Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 29 Tape 59 Side 2 Bodhicitta

43 min · 4,965 words · 29 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 29 Tape 59 Side 2 Bodhicitta
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains the law of cause and effect as the essence of Dharma, showing that observing it means renouncing self-cherishing and caring for oneself, which leads to compassion, bodhicitta and wisdom. It covers how karma ripens (throwing, completing and habitual karma, and the cows-in-a-barn analogy), how negative karma arises from mind, speech and body, and how following disturbing thoughts obstructs concentration and realisation of emptiness.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-29

Duration: 44 min

UUID: c4e0506b-ea6d-4fc2-85aa-304df1b9ceb8

Words: 4,965

Discover the nature of our mind, its quality of clarity and knowing, we begin to understand that it is eternal, it will last forever. As soon as we begin to understand that, then the question arises: what is more beneficial, sorry, important, the happiness of this life, the suffering of this life, or the possibility of happiness in our future existence that goes on and on eternally, or what is more important, the suffering that we may experience on and on eternally in our future existences. Thinking about this, we consider how important it is to discover a path that leads us away from all suffering and the causes of suffering, a path that leads us to experience eternal happiness. And When we generate that refuge, then we discover the importance of having a teacher who can wisely guide us along that path, compassionately guide us, skillfully guide us, so that we don’t cause any more suffering to ourselves or others. And the first job of such a teacher is to encourage the disciple, the sincere disciple, to renounce the things of this life because that is the beginning of the spiritual path to liberation and enlightenment.

Nothing can happen without that. So especially, this can begin by recognising that we have a precious human rebirth, the optimum chance. Because we have the Eight Freedoms and Ten Endowments, we have the optimum conditions to renounce this life, renounce all of saṃsāra, and not only that, totally renounce the self-cherishing thought and achieve complete enlightenment. It all begins now in this life. We’ve wasted all our previous lives, so that’s past, and the past is past.

You can’t change the past. The past is the past. By changing the present, then the past is changed in the sense that all the negative karma we created in the past can be purified, but the past is the past. But there is the present arising moment by moment, and every moment with this precious human rebirth we can do amazing things with it, we develop the right wisdom, we follow the right method. So it’s so important to check, to have confidence that we have found the right method to follow.

So, the meditation teachings, the topics I’ve been covering so far, are topics to be meditated on, not once, but again and again, until we gain a deep experience, insight into them, or a realisation that if we then continue to meditate on, we can maintain in our mind. So, particular meditation teachings, thought about the importance of the Guru and recognising that we have the precious human rebirth, then the very specific topics, meditation topics of impermanence and death, the suffering of the lower realms, taking refuge, meditation on refuge, and then the meditation on the law of cause and effect. This set of meditation teachings are the meditation teachings that if we do again and again with understanding, are the meditation teachings that bring about the renunciation of this life, renouncing our obsession with the small pleasures of this life that cause us to follow our disturbing thoughts and bind us to saṃsāra. Actually, our attachment to this life, following the attachment to this life By following that attachment, we create the causes of lower realms, not for human life. So these attachments, these meditation teachings, are designed for the purpose of each one has a specific purpose, but altogether their purpose is to bring about the basic renunciation.

And in a sense, the most important of them in some ways they’re all incredibly important, but the key one is the understanding of the law of cause and effect, and having that understanding, practising according to it in one’s daily life. Because in order to practise the law of cause and effect, one has to renounce one’s obsession with the things of this life, thinking that they are so important. We are attached to self-cherishing thought, is so obsessed with pleasure now, getting it easily, is so obsessed with stopping the suffering now and stopping it quickly, easily. And it is that mindset that is the condition for us to create every kind of negative karma. Because we want happiness now, we create negative karma to get it.

Because we want suffering to stop now, not the causes, we just want the suffering, the source of our problem to stop. self-cherishing isn’t concerned with the cause, the real cause. It likes to say the cause is other people, it’s got nothing to do with me, it’s got something out there is the cause. And we want it to stop immediately, so we create negative karma. So, when we realise that following the disturbing thoughts is creating negative karma and that results in suffering, when we understand that, then the whole focus of our mind and our life changes.

Having developed the renunciation of this life, which is what is it? It is having genuine love and compassion for oneself, really taking care of oneself. When one really starts to change one’s mindset from self obsession to actually caring for oneself because self obsession is not caring for oneself. It doesn’t care for oneself correctly at all. So when one changes from being self obsessed and full of self-cherishing to caring for oneself, one observes the law of cause and effect.

That becomes the most important thing to avoid creating negative karma as much as possible and to accumulate as much good karma as possible because that will bring happiness for me. Also, what does it involve? Involves the voiding of negative karma means we don’t experience suffering in the future, but the voiding of creating negative karma means we don’t cause suffering to others right now. Right? By accumulating by creating virtuous actions with our body, speech and mind now, it will bring happiness to us in the future.

But it means that by creating good karma now for our future happiness, it brings happiness to others right now. So the law of cause and effect, as I try to say, is when we take refuge, we take refuge in the Dharma and the essential Dharma is the law of cause and effect because it contains all of the Buddha’s teachings in it. It is the seed of all the Buddha’s teachings. Is the practice of loving kindness to oneself. Loving kindness is love, or loving kindness is the thought wishing happiness.

Not worldly happiness but genuine happiness. So, if we have loving kindness for ourselves, we observe the law of cause and effect. If we don’t have loving kindness for ourselves, we don’t observe it. If we have compassion for ourselves, not the mind which does want suffering and especially the causes of suffering, then if we have that compassion for ourselves, we avoid creating negative karma. If we have loving kindness for ourselves, we create good karma.

We put a lot of effort into that. So this is the practice of loving kindness and compassion for ourselves. And if we don’t have love and compassion for ourselves, there is no way we can really develop it for others and sustain it for others. Develop it and increase it in the way it can be by following the Buddhadharma method where it transforms into not just compassion for the suffering of suffering, but we can develop the compassion for those who are experiencing the suffering of change, which is what we think is happiness. We can develop the compassion that is for all sentient beings because all sentient beings are experiencing compounded, pervasive suffering, the most subtle kind of suffering.

On the basis of that, we can then generate great compassion, and on the basis of great compassion, we can generate Bodhicitta, and on the basis of Bodhicitta, we can achieve enlightenment. It all starts from having love and compassion for oneself, which comes from practicing the law of cause and effect. If we really care for our self, this person that we are, that is validly existing, the way the person validly exists, the person that we are that validly exists, that person exists merely in dependence on this body and mind. If the mind is under the control of delusion and karma, there is no way the person that we validly are can be happy, genuinely happy, at peace, if the mind isn’t at peace and if the mind is obscured by delusion and karma. Because what the person that validly exists is something totally dependent on our mind, it is not something separate.

If the mind is happy, the person that we validly are is happy. If the mind is suffering and confused and depressed and agitated, then the person that we validly are is suffering, depressed, confused and so on. Because we are our mind, not exactly totally, but we are totally dependent on our mind. There is no person that we validly are that is somehow separate from our mind. Our ignorance thinks we are something totally separate from our mind.

That’s why we think we can do negative actions and not suffer. That’s why all suffering comes from ignorance. Like I said before, with a policeman you can say, I’m sorry, I didn’t know the laws of this country, please don’t fine me, please don’t throw me in jail. And maybe we can convince, using the argument of ignorance, we can escape. But, in terms of the mind, why all suffering comes from ignorance?

We can’t say, Oh, I’m sorry, I didn’t know about the law of cause and effect. There’s no one you can say that to, to get out of the suffering of not knowing the law of cause and effect. Following the self-cherishing thought disturbs the mind. It is not caring for the mind. It is the mind that harms it is the thought which harms our mind.

So following the self-cherishing thought, there’s no way for the mind to be at peace or happy, therefore there’s no way for the person I validly am to be happy. It’s only when we overcome our self-cherishing and replace it with genuine love and compassion for ourselves that we can be happy. When we have genuine love and compassion for ourselves, we take care of our mind. Because it’s only by taking care of our mind that I can be happy. Because I am what depends on my mind.

Just like our body depends on food, we put poisonous food in our body, we will get sick. The poisonous food may taste delicious, so the self-cherishing thought likes, Oh, delicious. Eat it. It doesn’t matter if it’s poisonous. But we’re going to suffer no matter what the self-cherishing thought says and how much it says, This is delicious, this is good.

But it’s poisonous. If we use our wisdom and recognise that, we don’t eat poisonous food no matter how delicious it is. And if we really want to take care of our body, we will eat something that is nutritious even if it tastes bad. But the dharma doesn’t taste bad. When one really listens in the right way and practises in the right way, it is also delicious.

It is, as Tenzin Zopa said, delightful. It is delightful. So, practising the law of cause and effect contains within it all the practices of loving kindness and compassion and Bodhicitta that lead to enlightenment. No way to achieve enlightenment if we don’t understand and observe the law of cause and effect. It is also the practice of wisdom.

It is wise to observe the law of cause and effect. It’s a basic kind of wisdom, intelligence, to be able to recognise what is the cause of suffering, what real suffering is and what its cause is, what is real happiness or more genuine happiness and what its cause is. So this is wise, this is wisdom. Practicing the law of cause and effect is a type of wisdom and it leads to every kind of wisdom. Because the highest wisdom arises in our consciousness, the highest wisdom that destroys ignorance, all confusion, all suffering, the highest wisdom rises in our mind through understanding dependent arising.

Lama Tsongkhapa explained in his teachings. One of the unique contributions of Lama Tsongkhapa is the easiest way There are many ways to understand the empty nature of all phenomena, but the easiest way is by understanding dependent arising. Ignorance creates the illusion that things are independent, separate, they do not depend on anything. That’s what ignorance does. The understanding of dependent arising destroys that view that anything can be independent.

It is utterly impossible for anything in the universe, including the universe itself, to be independent of any kind of force whatsoever. Nothing can exist that way. Things exist either depending on causes and conditions, or parts, or the labelling mind. Everything depends on those things. At least all impermanent things depend on all those factors.

Permanent things don’t depend on causes and conditions, but they depend on parts and the labelling mind. So the law of cause and effect, if we really understand it, is part of this understanding of dependent arising. Our suffering arises dependently. Our happiness arises depending on things. It is not a truly existing phenomena.

If it was a truly existing phenomena, we could never be happy. If we’re not happy now and happiness, genuine happiness, was a truly existing phenomena that did not arise dependently, we could never be happier. Because it arises dependently, we can have happiness. If our suffering, which we all have, we all are suffering now, if our suffering truly existed, it could never come to an end. But because it doesn’t truly exist from its own side, but is arising dependently, we can change it, we can eliminate it.

So, the understanding of the law of cause and effect is an integral part, an inescapable part of developing the highest wisdom. And from another side, how does one even if one has a complete intellectual, a perfect unmistaken understanding of emptiness, will not bring about wisdom, that will not destroy ignorance. In no way will that intellectual understanding destroy our ignorance, the source of suffering. We have to meditate on it. And even meditating on it won’t do it.

We have to be able to meditate with single pointed concentration on it, in a state of actually calm abiding which is even little bit further beyond single pointed concentration. And how does one develop single pointed concentration? It only comes from subduing the disturbing thoughts. How do you subdue the disturbing thoughts? By not following them, by not creating negative karma.

We create negative karma by following the disturbing thoughts. And every time we follow the disturbing thought, we create the habit to follow the disturbing thought again, and again, and again, and again. So, in the process of creating negative karma, we strengthen our disturbing thoughts and we create obstacles to being able to develop single pointed concentration. And until we develop single pointed concentration, we will never realise the true nature of our self and phenomena. Apart from that, by following the disturbing thought creating negative karma which comes from following the disturbing thoughts, it creates every kind of obstacle to gaining every other realisation as well.

Because our mind is never able to concentrate long enough, focus long enough on what we’ve understood to transform it from just something up here to something deep in our consciousness. Creating negative karma is an obstacle to every realisation on the path and it’s the obstacle to the main realisation of wisdom. So, within the teachings of the law of cause and effect is contained all the teachings about how to develop loving kindness and compassion, basically, and how to be wise. And also, so that’s two of the three principal paths, and when one observes the law of cause and effect, one is practising renunciation. So it contains within it all the teachings of the Buddha.

All the teachings of the Buddha are contained in renunciation, wisdom from Bodhicitta. There is nothing else. And these are the things that one needs to transform the mind. And these are contained in the Buddhadharma completely. They may be contained in other teachings, under other titles, but I’m not sure.

But certainly they exist in the Buddhadharma. If one checks, if any of these qualities are missing, there’s no way to be totally free of suffering and to be able to totally benefit others. So it’s all contained in the teachings of the law of cause and effect. Since harming any sentient being harms us, we have to love every sentient being. It’s all there.

Even if we don’t kill an ant, which is the negative karma of body, which is the heaviest kind of negative karma, but if we still hate the ant, we’re creating negative karma. If we hate, if we love every sentient being in all the countless universes, but there is one ant that we hate, we will never achieve enlightenment. We will never even get liberation from suffering by hating one ant. Impossible. It blocks the mind, just obscures the mind.

By hating one ant, we develop the habit of hating, then it becomes easier to hate, it becomes easier to hate not just this one ant, but two ants, cockroaches, rats, dogs, mice, human beings. And all of Samsāra keeps going. So the law of cause and effect is unbelievably profound and important and wonderful. It’s the greatest protection in our life. So it’s important that it is also the most difficult thing to understand totally.

To develop the realisation of emptiness, the wisdom that realises the empty nature of phenomena is easier than to understand karma because the way things actually exist is called a hidden phenomena. It’s hidden from our it’s not apparent to our ordinary consciousness. It’s a hidden phenomenon, the way things actually exist. But the way karma works is a very hidden phenomenon that only Buddha mind can see and understand. Even arhats cannot understand or perceive, at least, the way karma works in its entirety.

So it depends on faith that we can develop some intelligent faith. Which again goes back to asking, Why does this happen? Here is an effect. What is the cause? Does it have a cause?

And, of course, the law of cause and effect can only be understood in terms of believing in mind. Because if you think a car accident just happens because this body, this lump of stuff is there and then this other metal stuff crunches into it. That’s the cause of the accident. Finished. No, nothing else.

It’s just there’s this thing there and this other thing comes along and bang. But why is this lump of flesh there? Because it’s got a mind that moves it around. And why is it there then? So that this thing comes along and crunches into it.

Why? Why does it happen to me? Because a person experiences that, And that person validly exists depending on a body and mind. Why do I experience this accident? And why do I have this body?

So, how does karma ripen? Buddha gave a very down to earth example of how karma ripens. In the sutras, the explanations, the analogies are really very wonderful, very simple and related to the ordinary life that existed at that time. But unfortunately, have changed, so maybe for us now, probably most people here are city dwellers, maybe not everybody. Anyway, the Buddha gave the example of karma ripens like if you have a barn of cows, a whole bunch of cows in a shed, locked up.

Cow gets out of this? When you open the door, which cow gets out first? Well, the biggest one, the heaviest cow, gets out first, usually. Or other factors being equal, then the strongest cow, the lead cow, in any herd there’s always the strongest cow, the one who takes charge, she will get out first. So, in the same way, the heaviest karma we create tends to ripen first.

But if that doesn’t happen, if the main cow, the strongest cow, doesn’t get out first, the one closest to the door will get out first, which means that the karma that we’ve created most recently will ripen next at the time of death. I’m not sure how the analogy goes now, but after that, then the karma which is most habitual ripens. And if that doesn’t ripen, then the karma created earliest will ripen. But sooner or later, all karma will ripen if we don’t purify it or if we haven’t dedicated it. So the negative karma will definitely ripen if we haven’t purified it and our positive karma will definitely ripen unless we’ve destroyed it by anger.

If we haven’t protected it by dedication, then it can be destroyed by anger. No, no. The first one is the karma which ripens first. The second way it ripens is the karma created most recently, then habitual karma and then the karma created earliest, like way back. This is why, if we create lots of strong, good karma in this life, even if we’ve created lots of negative karma and it hasn’t been purified, it won’t ripen because all this strong, good karma is up near the door.

So we can postpone. Even if we haven’t purified our negative karma, we can postpone it ripening by keeping the mind in a virtuous state and keeping and creating strong, good karma again and again. This is one method. But you never know when one of these cows will escape and bolt for the door. So we have to be very careful and therefore it’s important to purify.

Maybe we can leave it a little lighter, thanks. Alright, so, there are different kinds of karma. There is positive karma which comes from following the virtuous thoughts, loving kindness and compassion, which are reflections of our Buddha nature. The negative karma which comes from following the delusions. And then there is indifferent karma, neutral karma, when our mind is in a kind of neutral state and so certain actions and things don’t really create any cause for suffering or happiness.

For example, just merely walking along the road is not creating good karma or bad karma. If we’re walking along the road in order to kill someone, that is creating negative karma. If we’re walking along the road to benefit someone, that is creating good karma with the body. In terms of we talked about the ten non virtues yesterday the three of body, the four of speech, the three of mind. So all karma ultimately, of course, is created by the mind because of following the delusions.

But, for example, in the case of having a thought of anger or ill will, that thought of anger transforms into ill will. This becomes a very heavy negative karma of mind. And if we keep following that thought again and again and again, and it really takes over our mind completely, then that can turn into the negative karma of speech by saying really harmful, ugly things to that person that we have this anger or hatred towards. So, the karma of speech is heavier than the karma of mind, but only because the state of mind has actually got worse, in a sense. And then, if we’re not satisfied that we’ve hurt the person with our speech by insulting them and criticising and lying about them and so on, then we act out our anger with our body and hit them, punch them, stab them, kill them, whatever.

So that becomes the worst negative karma. The karma of body is the worst negative karma because the thought in the mind has become strongest and forces our body to do something. We may think of stealing, but we don’t steal. But if we think more about it, we act on it, so that becomes even heavier. We may think of engaging in sexual misconduct which creates some negative karma, but we don’t.

But then, if we think about it more and more, we follow the desire more and more, we act on it and then we create the negative karma of sexual misconduct with our body. So all negative karma originates with the mind but generally speaking, the karma created with the body is the heaviest, with the speech slightly is a little bit less, and just the thoughts without acting on them is the least. But when the thoughts are acted on with our speech and body, then the karma is much greater. Also, just to try and clarify, maybe this gets a bit more complicated, but just to clarify things, if we generate a thought of anger in our mind, as that anger is being generated, which is a delusion, afflicted thought, at the same time it is creating an imprint in the mind which is an imprint of the delusion. So then that imprint ripens as anger again.

The anger we’re experiencing now is arising from a previous imprint of anger which is based on ignorance, But because of ignorance, we have the imprints of the delusions. Then, when the outer conditions come together, the imprint ripens as anger. So then, as we’re generating the anger, we create another imprint of anger in our mind. And also the habit to get angry again. Not only the imprint of anger, but we’ve started to develop the anger sorry the habit to be angry.

So every time we get angry, the habit gets stronger and we put more imprints of anger in our mind. That’s one thing. At the same time, we are creating the karmic imprints as well. So there are two kinds of imprints: the imprints of the delusions and the karmic imprints. The imprints of the delusion ripen as that same type of delusion.

And the delusions create karmic imprints which ripen as suffering. So, lots of imprints. We discussed this before, but there is throwing karma, particularly any of the ten non virtues done completely and not purified. If that ripens, if that’s the strongest cow at the time of death, then that throws us. It can’t throw us into a human experience, it can only throw us into a realm of non human experience, into the lower realms.

And then, that throwing karma also has the effects when we are born human as a result of some other virtuous throwing karma. That throwing karma ripens as the result similar to the cause and the environmental result. For example, in this life we kill something, some sentient being completely, we have no regret about it, so this is a complete negative karma in the mind. We don’t purify it and at the time of death, for various reasons, that ripens first. So that becomes a throwing karma that throws us into a lower realm.

Right? So we’re in the lower realm, so we get reborn as a dog. And then that karma finishes, aspect of the throwing karma finishes. Then we get reborn in some other situation because some other karma ripens, and so on and so on. At some point, we get reborn as a human being again because of some virtuous throwing karma we’ve created, and we’ve become a human being again.

So then, when we’re a human being again, the other aspects of the throwing karma ripen as the result similar to the cause. I think this is correct, yes, the result similar to the cause and the environmental result. So the throwing karma has all these results the throwing into the lower realm, giving the result similar to the cause when we were a human being again. It doesn’t cause us to be a human being, that has to come from some virtuous throwing karma. But when we were a human, we experienced the result similar to the cause and the environmental result.

And then there is other the other kind of karma is called completing karma, which is when we are in a particular realm, then for example, now we’re experiencing the good throwing karma, the virtuous throwing karma that has thrown us into this human realm. And now, as we are a human being, we experience different kinds of completing karma, some of which is good and some of which is bad. Like, as I mentioned, to be here, this is good, completing karma. To have an accident, for our money to be stolen, not to be very rich in this life or something, many different things, this can be completing karma, to get various sicknesses and whatever, some of this can be completing karma. And that will change, you know, some good karma, bad karma, all that is the completing karma.

So, one can be born as a rich dog, so the dog is a result of non virtuous throwing karma, being rich is some good, virtuous, completing karma. So, one can be born as a human being, a very poor human being, so being born human is the result of good throwing karma, but being very poor is some negative completing karma. It also could be the result similar to the cause of the non virtuous throwing karma, so it gets very complicated. And then, there are three ways to create karma. The main way, of course, is doing it ourselves.

The other one is encouraging others to do an action. So, if we encourage someone to do something negative, we cheer someone on to do something negative, we accumulate negative karma. If we encourage someone to do virtuous actions, we accumulate positive karma.

Key terms in this teaching

Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
completing karma drubje kyi lä (Tib)
Also called finishing karma, the karmic imprints that ripen to determine the type of experiences we have when we are reborn, as opposed to throwing karma that determines the actual rebirth. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
possessed result
One of four ways we can experience the result of an action, also called environmental result; possessed result is the environment we find ourselves in when we take rebirth. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
throwing karma phen jä kyi lä (Tib)
Also called projecting karma, the karmic imprint that ripens at the time of death to propel us into the next rebirth. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top