44 min · 4,742 words · 8 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk teaches that anger is a painful, agitated state of mind that never brings benefit, and that afflicted desire differs from a wholesome wish for wisdom and compassion. It explains ignorance as the root affliction that produces desire, anger and other disturbing thoughts, compares it to a disease, and contrasts the arhat’s liberation with the Mahayana aim of full enlightenment. A question and answer session follows the first part.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-08
Duration: 45 min
UUID: 4ff2add9-d041-418e-b4b3-eb115b8fa804
Words: 4,742
So we try to push it away. This anger arises that wants to harm it, to push it away. To push it away, if that’s not good enough, want to really harm it, destroy it, eliminate it. Again, if you check with anger, that mind is suffering, it is totally agitated. That’s fairly easy to notice, that that’s what anger does to the mind, it does it to the body.
The body face turns red, perspiration pours down, everything, the body shakes, you shake with anger. Even when it stops, you still vibrate for some time. It completely rattles the entire nervous system, it’s such a gross mind, such a totally agitated mind. And so the berserk thing is, the truly berserk thing is, that why do we get angry? To protect our happiness.
What does anger do? It is an unhappy state of mind. Our anger destroys our happiness. The very happiness that we’re trying to preserve is destroyed by our own agitated, angry thoughts. This shows how confused we are.
And there are people, there are psychologists in the world who say anger is a good thing, you should express your anger, you’ll get sick otherwise. And people take these as wise beings. This is an example of having no real understanding of the mind, having a very superficial understanding of one aspect of the mind, but not seeing the totality of what the mind is and the totality of the effects of our actions beyond just a few days, a few weeks, a few years, beyond this life. So Buddhism is a psychology, but it is a total psychology of the totality of the mind, understanding mind beyond just this life. Anger is suffering, it is painful, there is not the tiniest benefit in it.
Cold water, you apply heat, you get hot result. You use anger as a cause, the result is only suffering. It is impossible to be anything else. Impossible if anger is painful, the result is painful. There’s no other possible result.
This is scientific reality of the mind. There is not the tiniest benefit of being angry for one second. It doesn’t benefit oneself for a second, it doesn’t benefit anybody in any way, in any way, ever, ever. This is what the Buddha taught. Someone harms us, there is no way that anger will benefit, will eliminate that harm, or benefit us, now or in the future.
It will never do that. No matter how terrible the act is, anger actions based on anger and revenge and wishing to harm, they cannot produce a moment of benefit, happiness, peace. It’s utterly impossible. This is totally contrary to what the mind is and how it works. Time.
Sorry, I’m sorry. Sorry, I’m not sorry. That was stated very dogmatically, but if you check up, it’s pretty easy to discover these truths. Some parts of the Buddhadharma, it’s very difficult to discover their truth. We need to have faith.
Some things doesn’t take long to discover if one really wants to be honest with oneself and what is happening in the mind. If you have any questions? Yes? Have a question about desire. Mhmm.
When you talk about the desire to be kind with people and Mhmm. Compassionate and Could you try and speak up a little bit? So the question is, is there some kind of constructive desire, is every kind of desire bad? So as I try to say, we have this word, you know, it’s a word desire, but there are two completely different states of mind that this word can cover. So there is one state of mind that is called desire which is completely terrible suffering.
This is afflicted desire. And then there is a desire, a state of mind which we also can call desire which is a positive state of mind, such as but maybe it’s better to use the word wish for something, to to wish to change one’s mind, the wish to develop one’s mind, the wish to become more compassionate, wise, etcetera. This kind of wishing or desiring is not disturbing the mind, and it doesn’t produce suffering in the future. By following that kind of desire, that kind of wish, it will eventually lead to real happiness and peace. But afflicted desire, where we exaggerate the importance of something and believe it to be permanent and so on, that that kind of desire, that is an affliction, it is a disturbance in the mind, and that is suffering and produces suffering.
So it’s up to us to use our mind to develop clarity and space in our mind to be able to distinguish. Is this thought a virtuous kind of desire that is going to benefit me, or is it a harmful, afflicted desire? We have to check up ourselves. I know there is this teaching and it belongs to a different school, so I can’t refute it. The idea that in anger and in desire there is the seed of goodness or wisdom and so So this teaching is a very very high teaching that is not applicable at our level now, and it’s a big mistake to think that we can follow our anger because there’s something good in us, or we can follow our desire because it has the seed of compassion.
This is just fooling ourselves. It is a total mistake. And in understanding the nature of things, we have to understand that there is a conventional truth, and we cannot deny the conventional truth. And conventionally there are things which are good and beneficial, and conventionally there are things that are harmful, and this cannot be denied. And the denying of them leads to suffering.
There is suffering, this is undeniable that there is suffering, and there is a cause of that suffering. The cause of suffering is what we call bad. Because what every sentient being wishes just naturally, uncontrollably, is happiness. That is that is the the good that we all want, and that which leads to genuine happiness is good. And that which harms that happiness is bad.
This is undeniable. No one wants suffering. There’s no even the bodhisattvas who take on try to take on the suffering of others don’t want it. They don’t think it’s good. They don’t want it for its own sake.
So suffering is bad, isn’t it? And therefore the causes of it are bad, what we call bad or evil or negative. Oh, I’m not saying that. Of course it’s not good to ignore anger. This is what the Buddhist teachings are about, is we have to we cannot ignore anger.
We have to wake up to what it really is. I’m not saying to ignore it, of course not, you can’t ignore it that it’s there. Oh, well that comes in the course, right? The question was how do we deal with it? So that will come step by step.
What sort of thinking? This man is saying that which philosophy? Buddhist philosophy? The presentation of Buddhist philosophy means that you have to suppress anger? So how do you deal with that?
This not what Buddhist philosophy says at all, and I hope all I simply said so far is that anger is a negative state of mind. I never said therefore suppress it. I did not say that at all. Absolutely not. I just simply stated that anger is a negative state of mind, therefore I implied we should do something about it.
And what I’m always trying to say is what we should do about negative states of mind is be wise and compassionate with them. You do not suppress them because the suppression of anger just creates more anger. What we have to do is wisely and compassionately undermine the causes of it, and I’ll try and talk about that later in the course. I can’t talk about everything at once, unfortunately, I wish I could. But all of the Buddhadharma is interconnected and I’m just trying to relay some fundamental points now, especially for the new people, so we can talk about the graduated path to enlightenment.
But definitely it’s not about suppressing anger, not at all. Yes? Oh, yes. Can something physical enrich your life? To a point, yes.
Buddhism isn’t denying, the Buddhadharma isn’t denying that there are pleasant things, beautiful things that bring happiness to some extent, sure. And we as ordinary people working on the path, we need these things, we can’t deny them or totally reject them. But what the Buddhadharma is trying to tell us is that generally, for most of us, we totally exaggerate the importance of things. We place too much importance on them time, energy and everything on these things, and in doing so we miss the chance to create the causes to experience something much greater in our mind. This is basically what we’re trying to balance.
What can be experienced from the external world and what can be experienced from the inner world of our mind. So we need to check, and most of us, most of the time, have a lot of experience of things of the external world and what they can bring, but we have almost no experience of what our inner world can bring. So the Buddhadharma is trying to tell us why the Buddha appeared in the world, is he came to tell us that there is something more, much more satisfying and beneficial within our mind than anything that we can find in the external world. And it’s our choice what we do with this teaching. We can investigate the truth of it, how much pleasure and happiness comes from external things, and how much benefit can we bring with these external things to ourselves and others, and how much satisfaction can be achieved from within our mind and how much benefit can we bring to others with our mind, by developing our mind.
It’s our choice. Doesn’t the desire for happiness, loving kindness, compassion, liberation, enlightenment, doesn’t that cause us suffering when we don’t get there, when we don’t achieve those results? No. The desire for those things doesn’t cause the suffering. The lack of those things is suffering but the desire for them doesn’t cause suffering.
The lack of those experiences is suffering because other things are causing that frustration and misery. Frustration? Not getting Not getting getting Not But the desire for those things doesn’t cause suffering, Especially if it’s a genuine, pure wish to be compassionate, wise, liberated and enlightened. We better stop, it’s way over time, sorry. Thank you very much for paying attention, so we can dedicate the good energy, whatever good energy we’ve generated during this time, may it become a cause for us to achieve a true experience of our mind, all the amazing positive qualities of our mind, may they become completely developed in order to bring about lasting happiness for ourselves and continuous great benefit to all living beings.
Thank you very much, but I spaced out and I thought we had to finish at eleven, but we don’t finish till eleven thirty because we’re supposed to have meditation. So you don’t escape. So there’s fourteen minutes, so we can take just a couple of minutes break, people might like to stand up and stretch their legs. Maybe not necessary for a pee pee break, is it okay? Just a couple of minutes and then we’ll just have a very short meditation.
Beneficial being able to more clearly recognize our attachment to small limited things that take us away from experiencing our inner world and the incredible potential of our mind. So we can dedicate this again, this awareness of the effort we’ve put in, may it become a cause for us to be completely free of the disturbing thoughts of ignorance, desire attachment, and anger. That cause us suffering, cause others suffering. Being free of these states, may we achieve our true nature, the enlightened state that continuously benefits all living beings. Okay.
Thank you very much. Chötra will start with doing some breathing meditation, and then we go into the generating the refuge in Bodhicitta, which is page eighteen and nineteen. So basically what we’re trying to do is prepare our mind so that we’re able to listen in the best way and with the best motivation, so that the teachings can have the greatest impact on our mind, not just now, but continuously. So we sit in the correct posture as much as we can. Be aware of the breath coming in and going out, and allow the mind to focus in on that experience, especially this sensation arising at the tip of the nostrils as the breath goes in and goes out.
Trying to take a strong interest in that and to notice, to have this mindfulness that is quick to observe anything that is not the arising of the breath, such as the mind being attracted to sounds, pains in the body, or thoughts. So noticing those things, simply rather than being caught up in them or analyzing them in various ways, we just simply label them a distraction so that immediately it can help to cut our fascination with those things. We let go of them, gently let go of them, and bring the mind back to the breath. As Buddha nature and his Buddha nature has been suppressed, obscured, not just in this life but since beginningless time. And because of that, we continuously experience only limited kinds of happiness, the illusion of happiness, but continuous types of suffering, confusion, dissatisfaction, problems, fears, anxiety and so on.
Right now we have the chance to recognize the cause of our confusion, to be able to eliminate it and develop our broader nature. By doing so we will establish the causes that bring about our own lasting happiness that we’ve always been seeking, and more than that we’ll be able to develop the qualities that not only do not cause harm to others in any way, but actually bring about lasting benefit to countless living beings. In order to free the mind and fully develop the mind, we have to follow the path of mental development, and to follow that path we have to we have to understand the path correctly, and this comes about by listening to the teachings again and again. So we try and generate the thought for the benefit of myself and all living beings, I will listen to these teachings. And as much as we have understanding and faith, we can request, make strong request from the depths of our heart to all the Buddhas, bodhisattvas and holy beings to bless our minds to be able to understand these teachings and practice them as much as possible.
For this reason, it’s helpful if we want to to visualize the Buddha, the historical Buddha, Śākyamūni Buddha, directly in front of us as the very embodiment of all perfect qualities of wisdom and compassion, and we think of ourselves surrounded by all the sentient beings who need our help, beginning with our mother on our left, our father on our right, family and friends behind us, people we dislike and who dislike us directly in front. Shog. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, the supreme assembly by the merits I create through practicing the Dharma. May I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings. So this morning, was talking about the what are called the afflictions or the disturbing thoughts which act to interfere, to obscure our mind, and while they’re arising, act to obscure our mind, and even the potential aspect of them obscures our mind.
When they actually manifest in our mind, they manifest as suffering. There is this discomfort in the mind, there is the disturbance in the mind, and they act to produce suffering in the future, which I’ll talk about a bit later on. So for this reason, the Sanskrit term for these thoughts, these minds klesha, which can be translated as afflictions or disturbing thoughts or also delusions. These are the, I think, the three main translations that are used for this term. So the principle delusion or affliction is ignorance, misconception of self that we create with our mind, with our mental consciousness, and that same mental consciousness grasps that as being real.
Because of that central root affliction, and only because of that, all the other disturbing thoughts arise. This is one important thing that we can try to check up and understand, that it is simply because of this wrong view of self that we have, this distorted conception of self that we have, that which also then acts to produce a distorted conception of everything else. It’s simply because of that, that all the disturbing thoughts exist in our mind. If that wrong view of self wasn’t there, it would be utterly impossible for desire attachment to exist. Utterly impossible.
And if there wasn’t desire attachment there wouldn’t be anger, there wouldn’t be any form of anger, aversion, hatred, irritation, annoyance, resentment, so on. And if it wasn’t for these two main disturbing thoughts of desire, attachment and anger, all the other disturbing thoughts wouldn’t exist. Other disturbing thoughts such as jealousy, pride, doubt, fear, anxiety, all of these things are all offshoots of desire and anger. So these three delusions of ignorance and attachment desire attachment and anger are called the three poisonous minds. These are the three principle poisonous minds.
These are the three thoughts or types of mind that poison our whole mind when they arise. So they afflict our mind, they are diseases of the mind. So we all have that, unfortunately. All of us have this amazing mind that has a Buddha nature that could bring about incredible benefit and joy to ourselves and others, but we have this disease in our mind that prevents that. We have several diseases, we have the root disease of ignorance, and then because of that disease we have a whole lot of other diseases desire, anger sorry, desire, attachment, anger, jealousy, all these diseases.
It’s for this reason that when we listen to the teachings we are asked to listen with the thought that we are sick people, because in fact that’s what we are, we are completely sick. And we try to listen with the thought that the teacher, and in this case it doesn’t mean the personal teacher, the founding teacher, Buddha, Śākyamūni Buddha, the historical founding Buddha, is like a doctor, the perfect doctor, not like modern doctors who don’t follow their advice, their own advice, who are usually sicker than their patients, but the perfect doctor. And we are requested to think of the Dharma, the teachings that come from this perfect doctor, this perfect teacher, that these teachings are the perfect medicine, the medicine that will definitely cure our disease. And of course the only way this medicine will cure our disease is to take it, not to listen to it, but to take it, which means to practice it. We hear the teachings in order to practice them, because only the practice of the teachings will firstly modify our disease, make it manageable, and through further practice we will be able to completely eradicate it.
So, because we identify so much it’s just natural that we identify so much with this body. Our body is apparently much more vividly present to us than our mind normally in one way. We’re always conscious of our body, we may not be so much conscious unfortunately of our mind. So when anything goes wrong with our body, of course we really get very upset. And we would do anything to get back to health.
Even if we have a little headache we worry, what could it mean? It may be more than a headache, I’ve got brain cancer, or something like that. So we really worry about the slightest dis ease in our body. We assume that there should be this natural perfect health in our body, that our body should be at ease, and when it is not at ease, when there is some disease, it really worries us, and if that disease is something very serious, then we will do anything naturally to get rid of it. It really frightens us the implications of it, the pain, the suffering, the possibility of death.
We will go anywhere in the world, spend us all our money to do it, we will try any remedy, know, quackiest remedy possible, understandable. First we try all the acceptable ones, if they don’t work we try something else, if that doesn’t work we travel further and further and try everything possible to be cured because we want this ease of body, because this is what we identify so strongly with. This is completely understandable. But what we don’t understand, which is not understandable, is that right I don’t I’d like to make this kind of scary, I don’t know how to scare you scare me. But right now all of us have a disease that is far worse than any physical disease.
We all have it right now. This is the bad news that the Buddha brought. Yeah? Any physical disease that we have, the very worst one, even if we have all of them together, all they will do is kill us, we will die. If we have all the worst diseases in the world we will die very quickly.
But we have a disease far worse than that right now, which is called ignorance. That, like ordinary diseases, produce all sorts of physical pain and worry associated with it, which can last some years, and then there is death and finished. But ignorance produces suffering again and again and again and again, endlessly. It produces every kind of suffering. It itself is the root cause of every disease.
It’s not because we eat improperly that we get disease, or we don’t exercise enough, or because we breathe the wrong air, I mean these are certainly these are secondary conditions. The root cause of all disease in the body is the disease in the mind, and we have it. It’s there right now operating in our mind, and we’re quite completely casual that we’ve got it. And this disease is not going to go away. It will kill us in this this disease of ignorance and all the delusions is what will cause us to die anyway.
And then we’ll get another body and that disease will kill kill that body and it will kill the next body and the next one and the next one and the next one and the next one and the next one. And it will just keep going on until we do something about it. This is what the Buddha taught. And right now we have perhaps had the chance to meet the perfect doctor and the perfect medicine. So all we have to do is start taking the medicine.
This is the Buddhist message. That part is kind of grim. The other aspect, we have to bear there’s two aspects of the Buddhadharma. There is the grim aspect that keeps telling us what we don’t want to hear, all the about suffering and so on, pain, death, and all these things which our self-cherishing mind doesn’t want to hear. But on the other hand, the Buddhadharma also teaches about experiencing this incredible joy, bliss, and not just some meaningless bliss, some kind of fun fun bliss, but this purity of mind that frees us from all suffering and has this wonderful effect of not causing suffering, harm, confusion to others, and actually has the ability to bring amazing benefit and happiness to all living beings.
And the only way we’re going to experience that is to face the fact that why we’re not is because of suffering that we have, the suffering that obscures our mind, which we ourselves perpetuate, that because we don’t want to look at it, we can’t be bothered doing anything about it. Okay, maybe that’s enough about the delusions for the time being. Path to liberation and enlightenment is about eliminating the delusions. So this is what we need to know what they are to really think about firstly to get an intellectual idea of what is meant by these afflictions. Ignorance I’ll talk try and talk about in more detail later on what it really involves, but I think I’ve tried to cover what desire attachment means from a Buddhist point of view.
I hope everyone they may not agree with me, but I hope at least they’ve understood what what the definition is in Buddhism of what desire attachment is and all its effects. So the path to liberation involves getting rid of those, firstly subduing those delusions and then getting rid of them. When they’re totally eliminated there is liberation, there is this state called nirvana, and we get labeled an arhat, we become an arhat. So in this state there is this incredible bliss in the mind, the natural bliss of the mind arises. And as a human being, and we achieve this liberated state of nirvana, and we can walk around as an arhat, then an arhat is an extremely nice being, they have no negative qualities whatsoever, their minds are pervaded by loving kindness and compassion, so they can be of great benefit to all the sentient beings they meet.
But when an arahat dies, when that body because the body has been produced by is a contaminated body produced by delusion and karma, when that body of an arhat dies, the mind of the arhat of course goes on because mind is indestructible. It goes on in this state of nirvana, but that state of nirvana is a type of mental meditative absorption where the mind is absorbed into this bliss, this incredible bliss, and is totally unaware of anything else. The mind is just floating in this nirvanic state of bliss, totally unaware of any sentient being. So an arhat from that point, when they leave the body, is not able to benefit a single sentient being because they’re not even aware of any sentient beings. This is why in the Mahāyāna path we are encouraged not to achieve just liberation because it only benefits ourself.
Whereas, by following the Mahāyāna path, we are able to go beyond this state of just self liberation and achieve complete enlightenment. Just very briefly, what the difference is, is that according to the Mahāyāna teachings, according to the Mahāyāna propaganda, when an arahant, a being becomes an arhat and they have destroyed ignorance by developing this wisdom realizing the true nature of self and phenomena, when that ignorance is destroyed, all the disturbing thoughts, all the afflictions of desire, attachment, anger, doubt, fear, jealousy, all of it goes immediately, instantly. But and therefore the bliss of the mind arises. But what is left behind are these very subtle imprints of these afflicted thoughts. And the traditional analogy that the Tibetan lamas give is that if you have a bowl which you crush garlic in, and then you take the garlic out, and then you wash the bowl very well, so it’s completely clean, and so from a conventional point of view there’s no garlic in there, but you can still smell the garlic even though there’s no garlic there.
So it’s a little bit like that for an Arhat, the delusions have completely gone, but there’s still some faint impression, some very subtle impression of these afflictions in the mind, and these subtle imprints which are called the obstacles to omniscience prevent, still obscure the mind from developing its full potential of omniscience. The ability to know everything all the time, and it obscures the mind from developing its full potential of loving kindness, compassion and so on. So Mahāyāna path involves it still requires uses the same wisdom, the same wisdom is necessary to develop, but in the Mahāyāna path that wisdom that has destroyed the at first destroys these delusions in our mind, the ignorance in our mind, is then strengthened by the power of Bodhicitta, this incredibly
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
- As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
- graduated path lamrim (Tib)
- A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Is there such a thing as constructive desire, or is every kind of desire bad?
The word desire covers two completely different states of mind. Afflicted desire is a disturbance in the mind that exaggerates the importance of something and believes it to be permanent. It is suffering and produces suffering. The other kind is a positive state of mind, for which the word wish may be better: the wish to change one's mind, to develop one's mind, or to become more compassionate and wise. This kind of wishing does not disturb the mind or produce future suffering, and following it eventually leads to real happiness and peace.
Some teachings say anger and desire contain a seed of goodness or wisdom. Can we therefore follow our anger and desire?
That teaching is very high and not applicable at our level now. It is a big mistake to follow anger because there is something good in us, or to follow desire because it has the seed of compassion; this is fooling ourselves. We cannot deny conventional truth: conventionally some things are good and beneficial and some are harmful, and denying this leads to suffering. Suffering is undeniable, and its cause is what we call bad, because every sentient being naturally wants happiness. What leads to genuine happiness is good, and what harms it is bad. Even bodhisattvas who take on others' suffering don't want it for its own sake. So suffering is bad, and therefore its causes are bad.
Doesn't wanting happiness, loving kindness, compassion, liberation and enlightenment cause us suffering when we fail to achieve them?
No. The desire for these things does not cause suffering. What is suffering is the lack of those experiences, and that lack is suffering because other things are causing frustration and misery. The desire itself is not the cause of suffering, especially when it is a genuine, pure wish to be compassionate, wise, liberated and enlightened.