Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 08 Tape 07 Side 2 Attachment

45 min · 4,871 words · 8 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 08 Tape 07 Side 2 Attachment
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teaching explains that afflicted desire is a form of ignorance that exaggerates the pleasantness of objects and perceives them as permanent, so it always brings suffering rather than lasting happiness. It describes how desire agitates the mind, how the mind’s natural state is calm and blissful, and how attachment blocks awareness of the potential within. The speaker also links desire to anger as a related disturbing thought.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-08

Duration: 45 min

UUID: cd97d8c9-a13e-4b98-9c69-37fa64bd9fb0

Words: 4,871

So now I have to hold these two things all the time, otherwise I’ll be miserable because this one’s not enough, so I do need this one as well. So now I’m twice as happy as before. I think I, me, me that is grasping at this is telling me that I’m twice as happy or at least much happier, solid, more real, secure. But in fact, now I am dependent on two things that I never depended on before. I’ve become even weaker, not stronger, weaker.

The mind is now depending on two things it never needed before. But my ignorant mind thinks I need these things. I’m attached to them. I can’t let them go because this is really beautiful. It is real happiness.

It is making me really happy. I don’t know if you can identify with any of that. I can. So we do this with many, many things all the time. Afflicted desire — there is a desire to be liberated, there is the desire to benefit others, there is the desire to be wise, there is the desire to be compassionate.

This is not an affliction, this doesn’t disturb the mind. But there is an afflicted desire that grasps at things. The quality of afflicted desire is that it sees something this thing, conventionally, can say, conventionally, is attractive, is pleasant to some extent. But what desire does is desire sees this conventionally pleasant thing, and because it makes me happy, we say that this thing is not just pleasant or attractive, but it is really, really beautiful. We exaggerate the pleasant quality of it.

Afflicted desire exaggerates what is there because it’s a type of ignorance. Ignorance is a distortion of reality, and from that fundamental ignorance that distorts the reality of our self, it also acts to distort our perception, our experience of everything. So desire coming from ignorance has what it does is it completely distorts the beautiful, pleasant appearance of something. It totally exaggerates it far beyond what it is. In our world, in our mental world, this thing becomes unbelievably beautiful because my world is dominated by me.

And if me feels good and happy, this must be fantastic. Right? And me, my world, my perception cannot see anything else because I’m seeing this through this filter of me and what me needs. Me needs this. Right?

So desire exaggerates the quality of something and also what it does, Because it’s an aspect of ignorance, it’s a type of ignorance, one can say. I don’t know if the Geshes would technically say this, but I think it’s okay to say that all disturbing thoughts are aspects or types of ignorance in a way. This object is in its nature, and this is something we’ll go into later on, I don’t know if you believe it or not, is impermanent, it is not lasting. It will decay, the colors will fade, get dirty, you can break this thing and whatever, chop it up. It doesn’t last.

It’s an impermanent phenomenon, changing all the time. But the nature of every kind of disturbing thought, and in this case the afflicted desire, it perceives this object as being permanent. That is, it perceives it as not changing moment by moment at all. It is permanently beautiful, it is permanent happiness, and that is of course why I desire it. Why the desire is so strong.

Because in the emotional moment of contacting this object and experiencing this object, I experience it as something that is real happiness, it is really beautiful, it is real happiness, and it is permanent. It is permanently beautiful, it is a permanent source of happiness. That’s why I desire it, and that’s why I get attached to it, because it’s permanent. So this is completely a false suffering mind. And if look into our mind, we can discover that our desire for things, when it arises, that desire, that afflicted desire is suffering.

It disturbs the mind. That’s why it’s called a disturbing thought. If one generates a calm, clear mind and then desire arises in that mind, or you can recollect, you can generate a calm, clear mind and then you can try to recall what it feels like when a desire for something arises in the mind. One can discover, one doesn’t have to believe in Buddhist teachings, one can discover directly for oneself the nature of desire, that is, what it does is it disturbs the mind, it shakes the mind, it does that. The mind is like that, desire comes along, and the mind becomes instantly agitated.

Maybe we’ll take break and we can have some questions after. A ten minute break? Okay. So, if we honestly check-in our own mind when desires for things arise. If we check carefully, we can discover that desire does have the effect of disturbing the mind it agitates the mind, it shakes the mind.

I always give the same example, it’s a very simple example, but generally, why we follow desires is because of never checking in our mind what goes on, how the thoughts and perceptions and so on that arise in our mind most of the time we’re not even aware that certain kinds of thoughts are arising in our mind, because we haven’t trained our mind. We’re really not aware of what is arising in our mind. And not even knowing what is arising in our mind, we’re not aware of the effects they have. So, in our confusion, in our ignorance, when desire actually becomes strong in our mind, why we follow it, believing it to be something good, is because when we follow our desires and we meet the object, of course, conventionally, there is some happiness. At one level, there is a correlation between having a desire and meeting the object, and then some happiness arises.

Some happiness or the illusion of happiness arises, some temporary pleasure does arise, sure. And that’s why, we don’t check and we never remember in our confusion because we’re so agitated, we don’t remember that our happiness doesn’t last, that it doesn’t completely we’re not even aware that it doesn’t completely fulfill us. So, not just through this life but through countless lives, we have developed this belief, this trust that desire is something good and brings us happiness and that it’s essential for life. But the reality is, desire agitates the mind and brings suffering. It is suffering and it brings suffering.

And, for example, the simple example I was going to give is that when we feel hungry, when we want something — this hunger, we want something to eat, our hunger motivates us to get something to eat. So we get something and we go out and get something that we want, we enjoy. So pleasure arises. Therefore, ergo, desire equals pleasure, desire equals happiness. For for the gross, agitated mind, this is true.

But if we investigate, what happens if there is desire for food, we go out, but we can’t find it? Desire for pizza, go to the place, it’s shut. Favorite pizza place, it’s shut. Go to second favorite one, it’s shut. Third favorite one, it’s shut.

Fourth, fifth, they’re all shut. Even if you go to Pizza Hut, it’s shut, fortunately. Then, one can’t meet the object and then what experiences is one’s desire without meeting the object. So when we experience desire without meeting the object, what is the nature of that experience? Please check yourself.

But I remember occasions because unfortunately, we’ve all had experiences where we desire something but we don’t meet the object. Yeah. So what happens? Are we just filled with pleasure and happiness when we don’t meet the object of our desire? Is that just the most ecstatic experience possible?

No. It is unbearable. It is unpleasant, and the longer it lasts, the worse it gets. Especially if we don’t try to reduce the desire, if we allow the desire to go on but there’s no meeting of the object, we can experience that that desire agitates the mind. There is no happiness in the mind.

And just as I mentioned yesterday, just as a virtuous mind and a negative mind, a harmful mind, cannot exist in the mind at the same time, a virtuous thought, a positive thought cannot exist simultaneously in the same moment at the same time. It is impossible for happiness and suffering to exist at the same time simultaneously in the one moment. It’s utterly impossible. Right? So, desire, when it arises, agitates the mind.

The agitated mind, despite roughly speaking, is suffering. It is painful. The mind is meant to be still, clear, that is its nature. Just completely calm and clear, able to reflect things and experience things as they are, without any disturbance. This is the quality of a trained mind that one can experience something incredibly beautiful and it doesn’t disturb the mind.

One can experience something incredibly terrible, frightening, and it doesn’t disturb the mind. That is the potential of our mind. The mind just simply knows it. And in that knowing, there is no suffering, there is no problem of any kind. The mind never moves from its blissful state.

That calm state is blissful. This we have to develop some belief in, some trust in, that this is the nature of our mind. This essential, blissful, calm, joyful quality is the natural state of our mind, which is indicated a little bit, like when our mind is like that and we try to meditate, what the meditation is doing is removing these agitating factors, or starting to, and as soon as those agitating factors are reduced, the agitation in the mind naturally reduces. Right? Naturally, the mind goes back, it starts to revert, even just a teeny teeny bit, to its natural state.

And what is the experience that one has when that happens? It is pleasant. It is a pleasant experience. It is not a painful experience when the mind starts to calm down even a little bit. Right?

It is a pleasant experience. And this, I think, is an indication it is just giving a tiny, tiny glimmer of a hint of what the mind is really like when it is completely still and is able to remain, abide like that continuously. If there’s a tiny little bit of calmness and pleasantness when the mind is just a tiny bit less agitated, imagine what the mind must be like when it’s not agitated at all. So the Buddhas have discovered this state of mind and want us to discover it because it’s the only thing that will satisfy us. It is the only thing that is really completely fulfilling.

Happiness that doesn’t last is not fulfilling, it is not satisfying, it is unsatisfying, which is what the meaning of suffering is. Suffering is anything, any situation state that is unsatisfying. So even happiness that doesn’t last is unsatisfying. It is suffering. So if if this is the nature of the mind, this calm, clarity, blissful state, As soon as that calmness, clarity is disturbed, there is suffering.

There is something less than this perfect happiness, which is unsatisfying, unwanted, yeah, unwanted. And that is what desire does to the mind. And we can we can experience that when we don’t meet the object, the mind is agitated, it is painful, it is unpleasant, unwanted. It is suffering. That is the nature of desire.

The nature of desire is suffering. Unpleasant, undesirable, unwanted. That is its nature. This is not just Buddhist philosophy, this is something one can easily experience if you check up. Check up your mind.

When the thought of desire is there, the feeling is actually unpleasant. It is not a pleasant feeling. It is not a pleasant feeling in the mind and it is also not a pleasant feeling in the body. So, I’ll talk about this a little bit later, maybe this afternoon or tomorrow, I don’t know how long everything takes. Of the fundamental views of Buddhism in the Buddhadharma is that if a cause has a certain nature, the effect has to be of that same nature.

The real effect, not the imagined effect, the effect that we think with our confused mind is happening. But if something has a particular nature and acts as the cause for something, the result that comes from that cause has to be of the same nature. If you apply heat to water, the result is hot. Right? If the coils are hot, the result is hot.

Simple. Inescapable. So, since desire is suffering and we can discover that, it’s not Buddhist philosophy, or it is Buddhist philosophy, but it’s not just some idea. Let’s decide desire is suffering. We’ll have a philosophy, we’ll have a religion where we decide suffering is miserable.

It’s not like that. The Buddha taught that because that’s the nature. The Buddhist teaching is called the Dharma. The meaning of Dharma is the truth. Not the truth we want to believe in, but the reality, reality, free of all our neurotic beliefs and perceptions and projections.

The reality is desire is suffering and painful. So if it acts as the cause of something, the result has to be suffering. It cannot be the result cannot be happiness. The result may look like happiness, but the reality is not happiness. This is what the Buddha taught.

This is what we should check up in our life. Because what do we want? Do we want happiness, genuine happiness, or do we want the illusion of happiness? Do we want lasting happiness or do we want little bubbles of happiness that come to an end? Which is replaced by what?

Real suffering. Yeah. We really have to decide what we want. Anyway, I I already said our our mind wants perfect lasting happiness. We can’t avoid it.

That is the nature of the mind to desire it. But are we just going to dwell in our confused mind and accept the illusion of happiness and little bubbles of pleasure and completely waste this life and the chance of incredible happiness and the chance to bring happiness, real happiness, to others. So, if heat applied to water produces hot water, desire, which is suffering, agitating the mind, produces the result of agitating the mind. It doesn’t produce the result of bringing peace, calmness and clarity into the mind. It’s impossible.

It is totally impossible according to what the Buddha discovered. Utterly impossible. So, just as with the example of the desire for food, it is the same for every desire. Right? Every afflicted desire is suffering and it can only produce suffering.

It cannot produce real happiness, any real satisfaction, even for a moment, even for one moment. It can produce the illusion of satisfaction for a moment to a confused mind, but to a clear mind that is really aware of what is going on. Afflicted desire cannot produce comfort and satisfaction even for one moment. This is what the Buddha taught. If the mind if you’re, like I used to be, a heavy chain smoker, if you smoke another cigarette, it can appear like happiness.

It can appear like happiness. Some pleasure, but that doesn’t mean it is. To a very confused mind, many things can appear as pleasure and happiness. To a mind confused by desire, following desire might look like happiness. So, although in the Buddhist teachings, the point of all the Buddhist teachings is to develop the wisdom that will eliminate ignorance, because that ignorance is the source of all these disturbing thoughts.

Many people, when they meet the Buddhadharma, get very intrigued and excited by the teachings about emptiness, which is teachings of how to develop wisdom seeing this empty nature of phenomena. But to really understand emptiness takes lots of time and effort and so on, is not an easy subject to understand. But at our level what we really need to do is work on desire attachment. That is the enemy, Believe it or not, unfortunately, this is the thing to really try to reduce. Desire attachment is not something that just monks have to give up.

Some people think, Oh, monks have to give up desire attachment, but as a layperson it is, that’s okay. No problem. But unfortunately, it’s not like that. Desire in the minds of everyone is painful. If don’t want pain and suffering and confusion, we have to give up the causes of it.

Big desires bring big suffering, little desires bring little suffering. Lots of little desires bring lots of continuous agitation. Yeah, so desire is suffering. It is a false mind, it perceiving things in a wrong way. And this is basically what the Buddha is teaching us, that all mistakes of any kind are the source of suffering.

All mistaken perceptions of any kind produce suffering. If you mistake a red stoplight for a green light, there will be suffering. Yeah? A very simple example: If somebody of the opposite sex smiles at you and you think this means they really want you, all they’re doing is just simply saying hello, suffering comes. From every mistaken perception, some kind of suffering comes.

So basically, what the Buddhist path is about is developing this clear mind that doesn’t make any mistakes of any kind, has a clear understanding of oneself, which is the essential theme because once there is a clear understanding, not intellectual understanding, but a clear knowing, a clear experiencing moment by moment of who we are, then everything goes right, everything goes well. So that is the key, the point of the Buddhadharma is discovering the truth about ourselves and all phenomena. And we can do that, and so one can have two reasons for doing that. The first one of discovering this truth about self and phenomena is because it will benefit me. I will become free of suffering, I will be able to experience lasting happiness.

With that motivation, we can follow the path to liberation, achieve nirvana and become an arahat. Or, the other motivation for developing this wisdom is in order to be able to pass it on to others so they can be liberated from suffering. So this is the Mahāyāna path that leads not just to liberation and nirvana, but leads to complete enlightenment, complete flowering and development of the mind, so that we can help every living being develop wisdom that is the basis for the full blossoming of the mind. Day by day, the arising of desire and attachment in our mind, these two things always go together. Why do desires arise in this life?

Because we’ve developed attachment to pleasure in our past lives. There’s this strong, incredible strong attachment in our mind, this imprint of being attached to pleasure, just momentary pleasure, believing it is so wonderful because we have no idea of anything else. When we look around the world, until, you know, I met the Buddhadharma when I was thirty years old, I had it never occurred to me that there was anything beyond this life and the things of this life. It never entered my mind for one second that there was anything that one could experience beyond the pleasures of this life. Thinking that, then the pleasures of this life become all important.

We totally exaggerate them, which is also an aspect of desire based on ignorance not knowing that there is anything else. Not knowing there is anything else, pleasure becomes unbelievably important. We are so desperate to have it. And one can see in the world where this materialist view dominates, the people dominated that mind are so desperate for the pleasures of this life because that’s all there is. And this is so dead, you know, because pleasure doesn’t bring any warmth into the heart.

It kills the heart eventually. It’s very deadening, that mind that puts everything onto pleasure, that the pleasure is the be all and end all of everything. So, I think I lost my point a little bit, but I’ll try and go back. Desire is suffering in itself and it limits us. And also, one of the worst things about desire attachment is that, you know, in this case, one is holding on to this thing because it makes me happy, one becomes attached to it, and one becomes dependent on it, it becomes part of us, part of our personality, this thing, whatever it is.

Of course, it could be a person, remember? I hope you realise that point. So, in our confusion, we think this desire attachment is good, but actually, by following desire attachment, is happening is that the energy of our mind is going out to this thing continuously, continuously. So it doesn’t allow us, there is no space of any kind, to look inside, to discover something else. There’s just no time to find anything else when one is so totally, totally attached.

You can’t see anything else, you have no idea there is anything else. Again, I’m sorry but I often repeat the same examples but a long, long time ago, I saw a film, a love story, a very simple love story. There was a true love story. It was a movie called Elvira Madigan. I don’t know if any of you have ever heard of it.

It was, I think, set in it was a Dutch not Dutch, Danish movie or something about a military officer. It was set in the late nineteenth century. A military officer who falls in love with this girl who is a tightrope walker. So they’re completely different classes, and so their love is doomed because they can’t marry, they can’t live together because it’s utterly impossible in those it’s a true story. So they just run off and live in the forest.

And they eventually have nothing to eat, so eventually the military captain shoots the girl and then he shoots himself. True story. Anyway, so that’s suffering, right? Sorry. But one part that stuck in my mind in this movie is that at one point the movie is incredibly beautiful, visually beautiful, and the couple, this young, attractive couple, lying on the grass in this incredibly beautiful field and the man is lying on the grass and the camera comes up close and he says, there’s this grass poking up, and he says, If you look at one blade of grass, it can block out the entire world.

Try it on the grass outside. When you just look at one blade of grass, you look at one blade of grass, you look out and you get so fascinated, you see that it can block out the entire world. And that’s what attachment does. And particularly, what attachment does, it doesn’t block out the external world, it blocks out our inner world. That is the really terrible thing about attachment.

Not the suffering that we experience as we experience desire attachment, not even the suffering that comes as the result of desire, but the fact that it blocks out the awareness of what is really possible inside our mind. Also, associated with that, what is the really terrible thing about desire attachment is that why do we desire this thing and get attached to it? Because it is beautiful, it is happy, it is happiness. So, by desiring it and getting attached to it, we are actually saying to ourselves, what our desire attachment is very, very secretly telling ourselves that we don’t even know that it is affecting us, is that because this is happiness and this is beauty, there’s no happiness inside. There’s no beauty inside.

The goodness, this is good. I need this goodness here, this beauty here, this happiness here because it’s not here. It’s not there. And the more we hold on to this beauty, goodness, wonder out there, the more we tell ourselves, I don’t have it. I am not it.

I am not beautiful, good, happy, etc, or have the potential for it. That’s why it’s out there, and that’s why I have to get it out there. It’s all out there, all the good things are out there, they’re not inside, they’re out there. That is what desire is telling us secretly, which is the worst message of all. It is a totally depressing message, totally depressing, and it’s completely wrong.

It is a total lie because all the good things are actually in us. There is nothing really meaningful out there. It’s inside us. Everything that we want to experience is inside us, and it will never disappoint us. It will never betray us.

It will never go away because it’s our mind, And mind doesn’t go away, it doesn’t get destroyed, it doesn’t deteriorate. The ordinary gross mind, yes, but not the very fundamental mind that is the source of our being. So, we have desire attachment, we will never be able to really go inside and discover what is there. None of us have ever gone beyond attachment, so we have no idea what’s out there, what the territory is. There is this amazing territory that we could experience that is beyond attachment.

We think that would be horrible, frightening, boring, depressing. It is the the Buddha said, it is the absolute opposite. It is bliss, joy, every possibly amazing, exciting, wonderful thing to have gone beyond desire attachment and to go beyond the little me that follows desire attachment. So these are some of the terrible things about desire attachment that is lodged in our mind. There are more things, worse things, to come about desire attachment.

And one of them is that firstly, there is ignorance. Because of this ignorance, this wrong view, this mistaken view of self, this self grasping, it gives rise to desire attachment. And desire attachment itself gives rise to the next worst disturbing thought. The most subtle, worst disturbing thought is ignorance, the next worst disturbing thought is desire attachment and then the next one, in this little unhappy family, is anger anger, aversion, hatred. If, again, we use our mind carefully to check up why do we get angry or when do we get angry?

Why do we get angry? Because our happiness is threatened. Our happiness or the things that we depend on for our happiness is threatened. This is my happiness. This is very beautiful, precious, desirable, and I can see by looking around you bunch of people that some of you want my bunch of flowers.

How dare you want my bunch of flowers? Who do you think you are to want my bunch of flowers? This is my bunch of flowers, and you cannot have my bunch of flowers because it’s my happiness. So don’t even think about it. Even get close to the moment.

Don’t get close. Right? Anger, our anger, is used in our confusion, in our ignorance. We use anger to ward off threats or imagine threats to our happiness or what we think is the cause or basis of our happiness, our comfort, our pleasure, our security. We use it to avert — our aversion, our anger, our aversion is to avert that trouble, that threat.

Just because there is this shaky sense of self that we constantly because it’s not real, we’re just manufacturing it day by day, moment by moment, and grasping that it is true and real. So that’s why we get attached to anything that makes this sense of ‘I’ more real. When something comes along that is that appears to be that gives unpleasant feeling, shakes me, makes me feel unsure, uncomfortable, not so solid, so real, my personality, even my ideas feel threatened, everything starts my world starts shaking, then that thing that is doing that must be bad. It must be bad. It must be bad.

It must be ugly, terrible, evil. Yeah. Evil. I’m good. Remember if someone said this?

I’m good. Therefore, it’s evil. Yeah. If I’m good, this is evil. Anything that threatens good old me is evil.

Evil, evil, evil. And what do you do with evil? You kill it, destroy it, squash it, mangle it, everything. One is justified because it’s bad, evil, really evil, of course. Not temporarily or just momentarily or something.

It’s really evil because it’s harming me. It is really, really, truly, truly bad, evil, ugly, disgusting. This is anger. This is the mind of anger that sees just like desire exaggerates the beauty of something, there’s something relatively pleasant, there may be something conventionally relatively threatening, harmful, unpleasant anger exaggerates that because it’s threatening me. Totally exaggerates that.

And also, again, sees that threat, threat, that ugliness as being permanently like that. Totally, completely, permanently ugly, threatening, disgusting, evil, horrible, repulsive. So therefore, it’s unbearable. My mind cannot bear this. I can’t bear it.

I can’t my mind can’t support it in any way. I can’t even support to think about it. I can’t support the feeling

Key terms in this teaching

Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top