44 min · 4,766 words · 23 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk continues the Kopan course with teaching on the six sufferings of samsara, including the suffering of loneliness and the lack of a true refuge. It then moves to the eight sufferings, beginning with the suffering of birth, and discusses how samsaric realms and even this world are products of delusion and karma. A question and answer session on loneliness, the lower realms and teaching children about impermanence and death is included.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-23
Duration: 44 min
UUID: 2d7d3eb0-398b-42f4-8259-2aa2852faa84
Words: 4,766
This kopan course comes to an end. But we meet our teacher, then we are separated from the teacher. So this happens so many times in this life, but then it happens life after life. We rise to the highest God realms, fall to the lowest hell realms. So, there’s this constant changing again and again.
So if we think about it, going through this again and again, what’s the point of going into the God realms if we fall into the hell realms? What’s the point of being wealthy if we lose the wealth? We put all this effort into gaining knowledge and then we lose it. We meet all these friends, we’re separated from the friends. It goes on and on and on, life after life.
What is the point of putting any ultimate value on these things? It’s frustrating, it’s suffering, it’s not fulfilling. And then the last of these sufferings, way of thinking about the problems of saṃsāra, the unsatisfactoriness of saṃsāra, is that there is the suffering of being alone. That, especially because of ignorance, generate this view of self, if it really existed, be an independent phenomena. So, create this I which is separate from others, independent of others.
We create the illusion of that and and our self obsession maintains that. We create all these barriers between ourselves and others. And so, though when we follow desire, attachment for others, and want to have these strong connections with other people that we desire and love and feel attached to, still there’s always the barrier of our self-cherishing and our self grasping. So we’re always alone. We are born alone, we die alone, and in the middle we are just alone.
And what perpetuates that is our self-cherishing, self grasping all our delusions. In some of the realms we are totally alone. In the human realm we are alone with others but we’re still alone. In some of the realms of mind, like in the highest God realms, we have no awareness of any other being. In the lower hell realms, we’re just alone with our own suffering mind.
So, self-cherishing creates alienation in this realm, the best realm to be in generally to practice Dharma, still our self-cherishing creates alienation from others. Because this world is dominated by self-cherishing, there’s so much alienation in this world now from others. There’s more human beings on the planet than ever before, but we’re all alienated from each other. We live in squashed cities, apartment buildings and so on, where we don’t even know our neighbour, don’t even want to, don’t even look at them in the lift or something, walk along the streets. Many many years ago, I I I met someone from when I was in where was this?
In Sydney. I met this dancer that’s from New York City and and she was explaining explaining she was also black, so she was explaining that in New York, especially if you’re black, you cultivate this look where you don’t show anything, you you don’t reveal any expression because if you smile at someone, this could be very threatening. If you look bad, if you don’t smile at them, this could also be bad. So you have to cultivate this totally bland look where you also don’t look at anyone because they may take it in the wrong way. So, you have to live your life like that for protection.
It’s pretty alienating. So, our delusions alienate us from others. We follow them thinking they will make us happy, but actually they alienate us. We’re all trapped in this little bubble of our own self-cherishing. So this is one aspect of being alone, is very frustrating and unsatisfying.
The worst another interpretation of the meaning of this term being alone is that being without a refuge. This is the worst loneliness of all, not having a true refuge to a companion in suffering. Why do we want friends and lovers as a companion against suffering? Some shelter, some protection against suffering. But our friends and lovers, as suffering people do, so they can’t really protect us.
What we need is a real refuge, a real reliable companion against suffering. So when we don’t have that refuge, we are really alone. We are really lost in saṃsāra, completely wandering alone and lost in our mind, this deluded mind. That is really being alone. So we can spend lifetimes like that without any real refuge, completely alone, nothing to protect us from suffering and confusion.
So it’s so rare to have the precious human rebirth where we meet the Dharma and have that refuge, generate faith in Most of the time we’re completely alone. Okay, any questions on that? Well, the six are applied to saṃsāra in general. To all samsaric states, more or less. Even the highest God realm one is experiencing the suffering of uncertainty because it doesn’t last.
So these are some of the six drawbacks of saṃsāra in general. Then the eight sufferings are particular to the desire realm. Specifically, some apply more generally to the human realm, the eight. Although some of them also apply to other rebirths in the desire realm, one can particularly apply them to the human realm. The three sufferings I’ll try and explain when I get to it what realms they relate to.
It is there, is it? Yes, right. Thirty eight. Yeah, I’ll try and explain it when we get to it. Then there are are there any other questions on that?
Yes? I have a question to the mind of discontent. When you have something and there’s not even a choice, you’re not chasing after something better, You can see, sort of, that it does not bring you so much joy after a week, after another week. What is the mechanism? Of that dissatisfaction?
Yes. That the mind, when you have one object, when you say something that automatically so the happiness declines from the side of the mind, not from the side of the object. If you have an object and even you’re not desiring another object, the pleasure declines. Well, that’s an example of Maybe we can talk about that later. This is an example of the suffering of change, right, I think, which we can try and talk about later when we get to that.
There’s also an aspect that the mind itself, the ordinary mind, is changing moment by moment. So Okay. Yes? I have a question about suffering of loneliness. It’s a delusion because we are thinking that we are separated from the others.
So, then to have refuge or take a strong help feel that’s really helping you to be with other companions, or say that entrance to enlightenment of your Is that a delusion then again? The suffering of loneliness is not a delusion, it’s suffering. Delusion is an affliction in the mind that leads to suffering, but loneliness itself is suffering, it’s not a delusion. It comes from delusion, but it is not delusion, right? So, wanting to have companions on the spiritual path, is that a delusion?
No. If spiritual companions? Yeah. No, no, no. I mean, we need them.
It’s conditioned to follow the path. It’s a character. We need that to have the precious human rebirth. It’s one of the features that qualifies our rebirth as a precious human rebirth, that we have spiritual companions to help us, inspire us and so on. Which of the meditations to the lower realms speaks most most to the topic of being the lower realm?
Hell realms, the lower hell especially the lower hell realms, especially in particular, I think if I was very compassionate, I’m not even compassionate at all, but if I was compassionate, I would talk about the hell realms a lot but everyone gets upset. I haven’t only talked one afternoon briefly. But there are the hot hells and the cold hells. So the cold hells, even in the least cold hell, one is totally alone there. There’s no awareness of any other being, there’s just total darkness and one is freezing.
Yeah. You’re completely alone, pitch black freezing. Then in the lowest hell realms, again, there’s there are no you don’t see other beings except these karmic monsters, which aren’t other human beings, they’re just projections of the mind. Suffering of parting from loved ones? What about it?
Suffering of loneliness, of being alone. Yeah, yeah, I suppose so. That’s what you’re experiencing when you’re being parted from loved ones, that the sense of being alone is arising and that causes fear and pain and so on. And one tries to stop that by getting attached to the loved ones, but it’s actually reinforcing it. Right.
Well, the Buddhadharma was taught to adults, and much of this is really only suitable to be heard by adults. It’s not wise to go around teaching children that everything is suffering. I mean, this is really not appropriate. I mean, we’re not children here, so we can talk about it. Well, I’m not quite sure exactly, but often the little kids are taught quite abstract, technical stuff from the beginning, even though they don’t understand it.
First they memorise it and then they receive teachings on it. But one of the first things they are taught, dura, is things like the colours, to distinguish the colours and to start developing a logical way of thinking and various things like that, and identifying the different objects of the eye consciousness, ear consciousness and so on. And then there’s the colour, you know, there’s shape and colour, and then there are what the shapes, the colors, these kinds of things. I’m not sure when they’re that’s a good question, actually. Don’t know exactly when they are interested.
In Tibetan culture, it’s also this is the thing, kind of, I think, absorb it because people accept that. Even though they don’t have realisations or even meditate on, the average Tibetan knows, accepts that life is suffering, the first noble truth. Even though, of course, they’re chasing after the pleasures of it, there is this basic acceptance that that’s it. So, children sort of absorb some of that and learn about impermanence. This is a very good thing to teach.
I think children can understand this. I think you can teach this to children in a wise way, some simple aspects of it. Because also, if one checks these six sufferings, most of all that suffering arises because things are impermanent. It’s just a very clever way of saying things are impermanent. In the First Noble Truth, as I mentioned before, there are the four aspects of true suffering and it is impermanent.
Everything is impermanent. That’s why existence is suffering. But I think it’s possible to teach children how things don’t last, your toys don’t last, and maybe one’s friends will go away. I’ve never had children’s and I haven’t had much experience with children. I’m not the person to really ask, but I think there’s an appropriate time when you could explain these things.
Children are open to that and can understand. Children are very wise. There are things about when friends go away and, you you have this big piece of chocolate cake but it’s not going to last. You know, and All sorts of simple examples that you start putting this wise knowledge into them and people can draw their conclusions later in life as well. But to learn about death, children can learn about death in a non confronting way.
And, you know, this little bird, your little pet canary dies and, you know, everything dies. And don’t have to it’s okay for the little pet canary to die, that it’s natural, it’s not unnatural, like there’s no pet little canary that lasts forever. It’s okay to die. This is a very important thing to learn, that it’s natural to die, It’s not disgusting. It’s not a failure of life to die.
Because that’s what we’re brought up to think, that to die is terrible. It’s the greatest failure of our existence, to die. It’s somehow shameful to die because we should go on living because life is wonderful. Because, you know, Hollywood movies, everyone lives happily ever after. The magazines and everything.
And then, they don’t talk about dying. But it’s okay to die. This is an incredibly good thing to teach children. So, think some of these things are very gently and simple examples can be taught, yeah, and that animals suffer, yeah. No more questions?
Maybe we can take a leg stretching break, one minute break, and then we can think about these points. Contemplate. So the six sufferings that I went through are listed on page thirty eight, with a small commentary on how to meditate by Lama Zopa Rinpoche at the bottom. So, just quietly go through these points. You can just think about one if that one really kind of strikes a chord in your mind or go through all of them or just a few of them.
Just try and think about them in terms of one’s own experience in this life and then try to have this broader perspective of how this goes on, can go on and on and on. It’s so unnecessary, so much time, energy, that one could put all this time and energy into cultivating the mind, which is more worthwhile. So we spend a little time focusing the mind on the breath to establish a little bit more calmness, clarity and concentration which we can apply to listening to the graduated path. Okay, thank you. So, in the path to enlightenment, to get to that goal, we have to start at the beginning, there’s no other way, and step by step, we start from a state of ignorance, confusion, and the mind often controlled by the self-cherishing thought.
And so, the first main step on the path to enlightenment is to move the mind away from its obsession with the limited pleasures and the small problems of this life to that obsession is the basis for creating negative imprints in our mind. We move our mind away to having this broader perspective that not only thinks of this life, the welfare of this life, but includes in it the awareness of our future existence and works for that future existence by protecting the mind, putting more and more emphasis into protecting the mind by trying not to follow the delusion so much, and developing the mind of at least love and compassion for oneself, at least putting effort into generating, starting to overcome the gross self-cherishing thought and starting to develop this mind of loving, really loving oneself, taking care of oneself, having compassion for oneself by developing the positive qualities of one’s mind, by valuing the virtuous things with one’s body, speech and mind. So, doing this more and more, then we generate the causes to have better and better rebirths within saṃsāra. And then, at that point, having generated that mind, that basic mind of renunciation, then we can contemplate that even if we continue to take rebirth within saṃsāra again and again, even in the high realms, the fortunate realms of saṃsāra, we don’t escape suffering.
It comes back to us again and again and again in so many ways. And while we remain within saṃsāra, even in the higher realms, sooner or later, we will end up creating the causes of the lower realms. It’s a little bit like being in a forest where there are even a large forest and there’s one deadly poisonous snake. If you stay in the forest long enough, you’ve got to run into the poisonous snake. Something like that.
I don’t know if that’s a very good analogy. See, when you hear my analogies and you compare them to the Buddhist analogies, then you can understand some how Buddha mind is so wonderful to develop these really good analogies. They’re called clarifying analogies. Mine are confusing analogies, but the Buddhist analogies are clarifying analogies. Just going back a little bit, just thinking about the six kinds of suffering.
In some ways, just using this terminology, the six sufferings, there’s the six sufferings, the eight sufferings, the three sufferings, it turns life into a list of things and it tends to distance us. It becomes an academic topic, but it’s not an academic topic. These six sufferings manifest in our life again and again and again and again. So, we should try and approach it in that way, but somehow it’s inevitable to talk about the six sufferings, the eight sufferings and the three. But each one of these six sufferings manifests in many, many different ways, so many ways.
An example of leaving the body again and again, one way to contemplate this that the Buddha gave is to think that if all the bones of all our previous bodies were piled up, it would just fall mountains, bigger than Mount Everest. If you know about Mount Meru, it’s even bigger than Mount Meru. Just piles of them. If all the blood from all our previous bodies was put together, it would fill all the oceans of this earth, more than fill the oceans of this earth. All the milk we’ve drunk from our previous mothers would fill the oceans of the earth.
The tears that we’ve cried with these bodies in previous lives would fill the oceans of the earth. And the Buddha himself gave the analogy that when we think about joining with bodies, suffering bodies, again and again, the Buddha gave the analogy, if we were to take all the soil of this earth, the whole earth, not just the soil but everything, and made little pellets the size of a juniper berry. There’d be a lot of little pellets of juniper berry sized berries if we took all the substance of the earth. But this wouldn’t equal the number of previous mothers we’ve had. So we can contemplate like that, trying to get some sense of how we’ve gone through samsaric experiences again and again, an inconceivable number of times.
In Kadam’s book, on page thirty eight, there’s the quotation from Arhat Shariputra it says, He eats his father’s flesh, hits his mother, so on. Our wife gnaws her husband’s bones. So, it’s a little bit of a skewer there, what that means. Many of you are very familiar with this story, but maybe some of the new people aren’t, so I’ll just go through it because it’s helpful to know this story as a contemplation on how we experience these six sufferings. This is particularly an illustration of the first of uncertainty everything changes, nothing lasts, nothing is reliable.
And it’s also this particular story is always used as an example, an aid in developing equanimity. But there is a story that the great Arhat Shariputra, who went begging, being a good monk, went begging every day for his lunch, even when he was an arhat. You don’t get out of things. So, one day when he was begging near a village or something, there was this small farmhouse and he went there and he saw there was a small family, a young family. There was the young man, his wife, and the young man was very lovingly holding his baby, their baby, and at the same time he was eating lunch.
So the man was eating some cooked fish and, you know, when he ate the flesh of the fish he was spitting out the bones onto the floor and there was the family dog there trying to get the bones, and so the man was kicking the dog away every now and again when it got near his feet or something. So, he was holding this baby, eating this fish and kicking the dog and his wife is there. So, because Saraputra was clairvoyant, he could see the past lives of these beings, and he could see that the man’s baby that he was lovingly holding was actually the incarnation of his worst enemy that he had been fighting with for some years before. I think the story there’s some other complications to that, but that’s good enough. Anyway, was this man he hated, the man had died and had been reborn as his son, so now he was lovingly cradling his child, who in an immediate previous life had been his worst enemy.
The father of this man, the man with the baby, had died and the father had kept a pond of fish in the backyard because he was a farmer for food. So, now and again he’d killed the fish to feed the family. So, because of the negative karma of killing the fish, he had been reborn as one of the fish and the fish that the young man was eating was the incarnation of his father. The mother of the father, mother of the young man who was holding the baby, she had also died and because she had been extremely attached to her family, she had been born as the dog in the family. So, the young man was eating the fish, which is the incarnation of his father, and kicking the dog, which is the incarnation of his mother, and holding the baby, which is the incarnation of his worst enemy.
So, nothing is definite in saṃsāra. So, this is also a way to develop equanimity because friends become enemies, enemies become strangers, strangers become friends, strangers become enemies. Nothing is certain, nothing is definite, nothing is reliable, nothing lasts. So, this is something about the six sufferings that we experience again and again in this life. In most of the realms of saṃsāra, these things occur again and again.
So then, way of moving our mind to look for the causes of our suffering and to get out of saṃsāra and not be concerned just with redecorating the prison cell but escaping the entire concentration camp is to think about the eight kinds of suffering. So, the first of these is the suffering of taking birth, the suffering of birth itself. So, there are five things that we can contemplate in regard to the suffering of rebirth itself. The first one, which is the very obvious one that we could relate to, is the suffering of the physical process of being born itself. Coming out of the womb, is often a painful thing.
Maybe in some cases it’s not. Some people may be born without any pain as they come out from the womb, but generally it seems it’s not that much fun being born. So, if sometimes it’s not, the point is to think not just this one time, but every time we get reborn human or born in a womb, some kind of womb, a human womb, an animal womb, then there is this painful process of being born. So we have to experience that again and again and again and again. So that’s one aspect to contemplate.
And, what then, another aspect of this is that we are born into ignorance and delusion again and again. Take rebirth into more ignorance or not necessarily more ignorance, but into a state of ignorance and delusion again and again. So this is something and while delusion encumbers there, we don’t escape. Even if we have a good rebirth, still there is the suffering of that. And also, one is born into a suffering realm.
Even this human realm, which is, compared to many other realms, very pleasant, still it is a contaminated place which gives rise to suffering. It does give rise to happiness, temporary happiness, pleasure, but it also gives rise to suffering. It is an example of true suffering, this world, because it is a product of delusion and karma although it’s a product of usually some good karma but still it’s a product of delusion and karma, is an example of the truth of suffering. Even this table, technically in the Buddhadharma, this table is an example of a true suffering. It’s an example of a true suffering.
It doesn’t mean the table is suffering because it doesn’t have consciousness. It’s an example of what the Tibetans like to call, the Tibetan lamas call, or what is called in the Abhidharma, of giving the name of the result to the cause. So, this table, because it is a product of delusion and karma, acts as a cause to give rise to suffering. Because we can develop attachment to it, we can develop aversion to it by conceiving it as mine, we develop attachment. We can give rise to jealousy, Oh, this person has got this table, why don’t I get a table like that?
And so on. Because it is a product of delusion, karma, it acts as a condition, it can act as a cause to give rise to suffering. So, this Earth, this whole planet is like that. It is not a pure land. In the pure lands, which are not produced by delusion and karma, but by the pure minds of the Buddhas, just as our pollute, our confused, our ignorant minds give rise to the ordinary universe, the minds of the Buddhas give rise to pure lands where everything is pure.
It doesn’t give rise it cannot give rise to any form of suffering, attachment, aversion or anything. That’s why it’s good to consider taking rebirth in these pure lands because our delusions won’t manifest there. We can receive the teachings of the Buddhas and progress on the path to enlightenment there. But here, taking rebirth in saṃsāra, we are always taking rebirth into a suffering place. And, of course, even in this earth, some places give rise to more suffering than others.
Some are very beautiful places, conventionally beautiful, pleasant places, and some places definitely do have special qualities about them. Even though it’s a physical place, there are special, like holy places such as this one, I think. Copan is definitely a special place. The Kathmandu Valley itself is believed to be a very holy place where many holy beings have lived and practiced and gained great realisations. Padmasambhava lived here, I think Milarepa — was Milarepa here at all?
Maybe I made that up. Forget that one. Padmasambhava, Padmasambhava was definitely here. Machig Labdrön, the famous female practitioner who introduced the Chöd practice into Tibet, she lived here. Gelongma Palmo, who introduced the Nyung Ne lineage of the Chenrezig fasting retreat, came from Nepal, from this area.
And many great masters, the Kadampa brothers, if you read the lineage lamas, came from here. So, great realized beings. Also, what’s his name? No, I can’t remember, sorry. So, anyway, this valley itself is considered to be very, very holy.
The stupa, the Boudhanath stupa, is considered to be of the holiest, most special Buddhist stupas in the world, very ancient. That wish will be fulfilled. When you see the stupa, make these very strong virtuous wishes and they will be fulfilled. I understood what Rinpoche said, the very, very first time you see. But maybe also, every new time you come in, maybe a little bit works like that too.
So, there are special places in this earth but generally, this is we are born into a suffering realm and into a deluded place. That’s the fourth aspect. And having taken rebirth is the suffering of being separated from this body. So, are all aspects of the suffering of taking rebirth. One could also include in that well, in the suffering of being separated from the body, there is the suffering of the Bardo state itself.
Going, you know, that is a suffering situation, being in the womb is suffering. It can be suffering, not all the time, but in the teachings it says like when the mother moves, like if the mother moves violently, then this can cause some suffering to the child in the womb. If the mother eats hot things, this can affect the child and so on. Even the state of the mind of the mother can influence the child. I did hear that even through some modern psychological tests, something has been done that seems to indicate that this is true, that somehow they’re able to test something about the state of the mind of the child in the womb and when the mother is like this
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- chöd chö (Tib)
- A tantric practice aimed at destroying self-grasping, where the practitioner visualizes dissecting and distributing the parts of the ordinary body to spirits and other beings as a feast offering. LYWA
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- Kadam
- The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded in the eleventh century by Atisha, Dromtönpa and their followers, the "Kadampa geshes"; the forerunner of the Gelug School. LYWA
- Mount Meru
- The mythical center of the universe in Buddhist cosmology. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.