Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 18 Tape 33 Side 2 Rebirth lower Realms

44 min · 4,999 words · 18 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 18 Tape 33 Side 2 Rebirth lower Realms
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. This talk, which follows the Lamrim Chenmo’s presentation of the three lower realms, asks listeners to contemplate that after death their mind could be reborn in a miserable state according to their karma. It describes the suffering of animals, argues that animals have mind and Buddha nature, and says the purpose is to generate wise fear, avoid negative actions and develop compassion for all sentient beings.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-18

Duration: 45 min

UUID: f8b490d4-ebc0-4f18-8350-4c98700257f6

Words: 4,999

We can generate the thought for the benefit of all living beings, which we visualize surrounding us. I will listen to this presentation of the graduated path to enlightenment. We can base out this thought on the refuge in the triple gem and reinforce that by imagining, visualizing Śākyamūni Buddha in front of us as our as the very embodiment of the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. And firstly, we offer the mandala in order to receive the blessings of the Buddhas to be able to understand the graduated path. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, the supreme assembly by the merits I create, but through teaching the Dharma.

May I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings? So again we spend just a little time focusing on the breath to develop some concentration that we can then apply as we listen to the presentation of the graduated path. Okay. Thank you. Before starting, I just received a note from some people who are health workers, work with dying people and so on.

So maybe those people who are involved in that field, maybe we could meet together at some point, maybe we could organize a meeting with Lama Lhundrup, because maybe it’s best people could ask their questions to to Lama Lhundrup directly. Maybe we could talk a little bit first, then if if if you feel necessary, there could be a meeting with Lama Lhundrup about how best to take care of dying people in the context of working in this modern hospital system and so on. Okay. So I would like to make a very strong request to everyone right now to please generate an extremely open mind to what you’re going to hear now. Please don’t get don’t get too upset, just listen.

Try to think, try to remember that there is the enlightened mind. The enlightened mind saw many things. It did the enlightened mind did not make things up. The enlightened mind saw things with direct unmistaken perception, and out of great compassion taught these things for us, either to avoid or to create the causes to experience. So we’re now at the point of reaching the topic which is the most difficult to listen to, most difficult to talk about and the most difficult to listen to, the most upsetting topic on the path to enlightenment.

You want to hear? Okay, good. Can you turn it up? Is it possible to turn it up? So, we’ve been considering that we have this precious human rebirth and we’ve been trying to recognise that it is not going to last because we are going to die.

So even before we die, the precious human rebirth can be lost, but especially we can lose faith in the spiritual path, and so many things can happen, we can lose faith in our teachers, in the teachings and many things can happen, but especially it will be lost at the time of death, and death can happen at any moment. So we then come to the topic of considering what could happen at the time of death or what will happen after death. We’ve considered what happens in the death process, but then what will we experience after death? Maybe I’ll just read this directly from the Lama Tsongkhapa, from the Lamrim Chenmo, The Graduated Path to Enlightenment. Since it is certain that you will die soon, you cannot remain in this life.

As you do not cease to exist after death, you will be reborn. Furthermore, you will be reborn in either a happy or a miserable realm because there is no birthplace other than among these two types of beings. Since you are controlled by your karma and cannot choose where you will be born, you will be reborn in the manner in which your virtuous and non virtuous karma impel you to be reborn. This being the case, contemplate the suffering of the miserable realms thinking, How would it be if I were born in a miserable realm? So this is the topic of thinking about firstly, this presentation of the topic of the three lower realms.

This is presented for us to meditate on in the context of contemplating that we ourselves, the continuity of our mind after death, could fall into one of these states and experience these lower realms for a very long period of time. This is a very painful topic. When I go into the descriptions of the lower realms, it’s very hard to believe in them. It’s very hard for all of us to believe in them, that this is what the Buddha taught. For example, some of the many of the descriptions that are given of of what happens in the lower realms, I think this is help helpful to be aware of, for example, presented by Nāgārjuna, for example in his text The Friendly Letter, he describes the lower realms.

So Nāgārjuna is this great bodhisattva who presented the Prajñāpāramitā Sutras in this world, explain the definitive meaning of the most profound teachings of the Buddha about the empty nature of all phenomena. The most amazing teaching well, I’m a bit biased. The most amazing teachings existing in the world, something truly amazing about the empty nature of phenomena. So this being who explained this most profound topic believed in the lower realms and gave these descriptions. We like to dismiss that these descriptions are something for primitive minds.

Only very primitive people could possibly believe with totally superstitious minds could believe these things, but these things were believed by the greatest scholars and practitioners of the Buddhist tradition, including Lama Tsongkhapa. So I’m going in thinking about what could happen to us after death, what kind of life we could have if we believe I mean if we don’t believe anything’s going to happen, there’s just going to be darkness and everything stops, then we don’t have to think about this at all. But if we’re starting to get some awareness of the nature of mind and it goes on, then as Lama Tsongkhapa says, we’re going to experience something after this life and it’s either it either has to be good or bad, it can’t be anything else. And it what we experience, good or bad, depends on our karma that we’ve created. Right?

So of course, even even in this human realm we can see so much suffering. So we could one can use the suffering of this life thinking about being reborn as a human being in places where there’s perpetual war, hunger, political repression, racial discrimination, being excuse me, this is considered a bad example, but being born as a woman in Afghanistan where people women are going literally crazy at the moment because of being so totally repressed. People women are committing suicide. Highly educated women who’ve been doing all sorts of amazing things in their life and suddenly they have a bag stuck over their head and they’re locked in a room for the rest of their life. Yeah.

We can be born like this depending on our karma. So in fact, there’s enough suffering in this world that we can think about to motivate ourselves to practice. But in the presentation of the lumb, the graduated path, this topic is there about the other realms, not just in this human realm but other realms where we can our mind can sink, where there’s inconceivable suffering. So this is part of the Buddhist teachings. It’s not part just part of Tibetan Buddhism that made was made up in Tibet.

It cut and it’s not just part of Mahāyāna Buddhism, it’s it’s in all the schools, the valid schools of Buddhism, in the Pali Canon, in the Mahāyāna Sutras, in the Tantras, and so It’s it’s it’s there. These days some Buddhist teachers like to avoid talking about these topics watering down the Buddhadharma, but since if you take interest in the Buddhadharma and then you start reading it, sooner or later you will discover that these things are taught, so we might as well face it now. And it may be of some benefit. And as I always my way of trying to approach this is we can see animals, I can see animals, and I believe that animals have minds. I’m not very intelligent, I don’t have any psychic powers whatsoever, I have very little sensitivity, but I can see that I think I can see that animals have feelings and intelligence.

Again, I always give the same examples. Many years ago I lived on a farm, there was a horse on this farm, it was locked in a paddock, and there was a door a gate that went into another paddock, and in this other paddock do people know what a paddock is? A field? So anyway, in the smaller paddock which it sometimes could go into, there was a wooden gate with a sliding it had two slits like that, and there was a post along there, and so you open the gate by pulling it along. So this horse, Sally, when she got in there she would go to this gate and she would because she’d seen human beings slide it along, so she would pick up a piece of wood in her teeth, in her mouth, pull it along a bit, drop it, pick it up, pull it along, drop it, and then of course the thing would find, you know, she’d pull it along, drop it, pull it along, drop it, until it came out and the door opened.

This is logical thinking. Yeah. This is mind. This is mind. Yeah.

I used to like to ride her but she didn’t like me riding her so she would buck, you know. She would wait until I thought I was really confident and then she’d go, choom. Yeah. She had a mind of her own. The more we can think about that animals have mind, that then there’s the point that we could say, well, there are human, like human minds, that there’s the continuity of human minds, and then there’s the continuity of of animal minds, but that doesn’t really work because if mind is that which is clear and knowing, then and it is empty by of true existence because everything is empty of true existence, then mind has Buddha nature.

So then animal mind if animals have mind, that mind also has Buddha nature. So then the argument goes, and what’s my argument? But then if these animals have Buddha nature what’s my argument? They have a Buddha nature and mind works by the law of cause and effect, then how can they become enlightened? Animals never if yeah, okay, say.

They don’t experience the same kind of karma as a human being. They already have more suffering than a human being, but they have Buddha nature, they have delusions and are creating negative karma, so it must be it must work different than for a human mind. So how do they achieve enlightenment? They have Buddha nature. If they have mind, they have Buddha nature, but they can’t achieve enlightenment.

This is impossible. It starts to get very messy if you say there are separate streams of mind. And then you could argue, well then women have different minds than men. I mean, they work in different ways temporarily, but it’s not a different mind. Every man has been a woman, every woman has been a man.

So animal mind is in that state because of karma. It’s mind that is has been trapped in a particular state because of heavier delusion and karma. One way to try and think about it, if if I’m not making any sense, is there’s this entity called water, and by applying certain conditions to it, that water can turn hot. It can be well, it can become warm water. It can be hot water.

It become boiling water. That boiling water can turn into steam, that water can become cold water, that water can freeze and become ice, water can turn into clouds, water can turn into steam, water can turn into mist, water can turn into sleet, into snow, into hail, into sleet. All different, but these are not separate things. They all originate from this basic nature, this basic entity of water. There’s this basic entity mind, if you affect it with heavy delusions and karma, it transforms into animal mind, preta mind, hell mind.

You’re affected with other conditions that mind manifests as human mind, the mind of a desire realm God, the mind of a form realm God, the mind of a formless realm God, or the mind of an arhat, the mind of a bodhisattva, the mind of a Buddha. So my argument is if Buddha’s sorry, if animals have mind, then why not how can we deny the existence of the other realms? It becomes very difficult to deny what the Buddha taught, that there are these other realms our mind can sink into. The preta realm, the hungry ghost realm, and the hell realms. And also, many cultures, many religions have spoken about such things, have very similar ideas about these things.

It’s only in very recent times in our cultures that we have tended to reject and deny these things. So that’s one of some things to think about. So the reason the idea is to think about the suffering of these realms so and to understand the causes of them, and of course generally the causes of them are following the delusions, our self obsession, and therefore creating these negative imprints in the mind that ripen as the experience of these lower realms. So the point is, by really putting ourselves in these sufferings, imagining, coming to a conviction that our mind could really sink into these states, it generate the purpose is to generate a wise fear that gives us the courage to avoid negative actions, and give us the courage to do virtuous actions, the energy, the perseverance to do virtuous things with our body, speech and mind, so that we can make sure that we don’t fall our mind doesn’t fall into these lower realms. So this is the initial specific purpose.

Or another way of putting it, it’s actually a way to generate generate compassion for ourselves. Yeah. And and also by thinking about these realms and gaining some conviction that they do exist, this is the basis for developing compassion. Because if we only have compassion for human beings, and human beings are not the only sent and human beings are not the only sentient beings that exist, then we can’t achieve enlightenment. Compassion for human beings is not enough to work to generate Bodhicitta, the mind seeking enlightenment to benefit all sentient beings, to work for the sake of all sentient beings.

We can take the suffering of human beings as a way to wake force ourselves not to create negative karma, but we can’t take the suffering of human beings that is not sufficient to generate great compassion. Sentient beings are because animals are suffering now. There’s thousands and millions and millions of these beings suffering right now. And they’ve been our mother. The preta beings are suffering right now, and they’ve been our mothers.

The hell beings are suffering right now, and they’ve been our mothers. But just generally as a prelude to that, I’m trying to postpone the topic, is like in terms of thinking about a lower rebirth, could take many kinds of human rebirths as a lower rebirth. So we could think that any kind of body more suffering than we have right now, any human body more suffering than what we have right now is a lower rebirth. We live in a world of conventional appearances and we ourselves are what’s the word? Conditioned by social values and so on.

So there’s social conventions of beauty and ugliness. So if we were born conventionally very uglier than we are, not saying any of us are ugly, but if we were born uglier than we are, then we’d have more suffering. Just from our own point of view because we don’t want to be ugly, we want to think we look nice in some way, are pleasant looking in some way. So if we have a less conventionally pleasant looking body than what we have, we’ll have a more suffering rebirth. If the energy of our body is less than it has been in this life, there’ll be more suffering.

If the physical abilities of our body are less, are more impaired than they are in this life, will have a more suffering rebirth. If we have more disease, more pain and so on in our body, in our next life, it’s a lower rebirth. If our mind is less intelligent, less clear, less virtuous, less creative, we have more fear, tendency to depression, skepticism, cynicism and less energy in our mind, we have a more suffering rebirth. These are all things that are possible. And imagine if we had a rebirth where all of those things came together.

We were uglier, our body was deformed, there was much less energy in our body, we were subject to continuous sickness, aches and pains, the body often felt we often felt very hot or very cold, we bruised easily, our skin we bled easily, many things like that could happen. And then we were much less intelligent than we are now, less educated, much less energy in the mind, lots of fear, worries, anxieties, and so on. Put all that together, that’s bad enough. Just in this human realm is bad enough, and there are plenty sentient human beings like that. Forget about the extreme ones who are starving, being tortured, trapped in wars, full of hatred, racial hatred, religious hatred, and so on.

So if one doesn’t want to and one doesn’t want to think about what I’m going to say now, one can leave it, but still there are lower realms in this life, even as a human being, there are lower realm rebirths that we have to protect ourselves from. And the only way to do that is to avoid negative actions with our body, speech, and mind, and to create a happy rebirth by by doing virtuous things with our body, speech, and mind. So this is the point of this teaching, this meditation. So maybe we start off with the animal realm, which is the one of, in many ways, the least suffering. So the main cause to be reborn as an animal is ignorance, following ignorance, and also the aspects of ignorance such as close mindedness, narrow mindedness, and so on.

And yes, ignorance and stupidity. And so the main suffering of animals is that one of the main sufferings is a great deal of fear because also animals have very little control over their environment. They’re very deeply ignorant with little control over their life and their environment and so they have much fear, especially because as I mentioned before, animals, particularly in the wild, are the subject of prey for some other form of animal. There’s this you know, we’re familiar with the idea of the food chain, which is very typical scientific like lifeless expression, the food chain, but the beings in the food chains are sentient beings, sentient beings. So, animals experience a great deal of fear.

Also, they experience being exploited by others in many ways and again being the prey for food is a major way of being exploited, but also animals are exploited in countless ways by human beings. They’re killed for the sake of their wool, their meat, their skin, their fur, their bones, for pearls, for feathers. They are forced to work carrying heavy burdens and while carrying those heavy burdens they’re kicked, whipped, prodded, etc. In our wonderfully advanced modern world they are used in medical experiments. So many cosmetics are experimented with on animals, these things are in their eyes to see if the acid, you know, makes them blind or if there’s some too much acid to make them blind.

They’re you know, monkeys are sent up into space. They they have the you know, they’re used in these crashing or have been in the past in crashing these strapped into cars that are crashed to see what happens to the body. So appalling things are done to animals by human beings. human these animals that have feelings and thoughts, and even sometimes altruistic thoughts. We eat them alive, we oysters alive.

Or different kinds of sea fish we eat alive, then we boil lobsters alive to eat them. If you if you ever listen to if you put a lobster in don’t do it, but don’t do it. But when the lobster is put in water and boiled, it makes a noise, it screams, it screams. So these are some of the sufferings. Then beings these human these beings with minds, Buddha potential are locked in cages for our purposes.

Like there is we have this delicious meat called veal, this white meat which is achieved by taking small calves from their mothers and locked in cages where they don’t move and they’re kept in the dark, so that’s why the meat is white. Yeah. Then we have this wonderful food called pate de foie gras, which comes from force feeding geese, stuffing their you know, you have this thing and they’re force fed down their stomach, down their throat, so you can get so their livers expand. Delicious. We could be reborn as these beings and experience these sufferings.

Then in our society to have eggs, hens are kept in these cages, and that there are scientists who work out how to make the cages smaller and smaller to make more profit, so the animal has less and less space. And also the scientists work out how to feed them less and less and more and and and cheaper and cheaper stuff. The food that is fed, even if you’re a meat eater or you want to eat I can’t imagine why people eat eggs when you know what these beings are fed. It’s all poisonous stuff and it’s got because they get unbelievably sick, they’re full, they’re fed so many antibiotics and so on, they get so many diseases. They have to have their beaks pecked because they go insane, because they’re trapped there and they just pull out all their feathers because they they go literally insane because it is so tormenting.

Yeah. And this is done for money to make more eggs. These are sentient beings. Yeah. There’s rows and millions and millions of these beings being produced to be put in these little little cages where they can’t even stand properly, yeah, and they shit on each other.

There’s a rows and rows, yeah, and then there’s the hens who are laying eggs which are kept awake all the time, again in these tiny cages, yeah, sentient beings. We could be born there in that state. His holiness I lived in South India in at Sera Je monastery for a year in the Tibetan camps, I was really quite shocked myself when I saw this, that there was one of these poultry farms, it wasn’t as anywhere near as lavish as you see in the West, but there were all these caged chickens, and I thought how could Tibetans do that? Many many years ago not so many years ago, His Holiness when he visited His Holiness of Dalai Lama, when he visited Bylakuppe where these Tibetan camps are, where Sera Je is, he saw this, either this one or something similar, and he said in a teaching, if if you if you don’t get rid of that, if you don’t release all those animals, I’m leaving this planet. So they all the Tibetans clubbed together, bought the got the money, bought the chickens, liberated them.

His Holiness did this once before, that’s the long story, but when the Tibetan people started criticizing him for something, his holiness said, okay, I’m leaving, goodbye. I’m I don’t you don’t need me, you criticize me, you don’t need me, there’s plenty of other places I can go, I don’t have to be here. I’m here for you, you don’t want me, bye bye. So same with this, he saw that, this is, you know, this is just terrible. How can you treat sentient beings like this?

I’m off. I’m teaching compassion, you do this, I’m off. No need. Yeah. So this is the some of the sufferings of humans of animals.

Then in the wild, like I said, you can watch these documentaries of how animals prey on each other, and and the hunger. There’s always the hunger and finding food. Life is spent finding something to eat. A couple of years ago when I I did a little a little retreat in a little cabin at Nālānda monastery, at night the rats would scramble the roof had a like these corrugations like that, like little tunnels, so at night the wild the bush rats would scamper up and go into these tunnels and they would make all this noise. One day while I was reading a book, there was this noise in ceiling and I thought it sounded different, I thought it sounded kind of strange, not not not than usual, and normally there wasn’t this noise in the day, it was only at night the rats went into the roof.

So I went outside and I went around the side of the wall, and the wall of the hut was like that, of course it’s a wall. Wall, this is the wall and the ceiling was like that, the roof was like that and jutting over quite a bit and these corrugations. And I went out and I was looking this way at the wall, at the ceiling, right? Roof. And I saw this thin tail and I thought it was a rat, the tail of a rat.

And as I was looking at that I was distracted and this rat came out, you know, looking really freaked out and jumped out and ran over the top of the roof and disappeared. And then I looked back to this tail which I thought was the tail of a rat but it kept coming out, you know, down from the roof and it was a snake. And it came out, dropped on the ground, and there’s all this little squeaking like crying, and of course it had a baby rat in its mouth, and it kind of wandered off and swallowed the little baby rat whole with the parents freaking out in the roof of the the hut. This is this is animal life. It’s sentient life.

We can be reborn in these states. Of you here might know Geshe Tashi, who teaches in the center in London, who also lived at Nālānda. He told the story when he lived in India, he went to somewhere in I think it was in Assam. He went to one market and they had he saw these turtles, huge turtles, and people were buying the meat of the turtles, but what the butcher was doing is the people would say, I’d like a pound of turtle meat, so he would slice off a pound from the live animal. Of course there’s all stories about chopping the heads off of monkeys and you eat the brains live.

One of the highest delicacies in Chinese cuisine is you fry you fry a fish, you hold you hold most of its body in a what is it? In a wet cloth and you fry it alive, so that when you put it on the plate it still moves. Sentient beings, we can experience these states. These are some of the sufferings of the animal realm. If you go to India, if you go to maybe many people might here might go to Bodh Gaya after this course for his holiness and teachings.

There are around Bodh Gaya there are these little horse drawn carriages that you can ride in. The owners pile as many people as possible into them. The horses are really tiny. They’re they’re they’re skin and bone. Where the saddle touches their skin, get these incredible sores, and they they just bash these poor little horses to make them go faster, dragging these people and loads along.

This is animal life. So the idea is to put meditate on those sufferings, to imagine being such a being, spending one’s life searching for food, killing something for food, and in the meantime being terrified that something bigger is going to kill me for food. If you look at the birds all around, they’re they’re constantly moving, they’re looking around all the time, to kill something, to eat, or because maybe there’s some danger. Or you could put in a cage this big for all your life. So the idea is to meditate on that, what it would feel like that that’s suffering because it is mind, it’s mind.

You don’t have to be intelligent to feel pain. It’s not just because one is intelligent, or educated, or come from a from a an upper class background that you feel pain. A rat feels pain. It is the nature of samsaric mind to feel pain. So we needn’t think that animal pain is something less than our own, or animal hunger is something less than our own.

hunger is hunger, pain is pain. When we think, I don’t want suffering. I don’t want suffering. If I say this, when I say I don’t want suffering, I mean me.

Key terms in this teaching

buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
definitive meaning nitartha (Skt); ngedön (Tib)
One of two main ways of understanding a Dharma teaching, this one is where the content is be taken literally and not open for interpretation, as opposed to the interpretive meaning. LYWA
form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top