44 min · 5,503 words · 23 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teacher explains that contemplating suffering in saṃsāra, which is driven by delusion and karma, motivates the wish to develop wisdom. He discusses how good karma only brings comfort within saṃsāra, and how compassion for oneself and others leads to wisdom. He then goes through the six sufferings, including uncertainty, dissatisfaction, repeated rebirth in bodies and rising and falling.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-23
Duration: 44 min
UUID: 98c65c26-84ab-4387-afbc-10392f585246
Words: 5,503
Better mattress. I want a TV set in my room. I want the walls painted. I want better I want curtains. Better curtains, more cushions, carpet on the floor.
So we spend all the energy, we’re in this jail, and we put all this energy into making our cell comfortable. But what we don’t realise is that this cell that we’re in is actually not just an ordinary jail, but it’s a concentration camp. And the people there are planning to torture us day by day and then kill us. But we have no idea because we’re just in this little cell, that’s all we’re aware of, and we don’t like the cell, and we want to make the cell comfortable. So instead of if we realise that we’re going to be tortured and murdered, we would try to escape.
Look, put our energy into escaping, because we’re definitely going to be tortured horribly and then killed. If we knew that, I mean, what’s the point of making the cell comfortable? I mean, what’s the point? There’s absolutely no point. If they chop your flesh to pieces, whether you’ve got a soft cushion, soft mattress, or a hard mattress, it’s not going to make any difference.
We’ll be in so much pain, there’s no difference, we won’t even notice. Where they’re on the floor, bed, bed with mattress, bed with most expensive mattress, it doesn’t make any difference. If we knew that we’re going to be tortured, what’s the point of painting the walls? We need to escape. Yeah.
Find a method to escape and put the time into to applying, you know, digging digging a hole in the wall, in the ground or something to escape. Looking around, is there a way to escape? Oh, there is a way to escape. And rather than repainting the room, rearranging the furniture, reading magazines, watching television, I could be I found the method to escape and I have to put energy into creating that escape route. But while we think, Oh, just this cell’s not too bad, but I just rearrange it, that’s okay, then I’ll be happy.
Yeah? So this is what we’re this is our situation, the Buddha said. We don’t believe it, we can’t believe it, but we’re in this concentration camp, waiting to be tortured in the lower realms, and we’re concerned with having a cozy little life, comfortable. This is the self-cherishing thought, trying to be cozy and comfortable, secure, having a security, having this nice secure jail cell when there is no security anyway because everything’s impermanent. And meanwhile, the concentration camp is being built.
So, this is why the Buddha taught about all the realms and the suffering we can experience, because it’s there, and sooner or later we experience it. We can postpone it and postpone it and postpone it, but sooner or later it comes. So the more we think about it and see this suffering and the potential we have for it, then we’re forced to look for the causes. Then we discover the causes are in our mind, they’re not out there, they’re in our mind, and we can eliminate them. They’re not stuck in our mind forever, they’re not a natural part of our mind, they’ve always been there, but amazingly, or not amazingly enough, they are not a natural part of our mind.
They are what are called adventitious. They are adventitious defilements. Adventitious defilements, great expression, I like that. I don’t think I really know what it means, but they’re called adventitious defilements, just momentarily arising, just appearing moment by moment and not a fixed aspect of the mind. Alright, thanks.
Alright. So this next set of meditations are about thinking about suffering, the suffering that we have, the suffering that we could have while the mind is controlled by delusion and karma. And the purpose is to wake us up, to discover the causes within our mind and apply the antidotes to those causes. To learn the antidotes, to firstly really subdue those delusions, but with an aim to be able to eliminate them. Okay, we take a break.
If we do that, it still isn’t going to protect us from suffering. We still remain trapped in saṃsāra, that is our mind controlled by delusion and karma. Maybe we’re less controlled by karma, but still, which is important, we’ve become less and less controlled by karma, but still delusion is there. But anyway, since while delusion is there, we keep creating fresh karma. It’s also important to understand that when we talk about creating good karma and bad karma, This good karma, just generally speaking, unless, as I try to indicate, if it’s really created not only with a bodhicitta thought and dedicated to enlightenment, but it’s actually mixed with a mind that has some understanding of emptiness.
That kind of karma becomes an actual cause to get out of saṃsāra. But general good karma that we create just creates the conditions that ripens as happiness in saṃsāra. We’re still in the concentration camp, we’re just getting a fluffier pillow in the cell. All good karma just does that, generally ordinary good karma created with the ordinary mind without much understanding of emptiness and so on, keeps the cell cozy. But if one how to make the analogy, I’m not sure exactly, but if we’re digging the tunnel out of the cell, can put it this way, we can create good karma just to have a nice cozy cell.
That’s the very sort of worldly view, but then if we realize we need to get out of the cell and we have to dig this tunnel, well, it’s going to take time. It’s going to take time to dig this tunnel, it’s going to take energy, So, while we’re digging the tunnel, we still need a comfortable cell. Yeah, good food, be able to sleep well, not just because all we want to do is sleep, but we need to have a good sleep so we can get up and keep digging the tunnel. We need to have a relaxing sleep, so when we wake up we’ve got the energy to dig the tunnel some more. So it’s good to have a comfortable bed, nice food, and also if we keep you know, we can’t dig the tunnel all the time so we have to relax a little bit, so the television set’s nice and these kinds of things.
So in that sense, also in following the path to liberation and enlightenment, we need to create good karma to have the conditions, the comfortable, the necessary conditions, to practice the Dharma. Basically, good karma is just doing that. What we need to do is go beyond that. To get out of saṃsāra we have to eliminate the delusions altogether. Again, should clarify this point for the new people, that the different delusions we have, you don’t eliminate those one by one.
First, for example, rid of the small delusions like jealousy and pride and this and that, and then you get rid of anger, and then you get rid of desire, and like that. It’s not like that, they all go at once, and the way to get rid of them is by chopping the root, the root of the tree, which is ignorance. You eliminate ignorance and all the delusions go at once. You don’t get rid of one delusion and then the other, because all the delusions are connected to that root of ignorance. While that root of ignorance is there, the different delusions keep growing out of it again and again.
So, the only way is you cut that root, that root of ignorance, and then all the delusions are gone. Generally speaking, I mean, there’s some but generally that’s how it is. As this ignorance is whittled, you have to whittle it away, as it’s whittled away you get rid of the gross delusions, the gross level of the delusions, the subtle level of the delusions, and then the very subtle. So first, one realises emptiness and the stages of that, you get rid of the gross of the gross delusions, then the middle gross delusions, then the subtle gross delusions, and then you get rid of the gross subtle delusions, then the medium subtle delusions, and then the subtle subtle delusions, then you get rid of the gross very subtle delusions, the medium very subtle delusions, and then you get rid of the very subtle when the ignorance is actually totally established in the mind, then the very subtle aspect of the delusion is gone. But it’s all of them together gone.
Something like that. So what gives us the energy to want to develop this wisdom is the motivation of our own suffering. And at first, that’s the first motivation, realizing our own potential for suffering. And then, as we’re motivated by that, since we’ve had a good karma to meet the Mahāyāna teachings, we can at the same time, even though that is our basic motivation, we can try to realise more and more that everyone is suffering, and everyone has the potential for more suffering, so that can become an even greater motivation to wish to achieve, to realize this wisdom, not just for one’s own sake, but to be able to pass it on to others. And in order to pass it on to others, I have to develop this incredible, great compassion for all sentient beings.
So this is the way Bodhicitta develops as well. So a bodhisattva how a bodhisattva really benefits sentient beings is teaching them wisdom. A bodhisattva has this amazing compassion for sentient beings, but it isn’t their compassion for sentient beings as such that benefits sentient beings. It’s the wisdom of the bodhisattva. Of course, a bodhisattva also tries to encourage people to be compassionate as well, because compassion modifies and subdues the delusions, but it doesn’t eliminate them.
There’s only one thing that eliminates our suffering, and that is the wisdom consciousness, directly perceiving things as they are. Compassion modifies it for ourselves, our compassion for ourselves modifies our suffering, our compassion for others modifies their suffering, but it doesn’t eliminate it. But it also acts as the context in which the more compassion we have for ourselves, the more we become motivated to eliminate the cause of our suffering and therefore develop this wisdom. So the more compassion we have for ourselves, the more we will want to develop this wisdom. The more compassion we have for others, the more we will want them to develop their own wisdom, and the more we will want to help them develop that wisdom.
So this is why we talk about suffering now, our potential for suffering in order to develop a greater compassion for ourself that will cause us to develop this wisdom, that will motivate us to develop this wisdom, to put effort into understanding the teachings about wisdom, meditating on them, so we can actually gain the direct experience. Because all of us can do it, all of us. It doesn’t matter how conventionally intelligent or unintelligent we are from an ordinary point of view, every being can do it. Every being. Every one of us can do it, if we use the method, especially if we use the Dharma method and we rely on a qualified teacher.
Through the blessings of the qualified teacher, the understanding of emptiness comes. Even if one is very stupid, if one has devotion to the Guru, then one can realize emptiness faster than some incredibly brilliant person. If one has faith and applies oneself. There is the story of, I can’t remember who, one of the Kadampa Geshe’s who had this incredible devotion to his teacher, who was another Kadampa Geshe, an older Kadampa Geshe of course. The Kadampa Geshe’s were the disciples of or the lineage of disciples from the great Indian master Atisha, who went to Tibet, who emphasized this very ascetic and powerful form of practice, which there was a great deal of that influence in the Gelugpa tradition.
It exists in all the four schools, but another name for the Gelugpa tradition is the new Kadampa, which is not the new Kadampa tradition anyway. Yeah, in Tibet they were called the new Kadampa, because Lama Tsongkhapa was like the new Atisha, because he emphasized this very the importance of morality and and very strong practice and so on, strong renunciation. Anyway, so this Geshe, whose Guru got very sick and manifested having lots of diarrhea and everything like that, so the disciple, the Geshe disciple, great devotion to his teacher, so he used to, wash his Guru’s body every day, wash all retreat off the body and collect it all, put it in the pot and take it downstairs and throw it away. So one day was doing this, he washed the Guru, his body was completely covered in filth and collected all the without any disgust, with complete devotion for the Guru, he collected all the filth, put it in a pot, and he was carrying this down the stairs. And as he’s carrying this pot of diarrhetic shit of his Guru, he realized emptiness because of his devotion, single pointed devotion to the Guru.
So they say. There is a story of one nun who, she went out begging and came back, and then she ate, and then she was washing her begging bowl, and the begging bowl tipped over and the water spilled out, and she watched the water of dribbling out of the pot along in the earth. Looking at that, she realized emptiness. But of course there were causes for it, she had to work for it, but that was the immediate thing that caused brought the experience to arise. So it doesn’t come about from being a genius, although the textual presentation of emptiness is very subtle and very complex, it looks like you have to be a genius to understand it.
But we all have the potential to be geniuses anyway, it’s just using our wisdom, and especially purifying our mind. The more we purify our mind, the more our wisdom functions. So what at first looks incredibly complex and remote and what’s this got to do with my life? To understand all these words, these concepts, actually as we purify our mind, we understand it more and more, and we understand the incredible importance of being able to really know, experience things as they are, to be able to experience oneself as one actually is, not how we would like to think we are and conceptualize and how we would like other people to think we are, but how we actually are. Because the way we actually exist is very fascinating.
The way everything else is existing is very fascinating and very kind of insubstantial. Existing but not truly existing. And experiencing that way of interesting sorry, experiencing that way of existing is much more interesting when one is actually experiencing it. It’s much more light. It’s actually blissful.
What is the difference between experiencing this with a mind controlled by delusion and karma, and a mind that is free of delusion and karma, that has wisdom present? When we experience this, it’s suffering. Our mind experiences suffering, not gross suffering, not suffering of pain, but it’s not satisfying experiencing this. There’s no satisfaction, it’s not tremendously satisfying looking at this thing. I mean, me, I don’t know about you, you may get a whole lot of bliss out of looking at this but for me it’s kind of not it’s kind of like if I keep looking at this I’m going to get really bored, you know.
It’s not satisfying. But when one has realized emptiness, the true nature of things, when one even just looking at that, it gives rise to bliss. It’s blissful, everything is blissful. Everything, everything is blissful. So they say.
But it’s worth trying to see if it’s true. Because when you look at some of the great practitioners, they seem to reflect that quality. So, it all comes from thinking about suffering and feeling that. This is the interesting thing. It all comes from that.
Real happiness doesn’t come from thinking about happiness, it comes from thinking about suffering. And not thinking about it in some kind of remote abstract way, but thinking about it for the purpose of feeling it, feeling it in our guts, feeling our own suffering, and the more we can feel our own suffering and our potential, we can feel it, we can see it in others. We can see it in others, no matter what they say or do. You can start to see it and feel it, and then compassion can arise, and then the motive, the wish to develop wisdom for not just one’s own sake but for all suffering beings can arise. So, there’s many ways to think about suffering but in the Lamrim presentation there’s the presentation of thinking about the six sufferings, the eight sufferings and the three kinds of suffering.
There’s many more but they can all be included in this way of looking at things. So the six sufferings refer to these are existing in most of the realms of saṃsāra. If we think of the three major realms, the desire realm, the form realm, the formless realm, then these six sufferings, at least some of them, apply to all the different realms. They’re more or less common to all of saṃsāra. The eight sufferings are more specific to the desire realm, especially the human realm, and the three sufferings apply well, when we get to the third sufferings, the third of the three sufferings, that applies to every samsaric realm situation.
Anyway, first we can think a little bit about the six sufferings. The first of these is that while we’re in saṃsāra there is always the suffering of uncertainty, that nothing can be really relied on within saṃsāra, everything is changing and therefore uncertain, indefinite. And basically, it means this suffering arises because nothing lasts. Nothing in saṃsāra lasts. Out of saṃsāra, liberation and enlightenment last, but within saṃsāra nothing lasts.
So, is this suffering of things being uncertain or indefinite or unreliable. So every pleasure we experience in the human realm is suffering because it doesn’t last, we can’t rely on it. And the things that produce that happiness other people, money, wealth, fame, power, possessions, they don’t last. We can’t rely on them. They’re completely uncertain.
So this is a suffering in the sense that it’s not fulfilling, it’s not completely satisfying. To experience happiness that doesn’t last is suffering because it is unfulfilling, it’s unsatisfying, and it’s ultimately frustrating. So everything in saṃsāra is like that. You know, one maybe it’s hard to believe, but the Buddha taught there are these incredible pure god realms where one there’s this amazing bliss and it goes on for millions of years. In the formless realm, I don’t remember how long it lasts, in formless realm there’s this unbelievable bliss that lasts for millions and millions of years.
In fact, more than millions of years, it lasts for eons. And it’s very difficult to conceive what Buddhists the Buddhists mean by an eon. But think one analogy that the Buddha gave is something that if you were to take a room like this, you filled it with sesame seeds and every one hundred years you took out one sesame seed. An eon or something like that. The time it would take to take out all the sesame seeds if you took out one every hundred years, something like that’s an eon.
Rough idea of what an eon is, but there’s millions and millions and millions of years. So, one can go the samsaric mind can experience that bliss for millions of years, billions of years. But the Buddha said, this is suffering, it is this suffering of uncertainty because it doesn’t last, it’s not reliable. In the teachings it says, actually to experience this bliss, to be born in these realms can be incredibly terrible because the beings who cultivate the concentration that leads to being reborn in that state do it believing that that meditation that they’re doing is actually the cause to achieve liberation. They think that state is liberation, so they are born, and so then in that life they achieve that concentration, they think they’re liberated, when they die, their mind continues into that actual realm state, And so, at the moment of death, their mind takes rebirth into that God realm, they think, Now, yes, definitely, I’ve achieved moksha, I’ve achieved liberation.
And then the mind goes into that mindless blissful state for millions and millions of years, and then it comes to an end, and that being wakes up and thinks, I thought I achieved liberation, but it doesn’t exist. Liberation is impossible because I experienced it and it came to an end. Then one generates one of the extreme wrong views, which is liberation is impossible, and then the mind falls into the lowest realms. This is very unsatisfying. And that view that liberation is impossible is very strong.
It’s a very deep imprint because the person believed that they had definitely experienced the highest thing possible and it didn’t last. This may be Buddhist propaganda, but if it’s true, it’s important why it’s important to know the whole path and what the path really leads to, real liberation is. Because the Buddha himself in the life story, he studied these two with the two greatest teachers of India at the time. The first one taught meditation that leads to the concentration the highest in the highest form realm, that the highest level concentration of the formless realm. The Buddha, Prince Siddhartha, as a renunciate, as an ascetic, experienced that meditation, and he realized this is not liberation.
Then he went to this other teacher and achieved, who taught that liberation is achieving the fourth absorption of the formless realm. The Buddha, Prince Siddhartha, achieved that state and realized that is not liberation. So then he sat under the Bodhi tree to discover what real liberation was. And it’s not just subduing the delusions, it’s eliminating them totally, because these concentrations, these meditations just subdue the delusions. They give the appearance that the delusions are eliminated, but the Buddha discovered that concentration does not destroy delusion, it does not destroy ignorance, it just pacifies it.
The second suffering that we can experience, the kind of suffering to contemplate, to think about So this suffering of uncertainty we experience in this human realm as well, of course. That we have so many pleasures but they don’t last, and the longer they last, when it comes to an end, more suffering, more shock. We didn’t expect it, we thought we got the real thing. We’ve we’ve discovered true love, yeah, the perfect job, the perfect house, the perfect place to live, but then something happened and it didn’t last. It didn’t last the way we wanted.
So the second suffering is the suffering of dissatisfaction, discontent, wanting more. We experience pleasurable things but then we want more, and then we experience other beautiful things and we want more. This is the nature of afflicted desire, as I quoted, following desire is like drinking salt water. It doesn’t stop our thirst, it actually acts as a condition for us to want more, to drink more. So the way to contemplate just to go back with the suffering of uncertainty, one way to contemplate that is first looking at our experiences in this life and thinking how frustrating it is just to have some pleasure, to work so hard, to get some pleasure, some happiness, and then it comes to an end.
Then we have to create the causes of more, and it comes to an end. Then we have to create the causes of more, and then it comes to an end. And then we die, and then we have another rebirth, and we get some pleasure, and it comes to an end. Then we have to work to create more, and it comes to an end. Then we create the causes for more, and it comes to an end.
Then we die, and then we get a little bit of pleasure, it comes to an end. Then we have to create the causes for more, and it comes to an end. I could go on for many hours, but this is the way to meditate, to drive ourselves nuts. This is pointless. This is ridiculous.
Why am I doing this? It’s utterly it’s ultimately frustrating and boring. It’s insane to do this. If there’s nothing else, there’s no choice. What else?
Work away, get a little bubble of pleasure. If it disappears, work away, get another bubble of pleasure. But it’s crazy to do this if there’s some alternative. And there is an alternative. There’s the ongoing, eternal, immortal bliss of the mind to experience.
And we have the method, and we have the conditions, we have the precious human rebirth, the optimum conditions. I should have said this before, just to think about suffering if we have no belief that there’s something beyond it and a method to achieve it, of course, is very depressing. No point to think about suffering if we think there’s no solution to it. But in the context of having the precious human rebirth and believing that we found a method, we have some refuge in that method, faith in that method, and that we have the Buddha nature, we have this Buddha potential, then there is value in thinking about suffering. Because why just go through all this limited, boring, frustrating stuff if if with the same effort I could experience something else?
As Śāntideva said, this great Indian bodhisattva Śāntideva said, the work of this life, of saṃsāra, is endless. There’s always something to do in the cell, you know, in the jail cell, paint the bars, paint the bars blue, paint the bars pink, paint the bars purple, green, yellow, pale yellow, dark yellow, very dark yellow. There’s so many things to do in a jail cell, endless things you can do, yeah, Endless, but the work never comes to an end, and no satisfaction. No satisfaction. The spiritual life is hard work, but it’s no harder than worldly life, it’s no harder.
And it’s not frustrating, it brings the result. There’s the end result which is total satisfaction. So again, with the second suffering we can think there’s the suffering of discontent, of always wanting more, never being satisfied. We have some pleasure but it’s not enough, we need it some more or something better. We have a car, then we see a better car, so we want the better car, but then there’s a better car, and then we buy a suit, then there’s a better suit or pair of jeans, but there’s a new fashioned jean, you know, I’ve got the old fashioned jeans, you know, something, you know, there’s always something better.
So we can contemplate, even in this life, always chasing after what’s better and the mind not at ease. But then we have to think in a broader context, we’ve been doing this life after life. And in previous lives, we’ve had infinite, vast numbers of lives, every possible thing that we are chasing after in this life, thinking this will bring happiness, we’ve had it before if we understand the mind in previous lives. We’ve been there, done that a million times. We’ve been there, done that a trillion times.
We have been kings and queens and presidents, movie stars, rock and roll singers, basketball players, football heroes. Everything before. We have been the most beautiful person in the world before, the sexiest person in the world before, the most loved person. We have been princess Di millions of times. Someone like that, not that one, but something like that person.
The most loved, admired, famous, beautiful, trendy person in the world, millions of times. We’ve been there, done it a million, million, million times. And there’s nothing left, nothing left, nothing left. As Nāgārjuna said, you know, is it?
Whether the happiness lasts one second or a billion years, when it ends, it’s finished, nothing left, except perhaps the negative imprints. This may be hard to believe, but again, if we always go back, I’m sorry to bore you with this, if we try to think about mind, yeah, we have mind, not a brain, mind. Maybe we have a mind, Uncreated, indestructible mind going back and back, one life, another life, back and back, and there’s always a previous moment where we did that, been there, did that, and in the previous moment we were there and did that, and in the previous moment we were there and had done that, and in the moment before that we were somewhere else and did that, millions and millions of times. So why do it again? It’s not going to work any better.
It’s frustrating, and this is something else that we could be doing that works, that is beneficial for ourselves and others, is not harmful to others, and can ultimately be of incredible benefit to others, working with our mind, taking care of our mind, cultivating our mind. There’s the suffering of having to join with bodies again and again. We have to go through the suffering of the bardo state, the suffering of taking rebirth, there’s the suffering of being in the womb, for example, the suffering coming out of the womb. So the whole suffering process of taking a body and we do that again and again and again and again. Not just one time, if we don’t get out of saṃsāra, it goes on forever.
Joining with one body, human body, centipede body, snake body, cow body, god body, hell body, preta body, every kind of body again and again and again. Then there is the suffering of having to separate from these bodies. We take these bodies with so much suffering, then we identify that they’re me, we get totally attached to this body. Even when it grows old and ugly and weak, we’re still totally attached to it, it’s me. We’re completely attached and in love with our body, and then we have to leave it, completely ripped out of it.
Again and again, we take care of this body, get attached to it, wash it, paint it, all sorts of things to it, stick things in it, take things out of it, rearrange it, put you know, make some parts bigger, some parts smaller, you know. And then it collapses. Then we get another one, do the same thing Again and again and again and again and again. So the idea is to think like in this broad perspective, you know, one time okay, I can deal with it. Two times, okay.
Three times, four times, a hundred times, a thousand times, a million times, a billion times, a trillion times. Come on, it’s too much. Enough is enough. So we try to contemplate like that to try to see, is this true or not? Is this just some Buddhist fantasy?
Or if there is mind, is this how the mind works? Going on and on like that. Then the fifth one is the suffering of rising and falling, suffering of fluctuation. We’ve done uncertainty, dissatisfaction, leaving the body again and again, joining the body again and again, that’s four, we’re on to number five. They may be in different order, and it’s called what?
Rising and falling? Yeah, okay. Which is referring to the fact that even in one life, we rise up to a particular position, but it doesn’t last, we fall down. Every meeting comes to an end, we gather friends around us, we meet our friends, we have to be separated from our friends. We collect possessions, but then we’re separated from our possessions.
Again and again, whatever we collect has to be dispersed. Whenever a meeting takes place, it has to end in separation. Whatever goes up has to come down. We become very rich, we have to lose that. We become very powerful, we have to lose it.
We become very knowledgeable, we have to lose it. We become very famous, we have to lose it. We become very beautiful, we have to lose it. We become very healthy, it collapses. Whatever comes, it’s all fluctuating, rising and falling.
This is frustrating. But liberation and enlightenment doesn’t rise and fall. Once it’s established in the mind, it is stabilized there. This is worth working for. And so this happens in this life.
Yeah. There’s constant change.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
- The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- Gelug
- The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
- preta
- Hungry ghost, or spirit. The preta realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
- Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.