Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 06 Tape 03 Side 2 The Mind….

44 min · 4,662 words · 6 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 06 Tape 03 Side 2 The Mind....
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk examines the nature of mind, arguing that it cannot arise from the physical body or from parents’ minds, because form cannot produce the formless. It describes mind as clear, knowing and formless, with gross, subtle and most subtle levels, of which only the most subtle continues from life to life. It explains that the mental consciousness is usually agitated and distracted, and that meditation, by calming the senses and the mind, lets its natural clarity and capacity to know emerge.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-06

Duration: 44 min

UUID: b1e08f1d-420a-42f1-a06f-da733b617ccf

Words: 4,662

So some more things about the mind. I’ve mentioned, we all do talk about the fact that we have a mind. We all say we have mind, I’m losing my mind, various things like that. We have these expressions. I don’t know.

Do we ever ask ourselves where our mind originates? When did it begin? How did it arise? What is the cause of our mind? So, as I mentioned this morning, if we assume that our mind arose at the time of birth, then we’re saying that it is a product of this body.

If it is a product of this body, then it ends with this body. There’s just this life. This may be true, but it’s a very depressing thought, and there’s many forms of evidence that suggest that mind and life goes on beyond this life. And according to Buddhist logic, for something to exist, it depends we’ll go into more detail about this later on, but for something to exist, it needs a cause, and the cause and the effect must be of a similar nature. Something of one nature cannot give rise to something of a completely opposite nature.

So, if we think that the mind has arisen as a result of this body, as a product of this body, of the nervous system or the brain, or some functioning of the brain, well, this body, this brain, is physical, it is form, and from Buddhist point of view, form cannot give rise to something which is formless. This is simply impossible. This body cannot give rise to a formless experience of knowing, a formless feeling. The only thing that can give rise to mind is something of the same nature, that is, a previous moment of mind. Or we could argue that our mind comes from our parents, But it comes from our parents, what part of our parents does it come from?

Does it come from our parents’ body? So which part? Does it come from our mother’s body, some part of our mother’s body, or some part of our father’s body? And if it comes from our parents’ body, does that mean our mind was existing in our parents’ body already? We were experiencing and feeling and knowing before we were born, somewhere in our parents’ body?

It just doesn’t make sense. Does our mind come from our parents’ mind? If so, did it come from our father’s mind, our mother’s mind? Did part of our father’s mind break off and become our mind? Did our father lose a bit of his mind?

Did our mother lose a bit of her mind to produce our mind? If this is so, we were existing with our parents’ minds, and if this is so, then our parents’ minds existed with their parents’ minds, and so our mind must have existed then too. This doesn’t make sense. Is mind a combination of our parents’ minds? Possible, but if we investigate, it doesn’t really make sense.

There’s a lot of arguments about this. Maybe Lama Zopa Rinpoche, if he comes at the very end of this course, may talk about it, I’m not sure. But maybe we can debate in discussion groups about this, but all of these kind of arguments tend to be nonsense. Something which is form cannot give rise to that which is formless, another mind cannot give rise to our mind. It cannot break off in some way and suddenly become a separate mind.

Although, we can all say that we have some characteristics from our parents which may indicate that we have our parents’ minds, this is mainly through the influence of our parents. We have our own separate mind that may be influenced by our parents’ ideas and so on, but it’s not actually our parents’ mind that has made our mind. Also, even though there may be some influence from our parents, it’s also very sure that each of us very quickly develops our own personalities, which can be quite contrary to our upbringing. We may have all sorts of personality characteristics and interests and qualities and so on that simply cannot be explained by the environment that we were brought up in. This is suggesting that we are bringing something from a previous life.

The interests we have, even the fact, for example, that all of us here have some interest in the Buddhadharma. Why is this? Do all our friends have this interest? The people here are from many different generations, and in each of those generations, are the vast majority of people interested in the Buddhadharma? Unfortunately not.

Why are we interested in it? Well, because we met someone or we read a book or this or that, but many people met people and read books and whatever, but had never interested them, never brought them to Nepal in these dangerous times. Why have we such a strong interest to do these things? This is indicating that we have some imprints from a previous life pushing us that are now ripening. So, the mind is we’re using this one term mind, we can also use the term consciousness.

But it sounds like it’s meaning just one thing, but also we have the term body, which is one word that when we think of it generally, we think of one thing, our own body, as one thing. If we analyse our body, it is made up of many, many different parts, and these parts are quite different, have different characteristics, and they’re also changing all the time. In same way, our mind is labeled on many, many different things. And all these things are changing moment by moment. The one thing that is common to all these different things that act as the basis for being called mind is that they are all clear, they’re all formless, and they all have the quality of knowing, experiencing, and feeling.

So, there are many ways of knowing. There are direct ways of knowing, for example, with our eye consciousness, our ear consciousness, nose consciousness, tongue consciousness, body consciousness, we directly know things. But on the basis of that direct information, we also conceive many different things. We generate so we have perceptions, we have direct perceptions of things, which is one way of knowing. Another way of knowing is indirectly through concepts of conceiving ideas about things.

We have dreams, this is also our mind, an aspect of our mind, a function of our mind. Sleep is a function of mind. This is consciousness. When the consciousness is operating at a very low level What else? My mind has gone blank at the moment.

So, all sorts of perceptions, conceptions, ideas, fantasies, dreams, sleep, every different kind of awareness, all of these things collectively we can call our mind. They’re all different ways of knowing. So, I just mentioned that from a materialist point of view, we things because we see things with our eye, with our physical eye. We could say we know things by seeing. Much of what we know, or what we think we know, comes through seeing things.

And from the scientific materialist point of view, this is purely a physical thing. Light comes into this eyeball and this produces some electrical stimulus or something which goes to the brain and so on. Somehow we know something. From Buddhist point of view, we don’t deny that that happens, but there is also something else happening, although there is this physical process going on. This is a basis for a formless knowing that as well as this physical eye, there is an eye consciousness that is operating at the moment through this physical eye, but is something different.

So that ‘eye’ consciousness, what it knows, and all it knows, is shape and colour. We also know many things by hearing. In fact, probably the vast oh, maybe much of what we know is from seeing, reading, but also a lot of what we know is from hearing. Again, from a scientific materialist point of view, this is just a physical process. Sounds, ear, eardrum, causes vibrations, some kind of electrical stimulus goes to the brain, and we recognise this sound, that sound, whatever.

From a Buddhist point of view, that is happening, but what is beyond that is that there is an ear consciousness that is hearing sounds, is knowing them, that is recognising them and knowing them. The ear consciousness is able to distinguish between meaningful sounds, which is human speech generally, and meaningless sounds, such as the sound of a river. So the ear consciousness knows that. Then we have a nose consciousness that is able to distinguish various kinds of smells, pleasant, unpleasant smells. We have a taste consciousness that knows, experiences pleasant tastes, unpleasant tastes, bitter, sour, sweet, astringent tastes.

We know those things, we experience them. And also, whenever we know and experience anything, as I mentioned, there is a feeling that goes with it. Pleasant feeling, unpleasant feeling, with each of these sense consciousnesses. And then there is the body consciousness, and what it knows or experiences is tactile sensations of hot and cold, smooth and rough. Any more scholars here?

Have I covered them? Something like that. So, that’s what our body conscious knows. And then, what puts all this information together, all these very general, low level kinds of knowing, which are direct types of knowing, what puts all this together is the most unique, important aspect of our mind, which is the mental consciousness itself. And that mental consciousness doesn’t really have a physical organ, such as the eye consciousness relies on the eye, the physical eye organ.

Our mental consciousness doesn’t rely on any organ, although perhaps you could say it relies on the brain and the whole nervous system. But what the mental consciousness does is put all that information together and creates the appearance of this world. And also, that mind, that mental consciousness, conceives based on those direct perceptions, the mental consciousness as it is operating for us now develops many concepts about what we’re experiencing. The eye consciousness perceives a red colour and the mental consciousness says, Oh, this is a beautiful red colour, I really like that red colour. I would like more of that red colour.

The eye consciousness doesn’t think that. The eye consciousness just simply, very simply, experiences the colour red, recognizes it, but the mental consciousness elaborates many things about it. So the mental consciousness is the most important aspect of the mind. And there are many levels of this mental consciousness. Generally, we can say that there are three levels of this mental consciousness.

There is the gross mental consciousness, which is the mind that we’re experiencing now, and even that gross consciousness has many levels levels of subtlety or refinement. When we’re in a positive state of mind, which hopefully we are now, we can say that that gross mind is at quite a refined state, especially when we’re generating feelings of loving kindness and compassion and so on. That mind is quite fine and refined in a quite subtle state, calm and clear. When we generate negative thoughts such as anger, aversion, jealousy and pride and so on, then that gross mind becomes even grosser, more disturbed, agitated. On top of that, you can really disturb it with all kinds of drugs, then the mind gets really gross, confused.

It is so gross and confused one may think one is in a very high, exalted, cosmic state of consciousness, but one is basically in a state of confusion. So, this gross mind has many levels. Below that gross mind there is what is called the subtle mind, and then beyond that or below that, figuratively speaking, there is the most subtle level of mind. So, is this most subtle level of mind which is the most important aspect of the mind. It is this most subtle level of mind that goes from life to life.

It is this most subtle level of mind that becomes Buddha mind. This gross mind that we’re experiencing now, that we’re using now, that is, at the moment, the only level of mind that we know about, this mind is arising very much in dependence on this physical body, this brain and this nervous system. So, depending on the nature of our body, our mind changes. If our body is healthy, our mind is operating well, if our body is sick, if our nervous system is harmed, our brain is harmed in some way, then this affects the operation of our mind. Not because the mind is the same thing as our body and nervous system, but that this gross level of mind is working through this physical body and its nervous system.

But when this body dies, which it will, when it falls apart, then the ordinary mind that we’re experiencing now, that will come to an end, it will stop. That mind that we have right now, that is not going to go anywhere, that is definitely not going to go into the next life. Even the subtle mind doesn’t go into the next life. What goes into the next life is this most subtle level of mind. It’s because of the existence of that, that the mind continues moment by moment, life after life.

And from that very subtle level of mind arises the subtle mind and then the gross mind. It is this very subtle mind that, in our past life, when the sperm and egg of our mother and father joined, it was that very subtle mind that entered these two physical substances. Fertilisation took place, that physical body grew, and the consciousness developed in that physical body. So right now, the mental consciousness that we have is constantly So this mental consciousness, this has the ability to know. The five sense consciousnesses of the eye, ear, nose, tongue, body, they are very limited in what they can know.

They have a very limited range of things they can know. The mental consciousness itself has the potential to know everything. Right now, it is knowing most things indirectly through concepts, via concepts. For example, we know things about ourselves. We have a view of ourselves, of who we are.

All of those view of self that we have is not a direct perception of who we are, it is a conception. We may like to think it is a direct understanding of who we are, a direct perception, I am this, I know exactly who I am, but we don’t. The person who we are that we know is a concept, or piles of concepts, mountains of concepts, ideas, generated by our mental consciousness, based on all sorts of information coming from all these sense consciousnesses. Someone smiles at us, eye consciousness recognises that shape, colour, good. Eye consciousness, then the mental consciousness generates a whole story about this smile, this shape and colour, white teeth showing, generates all sorts of ideas.

This person loves me, cares for me, therefore I’m good, wonderful, that’s true. Endless ideas come. But anyway, what I’m trying to say is that our mental consciousness at the moment is operating mainly through concepts indirectly. But this mental consciousness has the ability, the potential, to know everything directly, perfectly, unmistakenly. And this is what we’re trying to do in the Buddhadharma, to isolate that mind, that mental consciousness, and purify it of all the confusion that surrounds it, that overwhelms it, so that that mental consciousness can know, so it can operate the way it could operate.

It has this potential to know. If we let it know, it will do so more and more. And then the whole world, the more we know directly, the whole world changes. Some of you have seen my amazing demonstration of the mind. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn’t.

So, the nature of our mind is something like water. Whoops, better put it there. Something the mind naturally, the mental consciousness, when it is left in its natural state, allowed to exist in its natural state, is something like pure, clear water. It’s clear, it’s able to and like the surface of this water, when it’s completely still, has the potential to reflect anything perfectly accurately. This is the potential of our mind to know things exactly as they are in a very calm, clear, undisturbed way.

That is the potential, that is the nature of our mental consciousness. But our mental consciousness is rarely in that state. Sometimes it approximates it, but perhaps I think it’s accurate to say that we’ve never experienced our mental consciousness as it could be: calm, clear, perfectly reflecting things as they are. Our mind is kind of like that at the moment. It’s completely agitated, and in that state, there’s no way that that water can reflect things correctly.

It can reflect things and we may make the mistake that what is being reflected is how things are, but it’s not the case. This water, if it reverts to its natural state, has this potential to reflect everything perfectly. But, at the moment, it’s not doing it. It’s not in the situation to do it. Because, if you think about it, twenty four hours a day maybe not twenty four hours a day, well, anyway, sixteen hours a day, if not longer, our poor little mental consciousness is being bombarded by all this information from all our sense consciousnesses.

Twenty four hour, we are looking at things, hearing things, smelling things, tasting things, touching things. That mental consciousness is being bombarded all the time by that. And then, when we go to sleep, this poor little mental consciousness then generates a whole lot of thoughts and dreams and fantasies about all that information. There’s hardly a moment’s rest. So, the mind is always like that, when it could be completely still.

Also, it’s the nature of water that if you shake it, it gets agitated. If you stop shaking it, it reverts just naturally to its natural state of being calm and clear and level. Our mind is a little bit like that. When we stop agitating it, confusing it, just naturally it tends to revert to its true nature of being calm, clear, still, and having the ability to know correctly. Our mental consciousness is a little bit like someone at an office, sitting at an office all day long, and this poor little person sitting at their office has five telephones, and these five telephones are ringing all day long.

Sometimes all five are ringing simultaneously, sometimes it’s just one, sometimes two, three, four, but there’s not a moment when one of these telephones isn’t ringing. Eye consciousness here, look at that. Nose consciousness is here, listen to this. Smell that, taste that, feel that, twenty four hours a day, the mental consciousness is being bombarded. So we never experience the mental consciousness just alone, isolated.

In fact, worldly life you could define as avoiding that, avoiding just experiencing our mental consciousness for what it is. Many people, as soon as they are alone and things get quiet, freak out. That we have to do something. It’s too quiet, too still, too alone. We have to watch the television, listen to the radio, drink something, eat something, call someone on the telephone, do something, go jogging, exercising, anything, play solitaire, something, anything but to experience our mind by itself.

This is quite sad. But this is exactly what we’re trying to do in Buddhist path, is to be able to isolate our mental consciousness and discover its true nature and allow it to do what only it can do, which is to know things. I’m sorry if this expression to know things may sound really, really boring, but actually, it’s a wonderful thing to know. The way we know things now may be quite boring, but the mind has this potential to know in a very profound, direct, vivid, unmistaken, pure way, to experience everything completely, totally, without any sense of separation, completely oneness with whatever is there. So this is a really amazing way of knowing things.

This is what we’re trying to experience. And to be able to do this, to isolate the mind, this mental consciousness, so that we can allow it to just be itself and for us to discover its potential. We need to do things in our life to simplify our life, to not be so berserk in our life, rushing around doing so many things. The more things we do, the more become distracted. But also, we need to directly work with the mind, and the main way of directly working with our mind there are many ways to do this but the main direct way of working with our mind is meditation.

Meditation is about cultivating the mind, getting to know the mind, getting to know the mental consciousness. And in meditation, what we’re actually trying to do by sitting in that particular posture, just by sitting in that posture and keeping the body still, that enables the mind to calm down. Just that itself creates the condition for the mental consciousness to become a little bit calmer and clearer. Just naturally, that happens. When we sit in meditation, the idea is we don’t look around at various things so that the eye consciousness is not so active.

We don’t eat when you meditate, it’s not a good idea to eat, don’t wave incense in front of your whatever. And so, basically, we’re trying to deactivate these sense consciousnesses so that mental consciousness can arise strongly. That’s what we’re trying to do in meditation, in Buddhist meditation at least, that’s what it’s about. And then recognise the content of our mental consciousness, what is actually going on in our mental consciousness. And we start to discover that this is going on, that there’s all this shaking, all these thoughts going on.

And when we first look at our mind, we may not be terribly impressed with the contents of our mind, And we may want to run away, but the important thing is to have some patience to work step by step because, with time, this agitated mind will calm down and revert to its natural state, become calmer and clearer, and as it does so, then the positive aspects of our mind, which are always there, can start to become manifest. And as they become manifest, we can use various aspects of the Buddha’s teachings, various methods of the Buddha’s teachings, various meditation teachings, to enhance those positive qualities of our mind, allow them to arise more and more strongly. So this is basically what we’re trying to do. In the simple meditation that we’ve done just today that Venerable Karen mentioned this morning, and just the couple of minutes that we’ve spent just watching the breath today, Many people here probably meditate regularly, some people here may never have meditated at all, but even if one has had just today’s experience of focusing on one object, When we do this, even if we’re not very good at it, and no one is good at meditating at the very beginning, by persisting in this simple practice, one notices, hopefully you noticed, even in that short time, that by creating the conditions of sitting in this posture and just trying to keep the mind on one object, the mind does start to calm down, become more calm, more clear, more positive.

Hopefully, one’s had a little experience of that. So, this is indicating the nature of our mind. Given the right conditions, our mind will start to revert to its natural state. And when it is in that state, the mind can begin to know things more and more correctly, more totally. When the mind is so agitated, it can’t know anything, and when our mind is agitated like that, it doesn’t stay on any object for very long.

Even when we are talking to a friend, often we don’t fully pay attention to them. Because so many things going on in the mind. As you are listening to me right now, it’s almost guaranteed, probably, that hardly anyone here is really listening to me completely, despite the fact that this is unbelievably fascinating. So many thoughts arise, so many different things distracting the mind. Even if you want to pay attention and do find it interesting, there’s all sorts of body distractions, noises that the mind wanders to, physical discomfort, all sorts of things are arising.

So, even very simple, ordinary things, we don’t really experience them fully in the moment as they’re happening, but we have the potential to. Step by step, by training the mind, we can know more directly, totally, vividly, correctly. We just create the conditions and the mind will do its job. That’s what the mind likes to do. It’s the only thing the mind does, but it’s the most all encompassing thing, which is to know, to experience.

Alright. When do I stop? Five o’clock. Alright. I must confess I’m not very organized these first few days.

You have to give me time to relax into facing almost two hundred people. Maybe I’ll cop out and Do you have any questions so far? Yes? Yes, yes, yes. Yep?

Right. Sometimes you can use them sometimes it is these two terms are used to mean the same thing. But as I was trying to say, the mind is a general term that covers many, many, many different things. The mind is something that is labelled on the eye consciousness, the nose consciousness, body consciousness, and the mental consciousness all these different consciousnesses. It is labelled on direct knowing, it is labelled on perceptions, conceptions, it is labelled all our feelings, our mind, our thoughts, our mind, all these different things are the basis for talking about mind.

Within that, the most important aspect of what we call mind is the mental consciousness. Well, of the aspects of mind I’ll try and start again. With the body, we have the body, which we think of in one way as one thing, is made of many parts: skin, bone, blood. These have different characteristics, but they all make up they are the basis for what we call the body. So the mind based on many different things concepts, perceptions, ideas, feelings, thoughts, all these things many different things changing moment by moment.

The one thing that is common There’s a lot of difference in some ways between bone and blood, but all the different aspects that act as the basis for what we call mind, they all have the same characteristics in that they are all clear and knowing. They’re all formless and they are ways of knowing or experiencing things. So our feelings are formless. They exist, but they are formless, but they are also ways of knowing things. Our thoughts are formless and they are ways of knowing.

Some of our thoughts are correct, some of our thoughts are incorrect, but they are ways of knowing. You can know things correctly, you can know things incorrectly, but they’re ways of knowing. As I said before, don’t try to understand everything at once. The mind is a very amazing thing. We don’t really have in our language the right words to capture what it is because our culture, particularly Western culture, has arisen being obsessed with external things, of quantifying and examining external things.

So it has many terms for all of this, but it doesn’t have so much terminology for this inner phenomena that actually gives rise to all these things, which is the mind, this amazing thing which is clear and knowing, which is so subtle. Yes? And Right. Okay.

Key terms in this teaching

Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top