Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 22 Tape 40 Side 1 Part only. Karma

35 min · 3,765 words · 22 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 22 Tape 40 Side 1 Part only. Karma
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains karma: rejoicing in others’ good deeds creates merit, while rejoicing in others’ suffering creates negative karma. It teaches that suffering originates in the mind through ignorance and self-cherishing, that purifying the mind and accumulating merit change one’s situation, and how the four opponent powers (regret, determination, refuge and bodhicitta, and the antidote) purify negative imprints. Dedicating merit protects it from anger.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-22

Duration: 36 min

UUID: a324d59d-cb20-4058-b763-8d74d0227dea

Words: 3,765

Rejoicing in the action of others. So if we rejoice in the good deeds of others, which we’re encouraged to do, this is one of the easiest ways to create good karma. There’s some formula about this which I’m not a hundred percent sure of, but just generally, if we rejoice in the good deeds of someone who is less spiritually evolved than us, we get the same amount of merit. If we rejoice in the good deeds of someone who’s more or less at the same level of us, we get what is it? About the same.

But if we rejoice in the virtuous deeds, people much more realised than us, we don’t get as much, but we get a certain percentage of the merit they’ve created, something like that. I mean, we don’t get it from them, but it’s generated by ourselves, but depending on the base, because we’re rejoicing in someone who’s accumulated an enormous amount of merit, then we create quite a lot, but not as much as they do. So this is something very important to be aware of because especially, it’s difficult it’s not so easy to rejoice in the virtues of others. We tend with our self-cherishing mind to generate jealousy when we see other people better than ourselves doing better things than ourselves. So the antidote to that is rejoicing, making the mind happy that people are doing good things, making the mind happy.

But it is so easy, on the other hand, to rejoice when others, our enemies, the people we dislike, are suffering. And when other people are doing negative, you know, harmful things to the people we dislike, that is so easy to rejoice in. Lama Zopa Rinpoche sent an email around to all the his centers about being very careful not to rejoice about anything happening in the war now. People have lots of aversion to mister Bin Laden and the Al Qaeda, and then something, you know, they are defeated, and we rejoice, this creates lots of negative karma. Whenever we rejoice in the suffering of others, this creates negative karma, and that is so easy to do.

Even when you watch movies and and and one, you know, laughs when the you know, something terrible happens to someone, even though it may not be creating a great negative karma, it’s it’s not a positive good imprint in the mind. Because even though it’s not a real person, it’s reflection of things that can happen, so, you know, easily laughing at these things creates the habit for when it actually happens to sentient beings. So it’s not such a good thing. You know, if if you think about this, we we read newspapers and there’s always put downs of politicians, and we’re we’re happy when our our favorite unfavourite politician, the politician we most like to dislike is criticised, we’re happy. And then there’s political cartoons making fun of politicians or cartoons making fun of other people, and there are all sorts of kind of gossip magazines that make fun of movie stars and this is and that, and criticize them for that and that, pointing out all their faults, and we enjoy all that.

It’s not such good karma, very easy to create. So these are some of the basic points about karma that we should know if we have some understanding, a belief in our mind, and how the mind works. So it’s important to know these things, to meditate on them so they go deep in the mind, so that we can live our life according to these things because this this accords with reality, the conventional reality of things is operating in relation to this. So if we flow with it, then we not only prevent suffering, but it’s just helping us go in the direction to experience ultimate reality. If we go against it, we are just giving ourselves a hard time creating the causes of confusion.

Because we we we do it with this ignorance, thinking ourselves as somehow an independent agent, an independent agent that can just kind of swim through life, you know, unaffected and unconnected to everything else. But this is a complete fantasy. Alright? We’re totally connected and dependent on all phenomena around us. They are actually a reflection of our mind.

Okay, thank you very much. We’ll take a ten minute break. Maybe just conclusion, some of the conclusions that we should draw if we understand the law of cause and effect correctly, is that all our suffering, dissatisfaction, frustrations, pain, all our problems have their origin, their principal cause within ourselves. Of course, Buddhism the Buddhadharma does not deny in any way that there are external conditions for things. I mean, this is ridiculous that to try and deny this, the Buddha is not stupid.

Of course, because we have a certain body, things happen and there’s genetic explanations for things and so on. So one may have a disease which is genetically transmitted from one’s parents, and you say, Oh, that’s the explanation, finished. But why did we take our consciousness into a body that has that genetic problem? This is the dharma view. Of course, there is a genetic explanation for things in the body, and also, the way the mind is functioning, the nervous system, affects the mind, but they’re separate things, dependent but separate.

And if the brain is functioning perfectly well, the mind is. If the brain isn’t because of some chemical deficiency or something, there’s some mental problem. But so that from a dharma point of view, that chemical deficiency is not the sole reason. It’s not the root reason, it’s the condition, but why does my mind enter the body that has these chemical deficiencies? There is a cause for that.

There is a cause to have this body with this, and this body having its particular qualities. This is the Buddhist view. And then the interaction between this body and this environment produces all sorts of experiences. But the root cause, especially if we study the teachings about reality, and we start to see that this external reality is not totally external and totally independent of us, that there is some ongoing relationship, then the law of cause and effect makes much more sense, that the suffering we’re experiencing, even this very concrete outer suffering, the root cause is rising in the mind, has been developed in the mind. And it’s same with all our happiness as well.

So, if we understand this, then we can accept our own suffering, not think of ourselves as helpless victims and innocent and so on, but not accepting in the sense of being totally passive and just letting it happen, but mentally accepting it with the right understanding. Because the law of cause and effect is showing us that because our suffering depends our unhappiness depends on myself, then I have the ability to change it. So by mentally accepting that, that it is depending on me, my mind, that opens up this space where we can then wisely do something about our suffering and happiness. And we should understand that all all the suffering we’re experiencing comes from negative karma, which is created out of ignorance and self-cherishing, not because we’re inherently evil, but because there is this ongoing ignorance and self-cherishing that we perpetuate in our own confusion, not because we’re evil, we’re confused, because we have ignorance, but we can change that. So there are two main kinds of ignorance, the the root ignorance, which is the the completely wrong view of self, and the other ignorance is the ignorance of the law of cause and effect.

So the ignorance of the cause and effect produces all the suffering of saṃsāra, the specific sufferings of saṃsāra, the ignorance which is the ignorance which doesn’t understand our true nature, is the root of all of that, of all of it. Ignorance creates saṃsāra, ignorance of the law of cause and effect makes it worse and keeps us in it. So, if we understand the law of cause and effect correctly also, we can understand that when things go wrong in our life, in any way, the way to change this is to purify our mind and to collect merit. This is one of the major things to do, not to blame the external world and mess around with external put all the effort into trying to change the external situation, that has to be done to some extent. But the main thing is to change the mind, to change the attitude, and also to purify the mind and accumulate some merit.

Not some merit, a lot if we can. And that can that itself can change the karma that is operating, so the situation can change. In the Tibetan community, people have this basic faith even if they may not understand it in-depth, but Tibetan businessmen are really pretty good horse traders, so for them, whenever they want to engage in some new business, they always create some merit first. What they do with their business may not be so meritorious, but they always realize if the business is going to succeed, one has to practice some virtue first. If you go on a long journey, do some virtuous actions first to create the cause that there won’t be too many problems.

Wealthy Tibetans always put a significant amount of their wealth in virtuous objects, like incredible altars and holy statues, which is a very good thing to do, rather than investing one’s money in the stock exchange, which is only gonna maybe, if we’re lucky, make some money. If you invest your money in virtuous objects, it creates merit, which one can dedicate to enlightenment, to that one’s happiness in future lives and complete enlightenment. This is the best investment of all. If one has the money, wealthy Tibetans also have the custom of inviting monks and nuns to their homes to recite sutras for the well-being of the family now and in the future, offering food to the monks and nuns. Sorry, it’s usually the monks, I have to be honest.

Sometimes it’s nuns, but mainly it’s the tradition of offering, bringing monks, sponsoring pujas at monasteries for monks and nuns to do, to create merit, and if there’s sickness in the family or problems, then by offering to monasteries, this creates very great merit that can change the karma that is causing the problems and sickness and so on. So these are some things that we ourselves can do. It is the practice of generosity, and that generosity is creating merit, and generosity is one of the fundamental practices to engage in. Generosity leads to pure morality. The perfection of morality leads to the perfection of patience, the perfection of patience leads to the perfection of joyous effort, and joyous effort leads to the perfection of concentration, and on the basis of the perfection of concentration, one is able to perfect wisdom, which liberates us, and which we can use that wisdom, we can use to give to others, to liberate them.

It all starts with the practice of generosity. I’ll do it later on in the course when we get to the perfections. So, we not only need to avoid the negative actions, but like I tried to say, this is the important thing, it’s the easiest thing to do in a sense, and it’s the most effective thing because if we do virtuous actions but we keep doing negative ones, we undermine the power and the result of the positive things. We meditate but we keep doing negative things. That acts as an obstacle to being able to meditate well and gain insight.

But if we put a lot of effort in stopping negative actions, then everything else starts to go really smoothly. If we don’t want a little bit of suffering, avoid little negative actions. If we would if we want to avoid a lot of suffering, avoid creating large negative, you know, heavy negative actions. And then and then on the basis of that, we need to do virtuous things. If we want a little bit of happiness, create a little bit of virtue.

If if we want a lot of happiness, create a lot of virtue with our body, speech, and mind. And we can do this with this precious human rebirth moment by moment. There’s nothing stopping us. So this merit is needed for the happiness of this life. Even in this even though I tried to point out that generally speaking, the karma we create in this life, the result doesn’t ripen in this life but in future lives.

But as we’re creating good karma, in order to create good karma, one has to do virtuous deeds. One has to generate virtuous thoughts, say virtuous things, and do virtuous things with the body, and that has effects in this life anyway. It has positive effects in this life. If we meditate on loving kindness today, it will affect us tomorrow, there will be benefit tomorrow. And if we keep meditating in this life, there will be good effects in this life, but as we’re meditating, we’re creating these virtuous imprints, and those imprints probably won’t ripen until the future life.

And when they ripen, because the result is expandable, the result will be incredible, inconceivable. But anyway, we need merit in this life. We need merit to have a to create the causes for a good rebirth, and we need merit to empower to gain all the realizations on the path. In order to to gain the realization of loving kindness in the mind, we need to meditate on it. But for that meditation to succeed totally, completely as it can, we need merit to empower our mind, to strengthen our mind as we’re doing the meditation.

Also, need to purify the mind of the obstacles that prevent us realizing the state of loving kindness. Moment momento. Okay? A little bit later. I’ll just try and do my rave, and then we can have some questions.

I can’t go back. It’s all in the book. I’m just putting some imprint now, then hopefully when you read the book it makes a little bit more sense. If you read Pabongka Rinpoche’s Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand, it’s all there. Everything I’m saying is all there.

Then there’s even more detail in this book, the incredible translation of the first part of the Lam Rim Chenmo by Je Tsongkhapa. So also, it’s a bit yeah. So it’s important to dedicate the merit. We put so much effort into creating good actions with our body, speech, and mind, so then we need to dedicate those to protect them from the negative minds, especially anger, because the Buddha taught that anger can burn up these positive imprints. This is why one reason we’re not highly realized now, or we’re not bodhisattvas or buddhas, because we have done many, many virtuous things in the past, in previous lives, but we burnt up that merit when we got angry, because we forgot to dedicate that merit, or we didn’t dedicate it strongly enough.

But in this life, if we try again, we do virtuous actions and dedicate the merit strongly, then that will produce the bring the fullest result in the future. The Buddha himself taught, just as an analogy, a simple analogy, that if we take one drop of water and we place it on the ground, especially on a hot day, very quickly, it’s evaporated. But if you place that same drop of water in the ocean, it doesn’t evaporate. It joins with all the water. In the same way, like one one little virtuous thought, one virtuous merit, we create undedicated, unprotected, just as as easily burnt up by anger.

But when we dedicate it to enlightenment, when we generate that thought that we want this positive imprint in our mind to become a cause of enlightenment, as we’re thinking that, our mind in a sense becomes part of the great oceanic mind of all the Buddhas, because this is exactly the thought that the Buddhas have all the time. So that that karma is protected, that karmic imprint is protected. So it’s also incredibly important that we use this life to, as much as we can to purify the negative imprints with applying the four opponent powers, which I think Karen’s talked about. Mentioned last night that there are the four results of karma, being thrown into the lower realms, the results similar to the cause, the habit, and the environmental result. So the four opponent powers purify all of those things, and each of the opponent powers purifies specific things.

So the power of regret specifically purifies the ripening result of being born in a lower realm. That’s why regret is the most important of the four opponent powers. Then the opponent power of having the strong determination to avoid negativities in the future, that purifies the habit. So actually, my teacher, Lama Zopa Rinpoche, says that of all the results of negative karma, the very worst one is actually not being thrown into the lower realms, but the worst one is the habit. Because we create a negative karma, a negative action, and one of the karmic results is the habit to do it again.

And as the habit gets stronger, so then you yeah, the habit gets stronger, it becomes easier and easier to do these negative things. So we have the habit, the instinct to do negative actions. So we kill someone out of habit, or we kill an insect, an animal out of habit, without any thought, any awareness, just out of habit, we kill it, we don’t purify it. At some point, it can only ripen as an experience of the lower realms. Then, when we become human, we experience the result of, similar to the cause, of being killed, having a short life, lots of disease, a very weak body, and then we also experience the unpleasant environmental result.

But we also experience the habit we have a stronger habit to kill, So because of that habit, then we kill again, then we fall into the lower realms again, then when we become a human being, we experience the results similar to the cause of having a short life, being killed, lots of disease, and so on, and being born in a horrible place. And being born in this horrible place, there is the habit to kill, so we kill again. So we fall into the lower realms again, and all these things again and again. This is how Samsāra cycles again, again, and again. So we make the determination not to do the action again.

So that the stronger the determination, the more sincere, then we cut this habit. And of course, what is the most powerful way to cut our habits is meditation, because that’s what it is. It is familiarity with what is virtuous and real. It is creating this virtuous positive habit. It is the way meditation is the way to undermine all our negative habits.

So I don’t know how much venerable Karen has talked about the four opponent powers, but the lamas explain that with applying the opponent power of determination, it’s important to be honest with ourselves that if we know we have a very heavy habit, but we want to try and stop it, we can’t say, oh, I’ll never do it again, if we know that we will do it again. So that isn’t helpful opponent power. There’s no power to that because it’s a lie. We’re lying to ourselves. We’re lying to the Buddhas.

So what we should try to do is make the determination that tomorrow, I think I can manage all of tomorrow not to do this action. So we make this strong determination that no matter what, tomorrow, I will not do this action. And so then at the end of tomorrow, because we haven’t done that negative action, we rejoice. And but then we we say, well, tomorrow also I won’t do it. And then after two days, we rejoice and decide, well, also tomorrow I won’t, or for two days or three days now, I won’t do it.

But then the reality is often when we’re trying to break negative habits of body, speech, and mind, that we make the determination tomorrow, definitely, no matter what, even if I die, I won’t do this negative action. I won’t lie tomorrow. I won’t steal. I won’t this, that, or the other. But then one doesn’t.

What to do? What what is the what what do we have to what do we do then? Give up? We decide we’re totally hopeless, evil, completely, you know, a disaster. What is the solution?

It’s to develop sincere regret and make the determination again. Tomorrow, definitely, even if I die, I won’t do this thing. And then tomorrow comes along, and you break the determination. You you do the thing that you’d vowed you you won’t do. What is the solution?

Develop regret and make the determination again. And you just we just have to keep going until our determination generates. We get so totally fed up with our failures that we make the determination that today, I am not going to do it. And that day, we don’t do it. And then we rejoice, and then we make the determination again.

And along with those that regret and determination, not the guilt, but the regret, just this light, wise touch, this regret, that was stupid. That is gonna bring suffering. I better not do that anymore. Then as well as those opponent powers, then there’s the opponent power of generating refuge in Bodhicitta. This is one opponent power.

Why refuge? Because the ultimate refuge is well, with our outer refuge, the the main outer refuge is the Dharma, the the the teachings. And as I said, the main Dharma refuge is the law of cause and effect. So by taking refuge, we’re reminding ourselves to observe the law of cause and effect again more carefully, and that protects our mind. And by taking the outer refuge, we we we we reminding ourselves to rely on our inner refuge, to rely on our basic goodness and wisdom, not to identify with the disturbing thoughts, but to

Key terms in this teaching

Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
four opponent powers nyenpo tob zhi (Tib)
The four practices used to purify nonvirtuous imprints on the mindstream. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
possessed result
One of four ways we can experience the result of an action, also called environmental result; possessed result is the environment we find ourselves in when we take rebirth. LYWA
ripening result
One of the four ways we can experience the results of an action; the ripening result is the actual realm we are born into when we take rebirth. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top