44 min · 4,791 words · 17 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk continues a Kopan course session on death and impermanence. It explains meditating on impermanence and on the certainty and uncertainty of death, using the lifespan, the leaking pond and the movie examples, and it urges practising Dharma now because life is short. It also includes course announcements about punctuality and attending morning meditation and discussion groups.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-17
Duration: 45 min
UUID: fdaf41f7-d0fc-4e9a-9546-f031c8b2d6ae
Words: 4,791
We don’t look at our mind, our mind will remain deluded and lots of suffering. Now we have discovered this, and this itself is a cause for joy if we think in the right way. We could have come to Nepal and gone trekking and go home. You go trekking with your delusions, you go home with your delusions. Same thing.
You’ve come here, found out about the delusions and some way to do something with them, and you go home with the delusions, then you go home with method. Rejoice. Rejoice. The delusions have always been there. Buddhism didn’t create them.
Learning learning the Buddhadharma doesn’t doesn’t stick delusions in your mind. They’ve always been there. Now one has a method to start to do something about If you think on the positive side that now I’ve always had the delusions that always caused me suffering, I’ve never had anything to do with it to to stop it. Now I’ve got something. Isn’t this fantastic?
If you think like that, you’ll make yourself happy. If you think, now I’ve discovered Buddhism and Buddhism tells me I’ve got delusions, now I’m terrible. What’s the point? The delusions have always been there, but now you’ve got something that wasn’t there. Think about that part.
As Lama Zopa says, one way of thinking leads to all suffering. Another way of thinking leads to all happiness. Be wise. Be compassionate. It’s okay to have delusion.
It’s okay. No. Not necessarily. It could. It could generate that, but not necessarily.
I I again, I not necessarily, I don’t think. You like, you know, soldiers who like, who were in the first World War or the second world war in Vietnam, they saw many, many people dying all around them. I I don’t think they gained the realization of impermanence and death. I hope they did, but probably didn’t. That’s the way our mind works.
It blocks off that one still thinks I’m not going to die. Mean, sure, it could act as a condition if you think about it in the right way. If we don’t think about it in the right way, our the permanent concept and our self-cherishing blocks us from realizing that I could die. Of course, you know, soldiers in war have fear of death, but that fear of death is not the realization of death. Everyone has fear of death.
When you’ve when you’ve realized impermanence and death, you don’t fear death. Well, it’s not just a non fear of death. For some people don’t fear death because they don’t believe they’re going to die. But that’s one quality of the realization that there isn’t this fear, unreasoning fear of it. Maybe we should take a break now.
Our legs stretching, mind relaxing. Short break. And then we’ll do some meditation. Just to introduce the topic, we’ll just do a short meditation on impermanence. So try to go back to what I was explaining yesterday, this morning, about firstly, we sit in the right position, generate the right motivation, and then just allow the mind to think about impermanence that everything that we experience is arising depending on causes and conditions.
Just check that point, is this true or not? That what I experience in my life, my body, the things of this world, people, everything I see, hear, taste, touch, smell, think about is existing depending on causes and conditions. And then contemplate that because of that thing, most of the things that I see do change, I see gross change. Therefore, maybe it’s true that there is this subtle change, decay, taking place moment by moment. If this is true for some things that depend on causes and conditions, maybe it’s true for everything that depends on causes and conditions.
They not only experience gross change, but this gross change happens because of subtle change, moment by moment, subtle decay. Even from our own experience, our experience is telling us that if we think about it logically. But the Buddha, with pure, clear mind, perceived that actually everything, depending on cause and condition, decays moment by moment. Why? Simply because it’s depending on cause and condition.
Because there’s no power from the side of the object to stay the same. Think about that, and then think of the example of a sound arising depending on cause and condition. And then try to understand, realize, be aware that all phenomenon, no matter how solid, permanent looking, decaying moment by moment, insubstantial, a sound like a sound. And like a sound, once it’s finished, one can’t bring it back. Decay is irreversible.
The decision to use this precious human rebirth to be more aware, more mindful in our daily life, how everything we experience is actually changing and decaying moment by moment. And then, so therefore, to reduce our attachment to things that appear to be permanently beautiful, to lessen our aversion and anger to things that appear threatening, bad, harmful, permanently like that. So we can let go of our grasping of the appearances of this life so we have the time and energy to cultivate our mind, make this precious human rebirth really meaningful for ourselves and all everything. Let me dedicate the merit. May the precious bodhi mind not yet born arise and grow.
May the unborn have no decline, but increase forevermore. Then we can make the food offering, which is on page sixty, thinking of at least doing the contemplation when we sit down to eat that to eat this food not just simply for the momentary pleasure it can give, but to energize our body and mind so that we can use this body and mind to practice Dharma. Then we can do the practice if we wish of trying to see the food as nectar that is completely blissful, totally satisfying our body and mind and cutting through attachment. We offer this nectar to the inner Buddha within us who we visualize surrounded by all the different sentient beings that we offer this nectar to as well. Just before we go, just one announcement.
I’d like to make a request that, please, if people could try to be on time for the sessions. The weather is extremely beautiful during the day, so there seems to be a tendency of people coming later and later, even to the first session. Then the breaks get longer, people dawdle in the sunshine. Sunshine is much nicer than thinking about death. So please remember it’s a practice of being sensitive to others and offering to others because we all have to wait until everyone is here, people wait and wait.
So it’s part of the course to work really well if everyone comes on time and also please, if people can come to the morning meditation session, it’s an integral part of the course. The course structure was developed, the whole course, the whole idea of the course comes from Lama Yeshe’s holy mind. The structure of the Course is from Lama Yeshe. It was his wish that everyone come to everything for their own benefit, to encourage everyone else to do so. If one person doesn’t come, then two people don’t come, then three, then the course falls apart.
And the morning meditation is really crucial because we contemplate what’s been taught during the day and as I tried to say at the very beginning of the course, this is called a meditation course because even if a great deal of meditation isn’t done in the course, the course is about presenting meditation topics that we can meditate on for the rest of our life and developing some energy now so that when we go away from here we will want to meditate in a correct and continuous way. One of the crucial things of having a regular Dharma practice in our life is to meditate first thing in the morning. It’s the hardest thing to do and it’s the best thing to do. As His Holiness the Dalai Lama says, the best meditations are done early in the morning, to get up early and meditate because then the mind is fresh and this more subtle mind, a little bit of the more subtle mind is active. The gross delusions haven’t woken up quite so strongly and if we can catch this clearer mind and meditate with that, it can be very powerful.
So it’s really good to try to get into practice of doing the morning meditations because then there’s a chance we can keep going with it if we want when we go back home. The other thing is also it’s really good to come to the discussion groups. It’s very good for the old students to come because they have some background which they can offer to the new people. It’s very good for the new people to come, who have no background in Buddhadharma, come to the discussion groups because they can learn something from the older students and discuss and also they have a fresh mind, a fresh approach, have thought of things that the old students may never have thought of. So it’s really helpful for everyone to come to the discussion groups to learn something with the idea of learning something but also with the idea of trying to contribute something to the discussion group and just even being there is a contribution because it encourages everyone else to come.
It’s really important, it’s an integral part of the course. And the more people come, the more that can be discussed, more ideas bounce off each other. Yeah, like that. It works better if we can all contribute. I think it’s really good in the discussion groups for everyone to try to discuss, at least at some point, say something, not hold back and don’t say anything about anything.
It’s really nice if we can all talk to each other. Because we all want to be happy and we are all suffering and it’s really nice to be able to say that to each other. Here we have a place where we can say that. Difficult in other places. If we can’t say it now, when can we say it and discuss it?
With nice people, friendly people who are trying to tame their minds, who won’t scream and yell at us? Much. Thank you very much. So for the greatest benefit to arise in our mind right now from being here, it depends on our motivation. Firstly, to develop a motivation that transforms what we’re doing from an ordinary, worldly practice into something that is actually a spiritual practice and then beyond that to develop the motivation, the highest motivation we possibly can or aspire to that, which is the bodhicitta thought to develop our mind completely, to achieve the state of buddhahood or enlightenment that has all the qualities to perfectly benefit continuously all suffering mother sentient beings.
And, as much as possible, we can base that aspiration on the triple gem of the Buddha, Dhamma and Sangha which we can imagine manifesting in front of us in the form of Śākyamūni Buddha seated on a lion throne, lotus, sun and moon, having a body of golden transparent light. And ourselves surrounded by all the different sentient beings beginning with our mother, father, family and friends and people we dislike or who dislike us. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddhadhana of the Supreme Assembly. By the notes I create by practising the Dharma. May I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings?
So we spent a little time focusing on the breath to enhance our concentration, to use that to listen to the presentation of the Dharma so we can understand more clearly and therefore this makes a deeper imprint, deeper, stronger, clearer imprint in our mind. So, have this very amazing Buddha potential within us and we have a precious human rebirth, the optimum chance to develop our brilliant nature or develop our mind so that this brilliant nature becomes totally manifest. And yet, strangely enough, we waste this life, so much of this life goes into all these petty concerns of this world. So many different things attract us and repel us but they all come down to these eight worldly concerns. So what helps us to cut through all of that is to be able to renounce all that so that we can cultivate our mind is an awareness of the impermanence of the things that we’re so obsessed with.
On the one hand, to really train ourselves to be able to see that, in some way, at some level, to perceive that, not with our eye consciousness so much, but in every way, to perceive it with our mind to understand it. So that’s one part of the process. The other process is to realise that we ourselves are going to die, that our death is definite. And we could also die at any moment. So if we could have that awareness, that mindfulness in our daily life, then it’s important to think that if I had this awareness, sorry, this mindfulness, then when I was caught up in these worldly concerns, if I could just remember that I could die now in this state, being obsessed with these small things, developing aversion to these things.
What incredible waste that would be. So we need to meditate on these points for that purpose to develop this wise, loving, compassionate state of renunciation, that lets go of the causes of suffering, the first level of causes of suffering, our obsession with the things of this life. And as I mentioned, one of the great benefits of having this mindfulness of death and the uncertain time of death is that it is able to cut through every single deluded thought that we have. And by being aware of mindfulness aware of death during our life, then when death actually comes, then it won’t be a surprise, we’ll be prepared for it. So we can uh-huh.
That’s why it was so strange. So, and as I mentioned before this morning, if we feel a lot of fear of thinking about death and impermanence, well firstly, the way to prepare our mind to do that is firstly to meditate on the precious human rebirth. That’s why the meditation on death comes after recognising the precious human rebirth. The more we recognise that we have this precious human rebirth, then to lose that is really sad. If we don’t think our life means very much one way or another and that the life ends in some kind of blackness, some nothingness, then to meditate on death and impermanence is not so helpful.
As somebody said, who I forgot to find out who said it, death without any sustaining belief leads to cynicism and despair. But if one has this belief in Buddha nature and the preciousness of our human life, that acts as a really valid context to think about death and to wake up. And then to think about the advantages of thinking about death, contemplate the advantages, contemplate the disadvantages, so put time into those things, then one has prepared the mind to really contemplate death, which is attacking the self-cherishing thought, the self obsessed thought that limits us constantly, keeps us in suffering. So, in trying to think about the certainty of death in the traditional meditation, the first point is to try to understand, to try to convince the mind that we have no power to remain in this earth. No one has ever been able to remain.
The most powerful political leaders, spiritual accomplished beings and so on, no one has been able to do that. No one is able to no human being is able to live much beyond a hundred years. There’s a few exceptional people who have lived to be a hundred and twenty or something, a hundred and twenty five, but beyond that, not much. Very, very rare. So, how can we think that we’re going to succeed?
What is so special about this body? It’s very difficult to find a valid reason that we can give ourselves to prove that we’re going to live, that we’re going to keep living. Especially when we’re living in a world much more polluted than in the past. I mean, I am tempted to go on more about this but the course is not so much time, but the idea is to give many many examples of this to oneself, to one’s deluded mind. Trying to change that, to overcome the familiarity of thinking I’m going to live and develop the familiarity, this wise familiarity that understands there’s no basis for me to be able to live on and on and on.
So if that doesn’t work, one can go to the next general point which is to think, or if it does work, one can enhance it with the second point which is that our life is constantly passing away without any way to add to it. Our life is like a pond of water which has a hole in it and the water is leaking out moment by moment and sooner or later, if the pond is empty, life comes to an end and there’s no way to add to that. This point makes much more sense, is much more powerful if we have some kind of understanding and faith in the law of cause and effect because this life itself is the product of previous lives. It is an effect depending on the cause generated in previous lives. So the cause has been accumulated, it’s finished, and now we’re experiencing the effect.
So there’s nothing we can do. We can’t create more causes for this life to go on. It’s a little bit like it. Everyone gives this example because it’s so apt, I think, which is that if watch a movie, the fact that we can watch a movie, the movie isn’t being made as we watch it. The movie was made has to have been made before we see it.
The movie is made and is imprinted on the reel, on the film. The movie was made it could have been made years before years and years before we ever see it. So no matter how if we watch a good movie, matter how much we would like the movie to go on and the hero and heroine have extra adventures or whatever, no way because the movie’s finished. Producer and everyone packed up and went home a long time ago. So it is the same with our life, our life is unfolding day by day because we created the causes before this life and now that’s the beings that we were that created those causes, they’re all dead, they’re packed up and gone.
And here’s the result, here’s the result. So if we really have some understanding of that, some inkling that that may be true, then we can really see there’s nothing that we can add to this life now. But by doing exercises and eating well and so on, this just acts as the condition for the good karma of this life to be fulfilled. And that by watching as we cross the street, by checking the vehicles, that acts as a condition so that we can keep living. None of these things themselves add to our life because our life is a karmic experience, so there’s nothing we can do.
It’s running out day by day. So nothing we eat is going to add to our life. The karma is there, what we eat, what exercise we do, all those things will just act as conditions for that karma to be able to keep manifesting. But once the karma has run out, no matter how many bean sprouts we eat, it’s not going to work. It’s just not going to work, you know.
It’s not going to keep us alive. No matter how much what is the most expensive spring water you buy, it doesn’t help. And certainly, you know, no matter how many up, you know, face lifts, this is not going to do anything. So one very powerful way, especially to meditate on this point, is to think that with the passing of the seconds, a minute of our life is finished. When sixty seconds go by and a whole minute of our life is finished.
And just like this, it can’t be recovered, you can’t bring it back, it’s gone. With sixty minutes of our life passing away, a whole hour has gone. With twenty four of these hours passing by, a whole day of our life has gone. With the passing of what is it, four weeks seven days, a week goes by, four weeks goes by, a whole month of our life has gone by, twelve months go by, a whole year of our life has gone. And then with the passing of the years, our life is easy enough and can’t be recovered and it comes to an end.
There is nothing we can do about Death has to come. And then the final point of thinking about how our death is certain is that actually this is in the traditional meditation, it doesn’t prove that our death is certain but it’s put there to make us wake up to the fact that we have so little time in our life, is that with the passing of our life, there is so little time to practice the Dharma. Our life is made up of so many transient factors like at the beginning of our life, we’re too young to practice the Dharma, we have no interest or we’re too young. At the end of our life we’re too old to practice the Dharma, too difficult. Body and mind, too difficult.
So, there’s really only the middle of our life to practice the Dharma. But even that becomes eaten away by the fact that probably for most of us, almost a third of our life of this precious human rebirth goes in sleep. If we sleep eight hours every day, that means one third of our life is spent concentrating on darkness. This is the definition of sleep. It’s the mental consciousness concentrating on darkness.
So we spend if we live to be ninety, thirty years of our life are spent concentrating on darkness. And then you think so much time is spent eating, cooking, shopping for the food, washing up, washing the body, clothing the body, doing so many small transient things of life that we have to do but they take up so much of our time. And in the present modern world now, so many people are trapped in working so much, so much, working so many hours each day, more and more to buy the transient things of this life, to get the transient things of this life. So when you take all that away, there’s almost no time to practice the Dharma, just a few years. A couple of years are left in the middle of our life.
So it’s important to try and think about these things. These aren’t kind of heavy Buddhist philosophy, they’re just simple realities that we experience all the time that we just simply don’t look at or want to look at. But if we allow our mind to become familiar with them, it can completely change our life because it’s so important, at whatever age we are right now, to think in the context that I’m definitely going to die, are the things I’m doing worthwhile? Especially if I have a precious human rebirth and I have this Buddha nature. This world, especially the younger one is, the harder it is to realize that death can come, generally speaking.
But for all of us it’s hard because this world appears so vividly to our mind. Everything seems so solid and permanent. But another helpful thing to contemplate is that all of this that we experience, this so called apparent solid world that we’re experiencing, beginning with our own body and everything around here, it just depends on the breath. This whole world just depends for us to experience it, it just depends on the breath coming in and going out. It comes in and goes out and then because of that very insubstantial process, all this appears.
And then one day, one day, and it’s going to happen to all of us, the breath will come in and it won’t go out. Or we will breathe out and we won’t be able to breathe in. This is definitely going to happen to all of us. The thousand million people on this planet, it will happen to all of us. So we should think about these things.
Again, it’s a little depressing at first, it’s a bit shocking, maybe very shocking, but the purpose of it is not to make us unhappy and depressed and so on, but if we think about it and go through that initial shock and depression or whatever, it is to wake us up to what we are and what we can do for ourselves and others. And to prepare ourselves, life is the preparation for death. It’s the one certainty in our life. There’s nothing that we can be really certain of except that our life is going to come to an end. So, by doing this contemplation again and again, the point is to come to the conviction that since our death is definite, we should practice the spiritual path and ripen our inner potential by cultivating positive mental qualities and abandoning the disturbing thoughts.
In other words, the conclusion is, since I’m going to die, I should practice Dharma. What is Dharma? It is the cause of happiness, the cause of peace and happiness. Since death is definite, then practice the Dharma. This is the purpose of this first part of the contemplation, to get to that point where we realise that is necessary to do.
So if we actually have we generate this inner experience that our death is certain, then the next part of the contemplation is to consider that because we can gain this realisation, we can feel absolutely sure that death is definite, but still because of our ignorance and self obsession, we tend to think that, Oh, sure, I’m definitely going to die, but it’s going to happen a long time in the future. It’s certain, but it will happen, you know, I don’t have to worry about it because it’s going to happen so many years in the future. It’s a long, long way away. But whether we are young, middle aged or old, death can happen at any moment, at any moment. The time of death is uncertain.
We simply don’t know, any of us, when our death will occur. We don’t know when the karmic energy that maintains this life will run out. Because it hasn’t got anything to do with having a young body, a strong body, a healthy body. It’s got nothing to do with that. These can be secondary conditions but these are not the reasons for staying alive, being young, strong, healthy.
Because we all know, if we think about it, that young people die. Strong people die, healthy people die. It’s not only old people that die, it’s not only unhealthy people that die, it’s not only physically weak people that die, it’s not only poor people that die. Everyone dies, and it can happen at any moment. Why?
The first reason is a very general one that the lifespan of human beings isn’t fixed. In teachings which we’ve sort of alluded to a little bit, the Buddhist teachings say there are many, many universes and even within our universe there are other human realms. There are three other realms apart from this human realm. We are in what is called the southern continent, there’s also a northern, eastern and western continents of human beings. And in those three other human realms, according to the teachings, the human beings there have fixed lifespans.
Whether that’s true or not, I don’t know. But here, I haven’t been there, seen them, haven’t been there, done that this life. Certainly on this planet, the lifespan of human beings is not fixed at all. And it’s for that reason, because it’s not fixed by some karmic situation, then we as human beings can die at any time. So it’s worthwhile to contemplate that and
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.