46 min · 4,939 words · 16 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains how the self-cherishing mind seeks pleasure now and follows the eight worldly concerns, which keeps us from lasting happiness. It then introduces impermanence, explaining that all conditioned phenomena arise, abide, and disintegrate moment by moment, and that this is the reason for death, as a basis for renunciation.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-16
Duration: 46 min
UUID: 11cf78a9-0c2f-4513-a961-a9165c4236f4
Words: 4,939
Obsessed with them, never thinking about our future existence, always following this kind of self-cherishing thought, the self obsessed thought that only thinks about now. Yeah? Because we have this suffering that we don’t really look at and face and admit, it’s very because everyone is so successful, people are earning thirty thousand, forty thousand, fifty thousand dollars and they’ve got this car and the latest fashions with the label and the latest haircut and everything. So everyone is really happy, yeah? Really, really happy.
And And we’ve got all this stuff, but secretly we kind of know that we are not happy. But everyone else has got all this stuff, and you can see by the that they’re really happy, so what’s wrong with me? So we can’t really admit this, that something is wrong and not working, and we never think that all the people smiling with all these things aren’t happy either, and that we’re all bumping into each other creating the same lie, the same illusion. Isn’t life wonderful? Aren’t you Isn’t things so exciting and fantastic and wonderful?
We all tell each other this lie because it’s very painful to say, I’m miserable to someone at a party where everything’s everyone’s snorting coke and Sorry, just you know, my exaggerated stories, right? In that situation where everyone’s wearing the latest fashions, you know, costume, you know, everything, that are absolutely designed to make you happy, and totally sexy, and desirable, and everything, and you’ve got it on, and somehow you don’t feel like that and no one seems to be responding the way you expected in the advertisements, you know? How can you say, I’m miserable? I’m miserable. It takes a lot of courage and no one’s listening.
So we have to pretend that we are actually happy and that these things out there because everyone else says so, mom says they are, dad says they are, the government says, you know, buy, you know, be an American and go out and spend, you know. Then we want to believe this stuff is happiness, yeah, and it’s permanent. Yeah? So there’s this suffering that’s going and none of that touches our suffering, our dissatisfaction, the emptiness inside it. Actually, the more we have of this stuff, it possibly acts to make the emptiness inside worse.
Yeah? When we don’t have it, and we think, If I have it in the future, I’ll be happy. But then when we get it and we’re not any happier, this is really terrible. And when we get it and we may be even more unhappy, this is horrific. Yeah?
So we have this suffering that all this outside stuff doesn’t touch, and so in our desperation, as I was trying to say this morning, the more we have that and don’t face it in a wise, compassionate way, we just latch on to all these momentary experiences. We have this pain, something comes along, bounces along into our world and it distracts us, so we blow up how important it is. So the self-cherishing thought, it just attaches what the nature of the self obsessed thought, the self-cherishing thought, it attaches on to this moment of pleasure and grasps it. It just wants this happiness now, you know, something now, something to distract me now. This is a crucial aspect of the self-cherishing thought, that we have to have the pleasure now.
Yeah. This is what the eight worldly concerns are about. We want the pleasure now. We want the suffering to stop now. Not can’t wait.
Dharma practice brings about perfect, lasting happiness, but it doesn’t happen now. If you sit and meditate, perfect, lasting happiness doesn’t come now, immediately. So the self-cherishing thought is not in the least interested in it because it doesn’t come now. And the self-cherishing thought, that is it doesn’t the self-cherishing thought doesn’t always dominate our mind, and even when it’s there it may not totally control our mind. But when it is there, the nature of the self obsessed, self-cherishing thought is to want the pleasure now.
So, if it is not coming now, I can’t be bothered to do anything about it, yeah, because it’s too difficult. Yeah. Because as I tried to explain with, you know, the attachment and you become dependent on it, we become dependent on things because it feels like it’s making us stronger. Now I have this thing which is permanently happy and therefore I’m more comfortable and secure. The reality is we’ve got weaker, our mind has become weaker, yeah, yeah.
And that weak mind can’t be bothered. It can’t deal with difficulties. The more attachments, the more weaker our mind becomes, the more difficult things are. Everything becomes more difficult for the self obsessed, self attached mind, the self-cherishing mind. The more self-cherishing, the more we can’t face problems, and especially in a wise way.
There’s the famous story of the Princess and the Pea, you know the story of the Princess and the Pea? Who it was the princess who somehow I don’t know what happened to her, she got lost and wandered into another kingdom, wandered through the forest, got all dirty, all her beautiful princess dress got torn and dirty, hair princess hair completely dirty and ragged and straggled, so when she staggered into the castle of the king in the new kingdom, she didn’t look like a princess anymore but she kept insisting she was a princess, so they said, Well, I will check, because princesses have incredible sensitivity. So they took a pea, one pea, sweet pea, green and then they put it under a mattress, yeah, and then showed her to her room and said, Good night. And then the next morning they asked her, Did you sleep well? And she said, Oh no, it was unbearable.
There was this incredible thing on the mattress, and I put another mattress on, and another mattress, and another mattress, but I couldn’t bear it, it was so uncomfortable. So then they realized she was a princess. So the self-cherishing thought turns us all into princesses. We can’t bear one pea. One pea under the mattress is a major problem and we can’t sleep.
Yeah? The more self-cherishing, the more we create problems and we can’t bear them and also it’s too difficult to deal with them. It’s too painful. It’s just too painful. It’s too problematic because I want happiness now.
Yeah? So, the self-cherishing thought, the stronger it is, it makes us more and more stupid and weak and cowardly and frightened. Yeah? So we rush to the worst possible conclusions and solutions to our problems. We follow the eight worldly concerns again and again.
We’re obsessed with suffering, not the causes of suffering. We’re obsessed with suffering so we get obsessed with just a little bit of pleasure now. Anything, anything will do to hide the suffering. Yeah. So, we want this happiness now and we want it easy.
This is the nature of the self obsessed, self-cherishing mind that all of us have, we all suffer from it when we follow it. Yeah. Please check. The self-cherishing thought wants happiness now and it wants it easy. It wants easy happiness now.
It doesn’t want pure lasting happiness because that’s too difficult. It just wants temporary happiness, the illusion of happiness, now, easy. If it’s easy, it’s happiness, if it’s difficult, it’s suffering. But if it’s easy, it’s happiness. I like it because it’s easy.
If we have a toothache, well we could go to the doctor, but that’s painful, I’m afraid, I’m afraid, costs money, so it’s easy to let the tooth rot and stay at home. Easy, happy now, right now. Always we make the self-cherishing thought makes the wrong decision conclusion. Again and again. And because our self-cherishing thought, the worldly concern, always opts for the wrong thing, The happiness that is not happiness, which is just the illusion of happiness, is just a bubble, a blimp of pleasure, it’s not satisfying.
So we need some more. So it goes around and around and around. And the more we cling to these things, wanting them to be happiness, desperately believing these things are happiness that will make our suffering go away, the more we block ourselves from recognizing the nature of the objects of our worldly concerns, that these things aren’t lasting, they aren’t real happiness. We don’t see how we project so much onto these things. We turn all these things into kind of like sacred idols that we worship, these famous people that we worship.
They’re completely empty liars we worship and read about, or many people in the world do, and the things that they’re engaged in, so important, which we project all this value onto what is just almost nothing. You do not read in the newspapers, in the world’s newspapers, the major newspapers of the world, you don’t read about the lives of holy beings. They’re not there. If they’re there, they’re usually trying to make fun of them, often. Or some famous person takes interest in the religion, so this is like a funny story.
If you read news, like the Newsweek mentality or Time Magazine mentality, it’s always kind of like if some politician takes interest in religion, well, this must be a very flaky politician. There’s a lot of attitude like that. So if we give up our eight worldly concerns and our attachment decreases, there’s less fear, less worry, less confusion. So, as long as Oberimsheth says, when we start to give up the eight worldly concerns, then that’s when happiness really starts. People think that attachment is the source of happiness, but this is because we, as people controlled by attachment, by the self-cherishing thought, we have never ever gone beyond the experience of attachment.
We have never gone beyond that. Our lives have never gone beyond being controlled by attachment. So we have no idea what it’s like, we maybe have never thought what it could be like to have a mind free of attachment. The mind controlled by self-cherishing by the eight world and concerns, our solution to life is to follow afflicted desire, to follow attachment, to develop lots of attachments. The radical revolutionary solution of the Buddha is to give up afflicted desire altogether, to follow the path of completely renouncing, giving up desire.
That’s very revolutionary. The great tantric master Tilopa said, When there is no more fear or hope, the goal is one. Salamu Sapparamshir teaches that there are eight ways to overcome the eight worldly concerns. And as I mentioned this morning, the most powerful way to cut through our concern with these limiting things, these limited things that continue to limit us, the most powerful one is meditation the true nature of self and phenomena. Trying to see that these things that we have attachment to, aversion to, actually are empty of any true existence, of any quality of beauty or ugliness from their own side.
It just simply doesn’t exist there from its own side the way we believe it to, while we’re following the self-cherishing thought. And the self-cherishing thought doesn’t allow us to check that. It keeps us busy. The more we’re busy, the less ability we have to check what we’re trapped in, and because we’re of that, we follow the self-cherishing thought again and again. But if we start to look at the nature of things, really start to experience that, that everything that we’re experiencing is arising depending, it can only exist by arising, depending on many factors, on causes and conditions, on parts, and especially on the mind and the way the mind labels or conceives things.
And right now, what forces us to conceive things in such a heavy fixed way is the strength of our karma, which itself has been created by following the self-cherishing thought again and again and again. But we’ll leave the meditation on emptiness to later in the course. Briefly some other ways to overcome the eight worldly concerns is to remember that to meditate on the fact that the happiness that comes from following the Eight worldly concerns, that happiness is only temporary anyway. It’s not the real happiness that we’re seeking. If we can have that mindfulness, then we don’t get so attached to things, we don’t desire things so much.
The only reason we have such strong desire and such strong attachment is because we allow ourselves to believe that this is real happiness, lasting happiness. In the emotional moment, when we’re caught up in our desire, when we’re caught up in our attachment, what keeps that going is the belief that this is real happiness, it’s lasting happiness. But if we can put these meditational imprints in our mind that it’s okay to experience these things, that they’re not going to last. It’s not going to make me really happy. So why put so much time and energy into them?
We can always remember the shortcomings of the delusions that cause us to get caught up in the eight worldly concerns, the principle ones being attachment, desiring pleasant sounds, praise, possessions, happiness. And then there’s the aversion to the opposite, which brings about our anger and hatred and so on. So, the more we meditate on the nature of those principled delusions, those poisonous minds, when desire meets its object, there’s the illusion of happiness, but desire itself, when it is not meeting the object, is a disturbed mind. So the real result, the real effect of following the delusional cause, the real effect itself has to be in the nature of suffering. It cannot be happiness.
Similarly, anger itself is much easier to discover is a disturbed mind. So, by creating that disturbed cause, the real effect has to be a suffering effect. It may force our problem to go away temporarily, which is what the self-cherishing thought is about. It only wants momentary pleasure and it wants to solve the problem now. It wants this problem to go away now.
So if it goes away for a short time, that’s good enough for the self-cherishing thought. Because the self-cherishing thought is really stupid, it thinks if the problem goes away now, it’s permanently gone away. But then the problem comes back again. But the self-cherishing thought doesn’t think about that because the self-cherishing thought has this tunnel vision, this tiny mind that just thinks about now. Just now is good enough.
That’s why we’re destroying this world, why we’re destroying the environment, because if we rip out all the trees now, we get all this stuff, we get all this profit now, yeah? And you turn the trees into this and that now, and have these things now, and make lots of money from them now, but the trouble is all these problems come later, but the self-cherishing thought can’t think about that. That doesn’t matter, that, you know, it’s not there, just now. Once upon a time, once upon a time, not at this present or when it was at the Olympics last year, or the Olympics, it might be the Olympic Games before that, or the one before that. I read something about some people did an interview of different athletes and asked them whether if by taking various kinds of steroids and these kinds of things, if it helped them win the gold medal but later on it would cause all sorts of physical problems for them.
But if they took these chemicals or whatever they’re called, and they won the gold medal now, but at the expense of some serious physical problems to their body in the future, would they take it? And some said, Yes. Yes. To give them gold medal now. Yeah.
Amazing. This is the self-cherishing thought. That just wants the glory, the pleasure, the praise, the fame, the adulation now. But you don’t think about the effects later. The self-cherishing thought, it itself, that self-cherishing thought cannot think about the future.
Our wisdom can, our compassion can, but not the self-cherishing thought. And we let ourselves being trapped by the self-cherishing thought when we don’t recognize that we have a precious human rebirth. One thing to help is remembering karma, that we follow the self-cherishing thought, we create negative karma again and again and again. Anyway, these are some of the ways to try to overcome the eight worldly concerns, but there is one main one. One main one that works very powerfully, that we, as ordinary people, can develop in our mind right now in this life.
And this is the understanding of impermanence and death. So this works for all the eight worldly concerns, and it helps us so following the eight worldly concerns is what prevents us developing renunciation to the things of this life. Without that renunciation we can never really follow the spiritual path in a satisfying way and reach the goal. We have to achieve that basic renunciation. The eight worldly concerns are the thing to block that, and the thing that we particularly can apply to overcome the eight worldly concerns and help develop this mind renouncing our obsession with the things of this life, is to remember to develop this awareness, this understanding of the impermanence of all things, and especially that we ourselves are going to die.
So this is the next topic. Yeah, which I’d like to talk about, at least I’d like to try and talk about impermanence now. This is the idea of impermanence and death, especially death, meditation on death, is something that is very common in most of them, I think, all the great religious traditions of the world, because by thinking about it, it makes us it forces us to think about our future existence and what is going to happen after death. And it helps us to cut our obsession with the things of this life, Not to reduce the happiness of this life, but to reduce our obsession with the things that produce limited happiness, so that we can put our time and energy into things that produce more satisfaction, even in this life, and bring about really good results in our future existences. So, if we look around the world, our world, if we really think about it, can see that things do change with time.
Many, many things change with time. Things come to an end, things are born, things die, and things change. New things become old things. The weather changes, the climate changes, the landscape changes, people change, cars change, fashions change, our bodies change, everything changes. Well, said everything, but we probably don’t notice that, but we are capable right now to see that many things actually change, they don’t stay the same.
They may appear to stay the same for quite long periods of time, but then we look around one day and they’ve changed. We don’t see our friends for many years, we see an old friend and they’ve changed. We look at ourselves in the mirror one day and we notice, Good grief, I’ve changed. The grey hairs start to appear or the hairs fail to appear and wrinkles start to appear and various things, we notice changes. But we really don’t allow ourselves to think about the implications of all that.
But it’s worthwhile just to think about that itself. Much of what we experience seems to change, it doesn’t seem to last all that long. If you go to a museum, it’s full of ancient, ancient things, and the museum spends enormous amounts of money in order to try to preserve these things, because they’re changing. Museums spend millions of dollars to preserve these beautiful old things from our past, to try to keep them, but actually one day they’ll be gone because they change. That’s one thing, one point, a little rough introduction, another point.
Also, if we look around our world with a little bit of clarity, little bit of wisdom, it’s not difficult to see that much of what we experience exists depending on other things, on causes and conditions. For example, our food. It exists depending on someone cooking it, people growing it, and the individual ingredients depend on the vegetables, depend on seeds being planted and cultivated, and so on. And furniture, our furniture that we use, it doesn’t mysteriously appear in space, it’s arisen dependent on causes and conditions, houses like that. If we look so much of we can check more and more and we discover that it somehow depends on other things.
If we analyze more and more, we can come to an awareness that everything that we, as ordinary people, experience with our senses and with our ordinary mental consciousness, everything with a few very, very minor exceptions. Everything I have to use the word everything otherwise it gets too watered down, but there are some minor exceptions which I can mention later. But virtually everything that we experience, and this we can check out, arises depending on causes and conditions. Everything that we experience, starting with our body, this body exists depending on causes and conditions. The causes were our mother and father, the conditions are, well, difficult to understand the very first condition, which was our subtle consciousness joining the sperm and ovum, but then there was the conditions of nutrition coming into the womb and nourishing the fetus, then when the baby came out of the womb, were all the conditions of food, clothing, shelter.
Because of the constant coming of these things, we have this body still. It totally depends on so many different things. And this is true of everything we experience, Everything that we see, hear, smell, taste, touch, think about exists depending on causes and conditions. There are a few separate things but the one exception that we do experience is space. Space doesn’t depend on causes and conditions.
But space is not a big problem, it’s difficult to get attached to space or to have aversion to it. So we don’t have to worry about that. But virtually everything else we experience, if you check, arises depending on causes and conditions. This world itself, this planet arose depending on causes and conditions. Not just this planet, this entire universe came into existence depending on causes and conditions.
And as I mentioned before, we have noticed that many of the things that we experience in this world change. The Buddha taught, because the Buddha perceived, that anything that arises depending on causes and conditions changes. That anything and everything, anything and everything that arises depending on causes and conditions is impermanent. The first general meaning of impermanent means it changes moment by moment. Doesn’t mean impermanent doesn’t mean it doesn’t last at all, it just simply means literally changing moment by moment.
The more subtle meaning of impermanence is that not only do things depending on causes and conditions change moment by moment, but they decay moment by moment. Everything arising depending on causes and conditions in one moment, when it is first coming, comes into existence, when it is first created, when it first arises, when it is first manufactured, when it is first born, when it is first produced. What’s another word? It is there, it is abiding, in the very next moment it decays. It is something a little bit less than what it was when it was first created, first born, first manufactured, And in the next moment it decays again, and again, and again, and again.
This is what is meant by the Buddhist teaching that all conditioned phenomena are impermanent. So this applies to everything that exists because of causes and conditions, and if we check everything in our universe depends on causes and conditions. Therefore, it is changing moment by moment, moment by moment, decaying moment by moment. So, with our ordinary mind, as I indicated at the beginning, we can understand gross impermanence that after many years things change, after weeks things change, after years things change, after hundreds of years things change, after thousands of years things change. But we don’t have an example always.
Way over there, this one. But if we imagine that these were real flowers and not plastic or whatever they are, imitation flowers, when they’re first picked, they’re very fresh and vivid and alive, very vibrant, and then maybe after one week they’re dead. At least in the English language we say they’re dead, some other languages is another term, but they’re dead. So that death didn’t happen suddenly. For one week they weren’t changing, and then suddenly this big change took place.
The change was happening all the time, moment by moment, moment by moment. This decay was taking place before our very eyes, but we can’t see it because it is so subtle, so incredibly subtle. Because it’s very interesting to contemplate what is a moment. We all talk about moments, but what is a moment? How long does a moment last?
Difficult to say. According to traditional Buddhist Abhidharma teachings, in a finger snap there are sixty four moments. There are sixty four moments in a finger snap. But that’s pretty gross actually, if you analyze one of these sixty four moments, it itself is made of many, many microseconds, and milliseconds, and something even less. It’s very difficult to define what a moment is.
It becomes very insubstantial, not truly existing from its own side. And everything changes in a moment, everything decays each moment. So, for things to exist there is the production, which is the arising of a new entity depending on certain causes and conditions. There is the production of something, you get causes and conditions, and something is produced, the arising of something new that didn’t exist before. Then there is the abiding of that new entity, which is the continued existence of that new entity, of that type of entity.
Then there is the disintegration, which is the quality of not lasting a second moment. Things disagree, things abide for a moment, and then they disintegrate. They do not abide beyond that moment. In the next moment, there is disintegration. And then there is the process of aging, which is the factor of that entity being a different entity oh, sorry.
Ageing is the factor of something being a different entity from the entity of a previous moment. Ageing is the process of this disintegration occurring moment by moment. So that which is produced is also that which abides and that which disintegrates, and it all happens in a moment. It decays in a moment. So everything is like this, everything depending on causes and conditions, no matter how solid, how solid it appears, it is all decaying moment by moment.
So it has to come to an end. At some point there’s this final destruction of that entity, the death of that entity, the destruction of that entity, the falling apart of that entity. And this process is irreversible. There’s no way to change it. Something is created by causes and conditions, and immediately, in the next moment, it disintegrates, and then it disintegrates, and it disintegrates until it totally falls apart.
And there’s nothing that can reverse that process. Nothing. It is irreversible. It is the very nature of all phenomena that we experience. We can then ask ourselves please listen.
Sorry, please wait for the questions later at this time. Sorry, this is badly judged to make this point, heavy point. So then we can ask ourselves, Why does this occur? Why do things that depend on causes and conditions disintegrate moment by moment. What is the reason for that?
Is there a reason, and if so, what is the reason? And the Buddha gave a reason, and the reason is really, really interesting. Why do things that arise depending on causes and conditions irreversibly disintegrate moment by moment? Why does that happen? The answer is simply because they depend on causes and conditions.
There is no other reason, There is no other reason. Simply because something is created depending on causes and conditions, it decays irreversibly, moment by moment. Simply because something is born, it will die, for no other reason than because it was born. As soon as one creates something, it starts aging and disintegrating and will die, come to an end, simply for no other reason than the fact that it was created. As soon as you create a clay pot, that is the reason it will be destroyed.
For the simple fact of putting new paint on this wall, that new paint will fall off. For the very reason of creating this building, it will fall down. This is what the Buddha taught. There’s no other reason. If I drop this glass, it will break.
Why? Because it’s breakable. Because it depends on causes and conditions. Dropping the glass is not the main reason that it breaks, that’s just the condition, The reason, the real reason this glass breaks is because there is no way it cannot break, because it depends on causes and conditions. Because it depends on causes and conditions, it is breakable.
So then you do the condition, and it breaks. But the real reason it breaks is not because you throw it on the ground, but because it has no way of staying the same beyond a single moment. Another
Key terms in this teaching
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.