45 min · 5,150 words · 17 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains that Dharma protects the mind from suffering and that a precious human rebirth offers the chance to seek liberation, with nirvana as the only true peace. It teaches that all phenomena are impermanent, arising from causes and conditions and decaying moment by moment. Contemplating impermanence and one’s own death is presented as the basis for renunciation and for turning away from the eight worldly concerns.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-17
Duration: 45 min
UUID: c20a736b-fa51-45e7-a20e-46fb341dbc56
Words: 5,150
Context of the Buddhadharma is about compassion and wisdom and being kind to oneself and others and benefiting oneself and others in all sorts of ways. And every part of the Buddhadharma is if understand it, is beneficial to the mind. It protects the mind and it protects and in protecting our own mind it immediately protects others from suffering because while our mind is held back from creating negativity, that means sentient beings aren’t harmed. There are sort of many etymological explanations of the meaning of the word Dharma. As I said, one general meaning of the word is it means phenomena and in the Buddhist context it’s implying the ultimate meaning, the ultimate nature of phenomena, how they exist.
Another meaning of Dharma is that which holds back. It is that which holds back. From what? From suffering. The Dharma is that which holds us back from suffering, falling into suffering of any kind.
That’s what it can do, that is its purpose. So once we start to discover that we have mind and that it has a Buddha potential, just like by its very nature, just as fire by its very nature is hot, we need to the more we realize we need to discover a path, when we discover the nature of our mind, we see that the superficial nature of our mind produces suffering and only temporary happiness, whereas the deep nature of our mind is the source of all benefit, all joy, all wonderful things. When we start to understand that and perhaps experience it, we discover the need for a path that can help us overcome that superficial mind and only continuously experience this deepest level of our mind in its purity. And then, in discovering the need for that path, also discover the need for a fully qualified spiritual master who can guide us along that path. And the first job of that qualified master is to encourage us, to exhort us, to recognize that we have a precious human rebirth.
This very unique opportunity right now with this human body and mind that has the eight freedoms and the ten endowments. We have the unique opportunity to liberate our mind. We can do it for our own sake and achieve enlightenment sorry, state of nirvana and become an arhat, or we can do it for the sake of all living beings and achieve enlightenment and attain the state of Buddhahood. And the more we start to discover the real potential of our mind, having this precious human rebirth, what we can do with our life, moment by moment, then we start to realize how we waste our life by following the eight worldly concerns, which is all based on the belief, this ignorance, that coming from ignorance, that there is only this life, Even if we intellectually, because of whatever religion we follow, we intellectually we believe that there are future lives, but emotionally we are caught up in our self grasping and our self obsession which dominates our mind and we get caught up in emotional moment, there is just this life. There appears we are so dominated by the thought of this life and the things of this life which so truly exist and so permanently exist and therefore we follow all these worldly concerns.
They can look incredibly special and important and they can cost millions of dollars and everything, but what it comes down to is just a worldly concern. And so we need in order to to have some happiness in this life, some more genuine kind of happiness, which really is referring to having peace of mind. Peace of mind is happiness, not an excited mind, but a calm mind. Remember? It looks kind of boring, but that is real happiness when the mind is still.
We think when the mind is like that, we’re really happy. When you go to the disco and the mind goes like that, that’s happiness. But it’s actually when the mind is really still, no matter what, that there is peace. There are four particular seals of the Buddha’s teachings, defining characteristics of the Buddha’s teachings. One of which is, it is so simple, it looks ridiculous, the statement.
It’s three lines, three words, three words. It’s unbelievably profound. It says, nirvana is peace. nirvana is peace, meaning only nirvana is peace. Nothing else is peace.
What is nirvana? It is the complete cessation of all suffering and the causes of suffering. Still mind, in other words, to put it in a simple way. Only that is peace and only peace is happiness. When all suffering stops we don’t enter this boring, flat, neutral state.
We enter a state of bliss. We start to experience we immediately experience this calm bliss of the mind. That is peace, nothing else. Yet we’re constant and that is in the mind, it’s within us, in the very nature of our mind, yet our worldly concerns take us to all this stuff out there. Yeah, out there.
As Lama Zopa Rinpoche says, Even if we had a mountain of diamonds as big as Mount Everest, something like that he says, Even if we had a mountain of diamonds, yeah, it wouldn’t bring happiness. You can’t do very much with a mountain of diamonds. It would be a huge pain in the neck to have a mountain of diamonds. You would have to have so many soldiers to protect it. You’d have to build a wall around it and you’d have to get architects to plan the wall and you’d have to dynamite all around it so people wouldn’t steal your diamonds and everything.
It would just be huge suffering. So that is nothing compared so that is nothing, those precious objects are nothing. Literally, quite literally, we should try to understand, it is nothing compared to having this human life that we have with the eight freedoms in ten endowments. Because those diamonds can only buy a little bit of temporary happiness. That’s all.
But this body can buy liberation and enlightenment. It is literally the most precious thing in the universe. We have it if we could only recognize it. So, one of the major factors that causes us to get obsessed with the external world and all these worldly concerns with the outer world is because it appears to be permanent. It appears to be static, not changing moment by moment.
And somehow every time things do change we don’t notice it or we never really allow ourselves to understand the implications of that. So, it is a really crucial thing to try to meditate on impermanence and death, To understand that the mere fact that because things are created by causes and conditions, they arise solely and only but through the power of causes and conditions, that each phenomena that we experience has no power from its own side to remain the same for longer than one moment because it is other powered, empowered, existing under the power of other phenomena, causes and conditions. So the mere fact that things are created is the reason they age and die, they fall apart, they disintegrate. Simply because something is born, it dies. Simply because it’s created, it comes to an end.
There is no other reason, no other factor whatsoever. And it means that everything is decaying moment by moment. In the very shortest moment, everything is irreversibly decaying, you know, like this. Everything is like that. That decayed very quickly.
Wow! Everything is like that. It looks so solid, but it’s no more substantial, finally, than that sound. And it has no more ability to withstand disintegration than this sound. Yet we waste all our life, this precious human life, chasing after things that are so insubstantial, yet developing attachment and dependence on them and an aversion to those who are attacking our these things, threatening them.
This world looks permanent and this is an indication of our ignorance. It appears to be permanent but it is impermanent. As Śākyamūni Buddha himself said, This vessel like world, which existed at an earlier moment, does not do so at a later one. That it seems to continue in the same way is because something else similar arises, like the stream of a waterfall. If we look at a waterfall, it’s pouring down and creating these patterns, these same patterns, so it looks like the same thing.
But those same patterns are created by completely different drops of water that are changing moment by moment. There’s not one drop of water that stays there in a waterfall. Right? They’re falling down, they can’t stay there. The next one is pushing the first one down, and then the next one comes, pushing it down.
But it’s creating this pattern that looks the same. The whole world is like that. Changing moment irreversibly, moment by moment. Lama Yeshe used to say, Every time you open your eyes, the world is different. One Thai lay woman practitioner, a very famous lay woman practitioner, called Upāsika Kee Nanayon.
She lived in this century died not so long ago, I don’t think. She may be still alive, I’m not sure actually, but I think she died a few years ago. She said, If you truly look at every moment in the present, there’s really nothing at all. You’ll see with every mental moment that things disband, disband, disband, really nothing at all. She was a very heavy lady, this one, if you read her teachings.
She did not beat about in the bush at all. They just fall apart, they disband, everything falls apart moment by moment. There is something there but there’s nothing truly, existingly there at all. There’s nothing that we can grasp onto at all because it’s changed in the very next moment. It’s decayed in the very next moment.
We can ask ourselves, you know, When does aging occur? When you’re thirty, when you’re thirty five, when you’re forty, when you’re fifty, sixty? When does it occur? It occurs the second moment after you’re born. In the second moment.
You are fresh for one moment and in the very next moment the ageing process has started. Everyone is ageing moment by moment And after some time that aging process becomes noticeable and we start talking about being experiencing middle age and then old age and then there is death. Inevitably, irreversibly. Many people hope that some miraculous cure will be found for old age. Even scientists think that it can be discovered, some scientists think.
So there are certain very rich people who have these machines that they go into, I think Michael Jackson has one, So that when he dies, his body can be preserved, so when they discover the key to immortal life, he’ll have it. There are scientists selling these things, producing them and selling them, but what they don’t simply understand is that everything they are making is created by causes and conditions. So these permanent machines that will save life forever are decaying moment by moment. You have plastic surgery. The plastic is created by causes and conditions.
The plastic is decaying moment by moment. There’s no chance, no chance whatsoever to reverse this process. And we need to face that fact quickly if we want to stop suffering. If we want to continue our suffering, believe the world is permanent. But if we don’t want to suffer, we have to accept this and live our life according to it.
Everything we experience is impermanent. So, is what we can really develop, of course we can’t have this direct perception of subtle impermanence right now, but we can intellectually understand that, and we can see gross impermanence so we can allow ourselves to understand this gross impermanence of gross changes and decays, old age, things like this, like the walls look kind of dirty and stuff, but a few years ago they were bright and shiny. Why this is, is because of subtle impermanence, this irreversible, subtle impermanence that is happening simply because things were created. So this understanding, if we allow ourselves to think about it and especially to be mindful of it in our daily life, how can we be mindful of it is only to contemplate it again and again and again and again and again and again until it goes deep into our mind. Because we can contemplate it once and we think, Oh yes, everything is impermanent.
But that understanding is impermanent, so it fades away. And then our mind goes back to, Oh, everything’s permanent, yeah, grasp. There is a point where these insights, these realizations, become stabilized in our mind so they do not decline. But that is at a very, very high level of mental accomplishment, of mental development, of mental training. We are nowhere near that point.
So, all of our realizations, our experiences, because they arise depending on causes and conditions arising in the gross mind, and the gross mind does decay moment by moment, its experiences decay moment by moment, it not only changes moment by moment, but it decays. Then these experiences don’t last, we have to continuously refresh them. But the deepest level of our mind, more subtle levels of our mind because they’re not connected with this physical body which is decaying moment by moment. When we can establish these realizations in that deeper level of mind, Although that mind changes moment by moment, it doesn’t decay moment by moment. So those realizations can become stabilized in our mind and keep going and we can build on to them.
And enlightenment, liberation and enlightenment is achieved. But we need to remind, we have to meditate on this point to cut our grasping at permanence. And that practice itself is enough to develop the basic level of renunciation that lets go of our obsession with the things of this life. Because we see they’re impermanent, they’re just a waste of time. It doesn’t mean we can’t do things and enjoy them, but that we understand that enjoyment is going to stop because the object is going to decay.
Even our mind that is attached to them gets caught up in that attachment can change, get less because it’s also impermanent. So, we start to lose interest in the external world because it’s not so satisfying. It never is satisfying that our ignorance thinks it is. But when we start to really allow ourselves to understand what’s going on, we start to be aware of how unsatisfying the experiences of the external world are. And by that I don’t mean the experience of helping other people.
I’m not talking about that. Helping other people is not a worldly concern. The worldly concerns are following our self obsession, our desire, attachment for pleasure, for me, avoiding suffering, for me. I’m talking about those worldly concerns. The less we have of those worldly concerns, the more energy we have to benefit others, to help others.
And what I think of this point, because some people keep thinking that I am putting down the activities of being nurses and doctors and teachers and psychiatrists and psychologists and what else? Massers and whatever. I’m not. I’m just saying that these are wonderful things to do and they can also, if done with the right motivation, be spiritual practices that increase our love, compassion, wisdom and help to by dedicating the merit, it can become a cause that merit can act as a condition to help generate Bodhicitta and so on. But if we do it with a limited motivation and understanding and so on, it is limited.
These things in themselves don’t perfectly benefit sentient beings. And in the ordinary world there is much praise of doing those things. But in the ordinary world there is not much praise of following the spiritual life in a very deep way to its ultimate conclusion. There’s very little you know, can you please, if you can find an article in the last year in any magazine or, you know, ordinary magazine or newspaper in the world talking about that and praising someone who is doing that. I’d really like to read that article.
For example, when the communist Chinese took over China itself and Tibet, of course, all the monks and nuns were forced to disrobe, were tortured, imprisoned and killed because what they were doing they were just parasites on society. Parasites on society. They weren’t growing their food. They weren’t doing anything valuable. This is the extreme worldly view, that following the spiritual life is being parasitic.
Whereas actually, people are and of course not all monks and nuns are following the spiritual life deeply and some are well, maybe, I shouldn’t possible, could be something. But some of those people are following that life very deeply, and that is if people gain the realizations by following that life and depending on others to help them follow that life and they gain the realizations, these realizations can be returned to sentient beings. And this is the greatest gift that we can give. If you read the life story of Milarepa, he completely rejected helping people at an ordinary level for the vast amount of his life, the main part of his life. He completely left sentient beings.
I find this story a bit hard to take. When he was also I’m not sure if he was enlightened at that point, but it was very highly realized, and he actually came down to a village. He always lived in these very high, remote mountain places. He came down to a village at one point, and he was staying at a house, and the lady had to go out and do something, so she said, Please look after the baby and watch the cows so they don’t get in the fields. Milarepa I maybe shouldn’t say this story because it’s too extreme get into trouble now!
But he just spent the day meditating, the baby started screaming, so when the woman came home the baby was screaming and hungry and the cows had got into the garden and she screamed and yelled at him and said, But that’s not my job. Sorry. I think I’ve just undermined my whole argument with that story. But the point is that this being achieved enlightenment in his lifetime and was an incredible inspiration to countless beings in his lifetime. Many people became in contact with him and were totally inspired by him.
Their whole life totally changed and his life has been an inspiration ever since. If there’s one Tibetan practitioner who is known, even outside of people who are Buddhists of any kind, it is Milarepa, because of his incredible practice. So he’s benefiting and inspiring sentient beings right now. All his his meditational songs are translated into many, many languages that you can read. They’re amazing, amazingly wonderful poems, spiritual songs of inspiration.
So, when one works on the mind and gains the result, those benefits don’t last for a few people for one life. They spread to more and more sentient beings, life after life after life after life after life. So this is what we’re talking about here. A little bit of advertisement for this way of life. There’s a lot of promotion for taking care of sentient beings in this world outside.
And that is fine, it is wonderful. It’s wonderful. It is wonderful, wonderful, wonderful. But it is from the total perspective of what can be done, it is limited. So in the process of doing these wonderful things we can also and we actually need to work on our mind more and more.
The more we work on our mind, the more we can do these wonderful things in a very complete way. When we’ve achieved the deathless state of enlightenment, we can give that gift to other sentient beings, to our mother and all our mother sentient beings. So it all starts with starting to give up our obsession with the things of this life, seeing that they are limited and limiting. And then, when we have this kind of renunciation or we’re developing that renounced mind, then there’s more time, energy to work in cultivating our mind. And happiness comes.
Just knowing we’re doing that means our life is meaningful, and that gives joy into our mind, into our heart. Even if great realizations don’t come in this life. And that practice of renouncing, this basic level of renunciation, is the practice of loving oneself, of really acting on the thought of wishing oneself to be really happy. It is the practice of having real compassion for oneself and acting on that compassion. Compassion is the thought not to have suffering and create the causes of it.
So by renouncing, it is the practice of love and compassion for oneself, and therefore it becomes the basis of developing real love and compassion for all living beings. So every good thing comes from renunciation. Renunciation is not some painful state of mind it is a joyful, loving, compassionate state of mind. And how does it arise? By realizing in way that everything is impermanent.
There’s no reason to be attached for aversion, to feel pride. Everything we feel pride about is changing and decaying moment by moment. Everything that we’re jealous of, that other people have, is decaying moment by moment. It’s so much wasted energy. So the realization of impermanence is liberating.
It starts to liberate us from suffering and creating the causes of it, if we understand it and how to work with it. We can live in this world with the understanding of impermanence and we can live in this world with kind of a light touch. Just having a light touch, letting things flow, not trying to hold them because they can’t stay. We can just have this light touch, and by having this light touch that doesn’t grasp, then actually we can appreciate the insubstantial, effervescent nature of everything. We can actually appreciate it more without grasping at it.
So then, even stronger than the realization of the impermanence of the external world and the things of the world. In cutting attachment to the world, cutting our eight worldly concerns and helping to develop renunciation is understanding that we ourselves are going to die. Definitely, we are going to die, and that we can die at any moment because the time of our death is uncertain. So, all of us intellectually know that we are going to die. And we’ve known this since we were quite young.
I don’t know exactly according to psychologists, child psychologists, when a child realizes that. Does anyone here know? Maybe about seven or something, maybe a bit later, maybe earlier. We realize that we’re actually we don’t realize we know, we have some knowledge that we are going to die. So we’ve known it a long time, but this is an example, I think a very clear example for us, that we know something at one level, we know it in our head intellectually, but we don’t know it in our heart, in the depths of our mind.
In other words, we haven’t realized it. We don’t have the realization that we are going to die. I don’t know what the definition of realisation is. The word the term this dharma word we use all the time, realisation is, but I think one can get an understanding of what it means with this example that we know we’re going to die, we’re going to die, but we don’t realize it. And we don’t realize all the implications of it.
And because we don’t realize it, we act as if we’re not going to die. We act as if we’re going to live forever, and that we’ve got all the time in the world to do whatever we want. But this is not true. It is just simply literally not true. It’s not Buddhist view, it is scientific reality.
From Buddhist point of view, Buddhism is scientific reality, but that’s another thing. So, the reason of thinking about death, our own death, and that we could die at any time, is not to generate a fear of death as such, but to generate again this wise fear that we could die without having led a meaningful life. And therefore, having not led a meaningful, virtuous life, we could have there’s a great chance that after death we could have a worse rebirth than we have right now. We could possibly have a much worse rebirth than we’re experiencing right now. So it’s designed I mean, it is true, but the purpose in the spiritual path is to force us to wake up so that we don’t waste this life and particularly to not waste this precious human rebirth.
If we think our life is not precious, it’s just something very totally ordinary, and we may not believe there’s anything after death, then there’s not much point thinking about impermanence and death, it’ll probably just make us depressed. But in context, in any kind of spiritual tradition, and here in the Buddhist view of the path to enlightenment, the purpose of contemplating, thinking about death, our own death, is to wake us up so that we don’t waste not this ordinary life but this incredible, precious human rebirth. On the basis of realizing that we have this optimum chance to change our mind, to create the causes of liberation and enlightenment, to waste that chance by not realizing we’re going to die, and therefore we waste our life following the eight worldly concerns. This is a huge tragedy for ourselves and others. It is a great tragedy.
So this is why we contemplate the more we’ve realized our precious human rebirth, it’s important to realize that this precious human rebirth is going to come to an end, and it could come to an end at any moment. If realize that, we will practice the Dharma, practice it strongly right now and practice it as purely as possible, free of all the eight worldly concerns. And then we can die happily. Anyway, Plato once said something like, If you want to know Plato? Plato?
If you want to know how to live well, practice dying. I think it’s quite funny. It’s not very funny. If you want to know how to live well day by day, practice dying. Not know that one is dying.
So sometimes the maras get in the way, sometimes the Buddhas help, sometimes the maras get in the way. And we would take a break. Apart from thinking about our own mortality, because it just simply is a fact, the reasons for contemplating it so that we develop a daily mindfulness of it and therefore act on that moment by moment is that the main purpose is to help bring about this basic level of renunciation. Also, as we study the path to enlightenment more and more and we become familiar with it, one begins to understand that many other qualities that are needed in developing the path to enlightenment also arise in dependence upon having a very strong experience, realisation of impermanence and death. So although here it’s part of the part of the very beginning of the path, it also, in order to engage in many of the higher levels of the path maybe you could turn it up a little bit because it’s not very loud anyway.
Yeah, it’s not going to do much because this is guaranteed to it’s designed to invade all space. So many of the higher level experiences of the path depend on having a very strong experience of impermanence and death. Just for example, in actually engaging in the bodhisattva path, one engages in what are called the six perfections, the six paramita of generosity, morality, patience, perseverance, concentration and wisdom. So one of these is perseverance. Perseverance is the mind that takes joy in doing virtuous things.
This is a quality that we need at the beginning of the path anyway, but also it arises very strongly when one is a bodhisattva, one perfects it as a bodhisattva. And one of the main things that opposes perseverance is laziness, spiritual laziness, sloth, torpor, sloth. What opposes laziness, what is one of the main antidotes to overcoming laziness is the realisation of impermanence and death. So the more we have that, the less lazy we are, spiritually lazy, the more perseverance we have. With perseverance comes concentration.
With concentration, one is able to perfect wisdom. When one has perfected wisdom, one is liberated. So it depends, liberation and enlightenment depend on realising impermanence and death. It’s not a minor little part of the Dharma path, it is one of the most essential aspects of the Buddhadharma and all spiritual traditions. But particularly in the Buddhadharma, the realisation of impermanence and death is connected to practically every other aspect of the path.
And the reason we enter the path is because we realise we’re going to die and death could happen at any moment. That cuts our obsession with the things of this life. Firstly, we realise these things are impermanent and we are impermanent. So what are we going to do? Practice the path.
And also, more specifically, I’ve talked at least in some detail about the quality of the delusion of desire attachment and a little bit about anger. Because of ignorance, is attachment, and because of attachment, all the other disturbing thoughts arise in our mind. So each of the disturbing thoughts has a very specific antidote that we need to learn, meditate on, practice in order to overcome the disturbing thoughts. In order to overcome ignorance, there is the ultimate practice of developing the wisdom that realises the empty nature of all phenomena. That’s the goal of both the Hīnayāna path, sorry, the path of individual liberation and the Mahāyāna path.
But we can’t apply that antidote immediately. There is an antidote to attachment, there is a direct antidote to attachment, there is a direct antidote to anger, to pride, to jealousy. And it takes time to study these and to meditate on them and to actually gain the realizations, the power of these antidotes. But that’s what the path is about. Many of the meditations on the path to enlightenment act as antidotes to specific delusions, afflicted thoughts.
But there is one antidote that works for all delusions. And that is the realisation of impermanence and death. So it’s incredibly because what is the path to it? What is Dharma? What is the definition of Dharma?
Anything that works against our delusions is
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- eight freedoms dalwa gyä (Tib)
- The eight states a perfect human rebirth is free of: birth as a hell being, hungry ghost, animal or long-life god; as a barbarian; in a dark age when no buddha has come; with wrong views; or with impaired faculties. LYWA
- four maras du zhi (Tib)
- The four external and internal hindrances or obstacles to our spiritual progress. LYWA
- individual liberation
- The liberation from cyclic existence achieved by a hearer (shravaka) or solitary realizer (pratyekabuddha), as compared with the full enlightenment of a buddha sought in the Mahayana. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- upasika genyenma (Tib)
- A female lay follower of Buddhism. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.