44 min · 5,013 words · 25 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains that generating bodhicitta depends on first recognising suffering, impermanence, karma and the disadvantages of self-cherishing, and that all practice can be aimed at it. It then teaches how to subdue disturbing thoughts by examining the faults of desire, anger, pride and ignorance, using wisdom to check their consequences and nature.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-25
Duration: 44 min
UUID: 2f36039f-7c58-4ff6-bc5f-3063d020327f
Words: 5,013
By the merits I create by teaching the Dharma, may I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings. So now we just spend a little time focusing on the breath to generate some concentration that we can apply to listening to the teachings. Thank you. So, to fully awaken the potential of our mind we need to generate the Bodhicitta thought which is seeking enlightenment. And that thought basically arises from feeling the suffering of all sentient beings.
Therefore making this incredibly powerful, courageous decision to completely overcome every aspect of the self-cherishing thought. Not just the gross self-cherishing thought, but the subtle self-cherishing thought. The gross self-cherishing thought is a negative mind, the subtle self-cherishing thought is a virtuous mind which only seeks our own liberation. So for this bodhicitta mind to arise to arise fully and completely and for us to be able to engage in the practices of the bodhisattva, then that mind can only arise first on the basis of having ourselves generated the wish to become completely free of all suffering ourselves to develop the wisdom that will destroy suffering. And that mind itself can only arise when we have first generated the mind, the consciousness that sees the faults of just being concerned with trying to gain pleasure in this life through external sources and blaming the external world, seeing the external world and its contents as the cause of our suffering.
So the whole beginning of the path begins with developing this basic level of renunciation. So this is why it’s so seemingly, some people may feel, maybe everyone here may feel that I came to hear about Bodhicitta and everything, these wonderful teachings that lead to enlightenment, and we haven’t got anywhere near it yet. But actually all that we’ve been talking about is about generating Bodhicitta. It’s all about generating Bodhicitta. One can’t generate Bodhicitta if one hasn’t recognized the precious human rebirth.
One can’t generate it if one hasn’t developed some understanding of impermanence and death. One can’t generate bodhicitta if one has no fear of the lower realms. One can’t generate bodhicitta if one hasn’t taken refuge. One can’t generate Bodhicitta if one hasn’t some understanding and awareness of the law of cause and effect. And one definitely can’t generate Bodhicitta if one hasn’t thought about one’s own suffering and the potential for suffering.
And one can’t generate Bodhicitta if one isn’t doing something to subdue one’s own disturbing thoughts by applying the antidotes. So it’s all about generating Bodhicitta. It all depends on the motivation. All of the things so far can be done with the motivation just to benefit oneself. But this course, which is some attempt to present the inconceivable thoughts of Lama Tsongkhapa and Atisha and the Buddha arranged in the system called the path, the graduated path to enlightenment.
It’s all about, even from the beginning, trying, even though we don’t have the Bodhicitta thought, to put that imprint in the mind and to practice guru devotion with the Bodhicitta thought, to practice the awareness of the precious human rebirth with the Bodhicitta thought, practice impermanence and death with the Bodhicitta thought, practice an awareness of the lower realms with the Bodhicitta thought, to take refuge with the Bodhicitta thought, to think about suffering with the Bodhicitta thought, and to apply the antidotes with the Bodhicitta thought, and then to actually think about Bodhicitta with the Bodhicitta thought, and to meditate, to study the teachings on wisdom and develop wisdom realizing emptiness with the Bodhicitta thought. So if we do all that, maybe we’ll generate the Bodhicitta thought one day. So, at the very centre of all the practice, in a sense, is recognising our own delusions, meditating in order, living our life in order to subdue the delusions so that we can also have time and energy and interest to practice formal meditation. Everything can be meditation that we do walking along. We can work with a Bodhicitta thought.
We can cook with a Bodhicitta thought. We can wash our body with a Bodhicitta thought. Everything can be done with a Bodhicitta thought to some extent. Negative actions can’t be done with the bodhicitta thought. All neutral actions can be transformed into a positive action with the bodhicitta thought.
All virtuous actions can be made immensely more virtuous by doing them with the Bodhicitta thought. So everything can be, as Trungpa Rinpoche used to say, meditation in action. We’re fooling ourselves a little bit I think or maybe even a great deal if we think that’s the only meditation to do. To be able to practice meditation in action in our daily life as we’re doing whatever we’re doing. We all of us, unless we get born into this world as highly realized beings, so for those of you who are highly realized beings, you don’t have to worry about what I’m saying, be concerned.
But if you recognise that you are not a highly realised being, then for us who are not in that category, then we need to find some time in our busy life to do formal meditation, to sit down on the cushion and do some formal meditation because this, generally speaking, is the most powerful, direct way to work with the mind. And then if we do something, if we put time into doing that, then our meditation and action, our mindfulness in our daily life can be so much more powerful and all encompassing and effective. But in informal meditation, one of the fundamental things is to be able to observe, to recognize our deluded thoughts and see what they are doing, the suffering they are creating, how they are disturbing, they are afflictive, how they are diseases of the mind. And then the more we actually see that, not in some kind of remote intellectualized way, that we actually feel it, we feel the disturbance, then we generate more and more the energy, the wisdom energy that wants to apply the antidote. And then we learn the antidotes and more and more we quickly apply these antidotes.
So the more we do that in meditation, the more we can do this in daily life by having mindfulness. Mindfulness has this moral connotation. It’s not just being aware of what one is doing. Of course, the more we are aware of what we are doing, then that is the basis to be more mindful of the whether what we are doing is beneficial or not, meaningful or not. And whether it’s beneficial just for this life at the expense of being harmful in our future lives, or whether it’s really beneficial not just in this life, but it benefits our future lives, or at least doesn’t harm our future lives.
So one definition of dharma, as I mentioned before, is anything that actually subdues the disturbing thoughts. Of course, that eliminates the disturbing thoughts is definitely Dharma, but anything that even temporarily subdues, not represses, but subdues, skillfully subdues the disturbing thoughts is Dharma practice. Even if it doesn’t look like it, if what one is doing is actually skillfully subduing the disturbing thoughts is Dharma practice. Whereas we may do things that look like Dharma practice such as listening to teachings or meditating or doing retreats and saying mantras and things, but if they are not having the effect of, in some way, subduing our afflictions, then it’s not Dharma practice. We can go into retreat up in the mountains, hardly eat anything, not see anyone.
And that looks like unbelievable Dharma practice, but it can be done totally with the worldly thought. We may not even be aware it’s done totally with the worldly thought. We may think, you know, we are great yogis and yoginis doing amazing things. But if it’s not actually subduing the disturbing thoughts and it hasn’t temporarily subdued the disturbing thoughts, it’s not. It hasn’t been a real retreat.
As Lama Zopa Rinpoche says, What is a retreat? What is a retreat? What is the definition of a retreat? A retreat is retreating, moving away from the eight worldly concerns. That’s what all retreats are about.
Taking the mind away from retreating from, escaping from the eight worldly concerns. No matter what, even if we’re doing highest yoga tantra practice, which looks like very impressive retreat, but if it isn’t taking our mind away from the eight worldly concerns, It’s not retreat. But we could be, it’s not very easy, but it’s possible to live in the middle of a city with a busy job and family and be taking the mind away from the eight worldly concerns. And then that’s retreat. Anyway, so it’s really crucial, even for the happiness of this life, to be able to recognize the thoughts that disturb our mind so that we can apply some skillful antidote even in this life, even for the benefit of this life, to at least minimize that disturbance.
So the Buddha taught that all these disturbing thoughts come from the root disturbing thought, the root disease, which is ignorance. And there are many levels of ignorance, but the ignorance which is the root of saṃsāra is this mind, the thought, the mind it is a thought which creates it is this invalid mind which creates the appearance of a truly existing self that is independent of the body and mind, and even separate from independent of being labeled by thought. This is the very root of saṃsāra, of the mind controlled by delusion and karma. That is instinctive. It’s not learnt in any way.
It’s instinctive. It’s existed from we can’t say from because from has a beginning. During beginningless time. And so then that gives rise to all kinds of intellectually acquired ignorance and then ignorance of the law of cause and effect. But anyway, that root ignorance comes the main disturbing thoughts.
The two other ones, the two chief lieutenants of ignorance, afflicted desire and attachment and anger. So, I’ve said something about, and I talked in some more detail earlier in the course about the nature of afflicted desire and attachment. Particularly just to remind you also how it has this very insidious effect of always taking our mind to the external world, so it doesn’t give us a chance to look at our mind and discover how our mind creates suffering, but also how our mind, the undisturbed mind, is the source of real peace and contentment and lasting happiness. And the other really insidious aspect of afflicted desire attachment is that secretly it’s telling us that there isn’t anything worthwhile in ourselves, that we ourselves have no value, no beauty, no goodness, no good qualities. It’s all out there.
They’re all really out there in the samsaric supermarket. That’s where all the good stuff is. It’s not inside. So I’ll just go through a little bit on the disturbing thoughts and then we can consider how the disturbing thoughts arise and how to counteract them, what the antidotes are and then how to yes, and then we can apply them. So, But just generally speaking, one way to subdue all the disturbing thoughts is just as in the example in the meditation of death, before actually engaging in the meditation on death, is the eight disadvantages, I don’t know, six disadvantages of not meditating on death and the six advantages of meditating on death.
The more one does that meditation, the more one wants to meditate on death. If you see the disadvantages of not doing so, and all the advantages of doing so. So this is one very useful technique that we can learn to apply in our life, in worldly things, but also to improve our worldly life, but also in any kind of situation or aspect of our spiritual life. Which is to whenever we encounter something where we need to make a decision to do this or not to do it, we should check, we should spend time to think, what are the advantages of doing this? What are the advantages?
And especially, not just the advantages in this life. What are the advantages now and in the future? And what are the advantages for myself and for others? And what are the disadvantages of not doing this? For myself now and in the future, what are the disadvantages for others now and in the future?
So, we use our wisdom to think like that, then we can make wiser decisions, more beneficial decisions. Like one major thing to think about, what is the benefit practicing the spiritual life, especially the graduated path to enlightenment? What are its benefits? And what are the disadvantages? What are the benefits of totally ignoring the practices of the graduated path to enlightenment?
If one does that contemplation, hopefully one comes to the conclusion that there are lots of advantages in using one’s life to practice, contemplate and practice the graduated path to enlightenment. And there’s an awful lot of disadvantages in not doing it for oneself and others now and in the future. So similarly, with the delusions, whether we know these specific antidotes or not according to the dharma, we can use our own wisdom and check up, as Lama used to say, Use your own wisdom, check up. And try to be honest that it is your wisdom and not the self-cherishing thought that is checking up. Use one’s wisdom to check up and see what are the advantages of following attachment, desire attachment.
What are the disadvantages for myself and others now and in the future? What do I really get out of following attachment? Think, of all the things in this world that I’m attached to or could be attached to, What is the most I can get from that? And especially if I increase my desire for that, what will I get? By increasing my desire and attachment to something, What will happen?
What can I get? And what will happen if I reduce my afflicted desire and attachment for something? What will happen if I have no desire or attachment for it? Are there any advantages of that or is it a total disadvantage? Try to check up with one’s wisdom.
I mean, within the context of also seeing, are there other people who don’t have desire for this or that? Are they totally suffering and freaked out because they don’t have desire for this or that that I have desire for? Or do they seem to be enjoying some advantages, some benefits? For example, look at His Holiness, the Dalai Lama. He doesn’t seem to have too much attachment to many things.
Is he freaked out by that? Is he seeing a psychologist about this? So, that, even without knowing the specific antidotes to things, just that wisdom knowledge, that wisdom energy helps us to disengage from afflicted desire and attachment, if we want to. And all the other delusions. So we can do that.
And also just simply meditating to remember what the mind was like when there was afflicted desire. Not when one was meeting the object, but when just the desire was there, when just the anger is there, when just the jealousy is there, when just the fear is there, the doubts, the pride. Try to when we just meditate on remembering, not getting caught up, you know, identifying with those states of mind, but trying to step back a little bit and look at what happened to the mind when it was controlled by those thoughts. And what did one say when one was controlled by those thoughts? What did one do with the body controlled by those thoughts?
Was it pleasant or unpleasant? What were the repercussions? And if one has any belief at all in karma, what could be the repercussions in the future? If we contemplate like that, this can be very powerful way to overcome various disturbing thoughts. If we allow ourselves to feel their nature.
If you feel the nature of fire, you don’t ever put your hand in a fire because the nature of the fire doesn’t change. So, if you put your hand in a fire once, it burns. And you know, if you put your hand in again, it will burn again. It won’t be any different the second time because it is the nature of fire to burn. It’s hot.
Hot and burning. Fire is a dharma, it holds its own entity. Desire is a phenomena, it is a dharma that holds its own entity, it has its own nature. Of course, particular desire or any particular disturbing thought, fortunately, very, very fortunately, because it is impermanent, it doesn’t stay in our mind, so it declines, it gets less and less, unless we keep repeating the cause. But even though it gets less and less, the nature of this desire is the same.
As you lick an ice cream, it gets less and less, but the nature of it remains the same. The taste is the same. When you’ve got a whole ice cream, it tastes of ice cream. When you’ve only got one drop of ice cream left, it tastes of ice cream. If you’ve got a piece of chocolate that big, it tastes of chocolate.
If you’ve got one just little drop of chocolate, it tastes of chocolate. The nature doesn’t say, even though it’s getting less, its nature is the same. If you’ve got a mountain of anger or one just one drop of anger, the nature is the same. It disturbs the mind. Check up.
So, because of ignorance, there is afflicted desire attachment, and because of that, as I tried to explain before, because that is always the potential when that is present, when attachment is present, that acts as the condition for anger to arise. Because in our ignorance, we use our ignorant mind and our self-cherishing thought uses anger to protect the objects of our attachment, which is me. My main object of attachment is me. Is me and what is mine? My happiness, my friends, my country, my religion, my ideas, my dog, my books, my everything.
So, we use our anger to protect any threat to that, me and mine. So, again, we should check how it is a disturbing thought, whether it is a disturbing thought or not. If it is disturbing the mind, it cannot produce the effect in the future of happiness. Impossible. So, won’t talk yeah, boom.
What else can I say about anger? So, anger is not only directed towards other sentient beings, it can also be directed towards oneself. Just like we have attachment for ourselves, can have that we have attachment for others and also inanimate objects. Similarly with anger, that can be directed to other sentient beings, it also can be directed to our self. It can also be directed to our own delusions.
We hate our delusions. We get angry with our own thoughts. We get angry with our thoughts, we get angry with me, we get angry with others, other sentient beings, and we can also get angry with inanimate objects. Such as this chipped table which no one’s repaired yet. So again, as without attachment, it exaggerates something that is bad, that is threatening to me.
Because it is threatening me, it is really bad. Of course, is truly existing, like with all things that we create the illusion that the object we are attached to, the object we have aversion to, truly exists that way from its own side. It’s not arising dependently. If we see something as arising dependently, There’s no way we can develop attachment to it or aversion to it because we understand we experience. It’s arising depending on our mind and the way we conceive it.
Because we conceive something as beautiful, because we label it as beautiful, it appears to be beautiful. If we don’t label it as beautiful, it cannot appear beautiful to our mind. If we label it very beautiful, if we do not label it, we can label it beautiful and it will appear beautiful to our mind. If we label it very beautiful, it will appear very beautiful to our mind. If we label it very, very beautiful, then that’s what it appears, how it appears to our mind.
And if we label it bad, ugly, evil, then that’s how it appears to our mind. It cannot appear to our mind. It cannot be experienced by me unless we label it in some way. But our mind puts that label on something and then our ignorance believes, so then there is the appearance and then our ignorance grasps that that is unquestionably real from its own side. That it’s bad from its own side.
It’s ugly, bad, evil from its own side. And therefore aversion, anger, and eventually hatred, and so on arise to that thing to push it away. To push it away or destroy it. This is sometimes what we do with the Buddhadhara itself. I don’t like that.
It sounds bad. It’s really bad. That’s upsetting, so it’s bad. It’s upsetting my mind, so it’s bad. It’s really bad.
This is disgusting. And then it appears like that, and then our mind grasps that that is real. That is the self grasping ignorance. We grasp that this is essentially really like that. There is an essential goodness or badness there that you can really find.
When you look, can really discover that this is totally evil, bad, ugly. From its own side, not dependently arising, but from its own side. Conventionally, there is good and bad. Conventionally, there is good and bad. But it only exists that way depending on many factors.
Conventionally, can say something is beautiful. Every culture agrees there are beautiful people and beautiful things, conventionally. We don’t think that they’re conventional, we think they’re absolutes. But conventionally, they’re but when you look for some the beauty if the beauty in a beautiful person or the beauty in an object is very difficult to find that beauty as an independently existing thing, Where is the beauty? Or where is the ugliness?
Where is the badness? Conventionally, there are ugly things, bad things. But when you look, can you really find it as an independent thing existing completely from its own side? But our deluded thoughts, because they are arising from ignorance, they are expressions of ignorance, create that appearance of something that is really like that from its own side. And then, so in the case of anger, we find that unbearable, it’s unsupportable, we cannot bear it.
And especially it’s unbearable because that anger, which itself can’t bear this harm, this ugliness, this threat and so on, this evil, is creating the illusion that this is permanent. And because it’s permanent, it’s going to go on and on and on. So that the anger is a thought or a whole series of thoughts that is seeing that this thing is so bad from its own side, it’s so threatening from its own side, and it’s going to go on and on, it’s not going to stop. In the emotional moment that we experience our anger towards something, intellectually if we step back we could say, Of course this isn’t going to last. But our anger doesn’t know that.
Our wisdom, our intelligence knows that. But anger doesn’t know that. Anger is a way of knowing, experiencing, conceptualising something that only knows it as permanent. So it’s unbearable. This thing is bad, threatening, painful, and it’s permanently like that.
So this is unbearable. So this energy arises to push this thing away or destroy it, harm it or totally destroy it. And what underlies that is our attachment to something. It may be a little bit of attachment, a little bit of anger. If it’s a little bit of attachment, maybe a little bit of irritation, little bit of annoyance.
You know, we’re attached to doing something exactly this way, getting the key in the car ignition. Key hole. And it won’t go in. We’re in a rush. We have the attachment to doing it right now, so we get annoyed.
We get irritated. We have attachment that, you know, this table should be perfect. So we get irritated, we get annoyed. Because we’ve also labeled this something. Mind is wanting perfection, the other mind is labeling this imperfect, can’t bear it.
Can’t bear it. So the more I think about this, if I keep looking at it, it really starts to get unbearable. Then you smash the table because you can’t bear it anymore. Right? So, anger is suffering, it is painful, and it is a disease of the mind because it afflicts the mind, it disturbs the mind, So the effect, the actual effect, not the perceived effect that is perceived by our confused mind, but the actual effect now and in the future can only be suffering to our self and others.
So this is what the Buddha taught. We can check up and see whether this is true or not from our experience, from the experience of others. So then, because of these three poisonous minds of anger, sorry, ignorance, attachment, anger, then all the other disturbing thoughts arise. So there are three other particular ones which are called the six main afflictions, the six root defilements, and one of these is pride. So pride is an inflated mind, relating to oneself.
One has some good quality, conventionally there is some good quality, or some quality, some characteristics, not necessarily good quality actually, but we recognize some characteristic in ourselves that we consider to be a good characteristic and we exaggerate that and the mind inflates the importance, the value of this characteristic that we have. And this pride itself acts to disturb the mind, And it acts to create a barrier, a distinction between self and others, which is the source of suffering. When that barrier the stronger that barrier is, the more suffering. This is what our ignorance itself does. It creates the appearance of this truly existing me, and because of that, there’s there is everything other which is not me.
There’s this this big gap, this great duality between me and everything else, me and other. So pride really reinforces that. So pride is a great obstacle to the spiritual path. It’s very harmful in ordinary life, even in worldly life, because it creates barriers between people. People think because I have so much money, this makes me better.
Yeah. But, you know, the money isn’t in my mind or in my body, so it’s not me. But because I’ve got it, I am better. I am superior to other people. I have this pride that sets me apart in a whole category of my own because of these piles of green stuff.
Well, maybe it’s not always green, but whatever color it is, I have these pieces of paper, or I have gold or something. Or, again, even just in the possession of one thing, a particular piece of clothing. Desirable clothing by some famous name. Because I have that. Is proud to have this.
Because other people don’t have it. And this is also in our culture. Because we have pride, we want to get things that show that other people can’t get because this proves to me and to them that I’m superior. And, of course, the more of these things we can have, the more pride, the more of these exclusive things we want to prove to ourselves that we are superior and that there are definite proof to others that we are superior. The shoes, the clothes, the hairstyle.
And it’s the hairstyle from some famous person. Yeah. And the glasses are designed by some famous person. Even our toothbrush is designed by some famous person. Even our underpants.
Even you can’t have underpants designed by famous people. So now if you’re a man, have your pants hanging down so that the label can show. teacher, the famous name on. The car, everything where you live is an exclusive area. Exclusive to who?
You go to clubs that are exclusive clubs and things like that. Exclusive holiday resorts and so on. So this creates these incredible barriers between people and so And it’s even worse from the point of view of following the spiritual life of trying to develop compassion. Because how can you have compassion if one is constantly generating this thought, I am superior. I am so superior.
I’m so superior to everyone else. Then one’s compassion is pity. It’s not compassion. What we think is our compassion is just some kind of contempt or pity for others. And then, because of pride, when we actually gain some spiritual qualities, that enhances the pride.
So our pride can be based on kind of meaningless things, It can be actually based on virtuous things, or it can be based on even negative things. We may be able to I don’t know. Shoot six ducks in five minutes, you know, faster we can kill more animals faster than anyone else in our hunting club, know, catch more fish, bigger fish, you know, than anyone else around, and we are proud of that. So our pride is based on an actual negative action or a negative quality. I’m the meanest, toughest guy around and I’m proud of it.
You know, I can steal, you know, I can pick pockets and no one knows. I’m I’m proud, you know, is proud of it. So one’s pride is based on a negative quality and it enhances them because of that, it acts as the basis for more negativity. So, we have this wrong view of self and our pride inflates that even more, Which itself is suffering, and it becomes a cause of more suffering.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- graduated path lamrim (Tib)
- A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
- guru devotion
- After finding a fully qualified spiritual teacher and establishing a connection, the disciple trains in devotion using logical reasoning. LYWA
- Highest Yoga Tantra Anuttara Yoga Tantra (Skt); la na mä pä gyü (Tib)
- The fourth and supreme division of tantric practice, sometimes called Maha-anuttara Yoga Tantra. It consists of the generation and completion stages. Through this practice, one can attain full enlightenment within one lifetime. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- Yoga Tantra näljor gyi gyü (Tib)
- The third of four classes of Buddhist tantra, literally meaning "union" due to the increased emphasis on internal activities compared with the previous two tantras. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.