Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 12 02 Tape 66 Side 2

43 min · 3,612 words · 2 December 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 12 02 Tape 66 Side 2
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk teaches that the self and all phenomena exist only dependently, on causes and conditions, parts and the labelling mind, not truly from their own side. It explains that suffering arises from grasping at true existence and from wrong labels, and that understanding emptiness builds on correct conventional understanding. A question and answer session covers labelling, direct perception and karma, and the talk ends with a dedication of merit and a refuge and bodhicitta visualisation.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-12-02

Duration: 44 min

UUID: 8cb55de5-22f3-44dc-ae56-ad9ce9c9de7a

Words: 3,612

On which we can label the ‘I’. All these five aggregates are parts that make up a basis on which we can label ‘I’. But an ‘I’ existing from its own side, independent of causes and conditions, independent of the aggregates, independent of the labelling mind, such an I we can’t find. Impossible, it can’t exist. But we are grasping that such an I is present right now.

I think this talk is a load of garbage. So, if you think that way, then this talk is a load of garbage because this talk does not truly exist, fortunately. If you think this talk is brilliant, it is brilliant from your side. This talk doesn’t truly exist at all. It’s arising depending on many causes and conditions, parts, and the labeling mind.

Whose labeling mind? Your labeling mind. It’s got nothing to do with me. Well, maybe one of the causes of it. And the parts, where is this talk?

We can’t even find this talk as a truly existing phenomenon. Was the first word I spoke the talk? Is the last word, and we can’t wait for the last word? Is that the talk? Which word is the talk?

If you look at this talk, you can only find words. Just words, many words. So, they’re just the basis to label a talk. So then, if this talk is interesting, boring, stupid, ridiculous, challenging, dreary, boring, whatever, that is your label. And that’s how it is experienced, no matter what I say.

Even if I was Buddha, it will only appear the way you conceive it and label it. So, I can relax and just talk nonsense. So this applies to everything, sort of like this thing. This we call Tibetans call it a Chengwa, something like that. In Sanskrit it’s a Mala.

Sometimes we can call a rosary. It appears to be something, but then again, when you look at it, all you can find is a bead, and another bead, which is this, and this is not the mala, and this is not the mala, and this is not the mala, and this is not the mala, and this little thing is not the mala, and this stuff here is not the mala. Where is the mala? It’s just what is labeled on many different parts by the mind. It can’t exist any other way.

Everything is like that and we don’t see anything like that. And that’s why we suffer. Especially because there’s this truly existing me that doesn’t depend on the body and mind. If we saw things as beautiful or ugly, still things conventionally appear as beautiful or ugly, but if we experience them as being beautiful because we have labeled them that way, we wouldn’t grasp at them in the way we do now. So desperately, believing that they’re really that that’s real happiness there, truly existing happiness there, that mind could not exist.

It only arises by seeing this thing as something separate from me, other, yeah, got nothing to do with me. And this bad thing, this problem has got nothing to do with me, nothing whatsoever to do with me. I’m not at fault at all, not involved. This is really bad from its own side, threatening and nasty from its own side. This is how all suffering arises, by not seeing that things can only exist by depending on causes and conditions, parts, and the labeling mind.

So if you have any questions? Yes? Well, the question is that talking about labeling only seems to apply in terms of language, so one is wondering about how this works in terms of sentient beings that don’t have language. Well, I don’t know how to explain that exactly, I don’t think we need to worry about that. These teachings were taught for human beings to deal with problems.

But I think this is also an instinctive thing. There are all sorts of levels of labelling, because the labeling is the what it really means is conceiving something in a particular way, creating the appearance of something. That’s the main thing, is labeling, is conceiving something, and animals do that. No, doesn’t mean a word. But also, at a grosser level, it also, at a human level, does mean words.

There’s the conceiving of it and then giving it an actual label, which in our case, actual words. And those words take on a life of their own. Really, for us as human beings, words take on a life of their own. Yes? Oh, absence of form.

Yeah. Yeah. Oh, it’s just what I’d mentioned before, absence of an elephant in the room. It’s okay. Yes.

The pure lands and the hell realms, you could say on the one hand, you’re empty of the current existence in the sense that they depend on causes and conditions. Yes. Which is wisdom and ignorance. Which case How would you verify those two? That the hell realms and the heavens appear the way they exist.

Either as pure bliss, happiness or But they don’t appear the way they exist because when one’s in them they appear to be truly existing from their own side, which they’re not. No, you can’t. This gets very tricky, but for example, fire Sorry? I don’t know if I can repeat it. The question was about the heavens and hells are existing according to causes and conditions.

Yet at the same time, you described them as But when you say to be consistent with the way they appear, To residents, it would have to be completely consistent, but they’re not because to the residents of the heavens and hells, the god realms, the residents experience them as truly existing from their own side, which they’re not. We experience this Earth as truly existing from its own side, but it’s not. It is arising depending on our mind. We don’t experience this Earth as depending on our mind. And the hell realms depend on mind, the God realms depend on mind, but they’re not experienced that way at all.

Especially, you could say, in some ways, the existence of hell is like the existence of true, true existence. This is truly terrible. It’s a mind grasping at true existence in an extremely, like, total heavy way. I don’t understand what I can think Yeah, right. Yeah.

I don’t know if I understand either, but. Okay. My perception of things, the pillar, my mother, myself figure out what this Self is, is dependent on causes and conditions of karma and conditions in his life but which is also a result of karma. Yes. And so to change that and learn how to not label the way I have been always labeling, that has caused suffering, I need to practice all this stuff.

Is there any other one? But is that the basis? Is that the mental thing? So I have to change my mind the way I perceive everything through the belief? Yes, this is about what wisdom is doing.

Firstly, we have to understand the conventional truth of things, and then through that we are able to understand the ultimate truth. This is why the dharma means the truth. That the truth is going to set us free, nothing else. But we have to get the complete truth and nothing but the truth. Yeah?

And we don’t have that, we may think we have, but even within conventional appearances we don’t see things correctly. We make many incredibly gross mistakes. So, all the other teachings are teachings about conventional reality and getting those right, and through gaining some understanding and faith in those things, then that acts as the basis for us to be able to realize, experience how things are dependent arising, and when we realize that completely, we will be able to realize the empty nature of everything. But right now, even as conventional truths, we see the impermanent as permanent. So, we’re not even seeing something of the conventional truth of phenomena.

We see things suffering as happiness, we see ugliness as beauty, oh, no, sorry, we see what is unclean as clean. These are three major mistakes we as ordinary people see, which is not even seeing the conventional nature of things. So each of us in this room could look at one thing, and we are each labeling it in Yes, yes, yes. Well, so maybe one thing to clarify, just from what you said maybe, is that sometimes when it comes to the point about talking about what is labelled by the mind, then some people think that the way to realize emptiness is you stop labeling things. If I stop labeling it, then that’s emptiness.

But that’s not the understanding of emptiness, because firstly, we have to stop firstly, we have to stop making the wrong labels, putting the wrong labels on things. This causes the grossest suffering. Because things do exist, but they can only exist in dependence on labels. But usually we give the completely wrong, even the wrong labels. It’s not a matter of stopping labeling things altogether, that’s impossible.

Things can only exist in dependence on labeling them. But, we give them the completely wrong labels truly, existingly beautiful, truly, existingly bad. Person. Mother sentient being. This is a very good label to put on any sentient being.

Kind mother. This is a valid label to put on any sentient being, including mass murderers, rapists, one’s mother, father, everyone. This is the best label to put. No, no, that’s exactly what I’m saying. No, no, no.

Sorry? Yes. We need labels, But we need to get the right ones. But then we have to avoid believing that the labels are the thing. Could you just clarify what’s in the United States and some United States?

This is really very difficult to clarify this. This is really one of the most tricky parts to finding the valid base. Yeah, maybe I have to think about this one. But, you know, it has to have the right characteristics. We can’t just label anything what we like.

That won’t turn it into that thing because it has to have the characteristics. Roughly speaking, the answer is that to be able to label something as something, it has to have the characteristics of the thing that we want to give it to labeled. In order to label a pillar a pillar, it to perform the function of holding something up, a roof up, something like that. It has to have conventional characteristics that are conventionally accepted in order to bear the label. That’s for something to validly exist.

Yeah. I don’t know if that necessarily applies to the basis itself. Yes. The ultimate truth exists right now, everywhere, in everything, that the ultimate truth of this glass is existing right now, which is the emptiness of the glass, but we are not experiencing it. So, is the consciousness directly experiencing that.

So, when we generate that wisdom consciousness that directly sees the emptiness, that directly sees the Ultimate Truth, then we are liberated. But Ultimate Truth is not wisdom. Wisdom is a consciousness experiencing the ultimate truth. And emptiness itself is not a consciousness. There is a wisdom that perceives that emptiness of things.

Me? No, no, you can’t say ultimate truth leads you to see emptiness. Emptiness is the ultimate truth. And that is existing everywhere, in everything, in each hair we have, in everything exists in that way, exists as being empty. Right?

But we are not experiencing it. When we experience it, are liberated. Yeah. That’s what is meant by, you know, we don’t create the experience of emptiness. It’s always there.

It’s always present. It’s only because things are empty that things actually exist. But we are not experiencing it. So, we develop, we generate this consciousness, a wisdom consciousness that is actually able to experience it. And firstly, we experience it through the means of concept.

We have an inferential understanding of emptiness, through like, the way we recognise this thing as a glass is through a generic image of having seen many, many glasses before, then we have a generic image of a glass, a cup, generic image of a flower. So we understand that this is flower through the power of a generic image, and we also understand emptiness in the same way. We generate a correct generic image of what emptiness is, and then we experience it through the power of this generic image. But eventually, one is able to experience it directly without that generic image. On the path of what is called the path of insight, one day, having trained our mind and whatever, we will sit down one day and meditate and we will have this direct perception of the empty nature of this person.

And everything will become empty. There will be this space like emptiness where no thing whatsoever appears to the mind. And it will be completely blissful. And then out of meditation everything will start to appear like a dream. It will still appear to be truly existing, but it more dreamlike.

So then, in meditation, one goes back into meditation and slowly, slowly one is able to maintain perception of emptiness more and more strongly and more powerfully, and slowly it eats away the ignorance that is creating this false illusion. So, by step, one, because the direct perception of emptiness doesn’t eliminate ignorance, completely unfortunately, it just starts to chop it away. There are many stages after directly perceiving emptiness one has to go through before ignorance is completely eliminated. What? Oh, ten minutes left.

Oh, okay. So the way I’m putting this together is that the more we practice Dharma, the wiser we get. The wiser we get, the better we get at labeling. The better we get at labeling, the more happiness we feel until we get to enlightenment. Very roughly.

It’s not just a matter of labeling things better, but it’s also knowing that we are doing that. That’s the most important thing. I mean, the gross thing of making the wrong labels is really like gross mind, pretty much. But then, when we are conceiving things in the correct way, the real thing is to develop this awareness more and more that we are doing exactly that. It is our mind that is enabling these appearances, good or bad, to arise.

It cannot exist apart from the mind. Because this is the most subtle aspect of dependent arising, to understand. The grossest, easiest thing is to understand the things depend on causes and conditions. It’s more difficult, much more difficult, to understand that things depend on parts, much more difficult to actually experience it or even understand it, and the most subtle is to understand how things arise depending on our labelling mind. Yes, all the levels of wisdom, yeah.

As Nāgārjuna said, the beginning of that is depending on the law of cause and effect. That itself is being wise. Because that is also the beginning of understanding how things depend on causes and conditions. They’re practically synonymous, aren’t they? The question was, how do causes and effects fit into things depending on causes and conditions?

This world is a condition for effects to arise in our mind, and those effects arise in our mind depending on causes our mind has created in the past, either earlier in this life or in a past life. And those causes themselves are effects coming from previous causes. That’s causes. Yes, that’s also causes and conditions, same thing, basically. Can you define or explain direct perception, the experience of a direct perception of something?

Don’t know if I can define it. It’s where you perceive something free of a generic image, free of any concept. The way our sense consciousnesses have direct perception of their object. We directly see shape and color, directly hear sounds and so on, directly experience smells, free of any concept. But our mental consciousness now experiences everything through concepts.

You know, in one moment there is a shape or color appearing to the eye consciousness directly, but then our mental consciousness knows that shape or colour indirectly via these generic images that have been generated in our mind by all sorts of past karmic imprints and so on, in this life and past lives. So, what would truly perceive in that pillar of fear? That’s a good question. Well, like now we perceive it with our eye consciousness, we can only perceive it with our eye consciousness, but at the same time our mental consciousness is the appearance created by the eye consciousness of shape and colour, then our mental consciousness puts a whole lot of things onto that shape and colour via generic images plus our attachment or aversion and all sorts of things. So it’s very indirect, but somehow a direct perception of it is the mind, the mental consciousness, directly seeing that.

But of course our mental consciousness can’t directly see a pillar. The Buddha’s mental consciousness can, but we can’t. But our mental consciousness knows everything via many, many concepts. But it’s our eye consciousness seeing it, actually seeing it. See, our eye consciousness sees round and this and that, round and red, and our mental consciousness labels that.

The eye consciousness doesn’t call that a pillar, the eye consciousness just simply sees a shape and a color. And then our mental consciousness, because of past experiences and through the power of a generic image, that has a generic image of pillars which can be square, round and different colours made of plastic, marble, wood, cement, but we have a generic image of a pillar and our mental consciousness recognizes this shape and color is pillar. Yeah? And then it labels it Tibetan type pillar, beautiful pillar, ugly pillar, so so pillar. Our mental consciousness does all that, and then it appears to our mind as truly existing pillar.

It doesn’t appear that all those things have gone on. So if we were to directly perceive that, then we would our mental consciousness would just know that’s a pillar without needing the eye consciousness and all these other things to come together. Yes, but even the mental consciousness still needs the label. Yeah, the pillar can’t exist from its own side without the label. The pillar can’t exist for us, even for our mental consciousness, without the label ‘pillar’.

Excuse me? If a baby does not know the concept of a pillar, yes? Yes. But it can’t see a pillar? No.

A pillar is a valid, a conventionally existing phenomenon which is valid to perceive. Pillars exist, there’s a pillar. That we were in some what? Yes, because they don’t truly exist. Why do they cause karma?

They don’t truly exist. Because they depend because causes depend on causes, they don’t truly exist. If the causes themselves truly existed from their own side, we couldn’t do anything, we would be stuck. But everything depends on other things, that’s the only way they can exist, and because of that, enlightenment is possible. If karma truly existed, we are doomed, but it doesn’t truly exist.

It exists and it functions, but it doesn’t truly exist from its own side, and that’s why everything is possible. I think we have to stop, yeah? So we can dedicate the merit that by this imprint, may we be able to, at some point, actually understand the way of myself and all phenomena do exist, free ones become completely free of all ignorance, all delusions, all negative karma, quickly achieve enlightenment to benefit all the kind suffering other sentient beings who are suffering by being controlled by the belief in true existence. May the precious bodhi mind not yet born arise and grow May that born have no decline, but increase forevermore. And we can make the third offering.

Omam, So, whatever we experience in this life and in any other life arises depending on many factors, many causes and conditions, and especially the effects that we experience arise in dependence on the court hello? Hello? Little bit loud. Hello? So, the effects arise depending on the causes and the strength and the nature of the effect depends on the strength and nature of the cause.

So this is why it’s so important that we try and, with everything that we do, to have the very best motivation, the strongest, clearest, best motivation we can possibly generate. So this applies most of all when we apply our mind to the spiritual path and, for example, listen to a presentation of the graduated path. So, as much as possible, we can try and generate the Bodhicitta thought based on a strong refuge in our own Buddha nature that doesn’t identify, that doesn’t allow us to identify with our self-cherishing mind and acts as a cause to be able to give up the self grasping thought. So we can, if we wish, imagine the very embodiment of that perfect mind that we aspire to manifesting in front of us in the form of Śākyamūni Buddha, and with countless other holy beings surrounding him, and ourselves surrounded by all the different kinds of beings, beginning with our parents on either side, family and friends behind, and so called enemy in front. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, Dharma, and the Supreme Assembly by the merits that I create, by listening to the Dharma, in order to benefit all sentient beings.

Okay. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
graduated path lamrim (Tib)
A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Is it right to say that the more we practice Dharma, the wiser we become, the better we label, and the happier we are until enlightenment?

Very roughly, yes. But it is not just a matter of labeling things better; it is also knowing that we are doing it. That is the most important thing. Making wrong labels is a gross level of mind. Once we conceive things correctly, the real task is to develop more and more awareness that it is our mind enabling these appearances, good or bad, to arise. Nothing can exist apart from the mind. This is the most subtle aspect of dependent arising to understand. The easiest, grossest level is understanding that things depend on causes and conditions. Much more difficult is understanding that things depend on parts. The most subtle is understanding how things arise depending on our labelling mind.

What is direct perception, and what does it mean to experience something through direct perception?

Direct perception is perceiving something free of a generic image and free of any concept. Our sense consciousnesses perceive their objects this way: we directly see shape and color, directly hear sounds, and directly experience smells, without concepts. Our mental consciousness, by contrast, now experiences everything through concepts. In one moment a shape or color may appear directly to the eye consciousness, but the mental consciousness then knows that shape or color indirectly, by way of generic images. These images have been generated in the mind by all sorts of past karmic imprints, from this life and past lives.

Scroll to Top