29 min · 3,111 words · 30 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk teaches that self-cherishing, grasping at a false self, harms us, and that cherishing others is the best way to care for our own mind and wellbeing. It explains that self-cherishing is unskillful rather than evil and quotes Śāntideva on self-importance. The question session covers Buddha nature, beginningless ignorance as the basis of self-cherishing, and purifying the self that seeks enlightenment.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-30
Duration: 29 min
UUID: 0804ba3d-d093-4ce5-b82d-1d885fa7d684
Words: 3,111
For that purpose at all, but just to inspire us and to see, you know, what what is what is this person doing to be like that? Come and what am I doing? Am I doing any any of those things to be like that? What am I doing to be like I am and what is his holiness doing to be like he is? Because he’s a human being also, has human body, has mind, So, you know, by thinking in the right way, we can inspire ourselves to give up the self-cherishing thought, seeing it’s a total disaster, and inspire ourselves to do something, why not try the very opposite?
Since what we are doing is not working, is not really working, and it never worked before, and is not working for anyone else, why not try the opposite for a change? Just even for a little while to see what happens. It would seem like a logical thing to do. And since many people have done that and have gained incredible benefits for themselves and others, that seems an even better reason, an extra reason to try to cherish others more than self. Because when we cherish others more than self, what are we doing to be able to do it really well and perfectly?
On on the one hand, as I try to say, how do we cherish others? With love, compassion, generosity, patience, perseverance, every good quality. We direct it towards others to cherish them, to take care of them. But what takes care of them, this love and generosity, is coming from our mind. So when it’s operative in our mind and when it’s operative very strongly directed to many people, there’s immediate benefit in our mind, in our mind.
And when our mind is pervaded by these good qualities, the I that I actually am, the merely labelled I that does exist, is existing in contented, peaceful, happy way because the mind is in that state. By taking care of others, we take care of our mind and just naturally, I am okay. I’m fine. Everything is okay, automatically. And especially the more we see the benefit of taking care of others, of cherishing others, of not harming others and wanting to develop these virtuous qualities, these strong positive qualities of love, compassion, courage, enthusiasm and whatever, and wisdom, then the more we see how the wrong view of self is getting in the way, we work to get rid of that.
So and the more we do that, the more we are able to experience, come in contact with the I that is existing. And the more we get into that frame of mind, we reduce this wrong view of self. And the more we reduce that wrong view of self, the less we grasp at it and grasp less strongly, then the self-cherishing, that gross self-cherishing itself gets less. So by thinking about others in correct way, we are actually taking care of who we are in the very best way. It can’t be any other way.
When we have this wrong view of self and cherish that, it harms who we actually are. When we cherish others in the right way, it takes care automatically, immediately of who we really are. Because also if we want to cherish others, if we really want to dedicate our lives to helping others, we also have to take care of our body as well, properly. And so if we take care of our body properly, not overindulging but taking care of it, and we take care of our mind, the ‘I’ that ‘I am’ is what is merely labeled on the body and mind. If I have a healthy body and a healthy mind, I am okay, I’m fine, I’m just fantastic in fact.
The way to get that way is to cherish others more than the false self. The more we cherish others more than the false self, the more we cherish we are actually cherishing who we actually are. So every good thing comes from thinking about others and taking care of others correctly. But it particularly means not just taking care of my friends, because that is not cherishing others more than self, because they’re my friends. The mind that just wants to take care of my friends is also that only wants to take care of my friends.
That is also the self-cherishing thought. And at this point I should try to say, explain that most of us here have not been this is obvious, not brought up as Buddhists and don’t have the Buddhist way of thinking and we’ve been influenced by other philosophies and religions and so on. So when we hear in Buddhism it talks about something being bad or negative, then we immediately tend to think evil. This is evil and self-cherishing is evil and therefore since I have self-cherishing, I am evil. But self-cherishing is not good, it is harmful, it is unskillful, but it is not evil.
Maybe some very extreme forms of it maybe deserve the label evil, but I’m not very keen on this label evil at all. It’s kind of dangerous throwing this label around at oneself or anyone. So of course to have self-cherishing for one’s friends is not evil. It’s not evil but it’s not so skillful, so beneficial, not really compassionate, because we can be kind not just to our friends, we can be kind to more and more sentient beings. We have the potential to be kind to everyone, and trying to do that is what is really skillful, beneficial, meaningful.
Just trying to do it, this is what we can do in this life through the power of familiarity. Śāntideva says, Because of desiring benefit yourself, O mind, all the weariness you’ve gone through over countless past eons has only succeeded in achieving misery. Śāntideva also says, another form of self-cherishing or another way of looking at it is self importance. self-cherishing generates self importance. Śāntideva says, Whoever has self importance is destroyed by it.
Such a person is disturbed and has no self confidence. For those with self confidence do not succumb to the power of the enemy whereas those with self importance are under the sway of the enemy of self importance. Whoever has self importance is destroyed by it. He or she is disturbed and has no self confidence. For those with self confidence do not succumb to the power of the enemy, whereas the former are under the sway of the enemy of self importance.
Maybe you need to read this to make it’s in chapter seven verse fifty six. In the same chapter in verse fifty nine Śāntideva says, Whoever seizes self confidence in order to conquer the enemy of self importance becomes a victorious hero completely winning the fruit of enlightenment and fulfilling the wishes of the world. So His Holiness also, as you’ve probably heard many times, is quoted a great deal when His Holiness says, If we’re going to be selfish, then be wise selfish. But when we’re being wise selfish, we’re not really being selfish anyway. So first we have to get rid of this gross self-cherishing thought, then we start cherishing the person that we actually are, that is merely labeled on the body and mind.
And as we do that, in the process of doing that, we can open our mind to be aware that actually all sentient beings are suffering, so I shouldn’t just take care of the merely labeled ‘I’ and allow that merely labeled ‘I’ to achieve enlightenment, liberation and nirvana, need to take care as I’m taking care of myself, I need to take care of all sentient beings, all the kind mother sentient beings. For some of you, you are familiar with this text called the Lama Chopa, the offering ceremony to the spiritual master, was composed by the first Pänchen Lama. Is a verse, verse ninety six, which says something like, Please bless me to see that cherishing all mothers wishing to place them in bliss is the gateway to infinite virtues. May I cherish these beings dearer than my life, even should they rise up as my enemies. Ninety two.
So this is the mind that we can try to cultivate in this life and be mindful of it and practice it, try to put it into practice as much as we can, moment by moment. So this can cut out so much suffering and confusion and bring so much more peace in our life and in our environment more and more. So if you have some questions? Yes. The question is that I said that the self-cherishing thought is a primordial instinct.
So how does that fit in with our mind exists because of a previous moment of mind, and how does that fit in with the fact that we have Buddha nature? Well, the Buddha nature is beginningless, but it’s been beginninglessly obscured by ignorance, and that ignorance has always been there, so the ignorance has always produced, has been the basis for the self-cherishing thought to operate. Because of ignorance, there’s always sorry, attachment, anger and so on, and these combine together as one sort of nasty kind of combination to generate the self-cherishing thought. So it’s always been there, the gross self-cherishing thought. It isn’t part the but it is not part of the basic nature of mind.
No, no, it’s not. Even though it’s always there, it is not a natural part of our mind. Because primal instinct is sort of I mean, has the kind of Oh, I see. Yeah. So I’m using maybe instinct in a different way than the Darwinian idea, and also instinct is like materialist view, maybe of something produced by some chemical in the brain or something for our survival.
But here instinct is just a very strong habit that we followed life after life going back and back. It’s always been there. So we have this beginningless instinct to cherish this illusory self in the wrong way. But we also have the nature of wisdom that can see all the failings of that, how it’s a complete fantasy. Yes?
Is it proper to have? Maybe we can leave it at one at a time otherwise I forget. Is it possible to have a totally wrong consciousness now? Yes, yes it is. But of course it doesn’t last.
No, hopefully. It is impermanent. All of these types of minds, these thoughts are impermanent so they will arise for some time. And then Excuse me? Wisdom?
Yes. A little bit. We have some intelligence which is the basis of the higher forms of wisdom, so the potential of that is also always there. But of course if we follow these totally wrong consciousnesses again and again, then we generate a very strong habit to be stuck in those totally wrong consciousnesses. Is cherishing others just like feeding the ego of others?
Yes and no, but in one sense it doesn’t matter. Okay, okay, okay. All of us have egos anyway, the wrong view of self, you know, and it’s not going to go over away overnight and what can I say? It’s not like every time the self-cherishing thought this is going to be contradictory, but anyway It’s not like every time we go along with the self-cherishing thought that it’s a major disaster, because we can’t stop every instance of the self-cherishing thought now, and we can’t stop every instance of ignorance now. Right?
It’s just impossible. But we can, for ourselves, start to reduce that. And the same in being kind to others, we can’t be kind in this perfect way right now that doesn’t have any chance of causing the ego to shake a little bit. People have egos and whatever. We we can’t do any things that are only how do you say?
That will not in any way increase or maintain their ego because they’re doing things everyone is doing things to maintain their self sense of I anyway. So practically anything that we do, virtually everything we do in this world, kind to kind things to others, will be viewed from the point of this wrong I, this false sense of I. That’s impossible to avoid. But what is better to make the wrong sense of I angry or happy? It’s better to make it happy.
Yes, yes, yes. But slowly one can become more skillful. It’s the only way to do things. We’re living in this very this world of dualities and complexities but that’s how it works. One also sees that with the way the lamas operate, you know, that they give you pieces of chocolate, Yeah?
They give they give us things we like that we’re attached to, and they know that. They don’t take the things away from us. You can’t have that. You shouldn’t have that because you’re attached to that or you’ll get attached to that. They don’t operate like that.
But you can’t do that with most people. We can’t do that with most people. We can’t even do it without I don’t think we can usually do it with our dharma friends. You walk up to a dharma friend and say, I’ll take your watch, thank you, because you’re just attached to it and I’m saving you from your attachment. I’ll take your girlfriend, she’s much too beautiful and you’re just getting too attached or you know?
So out of great compassion, you know, I’ll yeah? It just doesn’t work like that. It can’t you know, even for a dharma practitioner, very difficult. Yeah? Nihilist?
Nihilist, yeah? Yes, sure, sometimes it is possible if we have a very good connection with someone and we can say something, but it’s not often and it’s not easy to do that, to be very skillful like that. So we have to work with people at their level, and because also this can become an excuse not to do anything. You know, I can’t do a perfect action, so I won’t do it. I won’t do anything to help anyone, because anything I do is imperfect and it’s coming from ego and it might increase my ego so I won’t do anything.
So that mind is a disaster, this doesn’t help us. Of course everything that we do starting practicing Dharma is a mess. It’s a mess! That’s where we start, we are a mess. Sorry, just talking about myself.
I’m a mess, so everything I do is a mess. But we have the ability to learn from the mess we make, so we make a little less mess next time. And in making a little less mess, also our mind becomes a little less messy and therefore makes less mess. But that’s the only way it goes. Nothing can be done perfectly with a pure motivation, with pure perfect results like that.
Only Buddhas can do that. Even bodhisattvas make mistakes, until I don’t know which point about when they were up the eighth level or something. I didn’t say there weren’t. A bodhisattva is bodhisattva. The question is, where is the self pity heavy burden mind coming from?
Why is it in the West? I’m not really sure. I don’t know. Maybe it’s just karma. Well I think Lama Yeshe’s advice was the Dharma destroys it, overcomes it, Dharma happiness.
Practicing the Dharma and seeing like I try to say, that we have Buddha nature. Therefore we don’t have to have this kind of self pity heavy burden, me. Comes from also we keep identifying, going back to that. But what we’re trying to see is this there is some other aspect to us in the garden of our mind. There are not just the weeds.
We don’t have to keep identifying with the weeds. There’s something else there all the time, all the time. And it’s just a matter of putting a little bit of effort into doing that. And of course, also Lama’s solution was for people to practice tantra, start out with some basic tantric practices like doing Chenrezig practice, Tārā practice, Mañjuśrī, some Vajrasattva, these kind of things. It is incredibly helpful to counteract this kind of mind that thinks about sin and guilt.
Wondering if there’s a cultural issue there in the sense that it originated from wrong perception of mind. And in many Western societies we live as individualists, whereas in many other societies they have a collective condition. Yeah, sure. Yeah, true, I think that maybe helps reinforce it. But Western mind also was much more communal in the past, we just have somehow broken that down much more quickly than many other societies and civilizations have.
Which two Is? The Is that is like, you know, I am enlightenment. Well, they’re mixed, they’re mixed. It’s for example, like, I try to generate I try to generate the thought that I want to generate Bodhicitta for in order to become enlightened to benefit others. While I’m thinking that, that I that I’m thinking wants to become a Buddha, that is the truly existing I.
But the basis of it is the merely labelled I too. So as the truly existing I is thinking I should become enlightened, the merely labelled I is also thinking that. But it is, yeah? Because the basis of the truly existing ‘I’ is the merely labelled ‘I’. So if the mind is thinking I want to become enlightened, the person that is merely existing is also yeah, It’s difficult to put it in words.
If the mind is thinking that, then I the merely labeled I is aspiring to achieve enlightenment. But we don’t experience it that, we experience it as a truly existing I that’s going to get enlightened. But that truly existing I will not get enlightened because that will fall away at some point. And what is getting so we say I want to get enlightened but what prevents us practicing that, even though we have this thought and there’s some sincerity to it, what makes it so slow and difficult is that the wrong view of I that’s getting enlightened because, you know, we keep saying I want to get enlightened but also this I that wants to get enlightened is actually sneakily cherishing itself, which is an obstacle to get enlightened. So as we purify the view of the ‘I’ that’s getting enlightened, the self-cherishing gets less and so it becomes easier to get enlightened.
Did that make sense?
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
- A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
- merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
- The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- tantra gyü (Tib)
- Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.