Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 12 02 Tape 65 Side 2

43 min · 4,355 words · 2 December 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 12 02 Tape 65 Side 2
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Continuing a graduated path teaching, the speaker explains that wisdom realising emptiness arises from many causes and conditions, including merit and a qualified teacher’s blessing. The talk covers the five aggregates as the basis of the merely labelled self, the argument that independent phenomena cannot exist, and the conventional and ultimate truths.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-12-02

Duration: 43 min

UUID: 3f27bbd4-6677-4835-8f22-32c685d66525

Words: 4,355

human rebirth, we have the chance to recognise how we ourselves create our own suffering and prevent ourselves from experiencing true lasting happiness. And we can recognise that in our confusion trying to achieve happiness just for ourself, we cause harm to others and don’t bring any real benefit. But by reversing the self-cherishing thought and cherishing others more than self, then we actually bring about our own genuine well-being right now and are creating the causes to experience the highest happiness in the future. And we can do this because we can reverse this self-cherishing thought by realizing how all sentient beings have been our mothers and unbelievably kind life after life. So, the more we understand that, we generate this wish to achieve enlightenment, to benefit ourselves and repay the kindness of all beings.

And to achieve that state, we have to gain all the realizations on the path to enlightenment. And, to be able to follow that path correctly, we need to understand the path, how those realizations are gained. So, comes from listening to the presentation of the graduated path. So, we can think that for the benefit of myself and all beings, I will listen to this presentation of the graduated path to enlightenment. As we generate this thought, we can perhaps imagine in the clear space in front of us, Śākyamūni Buddha as the very embodiment of all objects of refuge, surrounded by countless Buddhas and bodhisattvas and other holy beings, and especially also our own teachers, and think of ourselves surrounded by all the different beings of the six realms who experience so many different kinds of torment, suffering, confusion, and just occasionally the illusion, the appearance of happiness.

And especially we think of our parents on either side, family and friends behind, and those we dislike in front. Then we can offer, if we wish, the mandala to open our mind to receive the blessings of the Buddhas, so that our mind can become the Dharma and the Dharma can become the path. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, the Supreme Assembly. By the merits I create by teaching the Dharma, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings? So we can spend a little time focusing on the breath to develop some concentration which we can use to apply to listening to the graduated path teaching.

Thank you. So, as Śāntideva says, Everything the Buddha taught was for the purpose of being able to develop the wisdom, realizing the empty nature of all phenomena of self and of one’s — now I’m using self in the sense of the person and all phenomena as they actually exist, because through that we destroy ignorance, which is the source of all suffering. When we develop wisdom, the wisdom consciousness realizing the true nature of all phenomena, which includes one’s own self, sorry, one’s own person, then it’s like a light being turned on in a room, and the darkness is instantly dispelled. And once it’s completely dispelled from the mind, that darkness of ignorance can never come back.

There is no way it can reestablish itself in the mind. So, is a graduated path to realizing this wisdom beginning with developing the basic level of renunciation, giving up our obsession to the things of this life. Because by doing that, that itself, in some ways, starts to lessen our self-cherishing, which perpetuates self grasping wrong view. In practicing this basic level of renunciation or non attachment, then also it involves observing the law of cause and effect very carefully, as much as we can, and this is the basis, this is the very basis of beginning to eliminate the obstacles that prevent us understanding emptiness, and it itself is a part of the process of realising how everything arises depending on many, many factors, which is the key to realizing emptiness. Why we remain trapped in saṃsāra, thinking it is something really pleasant, Like in the teachings it says, We ordinary people think that this world and all the samsaric existence is like a huge pleasure park that we can wander around in.

It’s all sort of very beautiful and just there for our pleasure. But it looks like that, but that’s not how it is in reality. So, why we remain trapped in saṃsāra, wanting to get out, is because we believe what appears to our mind is true. Whatever appears to our mind, we grasp at it as being real, unquestionably like that. That’s why we follow everything out there, get attached to it, develop aversion to what interferes with that process.

And so, we remain trapped in Samsāra. But, do have, all the time, have this basic wisdom, our intelligence, that is able to begin to distinguish the nature of things more and more clearly, if only we let ourselves do it. So, if we simplify our life and do things both in an external way and in internal way. By meditating, we can create the conditions for our mind to be more calm and clear and see how we create all these illusory appearances. So, there’s many things we need to do to realize this wisdom because this wisdom, like everything else, doesn’t truly exist.

But because it doesn’t truly exist, we can create the causes and conditions for it to exist. So, it arises, this wisdom arises depending on many factors. So, if we generate those factors in our life, in our mind stream, then we will realize it. There’s no escape. If continue to generate all the causes and conditions, etc, that give rise to wisdom, wisdom has to arise.

There’s no choice. Just like if all the conditions and causes and conditions gather together, a rainbow appears in the sky. No choice. But if the causes and conditions, all the aspects, not just the causes and conditions, but all the other aspects of the dependent arising aren’t there, the thing can’t exist. No way, no matter how much we wish it, it won’t arise if we don’t generate correctly all the factors necessary.

But if we do, wisdom has to arise. There’s no choice. So, we have the ability with our precious human rebirth to at least begin to gather all the factors necessary for this wisdom to arise in our consciousness. And we have the optimum situation, the optimum conditions to gather together all those factors. So, we have to understand the teachings correctly to gain a correct conceptual understanding first, which will lead to then eventually a direct perception of the way things exist.

But, it is not just an academic process. As I mentioned yesterday, there are academics teaching emptiness in universities, are teaching a completely wrong view. There are also academics who seem to have quite a good understanding of the traditional presentation of emptiness, but it doesn’t benefit their mind, because it’s something distant from them. It’s just a philosophy that they don’t allow it to touch their heart in any deep way. It’s just mental entertainment.

And this is basically because one of the essential factors to actually realise emptiness, to experience rather than just have it as a conceptual understanding, is we definitely have to purify our mind of all the various disturbances and to accumulate merit, a lot of merit. In the Prajñāpāramitā Sūtra itself it says, So long as merit has not been made sufficient, long one will remain unable to realize the truth of voidness. While we don’t have sufficient merit, we will never realise the truth of emptiness or voidness, the way things exist, even if we have the correct intellectual understanding. It does depend on merit. And the best way to get this is relying on a qualified teacher and receiving the blessings of such a teacher.

But in order to receive the blessings of the teacher, one has to please the mind of the teacher, the Guru. How does one please the mind of the Guru? What is the best way to please the mind of the Guru? It’s by practicing the Dharma sincerely, not by giving lots of money and things like that. Certain Gurus like that, but they’re the wrong ones.

So, as I mentioned yesterday, in presenting the teachings on emptiness, firstly, the tradition is to talk about the emptiness of phenomena, and then the emptiness of the person. But as a practice, one first realizes the empty nature of the person, and then through that one realizes the emptiness of phenomena. But basically, the emptiness of the person and the emptiness of phenomena is the same thing. Just the object is different, but once one has realised one, one will realise the other, because everything exists in the same way. Lama Lhundrup did mention this, but maybe people, especially the newer people, may not have quite understood.

But in studying the teachings about emptiness, then it’s always done in relation to meditating on the five aggregates. So, someone asked me to go through these a little bit in more detail. I don’t think I can do very much more than other than maybe repeat what I’ve already said and maybe it becomes a bit clearer. The aggregates The term aggregate itself means a collection, a heap of something. A collection or a heap of something.

Just using this term itself is a way to cut our mind, the grasp of things as being something solid and one, as one thing. But in fact, the validly existing I, the validly existing person, is dependent on many things, five different things, and each of those things itself is made up of many things, five heaps. The I that does exist can only exist in dependence upon these five factors, and each of those is not one thing, but a heap, a pile, a collection of many things. So, the first heap, the first aggregate, is the form aggregate, which is this body. But I have mentioned before, one can also include in the form aggregate the objects of the five senses of the body.

So, sights, sounds, objects of touch, smells, sounds can be included in that first aggregate of form. Particularly when we’re meditating on trying to discover the refuting object, the object to be refuted, the ‘I’ which is the object to be refuted, the form aggregate is really just referring to this physical body. So, that’s the first aggregate. Then the other four aggregates are all aspects of the mind. The mind is what we label on these other four aggregates.

Anyway, just go back to the form aggregate for a moment. Of course, this body, in one way we say is one thing from a very ordinary point of view, but this body is made up of many, many things, many parts, and each part is made up of many things. There’s blood and bones, anyway, we all know that. Also, it’s all changing all the time, constantly changing. Just as the body is labeled on all these many parts, so our mind is labeled on the other four aggregates, the first of which is our feelings, the aggregate of feelings.

So, are physical feelings and mental feelings. But the physical feelings, of course, also are mind. But they’re physical feelings in the sense that they are arising through the body consciousness. And then there are the mental feelings. And there are three kinds of feelings: pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral.

So, we can have pleasant, unpleasant, neutral bodily feelings and then pleasant, unpleasant, neutral mental feelings. As very ordinary untrained people, when we have an unpleasant bodily feeling, then our mind, mental consciousness, also feels aversion to that and also generates an unhappy, unpleasant mental feeling. But as a Dharma practitioner, especially following the mind training teachings which are included in the Bodhicitta teachings, one can have an unpleasant bodily feeling, but the mental consciousness can then, through the understanding that this comes from karma and many things too long to explain now one can actually the mental consciousness can, by observing that unpleasant physical feeling, actually feel happy. There can be pleasant mental feeling. Observing the unpleasant bodily feeling, that is possible.

So, there is the aggregate of feelings, which arise with every moment of thought. Every time one of the sense consciousnesses is operating, the five sense consciousnesses and also the mental consciousness, in every moment of perception or conception, there is feeling that goes with it. As soon as the eye consciousness sees something, there is a feeling. When the ear consciousness hears something, there is feeling. When the mental consciousness thinks something, there is a feeling associated with It’s called this is called one of the omnipresent mental factors.

It’s always there. And always means always, even when we’re dying and dead. Because when we’re dead, we’re alive. We’re alive in another realm when we’re dead. When we’re dead to this realm, we’re alive somewhere else.

So, feeling never stops for a moment. It may be very, very subtle feeling, but it’s still there. So, that’s the aggregate of feeling. Then the aggregate of discrimination or recognition is the function of the mind that is in its most basic level, is just being able to distinguish this from that. This is round and this is square.

This is me and that’s you. On the basis of that very basic recognition, one can have all sorts of false and correct and false types of discriminations. This is good, this is bad, this is beautiful, this is very beautiful, this is ugly, very ugly, this is inferior, this is superior. All sorts of kinds of discriminations can arise on the basis of this basic kind of ability to recognise different things. It’s a very fundamental aspect of the mind if we can’t recognise something, then we can’t know anything at all.

A friend of mine works with computers and working on artificial intelligence, and she was explaining to me how there are programs I don’t know, this was a few years ago now, so maybe it’s far more advanced. But she was explaining to me that for a computer working these experiments, for a computer to recognise this as being different from that takes millions of calculations, something I may be exaggerating. But, yeah, it’s an enormous number of calculations the computer has to make to be able to recognize that this is not that. Yeah. So, our mind does it in a flash.

We also probably do millions of calculations also. So, if we can’t if the mind that is a fundamental aspect of knowing, of being able to distinguish something from something else. And then on top of that, we make many, many distinctions, right? Valid and invalid distinctions between things. So, there is the yeah, where are we?

Then there’s the compositional factors. We always skip that one because it’s easier to explain that last. Then the next one, what is called the fifth aggregate, is the six primary consciousnesses. There’s the primary eye consciousness, ear, nose, tongue, body, and mental consciousness the primary consciousnesses. Just generally what this means is that the primary consciousness of each of the six senses simply knows its object in a very, very general way, in a very primitive way, simple way.

Then, there are many other mental factors that come in that give all the other aspects of what we’re experiencing, such as the feelings come in, but they come in at the same moment with the primary mind, in the same moment as the primary mind experiences its object, either a shape or like the primary mental eye consciousness just experiences shape and colour, that’s all. But in the moment the primary eye consciousness experiences shape and colour, instantly there is feeling, which is a secondary mental factor, and there’s all sorts of discriminations that come in and labels, Oh, this is red, this is pale red, and thoughts that this is beautiful color. Many, many other secondary minds come in to be able to fill in the whole picture for each of our sense experiences. So, all these secondary mental factors that come along in the train of each primary consciousness, they fit into this fourth aggregate of compositional factors. As soon as the mental each consciousness operates there’s contact, there is discrimination, there is intention, there is the movement of the mind to that object, and then there can be virtuous thoughts generated of love, compassion, and so on towards the object, or there can be the negative thoughts of anger and attachment and so on.

So, these are all secondary minds that are in this fourth aggregate called compositional factors. So, compositional factors includes everything about the mind which is neither feeling, discrimination, or the primary consciousness. So, it’s every other kind of thing. It’s our perceptions, our conceptions, all our different kinds of thoughts, fantasies, like visualizations, and so on, positive and negative, all go into that category. Every aspect of the mind except feelings, which is an aggregate in itself, which is an aggregate in itself, and the six primary consciousnesses, which is also an aggregate in itself.

So everything else about the mind, every other aspect of mind goes into this fourth aggregate of compositional factors. So these are the five aggregates which are the actual basis for the merely labeled I, which does exist. It doesn’t truly exist, but it does exist. So, Lama Lhundrup made the point that everything that can exist can be divided into the person and phenomena.

So, the person is the I who has a name, and phenomena are the five aggregates. Especially when you include in the first aggregate of body all the objects of the body, the five sense experiences the whole world. So then one has, in that way of looking at the five aggregates, five aggregates are phenomena, include all phenomena, and then there is the person. So everything, all phenomena and the person, everything that actually does exist, the Buddha taught its actual nature is empty of true existence. It’s empty of existing from its own side, with its own power, with its own characteristics because if yeah.

Because that’s the only way things can exist. They can’t exist any other way. It is logically impossible for something to exist independently. Because if something existed independently, then nothing could react with it in any way whatsoever. If this for example Lights, cameras, actually.

Anyway. No, I can’t do it. Anyway, if this glass truly existed as an independent phenomena, you wouldn’t be able to cast a shadow on it, which I can’t at the moment. But anyway, but you can cast a shadow on it. But if it was truly independent, something couldn’t touch it, contact it, change it, because as soon as you put a shadow on it, you can put a little bit of a shadow there, it’s changed.

It looks different. But if it was independent, even the shadow couldn’t fall on it. Its color couldn’t change in any way. If it did, it’s not independent. And also you couldn’t move it, you wouldn’t be able to move it if it was an independent phenomenon.

If you can move it, it’s not independent. If it’s independent, it has all its power to do what it wants from its own side, but it has no power to do that, to remain the same, to remain in the same place and remain the same. It has no power what from its own side whatsoever, to do anything. It is not independent. But if it was independent, nothing would move, nothing would change at all, nothing could affect it.

You wouldn’t even be able to touch it. So, if we think about I mean, one has to try and I’m sorry if I’m sounding like I know what I’m talking about, because I don’t, but some vague idea, but please don’t think I’m claiming that I really know what I’m talking about. I’ve just heard these things, and I have some little, you know, I hope I have some inkling of what it’s about. But it’s really worthwhile to try to think what an independent phenomena means, really means, and how could it exist. One could start to understand, get some idea, that an independent phenomena simply cannot exist.

But the way we see things would imply, it would mean that they were independent. But the point is we don’t really understand the full meaning of what independent means and all the consequences. This is the beauty of the Mādhyamika consequence school. The people say something and the Mādhyamika consequentialists say, You think that means that, but if you say that, what it really means, what it really implies is this, this, this, this, and this, and you get to a logical absurdity. If you watch the monks debate, sometimes, you know, they debate and debate with one poor little guy there having to answer all the questions, and they’re all jumping around and slapping their hands, and at some point, they all laugh hysterically because they make the monk say all these things until you get to the point where you say something totally ridiculous.

Yeah? The logical consequence of holding your position, you have to someone says, Is this something like that? And someone says, Yes. If that’s the case, what about this? And you say, Yes.

And then you say, Yes. And then you end up saying something, Yes to something which is even obvious to oneself, is totally absurd. You start to see the consequences of believing or thinking, this is how it is. So, this is Nāgārjuna’s method. It’s not the only aspect which some people think that all the Mādhyamika Prasangikas do is insult other people’s opinions.

They don’t. They just point out their faults, and they do establish their own view, definitely. Is this too fast? Yell out if I get too carried away. So, mean, is just scrambled egg presentation of emptiness, sorry, just whatever comes into my mind.

So, in trying to have the right view, the Buddha taught about the two truths, that everything has there is the conventional truth and the ultimate truth. So, ultimate truth and these two things are different, they’re separate, but they also are not they don’t contradict each other. They are different things, but they do not contradict each other and they apply, and both truths apply equally to everything that exists. Everything that exists has a conventional truth to it, a conventional way of existing and an ultimate way of existing. Or a relative truth, a conventional truth, but as someone pointed out, is generally the terminology that is used, but the actual correct term that one should use is truth for a concealer.

Truth for a concealed mind is the conventional truth or the relative truth. Truth for a concealed mind means truth for a mind where the ultimate truth is concealed. When the ultimate truth is concealed from a mind, there is the conventional appearance, the relative appearance, which is valid. There are also What we think are conventional truths, which are invalid, they are not actually conventional truths. If one gets drunk and sees pink elephants wandering everywhere, this is not a conventional truth.

It is just a total hallucination, a delusion completely. It has no validity whatsoever. But when we see a table or a pillar, this is it is conventionally existing, relatively existing, it is existing validly for a mind that is not seeing the ultimate truth. So, some things we perceive aren’t even conventionally existing, such as pink elephants, horns of rabbits is a traditional Buddhist example of something that doesn’t exist at all. Horns exist, rabbits exist, but there’s no such thing as the horn of a rabbit.

Yeah. It’s something we can think of, but it simply doesn’t exist. And like in our culture, Father Christmas is a good example. Father Christmas oh, you know, Santa Claus does not exist. The Easter Bunny does not exist.

I’m sorry to tell you folks that the Easter bunny does not exist. So, but we all have ideas of that, you know, of Santa Claus and the Easter Bunny, but these things do not exist. The Tooth Fairy, things like that. But then, the things that do exist, the things that validly exist, either they exist conventionally and ultimately. Everything has these two natures.

Everything that does exist has these two natures. This glass has a conventional existence and an ultimate way of existing. The conventional way of existing is that it is existing as a dependent arising. It is existing by arising dependently on many factors. And that’s the only way it can exist.

It can’t exist any other way. But at the same time, there is the ultimate way this is existing, which is that it is empty of true existence. It is empty of it is completely empty of existing from its own side, with its own power, with its own characteristics, and all those things. It is empty of being truly existing, inherently existing, substantially existing. All those things are synonymous, but it is existing.

And these two things go together they’re different, but they go together in the one thing. This glass conventionally exists as a dependent arising, ultimately it is empty of any true existence at all. And when one actually understands, realises, the conventional truth of it as a dependent arising, one will be able to realise its ultimate nature. But while we are experiencing the conventional appearance, the conventional truth of a phenomena, we cannot experience its ultimate nature. Only a Buddha can do that.

This is a unique quality of Buddha mind. Even a tenth level bodhisattva cannot see, experience, the ultimate nature of this glass as he or she is experiencing its conventional appearance. Bodhisattvas and arhats and so on can experience the ultimate truth of this phenomena in meditation.

Key terms in this teaching

conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
graduated path lamrim (Tib)
A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
omnipresent mental factors sarvatraga-chaitta (Skt); sem jung kun dro (Tib)
One of the six groups of mental factors, these accompany every main mind. There are five: feeling, discrimination, intention, mental engagement and contact. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top