44 min · 5,110 words · 28 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains the purpose of taking vows, from the five lay precepts and pratimoksha vows up to bodhisattva vows, presenting morality as protection for the mind and a basis of the path, especially in the Gelug tradition. It then contrasts the path to liberation with the path to enlightenment and presents bodhicitta as the aspiration to become a Buddha for all sentient beings, quoting Shantideva.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-28
Duration: 44 min
UUID: 10785027-08e0-4bd3-bbed-162ebd593157
Words: 5,110
The vows of the pratimoksha vows of an ordained person, either the thirty six vows of a of a we call a novice, monk or nun, or the full ordination of a monk or nun. And then one can take the bodhisattva well, one can take also the bodhisattva vows, and eventually one can take the tantric vows. If one’s thinking to take the bodhisattva vows, which are much greater commitment to the path, then why not take the five precepts first? They’re really important, it seems very strange to have the bodhisattva vows but not the five lay precepts. It’s much more difficult to keep the bodhisattva vows, so if one decides to keep them, one at least should decide to keep the five lay precepts.
And so at least one can think of using these as a guide in one’s life and and but if one has the actual vow, then it’s it’s much more protection for the mind. We take these vows, they are they protect our mind. The whole purpose of all the levels of vows is to protect our mind more and more from the disturbing thoughts. And therefore creating negative karma. So if want to be free of the disturbing thoughts, then the best way to be free, to be liberated, is to take vows, some level of vows.
That’s the way to be free. All of these vows, the five lay precepts, the vows of monks and nuns, are called the pratimoksha vows. They’re at the various levels, but even the five lay vows are part of the pratimoksha system, which is the vows of individual liberation. By maintaining these vows one will achieve liberation for oneself. They are essential, they are essential for achieving liberation.
But one can’t achieve them without the basis of either the five lay precepts or the vows of full ordination, I don’t know how to put it otherwise, the vows of monks and nuns. Of course, also another form of vow is the the eight precepts that one can take like we are taking now, and so one can take having taken them from someone who has had received them before, then one can take them at any time, don’t think you can only take them here at Kopan, one can take them at any time, now and keep them for the one day. So this is also a very wonderful practice that brings about great deal of purification and generates merit and so on. So if one wants to be free of the disturbing thoughts, one can take the vows with a happy mind, seeing understanding that they free us. They’re not some kind of burden, they free us from the thing that we want to be free of.
Whereas if we want our delusions to run wild, then don’t take vows. No. I didn’t know. No. No.
Tantric vows, the tantric vows. Yeah. So in the in the Vinaya, it it calls the vow something like a bridle for a horse. Mind is like a wild horse, a completely untamed wild horse. So such a horse you can’t use, it’s just too berserk and wild.
But if you put a bridle on it, you can direct it any way you like. So, some people never want that, so difficult to achieve in liberation if one doesn’t want that. One doesn’t want to tame the mind. It’s very difficult to achieve liberation, let alone enlightenment, with an untamed mind. So the way to do it is to direct one’s life, one’s energy of the mind with taking vows.
So these are not only of course, they benefit oneself, but they’re also a great benefit to everyone around us. They’re a real contribution that we can give to the peace in the world, to being a better human being, as a better member of society. By transgressing, if we take these precepts either formally or even if we just decide to use them as guidelines in our life, then when we don’t follow them it only troubles our conscience. So by listening to our conscience we remain guilt free and we can enjoy inner peace. In fact, it is one of the main reasons why all vows are taken to be to have a for the mind to be free of guilt and to avoid having a troubled conscience.
Because deep down we know, having heard the even before we heard the Dhamma, we have some idea of what is beneficial and non beneficial, what is virtuous and non virtuous, we have some idea. Now you’ve heard that the teachings on the law of cause and effect, one knows. So on the one hand, it is great news to know about the law of cause and effect, because by knowing it, one is able to free oneself of all suffering. But now that you know it, when you don’t when one creates negative karma consciously, one’s creating more negative karma. Someone who is like a fisherman who doesn’t know that killing is negative will kill fish and create a lot of negative karma.
So if you if you know about the law of cause and effect and you continue to kill, there’s more negative karma. But without knowing the law of cause and effect, we will never think to stop avoiding things, negative actions. So it’s it’s very liberating to have this knowledge, but if we ignore it, it just creates more. We’re just making ourselves more ignorant, a really gross kind of ignorance. The fundamental ignorance is a mind that doesn’t know, that not only just doesn’t know, it distorts what is there, then because of that, then we can have this really gross ignorance that really doesn’t want to know and rejects what is true, even though deep down we may feel it’s correct.
So if all of these five precepts are very positive things, they add joy to our life rather than by following them, they add joy to our life rather than deprive us of any kind of supposed freedom that we think that we should have. As one Kagalama, Katharine Rinpoche said, There is a tremendous experience of joy in being able to live in a dignified and disciplined way. So by following the five precepts, we live a life which has dignity and discipline, so that gives a great deal of joy to our life. So by taking the vow or at least determining to avoid killing in our life, and then by abstaining from that, it helps us to realize the sanctity of life. And by putting effort into observing that in our daily life, really putting a lot of emphasis on that, that we avoid killing others as a very principle of our life, then by doing that gradually we develop a very sympathetic non violent attitude towards all living beings, which affects all our behaviour and it helps, it develops loving kindness, it is the practice of loving kindness, and it develops loving kindness more and more.
By abstaining from stealing we develop this wonderful quality in our mind of contentment, the ability to share with others and the ability to practice generosity, the mind that wants to give to others, that actually enjoys giving to others. And And again, by abstaining from sexual misconduct we develop contentment, we promote contentment in our life, and it’s the basis for happiness, joy in family life, if one wants to follow that path. By abstaining from lying we become trustworthy, people trust us, we become dependable and therefore respected and admired. And because of that, we can develop these qualities not from some kind of ego point of view, but as a way to benefit others. The more people respect and admire us, then we can help others in meaningful ways.
But if people don’t respect us and don’t admire us, then we we can’t even if we want to help others, our ability to help is limited. So one way to gain that respect and admiration is by becoming trustworthy, dependable, by being an honest person, having integrity. By abstaining from all different kinds of intoxicants we develop a clear mind, our mind becomes alert, we have a basic sanity in our life because following all sorts of intoxicants really disturbs the mind, brings about all sorts of kinds of mental disturbances. And by avoiding these things we become reliable and so on, able to carry out our responsibilities in life. So someone who, by observing the five precepts, is a form of generosity.
Because such a person who is observing these vows either formally or these practices either informally or as vows, such a person is not a threat to anybody’s life, is not a threat to anybody’s property, is not a threat to any family or the rights or well-being of others. And so such a person bestows fearlessness, benevolence and love on all beings. So these are wonderful things to do. This is exactly what the Buddha wants us to do. So this is something very practical, even from an ordinary worldly point of view, to observe these five precepts.
If everyone or the vast majority of human beings in society were observing these five simple practices, there would be so much more peace in happiness, in family life, in communities, in cities, and in countries, and throughout the world. If we look this why there’s so many problems within relationships, families, and societies, communities, neighborhoods, cities, is because people aren’t observing these five basic things. Five very simple basic things. So this is a great offering to to the people around us, our our own neighborhood, communities, cities, so on, to live like this. And of course, if we live like this, really live like this in a very sincere, committed way, then it’s a great model for other people.
And and our society needs role models, valid role models, not movie stars and and and football heroes. I mean, okay being a football hero, but if you look at the lives of some of these football heroes, it’s not all that amazingly inspiring. So worthwhile thinking about, especially for those people who have been Buddhist for some time, worthwhile to think about following these precepts more and more in one’s life, and especially making a really strong commitment to the path by taking these vows, at least one, two, three, four or five. This is definitely the method that is pleasing to all the Buddhas. So okay.
Are many levels morality is a very basic part of the spiritual life, and especially in the Gelug tradition, which means the virtuous tradition, Geluk means virtuous tradition, that morality is is emphasized a great deal as the basis of the path. This is one of the great great contributions that Lama Tsongkhapa, the inconceivable great bodhisattva Buddha Lama Tsongkhapa contributed to Tibetan Buddhism to emphasize the need on at all levels of the path to observe morality as carefully as one can. In other traditions there’s a great emphasis on doing the four preliminary practices of prostrations, making mandala offerings, Vajrasattva and the guru yoga or refuge. But Lama Tsongkhapa argues that if you keep creating negative karma, then you have to keep doing the preliminary practices all the time because you create the cause to purify things. But if you observe pure morality, there’s no need to do the preliminary practices.
So this is the emphasis in the Gelug tradition, avoid negative karma, lead a very moral life, then there’s less and less need to do the preliminary practices. Of course we still need to do the preliminary practices because we have imprints from the past, but one if we do the preliminary practices and then keep doing creating negative karma, there’s the need to do more preliminary practices. You understand? No. The preliminary practices about So one can do the what in Tibetan they call it ngöndro, the preliminary practices which are preparation to doing tantric retreats.
So one can do those and purify some past negative karma. But so you do those in this life, but you keep doing creating negative karma in this life, so in the next in another life when you become a human being and lead the dharma, which may be billions of lifetimes in the future, then you have to do the preliminaries again, and again, and again, and again. But if one stops creating negative karma, then there’s no need to do the preliminaries at some point. And as I try to point out, the whole of the Buddhadharma practices is contained within the observing the law of cause and effect. It’s the practice of renunciation, one has to renounce one’s attachment to immediate pleasure and immediately solving problems, one has to renounce that in order to practice the law of cause and effect.
And it is the practice of loving kindness and compassion for oneself, and it’s the basis for developing love and compassion for others. It is the practice of wisdom. Nāgārjuna himself, and if if anyone knows, Nāgārjuna should know, since it’s Nāgārjuna who explained the wisdom teachings of the Buddha, reintroduced them into this world and explained them at a in a way that more and more sentient beings could understand. But actually if we read Nāgārjuna, we can’t understand Nāgārjuna. So the great bodhisattva Candrakīrti explained Nāgārjuna’s teachings in a more simple way, but even Candrakīrti difficult to understand, so that’s why Lama Tsongkhapa explained the teachings of Candrakīrti and our kind own teachers explained what Tsongkhapa said.
Anyway, Nāgārjuna said, until we develop the right view, the wisdom realizing emptiness, we should take as our right view the law of cause and effect. Until we’ve developed the highest right view, we should take as our right view the law of cause and effect. So in the different levels of practicing morality, at the beginning, as a being of initial scope, we avoid creating negative karma, the ten non virtues. In the middle scope we realise the importance of observing morality more important and more strongly, so there one can take the vows of individual liberation. Of course we can take them right now, But the more we develop the wish to renounce saṃsāra altogether and achieve liberation, becomes that’s especially when the thought to take vows becomes stronger and stronger.
That we can take them now because the thought may we we may understand already the value of them, at least the value of the lay precepts. And then and then in the path in the highest scope of so the pratamoksha vows are for our own benefit, but then when we enter the higher scope, then we take the bodhisattva vows for the benefit of all sentient beings. Because the pratimoksha vows are basically about controlling our speech, our body and its speech with the purpose of indirectly controlling our mind, right, of subduing the mind that way by controlling our body, avoiding sexual misconduct, killing and stealing, then this is controlling the gross negativities of our body and indirectly starting to subdue the delusions that motivate that. Also by controlling our speech, we’re working with the delusions. But then with the bodhisattva vows, we’re actually making vows that are controlling our mind directly.
But if we haven’t decided to control our body and speech, then how can we take the vows, the bodhisattva vows? So this is why at the end of the middle scope teachings, talks about the three higher trainings. If we want to achieve liberation, we have to engage in the three higher trainings. The higher training of morality, in other words not just avoiding the ten non virtues but taking vows very strongly and which leads to the higher practice, the higher practice of concentration where we can develop calm abiding, and having calm abiding we are then able to develop the higher wisdom, the higher practice of wisdom that leads to destroying ignorance. So this is the path to liberation.
But in the context of the lamrim teachings, the teachings of the path to enlightenment, these are taught as things that we practice in common with the path to liberation. Developing the basic renunciation of the things of this life and then developing the great renunciation of all of saṃsāra, these are practices that we do in common with the path to liberation. That is not our goal, we are not trying to achieve liberation. We are trying to achieve enlightenment, but in order to achieve enlightenment we have to do the practices those practices that are in common with the practices that lead to liberation, just as our goal is to get to Kathmandu, it’s not to get to Bodh what do call it? Bodhah or just to go down the hill.
Unfortunately I don’t like that example because we have to go down the hill. In the path to enlightenment we don’t go down anywhere. But anyway, since we’ve got stuck with that example, so to get to Kathmandu we firstly have to go down the hill to Kopan village, and then but that’s not our intention to stay there. And then we walk to Bodha, so we have to get to Bodha, but it’s not our intention to stay at Bodha. The reason we’re going to Bodha is to get to Kathmandu.
So on the path to enlightenment we share these practices in common with the path to liberation, but it’s not our goal at all to achieve liberation as such. Our goal is to go beyond that. Well, our goal is to no. I should put it this way. Our goal is to achieve we do have to achieve liberation from enlightenment, but our goal is not to rest there in that state of nirvana, because in that state we can’t perfectly benefit others.
While we’re in an arhat, in a human body, we can go around teaching loving kindness and compassion and teaching how to achieve liberation to others if we want. But then when we when our mind leaves that body, the contaminated body, our mind goes into this blissful state of nirvana where one is not conscious of any sentient being whatsoever. So then from that point, an arhat is no benefit to anyone at all. The arhat mind is not harming any sentient being at all for sure and can’t because it’s pervaded by love and compassion, but it can’t benefit anyone. So we don’t want that state.
We don’t want that. What we want to do is to be able to benefit all sentient beings because we can, because we have Buddha nature. So now we now start the presentation of the great scope, the most amazing motivation thought that any living being can possibly generate. This unbelievable, inconceivable thought, which is that I am going to become a Buddha to benefit without exception every single sentient being throughout the countless trillion billion gazillion universes that exist. I myself alone will become a Buddha to benefit all of them, to repay the kindness of all sentient beings.
This is like totally mind blowing science fiction thought. But it’s not fiction because it’s possible, because we have Buddha nature, and it’s achieved by the power of familiarity step by step. First step, first big step, renounce the things of this life. Next big step, renounce all of saṃsāra’s pleasures, the saṃsāra perfections, because they’re just ultimately unsatisfying. And having done that, then we can direct our mind, our mind is completely free then to dedicate all our energy to benefiting sentient beings, all mother sentient beings.
Śāntideva says in the Bodhicharyavatara, a guide to the bodhisattva’s way of life. He says, Just as a flash of lightning on a dark cloudy night, for an instantly brightly illuminates all. Likewise in this world through the might of Buddha, a wholesome thought rarely and briefly appears. So in this world, even as a human being, it’s very rare to generate a completely wholesome thought free of the eight worldly concerns. And that thought, believe it or not, arises through the enlightening activities of the Buddhas influencing us, and we generate these virtuous thoughts.
So it’s a miracle to generate a totally comprehensive, complete, perfect, pure virtuous thought. So it’s even rarer to generate Bodhicitta, which is the greatest virtuous thought. Śāntideva says that even the thought to relieve living creatures of merely headache is a beneficial intention endowed with infinite goodness. It’s incredibly wonderful to think of relieving just the headache of other living beings. So compared to that, what need is there to mention the wish to dispel the inconceivable misery of every sentient being?
And wishing every single sentient being to realize boundless good qualities. This comparison is inconceivable. There’s no way to compare the thought to relieve the headaches of all sentient beings to them, which we’ve never thought. I don’t know. I’ve never thought of before meeting the dharma.
Now I try to think of it but it’s just like a little thought, a little bubble rattling around in the mind, but before meeting the dharma, I mean the idea of even relieving all the headaches of sentient beings or human beings never occurred to me. Partly because I was totally obsessed with my own headache. It never occurred while I was having a headache, how wonderful it would be if no no sentient being had a headache. Never occurred to me. To even even say the words, even even just as words, let alone to actually feel the meaning of the words never occurred to me.
So to generate the thought how wonderful if all sentient beings could be free of all headaches is an amazing thought, totally amazing. Even even if it’s not possible, doesn’t matter if it’s possible or not, just to generate that thought how wonderful that would be, is an inconceivable thought to have. I mean, we can all say it, but actually to feel it, to actually think it in the depths of our heart is amazing. Just totally amazing. So then to think not only how wonderful if sentient beings could be free of headaches, but all kinds of pains of body and mind, and and all the causes of it.
How wonderful if they could be completely free of all of it. And not only that, to think how wonderful if if they had every possible happiness, every possible good quality. And really it doesn’t matter if these things are possible or not. What an amazing mind to want that for others. And Śāntideva says, do even our fathers and mothers have such a benevolent intention as is towards us?
And actually they don’t. Our fathers and mothers love us, but they’ve never thought for us to be completely free of all suffering because our fathers and mothers don’t understand what all generally speaking, some fathers and mothers here may be Buddhists and know, may be bodhisattvas, but generally speaking, the average mother and father doesn’t understand what suffering is and what real happiness is. Our moms and dads want us to get married, have two point five children, a lovely house with hot water system, and a nice television set, and lovely wall to wall carpet, and a nice car, and a nice garage, and a lovely garden, and a nice lawn mower, and we have a nice job with nice friends, and we go on nice holidays to nice places where there aren’t nasty people, and that’s what our mom and our parents want us to do, and we believe all the right things, and dress nicely, and have nice haircuts, so we don’t embarrass everybody, don’t embarrass the family and make everything upset, and we marry a nice girl or a nice boy who has a nice religion, know, come from a nice family. That’s what our parents generally want.
And they want it sincerely because that is happiness. If you do those things, we will be happy. That’s what they want. And wouldn’t it be nice if everyone did that? So our parents have not this thought That for us to be totally free of all suffering and all the causes of suffering.
This is not a criticism of mothers and fathers, Buddhists are not criticizing mothers and fathers, please don’t misinterpret it that way. Buddhists love mothers and fathers. We are encouraged to love our mothers and fathers more and more. I’m just trying to get this point. Then Śāntideva goes on to say, Do even the gods and all the wise people have this?
Does Brahma have it? So for us it’s maybe difficult to relate to Brahma but anyway. He says, If those beings have never before even dreamt of such an attitude, even for their own sake, how would it ever arise for the sake of others? This intention to benefit all beings, which does not arise in others even for their own sake, we’ve never even generated the thought to perfectly benefit ourselves, let alone others, This is an extraordinary jewel of the mind and its birth is an unprecedented wonder. For this mind to be born in that for this thought of Bodhicitta to be born in our mind is an unprecedented wonder.
And it says that this is the most virtuous thought that we can possibly generate, the most powerful, the most virtuous, all encompassing thought that is possible to generate. Because also Śāntideva gives the example that any other virtuous thought is like a banana tree, that a banana tree or banana plant, when it grows it produces some bunches of bananas and then it dies. And then that’s it. It produces just one crop of fruit and then it dies. But the thought of Bodhicitta, that virtuous thought, once it grows in the mind then it produces crops of fruit again and again and again and again.
It never stops bringing these beneficial results. It just doesn’t like any other good karma we create, it brings one result and that’s it. And then it’s finished. But when we generate the bodhicitta mind, from then on continuously good results come. And even when we’re asleep, we’re creating virtuous karma, the causes for happiness in the future, once the bodhicitta mind is generated.
Through it, all our negative karma begins to be purified. Once the bodhicitta thought is generated, because it is so virtuous, all, absolutely every kind of negative karma begins to be purified. So it is an inconceivable wonder, but it is possible. But Bodhicitta, this mind seeking enlightened, bodhi, bodhi means enlightenment, citta is mind, so that’s sometimes why it’s called bodhi mind, it’s the mind seeking enlightenment. It’s not the mind of an enlightened being, but it’s the mind seeking enlightenment, wishing to achieve enlightenment.
So this mind is not just compassion, it is not even great compassion. It is something inconceivably greater than either of those thoughts. And as I said before, many people sort of once they meet Buddhadharma and hear this word start throwing it around all over the place and anyone who’s nice becomes has Bodhicitta, and anyone who’s nice becomes a bodhisattva. The bodhisattva is someone who’s generated Bodhicitta. And as I said before, in some ways it’s kind of nice to say that, but in another way it’s degenerating what Bodhicitta really is.
Practicing Bodhicitta is not being nice and kind or even generous or moral. It’s far, far greater than that. I mean, it involves those things, but in such inconceivable way. Giving away things is nice, is good, is virtuous. Bodhisattvas can give their body away.
They take their eyes out and give them. They chop off their arms and give them happily, happily. Hard to believe that this is what it says in the teachings, especially when you’ve realized emptiness doesn’t matter. So it’s an inconceivably different state of mind. It’s quantum leap between being nice and compassionate and even deeply compassionate than to having Bodhicitta.
Because one can have incredible compassion for a group of people, but that is not Bodhicitta. Bodhicitta is having an overwhelming compassion for all sentient beings, including the worst people that exist in the world. Like a bodhisattva has maybe I shouldn’t give the example because it sounds like it’s anyway, for Hitler and Mao Zedong and Stalin, a bodhisattva has overwhelming compassion for these people, wants them to be enlightened right now, and will do anything, a bodhisattva will do anything virtuous, anything virtuous to make sure that person, Hitler, they are doing it right now. There are millions of bodhisattvas helping Hitler, Mao Zedong, Stalin to become enlightened right now. Now that’s Bodhicitta.
It’s a little bit different than being a nice person, much more different, greater than being nice and kind. But we have that potential in us, there’s no doubt that we have this potential within us simply because we have a mind. Even though our mind is very disturbed by anger, attachment, hatred and distinguishing friend, enemy and stranger, it’s all superficial, it’s all superficial. And below that there is Buddha nature that is never affected in any way, can never be affected. All we have to do is allow it, just get rid of the junk that is suppressing it.
In the teachings that the Buddha gave that lead to liberation, that lead only to liberation, the Buddha never taught anything about Buddha nature. So there’s the belief that only even in those teachings they do talk about the existence of bodhisattvas because they also recognize that Siddhartha was a bodhisattva. But that presentation of the path to liberation, there was the presentation that only a very few exceptional beings can achieve enlightenment, and Prince Siddhartha was one of these. But it’s unbelievably rare thing to be able to do. In the Mahāyāna teachings the Buddha explained, because of the very nature of the mind, every sentient being has the Buddha nature.
Not just one or two exceptional beings, it is the very nature of mind, and every sentient being can achieve enlightenment. And all the arhats who went to achieve nirvana, one day they will wake up from their bliss and follow the path to enlightenment and become Buddhas. So why not start now rather than going to nirvana, spending all that time hanging out in that space, not doing anything, wasting all that time, why not just start now and decide to follow the bodhisattva path to enlightenment?
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
- The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- Gelug
- The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
- individual liberation
- The liberation from cyclic existence achieved by a hearer (shravaka) or solitary realizer (pratyekabuddha), as compared with the full enlightenment of a buddha sought in the Mahayana. LYWA
- pratimoksha vows pratimokshasamvara (Skt); so thar gyi dompa (Tib)
- The various levels of individual liberation vows for lay and ordained, including the five lay vows, and the novice vows and full ordination that monks and nuns take. LYWA
- preliminary practices ngondro (Tib)
- The practices that prepare the mind for successful tantric meditation by removing hindrances and accumulating merit. LYWA
- tantric vows sang ngag kyi dom pa (Tib)
- Vows taken by tantric practitioners. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.