with a lot of anger, we can die with a lot of anger, because also this is something that does tend to happen. One of the features of people when they’re dying is to have a lot can be quite angry that everyone else is alive and enjoying life, and here I am dying, this is not fair, this shouldn’t be happening to me. So a person with a very untrained mind can get very angry at the time of death. So, yeah.
So these are the disadvantages. And of course, by not being able to practice patience with the enemy, human beings, or other sentient beings, the less we are able to practice that, the less we are able to practice patience with every kind of other suffering problem in our life, and then there’s no way to practice the patience of engaging in the Dharma, voluntarily taking on the difficult practices of Dharma. Certain Dharma practices are very easy and enjoyable, like making water bowl offerings, things like that, but to engage in studying the teachings on emptiness requires effort, mental effort, time and energy. Meditating really strongly, correctly, doing retreats can be difficult. Doing purification can be difficult.
It’s not just one big happy bubbly thing practicing Dharma because real Dharma practice involves getting rid of the self-cherishing thought. So this if we’re really doing it, there’s a certain amount of pain involved. On the one hand, we can be happy that it’s happening, but as we cling to our diminishing self-cherishing, there’s some pain there, which we’ve all experienced during this course. Sometimes it’s painful. Just listening to the dharma is can be painful.
So yeah. But, you know, yeah. So these are some of the main disadvantages of getting angry. It harms everyone, other sentient beings, and it harms ourselves in so many ways. And it’s very difficult to find an advantage of getting angry, a real advantage.
There’s the appearances of advantages that and of temporary advantages that last a short time, but it’s very difficult to find an advantage of getting angry that lasts beyond this life. An advantage that one can take into one’s next lifetime or into the next generation of human beings on this earth. If you look at it from an ordinary point of view, it’s very, very difficult to find any advantage, real advantage. And so there are countless advantages of practicing patience. From a Dharma point of view, as I try to say, of the greatest advantages is that through practising patience with the enemy, we develop the patience with accepting all kinds of difficulties, and that enables us to develop the patience that enables us to practice Dharma and take on more and more Dharma practices happily without finding it unbearable, and that’s how we get enlightened.
So that’s the greatest advantage in a sense of practicing patience. From the point of view of self, from the point of view of others, if we try to think in terms of others, the great advantage is that we don’t harm others. Fantastic advantage. We don’t harm others now. We don’t harm others in the future.
We don’t harm them directly or indirectly, consciously or unconsciously. It’s a fantastic advantage of practicing patience. According to the Pali Sutras, by practicing patience, one is able to sleep well, wake up well, have no bad dreams. One is dear to other human beings, one is dear to spirits, the deities, the gods look after us. It easy to concentrate the mind, our features are serene, one dies unbewildered, and we have a good rebirth.
So, these are some of the advantages. All the advantages can be summed up in the very famous verses of Śāntideva. Who else? Chapter five verse twelve and thirteen. Twelve and thirteen.
So, in verse twelve, Śāntideva says, Unruly beings are as unlimited as space. They cannot possibly be all be overcome, but if I overcome thoughts of anger alone, this will be equivalent to vanquishing all foes. There are so many unhappy, miserable people in the world which I can’t escape, and also angry people, but if I myself overcome thoughts of anger, then none of these people can harm me in any way, they can’t disturb my mind in any way. Yeah, it should be chapter five verses twelve and thirteen. Oh, okay, maybe different.
Yes, the patient’s chapter anyway. No, no, it’s chapter Guarding Alertness, it’s not the patient’s chapter, The one before, chapter guarding alertness or introspection, I’m not sure what it’s called. Chapter five. Vigilance, okay. And then there’s this most famous quote where he says, Where would I possibly find enough leather with which to cover the surface of the earth?
But wearing leather just on the soles of my shoes is equivalent to covering the earth with it. So walking on the earth, there’s many uncomfortable things on the earth, so one way to protect us is we’d have to cover the entire earth with leather. But if we just cover our feet with leather, it’s the same thing. So there’s no way to get rid of all the unhappy, angry people in the world. But if we ourselves aren’t unhappy and angry, if we protect our mind from anger, we can go anywhere Oh, with patience, sorry.
If we can protect our mind with patience, then we can go anywhere amongst the angriest people and the most harmful people, and it doesn’t upset us, it doesn’t hurt us. Then there is the other incredibly famous statement by Śāntideva, I don’t remember where it is now, but basically Śāntideva says Śāntideva’s arguments are so simple, they’re infuriating, they make angry, they are so simple, but correct. But Śāntideva says something like, what is it, If there’s some problem and it can’t be changed, why get angry? Because it can’t be changed. And if there’s something that is upsetting us and it can be changed, why get angry?
Because we can change it. Yeah. If we know we can do something to change something, why get upset? Because we can change it. Just do it instead of getting angry.
And if there’s absolutely nothing we can do to change the situation, why get angry? Because there’s nothing we can do about it. And just the anger, since we know nothing can do it, we can’t change the situation, and therefore the anger is not going to change the situation. Why get angry? Because the anger will just make the situation worse.
Why expect it to change for the better? If there’s nothing that can improve the situation, it’s pointless to get angry. It’s such simple logic, but it’s correct logic. It’s just straight to the heart of the matter. Sorry?
It’s verse ten. Oh, it’s verse ten of patience, if you first, yeah. Other advantages of patience: it’s a cause for physical beauty, health, long life, a good reputation. One develops skill and discrimination, one is able to recognize more and more easily what is actually meaningful, what is meaningless, what is beneficial, what is not beneficial. Whereas anger obscures that ability.
And patience purifies our non-virtues. And again, just to repeat the point, it helps develop this courageous mind that can deal with any problem. So if we do this two fold analytical meditation of meditating on the disadvantages, and meditating on the advantages of patience, it becomes very helpful. This is the way to undermine the thoughts that give rise to our anger because, you know, as I tried to say, the anger arises depending on this whole network of thoughts which says it’s good to get angry, there’s benefits in getting angry, I have to get angry. This is bad, and I am good, and I am happy, and this is this is causing me unhappiness.
But if we analyze it, actually it’s our own anger that destroys the happiness, not the enemy. Nothing the the appearance of the enemy can’t make us unhappy, the voice of whatever the enemy says cannot make the mind unhappy. Even the physical activities of the banging on the head by the enemy cannot make us unhappy. It’s our own mind, the way our mind reacts to those things which makes us unhappy. It’s our own inability to bear these things and see them as inherently terrible that causes suffering.
So another way to help reduce the anger in practice patience is, again, to meditate on impermanence, because what increases this sense of being unable to bear this terrible thing is that it appears to be permanent. It’s going like, in the situation, in the emotional moment, we never analyze things so it feels like it’s going to go on forever. You know, it may only last a few minutes, but to our mind, in the moment, it feels like it’s going to go on and on, and that I can’t bear. So the more we have some awareness, mindfulness of impermanence, then it helps us to practice patience, not to get angry. Also, the more we have an awareness, mindfulness, that I could die right now in my anger, This is not so great.
I don’t want to die in an angry state of mind. No matter what the cause, you know, even if I think there’s a valid reason still, even if there’s a from my ordinary point of view, there’s a valid reason to be angry, I could die in anger. Śāntideva says in chapter six verse fourteen, There is nothing whatsoever that is not made easier through acquaintance. So through becoming acquainted with small harm, I should learn patiently to accept greater harm. So again, Śāntideva is pointing out how everything is a graduated path, we practice patience with small things first, training our mind not to get upset by small things, and then through the power of acquaintance, we can train our mind not to get upset by greater things.
And through the power of acquaintance, eventually, hopefully, can reach a point where nothing, no matter how terrible, upsets our mind. Which doesn’t mean we remain indifferent to things, we don’t care about anything. It means, by the mind not being upset by anger, with negative thoughts, there is the space to be able to react to things with compassion and love and wisdom and so on. We can be patient about what happened on September eleventh that gives us the chance to feel compassion for everyone involved, including the so called enemies whose minds must have been incredibly distorted to do something thinking this is a good thing to do. So, way to help develop patience is going back to the point I’ll just make this point again about understanding dependent arising.
Śāntideva says in the chapter on patience, starting with verse twenty-five, Śāntideva says that all mistakes there are, and all the various kinds of problems, I don’t know. Anyway, all mistakes there are and all the various kinds of problems arise through the force of conditions. They do not govern themselves. So everything that you know, the enemy that appears is not a truly existing enemy. Whatever problem there is, it hasn’t created itself, it hasn’t created itself, and I’ve created myself as a problem for you.
I’ve created myself as an enemy for you. The enemy, the problem, the disease, the difficult situation, the bad weather, whatever the problem is, it’s arisen through the force of conditions, nothing else. In verse twenty six, Śāntideva says, These conditions that assemble together, they themselves have no intention to produce anything and neither does their product, the thing that they produce, the thing that is produced by these conditions, it also has no intention to be produced. It just simply arises. A rainbow has no intention to be produced.
It just arises depending on conditions. And that thing that’s produced the rainbow itself has no intention to produce an effect on anybody else. If we think, Oh, what a beautiful rainbow, and we get happy, the rainbow didn’t intend that. There’s no intention of the rainbow. It’s just there.
It had no intention whatsoever. It just happens through the force of conditions. So even oh, maybe we’ll go on a bit. So then, Śāntideva concludes, he goes on a bit more and then concludes in verse thirty one, Therefore everything, everything is governed by other factors. Everything that exists, arising is governed by factors which are not it.
Everything is arising, governed by other factors, and these factors in turn are governed by other factors. The rainbow arises depending on other factors which are not a rainbow: The water, the sunlight, this and that, and the water content in the air and so on. And these factors themselves have arisen depending on other factors. You know, air currents moving, moisture into this area, and this and that, the clouds go away and the sun comes up. So the factor that produces something itself depends on other factors which in turn depends on other factors back and back and back.
So in this way nothing governs itself, nothing controls itself. Having understood this, I should not become angry with phenomena that are like apparitions, that are like rainbows. How can you get angry with a rainbow? What’s the point of getting angry with a rainbow? Or what’s the point of getting angry with a black cloud in the sky?
Getting angry with the rain. It had no intention to destroy our picnic, it just did. But it had no intention, it just arose depending on factors that themselves arose depending on factors, which in turn arose depending on factors. So what are we getting upset about? But we think there’s something really out there that’s plotting to hurt me.
But then you think, But, that’s exactly what the enemy is doing. They have this total intention to harm me. But this is not true. This actually, if we analyze, is not true, which then comes to Śāntideva’s fantastic little simple mind boggling argument, which is in chapter six verses. I don’t know where it is.
The most famous one. Oh, it’s verses forty three to forty four in chapter six.
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- graduated path lamrim (Tib)
- A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- possessed result
- One of four ways we can experience the result of an action, also called environmental result; possessed result is the environment we find ourselves in when we take rebirth. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
- Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA
- throwing karma phen jä kyi lä (Tib)
- Also called projecting karma, the karmic imprint that ripens at the time of death to propel us into the next rebirth. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.