Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 21 Tape 39 Side 1 Karma

45 min · 4,444 words · 21 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 21 Tape 39 Side 1 Karma
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk develops the practice of recognising and repaying the kindness of one’s mother, using personal memories and passages from Thich Nhat Hanh, and extends this to all sentient beings. It then reflects briefly on the food we eat and explains how the twelve links operate across lifetimes, answering a question from a discussion group about the gaps between links.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-21

Duration: 46 min

UUID: c7eccf4b-9467-4ad0-b1b4-8762709b4525

Words: 4,444

Work very hard in so many ways to take care of us endure all sorts of difficulties and problems and we’ve created problems for our parents and the neighbours complain, the police complain. Our teachers complain to our mother or parents, and our mother had to put up with that, or maybe she lied to protect us, maybe she even stole to help us in some ways. Some women become prostitutes to look after their children. Our mothers have to endure all sorts of things to take care of us. The point of saying this is not to make ourselves guilty, but just to recognise the kindness of that, how incredibly kind our mother has been, how amazing.

There is a little poem, a haiku, that says, Wild the mother is eating the bitter parts. Well, it’s a translation of either a Japanese, I think, a Japanese poem that says, Wild persimmons? Persimmons are a type of fruit. The mother is eating the bitter parts. In other words, we get the sweet part and our mother will eat the bitter part.

Whatever good food there is, our mother gives us the best part and she takes the bitter part. I always tell the same story. In my family, when I was young, were not starving, we were not rich by any means, we were not deadly poor, we were not, you know My father was just a what do call it? An unskilled labourer. There was I once read in the paper a list of one hundred and forty three jobs in Australia, the social ranking of these jobs, so my father’s job ranked one hundred and forty two.

Top was a doctor, bottom was a street cleaner, my father ranked one hundred and forty two. As a labourer, used to carry bags of potatoes and stuff. So, what was the point? So, we didn’t have so much money. So, the great treat was to have steak sometimes.

My mother would save up and buy steak sometimes. So, it was always a very small amount and I would always get the biggest bit. And then, then, even though I got the biggest bit, then while my mother was eating hers, she would cut off some and give me some. Every time. Every time that happened.

Every time. That’s what our mothers do. And my mother was very attached to the steak, there was no doubt about that. My mother liked to eat, but she always gave me some, always, even though I always had the bigger bit anyway, bigger than hers from the start. But that’s what mothers do, you know.

So, this is really kind. It’s a small thing in one way, but in another way, it’s amazing because we have the self-cherishing thought, you know, and it’s very difficult for us to give something, but our mother can do it for us just because we are our mother’s child. There’s no thought, it just happens. There’s this unconditional love that is there. So, even if we haven’t experienced it in this life, we have experienced it before, in previous lives.

Our mothers have died for us. Our mothers have done everything for us in previous lives. Every possible thing they’ve done. So, it’s important as much as we can to remember, to recall again and again the things our mother has done for us, and to think of the effort and the pain and the suffering that may have involved. Again, not to feel guilty, just to appreciate it, and to generate the mind that wants to repay that now, now that I have the chance to do so.

Because as a child, we can’t. As a child, we don’t have this awareness and we don’t have the ability to help our mother and take away her suffering. We can’t do that and we don’t have to feel guilty that we didn’t, we weren’t able to do that. But now, as a mature adult, especially with the dharma, we can begin to repay that kindness. But first, we think about it, and just not one time, again, to remember this again and again.

To feel kind, to feel it, because by remembering it and seeing it in the right light, that that small thing was actually an example of our mother’s love or our father’s love and concern so on, affection and the wish to help us, wish for us to be free of suffering and to be happy. That’s what it actually was. Even if it didn’t work so well, that’s what the motivation was. And then one can actually feel that kindness. Because, in fact, we have always been held in kindness by our parents life after life, by so many sentient beings.

We have been surrounded by it life after life. So, I’d just like to read a few things along these lines. When we first come into the world, we are utterly dependent. Without food, physical care or emotional sustenance, we cannot grow. Emotional connection is such an important feature of our survival.

It is such an important feature that babies taken into care but given no love and personal attention cannot sustain life. They give up and die. Whoever cares for us first and most consistently, usually our mother, becomes our psychological umbilical cord. We depend on her for our very existence. We are merged with her and have no sense of where we begin or where she ends.

According to psychological tests, as a tiny child, the sense of ‘I’ is there, but we totally identify without we’re not able to distinguish ourselves from our mother. We’re the same thing when we’re first born. It’s only slowly that we become aware that there is me and my mother. And then we develop some separation more and more. But at first, we can’t even distinguish where I and this mother begin and end.

What she gives us emotionally forms the very essence of our personality. Her love and attention are an essential food that builds our personality. It is as important as the physical nurture we receive to develop our bodies. She fills up our world and our first experiences, pleasurable or painful, take place in an emotional context which She has created. We are enraptured in Her, fascinated by and very much in need of Her.

I don’t know where this quote comes from, but it makes the point that motherly love has been a symbol of the highest form of love in art and religion all over the world. Apparently, in the Hebrew language, the term indicating God’s love for man or humans and human being’s love for their neighbour is Rakamim. The root of this word is erekem, which means womb. So then I’d like to read something from, which I find very moving and is quite emotional, from Thich Nhat Hanh, a Vietnamese Buddhist teacher. It comes from a book called A Rose for Your Pocket.

I have to leave a bit out because it gets just too touchy sometimes, but anyway. Maybe you don’t find so, but anyway. So he says, People in the countryside do not understand talking about the people in the Vietnamese countryside but also maybe in general People in the countryside do not understand the complicated language of city people. When people from the city say that mother is treasure of love, that is already too complex for them. Country people in Vietnam compare their mothers to the finest varieties of bananas or to honey, sweet rice or sugarcane.

They express their love in these simple and direct ways. For me, a mother is like a banana of the highest quality, like the best sweet rice, the most delicious sugarcane. There are moments after a fever when you have a bitter, flat taste in your mouth and nothing tastes good. Only when your mother comes and tucks you in, gently pulls the covers over your chin, puts her hand on your burning forehead and gently whispers, My darling, do you feel restored, surrounded with the sweetness of maternal love? Her love is fragrant like a banana, like sweet rice, like sugarcane.

Father’s work is enormous, as huge as a mountain. Mother’s devotion is overflowing like water from a mountain spring. I read this morning and I got a little mushy. Maternal love is our first taste of love, the origin of all feelings of love. Our mother is the teacher who first teaches us love, the most important subject in life.

Without my mother, I could never know how to love. Thanks to her, I can love my neighbors. Thanks to her, I can love all living beings. Through her, I acquire my first notions of understanding and compassion. Mother is the foundation of all love and many religious traditions recognise this and pay deep honour to maternal figure such as the Virgin Mary, the goddess Kuan Yin.

Hardly an infant has opened her mouth to cry without her mother already running to the cradle. Mother is a gentle and sweet spirit who makes unhappiness and worries disappear. When the word Mother is uttered, already we feel our hearts overflowing with love. From love, the distance to belief and action is very short. Mother is the source of love and inexhaustible treasure but unfortunately we sometimes forget.

A mother is the most beautiful gift life offers us. You cuddle up to her to get warm, you sulk, you get angry with her, you complicate her life, causing her to worry, undermining her health, making her to go to sleep late and get up early. Many mothers die young because of their children. Throughout her life we expect her to cook, wash and clean up after us, while we think only about our grades and our careers. Our mothers no longer have time to look deeply at us and we are too busy to look closely at her.

Only when she is no longer there do we realize that we have never been conscious of having a mother. So then he goes on to say that while our mother is alive, we should really make sure that we tell her we love her because otherwise we’ll regret it. I won’t read that bit because I’ll just get too mushy. When love is present, that is enough and there is no need to talk of obligation. To love your mother is enough.

It is not a duty, it is completely natural, like drinking when you are thirsty. Every child must have a mother and it is totally natural to love her. That mother loves her child and the child loves his mother. The child needs his mother and the mother needs her child. And he goes on to say, Please do not think I have written this to give a lesson in morality.

Loving your mother is a question of profit. A mother is like a spring of pure water, like the very finest sugarcane or honey, the best quality sweet rice. If you do not know how to profit from this, it is unfortunate for you. I simply want to bring this to your attention to help you avoid one day complaining that there is nothing left in life for you. If a gift such as the presence of your mother doesn’t satisfy you, even if you are president of a large corporation or king of the universe, you probably will not be satisfied.

I only want to remind you that a mother is like a banana, like good rice, like honey, like sugar. So, that’s the kindness of the mother. Sorry. So, the more we think about this, then we can generate the wish. The more we think about how we actually have received kindness, then we generate the wish to repay it.

When someone is kind to us and we recognize that this person is being kind, somehow naturally, if our mind is not totally obscured, there is some thought wanting to repay that. In the very moment, there is some wish wanting to repay that. So, the more we can see that our mother of this life has been kind, we want to repay that. And the more that we then see that everyone has been our mother and has been kind, we want to repay that. That is the next cause: wanting to repay.

So, if it doesn’t work with thinking about your mother, then think about the kindness of your father, think about the kindness of your brother who looked after you, your sister, your grandmother, your grandfather, your uncle, your auntie. Someone took care of us. Someone did these things in this life. Of course, Thich Nhat Hanh is very ideal and perfect, but our mother did that sometimes, for sure. Someone was kind to us in this life and in every life, and apart from thinking about the kindness of our mother in some way, hopefully.

Because the kindness of the mother doesn’t have to be our biological mother, but someone Mother does. So that is incredibly kind. Okay, maybe we don’t have any questions today. Maybe we can just oh, okay, yes. Possibly, yes.

Yes, sure. Yeah. There is the story of the preta, the mother preta called Hariti, who had five hundred children. Of course, they were all starved, she was starving and they were all starving. So, she was one of the types of pretas that was able to come to the earth and Yes, actually she she went around killing human babies to feed her babies.

And I can’t remember how the story goes exactly now. But, yeah, somehow, then to stop her do that, stop creating that negative karma, the Buddha hid one of her five hundred children and she completely freaked out that one of her children was missing. Then the Buddha said to her, Look, you have five hundred children. When one of them is missing, you can’t bear it, you can’t bear it. And yet human people only have a few children and you’re taking them.

Imagine the suffering it must be for them. So please don’t do that anymore. And then he said, I will dedicate the merit of the from now on, the ordained followers my ordained followers, will dedicate some of their food every day to your children so that they won’t starve. So that’s what we as ordained monks and nuns are supposed to do every day, is do this practice which we don’t do every day. In Nālānda we do every day.

Anyone can actually do it, there’s a mantra you can recite on page fifty nine, yes. At the end of the meal you can leave a little bit behind and you can squash it up and you recite this mantra over it and through the power of the mantra and the dedication of the Buddha, it is believed it becomes possible that these preta beings, not just the five hundred, the preta beings can see this and get some sustenance from it. So even preta beings love their children. My pronunciation, what I’ve heard is Om Amrita Hum Svāhā. Om Amrita.

Where is it? Sorry? The book is called I think all from that book it’s called A Rose for Your Pocket. Any more questions? Yes, in your hand, then you recite the mantra over it and then you should put it somewhere where birds or something can get it.

You know, something like that. Do you have to snap a finger? Oh yes, you snap your finger and recite the mantra, yes. Okay, it’s almost time, no time to meditate. Oh, maybe just a few minutes, a couple of minutes.

Just spend just a couple of minutes thinking about the kindness of the mother and trying to extend that, thinking that all sentient beings have been my mother, even if they hadn’t been my mother, they’ve been kind to me in so many ways, life after life. So try and allow that awareness, that understanding and that feeling arise in the mind right now. So we can now dedicate the merit of this time. May it become a cause for me to be able to quickly achieve the enlightened state so that I can perfectly repay the kindness of all suffering, mother sentient beings. May the precious bodhi mind not yet born arise and grow.

May that born have no decline, but increase forevermore. Then we can do the food offering practice. So, particularly, we can really think how the food that we are eating today really has depended on so many living beings so much suffering and hard work was involved and many beings actually died for the producing of this food. So, rather than so, just to eat that food just for the pleasure of that and for the meaning of this life is somehow not so kind. It doesn’t give any meaning to all the suffering that all the beings experienced.

But if we, to some extent, generate the thought to use the energy that we get from this food to sustain our body so that we can engage in some meaningful practices today, throughout this life, then that gives meaning to all the difficulties, the sufferings that all the beings experienced to provide this food that we enjoy right now. Thank you very much for your attention. Just one notice: Everyone who is here is welcome to stay at Kopan while making travel arrangements until December fifteenth. So people are welcome to stay here until December fifteenth if they need to make travel arrangements. Hopefully, people will be able to, especially during the course, won’t be any need really to go down to do things.

We can try and organize things from here as much as possible. And the other announcement is that the cost of the tapes of the course, that there’ll be seventy tapes and the cost will be about Rs. Four thousand five hundred and fifty for the seventy tapes. Okay, thank you. So, again, we can try to recall the motivation for listening to the presentation of the graduated path.

Really appreciating, recognizing that we have this amazing Buddha potential, Buddha nature within us and to happily recognize that we have the precious human rebirth, the optimum chance to develop this Buddha nature and by doing so, making our own life meaningful and joyful and by repaying the kindness that we have received from all the suffering mother sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma and the Supreme Assembly. By the merits I create by teaching the Dharma, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings? Thank you. So, if you don’t mind, before going on with the topic of generating Bodhicitta, just to go back to a little bit more complicated topic, which is because I got one question from the Satsang House South discussion group about the twelve links because they decided the Satsang House South discussion group decided that they were a little fuzzy about the twelve links and if I could just very quickly go through them.

This may add more confusion, I’m not sure. Because there was some doubt about since the twelfth link of old age and death comprises our entire life, then the question was when does link one and eleven take place? Is the misunderstanding due to the fact that maybe we’ve misunderstood the Tibetan conception of time? So, it’s not a matter of misunderstanding the Tibetan conception of time because firstly, this teaching is not a Tibetan teaching, it comes from the Buddha. Just briefly, this topic is very, very complex.

It really requires a lot of study to really make sense of it and also to understand clearly what is meant by each of the twelve links, especially in the context of how it’s presented. So firstly, there’s the presentation of the twelve links. If you look at the picture that’s on page forty eight, Then the outer rim shows the twelve links starting with the blind person at the top and going around. So this just gives a very general idea of how, in a very, very general way, each link leads to the other in a very general sense. But then, if one really wants to understand how we take rebirth because the twelve links is an explanation of how we take rebirth again and again and again, so it doesn’t follow the order, that order of one, two, three, four and five it doesn’t follow that order at all.

This is just a general idea which is also very helpful to meditate on just simply like this, what is called the forward order where you think, because of ignorance, I create karma and therefore generate this consciousness polluted by that. This leads to name and form, da da da, then this leads to existence, old age and death. You get this feeling of the inevitability of this taking place, yeah and how one inevitably cycles again and again. So that very general way of meditating can be very powerful. But to understand how the twelve links interact in throwing us into another life gets quite tricky and complicated.

Again, as Lama Yeshe explained, it can take place in two lifetimes or three lifetimes. But those two lifetimes doesn’t mean two consecutive lifetimes, it can mean two consecutive lifetimes or it can mean like this lifetime we create some of the links and then in some future lifetime, then the rest of the links will be finished. There will be a gap which could be a gap of one lifetime, it could be a gap of many, many, many lifetimes but then the other links get finished Or it can be completed in three lifetimes like we start the links in this life, then there can be a gap and then some of the other links are finished in a second lifetime, then there can be a gap of many lives and then the last bunch of links gets completed in a third lifetime. So it doesn’t mean two consecutive or three consecutive lifetimes. Although it could also happen in two consecutive lifetimes or three consecutive lifetimes.

No, no, no, no. This applies to all kinds of rebirths but specifically it’s taught in the context of a human rebirth because it’s just easier to understand, that’s what we’re familiar with. But this works for more or less for all types of rebirths. So where do the gaps occur? Because I’ll try and explain it now, maybe this might help, it may help, it may get more confusing.

So, actually, maybe in one way it’s good to start at the twelfth link because that’s where we are now. We’re in the twelfth link now, we’re experiencing aging and one day death will come. So, while we’re experiencing this life, which is the twelfth link, during this life we will generate moments of ignorance, which is the first link. And in those moments of ignorance we will follow that ignorance and generate like in terms of we’ll just take negative situation, right? Because this is the one to be concerned about.

The positive one is fine, we have to be concerned about the negative situation. So in this life, the twelfth link, we generate moments of ignorance and on the basis of that ignorance, disturbing thoughts arise, these negative intentional thoughts, which is karma, the negative karma, karmic formations or karmic connecting karma. So, that then sets off the third link which is the consciousness that then holds or supports the karmic imprints from the karmic link, the second link. The second link is the intentional thought which is consciousness And then the third link, which is called consciousness, is referring to the consciousness that is holding the karmic link sorry, the karmic imprint that comes from the second link. Right?

? Right. So, because of ignorance, we generate this negative intentional thought which is the second link, karmic connecting karma. So that consciousness, right? Intentional thought.

And the third link refers then to in the next moment you have the consciousness that is holding the karmic imprint that is generated by the second link and that karmic imprint is not consciousness, it is an existing entity which is neither form nor consciousness. And that karmic imprint is held in the consciousness which is the third link, by the consciousness which is the third link. Right? So then, we skip and then, at the time of death, at the end of this life at the end of this life, then the second aspect of this third link, the consciousness holding that imprint which is a throwing karma, which is the one that is going to ripen. Say we create something very negative, karma in this life, and that is the one that is going to ripen at the end of this life because it’s very strong, even though we’ve created other negative imprints in past lives and whatever, but this one in this life is going to ripen.

So now, that at the very last moment of this life, that consciousness with that imprint, that imprint comes it’s the biggest karmic seed at the door of our consciousness, the last moment of our consciousness. So then the link of craving the craving, which can be there’s three kinds of craving referred to here. There is the craving for one is dying and there is the craving to have a rebirth, to keep embodied. So that craving now starts arising in the mind, and that starts to nurture this seed just like water, like the seed has been in the ground, the seed has been in the consciousness. So just as when the water, like enough moisture is there, then that starts to really awaken this seed, start to nurture it and then the grasping also, that craving gets stronger and stronger and turns into grasping which adds more moisture and nutrition, some nutrients, some fertiliser to the seed so that the seed is starting, almost ripening.

This leads to the next link which is called here existence but also is called, maybe a better word, becoming which is referring to this imprint becoming is referring to the very last moment of consciousness of this life or you know, a life. And that karmic imprint is just about to become to produce its result. It’s just about to do it. It hasn’t exactly because it’s like the

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
graduated path lamrim (Tib)
A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
preta
Hungry ghost, or spirit. The preta realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
throwing karma phen jä kyi lä (Tib)
Also called projecting karma, the karmic imprint that ripens at the time of death to propel us into the next rebirth. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top