41 min · 4,362 words · 9 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk opens with a refuge and bodhichitta motivation and a short breath meditation, then urges listening with a clear, focused mind. It explains saṃsāra as mind controlled by delusion and karma, and describes the six desire realms, the form and formless realms, and the cycle of rebirth. It closes by explaining that death leads directly into the next life, shaped by the mind’s state at the moment of death.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-09
Duration: 42 min
UUID: b03fbd40-e1a3-4d5c-9bd8-2cd5691cc34e
Words: 4,362
So the refuge and bodhichitta prayer is on page eighteen. So, since there is this continuous and natural desire to experience real happiness free of all suffering. And we’re driven by this consciously, unconsciously, all the time, and the methods that we’ve been following up to now haven’t really worked. It’s worthwhile considering finding a new method. And this method that we could consider is the method employed by all those beings who attained enlightenment.
And that method is to rely not on the external world but on the inner world of our mind, and to overcome the disturbing thoughts in our mind and discover the positive potentials of our mind and develop those. The more we do that, the more we can begin to discover and experience less and less suffering, confusion and problems in our life, causing less harm to others, and we begin to develop a sense of calmness, peace, a sense of meaningfulness in our life that we can build on more and more so that our love, compassion and all positive qualities develop, which eventually bring about the greatest happiness, continuous undeclining happiness in our own mind, but also enable us to bring about those incredibly positive states in the minds of all living beings. So to follow this path of inner mental development, we need to understand that path, be completely familiar with it in an unmistaken way, and to gain that unmistaken knowledge, we need to hear the teachings again and again. So for this reason we can generate the thought that for the benefit of myself and all living beings, I’ll listen to this presentation of the Buddhadharma.
As we do so, again, when I say this, is one’s choice of course to do it or not, but one can visualize the Buddha in front of oneself as the object of refuge, inspiration, guidance, and to think of all sentient beings surrounding oneself who have suffering of one form or another and who need my help. Especially we think of our mother of this life, our father of this life, the mother of this life on our left, father on our right, family and friends behind us, and the people we dislike or who dislike us directly in front of us. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, the Supreme Assembly by the merits I’ve created by practicing the Dharma. May I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings? So, as well as having the right motivation for listening, it’s important to try to listen with a focused, concentrated mind.
So now we spend just a short time focusing our attention on the breath, firstly sitting in the correct position as much as possible so that we feel comfortable to remain still for this time. Then direct our mind to the experience of the breath as it comes in and goes out, allowing the mind to become calmer and clearer in order to notice that subtle sensation arising, changing as the breath comes in and goes out. Okay. Thank you. So, just to remind you to try to listen free of the faults, the three faults, or the faults of the three kinds of pots: the upside down pot, the dirty pot, the leaky pot, and also to try to listen with this thought sorry, doesn’t sound very nice, all of us, we are all sick, we have this terrible disease, affliction of the mind called ignorance, and we try to listen with the thought that the founding teacher, the Buddha, is the great doctor who possesses the cure to this terrible disease, and that cure is the Dharma, the teachings.
The Dharma is the medicine to overcome this disease, and the only way this disease will be overcome is by taking that medicine, meaning to practice the Dharma moment by moment as much as we can. So far, I’ve tried to introduce some basic ideas of what is meant by mind in the Buddhist context, and how the mind, although it has this Buddha nature that has always existed because of the very nature of mind, that Buddha nature has always been obscured. It’s been obscured by the disturbing thoughts, the imprints of those disturbing thoughts, and also by the negative karmic imprints that are generated by these disturbing thoughts. So, if we develop some understanding, some belief, some feeling using that word feeling in some vague way that we English speakers use this word Maybe I should make this point because strictly speaking according to Buddhist jargon, feeling is referring to pleasant, unpleasant, neutral feelings that arise with every moment of perception. But in the English language we also use feeling in a very vague, woolly way, which I sometimes use, which I probably shouldn’t.
Sometimes I think in the English language we use the word feeling when we say I think something when we have some logic or at least we believe we have some logical reason for believing something, but we say feel when we don’t really have any kind of we can’t put our finger on why we believe something or whatever, but we think it or believe it. So, I use the word feeling in that way. I hope it will become clear when I’m using the word feeling in the strict Buddhist sense and when I’m using it in the usual English sense of the word. If not, I’m in trouble. Is this the same in French?
No? So, having heard this presentation, one may feel, think, begin to believe that there is some truth to it, that it corresponds to something that one is experiencing, knowing already to some extent. Then one of the basic things that I’m trying to myself present, and which is of course a fundamental theme of all religions, which is something I indicated at the very beginning of the course, is that if all these things are true, then what we really have to consider and think about is to use this life, not just for what some experiences that we can gain in this life, to try to squeeze as much pleasure out of this life as we can for ourselves and to avoid various problems of this life, but we really have to consider that our mind goes on. And if we don’t take care of our mind in this now, in this life, then our mind may go on into greater suffering. So then, having this perception, we start to develop what is one of the basic spiritual motivation sorry, state of mind which is beginning, starting to give up our obsession with this life.
If we think this life is all there is, then we are totally obsessed naturally with this life and we block out the possibility of future existence. But if we start to consider the possibility of the mind going on, not the body, of course the body doesn’t go on, but the mind going on, then we can begin to develop this very interesting state of renunciation, of beginning to let go of our complete obsession with this life, to be a bit more soft in our approach to this life, to let go of that so that we can use the energy of our life, of our mind, to develop this bigger perspective that uses this life, of course, experience happiness in this life, but not at the expense of creating the cause of suffering in the future. Because the mind is going on. So this is one of the most fundamental things, I think, to think about in this course, is there just this life or is there the possibility of future existence? If there is mind as the Buddha taught, then definitely future existences go on, reincarnation occurs.
This formless mind reincarnates, it goes into flesh, reincarnates, it goes into this soft, flowy stuff again and again. Why? Because this is the most fundamental attachment we have. We may think, I don’t have many attachments. I’m not really attached.
What was he talking about with all this grasping it and stuff? But we have this incredible attachment to this body, and not even to this body, we have this incredible attachment to the idea of body, of having, of being something solid, because that’s what we’re used to. Even though what our fundamental reality is, is just this insubstantial, clear clarity and knowing mind. We’ve never directly experienced that. What we’ve always experienced is this solid stuff, being something solid, concrete, or what we think is solid and concrete, that’s been our experience life after life.
And so we have this unbelievable attachment to being in the flesh, and therefore the mind grasps at that solidity again and again. We reincarnate. There’s chili con carne, chili with chili with meat, there’s reincarnate. Yeah? Mind in meat.
We like putting our mind in meat again and again and again. That’s what it’s all about. That’s what reincarnation is. Grabbing at another piece of meat. This time, we managed to grab quite a good bit of meat, a human piece, and have a human consciousness, a human brain, nervous system and therefore our mind is able to operate at a human level which is really a fantastic level of mind to operate but it’s not the only one.
So this is what I’d like to talk a little bit about now, especially for the new people here. Some people, according to the questionnaire, not only have never heard any Buddhist teachings before, there are a few people here who haven’t even read a word of Buddhism. So, there are some more surprises. You thought you’ve heard some strange things so far? Then there’s really a lot more strange things to come.
So there’s this thing called saṃsāra. It’s another jargon word that we throw around all the time when you become a Buddhist. So, saṃsāra is not a place as we may think. You may have there’s Samsāra over there, there’s a depiction of Samsāra over there, the wheel of life. That picture actually originates, the idea of it actually originates, there is a story of how this image originated with the Buddha himself.
There was once a king who was given a present, a very precious present, by another king of India. So the king who received the present said thought, Well, I have to give something equally good in return, otherwise I’ll be in trouble, and then you have another war or something. So he actually went to the Buddha, this king who was a Buddhist, went to the Buddha and said, What can I give in return to this king? So the Buddha said, You give this picture that illustrates the wheel of life, and he described how to present it. So this is and then the Buddha said, This image should always appear in all Buddhist monasteries in the front gate and there should always be a monk who describes the meaning of the wheel of life to everyone.
The story goes that the king who received this was very happy with it. Samsāra is not a place. Samsāra is our mind, is the limited mind. Lama Je Tsongkhapa, the founder of the Gelug tradition, defined saṃsāra as the mind controlled by delusion and karma. This is what saṃsāra is.
And the mind that is controlled by delusion and karma, even though it has this Buddha nature, this enlightened quality, because of being controlled by delusion and karma, it circles around and around in various life after life, in various different states of awareness and experience. So, the human experience is only one state of saṃsāra, it’s only one state of this limited mind controlled by delusion and karma. So, this world is, you can say, a samsaric place. It is not saṃsāra, but it is a samsaric place because it is created by samsaric mind. It’s created by the minds of all sentient beings controlled by delusion and karma.
So, the human realm is just one state that our mind can experience when it’s controlled by delusion and karma. Maybe, again There are three possibilities for our mind. Our mind can be controlled by delusion and karma, which is what it is now and always has been. Our mind can become free of delusion and karma and enter the state of nirvana, but in that state there is still the subtle imprints delusion or not karma, but there is still the subtle imprints of the delusion there. But that mind of nirvana has gone beyond saṃsāra, is no longer in saṃsāra.
Our mind has freed ourselves of the causes to be bound by delusion and karma and therefore to cycle in these limited suffering experiences. And the other possibility that our mind can exist in is in the state of enlightenment. The great nirvana, not the little nirvana of self liberation, but the great nirvana where there is nothing whatsoever limiting the inconceivable qualities and potentials of our mind, where our mind has this incredible wisdom and all pervading compassion and awareness of every sentient being. So these are the three major states our mind can exist in or experience. So we have never experienced nirvana, we have never experienced enlightenment, what we experience is samsaric mind.
Our mind is controlled continuously, twenty four hours a day, life after life, by delusion, afflicted thoughts and karma. So, that mind one of the major experiences it can have is this human level of experience. When the mind generally we can describe the human mind we shouldn’t say human mind because it sounds like it’s something separate, but this human level of mind, human state of mind as having a great deal of freedom where the delusion and karma, are there but they not so heavy as they could be in other states, but they are also more than can be in other situations. It’s this relative freedom And particularly our intellect, our intelligence, is functioning quite well. And because of that, as a human being, we have the ability to discriminate between what is meaningful and what is meaningless, what is suffering and what is happiness, what is the cause of happiness and what is the cause of suffering.
So, according to the Buddhadharma, although there are states of mind within saṃsāra that are much more blissful and interesting than the human state, kind of more spectacular, really quite mind blowing. Some Hollywood movies just don’t compare to the sūtra descriptions of some other realms that the Buddha talked about. It is really only in the human state that we have suffering which we can recognise, we have a certain amount of suffering which we can recognise, and we have the ability to recognise its cause. And also, we have a certain amount of happiness and we can begin to recognise the causes of that. So the human situation is an incredibly fortunate one because we have suffering and we have happiness, so our suffering can motivate us to do something to achieve more happiness.
And we have the freedom to do so because our mind is not so weighed down by suffering and ignorance and confusion. There is some, sometimes quite a lot, but our mind isn’t really strongly obscured. It’s obscured but not completely and not all the time. So within the samsaric mind, the human realm is the best state to be in. From the point of view I should make this clear from the point of view of getting out of saṃsāra, where do we need to be to get out of saṃsāra, which is the best of the realms, situations to be in, to create the causes, to go beyond delusion and karma, the best one is to be a human.
In other words, to follow the spiritual path to liberation and enlightenment, the best situation is to be a human being. If we want just to have happiness, temporary happiness, the human realm is not the best one. There are other realms the Buddha taught that exist, and these are called the for want of a better word, are called the god realms. So well, it’s unavoidable to go into the details, the threes and the sixes. Samsāra, samsaric mind, limited mind the basic point about samsaric mind, because it’s controlled by delusion and karma that we create, no one else has created it, it’s controlled not by outside, it’s controlled by our own delusion and karma, limited by our own delusion and karma, is basically a suffering state, suffering in a sense that it’s unsatisfactory.
Within saṃsāra it is not possible to achieve pure, lasting happiness. It is possible to achieve pleasure and the illusion of happiness even for long periods of time, but it doesn’t last. That is why saṃsāra is suffering unsatisfying, and why the Buddha taught us that we need to get out of it. We are in a prison, our mind is trapped, and we may not even know it, but we are trapped and we need to get out of it, At least for our own sake, but especially from a Mahāyāna point of view, we need to get out of this trap, this jail, this prison, this concentration camp because we need to help others escape. While we’re trapped, everyone else remains trapped.
But if we get out, we can show others, all the beings that we’re connected to, how to get out. And there’s all these suffering beings who are actually in worse jails, worse concentration camps than we are right now, and that they have no way to get out. But we can help them if we free ourselves first. Samsāra can be broken up into three basic levels of experience. There is what is called the desire realm, where the mind is principally controlled by desire attachment.
Then there is what is called the form realm, and then there is the formless realm. So the form realm is I don’t know, maybe I should just try and describe the desire realm first. So within the desire realm that we as human beings are in, revolve in, that the desire realm itself has six states, possible states, that our mind can go in. So one of them is what we’re experiencing now, the human realm. Another realm is the animal realm.
One’s mind can sink down into an animal level of awareness and experience. The mind can sink down even further into a more suffering state which is the realm of what are called hungry ghosts or spirits, different kinds of clutching ghosts. And then, unfortunately, the mind can sink down even further into the most obscured suffering state of mind possible, which is called hell, of which there are various kinds. There’s not just one kind of hell, there are many. I know many people get attracted to Buddhism because Christianity has got hell, so we’ll get rid of it, don’t want that, become a Buddhist.
Then you discover, paid all this money, flew all this way. I’m sorry. But this is something that we do to ourselves, we create hell in our own mind. This is what the Buddha taught. Then, within this desire realm, beyond the human realm, there are these more blissful states which is the god realms of the desire of the realm of desire.
So these gods, these beings, which we have been in the past, and we can create the causes to be them in the future, when our mind is in that state we experience incredible pleasure which goes on for an extremely long time. But because it’s a karmic state, the karma runs out and we sink down again to be a human, an animal, a spirit or into the hells, and so we circle around and around and around. For your information, there are six kinds of desire realm gods. Six kinds. Some of which, it is said, can come to this earth sometimes, they come and visit.
We can’t see them, most human beings can’t see them, maybe some clairvoyant people occasionally see them. Some people, clairvoyants, contact these beings thinking they are God because they’re incredibly pure, they’re clairvoyant, they have all sorts of qualities and so on. So there are six kinds of these god beings. Some are like the Greek gods, are also what are called the demigods I forgot that category. There are beings who live a long time, have an incredible pleasure but not quite as much or nowhere near as much as the gods, and they can see the gods and they’re unbelievably jealous of them, and they’re always fighting with them, just like is described in Greek mythology, an indication that beings all over the world have seen much more than we see now.
They never may have saw the complete reality, but they certainly saw something beyond what we see and believe now. So that’s the desire realm. There’s the hell realm, the spirit realm or ghost realm, the animal realm, the human realm, and the six levels of the desire realm gods. This is the desire realm of saṃsāra, and it’s basically controlled by the dominant delusion in those experiences is desire. Beyond the desire realm is the form realm.
So the beings there traditionally called gods. They are the desire realm gods, but beyond them are the gods of the form realm. Form in this state is extremely subtle, it’s not a gross physical body like we have, but more like a body of light. And these beings exist with unbelievable blissful minds for millions and millions and millions of years. But their mind is still controlled by delusion and karma, but the delusion is not active like it is in the six realms of the desire realm.
The imprint is there, the potential is there, but it is not active. So these beings, which for want of a better word are called gods, we don’t have to take that word too concretely, that the mind in that state experiences this incredibly refined bliss for an enormous period of time. And there are seventeen levels of that. Seventeen, yeah, seventeen different kinds of form realm states. Beyond that, the Buddha said, there is the formless realm where, again, the beings are godlike beings, where the mind experiences an even more and it’s the formless realm where even this subtle body of light is without any kind of physical form, generally speaking.
Actually, even there there is a very subtle kind of form, which is like just the wind energy, prana, prana energy, and the mind is in an incredibly refined state where the bliss is even greater than in the form realm and lasts for even longer periods of time, inconceivable periods of time, but it comes to an end because it’s a karmic situation, just like our human experience is a karmic situation. We are alive because we’ve created a certain amount of karmic energy which is running out day by day. One day that karmic energy will run out and death will come. What is death? The appearance of this world will stop.
Just in one moment it will stop because there’s no karma to experience it anymore for us. It will go on for other people, but in one moment our mind will not be able to experience a single thing of this earth because the karma has gone. And in the very next moment our karma will force our mind to have a new experience, something else will appear to our mind which we will grasp at as being real and we will be completely involved in it. So what that experience is in the next moment after death depends on what delusion and karma is active in the last moment of consciousness. Or the lack of delusion at the Tonight, right now, hopefully we’re all awake.
And as today goes by, we will get to a point sometime tonight where there will be the last moment of waking consciousness, and in the next moment there will be the consciousness of sleep. In the very next moment. In the same way, we will get to a point at some time we do not know when, when there will be the last moment of consciousness of this life. And then, in the very next moment, the very next moment, there is the consciousness of the next life. It’s just the next moment, generally speaking.
Because there is the Bardo state, as all good Tibetan scholars know, there is the intermediate state. But that, roughly one can say, is the beginning of the next life. I don’t have to get too technical about this. The appearances of this life, all of them stop in one moment. That is death.
And in the very next moment a whole new set of appearances, experiences is occurring. And they will depend on that last moment of consciousness of this life because the next moment, the next life, is just the next moment. The next life is not millions of years away, it’s the next moment. It’s just the next moment. One moment we’re alive in this body, in this world, and the next moment we are somewhere else completely.
In one moment we cannot grasp onto anything of this life. And so, just as in this life today’s mind affects tomorrow’s mind, tomorrow’s mind affects the day after’s mind, In the same way, what we do in this life, whether we generate lots of delusion or lots of virtuous thoughts, affects will determine the state of mind we’ll be in at the time of death. And that will determine what karma will ripen, will be strongest, at the time of death. If our mind is in a virtuous state, it’s almost impossible in a very strong virtuous state, it’s almost impossible for a negative karma to ripen which could then throw us into a suffering rebirth. It’s almost guaranteed that some virtuous karmic imprint will
Key terms in this teaching
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
- The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- Gelug
- The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- six realms
- The general way that Buddhism divides the whole of cyclic existence; there are three lower realms (hell, hungry ghost and animal) and three upper realms (human, demigod and god). LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.