43 min · 3,875 words · 30 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk stresses that caring for oneself wisely, including periodic retreat, is needed to benefit others. It explains Shantideva’s method of generating bodhicitta, moving from equanimity to equalising self and others, recognising all beings as kind mothers, and opposing self-cherishing. It distinguishes the validly existing self from the truly existing self, using mirage, snake-and-rope and hologram analogies. A guided meditation on equalising self and others and a food offering practice are included.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-30
Duration: 44 min
UUID: da824cf4-9d4d-4c1a-80f7-9ac5ed67f501
Words: 3,875
We need to do that. This is like one of the questions about people working in caring, the health field and whatever, run out of people get burned out because there’s endless suffering to overcome and deal with, and we, at the moment, people get involved in that because there’s some compassion and loving kindness there. But, at the moment, being deluded beings, not have an endless reserve of love and compassion, and it runs out because there’s always an object. So, if we don’t withdraw and build up our resources again, then we get burnt out and can actually turn bitter and so on. So, this is the whole point, even in an ordinary level, that one needs to spend time on oneself in order to benefit others.
And in the point of the spiritual path, this becomes crucial at one point that the aim is, eventually, on the path that one withdraws from the world and goes into retreat in order to gain the deepest realisations, which doesn’t mean which many people think everyone suddenly wants to rush off into retreat straight away, but most of us don’t have the real preparations to do that, and we don’t have the real motivation. It’s just all intellectual. But at some point, for example, in the case of Milarepa, who separated himself, lived in the most remote places, but he did that for the sake of others, and then he gained these amazing realizations which have benefited others ever since. And it’s the same in all the religious systems, Saint Francis is an incredible example in the Christian tradition of someone who also lived, you know, withdrew and lived in very austere situations for periods of time, then went back and helped. This is an essential part and this is something that, like, if we right now, trying to follow the spiritual path in any way, it’s always good to spend some time doing retreat.
Like Lama Yeshe used to say, that we should retreat once a year, at least. Do one small retreat, like a week retreat each year by ourselves, or in a group, or by ourselves, to regenerate all the good energies, separate, retreat from the eight worldly concerns, and look at one’s life in a more quiet environment, and so on. So this is not being selfish, this is just being wise and compassionate. Everyone likes to when you hear about the Dhamma, everyone starts to say, Oh, but if I do something for myself, it’s selfish. But this this is just words.
There is selflessness in self. There is being compassionate for oneself and being selfish. There’s loving oneself and then there’s self obsession. The whole point of the dharma is to take care of ourself but properly, wisely, compassionately, and to take care of the validly existing self that needs our help. There’s this poor little me that is starving for attention which does exist, and there’s this I that doesn’t exist at all that we spend all our time looking after.
Yes, but I’m not sure whether the translations maybe they should be reversed, the translations. But does one lead to the other? Or are we making a mistake going through No, no, First one has to develop equanimity where one reduces this idea of friend, enemy and stranger. That has to come first. And then on the basis of that, one can develop equilibrium where one equalizes self with others.
One can’t equalize oneself with others without having first developed this equanimity of seeing people as basically all friends. Because while we have enemies, it’s impossible to think, I am equal to my enemy. I am equal to a stranger. Strangers are kind of I don’t even know them, so how can I they’d be equal to me? They’re way over there.
Yeah. If we go into a retreat situation, of course, we go with our self-cherishing thought. Yes. Unfortunately. With experience, time and experience, of seeing what works and seeing how much we can we have to I mean, point is, we have to challenge our self-cherishing thought.
We do have to push it, but we can’t push it too much at once, step by step. So, have to skillfully check out how much we can challenge ourselves without freaking out and getting this famous lung, which comes from self-cherishing. We push our self-cherishing too much and we get imbalanced. We get this famous lung. Oh, if you know about it, you’ll get it.
People who don’t know about it don’t get it. Soon as you know about it, everyone gets it, Oh, I’ve got lung, I have to relax. I don’t have to meditate anymore, I’ve got lung. Sorry, just joking. Lung, it just means wind, so it’s an excess of, like, a tantric point of view, we have the five, also from old time Western view also, we have the four elements in the body, one of which is the wind element on which the mind moves as well.
So, through unskillful meditation and various other things, the wind element in the body increases and it causes nervous tension so on anxiety, fears, worries, hallucinations, all sorts of things. And this pain in the heart here is a type of lung, a very dangerous type of lung, where you get this very painful feeling in the heart chakra. It basically comes from pushing too much, pushing the self-cherishing thought, not doing it softly, softly and compassionately. Oh wait, many people have it. Well, what we what I don’t know Well, in English we have things called nervous breakdowns.
This is lung, this is extreme lung. Yeah? This is lung. Yeah? Or just being anxious and having anxiety attacks, this is lung, a type of lung.
There are many kinds of lung, but this is, you know, when you get nervous, the body is shaking. Yeah? This is too much wind in the body. Oh, yeah, sure. Yeah.
Yes. Oh, sorry, I can’t hear a thing. It is an impermanent lasting situation. Impermanent lasting situation? Yes.
It’s an impermanent ongoing situation, Changing moment by moment, but changing in the same way, moment by moment. And is one mind never created No, no, no, no. It does create things but not original creations. It manifests as Buddhas. It manifests as Tārā and Vajrasattva, dogs, trees, teachers, all sorts of things changing moment by moment, manifesting different things moment by moment, but not creating them in the sense of coming out of absolutely nothing.
So, okay, we have a few minutes, so we can meditate on developing the mind of equalising ourselves with others. So, sitting in a comfortable position and generating good motivation, and just briefly go through the points I mentioned this morning about we have this very strong sense of I I wanting happiness, I not wanting suffering, but then try and see, look how every human being that we know, we read about, see, hear about, wants to be happy, same as me. If we look at the external actions, it’s different. But if we investigate the motivation, it’s the same. Same motivation that moves everything I do in this life.
So why make a difference? So we can contemplate along these lines in terms of suffering, in terms of our delusions, in terms of having Buddha nature, it’s all the same. What difference can I validly make? What is the benefit of making any difference? And also try to feel, experience the mind that feels that the thought of I wanting happiness is just the same as any other living being’s thought of wanting happiness.
Try to feel that connection, the mind experiencing that. We can dedicate the merits to be able to actually experience the state of equality between self and others, and through that experience, be able to make this become a cause to achieve enlightenment as Bodhicitta, and therefore, through that, actually achieve the enlightened state that continuously, effortlessly, spontaneously, joyfully and perfectly repays the kindness of all suffering Mother sentient beings. May the precious bodhi mind not yet born arise and grow May that born have no decline, but increase forevermore. We can do the food offering practice. So, to make this time beneficial, can it’s important to try and generate the best motivation that we possibly can.
What helps to do this is to generate the thought of refuge and imagine the perfect refuge of the enlightened mind manifesting in front of us in the aspect of Śākyamūni Buddha, surrounded by countless other Buddhas and Bodhisattvas, all our own holy teachers and other holy beings. Of course, for those who have a teacher, then we try to see the Buddha as the very embodiment of our teacher, visualizing the Guru Buddha, and then ourselves surrounded by all the different kinds of sentient beings. And thinking for the benefit of all the kind suffering Mother sentient beings, will listen to this presentation of the Graduated Path. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Supreme Assembly. By the merits I create by teaching the Dharma.
May I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings? Thank you. So, in Śāntideva’s method of generating Bodhicitta, There are four unique stages of his method, also some of the aspects of Asaṇga’s method are incorporated into it. So, Śāntideva’s method, actually, of generating Bodhicitta includes Asaṇga’s method in it, but Asaṇga’s method of generating Bodhicitta does not include Śāntideva’s method. So, for this reason, Śāntideva’s method is considered the much more powerful one.
In Śāntideva’s method, on the basis of having this equal feeling towards this sense of equilibrium that doesn’t distinguish friend, enemy, or stranger so strongly, then on the basis of that, one can develop the mind of equilibrium that generates this equal feeling between self and others Not just between self and all others, but having the mind that is able to have an equal feeling with any sentient being one meets or experiences, whether it’s a human or non human being. We don’t feel any separation, any superiority in any way, but this equal feeling. So, this is the basis of generating Bodhicitta, and it’s also, of course, the mind that a Buddha has because a Buddha mind doesn’t see any difference between themselves and other sentient beings. They don’t think, I am this holy being, and there are these deluded sentient beings. There is no forced discrimination like that.
So then, on the basis of that feeling of equality with others, there are the next stages also in Śāntideva’s method, there’s the practice of recognising sentient beings as one’s mother, thinking of the kindness of the mother and wishing to repay it. One of my teachers, Tārā Tulku, used to say that whenever we generate the mind that thinks of the kindness of others, that always brings some good feeling into our heart, into our mind automatically. There is some peace and calmness and some kind of gentle, positive quality in our mind. Whereas, when we generate the thought that believes that I am independent and I am totally all my happiness and qualities come from me, then that produces a very hard mind, a suffering mind. But when we open up and see how we depend on the kindness of others, even these very small acts of kindness, then this brings some happiness into our heart.
So, it’s such a beneficial state of mind to cultivate, just being able to recognize that. It makes the mind happy to see these small acts of kindness that people engage in day by day towards us and towards others, also to to rejoice in the kindness that others display towards each other. So, then the next step of Śāntideva’s method, which is one of the unique parts of Śāntideva’s method, is to contemplate the disadvantages of the self-cherishing thought. So, as I’ve been trying to say, there are two levels of this self-cherishing thought. There’s the very gross level, which itself is a negative mind that expresses itself in countless ways, especially through the eight worldly concerns.
And that mind, by following that mind, actually just keeps us trapped in saṃsāra again and again. Whereas the subtle self-cherishing mind is a virtuous mind, it is still thinking, it is thinking in a wise and virtuous way, it has qualities of love and compassion for others, but the main concern with the subtle self-cherishing thought is to achieve liberation, the state of nirvana for oneself. So, a Mahāyāna point of view, from, of course, the point of view of practitioners following that path, this is the best motivation to have. But from the point of view of the Mahāyāna, then this is a kind of subtle type of self-cherishing. It’s a virtuous mind, but it’s a mind from a Mahāyāna point of view, it’s a limited kind of mind that prevents full enlightenment, developing the mind of complete enlightenment.
So, this ultimately is the or finally, the mind that we want to eradicate completely. Because, in achieving enlightenment, we also do achieve our own liberation, we don’t get stuck in that state of liberation, that state of our own self bliss, but we are able to progress and continuously benefit others, and eliminate the subtle imprints in our mind which which are the obstacles to omniscience. They are removed by wisdom, but a wisdom that is much stronger because it’s empowered by the Bodhicitta thought the merit, this virtuous power that is generated under the influence of Bodhicitta. So, to get rid of the subtle self-cherishing thought, we first have to get rid of the gross self-cherishing thought. Just thinking about the kindness of others itself, again and again, how every sentient being has been one’s mother, has been kind, that should help cut the subtle self-cherishing thought that thinks only to benefit myself, only to liberate myself.
As I quoted from Lama Zopa Rinpoche before, Otherwise it’s like walking in the forest with one’s mother, and a tiger comes out, we run up the tree and watch our mother being eaten and think, Well, I’m glad I escaped. So, the more we think of the kindness of the mother, then we can overcome this self-cherishing thought. Particularly, I think at this level, what we need to understand especially the disadvantages of the gross self-cherishing thought that we’re caught up in now. And the more we think about that, we can also generate the mind. Since the gross self-cherishing is totally obsessed with me and my pleasures now, the more we see the disadvantages of that, the more we can see that the very opposite mind, the mind that wants to benefit others, is the very best antidote to that self-cherishing thought.
So, the self-cherishing thought, this term is in some ways a bit unfortunate, especially even in English, the term self-cherishing sounds like something good. The word cherishing generally has a very nice connotation to cherish others, to cherish ourselves. But in the Buddhist context, it has a negative connotation and also when it gets translated into other languages, there’s so much confusion of trying to get the right word for this self-cherishing. So, I don’t know, self obsession may be another term we can use, I don’t know if it’s better or maybe it’s worse, I don’t really know. But, so far, we seem to be stuck at the moment.
We don’t have to be stuck, but at the moment we’ve got this term, self-cherishing. So, it’s important to remember that it is different in meaning from self grasping. There are two terms: self grasping and self-cherishing. So, they are different. Go together but they are different.
Fundamental root of suffering is the self grasping ignorance which creates the illusion of this truly existing person. And because of that, one has self-cherishing. First, one has the gross self-cherishing or self obsession, and even when one follows the spiritual path, one can have this subtle self-cherishing, wanting to achieve liberation for oneself. So, we can start to immediately understand that there must be lots of disadvantages to the self-cherishing thought if we understand what the meaning of self and cherishing are in this phrase self-cherishing. So, in context of the gross self-cherishing thought, this negative mind, the self is not the validly existing self, but the false self that is appearing now.
So, we’re trying to cherish something that actually doesn’t exist. It only exists as a concept in our mind. But, just like when you see a mirage of water in the desert, that mirage exists, but the water doesn’t. Right? There’s no water there at all.
The appearance of water is definitely there, one can say, in a sense is valid, but the water doesn’t exist there at all. The mind believing water there is an invalid mind. It’s an invalid perception and therefore an invalid mind. Or if you pronounce it in English, if you pronounce invalid in another way, it becomes invalid and it becomes like a sick mind. It’s a sick mind that’s seeing, believing that that is true.
Please don’t think I’m criticising invalids as maybe some people are thinking, now I’m putting down invalids as being disgusting people. I am not saying that, please. I didn’t mean that, sorry. The self we’re trying to cherish with the self-cherishing thought doesn’t exist at all, at all, other than as a concept in the mind, a concept held by ignorance. The appearance is there but there’s nothing behind the appearance.
That particular appearance. Also, to try and clarify this point, I did mention it before but maybe people didn’t quite catch it or understand, But in the case of the analogy of the rope and the snake, there is the appearance of the snake but no validity to it, no substance to it whatsoever. Mind the ignorance is creating the appearance of the snake and believing it’s really there as it appears from its own side. But why that snake appears, what is the basis for that appearance, that false appearance of a snake to appear, is that a rope is there. A rope is there, something is there, and then ignorance knows that in a false way, in a distorted way, and creates the illusion of something else.
So in that analogy, of course, there’s quite a bit of difference between a rope and a snake. A snake is a sentient being, a rope is inanimate and doesn’t even move. But the same with the validly existing self, which is the merely labelled self which does validly exist, and then there is the truly existing self which doesn’t exist. Ignorance creates the illusion of the truly existing self and grasps at it as being true from its own side. The basis for that mistake to arise, that illusion to arise, is the validly existing person, the person that is validly existing as being merely labelled by the mind on the five aggregates.
So that person is existing but again, is not truly existing but is existing. So we can’t refute that, that becomes the wrong view of saying nothing exists whatsoever. So the validly existing person, the merely labelled ‘I’, is the basis for ignorance to perceive it and then immediately distort it, put something on it which is not there at all, is the appearance of true existence, something existing completely from its own side, sustainable from its own side, not depending on other phenomena. So, the self-cherishing thought is not cherishing the validly existing person. The self-cherishing thought, the gross self-cherishing thought, is trying to take care of just a ghost, just an hallucination.
Yeah. Like trying to feed a dead dog. We rush out and buy all the food, spend all the money, most delicious to buy the most delicious food to feed a dead dog. The dead dog can’t eat it, can’t get any benefit from it because it just doesn’t exist anymore. In fact, it never did exist.
It’s like trying to teach a plastic canary to talk. We can spend our whole life, you know, someone gives us a cage with a canary, here’s a canary, they forget to tell us it’s not a real canary but we think it is, so we spend the rest of our life trying to teach it to talk or budgie, canaries don’t talk, budgies do, trying to teach a budgie to talk. Yeah, it’s just a complete waste of time, complete waste because it’s only the appearance of a budgerigar or a cockatoo or something that can speak. It’s just the appearance, it’s not the real thing. Just like these flowers, they look like flowers, right?
But they’re not flowers. They’re imitation flowers. So, you you go up and smell them, Oh, there’s no smell, there’s something wrong with my nose. Go off and get an expensive operation. Life’s not worth living, I can’t smell flowers anymore so we commit suicide.
But, this is not a real flower, there’s no way, no matter how many nose operations we have, all these smell, The real ones don’t even smell anyway, probably, especially these days. Flowers don’t smell anymore. Anyway, sorry, raving, I’m raving. Totally raving. Right, so, in one sense, it’s a very sad, ridiculous situation that we’re trying to take care of something with so much time and energy and expense that is not there, it’s just not there.
Or maybe, I don’t know, I’ve never actually seen one, but there are things called holograms, three-dimensional holograms. So, one could mistake that that was whatever it is appearing to be. You only try to touch it, but no matter how much you try, you can’t touch it because there’s no substance there. So, the self, our ignorance creates, is like a hologram. It’s very real, three-dimensional and whatever, maybe.
I don’t know if it’s three-dimensional, but anyway, it appears very real. But it’s not there. So, it can’t be made happy because it’s just not there. It’s such an incredible waste of time. And the person that we are is dying for lack of attention Because the person we are exists solely and only on the basis of this body and mind.
So we do take care of the body because we think we are our body, to some extent we take care of that. But what we really are much more is our mind. We are not synonymous with our mind, but we are totally dependent on our mind. The ‘I’ that exists is merely labelled on the mind, On the five aggregates, four of which are the mind, aspects of the mind. And if we take care of the mind, I am happy.
If mind is happy at peace, I am happy. But then going back to this self-cherishing, we’re trying to take care of a self that doesn’t exist. And how do we cherish it? What does the cherishing of this self refer to? How do we cherish me?
We cherish me with our afflicted desire, attachment, anger, our jealousy, our pride, our doubts and so on. Particularly
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- graduated path lamrim (Tib)
- A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.