Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 27 Tape 52 Side 2

44 min · 5,096 words · 27 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 27 Tape 52 Side 2
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains how delusions arise from harmful friends, false explanations, fixating on objects, habit and exposure to desirable images. It teaches that delusions can be subdued by understanding cause and effect, their suffering and dependent nature, and by watching thoughts without feeding them. Meditating on impermanence is presented as a key antidote to attachment, and subduing is distinguished from suppressing.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-27

Duration: 45 min

UUID: 7b4437b4-54d2-4dde-b4eb-73461a212b4c

Words: 5,096

Admiration and so on, and don’t want criticism and blame, and we want people to admire us and think we’re we’re cool or good or fashionable or this or that, then then our mind gets corrupted. So of course, the aim of practicing the Buddha Dharma, especially in the Mahāyāna tradition, is to develop love and compassion for all sentient beings and benefit them. But right now we have to be honest and admit that we can’t do that. So the point here of avoiding negative people, just as it says when one takes refuge, one of the commitments is to avoid people who are antagonistic or critical of religious practice and so on. We don’t avoid them with a negative mind, but we avoid them out of compassion for ourselves, to protect our own mind so that we can develop the strength of mind that at some point, we can be with such people and help them.

But until our mind is really strong, then it’s not so wise to mix with such people very much. So as it or as it says in the teachings, the harmful friend, the so called evil friend, doesn’t have to have horns and come around saying, I am your evil friend. They appear as a good friend. The person who, when we’re depressed, says, Oh, you know, it’s okay, let’s just have a few drinks, you know, let’s go out and have a good time, and all this kind of thing. So it doesn’t appear evil at all, it appears as as fine as as someone being kind to us, but actually, in reality, they’re encouraging our delusions.

But the more we mix with such people, our delusions stay there and get strong. So just check out for oneself, you know. The third the third sorry, the fourth factor explained as explanation bad explanations, meaning listening to false theories about the nature of our mind and delusions, say either all the delusions are okay, that we should follow them, or teachings or philosophies or psychologies or whatever that say that certain delusions are okay and that we should express them. If we don’t express them, it’s very harmful for our health, our physical health, our mental health. As I’ve often said, this is quite maybe not always, but this is often said by certain types of psychology that it is important to express one’s anger, that if one doesn’t do it, one will get sick, physically sick, mentally sick.

So if we listen to these kinds of explanations, then we feel it’s okay to be angry, so we will get angry. I recently read a newspaper report in the Herald Tribune, where some scientists checked two different groups of people. One who followed psychologists who said expressing your anger was extremely good, and another group who followed the psychologist who said it’s not good to express your anger. So the people who followed the psychologists who said, you should follow your anger, strangely enough, the scientific results said these people got more and more angry, more and more upset, and more and more unhappy in their life. How interesting.

It’s a scientific proof. Now the numbers are in. The scientists who said Buddha said it two and a half thousand years ago. You just have to look at your mind. It’s painful. You know, there there are so many convincing arguments that people can say that things are like this.

What is up? What is act? That this is reality, but there’s so many convincing arguments, delightful arguments that say this is okay. And, of course, our whole culture says that following desire attachment is essential. You’ll go mad if you don’t follow your desire attachment.

But if you look at this world, maybe it is already a little mad with desire attachment. But anyway, by following wrong explanations, this can encourage our disturbing thoughts to arise and to arise frequently and strongly. Sorry. This is what is it? There’s this old joke that, well, there’s the standard belief that if you give up sex, you live longer and healthier, but there’s the joke that says, it all just seems like that. Another cause for our delusions to arise strongly is just paying attention to them.

Even if the object isn’t there, if we keep thinking about the objects of our afflictions, the objects of our desire, the objects of our anger and jealousy, then of course, again, the delusion arises. And sometimes it can arise even more strongly than if the actual object is there, just by thinking about something again and again. Possibly, we may have all had the experience of we have someone we dislike, and then we think about them, and then we we we fantasize some situation where they say something or do something, and we get completely angry with that. It hasn’t even occurred. It’s just something we’re not remembering something that happened.

We fantasize about what they could do. They’re so bad, they’re likely to say this or they’re likely to do that. And we then we get caught up and totally angry then. Complete fantasy, just by thinking about the object. And of course, there’s no mention no need to mention about desire.

We’re all experts in in in fantasizing about the people and objects of our desire. They don’t have to be present, we just think about them, and bingo, the desire is there. So wrong attention can be just our own thoughts, or talking about certain things, like if we talk about the situation that has happened starting from September eleventh, then it can generate you know, if we talk about it in the wrong way with the wrong people, then we can generate lots of anger and so on. Or but by talking about anything, else, can generate lots of desire or jealousy or pride. Then by watching reading things, this can generate the delusions by seeing movies, television and so on, magazines, all of these things can cause our disturbing thoughts to arise and to arise strongly.

So, we need to recognize these things and if we want to minimize our delusions, then we should avoid these things. If we don’t, the delusions arise. Even magazines with advertisements in, they’re designed to make us desire the object. And the photography, this amazing photography, that makes the thing so unbelievably beautiful, shiny, it’s all spotlighted and isolated. And shops, shops are the same.

They’re designed to make this one thing look so unbelievably appealing and beautiful and necessary for one’s happiness. So if we go window shopping, desire arises. If you look at magazines, you know, there are certain magazines that are designed to produce desire. Yeah. Don’t don’t have to mention what.

Yeah. So if you look at them, unless you’re an Ārya being, desire arises. And yes. And then the final way that our disturbing thoughts arise is just by habit. We we in this life, because of all the other things meeting the object, being with friends, deluded friends, and so on, always thinking about these things, we create mindlessly, we create the habit, and then there’s that energy that pushes us.

We develop this instinct to just kind of always go in the same directions. This is what our afflictions do, they just keep us traveling in the same old patterns again and again and again. And so the more we follow the habit, the stronger the habit becomes. It makes it easier. So just as the the habit of of of following the delusions and and creating negative karma gets easier and easier the more we do it.

Also, the more we try to practice Dharma do virtuous things, we create virtuous habits which then also become easier and easier. At first it’s difficult, but it gets easier and easier because of habit, by the power of familiarity. So these are the ways, the conditions or causes for our delusions to arise. So at the beginning of this life, we may have very few imprints of a particular delusion in our mind, But if we let ourselves get caught up in all these situations, then we can put more imprints so that by the end of our life, the delusion is even stronger than when it started. Or we may start out in this life with very strong imprints of certain delusions, but because we avoid the conditions consciously or we just don’t our life doesn’t go in that direction because of good karma or we actually put effort into avoiding it, at the end of our life, the delusions are less, the imprints are less.

Okay. Thank you. Take a ten minute break. So, as well as knowing what gives rise to the delusions, disturbing thoughts, some general methods, basic steps that help us to subdue our delusions when they arise is, as I mentioned, just knowing the suffering results, following them. And of course, even if we just believe in this life, then we can see that the delusions cause suffering in the moment, because the delusion by nature is not seeing reality as even the ordinary reality, then when we follow the delusions we make many mistakes.

And the mistakes can have effects that carry on throughout all this life. But what strengthens that so that can give us some energy not to follow our disturbing thoughts from just a worldly point of view, but what gives us greatest energy to try to overcome our delusions comes from of course understanding or believing in understanding and then believing in the law of cause and effect. That all the delusions act to generate negative imprints that ripen as suffering and much greater suffering in future lives than the suffering that comes in this life. And combined with that is again some understanding or belief that the mind as an effect of following the delusions could be thrown into a non human realm, a much more suffering realm in a later time. And all this requires some understanding of the nature of our mind, so the more we look at our mind and try to understand its nature, this helps And again, just the more we really are able to identify our own disturbing thoughts as being in the nature of suffering, disturbing the mind, shaking the mind, then if we think about how cause and effect works, how can something that disturbs the mind act as a cause to produce a positive, a pleasant effect in the mind?

It just is not logical. And then to know knowing benefits of subduing the delusions, that we have a peaceful mind in this life, a happy life, also we don’t cause harm to others in this life. We’re not creating the cause for future suffering. If we subdue our delusions in this life, we can have a peaceful death, a good rebirth. All our Dharma practitioners practices will be easier, they’ll be more stronger, more effective, and especially it will be easier and easier as we subdue the disturbing thoughts to be able to develop some degree of, you know, of a strong degree of concentration, single point concentration, if we’re able to achieve that, then all our Dharma practices can become unbelievably powerful and effective.

For example, if one has developed single point of concentration then if you read a Dharma book then you’ll remember it. You’ll remember it all, you won’t forget it. Especially if you read one or two times, you’ll be able to read it very quickly because there won’t be anything distracting the mind and you’ll recall what you read because one’s mind was focused on without distraction. But we read books and when we close it we can hardly remember what we’ve read. Oh that was great, it was great but I can’t remember why it was great.

Also with the same with Dharma teachings, we walk out and say, Oh that was fantastic wasn’t it? And then someone says, Well what did they say? And well, it was kind of about, you know But it was great, it was really very inspiring but I can’t remember it anymore, you know. But if we if you just imagine if we had some degree, real degree of concentration, then we would remember these things very strongly. So that comes from having a subdued mind.

By the way, just to try to point out everything is interconnected, when Lama Lungta was talking about the wheel of life, the depiction which comes from the Buddha. So here’s the wheel of life, there’s the lord of death, the wheel of life, and here’s the Buddha up here pointing, saying kind of he’s saying, there’s a way out of all of this, this is what this means, you know. This is our mind. This is this is a picture. This is a mirror of our mind.

Yeah? When we look at an ordinary mirror, see our body. This is a mirror of our mind, while it’s controlled by delusion and karma. Here’s the Buddha saying, Go that way. Liberation and enlightenment are that way.

And here is this statement that the Buddha told the painter to write on the Thangka for King Udayana, which is, Do not create even the smallest negative action. Put effort into accumulating virtuous actions. Subdue the mind. This is the teaching of the Buddha. All of the Buddha’s teachings are included in those lines.

It says something like, Do not create even the smallest negative action, put effort into accumulating virtuous deeds, and subdue the mind. This is the teaching of the Buddha. So, again, maybe just my propaganda, then sometimes people here feel that what is being said is just too heavy and too depressing. What did the Buddha suggest as the best present? This king was given this incredible pile of jewels, or this jewelled ornament, and the Buddha suggested what was an even more valuable present to give was a depiction of suffering.

Tell the man, tell the king, the kindest thing you can repay him is tell him about suffering and how you cause your own suffering. So the Buddha has been incredibly kind because he taught us not about the little bit of suffering in this life, but the entire horrendous suffering of saṃsāra that we could experience. If we don’t know about it, we can’t avoid the causes. If we know about it, we can avoid the causes. Also, a basic requirement for subduing the delusions is developing the confidence that we can do it, that it is possible.

One way this can come about is by doing the meditation of looking at thoughts, where one sits and tries, without getting caught up in the thoughts, trying to sit there objectively as much as one can observe the thoughts arising. If one doesn’t get caught up in them and therefore doesn’t feed them, if we don’t feed them and energize them, then they abide in the mind, they stay in the mind for some time, but then they fade away. Another one may come, but the same thing, if we don’t feed it, if we don’t pay attention to it, like in the sense of getting caught up with it, it fades away. Because it doesn’t truly exist from its own side, we can start to see it’s arising in our mind depending on causes and conditions. And if we don’t feed those conditions by paying attention, it has no power from its own side to exist.

And it actually has, as I tried to say earlier in the course, none of our delusions, although right now they appear to be very powerful, they are powerful because we give them power. But actually, they have no valid base. There’s no valid basis for any of the delusions. Their basis is ignorance, but that ignorance itself is an invalid mind and it can be eliminated. Whereas, all the virtuous thoughts, all the virtuous minds have a completely valid basis which is the fundamental mind itself, which is clear and knowing and empty of true existence.

And that never changes. But just by seeing that our thoughts themselves are impermanent, we can at least subdue them. They’re dependent on causes and conditions, Therefore, if we don’t perpetuate the causes and conditions, we can at least modify them. At least we can understand that. And if we understand the root cause is ignorance, then if we don’t perpetuate ignorance, the delusions can’t exist.

And what is the cause of ignorance? A previous moment. A previous moment of ignorance, going back into beginningless time, beginningless mind. Every time we follow ignorance, we create the cause for another moment of ignorance, a later moment of ignorance. But, we are able to get to the state where we don’t engage in our ignorance so completely and strongly.

We can cut the continuity of it. Just by doing the meditations we’ve been trying to do the past few nights helps that process. If we just really are able to generate definite doubt that what is appearing to my mind is real, that cuts the continuity of ignorance, or at least starts to. So, many reasons, we definitely can subdue our delusions even though we may feel like I am the most deluded person in the world. But this thought, I am the most deluded person in the world, that I isn’t real.

There’s no such person. That itself is the refuting object. Because when we say that, we also feel that person really exists from its own side and is permanent. There is no such person to be found validly. You can find the snake, the appearance of the snake, but there’s no snake.

So you say that appearance isn’t valid. It’s just a mistaken appearance. So we can find the appearance of this truly existing person, but that is not valid. It’s not a valid mind that is experiencing that. So, we can subdue our mind.

We can, all of us. No matter how disturbed we are, we all have the potential, the capability, the capacity to subdue our mind, at least to begin to subdue it. And even subduing the mind a little bit is beneficial. Especially because we have the precious human rebirth and the dharma, the method, and through the power of familiarity, first appears, it appears but it’s not actually it appears to be difficult through the power of familiarity, everything becomes easy. It says in the teachings, to kill a living being to consciously kill a living being requires an incredible amount of energy because it’s such a negative thing to do that one has to generate an incredibly strong mind to consciously kill another being.

But through the power of familiarity, it can become very easy. But at first, to consciously take the life of another being in full consciousness of what one is doing requires great energy. But through the power of familiarity, it becomes very easy. Practicing the Dharma may first appear very difficult, but through the power of familiarity, it becomes very easy. Until it becomes un you know, it would be unbearable not to do it.

A bodhisattva has no choice but to practice the Dharma. It would be utterly unbearable to do otherwise. Without creating unnecessary publicity for Lama Zopa Rinpoche and whatever. But it is true from the experience I’ve had of being with Lama Zopa Rinpoche, for Rinpoche, it’s unbearable to go to sleep. It’s just unbearable to go to sleep.

He never tries. Rinpoche never gives the appearance of doing anything to prevent going to sleep because for him it’s a waste of time. It’s a complete waste of time. Unless he wants to go to sleep to do some special tantric practices perhaps. But otherwise, just sleeping is a waste of time. So, Rinpoche never goes to sleep like we go to sleep.

We even try to create the causes and conditions to fall asleep earlier than necessary. So, we can reach that stage. It’s possible because we have Buddha nature and we have all the conditions now. So, course, are delusions in our mind, hopefully, we can learn from this course that that is not our true nature, that there’s more in the garden of our mind than these disturbing thoughts. Much more, which is much more interesting and powerful and beneficial.

So, we just have to raise this confidence that we can do it. Even if we fail, we just try again. And even if we fail, we try again. And even if we fail, we try again. And even if we fail, we try again because we will succeed.

There’s nothing There’s no other choice. To follow the delusions is not a choice. It’s just not a choice. Once we start to have even a hint of what they are, there’s no choice. So then, there are the specific antidotes to apply the delusions, the disturbing thoughts.

Because attachment is the most powerful delusion, actually, anger is the most negative one, but anger is actually much weaker. It’s much easier to overcome anger than it is to overcome attachment. Attachment is the most powerful of all the delusions. Again, apart from ignorance, there’s ignorance and then there’s all the other delusions. Of all these other delusions, the most powerful one is desire attachment.

The traditional analogy comparing a piece of cloth that is dirty and a piece of cloth that has got an oil stain in it. It’s very easy to wash the dirt out of a cloth, but it’s very difficult to get an oil stain out of the cloth. It seeps right into the cloth, whereas the dirt is just on the surface. Anger and jealousy and pride are just on the surface and are relatively easy to deal with, but our desire attachment is just kind of spread everywhere. So, there’s not one single antidote to attachment, but one antidote, one very powerful antidote to attachment is understanding impermanence.

In fact, as I mentioned before, this is an antidote for all the delusions, but especially for desire attachment, that try to see that whatever object we’re attached to that we desire, it is impermanent. Whatever afflicted desire we have, the object of that is impermanent. It’s not going to last. It has no essence. It’s nothing that we can hold on to.

So, this is something really helpful, important to meditate on so that we can have that mindfulness in our daily life. In this way, if we have this awareness of impermanence and death and less attachment, then we can enjoy, we can experience the beautiful things of life, but with less attachment or no attachment. And then we can let go, you know, we can just have this light touch and enjoy them for what they are without getting obsessed, putting this value on them that they can’t sustain. When we say that I love you, we mean you have to make me happy forever. Right?

That’s why I love you because you’re going to make me happy forever. So, we call this love, but actually, it’s very unkind to say, you are now responsible to make me happy forever. This is just a total inflated expectation that no human, ordinary human being can live up to. Yeah, it’s really an unkind mind to say that. Well, we don’t say that to the person, of course.

We don’t even consciously think it, but that’s that is actually what our desire attachment has. Now I’ve found you, you are going to make me perfectly happy forever. We’re going to live happily ever after. The movie stops there, remember? The movie is usually maybe not so much these days, but in the past, they used to stop at that point.

So this is a huge projection expectation. But, if understand that no one or nothing can make me happy forever, we really understand that, that there can be some pleasure, some happiness, some something, but it won’t totally fulfill, it won’t last. If we are able to relate to people and things with that awareness, that doesn’t have to be suffering or confusion for ourself or the other person. And when things change, we can be ready for it and move on, and hopefully change ourselves in the appropriate way. So, anyway, understanding impermanence is a very important way.

And again, it can’t be just words. Oh, this is impermanent. Got that realization? You can stick it on the But it has to be some deep awareness that touches our heart. So that acts as an antidote.

Just the words don’t have the power to subdue strong delusions. So, again, may try and make this point that with all the delusions, Buddhadharma is not saying that we have to suppress them because that does not work. It works temporarily, but it causes more suffering and problems in the future. The idea is that here is a delusion and It can be anger or desire, whatever you like, or dislike. Why it arises is because it’s depending, it arises, it’s not there.

And then, because there’s these causes and conditions, particular causes and conditions, because they’re operating, the delusion arises. There’s no such thing as a delusion over here, and then there’s causes and conditions, and then the delusion comes along like that. It’s nowhere. The delusion isn’t existing anywhere in the mind or outside anywhere because it just there are causes and conditions. Because those causes and conditions are there, the delusion manifests just like a rainbow in the sky.

The rainbow is appearing merely because certain causes and conditions manifest, arise, and because of that, there’s this appearance. And actually, there’s the appearance of these colors in the sky, but they’re not actually up there. They just appear to be up there because of causes and conditions. Something is existing, but it’s not really existing up there from its own side at all. It just appears to be up there.

Similarly, the delusion doesn’t come from anywhere. Like, here you have a table and now I can put that on there. This was over here, now I’ve got a table, now I can put this on here like that. This is the causes and conditions to hold up this pot. It’s not like that.

Delusion is totally a product, a manifestation of the causes and conditions. It’s not something separate in a sense. Is it yeah. Right? It’s like that.

It’s not like that. It’s like that. If all of these are here, this thing can’t exist. What the Buddhadharma is the way to subdue the delusions is not you can’t repress them because the conditions are here, you know. That just goes down, all the conditions, causes and conditions there, delusion is just hidden, but it’s there, causing suffering.

The whole idea is, in subduing the delusions, is that you weaken the causes and conditions. So even if you change one, it can’t stay the same. If you change two, three, four, it’s gone. It hasn’t been suppressed, it’s just not able to exist. It just simply isn’t able to exist because it has no existence from its own side.

It’s not a thing separate from the causes and conditions. So, what are basically and we don’t have to understand it all totally, but basically the causes and conditions are all our own thoughts, this network of thoughts that we generate, such as anger is good. This is bad, this is bad, and this uncomfortable feeling arises that can’t bear that sense of badness, and so on. And there’s the thought that anger is good, anger will protect me. And there is the thought of a me who can’t bear this and so on.

There’s a huge network of thoughts bouncing off each other which gives rise to anger. And then there is the antidote, which is a whole other set of virtuous, realistic thoughts. So, if we generate those, we can’t generate these at the same time. If we start to generate these, these have to get less because we’ve only got so much energy of our mind. Right?

So, if you generate these more, these get less. If you generate these more, then, finished. Instead of anger arising over here, you have patience arising here. It’s something like that. We’re not trying to suppress but undermine the causes and conditions by thinking, basically just thinking and perceiving in a different way.

And this is what meditation is. We have a way of thinking and perceiving like that. We have the habit of thinking and perceiving one way, which is a way towards what is unreal. It’s away from reality and towards the non virtuous. Sorry, we all do this.

I’m just talking about myself, so I’m not trying to That’s our mind. That’s the habit. So, meditation is generating the habit towards what is real. We can’t see reality completely yet, but it’s moving our mind to what is real, more real, more valid and more virtuous. So, this is what we’re trying to do.

So, if we understand that and do that correctly, we don’t repress our delusions, we annihilate them or we don’t deny. We subdue them. They just fizzle out temporarily. They fizzle out. But they keep coming back because the ignorance is there, the imprints are there.

But it’s the same with ignorance. Ignorance is arising in the same way. It does not truly exist from its own side. It has no power to exist from its own side. The ignorance is arising depending on a whole network of wrong views and habits and perceptions and thoughts.

So, we undermine those, again, ignorance is gone. And when ignorance is gone, then no delusion is possible. Another antidote to afflicted desire attachment is gaining the understanding, the wisdom, knowledge, that understands that the pleasure, the happiness that comes from desire attachment is changeable suffering. It’s not real happiness. It’s not what we really want.

Yeah. It’s somehow frustrating, unsatisfying, incomplete. So if we have had that awareness in the moment that we experience the things that we’re normally habituated to desire and get attached to, then we can still experience these things but with a little bit of less attachment, a little bit more non attachment, less expectation that this is going to bring amazing pleasure and happiness.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top