Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 10 Tape 13 Side 2 Four Noble Truths

37 min · 2,978 words · 10 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 10 Tape 13 Side 2 Four Noble Truths
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Continues a Four Noble Truths teaching on the cessation of suffering, which comes from dissolving the ignorance that grasps at a permanent self. Questions cover why the human realm suits compassion practice, how motivation determines whether merit leads to liberation or enlightenment, and why enlightenment needs great compassion beyond the nirvana sought by many. The session closes with a guided meditation on bodhicitta and a dedication, followed by a food-offering practice.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-10

Duration: 38 min

UUID: 064381b2-6655-422a-91a4-43da1170a684

Words: 2,978

And when we stop following the game, ignorance disappears. So the cessation of suffering is possible. It is not easy, but it is possible. It is possible for every living being. As Lama Yeshe says, possible.

Possible. Very, very possible. Because nothing as our mind is now is permanent. The trouble is our ignorance also grasps that what I am now is real and permanent, or I can’t do this, I couldn’t do that, I can’t meditate, I can’t cut desire, I can’t cut my anger. But that I is an illusion.

That I that we believe in can’t do this and doesn’t want to do that is an illusion. That is not like an illusion. That I is an illusion. It has no reality at all other than just a thought in the mind, which we mistake for something real. So also, our ignorance depends on believing I am like this.

If we let go of that heavy grasping, just this heavy obvious intellectual grasping at who we are, we undermine our ignorance. It’s it’s got much more work to do to keep maintaining itself, to operate. Anyway, I’ll stop here on the third noble truth. We have a few questions. Yes?

Sure. Well, generally, one one can concentrate on the the negativities of this life because this because we know the things we’ve done, so that can act as a strong motivation. But as you were saying, if we begin to, you know, have some faith in the nature of the mind and karma, then we can understand by logic that we must have created every kind of terrible negative karma in the past. So if we think about that more strongly, it can start shaking the mind, That we always haven’t been in this nice situation. We’ve been in worse situations.

When one is in a pleasant environment, for example, here on Kopan Hill and we’re with very nice people who are also trying to work with their minds and be kind and gentle and patient with things. Hopefully, we should discover that it’s much it’s for us to be nice people when we’re surrounded by nice people, and it’s more difficult for the negative minds to arise when we’re in a physically beautiful environment and with nice people. But we’re not always, even in life, in such positive environments. And as soon as the the environment gets less positive, our mind tends to get more negative. So in previous lives, we weren’t even human.

We were in very harsh, ugly, nasty environments where the negative mind, it’s very easy to arise, so we must have created lots of really nasty things. So if we think about that again and again, then we can understand there are so many negative imprints in our mind that need to be purified. Yes? I believe that you said yesterday that the form, the formless realm, as well as the God realm, the Well, in the in the formless realm, there’s no awareness of anything else whatsoever. In the lower level, there are seventeen levels of the form realm.

In some of the the the first two or three, I’m not sure exactly, first couple anyway, that you are with other sentient beings with all these subtle bodies of light. Also, gods of the desire realm are together with other gods having a great time floating around on lotuses and this and that. But in the upper levels of the form realm and in the formless realm, you’re not aware of anything else. So my question is, if you’re not aware of anything else, you don’t Yes. Yes.

This this is the point because in these blissful realms, because there is so much happiness, even even the realms where you you are aware of other sentient beings, but all the other sentient beings that you’re aware of are also blissing out all the time. So there’s no way to generate compassion because there’s no awareness of suffering, but that suffering is existing. And even that bliss is suffering because it doesn’t last, but the beings who experience it don’t know that. So the human realm, the point of view of practicing the spiritual path, is the best because it’s in this realm that we can see suffering and generate compassion and all these positive qualities. In the other realms, like in the lower realms, there’s much more suffering, but it’s almost impossible to generate compassion for the suffering of others because we are totally overwhelmed by our own suffering.

But in this realm, we have suffering and we can see others have suffering, but we are not so overwhelmed by our suffering that we can’t generate compassion for others. And it’s actually the very fact that we do have suffering that we’re able to generate compassion for others because we can empathize. We know we have some idea what other beings are experiencing because we are dissatisfied. Yes? Yes.

There is a is there is there a difference between the positive karma we create that leads to liberation or enlightenment and the positive karma that leads to the blissful realm god realms in Samsāra? And and yes, there there is a great there is a difference in the and and and it’s depending particularly on the motivation, the motivation for doing it. So in order to generate the cause the the the merit that becomes a cause for liberation and enlightenment, there has to be the motivation behind the action. So, for example, one can practice generosity, and you can have so many different motivations for giving something. You can do the act of giving something to someone.

So that can be done with a purely worldly motivation that people will like me. People I will get a reputation for being a generous person and so on. So this is not a cause of liberation, enlightenment, or the god realms or anything remotely like it. But then you can give something to someone with a worldly motivation, and it could become a cause to be reborn in the god realms of the desire realm. Or you can give with a thought, may this become a cause for my liberation from suffering, and it becomes a cause.

Or you can give with a thought, may it become a cause for my complete enlightenment to benefit all sentient beings? And it becomes that if motivation is really genuine, and one does it in the right way and also dedicates that energy at the end of the action. And of course, if in our mental training we get to a point where we are able to generate this motivation and action and dedication with some understanding of the true nature of phenomena, the empty nature of all phenomena, when we can do it with that, then very definitely it becomes a cause for liberation and enlightenment, A very specific cause. Yes. What is the difference?

Achieve nirvana, this self liberation from suffering, definitely you have to have loving kindness and compassion. Definitely. But there is a big difference between the state of nirvana and enlightenment because to as I said, the state of nirvana arises because ignorance is destroyed. And then this bliss of the mind, the natural bliss of the mind arises, and the mind totally absorbs into that. And when you die, there’s no awareness of other sentient beings.

So even though the mind is kind and compassionate, you don’t see any object. You don’t see any sentient beings, so you can’t help them. And also, so to achieve enlightenment, you need more than just compassion and loving kindness. You need what is called great compassion, which is someone on the path to their own liberation doesn’t generate because the person on their path to their own liberation from suffering, although they like other sentient beings, they love them and they have compassion for them, they don’t want them to suffer. The person who is completely fixed has decided, I’m going to get out of saṃsāra.

I’m going to destroy the causes of my suffering. And you get obsessed with that. It’s a virtuous obsession, but that mind prevents, and so you have compassion that doesn’t want others to suffer, but the fact that you are so concerned about getting rid of your own suffering, that acts to prevent the development of great compassion, which is a compassion that is more than not wanting others to suffer, it is the mind that says, I am going to stop the suffering of others. I’m going to do everything necessary to help others be free of suffering, and I’m going to do it alone. A person on the path to nirvana never generates that thought.

Never. Never. Because if you generate that thought, you can’t be obsessed with your own liberation. You start to become obsessed with the liberation of others. But, yeah, this is true.

This is good because in words, this is this may be true because we use words. But the point is the point is, and this is something we can maybe take some time to think about, but even forget let alone not forget about, but let alone seeking enlightenment or liberation, even to think about working for the happiness of future lives rather than the happiness of this life. The mind that is seeking the happiness of future lives rather than the happiness of this life, that thought of I wanting the happiness of future lives is much less ego obsessed than the I seeking the happiness of this life. It is a different state of mind. Because in order to genuinely work for the happiness of future lives, you have to give up gross desire.

One has to stop following it, and one has to stop creating negative karma, really doing it. Yeah? So that generates a completely different mind. And because the mind has changed, the person who is seeking that is a different person. So even though you say, I want there’s the I that wants the pleasure of this life and the I that wants the happiness of future lives, it it’s you may say just by words, oh, it’s just an ego.

But in reality, it’s a different state of mind. There’s in order to work for the happiness of future lives, there has to be less ego grasping, less self-cherishing. There has to be. In reality, we can pretend to be working for the happiness of future lives. We can think we’re working for liberation, enlightenment, but if there’s all this real self-cherishing there, it’s a it’s a game.

But to actually achieve the working for future lives, there has to be there has to be less self-cherishing, and therefore, the self grasping is a little bit less. Yeah. Tina. Oh, yeah. Sorry.

Thank you very much. So we can dedicate the merit, the positive energy we’ve created in this time since maybe Oh, Oh, okay. Sorry. We take a short very short break. Stand up, leg stretching break, and then we’ll have a little meditation.

Ten, fifteen minutes or so. Simply just try and recall the things I’ve been talking about this morning and to reflect on them, to consider the validity of them, and if there is some if one has some openness to the possibility of the truth of these things, then to reflect on them in the context of what does this mean for my life, to, think about what am I doing with my life, and what what could could I do with this life? How can I use this life to, seek, not just less suffering, more happiness, but perhaps complete liberation from suffering to ensure that my next life is better than this one, and I can go on to greater and greater happiness and achieve a state free of suffering? But more than that, to do this with a thought to to benefit others who have more suffering than myself and less ability to at any particular time, they have less ability, less freedom, less opportunity to overcome their suffering. So we sit in a comfortable position in a way that we feel that we can keep keep that posture in a relaxed way but without moving for the rest of the session.

Generate a good motivation, a clear, strong, virtuous motivation But as much as possible, we can consider generating the bodhicitta motivation, thinking, to perfect our mind or allow allow our mind to experience its natural perfection, its Buddha nature, not just for our own sake, but for the benefit of all living beings, and not just for this life, but for all time. So with this motivation and with a concentrated mind, not not giving into any distractions or boredom, frustration, and so on, just consider one’s mind and its potential. The potential for clarity, direct knowing, the potential for loving kindness and compassion, tolerance, generosity, and so on. But at the moment, we’re not experiencing the full potential of our mind. We’re experiencing dissatisfaction.

We’re experiencing the truth of suffering. Consider that. And we’re surrounded every living being we see, we experience, we know of, heard of, that has ever lived, will ever live as ordinary beings are only experiencing the truth of suffering, dissatisfaction, imperfection. And consider that there is a real a genuine cause, a discoverable cause for all of the suffering of existence, the confusion in our own mind, And consider that although this confusion has always existed in our mind, at least we know in this life it’s always been there arising from time to time. It can be eliminated.

The mere fact that it’s not always in our mind, it’s not always dominating our mind, it’s only there from time to time, indicates that this confusion, these disturbing thoughts arise depending on causes and conditions. And because of that, they can be eliminated. If we don’t generate and perpetuate the causes and conditions, the disturbing thoughts won’t arise. If the disturbing thoughts don’t arise, negative karma isn’t generated. If negative karma isn’t generated, suffering cannot exist.

So if we can open our mind, our heart to to recognize the fact that we are experiencing dissatisfaction, suffering moment by moment, and we can see that actually the cause of it doesn’t lie outside in the external world, but lies within our own disturbing thoughts based on not really knowing, not really experiencing who we truly are. And if we can begin to see that, actually, all of this suffering and confusion can be stopped, eliminated, then surely the very best thing to do in this life is to is to put more and more effort and energy, time into following the path of mental development, to working with one’s mind in a wise and skillful, compassionate way. Firstly, modifying the disturbing thoughts, then eliminating them and developing the full potential of our mind, not just for my own sake, but for the benefit of every living being. So we can dedicate the merit of listening to the the talk and and contemplating it may become a cause — this wisdom energy generated in our mind, this positive merit, may become a cause for us to be able to follow the path to enlightenment and actually achieve that state for the benefit of every living being.

Unfortunately, this book is I’ve been trying to follow the book because it’s easier, but the the normal way of doing your prayers is as Lama Lhundub did it, is of doing the dedication of merit first and then the bodhicitta prayer. Yeah. Oh, it’s like that on another page. Oh, okay. Ninety two.

Great. Oh, dedication prayers. So on page ninety two, we can do it. So sorry. So for the next prayer, I’ll do it in the English version, which is at on posted on the back of the on the green notice board there, which people might like to copy.

So it’s a it’s a translation that one can chant according to the Tibetan tune. So that the English translation here, you can’t chant according to the Tibetan tune. So this is much better to do, to use the Tibetan tune and be able to chant it so it’s more meaningful. So people can join along in the Tibetan if they like, or if they know this particular version of the translation, they can join in. May the precious bodhi mind, not yet born arise and grow.

May that born have no decline but increase forever And also, if you don’t mind, it is a nice practice to do. There is the practice of offering the food, which is on page fifty nine. Sorry, on page sixty, sixty one, there’s this short prayer that one can do, firstly reciting the mantra Om Ah hum three times. So we imagine that this, rather than eating something ordinary that we develop a desire and attachment for, we can imagine by reciting the mantra, it transforms it into nectar, not something ordinary that gives rise to delusion, but this incredible blissful nectar. And as we eat that, we imagine offering that, to the Buddha inside ourself.

Particularly, we can visualize in our heart, not in our physical heart, but in the heart chakra, the Buddha surrounded by all sentient beings, and the food becomes nectar, which we offer to the Buddha to all sentient beings. So then this become then, by doing that, it makes the practice of eating a Dharma practice, a cause of happiness rather than possibly a cause of suffering. So we can imagine the food that we’re about to eat, and we bless it, and then we recite the prayer to offer it to all the Buddhas, the Guru Buddhas. Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top