Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 24 Tape 47 Side 1 Afflictions

44 min · 4,676 words · 24 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 24 Tape 47 Side 1 Afflictions
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains that suffering is rooted in delusion and karma, and that the nature of phenomena (including emptiness) is permanent while things themselves are impermanent. It describes the sufferings of the god and demigod realms and the three kinds of dissatisfaction, and teaches that understanding the afflictions and ignorance is the next step on the path. It closes by introducing the Madhyamaka view of ignorance and the Prasangika position associated with Tsongkhapa’s Essence of Eloquent Speech.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-24

Duration: 44 min

UUID: 6b85919e-2651-4cdd-91b6-a0ce490a66e3

Words: 4,676

Fire is hot. That’s its nature and it doesn’t change. Discussion group, think about it if we get some answers. But I think this is what the word nature means anyway. I mean, having a particular nature is it holds its own characteristic.

This is what dharma means, phenomena. Particular phenomena is something which holds its it continues to hold, maintain its own characteristic. A rose is a rose is a rose. I think one understands these things in a general way. For a specific person, they don’t have to be that.

Generally, anything produced by delusion and karma acts as a condition for the disturbing thoughts to arise and suffering to arise. But of course, this is not a true suffering for Buddha. But for the for the ordinary yes, of course. But so but for the deluded mind, this can act as a condition. But of course, if we change if we work with our mind and and so on, it it it it’s not inherently such a thing.

But in this world these things act like that, generally speaking. But if we train our mind, doesn’t have to be like that, sure, definitely. You get upset, change, then you give us less consternation? Yes, of course, of course, yes, yes, yes, sure, sure. Yeah.

Yes, it’s not permanent but it’s everlasting. There are things which are no, there are things which are impermanent and everlasting. The mind itself, the omniscient mind, lasts forever, mind in general lasts forever, goes on. But the mind is impermanent. The Buddha mind is impermanent.

It changes moment by moment. It doesn’t decay moment by moment, but it changes moment by moment. But into the same it changes but it maintains its nature, this enlightened, omniscient nature moment by moment. But it changes and because it changes by moment, that’s why it’s omniscient. If it didn’t change moment by moment, it wouldn’t be able to know everything because things are changing.

Right? But it lasts it keeps going on. Sorry? Are things relative once you reach enlightenment, or appear happy? No, they’re not relative.

In the enlightened state, no, no. It’s unconditioned, unconditioned bliss. Uncreated, unconditioned. Read the Prajñāpāramitā, it goes on and on, all these wonderful Yes, yes. This is the world, this is the dualistic world of relative things.

Maybe this piece of wood is impermanent, decaying moment by moment. That is its conventional nature. The ultimate nature of this wood is it is empty of inherent existence. It doesn’t truly exist from its own side. That ultimate nature of this piece of wood is permanent.

It does not change moment by moment. But this particular wood is called a a what? A A mallet. Yes, right, a mallet. So, the empty nature of this mallet is permanent.

But if I burn this mallet, the mallet doesn’t exist, so the empty nature of the mallet no longer exists because there’s no mallet. So, this is an example of the empty nature of this mallet is permanent but it doesn’t last. It only lasts as long as the mallet lasts. The empty nature of things doesn’t decline moment by moment, it’s always just that. Just empty, moment by moment.

It’s not more empty one moment and less empty the next moment, it is just empty of inherent existence moment by moment. And you can’t have emptiness without something existing. There’s not just emptiness. There’s no such thing as just emptiness floating around. Oh, there’s a bit of emptiness over there.

By George. That’s what I have to get to get that to achieve enlightenment. There are I mean, you have to have an existing phenomena to be empty. Therefore, emptiness is form, form is emptiness. So, the emptiness of something can only last as long as the thing exists.

When it stops existing, the emptiness of it has stopped existing. But while the thing is existing, the emptiness of it is permanent, not changing moment by moment. Suffering questions? Why should we have relationships that have children if we know that living is one way of developing? Well, it’s not a question of should.

Remember, wouldn’t be better off. Question was why should we have relationships or children if at all sorry, if at all if if we lose them. Well, not like I said, it’s not a question of should and it’s a question of choice. But would it be better not to? I I can’t say it’s would it be better not to?

Sometimes, yes. If produces lots of suffering and attachment and whatever. Sure, better not to. Why have a relationship which is going to produce lots of suffering? Yes, because not having a relationship brings suffering.

True. True. But so one has to make in this world of relative appearances, make a choice of less suffering but maybe there’s a point one can reach where one can be alone and happy. Yes. But I I think that you might have to say that because the body itself, in the case of the body itself, is a contaminated phenomena, I don’t know if you can say the body itself has the potential for real happiness, a contaminated body.

The mind has, but I’m not sure if you can say the body itself has that. The the body has the potential to give rise to gross pleasure, which is changeable suffering. But I don’t think you can say this body. From a tantric point of view, maybe you can now, get it’s very complicated. From a sūtra point of view, I don’t think you can say the body has the potential for real happiness, the contaminated body.

That’s why even in an arhat, who is free of, you know, still the still has a contaminated body and can still experience some some unpleasantness, but the mind isn’t disturbed by it. But one can have a pure body, one can generate an uncontaminated body at some point. Yes? Well, I mean, child, unless it’s every child suffers. Yeah.

As a sentient being, unless unless you give birth to a Buddha or a an eighth level bodhisattva, that there’s suffering. There is suffering. In what? Well, I I I think I did What does karma do? You know, we have a choice.

You don’t have to produce babies. There’s nothing totally forcing one to produce babies. There are many reasons for having babies. Bodhisattvas have babies. Definitely Bodhisattvas have babies, to have Bodhisattva babies.

Because they know there are bodhisattvas hanging around there who need a bodhisattva baby. Sure, this happens for sure. But it’s through the power of karma, one is drawn to one’s parents through the power of karma. Sorry, just before there was some someone yes. Yeah.

How can you have suffering with a holy object? Strictly speaking, holy object, a genuinely holy object cannot act as a cause of suffering. Perhaps one’s contaminated view of it can. Yes. I do believe you.

When we discussed about the choice of children, children, two days ago we talked about Ramakrishna, And does he say, before he was dying, I came back in that, with that couple. Yes. Yes. That family Yes. They had to be together, they won’t have anymore, but it was an accident.

Yes. So It wasn’t three children. They have many, many of them, seven or eight. Oh, Yeah. That in health what’s the possibility in choice of possibility, but in this case, there is no choice.

Of having babies? Came back and with that couple of that couple said before one mother and one children, but it was an accident. They were all accidents. I know, I know the family. So in one sense.

Yeah. This gets very complicated. But Lama Yeshe suggested that couple get married for a start. And just also like Lama Kanchog told Tinsong Rinpoche’s, suggested Tinsong Rinpoche’s parents get married. He encouraged them to get married.

It was an arranged marriage, possibly because he saw that they would have Tinson Sopa, who has this strong connection. So this is how bodhisattvas work, this kind of thing. So this couple had, by accident, had had a baby, but but Lama Yeshe was waiting for that accident to happen. Because he definitely said predicted before he would take rebirth with him. Exactly in those words, but I’ll probably currently tell the story.

Oh, sure, sure, sure. Yeah. Yeah, if mean, especially if you, you know, sentient beings are going to take rebirth, right? Sentient beings are going to have babies, have intercourse and so on. So, it would be wonderful if there were more loving, kind parents, you know, men and women who came together and had children and really cared for them.

As not, this is my baby, but this is a child to nurture and educate with love and compassion. Yeah? Sure. In the sutras, the Buddha there are some sutras where the Buddha praises the family life and how wonderful this can be. Yeah, sure.

But again, it’s up to a point. We have to recognize there are some limitations and so But it’s very important that we have people who stay together and have children and care for them, look after them. That’s so important. And one can have as a religious you know, having some religious view, especially from Buddhist context, one can have that thought to at least have children to be able to teach them love and compassion and give them love and compassion. Great.

Yeah. Mhmm. Is there something of change related to pleasure of the senses? Yes. Sure.

That that is that’s all. Yes. Yes. Yes. In what way?

It’s our sense consciousnesses that experience those pleasures. Yeah. And one just sees that that pleasure doesn’t last, it is relative, and actually in its nature it doesn’t have that quality of satisfying in the very first moment. There is no ability to bring complete satisfaction in the first moment. And it seems to me that it is kind of similar to the nature of feelings?

Because feeling doesn’t matter? Yes, these are feelings. We are talking about suffering is feeling, happiness is feeling. Yeah? So even including the mental consciousness?

Feeling? Yeah, each consciousness has feelings and the mental consciousness has feelings. Right? So there’s like there’s bodily feeling, body consciousness feeling. So there can be pleasant bodily feeling, unpleasant bodily feeling, and then there’s the mental consciousness that observes that, normally, for the untrained mind, when unpleasant bodily feeling arises, the mind observes that and generates unpleasant mental feeling as well.

But, training and when pleasant bodily feeling arises, mental consciousness observes that and pleasant mental feelings arise. But one can train the mind that when unpleasant bodily feelings arise, the mental consciousness doesn’t experience unpleasant feeling. It can experience a neutral feeling by training the mind, there can be neutral one isn’t disturbed by that mental suffering, and with engaging in the Lojong practices, that physical suffering can produce mental happiness. By thinking, Oh, this is the ripening of my negative karma. Fantastic.

Great. And the mind gets happy. There’s a pleasant mental feeling. But the self-cherishing thought, the mind, the mental consciousness controlled by the self-cherishing thought, when it observes unpleasant physical feeling, gets unhappy, generates unhappy feelings. But with our wisdom, we can generate positive feelings even towards physical suffering.

For example, we can observe the truth that of the suffering of change, and we can we can make ourselves happier. Oh, this is true. The Buddha’s teachings are true. Then I should do something about this. Oh, this is great.

Or we can look at that and think, Oh, my happiness isn’t happiness. Oh. So we can make our physical suffering worse by getting depressed, our mental you know, getting thinking with our mental consciousness in a way that un suffering feelings arise as well. I’m doomed. So we can take a little minute.

We will experience the pleasure, the happiness of standing up for a short time. So, we can sit comfortably just for a short time and just contemplate over what we’ve been thinking about in this morning’s session about the the three kinds of dissatisfaction or suffering that try to recognize that we are in this situation that we experience the arising from time to time of the suffering of suffering in our body, in our mind, then we can try to think about that all our pleasure and happiness, it is actually, it doesn’t last, it’s relative. Its very nature is unfulfilling, incomplete, it’s not satisfying. And that we, all the time, no matter where we are, where we go, what we do in this life, other lives, are experiencing this very subtle state of dissatisfaction or unsatisfying state because we have a body and mind controlled by delusion and karma. So try and think about that as much as one can, however one can, in the context of understanding that all of this has causes.

It’s not something arbitrary, uncontrolled. There are causes, our own delusions, and the karma we’ve created. Try and raise the mind, generate the mind that wishes to not just pacify our delusions, modify them, but use the energy of this life, our precious human rebirth to begin the work, the effort of eradicating the disturbing thoughts. Think how wonderful that would be to be free of them. And how wonderful it would be to help others to be free of their disturbing thoughts, all their different kinds of suffering.

So, when the Buddha taught the first truth of suffering, that existence is in the nature of suffering or being unsatisfactory, incomplete, and so on. The purpose for the Buddha teaching that was to inspire those who heard to seek the causes of what leads to that suffering, that dissatisfaction. So, if we dismiss the existence or not necessarily dismiss, but don’t consider the existence of mind, then all of this can be explained just in terms of this life in a physical way. But leaves many in one way it can be explained, but it leaves many things unanswered, and a more profound explanation lies with considering the existence of our mind and the cause of all since the suffering is experienced by mind, then the cause lies within our mind. So the more we realize how our mind gives rise to suffering, and to all types of happiness as well, then we are drawn more and more to working with our mind of renouncing, giving up our obsession, our attachment and so on, to external things.

Firstly, just to working for the happiness of this life, eventually we can even renounce the thought of remaining just with this mind controlled by delusion and karma, but just continuously trying to create the causes of good rebirths as humans or in the god realms if we believe in it. So, the more we develop this wise mind of renunciation, which has the quality of love and compassion as well, then we seek to find the causes within ourselves and to eradicate them, to eliminate them. So, the next topic in the path to enlightenment is the topic of looking at the different afflictions, the disturbing thoughts. So, in order to be able to recognise them in our mind, and to then learn the direct antidotes to the different disturbing thoughts, so that we can, in our daily life as much as we can, apply those antidotes. We can apply them in meditation as well, of course, which is necessary, but to apply them in our daily life.

So, if we only think of this life, that there’s nothing more than this life, and even if we think our thoughts are something produced by the brain, just a product of the brain, still we need a method to subdue those thoughts. So by learning the antidotes, it can be very helpful even if we just have a view that there’s only this life. Strictly speaking, and talking about all the different kinds of suffering, one should talk about the suffering of the God realms. But maybe I can just I’ve mentioned this point before already that I don’t think it needs to be elaborated on too much because it’s very hard for us to, I think or maybe some people particularly relate more to the suffering of the god realms than the lower realms but Yeah, that’s possible. I never thought of that before.

Could I what? A tab. A tab. A tab. Yeah.

Okay. So, generally, the suffering of the upper realms is that or why the bliss of the upper realms is unsatisfying is, again, because it doesn’t last, and while one is experiencing that, one is totally unaware of the nature of saṃsāra that one is trapped in, one isn’t creating any causes to get out of it, one is just simply using up one’s good karma that one generated in previous lives, and then that experience comes to an end. And because that experience was so blissful, that unbelievably blissful experience, which has lasted such an incredibly long time comes to an end. There’s great suffering in the mind because the contrast is so great. And in the teachings it mentions that for although it’s never very, very clearly specified, for the gods of the desire realm I’m not sure if it’s all of the gods of the desire realm, and it would possibly include some of the types of gods and goddesses of the first two levels of the Form Realm.

It is said that in the last period of their life, the last week of their life, which is not a human week but goes on for hundreds and hundreds of Earth years, in this last period of life of being in this God realm, in the lower God realms, then all these signs of death start to appear for these beings who have had these incredibly beautiful bodies and have had all these amazing enjoyments, but then slowly the beauty of their body fades away and there’s the appearance of growing old and so on, and the body starts to smell because the body of a goddess only has this unbelievably beautiful smell, but in the last period of life this very bad odor arises, and there are various other signs like that. Because of that, all the other gods and goddesses will not have anything to do with them, just completely stay away. So this produces incredible suffering in the minds of these beings, and because also they know that they are going to, suddenly they become aware that this life, this blissful life that they thought was going to go on forever is coming to an end.

And they also see that they’re going to fall into a lower realm, one of the lower realms, not into the human realm but into one of the three lower realms. And in the teachings it says that, in fact, this suffering of being in this realm as it’s fading away and knowing one is going to sink into the suffering realms is the worst suffering in saṃsāra. It’s even worse than actually being in the hell realm. I don’t know, but this is what it says in the teachings. There’s also the suffering of what are called the demigods or the asuras, who are these beings who also, like as depicted in the Greek mythology, there are these beings who also have very beautiful bodies, much enjoyment, have very long lives, they don’t live as long as so they’re in the desire realm, but they don’t live as long as the gods and goddesses in the actual desire realm, god states, but they can see these beings.

They can see them, and they’re incredibly jealous of their enjoyment, and they’re constantly fighting with these demigods, they’re constantly fighting with these gods, and they always lose. They always lose. Particularly, they’re fighting because the goddesses well, the actual goddesses are much more beautiful than the demigoddesses, so they’re always trying to take off with the goddesses, so they have to have a fight with the gods there, and they always lose. So it’s incredibly tormenting for them. So this is something very similar to what is depicted in some of the Greek myths, all this fighting, even though it’s kind of a god realm, so much jealousy and fighting.

And again, of course, there is something like this, there’s something this type of state in the human realm as well, where there are people who have beauty and wealth, but are not as famous and beautiful and as rich as the very, very, very international jetset. They may hang out on the outskirts of that, but so jealous because they’re not completely in, in the in crowd, and so much suffering from that. But anyway, I think I’ve talked about enough suffering to contemplate on. So then we can think about the causes of this suffering, which is our afflicted thoughts. Because if one looks at those different kinds of suffering, why they arise and what makes them worse is our failure to see the impermanence of things.

So much of this suffering arises because of things being impermanent, but our mind not seeing that and not wanting to see that. So much of that suffering arises because we cling to those experiences, we get attached to them. Or the opposite, we have aversion to anything that interferes with our attachments. So that makes the suffering so much worse. So, it’s important to look at these delusions so that we can recognize them in our mind.

And not just to recognize them, but to try to use some wise, skillful, compassionate means to overcome them. So again, all of these delusions arise from the principle one of ignorance. There are many ways of talking about ignorance but there are two major ignorances, we can say. The one which is the actual root of saṃsāra, that gives rise to all the other afflicted thoughts, which is this misconception of the self. This, of course, are many misconceptions of the self, as I roughly indicated, when sometimes we identify with our body, sometimes with our mind.

So these are types of ignorance, but not the very subtle root ignorance that gives rise to all the afflictions. The very subtle ignorance well, all the different schools. There are four major philosophical schools of Buddhism, so they all define they all accept that ignorance is the cause of saṃsāra, but their definition of what this ignorance is varies. There are four different interpretations. So it is believed in this tradition, the Gelugpa tradition, and more or less in all the four schools of Tibetan Buddhism, that the actual correct view of what constitutes ignorance has been presented by Nāgārjuna.

This is the view called the Madhya Mika view, the view of the middle way, the Mādhyamika view. And this Mādhyamika view itself has two different interpretations. There is the Svatāntrika Mādhyamika and the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika. So, of these two presentations, it is believed that the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika view is the actual highest view, the actual view that the Buddha has. Lama Tsongkhapa composed a text called The Essence of Eloquent Speech.

In Tibetan, it’s called something like the Drang Nge Legs Bshad Nyingpo. So this is considered to be Je Tsongkhapa’s major masterpiece, the masterpiece, the most brilliant thing he ever written, in which he presents this argument which is about the interpretive and definitive teachings of the Buddha. Some of the teachings of the Buddha are interpretive and some are definitive. The definitive teachings are about the actual nature of existence. The interpretive ones are about the conventional aspects of existence.

The definitive teachings are about the true nature of phenomena. And even within the definitive teachings of the Buddha, there are aspects which are interpretive and definitive. For example, when it says, So the Heart Sūtra is a definitive teaching of the Buddha, it is about the actual nature of phenomena. But when it says, There is no nose, no ear, that is not literal, it’s interpretive. So, in this text, which is translated into English by Professor Robert Thurman, the Je Tsongkhapa Professor of Buddhism at Columbia University.

The text is called The Essence of Eloquent Speech. I think that’s the translation. The Essence of Eloquent Speech. So, this book presents the definitive meaning of the Buddha’s teachings and argues how Mādhyamika, the Prāsaṇgika middle way view, is the actual view of the Buddha, which is the view one needs to, at first, conceptually understand in order to directly experience what that conceptual view is aiming at. Prāsaṇgika is a Sanskrit word which means consequences, so it’s the middle way consequence school, because one aspect, it’s not the only aspect of this school, is that what the middle way consequence school does is it takes all the different views presenting what reality is and what the different views of reality exist in all different philosophical systems outside of Buddhism, within Buddhism, and then it says, If this is true, this follows.

This is the consequences. But you haven’t realized the consequences, so it doesn’t make sense. Because if this is true, all these absurd consequences follow from thinking things are like that. So the middle way consequence school just points out all the logical absurdities of thinking things exist like that. And then it presents how things do exist.

Some people some academics say the middle way consequence school doesn’t have a view, it just simply destroys the views of others. And this is an example of just reading Dharma texts without having a valid explanation from the living lineage of the teachings. So there is definitely in the Mādhyamika Middle Way view, is a very definite, precise presentation of how things exist. It doesn’t just simply refute the views of others it has a very definite opinion, idea, presentation of how things do exist. Anyway, in that view, it presents that the ignorance creates the appearance of a person that exists independently of body and mind.

This is what, deep down, we are grasping at. Not a person that is the body, not a person that is the mind, not a person that is the body and the mind together, but we have this belief that motivates us all the time, that the I, me, that has a name is something separate from the body and the mind. Not only that, the very subtle wrong view is that this person exists completely independent of any labeling whatsoever. So this is very easy to say, but not easy to understand what it actually is pointing to. So there is intellectually acquired ignorance and then the instinctual ignorance that has arisen moment by moment during beginningless time.

Because there is this instinctive ignorance that we all have, which is the root of saṃsāra. Then there are other intellectually acquired types of ignorance that come from studying wrong philosophies, wrong views, having you study a particular philosophy and come to the idea that things are like this. So this also produces if this philosophy is wrong and it’s not an actual presentation of the way things do exist and one believes it and acts in accordance with it, of course it becomes a source of suffering. But it’s not the real source of suffering. The real source of suffering is this primordial, instinctual grasping at true existence.

At some point, someone here will try and talk about this. I may work up the courage to do it. Anyway, it’s supposed to come at the end of the lam rim anyway, so that’s my excuse. I’m trying to give some points about it anyway. Again, just to make the point, what this view does, this ignorance does, it creates the illusion of a person that if that person and this is what the Mādhyamika

Key terms in this teaching

definitive meaning nitartha (Skt); ngedön (Tib)
One of two main ways of understanding a Dharma teaching, this one is where the content is be taken literally and not open for interpretation, as opposed to the interpretive meaning. LYWA
desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
Gelug
The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
upper realms
The three higher realms in samsara of human, asura and sura. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top