Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 18 Tape 34 Side 1 The Lower realms, Death

44 min · 4,806 words · 18 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 18 Tape 34 Side 1 The Lower realms, Death
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teaching describes the sufferings of the lower realms: animals, pretas (hungry ghosts) and the hot and cold hells, with their causes such as attachment, miserliness, hatred and harming beings. It uses the examples to develop wise fear and compassion, and to encourage avoiding negative karma while the precious human rebirth is available. Brief questions follow at the end.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-18

Duration: 44 min

UUID: 3182621f-b194-4099-9823-ebbe46830611

Words: 4,806

The thought I don’t want suffering and this person here thinks I don’t want suffering and you think I don’t want suffering. Is there any difference? So is there any difference between a human being thinking I don’t want suffering and an animal thinking I don’t want suffering? It’s very difficult to say there’s some significant difference. So we can put out try to put our mind in that state, feel how terrible it would be, the suffering, and also no way to get out of that suffering.

When one’s trapped in that state, how do you get out of it? What can you do to get out of it? Even our domestic dogs, which probably of all dogs and cats, and we have dogs and cats and we love them and we take care of them, but the dog eats when we want it to eat, yeah? It goes out when we want it to go out, yeah? It has to do what we want it to do, right?

It doesn’t have much choice what it wants to do. So if even that’s good enough, meditate on that, develop this wise fear, not this neurotic fear that just freaks out and doesn’t do anything, and possibly gets all depressed and guilt ridden and does more negative things. Wise fear causes us to do something wise, that is avoid creating negative karma, which is the cause to experience this state. So this is the direct benefit of meditating. Also, by doing this, of course, it’s acting as a way to develop more compassion to sentient beings, more sensitivity to sentient beings.

We open our mind to see that there are so many beings around us suffering that we’ve never thought about before. Lama Yeshe once said, If you could experience the mind of a dog for one day, you would never sleep again. Because it’s so terrible. And of course none of the beings in the lower realms have their intelligence is not operating at the level to understand the Dharma, to follow any spiritual path. So that in a way is the worst suffering.

And of course animals also suffer from hunger and thirst, heat and cold, we do too, but we have so much ability to overcome that. There’s very little an animal can do. We have so many choices, we’ve created the karma to have so many, so many freedoms and abilities. We have suffering but we have so much intelligence to overcome that suffering in so many ways, with our mind, with our body, and so on. An animal has very little choice when hunger comes, when cold comes, when heat comes.

We have negative instincts, also in our mind, but they’re not as strong as an animal. In the case of a cat. When a cat, even a well fed cat, sees a mouse, it has to chase it. The instinct is so strong, the instinct of hunting and killing is so strong. It’s not some kind of electronic device in the brain, it is the habit of killing.

And habit is that which is labeled on doing an action again and again and again. One does an action so often it becomes habit, it becomes and that habit can be so strong it becomes instinctual. So a well fed cat sees a mouse, it has to chase it. No choice. I spent some time, six months, pretending to do retreat in vajrapani Institute in California near Soquel.

And vajrapani Institute is up in the, what, the Redwood Forest, and there are mountain lions there. I used to go for walks, used to, imagine that a mountain lion was going to pounce out any moment. Never did. I did see a baby one. But at the centre they give you advice of what to do if you see a mountain lion.

One of the things is you stay still, you don’t run, you do not run. Because if you start running, the mountain lion just has to chase, there’s no choice, that instinct just starts. You run and it runs after you. One thing you learned from the meditation course, if you see a mountain lion, don’t run. Very useful.

So, if we don’t want to be any kind of animal, then the only way to not become one is to avoid the causes, don’t create negative karma. Especially avoid ignorance and things like that, and just mindlessly following one’s base desires. So then, below the realm of animals, our mind can sink to a worse state of suffering, which is the realm of the pretas or the hungry ghosts. In the traditional teachings, they give the description of the pretas, which are these very the hungry ghosts, but within just like there are many in the human realm, could say there are many levels of human experience. There are like from those who are experiencing great joy and happiness, wealth and so on, down to people who are experiencing great poverty, disease, like incredible suffering most of their life.

So many types of human beings, we could say. So also in the other realms, there’s not just one type of experience, there are many levels of experience. So, within the hungry ghost realm, the least suffering in that realm is possibly what we understand in our culture, as ghosts, beings that hang around houses. So the main cause of being reborn in the hungry ghost realm is attachment and miserliness. So the ghosts that sometimes can be seen by human beings in this realm, possibly they don’t have the negative karma to experience the extreme suffering of the hungry ghost realm and they have a little bit of karma so that they can see this human realm but they can’t really they’re attached to it but they can’t really enjoy it.

And these beings have strong attachment to particular people or places, so they get born around those places. So they’re there, but because they’re in another realm, they don’t have a human body, they can’t really enjoy that place, they’re kind of tormented by it. It’s there, but they can’t fully experience it. But they hang around and they live for a very long time. So there’s one kind of suffering of this realm, it’s the least kind of suffering.

But these beings can exist for hundreds of years. And there are many stories all over the world of such ghosts. Of course, some of them, sure, are made up or the person, you know, just made some mistake. But there are too many examples of these to deny the possibility that such beings exist. I myself have no experience of these kinds of beings whatsoever, but I have met people whom I consider normal, sane, stable people who have had such experiences with ghosts in houses and so on.

Like some of the people who’ve come to Nālānda monastery who were painting in a house in where is it? What’s that town? Verwe. Verwe. Verwe.

Yeah, they were repairing this ancient house and they had some really scary experiences. About three or four of the men two was it two? Two or three. I think it was at least three guys doing it. And they also discovered that the place had a history of people being scared by the beings living there.

And some of these kinds of beings in the spirit realm, I don’t know if this is necessarily, it gets a little confusing because in the sutras it talks about the spirit realm, the hungry ghost realm. When you hear the tantric teachings, in the tantric teachings it talks about many different kinds of negative spirits, harmful spirits, so whether they belong to this particular realm or not, or they’re in another category of their own, I’m really not sure. Once when I was with the Lama Zopa Rinpoche in Bologna in Italy, Rinpoche was requested to visit this house of this quite well off family, young family. They had, I can’t remember, two or three children, and the youngest one so they’re this very well off family, and nice house, beautiful car, everything. But their youngest child, it seems, was possessed by a spirit, and couldn’t eat.

So it was like a skeleton, this small child that hadn’t eaten for months, it was still alive, but it wouldn’t eat, maybe it drank a little bit, I can’t remember. But seeing this child, it was very easy to believe that it was possessed. When Lama Sopa Rinpoche when I walked in the room it didn’t react at all. When Lama Zopa Rinpoche walked in the room it kind of freaked out. It was really scared of Lama Zopa Rinpoche.

And this child, like it’s just completely emaciated, it was kind of like going like It was breathing like that twenty four hours a day. Like, sorry. So when you saw it, it didn’t, it kind of felt like there was something else there than just the child, something else had possessed him. Unfortunately the parents didn’t take Lama Zopa’s advice or Geshe Jampa Gyatso, this other great Lama who lives close by and the child died. But it lived for a long time like that, which is also abnormal, it went on so long.

So, maybe if there are these beings around, sentient beings in this other realm, we create the causes for that. The main causes are our attachment and this miserliness holding on to what we have. And so therefore, we make that strong imprint and we experience the result that we don’t have anything. We have this wish for things, this desire, but it’s never fulfilled. So the preta realm especially experiences this continuous torment of hunger and thirst.

There are three main kinds of pretas. There are ones that experience hindrances concerning their food. They are always hungry and thirsty, constantly tormented by visions of food and drink, but they can never experience it, it’s always out of reach. And this suffering goes on for not just a lifespan of a human being, but it says, I don’t have the details now, once one is born in the preta realm, it goes on for thousands and thousands of years, where one experiences only hunger and thirst, that one doesn’t die. Thousands and thousands of years, the Buddha said, hard to imagine, no doubt, there is no doubt, this is very difficult to believe that this is what the Buddha taught.

Other pretas experience outer hindrances, they experience this hunger and thirst, this perpetual hunger and thirst, but even if they find food or water, they are driven away from it by these karmically created monsters. Just like we in this human realm, we can also with our mind, with a disturbed mind create karmic monsters. Fearful monsters in our we see sometimes. You take drugs, alcoholics and so on. And one creates monsters in the mind.

So in this realm one experiences that as well. Then the third kind of hindrances are inner hindrances, that even if the preta being actually obtains food and drink, they can’t swallow it, they can only swallow very tiny amounts because they have these very narrow necks and they have all these knots in their necks, so they can’t swallow it. And even if they are able to swallow the food, they have enormous stomachs, so it doesn’t satisfy. And they say the food, when it enters the stomach, turns into molten liquid or something that just causes incredible torment. And this torment goes on and on and on and on and on.

There are some kind of pretas, it says that they are so tormented by hunger that they rip parts of their body off and eat it. Their body is all festering and pussy and its skin flakes off and they take it and eat it. They eat their own bodies. There are some human beings who do that. I’ve read stories of human beings who do that as well.

So there are preta like beings in this realm also. As well as that, these beings experience incredible cold and heat. The heat of the sun feels incredibly cold to them, so they are tormented by that. They live in environments which are extremely dry and ugly and stark like vast deserts. Some of these pretas are able to appear in this human realm for short periods of time and get a little bit of food, but the only things that they can eat are like pus and blood and excrement and vomit and things like that.

This is what the Buddha taught. Again we ask, Why would a being with a wise, compassionate mind teach this? Why? The being who taught emptiness taught this. Why?

The being who taught don’t cause a moment of harm, even mental harm, a moment of mental disturbance to any being for any reason taught this. So was he trying to make us miserable and suffer? Or the Buddha saw this and out of his compassion didn’t want us to have this experience? So then, below the preta realm are the worst states of mind of all. So these are the hell realms of which there are two main kinds: there are the hot hells and the cold hells.

So, I’m not sure exactly, but at least I think within the hot hells, the first two, maybe the first three hot hells are actual places like the earth where one shares the karma. There are other hell beings with you, which are sentient beings, in the lower because there are eight hot hells, progressively worse. So the lower ones are just experiences of the mind, just like the high god realms, gods in the desire realm are in places, but beings in the formless realm are not in a place, they are just experiencing mind as such. In the hell realms they are experiencing the pain of the deluded mind, Just that. In the hell realms it’s the very opposite.

The lowest hell realms one is experiencing the pain, the extreme pain, the ultimate pain of the deluded mind. So the lowest of the hell realms are not places, it’s just mind. One’s own mind creating these horrific images that just like we create these images now and we believe they’re real, we create the image of hell and fire and torment, and we believe it, and grasp at it, and suffer. So the first of these realms, of the hot hells, just before that, just to quote Śāntideva from this great bodhisattva whose teachings are considered to be the main, inspired way to generate Bodhicitta and practice it. Śāntideva said in his text, Engaging in the bodhisattva Way of Life, all fears and boundless problems originate in fact from the mind.

Who purposely created all the weapons for those limited beings in the joyless realms, who created the burning iron ground, The Noble One has said that all such things are the product of the negative mind. Therefore, within the three realms there is nothing to fear other than the mind. Okay, once more. All fears and boundless problems originate from the mind. Who purposely created all the weapons for those limited beings in the joyless realms?

Who created the burning iron ground. The Noble One has said that all such things are the product of the negative mind. Therefore, within the three realms there is nothing to fear other than the mind. So, in the hot hells there is the basic experience of heat, the torment of heat, flames causing incredible suffering. So apart from that suffering, then each of the hell realms experiences specific sufferings.

The first of the hell realms, the least suffering one, is called the reviving hell. And I find this one very easy to believe in. And in this realm, one is born in a place where one is this kind of claustrophobic state, where one is like there are sentient beings everywhere. Like you imagine this room and it turns into like the walls are metal and they get hotter and hotter and then it just fills with sentient beings. All these sentient beings come in like there’s almost two hundred people in this room, but more keep coming and more and more, and then you’re just you’re boiling hot and then there’s all these sentient beings standing right next to you, squashed right next to you, totally no space.

But the sentient beings all surrounding you, you look everywhere and it’s just wall to wall sentient beings. And it’s not like looking at the sentient beings here who are quite pleasant, nice people. These people, everyone you look at, there’s a sentient being right there, there’s a sentient being right there, there’s a sentient being right there, and they are hideous and you hate them. You hate every single aspect of them. You can’t stand them.

Everything about them is disgusting, they stink, they look repulsive, everything about them is totally vomit inducing. You hate them, you hate, not dislike, you have this intense hatred of them and you want to kill them. So you generate these intense thoughts of hate and wanting to kill, and as you generate these thoughts, you want to kill them this way and you want to kill them that way. So whatever way you think of killing them, the weapon appears in your hands and then you proceed to rip these people to shreds. But they have the same thought to you.

They can’t stand you, there’s these sentient beings everywhere and they can’t stand you and they want to kill you and they’re also destroying you. This is the first of the low the hot hells. It gets worse from there on. And one is killed and dies and then because it’s called the reviving hell because I don’t know why this voice comes out and says, Revive! Everyone comes alive again and starts killing each other again.

And this goes on and on and on and on and on. We do similar things in this world. We have our sense of space when someone gets too close, we kind of quake. Someone has entered our personal space, yeah, and if it’s someone we don’t like, if it’s someone we really like, it’s okay. But if it’s someone we don’t like, then this is really uncomfortable, yeah, and we feel really threatened.

And there are examples where, with our mind, when we generate great hatred towards someone and the fire of hatred arises in our mind, we do have this expression, the fire of hatred. It’s not just a Buddhist expression, the fire of hatred in the mind, because that’s what it’s like. It’s like fire in our mind, in our body. When we have intense anger, the body gets hot, it turns red, ugly, perspiration, everything. It’s unbearable.

And sometimes when there’s incredible fear and anger in the mind and one uncontrollably wants to hurt someone, in our desperation, in our fear and anger, we look around and what is like a nice vase, we think, Oh, I smashed on the head. This is good for smashing on the head. It doesn’t appear as a vase, it appears as a weapon. We turn everything in our mind, our mind of anger and hate, turns everything ugly, turns everything into ugliness and harm. Planes weren’t meant to be crashed into buildings, but when there’s incredible hate, oh, what a good idea.

So this is called the reviving hell. Maybe this is enough, It gets worse. How long does the reviving hell last? One point six two trillion years. The causes of this state are killing people in war, murder, mutilating others, picking fights, holding grudges, acting out of hatred.

The lowest of the hot hells is called the Avicii hell, the hell of unrelenting pain. In this state, one has this enormous body that is incredibly delicate and itself is like on fire. It’s indistinguishable between the fire of the hell and the being itself are indistinguishable. The causes of this are creating any of the five heinous crimes killing one’s parents, an arhat, causing division in the Sangha, wounding a Buddha, fighting with one’s parents or with one’s spiritual teacher, killing religious people, denigrating the Dharma, or if one is an ordained monk or nun breaking any of the four root vows. You can read the descriptions in Pabongka’s Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand, they’re also in here, which is the source, Lama Tsongkhapa’s stages of the path to enlightenment.

Again, if you read the teachings of Lamat Tsongkhapa, Lamat Tsongkhapa is considered among all the four schools of Tibetan Buddhism to be one of the greatest scholars to ever have appeared in Tibet. Just from an ordinary point of view, from a conventional point of view, he was a brilliant being, an absolutely brilliant scholar. His writings are considered to be some of the finest presentations of the Buddhadharma written on this planet, the finest presentations of Mahāyāna teachings and his incredibly precise explanations of tantra, the product of an unbelievably refined intelligence, like a huge intelligence. I mean, if any people here have heard His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, teach, and one has tried to study the Buddhadharma at any depth, even a teeny bit, one starts to get some idea of the unbelievable intelligence and knowledge and wisdom of His Holiness. It’s just incredible, his knowledge.

His Holiness not only knows back to front all of the Gelugpa tradition, he also knows the Nyingma tradition, the Kagyu and Sakya. He is a lineage holder of all of these different teachings. And each of these four schools has their own terminology, their own concepts, and His Holiness knows all of them exactly and is able to explain exactly the difference between how the Nyingma explains something like this, and the kagyu explain it like that, and the Sakyas explain it like that, and the Gelugpas explain it like that. Without any confusion, His Holiness can explain it in a very short, precise, concise, perfectly clear, brilliant way. Lama Tsongkhapa was like that.

Lama Tsongkhapa, with all due respect, His Holiness, manifested in an even more magnificent way than His Holiness, the Dalai Lama. So Lama Tsongkhapa talks about the hell realm. This is the point. The point? This being with incredible intelligence talks about these realms, believed in their existence.

So how come we know they don’t exist? We know, we know, you know. Hey man, I know these don’t exist. I’ve been around twenty five years, honestly. I know.

I’m fifty, I know. I haven’t got a clue about my mind but man, I know that the hell realms don’t exist. I’ve taken drugs, it’s great, no hell. I’m sorry, we can’t say that we know they don’t exist. We just hope they don’t.

We just hope they don’t. But that doesn’t make them not exist. So, I don’t want to believe they exist. I don’t want to believe this, but the Buddha taught this, so it’s worth considering. Just very briefly, there are also the cold hells there are the cold hells which are extremely, totally black and totally freezing like being in the Antarctic but it’s completely black.

And one is born in the ice, one’s body is like oneness with the ice, and there are also these eight levels where it becomes progressively more freezing and tormenting. The body splits apart and each when the blood comes out and each drop of blood is conscious and when it falls on the ice it’s tormenting. The main cause of the cold hells are holding distorted and antagonistic views with a cold blooded attitude. Also causing animals, humans, insects to freeze or die in the rain and cold. So this is just something about an introduction to some of the suffering of the lower realms.

Yes, the main cause is holding distorted and antagonistic views with a cold blooded attitude. And also specific causes are causing humans, animals, insects or so on to freeze or die in the rain and cold. Deliberately doing that, rejoicing in it, having no regret and so on. Nāgārjuna said, Even more stupid than one who fills a gold gem encrusted vessel with excrement is the one who, having been born human, performs negative deeds. Candrakīrti, the great master of the wisdom teachings, says: Now, when I have entered a rebirth in which I am under my own control and can live accordingly, if I do not hold myself back from destructive actions, then once I’ve fallen into the abyss of a worse realm and have entered a rebirth in which I am under the control of other forces, how will I ever be able to raise myself out of that again?

So we’re in this incredibly free situation, especially as a human being, especially with the precious human rebirth. It’s so incredibly sad, stupid, if in this situation we create the cause to fall back into the lower realms. However we conceive the lower realms. Okay, thank you very much for your attention. If you have some questions Yes?

How long does it take you from first meeting the timeline? Believe this almost straight away. True confessions. I don’t like talking about too much of the old days and what I was. I suppose I was some kind of hippie when I met the dharma, and of course I had some experience taking drugs, some of the minor ones, a bit of mushrooms, marijuana, not the heavy stuff, and sometimes this produced some pleasant experiences in the mind, but sometimes it experiences something quite fearful.

So this was induced by other substances, but it still was my mind. And so I have no doubt that I have the seed of the hell realms in my mind. I don’t doubt that. Some kind of hell. Sometimes reading these descriptions one can imagine worse states than the sutras explain.

Again, an example I give is sorry I read a newspaper account that in Syria the secret police there have a room which has all these and in the middle of the room there is a chair that is on some kind of lever, so you are strapped to it and it spins around, and all around the wall are these different kinds of swords and knives of different lengths and they can change it so you spin around slower or faster and you get slashed to bits with it. This is just in the human realm. Anyway, I don’t know why I said that. I don’t doubt that the mind can create these suffering states. And that if you can create them in this realm, then you just imagine you don’t have this body and this pleasant environment to modify.

You get on a negative train of thought, you start hallucinating in this fearful way. But then this body goes away, this environment goes away, and you’ve just got that thought. That’s hell. That’s the lowest one. This is called the hell of unrelenting torment.

In Sanskrit it’s called the Avici hell. The Sanskrit word for hell is Narak, so in Pabongka’s book there it mentions the Narak, so this is referring to the hell realms. Just one last one. Yes, to some extent, but I would agree with that. This realm, there are trees and this is and that, kind of fixed things which we all as humans generally experience in the same way, then we can say that, but then we also have our own unique experience of phenomena.

Some people don’t care a thing about trees and some people hug trees all day long, right? So, there’s these different specific experiences but there’s also a general kind of experience we have. So these teachings are talking about the general experiences one can have but then any particular individual can have it worse or better, last longer or shorter depending on one’s karma. But these are kind of giving general experiences. Just like one can say, in the human realm humans experience this and this and this.

I think we have to stop, it’s late, yeah? Next time, next time. So we dedicate the merit that by this merit may I always create the causes to experience only good rebirths, never to experience the lower rebirths. In these high, better rebirths, may I always have the conditions and ability to practice the Mahāyāna Dharma and quickly achieve enlightenment for the benefit of all living beings. Sure.

May the precious Bodhi mind not yet born arise and grow. May that born have no decline but increase forevermore. K. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

Avici narme (Tib)
The lowest level of hell. LYWA
eight hot hells
The hell of being alive again and again, the black-line hell, the gathered and crushed hell, the hell of crying, the hell of great crying, the hot hell, the extremely hot hell and the inexhaustible hot hell. LYWA
hungry ghost preta (Skt); yi dag (Tib)
The hungry ghost realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence, exemplified by incredible insatiable hunger and thirst. LYWA
Kagyü
The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded in the eleventh century by Marpa, Milarepa, Gampopa, and their followers. One of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. Cf. Nyingma, Sakya and Gelug. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
narak nyel wa (Tib)
Hell, either an overall term for the hell realm, or a specific term, as in the hot hells or cold hells. LYWA
Nyingma
The old translation school of Tibetan Buddhism, which traces its teachings back to the time of Padmasambhava... LYWA
three realms traidhatu (Skt); kham sum (Tib)
The desire, form and formless realms. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top