38 min · 4,383 words · 21 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains karma through the ten non-virtues, especially killing and stealing. It covers three results: the result similar to the cause (suffering such as being killed, short life or illness), habitual tendencies to repeat the act, and environmental results such as born in a barren or dishonest place. The question session distinguishes regret, which energises the mind, from guilt, which weighs it down, and discusses karma alongside conditions and psychology.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-21
Duration: 38 min
UUID: e0f5a91d-65bd-4475-83da-51bfcdf97487
Words: 4,383
Then, at some point in another life, we’re a human being again. We’re a human being, but then the two other aspects of negative karma of killing Person X, the person killing Person X negative karma, starts ripening when we’re a human being. The first result is to throw us into a lower realm, then when we become a human being again because of some other good karma, we’ve created some good karma that has thrown us into a human realm, but then we’re experiencing the bad ripening result of killing person X. So this is experienced as, firstly, what is called the result similar to the cause. The result similar to the cause.
So this has two aspects: the experience of the result similar to the cause, which is to be we murdered somebody, so we get murdered. This is one aspect of the result similar to the cause. But that’s not the only way this karma can ripen. It can ripen as being killed or it can ripen as having a very short life or it could ripen as having a lot of disease in this human life or having an extremely weak body and almost no energy in the body. Or it can ripen as all of those things.
Being killed when one’s young, having lots of disease, having a very weak body all of these things. It could be several of them, just one of them. These are all the karmic result of killing person X a million years ago. And then the other karmic result similar to the cause is that as a human being we have this tendency, this habit to want to kill for no reason. Like as a child we may enjoy killing insects bouncing balls on ants, swatting flies for fun, drowning cats, shooting rats, various things like that, enjoying hunting, just enjoying killing, even enjoying killing human beings, people like serial killers and things who have this uncontrolled urge to kill.
Possibly, this is my interpretation, maybe because they’ve killed so much then there’s this incredible imprint in the mind. There’s no particular reason to kill in this life, just this unbelievable, uncontrolled urge to kill or to harm enjoying harming. So that’s the second major result, the result similar to the cause which is the experience of suffering such as being killed or having a short life and so on. This is in relation to the karma of killing. And then there’s the habit of wanting to kill or harm, enjoying it for no particular reason.
And if someone wants to kill us and then we want to kill them, that’s not that karma. There’s the karma of just killing for no reason It is this karma. So then the third major result, which also occurs in the human realm, is the environmental result that we are born in a place that reflects the karma of killing in some way or the karma of stealing or lying or so on. So you have an outline here of all of this that comes with the Course Notes or something. It’s called the ten non virtues with their results.
It also gets very complicated because in the case of killing, we kill person X, then it may not be our next life. Like in this life, we kill person X, the karmic result may not happen in our next life but at some life in the future that karma ripens and throws us into a lower realm because we didn’t purify it. So the full result comes, we’re thrown into a lower realm. Then that energy runs out and then in some other life, it probably won’t be the very next life after that negative karma finishes, but in some future life, because of some good karma, we’re thrown into a human realm. Then we can experience the result similar to the cause of being killed.
But then in another human life we may experience the result of that same negative karma of killing Person X we have lots of disease. Then in another human life we experience the karmic result of killing X, of having a short life or having very little energy in the body. So these results can come over many human lives. And in all those human lives there may be this tendency to kill, to harm and to enjoy doing it. Or if not enjoying it, having no awareness, no thought that there’s anything wrong in doing this.
So then the environmental result is one is born in a violent place with many problems such as war and the food, drink and medicine of that place has very little benefit, power to sustain life. So it’s really important to reflect these things. So one way of generating some faith in karma, or it may cause one to lose, to totally reject it, is to think of the different suffering experiences one has in this life. And sometimes they just simply can’t be explained by the things done in this life. Why do we experience them?
Or if we look at the lives of other people, why does this person experience this suffering, so much suffering? It doesn’t seem to have such a strong, valid cause in his life. So maybe this is indicating that these are the results similar to the cause. Some people have so much sickness. Again and again and again, always getting sick.
Some people step off the aeroplane in India or Nepal and they get sick. Just on the tarmac, it’s just, Ah! I’m in this unhealthy country and they get sick. Some people drink all the water of India and Nepal and never get sick. Eat anything and never get sick.
Other people just one cup of water, one cup of tea is enough. Diarrhea, vomiting, everything. One meal, the first meal in India Nepal, and they get unbelievably sick. Other people eat meals every day from the chai stalls, you know, the dirtiest shops for twenty years never get sick. You know, one man in Uzbekistan eats greasy meat, piles of greasy, greasy meat and smokes forty five cigarettes a day and lives to be one hundred and twenty.
Other people eat only beet sprouts and die, you know. Why? Maybe it’s the result similar to the cause. Then it explains the karma of killing, sorry, of stealing. Again, if one has done that very strongly with all the four factors present, there’s no regret at the time and there’s no purification later on, if that karma ripens, then it may not ripen.
At some point it will ripen but if we practice Dharma and always create positive conditions then the karma may keep getting postponed. But if this karma ripens then it can only ripen as the cause of a lower realm. It simply cannot ripen as the cause of the happiness of the upper realm. If we really think about it, if the effect is of the same nature of the cause, Hot water, you need heat to make hot water, you need freezing temperature to make ice. If this is true, then we create this incredible negative imprint in the mind.
It can’t become a cause of the upper realm, it just simply can’t. And if it ripens in all its intensity because what does it do? It takes over the most subtle level of mind, It affects that incredibly subtle, sensitive mind and it creates an imprint there which from there creates the subtle mind and from there creates the gross mind. And there the result is experienced as a suffering rebirth, the appearances of a suffering rebirth. It can’t do anything else if there’s mind.
If there’s no mind, we can all go home. But if you don’t have a mind, how can you see your home? So stealing itself, if we do it strongly, completely or frequently, can that karma, if it ripens, can throw us into a lower realm. Then, when that karma finishes and we become a human being again at some point, then the result similar cause is experienced, that we experience poverty. Or we’re often robbed.
We easily lose objects, our possessions, we lose them all the time or they get stolen from us or they get damaged very quickly, very easily. Or even if we have them, we just somehow can’t enjoy them the way they could be enjoyed. We can’t sort of get access to them and enjoy them the way they could be. And all the things we try to do, you know, we’re intelligent and we’ve got all the things and everyone else has done this thing and when we try to do it, it never is the same. It never works out as well.
You bake a cake, you’ve got the same ingredients, but it’s never as tasty as the other person’s. You do some job to make money, it never works out like other people do. It never succeeds, it never comes together the same. This is the result of stealing, of taking away, of minimizing from others, so we get the minimum. It’s never what we want.
Check out I have plenty of these experiences in my life. I always burn clothes. All my clothes have holes in them, not from smoking but incense and things like this. This shirt top has got I don’t know where the burns come from. I always mysteriously get grease things all over me.
I have no idea where strange stains, I cannot explain where they come from. Nothing ever fits me. One of the reasons I became a monk is because I thought the clothes would fit me. I could never get clothes that would fit me. I have a good friend who was a monk, not anymore.
He has this amazing karma of people giving him things. He was always worried about He never had money but people he had the good karma for people to give him money to support him as a monk but he lost it. It was stolen so many times. So many times he had money someone would give him a pot of money to survive as a monk for a while then it would be stolen. I was with him one time at the Delhi railway station, we were standing together, our luggage was together and someone stole his money.
Just there, right there, bing. Again and again it would happen. This is the kind of karma of the ripening result of stealing. It just happens. You buy a new car and you get a scratch immediately.
You can’t enjoy it perfectly. Why? Why did it happen? Why to me now? You buy a brand new nice piece of clothing, you spill coffee all over it, cigarette stain, something, rip it, You can’t enjoy it completely, it’s there.
You inherit ten billion dollars but you have it, there’s a huge family feud about it. So it’s there in the bank, you’ve got this piece of paper saying you have inherited ten million dollars but you can’t even touch it, you can’t even touch it because the lawyers have got it locked in a bank and fifteen relatives are saying I should have it And this goes on for twenty five years and then at the end of twenty five years you get five dollars left, you know, paying the lawyers and everything you’ve got five dollars to take home. Yeah, this may be the karmic result of stealing. We lose things all the time, can’t misplace things, which causes frustration and annoyance and we get angry and upset. Maybe this is the karmic result of stealing or borrowing without telling.
And then the environmental result is that are born in a place what does it say here? A barren place where crops don’t grow or destroy, our old businesses fail. There’s lots of droughts, floods, hail. So we’re born in an environment where the results are stolen from us, they never quite come. So these are taught like when the Buddha lived and presented these teachings and the other great masters afterwards elaborated, of course for most of human history, all our cultures have been agricultural societies and agriculture has been very important, so crops failing and this and that is a very significant part of happiness.
So these are the examples but also we can modify them and understand them in modern industrial terms of businesses failing and so on. We start a business but it fails or our shares you know, we buy them at fifteen dollars and the next day, you know, they start sinking immediately. Know, we have the shares, but they’re not as valuable anymore. We start the business, but it doesn’t really work. It doesn’t succeed.
We’re born in a place where it’s so difficult to do business because everyone’s dishonest. The laws are so complicated and so on. So it’s so difficult to succeed, to have money, be forget about being rich, having a comfortable life. You can see many countries, many societies where things are so corrupt and the laws are broken so easily and people don’t pay taxes, everything gets very complicated, so it becomes very difficult for ordinary people survive economically. This is the result of stealing.
And the more dishonesty, the more you see, everyone else is being dishonest, so I’ll be dishonest. I’ll cheat and lie about my tax. I’ll cheat about this. I’ll sell things more expensively and use lousier goods and whatever and make excuses for not delivering things on time and deliver a little bit less than what I promised and all business practices. More and more people do it.
And then it becomes, even if you’re honest, becomes very difficult to survive properly. But it’s a karmic result. There are obvious reasons now, but to be born in that, why am I born here? Why is this happening altogether? It’s a karmic result, perhaps.
Then the karmic result of also sexual misconduct can become a cause to be born in the lower realm. Then as a human being we experience the other results similar to the cause. There’s the habit of wishing to engage in sexual misconduct knowing that sexual misconduct will cause suffering to others and so on, that one has this very strong desire for these things. And then the result, similar to the cause, is one has bad relationships, they end quickly, even apart from oneself one has unsatisfying sexual relationships, but also even with one’s ordinary friendships, one tends to have troubles, one gets separated from one’s friends, also in one’s love life or whatever, one’s partner is unfaithful. So these are some of the results similar to the cause.
And the environmental result is that one is born in muddy, dirty places with bad smells that are very unpleasant. I always tell the story to illustrate this. It doesn’t really illustrate it but that in nineteen eighty seven I went with Lama Zopa Rinpoche and forty other people to Tibet and when we came back there were some of the worst floods in Nepal or it was incredible rain that destroyed the road between Nepal and Tibet and all of us we had to walk for one day, one whole day in rain and mud. Was just amazing, was very dangerous at points too. And at one point I was walking with Lama Zopa Rinpoche and a small group of people because you know things changed sometimes you’d be with Rinpoche and then you’d fall behind and then suddenly you’d find yourself walking alongside Rinpoche At one point I was walking with Rinpoche and two or three other people and it was really muddy and Rinpoche said, We’re experiencing the result of sexual misconduct.
So it goes on and on like that, so one can read this oneself and think about it. And it is very helpful to think like the different experiences of one’s life. This is showing perhaps the results similar to the cause. And also seeing how we have habits for things, tendencies to do things that even consciously we may not want to do but sometimes it’s not always there but sometimes there’s this incredible urge to do something that’s perhaps completely out of character. Why do we do it?
Maybe this is the result similar to the cause. We have done these things in the past and so now we have the habit. I can’t give all the examples from my life because that would be too embarrassing. But there’s one incident when I was a little kid in primary school. Most of my life I haven’t stolen things and I hadn’t had the wish.
Once, at one point when I was in my late twenties and because of my socialist beliefs, deliberately stole some things from the supermarket as a blow against capitalist enterprise. But that was very conscious, it wasn’t like some just being pushed to do something. I didn’t even actually want to do, I was very uncomfortable but I thought it was a good thing to do. Having long views, I thought it was a good thing to do. But once when I was I can’t remember, maybe seven or eight, or even less than that, when I was in primary school, one day there was this huge cupboard in the hallway and it was open and there were these boxes of chalk, white boxes of white chalk, boxes of multicolored chalk and I had this incredible urge to have one of these boxes, incredible desire to have one of these boxes of chalk.
And I don’t somehow I I don’t remember the point that I stole one of these boxes of chalk. I think a multicolored box of chalk. And I put it in my little leather bag that we all had, you know, got home, went into my bedroom stupid enough I didn’t close the door properly. Just as I’m opening the thing and looking at this thing, my mother comes in and says, what’s that? So my father took me back to the primary school and we took it back.
But I mean, really I had never thought of boxes of chalk before, never thought of them after. Just in that moment there was this incredible desire to have this box of chalk so I took it. So this is result similar to the cause. So sometimes that impulse, that uncontrolled impulse might be just very one time because the habit has faded away, but it may be very strong, it may arise again and again because that karma is fresh, you know, from one has had many lives, recent lives of doing something like that. So one can check-in one’s life, why do I have these particular negative tendencies, especially when, you know, one doesn’t particularly want to do them.
But we we our karma pushes us sometimes. So it’s very helpful to think of these examples and also for our own life but also with other people, not in judging other people, that created negative karma. But sometimes one can see in their life such strange patterns that just people get caught up into, that seem to illustrate how the mind being pushed by these these imprints, drawn to negative things that happen again and again. Do you have any questions? Well, purification can work for everything, Vajrasattva can purify anything.
But it is also good if you know you have a specific habit in this life to apply specific antidotes to be more effective, sure. This is very difficult. In one way, in words it’s easy to say this is guilt and this is regret but in one’s mind they get very mixed up. Regret is a virtuous mind and it is a type of wisdom and it is not a heavy mind. It may make us sad but it doesn’t really weigh us down and inactivate our mind, make us weak.
It actually energizes the mind. Regret, virtuous real regret energizes the mind, it wakes us up to do something. Whereas if we check our mind, guilt is a heavy mind. It brings us down and it says, Oh, I am bad, I am bad, this is bad, and I’ve done this bad thing, and that’s because I’m a bad person. I did a bad thing because I am bad, And I am bad, and because I’m bad, I did this bad thing.
And because I did this bad thing, it proves I am bad. And I can never change I’m bad, bad, bad. And we just of wallow around this very limited dark space which also we come to the conclusion because I really am bad, I can’t change. So let’s do something else bad. So it’s kind of a very heavy mind, dark mind, and one doesn’t see any way out.
Whereas regret is a light mind. It’s not a happy mind. You can’t say regret is a happy mind. There may be some sadness, but that sadness doesn’t prevent us from doing something virtuous. Can you still think about things that you have done, but without them as a source of guilt?
Yes, sure. I mean the example that’s always given is that if by mistake we take some medicine, like in the medicine cabinet we’ve got this, that and the other, and we take the wrong medicine and it poisons us, then in that situation we feel regret. Oh, that was stupid, now I’m going to get sick, vomit, you know, That was really stupid. I wish I hadn’t done that. But we don’t hate ourselves for it.
We don’t feel disgusting and guilt. Oh, I am so bad for making a mistake. I’m so evil, beat me, beat me. It’s not like that. So it’s the same, what we can try and recognise that we have done bad actions, but it’s not because we are inherently evil, but because there is ignorance.
We made a mistake. We were deluded and we followed our delusion, not understanding. So we’ve done this negative thing, so suffering will come. How unfortunate. This is sad, but it’s not bad, bad, bad.
Yes? Well, that’s true to a point. You can’t deny that we are conditioned by the time we’re born in, the culture, the economy, the economic situation and our parents, sure. But then Buddhism, the Dharma says, Why? Why were we born at that time, in that environment, in that culture, in that economic situation with those parents?
The point about karma is that for the karma to ripen, needs the conditions. If the conditions aren’t there, the karma can’t happen. Also our karma attracts us to conditions, draws us to good or bad conditions. Buddhism is not at all denying any kind of temporal explanation of things, but it denies that these are the complete explanation. Sure, if if your mother beats you up, you know, and is is a is a bad mother, it will affect us.
But why do we have that mother? Yeah. And then some people have terrible environments but it doesn’t harm them in the way other people are because although they have the karma to be born in that environment, they have some other very powerful positive karma that somehow protects them from it. Yes. Yes.
Yeah. Within our mind. Yeah. Yes. No, no, no, no, it’s not that, come on.
No, no. Of course these things work, you can see that they work. Of course, you I mean there’s many psychological insights that people I mean, modern psychology, the good modern psychology, is very beneficial. It generally only works for this life. It’s not going to solve the deepest problems but it can solve and help.
It is a tool to deal with the ordinary mind now. But it doesn’t take us to see the root causes. It may help. Dharma does that. Psychology enables us to it’s about the mind, a certain aspect, so good psychology can show people how they are in this life causing suffering to themselves.
They may have had suffering in their childhood but their mind has also added to it and so psychological methods can give understanding to people that haven’t had that understanding, what positive ways to work with their mind and so on. For sure, this is good, it’s terrific, it should be done. Well, from a dharma point of view it’s superficial, but from this point of view of life, it be very strong and very beneficial. But from the vast perspective of the dharma of life after life and eradicating the causes of suffering, it can’t do that. It can modify, sure, and that’s important to do.
Anything that will modify our delusions is good, and show us that we have some responsibility that is good. So, please finish lunch before twelve. Remember. So, we dedicate the merit. That we are able to gain a deep inner realization of the universality of the law of cause and effect, and from that, this acts as the basis for us to protect our mind from suffering and develop all the positive potentials of our mind that lead us to achieve enlightenment for the benefit of all sentient beings.
May the precious bodhicitta not yet born, arise and grow. May that born have no decline but increase forevermore. Then on page sixty there’s the food offering practice, if you want to join in. So with the OM AH HUM we imagine this ordinary food becoming nectar that completely satisfies our body and mind and we also offer that nectar to the Buddha within and all sentient beings which we can visualize in our heart. Okay, thank you very much.
I think I’m not sure but I have to check but I think we worked out the Lama Lhundrup come to question and answer tonight. Anyway, it would be good if discussion groups discuss the ten non virtues and the environment, the three results in that list, that would be one good thing maybe to think about and argue about in the discussion group. Yeah, but the other half.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- possessed result
- One of four ways we can experience the result of an action, also called environmental result; possessed result is the environment we find ourselves in when we take rebirth. LYWA
- ripening result
- One of the four ways we can experience the results of an action; the ripening result is the actual realm we are born into when we take rebirth. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.