25 min · 2,376 words · 25 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains the five aggregates (form, feeling, discrimination, consciousness and compositional factors) and how karmic imprints stay neutral until a delusion is triggered by meeting an object. It also covers the difference between being alone and lonely at death, especially when dying with love and compassion. It ends with a dedication, a food offering and an announcement of a later talk on the twelve links.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-25
Duration: 25 min
UUID: 534d1633-5e9c-4f4a-823e-23b3c4c0b42d
Words: 2,376
A book, which I think express the ideas of some Buddhists in some places, you try to avoid using the word I. Shopping, going shopping, you know, because there’s no I and to think I is bad, this is wrong view. There is an I. Buddha also says I. He said when he was born, said I am the world’s enlightened one.
But he wasn’t grasping that I as real. And even when we are thinking I, I, I, it’s not always totally the ignorance which is the source of suffering. It’s not really the correct view either, it’s not the correct view and experience, but it’s not also the totally ignorant view. Now, said the Tathāgata, all the Buddhas will rejoice. No, not always, but when he was born he did.
Maybe. Okay. But even if he never used the maybe just to remind people who he was, who they were dealing with, I don’t know. But bodhisattvas have the thought, I will save all sentient beings. I will practice, I will overcome the self-cherishing thought to benefit all sentient beings.
But there’s no grasping at that I as real. Combinations are possible, definitely. One can get angry with oneself because one has lots of doubts. I’m not qualified to say which in that case which is the root. No, I can’t say.
Sorry, I have to think about it. I have to think about it more. What was the first one that? No, it’s not that when we die we have to realize we’re totally separate from other people because even there what I was trying to make the point is that become dependent on others but then at the time of death we will be separate from all these beings we’ve depended on. So then we experience this sense of being extremely lonely.
There’s a difference between feeling lonely and being alone, having an awareness of being alone. What can I say, this gets quite complicated? The sense of I creates a false distinction between there is some difference. When we get enlightened we don’t just become everybody else. But there is a non dualistic way of experiencing others where there’s not this incredible gap.
We don’t become others but we are able to we have the ability to identify very strongly with others. But ignorance prevents that and pride makes it even worse. So when we’re dying, we are dying, we are alone, we are just ourselves left alone to die but as we’re dying, we can die with compassion and love for others. Having a strong feeling of connection with others, not this neurotic attachment to them that I am dying and I hope I can die in a way that I can benefit sentient beings. And you die with a thought of love and compassion for sentient beings.
So then one isn’t lonely, one is alone but one isn’t lonely. But when there isn’t this love and compassion for others, that one has relied on attachment throughout one’s life, not love and compassion but attachment, then the objects of one’s attachments are gone and one is left completely feeling lonely. One is alone and lonely in death. But with love and compassion one is alone in death but not lonely, not frightened because one doesn’t feel separated from others. The thought of others in a very positive meaningful way is there.
Yeah. Okay. What is the aggregate of compositional factors? So, to explain it, to understand it, it’s good to get a rough idea of the other four. There’s the form aggregate which is the body.
Simply speaking, it’s the body. You can also include all of the objects because the body has the five senses, you can also include the objects of the five senses as being the form aggregate. But generally, when dealing with meditation on the ‘I’ we talk about just the form itself. There’s the physical body and then the other four are aspects of the mind, so there are the feelings, with the collection of all feelings pleasant, unpleasant, neutral. Then there’s the discriminations or recognitions that are able to recognise the separate identities of phenomena.
This is round, this is square, this is this, this is that. This is a very basic function of mind to be able to recognise the different characteristics of phenomena. Then the fifth aggregate is consciousness which is referring to the six consciousnesses of the eye consciousness, the ear consciousness, nose, tongue, body and mental consciousness, the six primary consciousnesses. So the six primary consciousnesses, what is meant very roughly by the term primary consciousness is that the eye, for example, the primary eye consciousness simply experiences shape and colour, that’s all. And then there are what are called the secondary minds.
There’s the primary minds and the secondary minds. So the secondary minds function to add all the details of the experience, of the primary experience of the eye, the ear, the nose, the tongue, the body and the mind. So the fifth aggregate is the six primary consciousnesses. And then the fourth aggregate of compositional factors is all the other aspects of the mind which are not feelings, discriminations and the primary consciousnesses. So it’s referring to all the secondary minds.
The secondary positive ones such as love, compassion, patience, perseverance, generosity, all of these, all the negative minds, anger, attachment, ignorance is one of the compositional factors. All our perceptions, conceptions, dreams, fantasies, all of these go into that one. It’s kind of a bit of a trash bag one. So, not trash bag because it’s got the virtuous minds as well, it’s kind of a catch all one. In some cases that can be put there but karma isn’t consciousness.
So the compositional factors is mainly referring to I mean the way things get categorised in Indian Tibetan traditions gets very funky in some ways and confusing, but especially in terms of doing meditation on the I, we need to understand the five aggregates, then the four there’s the other four aggregates, which are not the form aggregate, are all referring to consciousness, aspects of consciousness. So karma, the karmic imprint, is not consciousness. It’s not form or consciousness, it is this phenomena which is neither. In Tibetan it’s called something like tsenmin duché, tsenmin duché. That which is neither form nor consciousness, but an existing phenomena.
Because they’re thoughts. And what are feelings? Feelings. Every thought, every time there is a thought, is a feeling that goes with it. So love is the thought wanting happiness for self and others.
Is the thought wishing, may I and others, is not these words as such, right? But these words convey what love is, that it is the thought wishing myself and others to experience happiness. When that thought is existing in the mind, there is a feeling which goes with it and that is a pleasant feeling. It is a warm, pleasant feeling. And anger is a negative thought wanting to harm self or others, and it has an unpleasant feeling with it.
Compassion is the thought not wanting oneself or others to suffer and it has a pleasant feeling with it, not an unpleasant feeling. Because all virtuous minds generate pleasant feelings and all non virtuous minds generate unpleasant feelings. And neutral thoughts generate neutral feelings. And these go together simultaneously. You can’t have a feeling without a thought.
I don’t think so, as an ordinary person. No, in the very same moment. So, maybe we can go on a little bit on how the delusions arise. So we have these disturbing thoughts, the six root ones, from that many others, the eighty four thousand spread out. And so, why do they arise in the mind?
So, generally we consider that there are five reasons why the six reasons why the delusions become manifest, active in our mind. And the first one is just simply that the primary cause for the delusions to become manifest in the mind is simply because the imprint is there. The imprint of the delusion is there in our mind. Again that imprint is not form or consciousness, it is this third category, this imprint. I think according to Western this may be completely wrong but my understanding of at least some view of Western psychology is various mental problems we have come about because we’ve had some disturbing experience at some point in our life and there’s always these underlying thoughts about that going on that disturb us and cause all sorts of false behaviour, these unconscious sorry, subconscious thoughts operating all the time.
I think there’s something like that that cause us to project all sorts of things. So one may think that that is how karma, these karmic imprints are working also, that we, for example, generate anger, then we create this karmic seed from anger, That’s bubbling away deep down in our mind, hurting us. But this is not how it works, it’s not like that. These negative imprints they’re called negative imprints because the cause is negative and the result will be suffering. But these negative imprints themselves exist in a neutral state, they are not causing suffering or happening, the negative imprints aren’t causing suffering in the mind while are in that state as imprints.
So the imprints of the delusions aren’t bubbling away causing anger attachment subtly deep down in the mind. This is not the case. They are neutral. But they do have the effect of obscuring the mind, the imprints of the delusions, the imprints of the negative karma, both although they’re inert and neutral while they’re existing in the mind, they do have the effect of obscuring the mind, preventing the quality of knowing from functioning as it could. But they are neutral, so the delusions exist in a potential form as imprints in our mind, and when they’re in this potential form they are in a neutral state.
They’re not bubbling away, you know, there’s not this anger secretly in our bubbling underneath the surface. I mean there can be anger bubbling underneath the surface of the conscious mind but this is not the imprint of the delusion, that means actually the delusion is functioning. Did that get confusing? No? So there can be anger that we’re conscious of, there may be some subconscious anger underneath the surface which we’re not admitting and recognising.
We can be acting very cool, you know, very calm, but we’re doing it because we’re suppressing this anger. But that anger is active, so that is the delusion anger. But in this case, even though it’s maybe hidden from our conscious mind or we don’t identify it like as anger, it is anger, it is the delusion. Don’t tell me I’m angry, I’m not angry. So if it’s there, it’s the delusion.
But why that delusion becomes active, either in a very gross obvious way or in some subtle way, is because of the imprint. So the imprint exists in a passive neutral way in the mind. And it comes from, for example, the imprint of anger exists because we acted on anger at a previous moment, and that previous moment of anger in this life or in a previous life left an imprint. And of course, that previous moment of anger existed originally because of ignorance, that’s the root source. But the immediate source of why we get angry is because we have the imprints of anger in our mind from previous moments of anger.
Right? So that’s the primary cause. We have these seeds or tendencies or latencies or potentials in our mind stream. And they’ve been built up since beginning, during beginningless time. So then why do these imprints become active in the mind?
Why do they start blossoming just like a seed in the ground? And so as I mentioned yesterday, the main reason is when consciousness meets the object. We meet the object, we experience the object, and then the delusion, this seed ripens, becomes manifest. We see we experience beautiful object, attachment arises. You know, we experience what we label beautiful object.
If we experience it as beautiful object, we label it beautiful object, then desire attachment arises because we have the instinct, the habit of doing that. Whenever there is beautiful object, we desire it, we get attached to it. Our mind goes to it instinctively. So that’s usually the main reason, coming across the object. So we may not experience any desire or attachment for long periods of time, and we may think, Oh, I don’t have any desire.
It’s gone, finished. It’s just that we haven’t met the object. We may not get angry for years and we think, Oh, I’m so wonderful, I’m so kind and loving, I don’t have any anger. It’s gone. It’s just we didn’t meet the object.
If we haven’t actually consciously worked at applying a valid, powerful antidote to our delusions, then we have to know that we still have anger. Anger doesn’t go away by itself because the imprints are there. So if in this life we haven’t actively cultivated the antidote to the different delusions, then sooner or later we will meet the object and the delusion will explode in our mind. Alright. Oh, eleven o’clock?
Did someone tell me ten thirty? I’m sorry. Okay. Okay. So maybe say meditation time at ten thirty something.
Meditation time. Yeah, no, no, no. Just Yeah, but I sometimes forget. I get rid of, yeah, some things. So we can dedicate the merits that by this merit may we be able to recognize the disturbing thoughts, apply the antidote, and through this may we be able to quickly follow the complete path without any problems, difficulties, the complete path to enlightenment, achieve that state and continuously benefit ourselves and all living beings.
Partial. May the precious bodhi mind not yet born arise and grow. May that born have no decline but increase forevermore. So if people want to join in, there’s the food offering practice we can do. Om Ah Hum.
Thank you very much. Lama Lhundrup will come this afternoon at three thirty to teach on the twelve links.
Key terms in this teaching
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- tathagata de zhin sheg pa (Tib)
- Epithet for a buddha; literally, “one who has gone to suchness.” LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
What is the aggregate of compositional factors?
To understand it, it helps to have a rough idea of the other four aggregates. Form is the body. Feelings are the pleasant, unpleasant and neutral. Discriminations recognise the separate identities of phenomena, such as round or square. Consciousness is the six primary consciousnesses (eye, ear, nose, tongue, body and mental), which simply experience their basic objects, such as shape and colour for the eye. The compositional factors are all the other aspects of the mind that are not feelings, discriminations or primary consciousnesses, meaning all the secondary minds.