Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 27 Tape 53 Side 1

42 min · 4,554 words · 27 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 27 Tape 53 Side 1
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk covers how to counter attachment by seeing that objects do not bring lasting happiness and that the beauty we perceive is created by our mind, with a meditation on the body’s inner appearance as an antidote to desire. It then explains patience as recognising the faults of anger and developing compassion for oneself and others, not mere suppression. A question and answer session follows on suppressed anger and dealing with triggering situations, and the talk closes with course announcements.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-27

Duration: 42 min

UUID: dd35ffc6-de53-4b68-af30-70eac468f907

Words: 4,554

That when our attachment is very strong, it almost we can almost convince ourselves that this will solve all our problems. Especially today during this Dharma meditation course, this will solve my problems. Then, when one eats it and it doesn’t, it’s depressing. Also, can think, Oh, the chocolate should have done it, there’s something wrong with me. This was a perfect piece of chocolate cake and it didn’t solve my problem.

I must be really, really terrible and evil and sick and whatever. But, if we have some awareness that, Oh, this looks nice, and I’ve tasted it before, but it didn’t make me happy before completely, and it’s not going to make me happy again, but it still tastes okay, so I can still eat it and have a little enjoyment, but not get really obsessed with it. And if I can’t finish it or, you know, if it falls out of my hand or something, it’s okay because it wasn’t going to make me happy anyway, so it’s no big deal. Yeah? Or you see someone who would really like it, oh, might as well give it to them.

It’s okay. I won’t die if I don’t eat it and I can rejoice that I’ve done something to make someone else happy a little bit. So, that rejoicing may be more enjoyable than eating the chocolate cake. It’s possible. But I’m not saying we should have some chocolate cake at lunch today, it’s fine.

But don’t eat it thinking it’s real happiness. But also, one can see, I think, that the more we put this we overestimate the value of little things, we build up such huge expectations altogether. And then we think particular things, especially people. This person, this thing is going to bring so much happiness into my life. Nothing can do that.

So this is another way to and the thing is, we have to contemplate this again and again to counteract the strong belief that it is like that, this is happiness, this is permanent. It will last, it will make me happy. Of course, the ultimate antidote to attachment is some realization of emptiness. The emptiness of the object not truly existing from its own side, is as truly existingly beautiful, having truly existingly able to produce happiness. It’s dependent on my mind and how I label it.

The more we really understand that, that actually I’m creating the beauty in that. To a large extent, my mind is creating the beauty. If we are aware of that, we don’t get attached. If we are really aware, not just intellectually, but really aware that we’re creating the illusion, we don’t fall for the illusion. Similarly, through having understanding of emptiness if we really understand we have some experience of the way we actually exist as merely dependent on this body and mind changing moment by moment.

Therefore, isn’t the appearance of a truly existing person who must have this thing or person to be happy. Because why we desire this thing is because there’s the appearance of an I that has to have it. There’s this truly existing person who must have this, must experience this thing. I won’t live, I can’t survive if I don’t experience this thing. As the song goes, I can’t live if living is without you.

So don’t go start singing it. This also is a terrible thing to say to someone else. This is a love song, yeah? It’s supposed to be praising the object of love. But this is really a heavy burden to put on another person that if you’re not around, I’m going to kill myself, I’m going to die.

This is attachment and it’s really putting a heavy burden on the other person. I always have to be around otherwise they’re going to die. Okay. And then another way to part of the antidote to attachment is to try to see that the thing is the very opposite to what appears to our mind because desire attachment exaggerates the pleasant appearance of something, so as an antidote, we can try to see the unpleasant aspect of the thing, to see it as ugly. This we just do consciously to oppose attachment.

This is particularly a practice to be done in trying to overcome desire for other people’s bodies because the body appears beautiful, desirable, pleasant, and so the more the mind concentrates on that characteristic, we desire that. So, this is a very unpopular practice with most people, But it is a traditional meditation practice if one wants to cut one’s own attachment to a particular body. You don’t have to apply it to all bodies, but because desire looks at the outer appearance, so to try to stop that, we try to think of the inner appearance of the body. Although there’s this nice skin and this nice shape, but inside, you know, there’s just all this stuff: blood, meat, bones, fat, marrow and all this stuff, and all, you know, pus and blood and all this stuff, which is true, it’s true, it’s not made up. If we look inside our body, even if we cut our own body, often we don’t even like to look at our own blood or if you cut and you see some of the inside, kind of close it up.

So, the meditation is to the body of the desired person. You imagine, you know, opening it up. It’s nice to take the clothes off, but then when you take off the skin, it isn’t so desirable. But this is the meditation to do. Actually, don’t know if you’ve seen it, but I saw this video clip of some very famous rock and roll English rock and roll singer who’s like one of the leading sort of Robbie Williams.

Robbie yeah. It’s quite amazing where he have you seen this? No, you’re all good virtuous of Dharma practitioners. It’s only me who watches these rock and roll videos. But it’s really quite amazing where this guy is standing, singing and he’s surrounded by all these beautiful young ladies dancing away and then he starts taking off his clothes, you know, in this very sexy way.

So, he takes off all his clothes and then he’s left just in his underpants and then he kind of although you don’t actually see anything the way it’s filmed, you get the impression he’s taking them off and all these ladies are dancing around this naked man and then he starts taking off his skin. It’s done very realistically, you know, he peels off his skin then he starts taking off bits of his flesh and throwing them off. It’s quite amazing. And I often thought, it’s only quite recent this film, I thought, I wonder if his popularity has declined because all the women have now seen what he really looks like. But I think he’s more famous than ever.

But anyway, the idea is that they’ve maybe they didn’t look at the video often enough, but if you do the meditation again and again and again, it’s supposed to cut attachment. Right. Yeah, thanks. The antidote to anger is developing patience, not suppressing it, but developing this mind of patience. I think I won’t talk about this now, I’ll leave it until later in the course, when we get to the six perfections and we can go into it in detail.

Maybe I could talk about it now, but there’s not much time now. But again, it’s basically, as I was saying, one isn’t repressing the anger, one is generating a different set of thoughts and ideas and perceptions. And again, one of the aspects of that is just simply by seeing the faults of anger. While we continue to believe that anger is good, that it protects us, and certainly what anger does is it gives us a lot of energy to stop something. And often people think this is good, for example, in cases of social issues, political injustice and social issues about the environment, and taking care of saving animals and saving forests, and this and that.

People get very angry and they use that anger to go out in the streets and do things to stop what is perceived as bad. But that anger itself is part of the problem. We see that as something good, it energizes us to do something virtuous, beneficial. But if the motivation has one of the three poisonous minds, the result won’t be beneficial in the long run. So we need to see the faults of anger.

The more we see that, then from our own side, not just believing it because the Buddha said or whatever, and like, you know, one can get into this thing, oh, the Buddha said anger is bad, therefore I’m evil if I get angry, so I won’t get angry. So this is just a way of suppressing it. Yeah? That kind of way of thinking will just try to suppress the anger, Oh, I’m not angry, I’m not because this would mean I’m bad, anger’s bad, and I’m never bad, I don’t want to be bad, so I can’t, you know So this is just suppressing it. So, can think along the lines to see, to feel how one’s anger is actually painful, and since there is this natural tendency within us not to experience suffering, if we allow ourselves to notice when we are experiencing suffering, there is a natural tendency to withdraw from that.

Just like when we put our hand in the fire, is a natural tendency to immediately withdraw it. So if we feel our anger as painful, there will be a there is a natural tendency to withdraw from it. But if we keep telling ourselves our anger is good and beneficial, then we don’t recognize the stuff obscures us from experiencing our own suffering, the suffering of anger. But with a more clear mind, then we feel our anger and there’s a wish to withdraw from it, not to engage in it so much but to, you know, to have compassion for ourselves because this is what patience is. It has two aspects.

Real compassion is having compassion for oneself and compassion the person who is causing this suffering. If those two things are missing, it’s not real compassion it’s not real patience. For example, false patience is we’re all able to practice false patience, such as when in our working life, if the boss criticizes us and insults us and yells at us for something and what they’re saying is, We did a good job but they’re insulting us. It doesn’t manifest, but that is just suppressing the anger. Because we know it’s beneficial, and we talk nicely and everything.

So, this is just suppressing anger, it’s not practicing patience. Because one isn’t developing there’s no kind of sense of real compassion for oneself and there’s certainly there’s this negative mind towards the boss. There’s no compassion for them. It’s just convenient not to We recognize our self-cherishing thought recognizes that it is very convenient not to appear angry, but we keep it in our heart. We nurture, we nourish our anger towards the boss.

I’ll get him for that. I’ll never forget that. You wait. He’ll regret that. So we hold, we nourish our anger in our heart, but we don’t show it because we see out the self-cherishing thought sees the benefit of not showing it.

But if we see the benefit of showing it, then boom, when we decide, oh, I don’t want the job anymore, then quite happy to yell at the boss. But while we want the job, oh, sure. And also, even in a dharma situation, we may not express our anger out of pride. Am a dharma practitioner and I want everyone to think I’m a very peaceful, loving person. So, you know, is a virtuous mind of conscience or shame where one doesn’t follow negative thoughts because one realizes it’s not just having some sense of one’s own integrity of what I want, I really want to be and do.

And also there’s a sense of embarrassment, I shouldn’t do that because it’s harmful to others. If they see me as a monk getting angry, they’ll really be upset and think, Oh, then if monks get angry, no hope for anyone to. So there’s a virtuous mind that helps us not to get angry, then but there’s no sense of my personal reputation involved. But if there’s a sense that I want people to think I’m a really kind, sweet, patient monk, therefore I won’t I’m angry but I won’t show up at that because that will ruin my reputation, then this is suppression of anger, it’s not patience. And actually, as one’s anger gets stronger, you talk more softly, more sweetly, yeah, because you want people to think you’re so sweet and lovely, but actually you’re boiling inside and you to kill them.

But, I’m such a sweet, lovely monk. So that is not patience. That’s just suppressing it. Suppressing it and also suppressing it with a non virtuous motivation. So anger is I mean, patience is recognising the anger and undermining it with various virtuous kinds of thoughts and ways of perceiving, which we can learn and apply step by step.

So if you have some questions? Yes? Possible. Did he give an example? Did his holiness give an example?

He said that was good. I haven’t heard his Holiness say anything like that. Because, I mean, wouldn’t the invasion and the killing of millions of Tibetans be justified anger? His Holiness says, you can’t get angry with the communist Chinese for destroying that country, that culture, the environment, and millions of people. He has constantly worked to keep the Tibetan people quiet about that.

I think, Śāntideva’s text, is the best chapter, the best teaching on the core teaching on how to develop patience. Śāntideva book called Engaging in the Bodhisattva Way of Life. If anyone here is interested in following the Buddhadharma, especially the Mahāyāna Dharma, you must buy this book. No choice. This is the best Dharma book of all.

Are several translations, Entering the Bodhisattva Way of Life, Engaging in the Bodhisattva Way of Life, A Guide to the Bodhisattva Way of Life by Śāntideva. It’s in the Sanskrit title which is often in the book as well, in the different translations, is the Bodhicharyavatara. It’s in the bibliography, but this is a bit old. One of the best versions now is the one by it’s translated in English but in France by the Padmakara, is it called? Padmakara translation group.

There are copies of it available here in the library and for sale here. It’s got a blue cover with a picture of a bodhisattva on it. This is a really excellent translation. Anyway, in there is the chapter on how to develop patience. And in there it may not be in that actual chapter, but somewhere in that text Śāntideva no, it’s in that chapter.

He says, If one is going to get angry, get angry with the delusions. That you can do. But that anger is not real anger. It’s not this negative mind. It’s kind of it’s just it’s not really anger.

Definitely, His Holiness is an incredible advocate of non violence, of non harming in every possible way. That’s why he won the Nobel Peace Prize, as an advocate of not retaliating. It may not have been translated properly. Yeah. You look angry.

Yeah. You give the appearance of being angry. That’s for sure, that you can do. Sure. You don’t think it was that?

No. No? Oh, okay. Yes. Oh yeah, we should definitely try to change the world but not with anger.

It just doesn’t work. I think probably what his holiness maybe said something like, So you’re angry about the forest being destroyed or animals being killed or the injustice in the world. So, you’ve got that anger, so now develop patience and develop practice patience and then compassion will arise and then charge out into the streets with compassion. His was probably saying something like that, yeah? Because that’s what his Holiness does.

The poem? Which poem? W. H. Auden.

It’s part of a poem, right? I don’t know which one. I collect these quotes and I never remember where they come from. We would rather look, maybe I’ll just stick it up and you can copy it out. If you can read my writing.

Yes. Of suppressed anger? Yeah. The question is about, you know, this is the problem in modern time, modern world of dealing with suppressed anger and is there a terminology suppressed desire? Oh, not suppressed anger, suppressed desire.

Is there a term for that in Buddhadharma and the method for dealing with it? Not that I’m aware of, no. That doesn’t mean much. I think that the Buddhadharma is presented from the point of view of for the purpose of how do you say? The practitioner of the Buddhadharma is supposed to be someone who is conventionally well adjusted.

Although we have the diseases, we have the worst mental disturbance of we have all the mental disturbances, but from a conventional point of view, we are healthy and so on, mentally balanced. So, the Buddhadharma is presented from that point of view and for a practitioner to be in that state to deal with their delusions, not someone who is unaware of suppressed angers and desires and so on. But of course, all of us these days have a little bit of that perhaps. But I think the traditional practitioner is conventionally healthy, mentally healthy being. It’s not dealing with, you know, do you want to say something?

No? I mean, do you disagree? Sorry? Well, as we’re trying to practice the lamrim, we can also deal with these ones. Wouldn’t necessarily because also the way the the Lamrim the Lamrim itself works, even although the way it’s presented developing wisdom comes last, still we try to understand it at the very beginning.

So, have to try to do everything from the beginning, but we actually perfect the first thing first, then the second thing second, like that. And one of the problems in practicing the Dharma in modern times is that many of us do have hidden issues that we’re unaware of, and that’s where practicing using modern psychology can be helpful in unearthing these things because conventional Dharma practices may not make us aware of those things. There may be other traditions that have been lost from the world. I suppose without ways to practice. Sure, that may have existed, have died out.

That’s possible, you know. But from a Buddhist point of view, they wouldn’t surpass the Buddhist point of view, even if there were other ways. The potential of the delusions. How that relates to the creation of delusions as you explained it today. Yeah, the imprint itself of the delusion, we have which is they’re all we have these imprints of the delusions in our mind right now.

For every single the eighty four thousand delusions, we’ve got the imprints of all of them right now. So these exist in neutral form, they are not disturbing the mind. Like the imprint of anger is in our mind but it isn’t making our mind angry, it’s neutral. Alright, so it’s existing in this neutral way and it’s an imprint because the imprint itself is not consciousness. But it will affect when it ripens, it will manifest to disturb the mind by manifesting as anger.

And that imprint is created by a previous moment of anger, at some previous time. That’s about all I can say about it. So, we have these imprints, these latencies in our mind and then, when all these different conditions come about, like meeting the object, then it ripens and yeah. Yes? No, it’s not.

Samsāra is not safe. Yes, but that’s why one has vows to withdraw from most of the tricky situations. That’s why vows are so helpful. No. It’s not that bad.

It’s bad, but I mean I mean, generally, you know, we know what are our objects of delusion, I mean, of desire, what we know, what makes us angry. But of course, sometimes there are very strange things that we can experience. We never thought we would get attracted to that or get angry by that or jealous by that. That sure, can happen but it doesn’t mean that we have to kind of do nothing because just in case we might fall in love with an elephant or something, you know. So, there’s no two ways about it then.

You don’t pay attention to it. You don’t pay attention to it. Aren’t you suppressing it? No, we have to pay attention to it in the sense of acknowledging we have to acknowledge that the delusion is there. So we shouldn’t suppress it, but we shouldn’t pay attention to it in the sense of getting caught up in it, of feeding it.

We have to pay attention to it in the sense of, Oh, this is a delusion, I should apply the antidote. Even if we can’t apply the antidote, at least by not feeding it, it will weaken a little bit, but it will still be there. But if we apply the antidote, we kind of reduce it very quickly. It’s a very thin line when you realize it’s there and you try not to think about it, then you subconsciously suppress it. Yeah, no, yeah, but that’s not what I’m not what I’m trying to say.

No, you should think about it, but not think about it in the sense of getting caught up in it. But think about, Oh yes, it’s there, it’s there. So, at least, like one practice Śāntideva says, to remain like a piece of wood. If you can’t apply the antidote, just remain like a piece of wood. Don’t get caught up into it, you know, feeding it.

But you know it’s there and because you know it’s there, you try not to follow it and feed it. So you pay attention to it in the sense of knowing it’s there but you don’t pay attention to it in the sense you know, really following it wholeheartedly. You try to to just keep cool, be like a piece of wood. That’s true. And if possible, apply the antidote as yeah.

Yes? Is is there some magic way of of dealing with a situation where you can’t remove yourself from the object that you triggered. I’m thinking of someone within a family situation that that triggers anger or something in you, and you can’t you know, you try to tell yourself all the good qualities or throw your mind in the mantra, but every time you’re around the person I don’t think there’s any magic answer. If you if you find one, write to me. This is the difficult thing when it’s with someone we’re living with in the family or see very, very regularly.

That’s why in one sense the easiest thing is to separate from it, but if you can’t, then you have to do something with your mind and just try to train in all the antidotes. And one is just to remain like a piece of wood. Don’t say anything, don’t react. I mean, don’t act cold, but try not to because you know if I say anything I think we have to stop, it’s late, we dedicate the merit. And also there’s a couple of announcements to make.

Precious bodhichitta not yet born arise and grow. May that born have no decline, but increase forevermore. Then we can do the food offering practice if you wish to join in. Om Ah Hum So just a couple of announcements, ordinary ones, which is if there’s someone who would be willing to help washing up the dishes at lunchtime, there’s one position available. And another one from one of the doctors here saying, many people are concerned about Lama Lundup’s health and keep giving him advice and medicine.

So many people giving advice and many different medicines is not so helpful. So please, there are people trying to look after Lama Lundep’s health, so just dedicate the merit. Relax. And then, okay, the last piece of news which are I’m sorry, now you have to practice patience, which is a bit of unfortunate piece of news, which is that Lama Zopa Rinpoche was expected to arrive on the twenty ninth of the month, but unfortunately he can’t come, he will not be able to arrive until the fourth. And because His Holiness, the Dalai Lama is teaching in Italy starting on the twenty seventh of the month, and the private office of His Holiness has asked Lama Zopa Rinpoche to come for that, for some reason, to help.

So there’s no way Lama Zopa Rinpoche can say no to the private office of His Holiness, the Dalai Lama. Lama Lundup has been on the phone many, many times because in the past Rinpoche was sort of delaying coming here, so Lama Lundup was on the phone for hours at different times, an hour at a time, several times convincing, begging Rinpoche to come here for the course. And so that’s when it became Rinpoche said he would come on the twenty ninth, but then this came up. And also, Lama Lundup has been pleading for Rinpoche to try and just stay you know, just do the minimum and come here as possible, but it just seems not possible to come before the fourth. Rinpoche will arrive in the afternoon, hopefully maybe he will get here by four or five in the afternoon of the fourth.

So, Rinpoche normally Rinpoche never teaches in the mornings. Rinpoche does all his practice, he doesn’t even speak in the morning, he does all his private practices. But Rinpoche has agreed that he will teach on the fifth morning and give refuge that morning. So, basically, Rinpoche will give the motivation for the refuge so everyone can come to that because that will Rinpoche will probably teach for several hours at least as the motivation for taking refuge and one roughly speaking, possibly one never knows what Rinpoche will say, it’s possible that Rinpoche will just give it a will cover the three principal paths as the motivation for taking refuge. So everyone can attend that and then when the refuge ceremony actually starts, either people can leave or maybe Rinpoche says it’s okay to stay but you don’t take if the people who don’t want to take refuge, of course, don’t take it.

So, I’m sorry, I’m really sorry, myself, I was really looking forward to Rinpoche coming to teach, especially since I don’t have to teach that. Hoping to but it’s just somehow just not possible. Also, I think it’s partly because there’s not so many flights from Europe anymore. There’s not many choices. So, it’s also difficult to get the right flight.

So, thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top